Currently, the benefits of immune checkpoint blockade (ICB) for hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) are restricted to a subset of patients. We hypothesized that co-treatment with the inflammatory oncolytic virus (OV) vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV-IFNβ) would reprogram the highly immunosuppressive tumor microenvironment (TME) to enhance ICB. However, VSV-IFNβ inhibited the efficacy of ICB. To develop better, mechanism-based immunotherapies for HCC, here, we characterized (1) the baseline T cell response to HCC, (2) its enhancement by ICB, (3) the inhibitory effects of VSV, and (4) the antigenic response of HCC to treatment. We show that a slowly developing anti-tumor CD8+ T cell response becomes exhausted, is only initially sensitive to ICB, is outcompeted by a strong anti-viral CD8+ T cell response against VSV-IFNβ, and combination with ICB boosted the anti-viral, as opposed to the anti-tumor, response. We also identify additional molecules (CD39, LAG3) that may be valuable therapeutic targets to combine with ICB. Finally, we show that Sleeping Beauty (SB)-HCC tumors evolve different antigenic/immunogenic profiles to evade different therapies. Therefore, the future immunotherapy of HCC should target multiple molecules/immune checkpoints, avoid attritional competition by immunodominant T cells, and account for the rapidly evolving tumor phenotypes that emerge as a result of treatment-selective pressures.
Immune tolerance restricts the number of T cells with significant affinity for self-tumor-associated antigens (TAAs), thereby limiting successful cancer immunotherapy through an inability to generate populations of high-affinity anti-tumor T cells. In contrast, viral infection/vaccination primes and expands high-affinity effector and memory T cells against viral antigens. We show here that it is possible to exploit population-wide preexisting, anti-viral memory recall responses against SARS-CoV-2 antigens to focus a high-affinity, immunodominant T cell response into tumors by oncolytic virus (OV)-mediated or chimeric antigen receptor (CAR)-mediated delivery of viral antigens that are not themselves related to TAAs. Heterologous prime and OV/boost led to CD8+ T cell-dependent tumor cures using either SARS-CoV-2 Mem or Spike (S) proteins as vaccinating/tumor-focusing T cell targets, associated with epitope spreading against TAAs. We also show that CAR-T cells carry SARS-CoV-2 antigen-expressing vectors systemically to tumors even in pre-immune mice. Finally, S-specific CAR-T cells could be boosted in vivo with S protein vaccines to enhance anti-tumor activity and persistence. Thus, where high affinity anti-tumor T cells are not available, boosting preexisting infection- or vaccination-induced T cell populations within tumors using OV-mediated immunogen delivery provides a therapeutically valuable alternative.
The paradigm in the field of oncolytic virotherapy proposes that tumor cell killing by an oncolytic virus (OV) culminates in the priming of antitumor CD8 T cells. However, this ignores the impact a highly immunodominant antiviral response against the OV has on the antitumor response which has been weakened by mechanisms of central tolerance. Here, we show that inflammatory Vesicular Stomatitis Virus (VSV) failed to prime an adoptively transferred, or pre-existing, population of tumor-reactive T cells. Combination with αPD1 immune checkpoint blockade therapy improved survival only when VSV expressed tumor associated antigens (TAA). These data show that, in this model, the highly inflammatory OV VSV alone actively outcompetes antitumor immunity. However, we also show that viral expression of a mutant near-self TAA can break central tolerance expanding heteroclitic self-reactive and near-self-reactive T cells, thus overcoming viral immunodominance by promoting tumor-specific T cell proliferation in parallel with expanding antiviral T cells.
Chimeric antigen receptor (CAR) T cell therapy has revolutionized the treatment of liquid tumors but faces many challenges against solid tumors including T cell exhaustion and poor CAR durability. Here, we show that engaging the CAR T cell endogenous TCR using an oncolytic virus (OV) enhances CAR T cell functionality, durability, and therapy. Upon combination therapy of solid tumors with CAR T cells and vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV), a subpopulation of antiviral, TCR-primed CAR T cells was generated with enhanced effector functions, altered activation states, and differential gene and protein expression when compared to CAR T cells that do not undergo TCR priming. Single cell RNA-sequencing showed clonal expansion of anti-VSV CAR T cells, selective avoidance of exhaustion, and enhancement of effector-associated genes with VSV-mediated CAR T cell expansion. CD4 T cells played a pivotal role in both the generation and polarization of these TCR-primed CAR T cells. These results provide a strong rationale both for a novel use of intravenous administration of oncolytic viruses with separate applications from their direct oncolytic activity and for directly exploiting the TCR and its endogenous interactions as tools for fine tuning the phenotype and function of CAR T cells, with particular efficacy against solid tumors.
Although patients benefit from immune checkpoint inhibition (ICI) therapy in a broad variety of tumors, resistance may arise from immune suppressive tumor microenvironments (TME), which is particularly true of hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC). Since oncolytic viruses (OV) can generate a highly immune-infiltrated, inflammatory TME, OVs could potentially restore ICI responsiveness via recruitment, priming, and activation of anti-tumor T cells. Here we find that on the contrary, an oncolytic vesicular stomatitis virus, expressing interferon-ß (VSV-IFNß), antagonizes the effect of anti-PD-L1 therapy in a partially anti-PD-L1-responsive model of HCC. Cytometry by Time of Flight shows that VSV-IFNß expands dominant anti-viral effector CD8 T cells with concomitant relative disappearance of anti-tumor T cell populations, which are the target of anti-PD-L1. However, by expressing a range of HCC tumor antigens within VSV, combination OV and anti-PD-L1 therapeutic benefit could be restored. Our data provide a cautionary message for the use of highly immunogenic viruses as tumor-specific immune-therapeutics by showing that dominant anti-viral T cell responses can inhibit sub-dominant anti-tumor T cell responses. However, through encoding tumor antigens within the virus, oncolytic virotherapy can generate anti-tumor T cell populations upon which immune checkpoint blockade can effectively work.
Chimeric antigen receptor (CAR) T cells have had limited success against solid tumors. Here, we used an oncolytic foamy virus (oFV) to display a model CAR target antigen (CD19) on tumors in combination with anti-CD19 CAR T cells. We generated oFV-Δbel2 and oFV-bel2 vectors to test the efficiency and stability of viral/CD19 spread. While both viruses conferred equal CAR T killing in vitro, the oFV-Δbel2 virus acquired G-to-A mutations, whereas oFV-bel2 virus had genome deletions. In subcutaneous tumor models in vivo, CAR T cells led to a significant decrease in oFV-specific bioluminescence, confirming clearance of oFV-infected tumor cells. However, the most effective therapy was with high-dose oFV in the absence of CAR T cells, indicating that CAR T clearance of oFV was detrimental. Moreover, in tumors that escaped CAR T cell treatment, resurgent virus contained deletions within the oFV-CD19 transgene, allowing the virus to escape CAR T elimination. Therefore, oFV represents a slow smoldering type of oncolytic virus, whose chronic spread through tumors generates anti-tumor therapy, which is abolished by CAR T therapy. These results suggest that further development of this oncolytic platform, with additional immunotherapeutic arming, may allow for an effective combination of chronic oncolysis.
Chimeric antigen receptor (CAR) T cells are a clinically approved therapy for blood cancers. To produce clinical-grade CAR T cells, a retroviral or lentiviral vector is used to deliver the CAR and associated genes to patient T cells. Apolipoprotein B editing enzyme, catalytic polypeptide 3 (APOBEC3) enzymes are known to be upregulated after transfection and retroviral infection and to deaminate cytidine to uracil in nucleic acids, resulting in cytidine-to-thymine mutations in DNA. Here, we hypothesized that APOBEC3 enzymes, induced during the production of CART cells, impact the efficacy fi cacy of the resulting CAR T cells. We demonstrated that APOBEC3 family member APOBEC3B was upregulated at the RNA and protein levels after transfection of HEK293T cells with plasmids to make lentivirus, and that APOBEC3 signature mutations were present in the CAR construct. APOBEC3B overexpression in HEK293T cells led to further mutations in the resulting CAR T cells, and significantly fi cantly decreased CAR T cell killing. APOBEC3B knockout in HEK293T cells led to reduced mutations in the CAR construct and significantly fi cantly increased in CAR T cell killing. These results suggest that generation of CAR-expressing viruses from producer cell lines deficient fi cient in genome-modifying proteins such as APOBEC3B could enhance the quality of CAR T cell production.
T cell immune tolerance is established in part through the activity of the Auto-immune Regulator (AIRE) transcription factor in the medullary Thymic Epithelial Cells (mTEC) of the thymus. AIRE induces expression of SELF peripheral tissue-specific antigens for presentation to naïve T cells to promote activation/deletion of potentially autoreactive T cells. We show, for the first time to our knowledge, that tumors mimic the role of AIRE in mTEC to evade immune rejection. Thus, by expressing a broad range of SELF epitopes against which minimal functional T cell reactivities exist because of thymic deletion, AIRE acts as a master controller of SELFNESS, effectively cloaking the tumor from T cell attack. Moreover, we describe a completely novel immunotherapy in which engineered changes in AIRE expression in tumor cells alters their profile of SELFNESS, exposing both AIRE-modified, and parental unmodified, tumor cells to T cell attack. Consistent with our studies, patient RNAseq shows expression of AIRE predicts response to immune therapies with a strong correlation between AIRE expression and markers of TCR signaling. Therefore, by re-setting the immunological SELFNESS of cancer cells, this novel AIRE-mediated immunotherapy 1). converts a highly tolerized T cell compartment into a heteroclitic tumor-reactive T cell population; 2) confers de novo sensitivity to immune checkpoint blockade upon non-immunogenic tumors; 3). completely removes the need to identify potentially immunogenic tumor-associated antigens as targets for generation of de novo CD8+ and helper CD4+ T cell responses; and 4) leads to potent T cell-mediated rejection of aggressive, immunologically cold, non-immunogenic tumors.
Although immune checkpoint inhibition (ICI) has produced profound survival benefits in a broad variety of tumors, a proportion of patients do not respond. Treatment failure is in part due to immune suppressive tumor microenvironments (TME), which is particularly true of hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC). Since oncolytic viruses (OV) can generate a highly immune-infiltrated, inflammatory TME, we developed a vesicular stomatitis virus expressing interferon-ß (VSV-IFNß) as a viro-immunotherapy against HCC. Since HCC standard of care atezolizumab/bevacizumab incorporates ICI, we tested the hypothesis that pro-inflammatory VSV-IFNß would recruit, prime, and activate anti-tumor T cells, whose activity anti-PD-L1 ICI would potentiate. However, in a partially anti-PD-L1-responsive model of HCC, addition of VSV-IFNß abolished anti-PD-L1 therapy. Cytometry by Time of Flight showed that VSV-IFNß expanded dominant anti-viral effector CD8 T cells with concomitant, relative disappearance of anti-tumor T cell populations which are the target of anti-PD-L1. However, by expressing a range of HCC tumor antigens within VSV, the potent anti-viral response became amalgamated with an anti-tumor T cell response generating highly significant cures compared to anti-PD-L1 ICI alone. Our data provide a cautionary message for the use of highly immunogenic viruses as tumor-specific immune-therapeutics by showing that dominant anti-viral T cell responses can inhibit sub-dominant anti-tumor T cell responses. However, by chimerizing anti-viral and anti-tumor T cell responses through encoding tumor antigens within the virus, oncolytic virotherapy can be purposed for very effective immune driven tumor clearance and can generate anti-tumor T cell populations upon which immune checkpoint blockade can effectively work.
In multiple models of oncolytic virotherapy, it is common to see an early anti-tumor response followed by recurrence. We have previously shown that frontline treatment with oncolytic VSV-IFN-β induces APOBEC proteins, promoting the selection of specific mutations that allow tumor escape. Of these mutations in B16 melanoma escape (ESC) cells, a C-T point mutation in the cold shock domain-containing E1 (CSDE1) gene was present at the highest frequency, which could be used to ambush ESC cells by vaccination with the mutant CSDE1 expressed within the virus. Here, we show that the evolution of viral ESC tumor cells harboring the escape-promoting CSDE1C-T mutation can also be exploited by a virological ambush. By sequential delivery of two oncolytic VSVs in vivo, tumors which would otherwise escape VSV-IFN-β oncolytic virotherapy could be cured. This also facilitated the priming of anti-tumor T cell responses, which could be further exploited using immune checkpoint blockade with the CD200 activation receptor ligand (CD200AR-L) peptide. Our findings here are significant in that they offer the possibility to develop oncolytic viruses as highly specific, escape-targeting viro-immunotherapeutic agents to be used in conjunction with recurrence of tumors following multiple different types of frontline cancer therapies.
Repurposing FDA-approved drugs that treat respiratory infections caused by coronaviruses, such as SARS-CoV-2 and MERS-CoV, could quickly provide much needed antiviral therapies. In the current study, the potency and cellular toxicity of four fluoroquinolones (enoxacin, ciprofloxacin, levofloxacin, and moxifloxacin) were assessed in Vero cells and A549 cells engineered to overexpress ACE2, the SARS-CoV-2 entry receptor. All four fluoroquinolones suppressed SARS-CoV-2 replication at high micromolar concentrations in both cell types, with enoxacin demonstrating the lowest effective concentration 50 value (EC50) of 126.4 μM in Vero cells. Enoxacin also suppressed the replication of MERS-CoV-2 in Vero cells at high micromolar concentrations. Cellular toxicity of levofloxacin was not found in either cell type. In Vero cells, minimal toxicity was observed following treatment with ≥37.5 μM enoxacin and 600 μM ciprofloxacin. Toxicity in both cell types was detected after moxifloxacin treatment of ≥300 μM. In summary, these results suggest that the ability of fluoroquinolones to suppress SARS-CoV-2 and MERS-CoV replication in cultured cells is limited.
Functional analyses of mitochondria have been hampered by few effective approaches to manipulate mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) and a lack of existing animal models. Recently a TALE-derived base editor was shown to induce C-to-T (or G-to-A) sequence changes in mtDNA. We report here the FusX TALE Base Editor (FusXTBE) to facilitate broad-based access to TALE mitochondrial base editing technology. TALE Writer is a de novo in silico design tool to map potential mtDNA base editing sites. FusXTBE was demonstrated to function with comparable activity to the initial base editor in human cells in vitro. Zebrafish embryos were used as a pioneering in vivo test system, with FusXTBE inducing 90+% editing efficiency in mtDNA loci as an example of near-complete induction of mtDNA heteroplasmy in vivo. Gene editing specificity as precise as a single nucleotide was observed for a protein-coding gene. Nondestructive genotyping enables single-animal mtDNA analyses for downstream biological functional genomic applications. FusXTBE is a new gene editing toolkit for exploring important questions in mitochondrial biology and genetics.
Infected Ixodes scapularis (black-legged tick) transmit a host of serious pathogens via their bites, including Borrelia burgdorferi, Babesia microti, and tick-borne flaviviruses (TBFVs), such as Powassan virus (POWV). Although the role of female I. scapularis ticks in disease transmission is well characterized, the role of male ticks is poorly understood. Because the pathogens are delivered in tick saliva, we studied the capacity of male salivary glands (SGs) to support virus replication. Ex vivo cultures of SGs from unfed male I. scapularis were viable for more than a week and maintained the characteristic tissue architecture of lobular ducts and acini. When SG cultures were infected with the TBFVs Langat virus (LGTV) or POWV lineage II (deer tick virus), the production of infectious virus was demonstrated. Using a green fluorescent protein-tagged LGTV and confocal microscopy, we demonstrated LGTV infection within SG acinus types II and III. The presence of LGTV in the acini and lobular ducts of the cultures was also shown via immunohistochemistry. Furthermore, the identification by in situ hybridization of both positive and negative strand LGTV RNA confirmed that the virus was indeed replicating. Finally, transmission electron microscopy of infected SGs revealed virus particles packaged in vesicles or vacuoles adjacent to acinar lumina. These studies support the concept that SGs of male I. scapularis ticks support replication of TBFVs and may play a role in virus transmission, and further refine a useful model system for developing countermeasures against this important group of pathogens.