We present a joint analysis of all available seismological, geodetic and geological data to assess seismic hazard along the vulnerable French-Italian Riviera. This is achieved by discussing the most likely scenario and quantifying recurrence times for strong earthquakes. The most destructive earthquake known in the area (1887, M-w similar to 6.8) occurred offshore on the Ligurian Fault. This event is typical of strong but sporadic earthquakes that can provide valuable insights into the behavior of low-slip-rate faults. Given the uncertainties on each type of data, the results of the different approaches indicate a wide range of recurrence times for such an earthquake, from 607 to 15,969 yr. Considering the most probable values refines this range to 2353-9484 yr. Variations in seismicity rate associated with changes in geodynamic and environmental conditions are also discussed. Since the 1887 earthquake only ruptured the central part of the Ligurian Fault, the largest future hazard is posed by the adjacent fault segments, which could generate an event of similar magnitude.
Recent developments in Distributed Acoustic Sensing (DAS) have greatly expanded our capabilities for dense geophysical instrumentation by tapping into existing (but unused) fibre-optic telecommunication networks. Leveraging these so-called "dark fibres" permits an extremely rapid deployment of thousands of vibration sensors over distances of several tens of kilometres, which is ideal for rapid postseismic response efforts. Here we report on the use of dark-fibre DAS for monitoring of the aftershock sequence of the 2019-11-11 Mw 4.9 Le Teil, France earthquake. Through comparison with the local seismometer network, we assess the capabilities of the DAS array to detect and locate small-magnitude seismic events. Likely owing to cable deployment and DAS sensing characteristics, we find that the DAS noise floor is up to 3 orders of magnitude higher than that of nearby seismometers, which greatly inhibits the detection and analysis of the low-energy events. However, locating a selected aftershock with DAS yields an accuracy and precision that is comparable to that of the seismic network, even though the DAS array has a relatively unfavourable geometry. Based on these observations we provide a number of recommendations for routinely incorporating DAS into postseismic response protocols, and for optimal use of DAS alongside conventional seismic instrumentation.
We investigate the late Quaternary fault reactivation within Mescla Cave, offering the first dated offset in the southwestern Alps (SW France). While our dataset is limited to one outcrop, the observed W-dipping reverse slip displacing cave passage represents an outlier among the scarce young Quaternary tectonic structures expected in this seismically active region. Using the 230Th/U method, we dated fractured flowstones that predate the slip and stalagmite growth on the fault plane, bracketing the reactivation time frame from 51.6 +/- 2.4 ka to 11.7 +/- 1.3 ka. We interpret the detected displacement (23 cm) as secondary faulting associated with a larger, possibly distributed deformation along an unrecognised primary structure. Despite limited structural data containing only one strain, our findings highlight the geochronological value of caves in preserving deformation otherwise erased by erosion and provide new insights and questions into the active tectonics of the Maritimes Alps.
The spatial distribution of seismicity in active fault zones depends primarily on the geometry of the fault networks. However, recent advances suggest that seismic activity may also be controlled by the rheology of the geological units surrounding fault zones. In the present work, we use seismological and geological analyses to investigate the influence of the local geology on the rupture nucleation and propagation of the 2019 Le Teil earthquake (France; ML = 5.4; Mw = 4.9) and on the distribution of its aftershocks. The kinematic rupture model of the mainshock, obtained by joint inversion of seismological and INSAR data, shows that the rupture nucleated at 1 km depth and propagated mainly up-dip and bilaterally. Template matching detection identifies 115 aftershocks (-1.6 <= ML <= 2.5) in the two months following the mainshock. Double difference location shows that the aftershocks delineate a 4 km-long NE-SW plane with a 60 degrees dip to the SE, consistent with the extent and the geometry of the La Rouvi & egrave;re fault activated during the mainshock. By placing the seismicity in the local geological context, we conclude that the seismic activity was largely controlled by the rheological properties of the contrasting lithology. The mainshock nucleated in marly-limestone, but the coseismic slip was maximum above 0.6 km depth in a massive limestone more prompt to store elastic strain. The aftershocks occurred mainly in marls and marly limestone. They are interpreted as ruptures in competent beds of limestones of varying thickness, interbedded with marls.
The study of normal fault-generated landforms, such as fault scarps, is commonly performed to investigate fault evolution and the recurrence and magnitude of earthquakes. The Amorgos region (Cyclades, Greece), located in the central part of the Aegean Sea, is structured by ~70km large NE-SW normal faults accommodating the back-arc extension of the Hellenic arc and the Anatolian extrusion. These faults are able to generate large earthquakes such as the Amorgos event (Ms=7.8) on July 09, 1956, followed by a second shock (Ms=7.2) 12 minutes later. This destructive event was the largest Mediterranean earthquake of the 20th century and caused severe damage, especially on Santorini Island. It also triggered a tsunami with reported run-ups reaching locally 30m along the southern coast of Amorgos Island. The submarine Amorgos fault, structuring the island’s southern coast and cumulating a ~2 km high vertical offset, is suggested to be the source of the 1956 main shock and tsunami. However, the accurate position of the 1956 rupture and the magnitude of the slip at surface are unknown, as the fault outcrops at 700m below sea level, as well as the pace at which this fault breaks. Considering that normal faults frequently accommodate the deformation on multiple splays, and within their damage zone, we searched whether the onland faults found within the cumulative scarp of the Amorgos fault ruptured during the 1956 event. We first performed a morphological study of the Chozoviotissa fault segment with satellite imagery, Structure-from-motion modelling, and field observations. We found evidence of recent deformation along this fault, in particular a ~70 cm high fresh ribbon at the base of the fault scarp. To provide chronological constraints, we sampled along-dip the carbonate-rich fault scarp for TCNs (Terrestrial Cosmogenic Nuclides) dating using the chlorine-36 element. This paleoseismic approach provides new insights on the recent slip history of this secondary fault, which is important to better evaluate the activity of the Amorgos fault system and improve the hazard assessment of the archipelago.
The Amorgos-Santorini region (Hellenic Volcanic Arc, Greece), suffered the most powerful earthquake in the Mediterranean in the 20th century (1956, Mw ~7.5). This event caused casualties, severe damage and a large tsunami. The epicentral area is offshore and is characterized by several basins bounded by submarine faults accommodating back-arc extension and the Anatolian extrusion. Recently, the Amorgos fault was identified as the causative fault of the 1956 Amorgos earthquake. However, the characteristics of this fault, such as its detailed geometry, segmentation and kinematics remain unclear and debated. Using new high-resolution bathymetric data and sediment cores, we present a detailed mapping of this fault and its neighbors.The Amorgos fault is composed of three segments separated by relay zones. Taking into account the onshore geology, where E-W striking late Miocene normal faults are mapped, the segmentation could be controlled by structural heritage. Offshore, all but the southernmost segments of the Amorgos fault exhibit cumulative scarps of at least 700 m in relief. The segments strike NE-SW, except for the northern one that displays a curved structure in its middle, at 60° with respect to the main fault (E-W striking).The central segment, where evidences of the 1956 earthquake rupture were found, is composed of several secondary faults that offset young geomorphic features at the seafloor (such as mass-wasting scars) with purely normal kinematics. In comparison, the curved northern segment shows fewer secondary faults, none of them offsetting the numerous mass-wasting scars observed along its trace. We also find here secondary NE-SW faults that are crosscutting its cumulative scarps, and are offsetting the Last Glacial Maximum wave-cut platform by up to 5 meters, testifying for their recent activity. These observations question the role of the northern E-W striking segment in the accommodation of the present-day stress regime (NW-SE extension), that may be now inactive, or activated as a strike-slip fault, although we do not observe markers laterally offset. We discuss how the geometry and segmentation of the Amorgos fault can impact the rupture propagation, especially in relation to the 1956 earthquake and morphology of the nearby faults.
The study of normal fault-generated landforms, such as fault scarps, is commonly performed to investigate fault evolution and the recurrence and magnitude of earthquakes. The Amorgos region (Cyclades, Greece), located in the central part of the Aegean Sea, is structured by ~70km large NE-SW normal faults accommodating the back-arc extension of the Hellenic arc and the Anatolian extrusion. These faults are able to generate large earthquakes such as the Amorgos event (Ms=7.8) on July 09, 1956, followed by a second shock (Ms=7.2) 12 minutes later. This destructive event was the largest Mediterranean earthquake of the 20th century and caused severe damage, especially on Santorini Island. It also triggered a tsunami with reported run-ups reaching locally 30m along the southern coast of Amorgos Island. The submarine Amorgos fault, structuring the island’s southern coast and cumulating a ~2 km high vertical offset, is suggested to be the source of the 1956 main shock and tsunami. However, the accurate position of the 1956 rupture and the magnitude of the slip at surface are unknown, as the fault outcrops at 700m below sea level, as well as the pace at which this fault breaks. Considering that normal faults frequently accommodate the deformation on multiple splays, and within their damage zone, we searched whether the onland faults found within the cumulative scarp of the Amorgos fault ruptured during the 1956 event. We first performed a morphological study of the Chozoviotissa fault segment with satellite imagery, Structure-from-motion modelling, and field observations. We found evidence of recent deformation along this fault, in particular a ~70 cm high fresh ribbon at the base of the fault scarp. To provide chronological constraints, we sampled along-dip the carbonate-rich fault scarp for TCNs (Terrestrial Cosmogenic Nuclides) dating using the chlorine-36 element. This paleoseismic approach provides new insights on the recent slip history of this secondary fault, which is important to better evaluate the activity of the Amorgos fault system and improve the hazard assessment of the archipelago.
In the Rhone Valley near the city of Montelimar, a Mw 4.9 surface-rupturing earthquake occurring on the 11th of November 2019 was linked to the reactivation of the NE-SW trending normal La Rouviere fault as a reverse fault mechanism. Here, we present the first in situ calcite U-Pb data acquired on well-characterized microstructures from core samples from a first exploratory drilling conducted in the NE part of the La Rouviere fault. In agreement with relative chronology data based on microstructural observations, our results allow us to define four main tectonic events: A first event from similar to 90 to 75 interpreted to reflect a thermal subsidence at the regional scale (Ardeche-SouthEast basin of France), a second event bracketed between similar to 60 to 50 Ma related to the N-S trending shortening of the South-East basin, a third tectonic event dated from similar to 40 to 37 Ma that we interpret to reflect the opening of the Gulf of Lion and European Cenozoic Rift System (ECRIS), and a fourth and final event at similar to 25 Ma that very likely represents a middle to late stage of the ECRIS. No more recent event has been identified on this fault.
AbstractThe 2020 Alex storm in southern France led to localized extreme rainfall exceeding 600 mm in less than 24 hr. In the 100 days following the storm, a series of small earthquakes swarm occurred beneath the Tinée valley, a region characterized by a low background deformation. To gain insight into the mechanisms controlling swarm evolution, we used an enhanced seismic catalog to detect 188 events. These events exhibited magnitudes comprised between −1.03 and 2.01, and 78 of them were relocated using relative locations at an average depth of 3–4 km. Additionally, we estimated the directions and velocities of seismicity migration. Our analyses reveal multiple episodes of hypocenter expansion and migration within a fluid‐saturated fault system. Observations provide evidence of a bi‐directional seismicity migration marked by dual velocities within a swarm. The northward seismicity migration aligns with velocities indicative of aseismic slip (∼130 m/hr), while the southward migration corresponds to velocities associated with fluid pressure diffusion (∼5 m/hr). This migration pattern underscores the interplay of multiple physical mechanisms in both triggering and driving earthquakes. A stress‐driven model based on rate‐and‐state friction successfully explains the overall evolution of observed seismicity, whereas a fluid‐driven model fails to reproduce the data. Our observations and models suggest that fluid pressure changes resulting from intense rainfall caused aseismic slip in the shallow portion of the crust. We hypothesize that aseismic deformation serves as the driving force for the earthquake swarms, coupled with the invasion of pressurized fluid due to diffusing rainfall.
The geodynamic complexity of the Southwestern Alps (France, Italy) comes from its strong tectonic inheritage due to the European-African plates convergence. The motion being currently mainly accommodated along the Maghrebides, this region of the Alps only registers small to moderate seismicity linked to low-deformation rates (convergence rates of 0.3-0.9 mm/yr). Hence until now, the geometry of the active faults in the Southwestern Alps remains unclear and imprecise. Yet, a better knowledge of these faults is a prerequisite for the establishment of a regional deformation model and the improvement of the seismic hazard assessment.Taking advantages of a nine-year seismicity catalog (7659 earthquakes of local magnitudes ranging between -0.73 and 5.03), recorded by the French and Italian permanent national networks presenting no major evolution since 2014, a high-resolution relocation is currently ongoing. The purposes are to (1) understand how the seismic events are linked to the mapped faults, (2) highlight unknown deep seismogenic structures and (3) finally improve the overall picture of the 3D geometry of active faults in the Southwestern Alps.We present here the preliminary analysis of the relocated catalog. The seismicity is relocated using the double-difference relative method HYPODD with both cross-correlation and catalog times. As a result, the relocation is achieved for 5828 earthquakes. The uncertainties are reduced to less than 120m in horizontal and less than 600m in vertical compared to the initial average uncertainties of less than 2 kilometers for both values, referred by previous papers.We assess the reliability of our results by comparing, at regional scale, our new relocations with those obtained by similar methods in Ubaye region. We illustrate how the double-difference relocation refines active zones imaging at multiple scales, particularly in the swarms. In Isola region located around 60 kilometers from Nice, a swarm, active since summer 2021, initially detected by the national network as a 3-kilometerlong/1-kilometer-large shape, has been precised into a 1-kilometer-long/100-meterlarge spatial activity. This relocation improvement enabled us to detect progressive activation of fault segments. On larger scale, relation between faults that may play a key role in the present-day general dynamics of the Alpine chain and deep seismogenic structures is clarified. It is the case for the High-Durance valley (France), where the precise geometry at depth of the Crustal penninic Front and High-Durance fault is determined.
On 2nd October 2020, an unusual extreme rainfall event (600 mm) associated with the devastating “Alex storm” occurred in less than 24 hours in the Tinée valley, a low strain rate area (convergence rates of 0.3-0.9 mm/yr) of the Southern French Alps, located 20 kilometers from Nice city. This transitional zone between the Argentera Mercantour exhumed Alpine massif and the Nice/Castellane Arc, mainly filled with Cenozoic sediments covering inherited structures, has no clear active faults known and displays a low seismicity rate with only 60 events recorded between 2014 and October 2020 by the national RESIF-EPOS seismic network, with local magnitudes ranging from 0.6 to 2.6. However, in the days after the “Alex storm”, a sudden increase in the seismicity rate was observed, with 114 events detected by template matching (local magnitudes between -0.8 and 2.05). After a peak activity, reached on the 8th of October with more than 60 events detected, the seismic crisis ended around mid-December 2020. Here, we investigate how the intense rainfall can explain the seismic sequences and what are the triggering processes in such a low tectonically deformation area.Basing our analysis on a precise relocation of the seismicity, using the double-difference relative method, three swarms successively activating from south to north, with focal depths around 5 kilometers have been revealed. The main swarm clearly presents a N160 alignment, which is quite consistent with the general orientation of the Southwestern Alps main faults. A geological field analysis has also shown the presence of major unmapped pluri-kilometers faults consistent with the seismicity location and orientation. Those faults may cross-cut the entire sedimentary layers, connecting more or less directly the ground surface to the deep basement with some highly-permeable channels for fluid flow. Moreover, this relocation analysis highlighted a bi-directional migration of the seismicity within the main swarm: northwestward with a velocity of 100 m/hr, compatible with aseismic slip-driven seismicity, and southeastward with a velocity of 4.5 m/hr, rather compatible with fluid diffusion-driven seismicity.On top of that, preliminary numerical models, focusing on the analysis of Coulomb stress changes in response to the recorded rainfall rate, showed a correlation between the seismicity rate and the rainfall, which may indicate a rapid saturation of the shallow porous sedimentary layers with fluids after the storm. However, models of stress changes associated with increasing fluid pressure only or including the effect of poroelasticity are not sufficient to explain the temporal evolution of seismicity and its rates. The contribution of other driving processes is necessary and aseismic slip processes could be more relevant to explain the 3 main bursts of seismicity, the migration pattern and the few-days delay with the rainfall episode. Those rainfall-induced aseismic fault slip may have triggered local seismic ruptures along small seismogenic portions of unknown inherited structures. Thus, our study reveals that the Tinée valley area is a good example to study the complexity of aseismic triggering processes of seismicity in association with shallow rainfall-driven hydraulic perturbations in an intraplate region with a low-deformation background rate.
The 2019-11-1, Mw4.9 Le Teil earthquake occurred within the NE termination of the Cévennes faults system (CFS) in southern France, along the La Rouvière fault (LRF), an Oligocene normal fault which was not known to be potentially active. This shallow moderate magnitude reversefaulting event produced a 5 km-long surface rupture and strong ground shaking. No evidence of previous quaternary activity was observed in the morphology, raising the question whether the fault had been reactivated for the first time since the Oligocene or had broken the surface in the past without being detected in the morphology. To address this issue, we carried out paleoseismological investigations to analyze and characterize evidences of paleo-ruptures in Quaternary deposits. We discovered that at least one event prior 2019, occurred between 13.5 and 3.3 ka within the central part of the fault segment that broke in 2019, and that a possible earlier surfacerupturing event occurred within the northern part of this segment during the 16th century. Further investigations coupling sub-surface geophysical investigations and trenching are now carried out within the southern and northern segments of the LRF as well as along the other fault segments of the CFS.
The 11-11-2019 Le Teil earthquake (Mw4.9), located in the Rhône river valley occurred along the La Rouvière fault (LRF) within the NE termination of the Cévennes faults system (CFS). This very shallow moderate magnitude and reverse-faulting event inverted an Oligocene normal fault which was not assessed to be potentially active, causing surface rupture and strong ground shaking. Its morphology shows no evidence of cumulative reverse faulting during the Quaternary. All of this information raises the question of whether the fault was reactivated for the first time since the Oligocene during the Teil earthquake, or if it had broken the surface before, during the Quaternary period, but could not be detected. In addition, it poses the question of the potential reactivation of other faults of the CFS and other faults in metropolitan France as well. To tackle those issues, we launched paleoseismic investigations along the LRF to analyze and characterize evidences of paleo-ruptures in Quaternary deposits. Twelve trenches were dug along the section that broke in 2019. The trenches were dug in aeolian deposits and slope colluvium lying against the ancient LRF normal fault mirror carved in the Barremian limestones. Five trenches yielded favorable Quaternary deposits to document deformation suggesting that one paleo-event, maybe more, occurred with kinematic characteristics (sense of movement, amount of displacement) similar to the 2019 event. The radiocarbon dating of the deformed units (“bulks” collected from the colluvium clayey-silty matrix) suggests, in particular, that at least one event occurred in the past 13 Ka (i.e. penultimate event prior to the Teil earthquake) . The fact that these events are not preserved in the morphology is explained by the small amount of displacement and a long return period, consistent with the low strain rate measured by GPS in this region (~10-9 yrs-1). Our study shows that it is therefore fundamental to carry out more detailed paleoseismological investigations in metropolitan France, especially along ancient faults favorably oriented with respect to the present stress field. Those are already planned in the next coming months along other segments of the CFS.
The analysis of the seismicity catalog (1996 to 2019) covering the region from the Jura mountains to Corsica provides a first-order image of the distribution of earthquakes, highlighting large structures such as the Briançonnais and Piedmontais seismic arcs, the eastward deepening of the focal depths through the Western Alps, several large active faults (e.g. Belledonne, Middle Durance, Ligure). Over this period the magnitudes are moderate and the focal mechanisms of the main events display a diversity of seismic behaviors that can be explained by the complexity of the different geological domains with a more or less strong structural inheritage, by variable rheological characteristics at the scale of the crust and by the joint action of different mechanisms of deformation. The distribution of the historical events is in fairly good agreement with the instrumental seismicity, but several earthquakes of M>6 are highlighted since the 14th century until the beginning of the 20th.
The Ubaye Region is the most seismically active region in the Western Alps, with earthquakes that were commonly felt by the population and that even damaged local villages and cities. Since the first testimonies in 1844, this area has been regularly struck by seismic swarms with a high number of events, such as in 2003–2004 or 2012–2015, or by mainshock–aftershock sequences with a magnitude up to ML 5.3 in 1959. In this paper, we analysed both historical records and instrumental seismicity in the light of geological observations. Some earthquakes could be associated with known faults, even if most of them occurred on blind, unknown faults that reveal a highly fractured basement. The abnormal level of seismicity, together with its peculiar behaviour, suggests complex driving processes involving not only tectonic loading but also fluid pressure.
Mainland France is part of a plate interior with a strong structural heritage, undergoing a low rate of deformation, where destructive earthquakes can nevertheless occur. In this paper, we emphasize that the knowledge of active faults is still largely fragmentary, and that significant efforts are needed to generate robust data, in particular on the numerous faults, that still lack any study. This is the aim of the “Failles ACTives France” (FACT) axis launched in the framework of the Transverse Seismicity Action (ATS) of the Resif-Epos consortium. We present some recent investigations carried out along suspected active faults in mountainous areas, their forelands and remote lowlands, which implement new approaches and new tools, and allow characterizing their Quaternary activity.
The Ubaye Region, where the city of Barcelonnette is settled, is the most seismically active region in the French Western Alps since at least two centuries. Seismicity in this area exhibits a dual behaviour, with mainshock-aftershock sequences alternating with abnormally high rate of seismicity associated with seismic swarms. Understanding processes triggering such a peculiar seismic behaviour is of primary importance in order to assess the seismic hazard in this region. The latest swarm activity started on February 26, 2012, with an earthquake of moment magnitude 4.2. It was followed two years later (on April 7, 2014) by a shock of magnitude Mw 4.8. From the first earthquake to the end of 2016, the seismic level has not returned to the background level and shares the same characteristics as a seismic swarm. With the aim to discuss the seismogenic processes involved in the area, we focused on the two months following the 2014 mainshock (Mw=4.8). During this period, a dense temporary network (7 stations) was operating at a maximal distance of 10km from the epicentre area. We analysed this period starting with a double-difference relocation of ~ 6,000 earthquakes previously detected by template-matching. These hypocentres did not align on the fault plane of the 2014 mainshock, but on conjugated structures belonging to the 2-km wide damaged zone of the main fault plane and on remote structures with various orientations further away. We then computed 99 focal mechanisms from a joint inversion of P polarity and S/P ratio to clarify the geometry of the active structures. Many nodal planes are inconsistent with the structures deduced from the alignments of the earthquake locations. The stress-state orientation obtained from those focal mechanisms (σ1 trending N27°± 5°, plunging 50°± 9°, a σ2 trending N215°± 5°, plunging 40°± 9°, and a sub-horizontal σ3 trending N122°± 3°) is consistent with those previously calculated in the area (Fojtíková and Vavryčuk, 2018). Nevertheless, some structures are unfavourably oriented to slip within this stress-field, suggesting that additional processes are required to explain them. As the presence of fluids was highlighted for the 2003-2004 and the 2012-2015 crisis, we calculated the fluid pressure needed to trigger slip on the planes from the focal mechanisms using Cauchy's equation. We found that a median fluid-overpressure of ~20 MPa (range between 0 to 50 MPa) is needed to cause slip. Although the origin of fluids and how they are pressurized at depth remains open. The fluid processes seem to be the most favourable additional processes and were also proposed to explain the 2003-2004 crisis.