Behind-the-Meter Storage (BTMS) systems require dedicated development of battery materials that target long cycle life and low cost at the system level. Pairing Li4Ti5O12 (LTO) and LiNi0.9Mn0.05Co0.05O2 (NMC90-5-5) shows promise to achieve targets for BTMS applications; however, minimal literature is available that discusses electrolyte solvent selection for this pairing. This study explores the role of electrolyte solvent on cycle life in LTO/NMC90-5-5 batteries. Four model electrolytes are evaluated; the baseline, Gen2, is compared with 1M LiPF6 added to each of three separate solvents: ethylene carbonate (EC), ethyl methyl carbonate (EMC), and fluoroethylene carbonate (FEC). An additional consideration is that NMC90-5-5 undergoes an H2 -> H3 phase transition that allows for a significant increase to capacity; however, it's unclear how this phase transition impacts electrolyte stability and cycle life. Therefore, the phase transition is avoided or accessed by cycling to 2.6V or 2.7V, respectively. The cells with Gen2, cycled to 2.6V, show the highest capacity retention due to EC passivating the LTO, EMC improving stability at the NMC90-5-5, and avoiding increased degradation from the 2.7V protocol. Despite having high initial reactivity that causes Li-depletion, FEC was the only solvent to avoid increased degradation when moving to the higher termination voltage.
Behind-the-meter storage (BTMS) encompasses storage and distribution systems that bypass the electric grid. For example, energy stored in BTMS stationary batteries can be used for various purposes including electric vehicle charging or lowering the cooling load demands for large buildings. Many previous studies have focused on Li 4 Ti 5 O 12 /LiMn 2 O 4 (LTO/LMO) batteries for BTMS applications 1–3 rather than the more conventional electric vehicles comprised of graphite anodes paired with LiFePO 4 or layered oxide materials. LTO/LMO batteries are appropriate for BTMS because they provide a favorable balance of cost, safety, and cycle life, which are the most important criteria for BTMS batteries. LTO’s minimal strain, high operating voltage, and relatively earth abundant materials promote cyclability, safety, and reasonable cost. 4 LMO is very attractive to pair with LTO for BTMS applications due to abundancy of Mn, safety, and relatively high operating voltage to enable a higher voltage when paired with LTO. 5 While LTO/LMO fulfills many requirements for BTMS applications, the high voltage of LTO and the low capacity of LMO limit energy density and specific energy. Improving energy density has the potential to decrease cost in addition to enabling a smaller battery footprint for space-constrained BTMS applications. With the goal of increasing the cathode capacity at high voltage to improve the BTMS battery energy density relative to LTO/LMO, we investigated LTO paired with LiNi 0.90 Mn 0.05 Co 0.05 O 2 (NMC90-5-5). We selected NMC90-5-5 for its low Co content to minimize the impact of the cost volatility and supply chain challenges with Co in accordance with BTMS program goals. We investigated long term cycle life and rate capability of LTO/NMC90-5-5 coin cells with two different N/P ratios and two different charge termination potentials. Without the risk of Li plating at high LTO potentials, the cathode can be safely oversized in LTO systems (N/P < 1) such that the excess cathode capacity provides additional Li inventory to overcome losses during cycling and enables longer cycle life. We compared cells fabricated with N/P < 1 with N/P > 1 and we found that cells with N/P < 1 provided higher cell capacity during 1000 cycle tests. We also varied the full cell termination charge potential (2.6 V versus 2.7 V) for each N/P condition. While the 2.7 V termination potential enabled higher capacity, the 2.6 V termination enabled more stable cycling during 1000 cycle tests. Furthermore, because high Ni content layered oxide systems typically exhibit safety challenges, 6,7 we also fabricated 18650 LTO/NMC90-5-5 full cells for accelerating rate calorimetry (ARC) testing. ARC testing revealed a significantly lower heating rate as well as a higher temperature where the max heating rate occurred for cells cycled to 2.6 V versus 2.7 V. These data suggest that the termination potential in NMC90-5-5 is critical for optimizing these cathodes for the long cycle life and safety required for BTMS applications. This work was authored in part by the National Renewable Energy Laboratory, operated by Alliance for Sustainable Energy, LLC, for the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) under Contract No. DE-AC36-08GO28308. This work was performed, in part, at Sandia National Laboratories, a multi-mission laboratory managed and operated by National Technology & Engineering Solutions of Sandia, LLC (NTESS), a wholly owned subsidiary of Honeywell International Inc., for the U.S. Department of Energy’s National Nuclear Security Administration (DOE/NNSA) under contract DE-NA0003525. Funding was provided by the U.S. Department of Energy's Vehicle Technologies Office under the Behind-the-Meter Storage (BTMS) Consortium directed by Samuel Gillard and managed by Anthony Burrell. The electrodes used in this manuscript are from Argonne's Cell Analysis, Modeling and Prototyping (CAMP) Facility, which is fully supported by the DOE Vehicle Technologies Office (VTO). The views expressed in the article do not necessarily represent the views of the DOE or the U.S. Government. The U.S. Government retains and the publisher, by accepting the article for publication, acknowledges that the U.S. Government retains a nonexclusive, paid-up, irrevocable, worldwide license to publish or reproduce the published form of this work, or allow others to do so, for U.S. Government purposes. (1) Y. Ha et al., Journal of The Electrochemical Society 2023 , 170 (5), 050520. (2) Y. Ha et al., Journal of The Electrochemical Society 2021 , 168 (11), 110536. (3) Y. Ha et al., Energy Storage Materials 2021 , 38 , 581–589. (4) G. Xu et al., Coordination Chemistry Reviews 2017 , 343 , 139–184. (5) Z. Radzi et al. Journal of Electroanalytical Chemistry 2022 , 116623. (6) L. Gan et al., Applied Physics Letters 2022 , 121 (20). (7) J. Lamb et al., Journal of The Electrochemical Society 2021 , 168 (6), 060516.
Because of their high-gravimetric capacities, the use of Si-containing anodes in Li-ion batteries can lead to a large jump in energy densities. However, the calendar life of these Si containing batteries is poor because of the highly reducing chemical reactivity of lithium silicides at high states of charge (SOC) as well as other factors posing challenges for future life estimation and those attempts to extend lifetime. Lithium consumption through loss of inventory to solid electrolyte interphase (SEI) growth (and re-growth), and potential impedance increase through loss of active material contributes greatly to the shortened calendar life; typically on the order of one year to 80% energy retention. The US Department of Energy (DOE) has established a program (the Silicon Consortium Project or SCP) that currently is confronting the basic and applied science problems of Si with the hopes of developing >10 year calendar life for Si-containing cells. In this presentation, I will discuss these issues and provide some solutions to partly solve the short calendar life of Si together with models to estimate the future life.
Increasing the energy density of lithium-ion batteries, and thereby reducing costs, is a major target for industry and academic research. One of the best opportunities is to replace the traditional graphite anode with a high-capacity anode material, such as silicon. However, Si-based lithium-ion batteries have been widely reported to suffer from a limited calendar life for automobile applications. Heretofore, there lacks a fundamental understanding of calendar aging for rationally developing mitigation strategies. Both open-circuit voltage and voltage-hold aging protocols were utilized to characterize the aging behavior of Si-based cells. Particularly, a high-precision leakage current measurement was applied to quantitatively measure the rate of parasitic reactions at the electrode/electrolyte interface. The rate of parasitic reactions at the Si anode was found 5 times and 15 times faster than those of LiNi0.8Mn0.1Co0.1O2 and LiFePO4 cathodes, respectively. The imbalanced charge loss from parasitic reactions plays a critical role in exacerbating performance deterioration. In addition, a linear relationship between capacity loss and charge consumption from parasitic reactions provides fundamental support to assess calendar life through voltage-hold tests. These new findings imply that longer calendar life can be achieved by suppressing parasitic reactions at the Si anode to balance charge consumption during calendar aging.
The transition to a decarbonized economy will drive dramatically higher demand for energy storage, along with technological diversification. To avoid mistakes of the past, the supply chain implications and environmental and social justice (ESJ) impacts of new battery technologies should be considered early during technological development. We propose herein a systematic framework for analyzing these impacts for new stationary battery technologies and illustrate the framework with a case study. The goal is to promote future development of technologies with secure supply chains and favorable ESJ profiles to avoid expensive corrective actions after substantial resources have been invested. This framework should be a useful tool for public and private researchers and sponsors who want to ensure that supply chain and ESJ concerns are considered and integrated as part of decision making throughout the research and development process.
Li 4 Ti 5 O 12 /LiMn 2 O 4 (LTO/LMO) system is a promising candidate for behind-the-meter storage (BTMS) applications due to its critical-material-free chemistry exhibiting good safety and long lifetime. Here, we design LTO/LMO cells to mitigate their major degradation mechanism, loss of Li inventory, and improve their long-term cyclability. First, LMO electrodes with different loadings (2.61, 3.29, and 4.26 mAh cm −2 ) are paired with an LTO electrode (3.35 mAh cm −2 ) to create varying negative-to-positive ratios (N/P>1, =1, and <1). Additionally, conventional ethylene carbonate (EC)/ethyl methyl carbonate (EMC) mixture electrolyte and safety enhanced EC-only electrolyte are examined. We show that storing additional Li inventory in the cathode (i.e., using a thicker electrode and having N/P<1) is a convenient method to enhance the capacity retention of LTO/LMO cells, but only if the electrode utilization is not limited by the Li + ion transport. For systems that suffer from limited transport properties, prelithiating the anode will be more effective since LTO (∼165 mAh g −1 LTO ) can store the same amount of capacity using less material compared to LMO (∼100 mAh g −1 LMO ). In this work, we demonstrate how the electrolyte properties and the electrode thickness of LTO/LMO cells can be designed to enhance their performance.
Li- and Mn-rich layered oxide material (xLi2MnO3 center dot(1-x)LiMeO2, Me = Ni, Mn, and etc., LMR-NM) is paired with Li4Ti5O12 (LTO) in a full cell and evaluated for the Behind-the-Meter Storage (BTMS) applications. The LMR-NM/ LTO full cell shows very high capacities and excellent long-term cycle life. It delivers 192 mAh g-1 after 500 cycles at C/2 and 45 degrees C with a capacity retention of 75 % and coulombic efficiency higher than 99.95 %. It also has impressive rate capabilities. A capacity of 220 mAh g-1 is achieved at 2C which is 88 % of the initial capacity at C/10. The high cycling temperature clearly enhances electrochemical kinetics and activates more Li2MnO3 component, which gives high capacities, low cell impedance, and better rate capabilities. Moreover, it helps to form a relatively thick cathode-electrolyte interphase (CEI) film to suppress transition metal dissolution from the cathode surface. The upper cut-off voltage (UCV) of 3.0 V keeps the structural integrity of the cathode during cycling. A higher UCV of 3.2 V accelerates structural instabilities of the cathode as well as growth of the solidelectrolyte interphase (SEI) via transition metal dissolution and deposition on the anode surface. It results in higher cell impedance, worse capacity retention and faster capacity fade.
Toward the development of high energy density and long lifetime batteries for behind-the-meter storage (BTMS) applications, Li- and Mn-rich layered oxide cathode (xLi 2 MnO 3 ·(1-x)LiMeO 2 , Me = Ni, Mn, and etc., LMR-NM) and Li 4 Ti 5 O 12 (LTO) anode system was examined. To mitigate the major degradation mechanisms at each electrode (i.e., loss of Li inventory (LLI) at the anode and transition metal dissolution and oxygen release at the cathode), two approaches were taken—prelithiating the LTO electrode and varying the electrolyte solvent compositions. The effect of prelithiation and electrolyte engineering on the long-term cycle performance of LMR-NM/LTO cells were systematically evaluated via electrochemical analyses and post-mortem characterizations. By using a prelithiated LTO anode and supplying additional Li to the system, the capacity retention of LMR-NM/LTO system was improved. The degree of enhancement was dependent on the types of electrolytes used, as their decomposition products determined the level of LLI. With increased capacity retention, however, the cathode was utilized to a greater extent, resulting in more severe loss of the cathode active material. Thus, all degradation mechanisms should be considered comprehensively when designing high performance LMR-NM/LTO cells to account for their complex interplay.
A refined synthesis and facile purification process have been developed to access pyridine-phenolic ligand derivatives in high purity and yield, which are needed for optical detection of low levels of metal ions in biological and environmental sensor applications. The two-step process employs Suzuki coupling and demethylation, and the purification is facilitated by an acid/base extraction protocol that allows for significant impurities to be removed without the need for conventional gradient chromatography. These amphoteric ligands exhibit unique physical, chemical, and spectroscopic properties and are of interest in the complexation of metal ions. The simplest pyridine-phenolic compound, 2-(2'-hydroxyphenyl)pyridine, is shown to have potential as a switch-on fluorescence ligand for beryllium ions under aqueous conditions.
Silicon oxides (SiOx) have been considered as promising alternatives to pure Si in high energy anodes in lithium-ion batteries (LIBs) due to their improved cycling stability. However, their fundamental lithiation mechanism has not yet been systematically investigated, and potential collateral downsides remain unclear. In this work, we report on the role of oxygen in lithiation/delithiation and solid electrolyte interphase (SEI) formation processes in SiOx thin film model electrodes with different oxygen contents. We show that the SiOx anodes with higher oxygen content experience smaller volume change and form a thinner and more stable SEI, both of which are beneficial for cycling stability. However, these SiOx anodes also show an irreversible lithiation at around 0.7 V attributed to the reduction of Si oxides, leading to lower first cycle coulombic efficiency that is undesirable for practical applications. Overall, these results offer a balanced perspective on the advantages and disadvantages that oxygen brings to Si-based anodes in LIBs.
Project Introduction This initiative, referred to as Behind-the-Meter Storage (BTMS), will focus on novel critical-materials-free battery technologies to facilitate the integration of electric vehicle (EV) charging, solar power generation technologies, and energy-efficient buildings while minimizing both costs and grid impacts. For extreme fastcharging at levels of 350 kW or higher, novel approaches are required to avoid significant negative cost and resiliency impacts. However, it is reasonable to assume that BTMS solutions would be applicable to other intermittent renewable energy generation sources or short-duration, high power-demand electric loads. BTMS research is targeted at developing innovative energy-storage technology specifically optimized for stationary applications below 10 MWh that will minimize the need for significant grid upgrades. Additionally, avoiding excessive high-power draws will eliminate excess demand charges that would be incurred during 350-kW fast-charging using current technologies. The key to achieving this is to leverage battery storage solutions that can discharge at high power but be recharged at standard lower power rates, acting as a power reservoir to bridge to the grid and other on-site energy generation technologies such as solar photovoltaics (PV), thereby minimizing costs and grid impacts. To be successful, new and innovative integration treatments must be developed for seamless interaction between stationary storage, PV generation, building systems, and the electric grid.
The ongoing surge of electric vehicle (EV) adoption forecasts an unprecedented amount of lithium-ion battery wastes in the near future. Since cathode materials have the highest economic and engineering values, it is essential to recycle and reuse the end-of-life (EOL) cathode materials. Here, we show that redox mediators can deliver lithium ions and electrons from a lithium source to the cathode, efficiently relithiate the EOL cathode materials, and make them ready for new battery production after a postheat treatment. We have found that some quinone-based redox mediators, especially 3,5-di-tert-butyl-o-benzoquinone (DTBQ), can shuttle the charges very fast between Li metal and EOL cathode. Reduction of DTBQ on lithium is evidenced by chemical changes of Li metal and DTBQ, and successful relithiation of the EOL cathode by the subsequent oxidation of DTBQ is verified by electrochemical and structural evaluations.
Growing demand for stationary energy storage systems requires the development of low cost, long cycle life, safe batteries. Lithium-ion batteries (LiBs) utilizing Li4Ti5O12 (LTO) anode and LiMn2O4 (LMO) cathode are promising candidates providing critical-material-free chemistry, high power capability, and long lifespan. However, their low energy density is a major drawback. In this work, we evaluate the rate performance of LTO/LMO cells fabricated with electrode loadings from 1.7 to 4.2 mAh cm(-2) toward the development of high energy density and low cost LTO/LMO cells. The operating temperature is varied from 30 degrees C to 55 degrees C to evaluate the impact of electrode thickness vs temperature limitations on the electrode utilization. In addition, Newman modeling is performed to provide detailed understandings of the cell performance. Combining experimental and simulated results, we show the rate capability of the thicker electrodes is limited by the electrolyte transport. When the cells are discharged by applying pulsed current, Li+ ion depletion is mitigated and the discharge capacity increases. Thus, high energy density LTO/LMO cells for BTMS applications can operate more efficiently when intermittent rest is applied. Finally, overcoming electrolyte transport limitations will be the key to enabling the development of high energy density LTO/LMO cells using thick electrodes.
As part of the World Bank Energy Storage Partnership, this document seeks to provide support and knowledge to a set of stakeholders across the developing world as we all seek to analyze the emerging opportunities and technologies for energy storage in the electric sector. As global prices for renewable energy have dropped dramatically over the last decade and continue to decline and the value of energy storage has increased in many systems, the World Bank technical teams and others have been hearing of a variety of problems. Related, developing countries have been asking a series of questions in this new area. This working group seeks to address the issues raised in part by creating this document and working to gather a variety of experts in this area from across the globe in support of the World Bank efforts. Performance testing, in combination with test beds (Working Group 2), is critical to fulfill the promise offered by these breakthrough technologies and critical to increasing trust in these systems and reducing risk. This document seeks to provide information to stakeholders in developing countries on the current global performance testing landscape of the battery (and broader) performance testing landscape. This document does that by summarizing testing protocols published by key global entities. From this summary, it can be concluded that there are several organizations within each region that set protocols for the testing and specifications of stationary energy storage systems. Across most of these entities, there are extensive protocols for testing batteries for electrical vehicles and mobile devices, but less for large scale energy storage system and their usage cases. The working group and the Partnership more generally agree that the nascent markets for certain technologies and rapid growth make testing more important than ever as these markets continue to mature. This document also seeks to provide a set of "guideposts" to new entrants by pointing out some of the key organizations globally that are currently engaged in performance testing of energy storage systems (often batteries but the larger organizations are likely to engage in tailored tests for emerging thermal and other storage technologies).
Growing demand for stationary energy storage systems requires the development of low cost, long cycle life, safe batteries. Lithium-ion batteries (LiBs) utilizing Li4Ti5O12 (LTO) anode and LiMn2O4 (LMO) cathode are promising candidates providing critical-material-free chemistry, high power capability, and long lifespan. However, their low energy density is a major drawback. In this work, we evaluate the rate performance of LTO/LMO cells fabricated with electrode loadings from 1.7 to 4.2 mAh cm−2 toward the development of high energy density and low cost LTO/LMO cells. The operating temperature is varied from 30 °C to 55 °C to evaluate the impact of electrode thickness vs temperature limitations on the electrode utilization. In addition, Newman modeling is performed to provide detailed understandings of the cell performance. Combining experimental and simulated results, we show the rate capability of the thicker electrodes is limited by the electrolyte transport. When the cells are discharged by applying pulsed current, Li+ ion depletion is mitigated and the discharge capacity increases. Thus, high energy density LTO/LMO cells for BTMS applications can operate more efficiently when intermittent rest is applied. Finally, overcoming electrolyte transport limitations will be the key to enabling the development of high energy density LTO/LMO cells using thick electrodes.
High-energy batteries for automotive applications require cells to endure well over a decade of constant use, making their long-term stability paramount. This is particularly challenging for emerging cell chemistries containing silicon, for which extended testing information is scarce. While much of the research on silicon anodes has focused on mitigating the consequences of volume changes during cycling, comparatively little is known about the time-dependent degradation of silicon-containing batteries. Here we discuss a series of studies on the reactivity of silicon that, collectively, paint a picture of how the chemistry of silicon exacerbates the calendar aging of lithium-ion cells. Assessing and mitigating this shortcoming should be the focus of future research to fully realize the benefits of this battery technology. Silicon-containing batteries are increasingly becoming a reality in the mass market, but their calendar aging behaviours have received comparatively little attention. Researchers from the Silicon Consortium Project discuss the issues surrounding the calendar lifetime of silicon anodes for lithium-ion batteries.
Li4Ti5O12/LiMn2O4 (LTO/LMO) chemistry was evaluated as a potential candidate for behind-the-meter storage (BTMS) applications. Its long-term cycle performance at 45 degrees C was tested using ethylene carbonate (EC) and propylene carbonate (PC) solvent electrolytes. Over 1000 cycles, LTO/LMO cells exhibited similar to 80% capacity retention and Coulombic efficiency higher than 99.96%. Electrochemical test results showed the major degradation mode of LTO/LMO cells arises from continuous electrolyte decomposition at the LTO anode and loss of Li inventory. EC and PC electrolytes created distinct surface layers, where the EC reduction products were more effective in passivating the LTO electrode surface. Dissolution and migration of Mn from the cathode was probed as Mn2+ species distributed throughout the surface layer at the anode. By utilizing a prelithiated LTO electrode, the LTO/LMO cell performance was significantly enhanced with EC electrolyte. On the other hand, PC electrolyte resulted in accelerated electrolyte decomposition at the lithiated LTO surface due to the lack of surface passivation. Thus, mitigating parasitic reactions at the LTO electrode is the key to developing successful LTO/LMO cells.
Silicon (Si) is a promising anode material for high-energy-density lithium-ion batteries (LIBs), but its short calendar life and poor cycling performance prevent its large-scale adoption. Introduci...
Silicon (Si) is a promising anode material for high energy density lithium-ion batteries (LIBs) but its poor cycling performance prevents its large-scale adoption. Introducing Mg salt into the electrolyte has shown to form a ternary Li-Mg-Si Zintl phase upon lithiation of Si and improve the cycling stability; however, its formation mechanism and impacts on the solid electrolyte interphase (SEI) are not yet well understood. Herein, we demonstrate the formation of a ternary Li-Mg-Si Zintl phase via a Magnesium (Mg) coated Si thin film electrode, where Mg diffuses into the Si film upon deposition and in the lithiation process. The Zintl phase alters the nature of SEI, suppresses the excess decomposition of electrolyte and improves the capacity retention of the Si anode. This study provides insights into the formation mechanism of ternary Zintl phase and guidelines for the future design of Si anodes.