Saltmarsh restoration such as managed realignment (MR) projects often include excavation of simplified tidal creek networks to improve drainage and marsh functioning, but their design is based on limited evidence. This paper compares the morphological evolution of creek networks in current MR projects in the UK with creek networks in natural saltmarshes, in order to provide improved guidance. The evolution of creek networks was monitored for 2-20 years post-breach at 10 MR sites across the UK by semi-automatically extracting 12 morphological creek parameters from lidar. The rates of creek evolution in MR sites are linked to the initial tidal, morphological and sedimentological conditions using principal component analysis, then compared with power law relationships of morphological equilibrium defined from 13 mature natural saltmarshes. MR creeks evolved into larger, more complex, better distributed systems, with a total creek length and volume statistically similar to their natural counterparts. However, the creek volume remains poorly distributed, with a mean distance between creeks ranging from 33 to 101 m versus 5-15 m for natural mature saltmarshes. MR creeks are also clustered around the breach area, leaving the marsh interior poorly drained. MR creek network morphologies remain strongly influenced by the initial creek template, as evidenced by unnaturally straight creeks inherited from former drainage ditches. A combination of external conditions (i.e., tidal range, sediment concentration in the wider estuary) and local conditions (i.e., site elevation, topographical heterogeneity, soil compaction) controls how easily creeks can form within MR sites. This in turn determines the amount of engineering effort required to help achieve reference site conditions. The end goal of creek design is to create MR sites that closely resemble reference site conditions, however the final design is also likely to be affected by a range of practical factors (e.g. engineering/cost) unique to each site and project.
Salt marshes provide diverse ecosystem services including coastal protection, habitat provision and carbon sequestration. The loss of salt marshes is a global scale phenomenon, of great socio-economic concern due to the substantial benefits that they provide. However, the causes of spatial variability in marsh loss rates are inadequately understood for the purposes of predicting future ecosystem distributions and functions under global environmental change. This study investigated the relationship between the presence of different saltmarsh plants and the mechanical properties of the underlying substrate that relate to its vulnerability to erosion. Relationships between three halophytes (Puccinellia spp., Spartina spp. and Salicornia spp.) and sediment stability were assessed and compared to unvegetated substrates using in-situ and laboratory tests of substrate geotechnical properties and sediment characteristics. Sampling was conducted at two UK sites with contrasting sedimentology, one sand-dominated and one clay-rich. Sediment samples, collected simultaneously with measurements of shear strength, were analysed for moisture content, particle size and organic, carbonate and mineral compositions. These data were then used to explore the contribution of plant type, alongside the sedimentological parameters, to measured shear strength.Shear strength of the sediment varied between and, to a lesser extent, within sites, with the four cover types having a similar effect on shear strength within sites relative to each other. Sediments covered by Puccinellia spp exhibit the highest shear strength, while bare sediments exhibit the lowest. The effect of vegetation type on shear strength was greater in the coarser sediments of Warton Sands. Surface cover type made a significant contribution to exploratory statistical models developed for the prediction of sediment shear strength. The findings support existing recognition that vegetation can enhance sediment shear strengths but extend the insight reveal differences in this effect that show generality between sedimentological settings. Further, the combination of methods provides insight into the fundamental mechanics by which various measures of sediment stability may be affected by different surface cover types. Cohesion appears to be a more appropriate descriptor sediment erodibility than shear strength or friction angle and is most greatly enhanced by the presence of a fine, fibrous root system such as that of Puccinellia. A more detailed understanding of the multi-scale mechanisms which plants confer strength to substrates is needed to better anticipate their impact on sediment erodibility, and therefore salt marsh vulnerability.
Coastal wetlands provide crucial ecosystem services including flood protection and carbon storage, but are being lost rapidly worldwide to the combined effects of sea-level rise, erosion and coastal urbanisation. Managed Realignment (MR) aims to mitigate for these losses by restoring reclaimed land to tidal influence. Data of creek evolution is critical to assess the performance of design strategies and improve design and implementation practices. This data descriptor provides a dataset of the horizontal morphological evolution of creek systems from various initial conditions in 10 MR schemes across the UK. Using a semi-automated workflow, morphological creek parameters were extracted from 52 lidar datasets at 1 m horizontal resolution spanning 2 to 20 years post-breach. This constitutes the most comprehensive systematic monitoring of MR creek morphology to date. The dataset will assist future MR design and provide baseline morphological information for ecological and biogeochemical surveying.
Salt marshes deliver vital ecosystem services by providing habitats, storing pollutants and atmospheric carbon, and reducing flood and erosion risk in the coastal hinterland. Net losses in salt marsh areas, both modelled globally and measured regionally, are therefore of concern. Amongst other controls, the persistence of salt marshes in any one location depends on the ability of their substrates to resist hydrodynamic forcing at the marsh front, along creek margins and on the vegetated surface. Where relative sea level is rising, marsh elevation must keep pace with sea-level rise and landward expansion may be required to compensate for areal loss at exposed margins. This paper reviews current understanding of marsh substrate resistance to the near-instantaneous (seconds to hours) forcing induced by hydrodynamic processes. It outlines how variability in substrate properties may affect marsh substrate stability, explores current understanding of the interactions between substrate properties and erosion processes, and how the cumulative impact of these interactions may affect marsh stability over annual to decadal timescales. Whilst important advances have been made in understanding how specific soil properties affect near-instantaneous marsh substrate stability, less is known about how these properties interact and alter bulk substrate resistance to hydrodynamic forcing. Future research requires a more systematic approach to quantifying biological and sedimentological marsh substrate properties. These properties must then be linked to specific observable erosion processes, particularly at the marsh front and along creek banks. A better understanding of the intrinsic dynamics and processes acting on, and within, salt marsh substrates will facilitate improved prediction of marsh evolution under future hydrodynamic forcing scenarios. Notwithstanding the additional complications that arise from morphodynamic feedbacks, this would allow us to more accurately model the future potential protection from flooding and erosion afforded by marshes, while also increasing the effectiveness of salt marsh restoration and recreation schemes. (c) 2020 The Authors. Earth Surface Processes and Landforms published by John Wiley & Sons Ltd
The vulnerability of saltmarshes to lateral erosion at their margin depends on the local biogeomorphological properties of the substrate. In particular, the 3D architecture of pore and root systems is expected to influence shear strength, with repercussions for the wider‐scale stability of saltmarshes. We apply X‐ray computed microtomography (μCT) to visualize and quantify subsurface structures in two UK saltmarshes at Tillingham Farm, Essex (silt/clay rich substrate) and Warton Sands (sand‐rich substrate), with four types of ground cover: bare ground, Spartina spp , Salicornia spp and Puccinellia spp . We extracted μCT structural parameters that characterize pore and root morphologies at each station, and compared them with field measurements of shear strength using a principal component analysis and correlation tests. The 3D volumes show that species‐dependent variations in root structures, plant colonization events and bioturbation activity control the morphology of macropores, while sediment cohesivity determines the structural stability and persistence of these pore structures over time, even after the vegetation has died. Areas of high porosity and high mean pore thickness were correlated to lower values of shear strength, especially at Tillingham Farm, where well‐connected vertical systems of macropores were associated with current or previous colonization by Spartina spp . However, while well‐connected systems of macropores may lower the local deformation threshold of the sediment, they also encourage drainage, promote vegetation growth and reduce the marsh vulnerability to hydrodynamic forces. The highest values of shear strength at both sites were found under Puccinellia spp , and were associated with a high density of mesh‐like root structures that bind the sediment and resist deformation. Future studies of marsh stability should ideally consider time series of vegetation cover, especially in silt/clay‐dominated saltmarshes, in order to consider the potential effect of preserved buried networks of macropores on water circulation, marsh functioning and cliff‐face erosion.
Subsurface structures and especially the interactions between pores, roots and other organic matter elements have a strong impact on ecosystem functioning. Yet despite recent progress in the application of X-ray Computed Microtomography (mu CT) to soil structure in agricultural science, applications to the more complex and heterogeneous substrates found in natural soils, specifically wetland soils, remain sparse. We apply X-ray mu CT to a complex hetemgenous soil and develop a robust segmentation method to quantify the pores, live roots and necromass. This approach significantly improves the detection of the organic matter elements, and gives us unprecedented detail and resolution in the segmentation of pores, live roots and necromass at a high spatial resolution (62.5 mu m in this study). We identify several situations where pores and organic matter interact in the soil, including the disconnected air spaces (aerenchyma) that run within the Spartina stem and roots, tubularshaped pores left behind by decaying roots, and lateral roots deploying within structural fragilities in the sediment. The capacity of X-ray mu CT to distinguish the connected live root system from the necmmass opens possibilities for applications to determine key wetland soil functions such as soil cohesivity, soil nutrient exchanges and soil carbon dynamics.
Salt marshes provide diverse ecosystem services including coastal protection, habitat provision and carbon sequestration. The loss of salt marshes is a phenomenon that is observable on a global scale and is of great socioeconomic concern due to the substantial benefits these environments provide. The causes of spatial variability in rates of marsh loss are inadequately understood for the purposes of predicting future ecosystem functions and distributions in the context of global environmental change.We investigate the relationship between vegetation of different genera and the mechanical properties of the substrate. We couple in-situ and laboratory tests of substrate geotechnical properties with micro-CT imaging of undisturbed root network structures to assess the contribution of three halophytes to sediment stability. We investigate the role of Puccinellia spp., Spartina spp. and Salicornia spp. in the modification of geotechnical parameters such as critical shear strength and cohesion when compared to un-vegetated sediments. We then compare these effects between clay-rich and sandy contexts on the East and West coasts of the United Kingdom respectively.We find that the three genera are characterised by different root network morphologies which, in part, explain the differences that we observe between the geotechnical properties of sediments colonised by these contrasting vegetation types. The presence of roots within the sediment structure increases the cohesion, as measured using a laboratory shear box test, when compared to bare sediment, with the magnitude of this effect varying by root morphology and sedimentology. In-situ shear vane tests reveal a localised spatial variability in sediment shear strength that is related to halophyte species distributions. This allows multispectral UAV imagery to be used to map species distributions and thereby infer a component of the sediment’s vulnerability to erosion that supports the prediction of future marsh distributions and, ultimately, ecosystem service provision.
Coastal wetlands provide multiple ecosystem services through carbon storage, rich biodiversity and provision of harvested goods. A key service is their provision of ‘free’ coastal defence by dissipating storm wave and tidal energy, and their ability to accrete vertically and provide a natural buffer against the impact of projected sea-level rise. However, under IPCC climate projections, extreme hydrodynamic events associated with storm surges are expected to increase in both frequency and magnitude, exposing the margins of salt-marshes to increased erosion stress. The resistance of coastal wetlands to erosion during these events is poorly understood, and lateral erosion rates vary dramatically between UK salt-marshes. The NERC-RESIST project is exploring why this resilience to erosion varies, with a focus on the effect of the structural properties of the marsh substrate, to develop rapid evaluation tools of salt-marsh resistance for coastal engineers and inform future conservation efforts. The NERC-RESIST project explores how subsurface and surface structural characteristics of UK coastal wetlands affect their erodibility under tidal forcings, in order to provide coastal engineers with improved guidance for conservation schemes. In order to link internal sediment structure to erodibility, X-Ray CT scans were undertaken on large sediment cores recovered from two coastal wetlands (Tillingham, Essex; Warton, Lancashire) that are currently experiencing contrasting rates of lateral erosion. X-Ray CT scanning is a non-destructive imaging technique that allows a quantified analysis of 3D sediment properties, pore-space and root structure. After scanning, the cores were exposed to a variety of realistic wave energy conditions at the Grosser Wellen-Kanal (GWK) Large Flume Facility in Hannover, Germany, and high-resolution structure from motion imagery were collected to identify patterns of wave-induced erosion. This talk presents a 3D characterisation and detailed mapping of the topology of both pore and root networks within cores from the two salt-marshes. Two basic hypotheses are tested: the first examines the contribution of root systems in binding saltmarsh sediments and thus strengthening them against lateral erosion, and the second examines the role of macropores in facilitating the penetration of storm-wave water and energy into the sediment, contributing to weakening and increased erosion. A distance-mapping method is applied based on these hypotheses to develop a simple index of sediment structural vulnerability to erosion. These predictions are then compared to observed rates and patterns of storm wave-induced erosion from the GWK experiments. This informs an evaluation of the relative importance of inherent sediment properties (sediment type, cohesion, strength) and sediment structural characteristics in determining the erodibility of salt-marsh sediments.
(1) Cambridge Coastal Research Unit, University of Cambridge, Cambridge, United Kingdom (bre24@cam.ac.uk), (2) Royal Netherlands Institure for Sea Research, Yerseke, Netherlands, (3) University of Cumbria, Carlisle, United Kingdom, (4) Queen Mary University Of London, London, United Kingdom, (5) University of Hamburg, Hambirg, Germany, (6) TU Braunschweig, Braunschweig, Germany, (7) British Geological Survey, Nottingham, United Kingdom, (8) University of Antwerp, Antwerp, Belgium, (9) Forschungszentrum Küste, Hannover, Germany
Coastal saltmarshes provide a range of ecosystem services, such as flood protection and carbon sequestration, but face rapid global losses. Managed realignment (MR) is an increasingly popular method to artificially recreate these habitats by reinstating tidal regimes to reclaimed land. However, to improve MR design, better knowledge of the processes that control morphological evolution in natural saltmarshes is needed. In this paper, we develop tools to assist in the monitoring of creek network evolution towards dynamic morphological equilibrium, a state of landform stability under current physical forcings. Using lidar (Light Detection and Ranging) datasets, we combined a semi-automated creek extraction algorithm, based on elevation and slope thresholds, with a novel algorithm for morphometric creek analysis. A comprehensive suite of morphological creek characteristics was extracted for 13 natural British saltmarshes, including: amplitude, length, sinuosity ratio, junction angle, width, depth, cross-sectional area, creek order, bifurcation ratio, drainage density, and drainage efficiency. Results closely matched with field-validated manual digitization results, and were significantly faster and less subjective to produce. Morphological equilibrium relationships from the literature were found to be applicable to the new dataset, despite yielding high prediction errors due to the inherent variety of creek network shapes in salt marshes. New equilibrium relationships were also defined relating the creek network drainage efficiency to the mouth cross-sectional area and the marsh elevation. To improve future scheme designs, these tools will be used in further studies to monitor rates of evolution towards equilibrium in MR sites depending on their initial conditions.
Estimates of bed roughness used for predictions of sediment transport are usually derived either from simple scalars of the physical roughness (i.e., ripple height or grain size) or from the hydrodynamic roughness length (Zo) based upon velocity gradient estimates in the benthic boundary layer. Neither parameter accounts for irregular bed features. This study re-evaluates the relation between hydrodynamic roughness and physical bed roughness using high-resolution seabed scanning in the inlet of a shallow lagoon. The statistically-robust relationship, based on a 1D statistical analysis of the seabed elevation at different locations of the Cabras lagoon. Sardinia, has been obtained between Zo and the topographical bed roughness Ks by defining Ks = 2*STD + skin friction, with STD the standard deviation of the seabed elevation variations. This correlation between Ks and Zo demonstrates that the roughness length is directly influenced by irregular bed features, and that the Reynolds number accounts for the total drag of the bed: the data points collapse on the Law of the Wall curves with a fitting factor x = 0.5. Further testing must be done in other locations and in the fully-rough domain in order to test how widely those new parameters can be applied.