While artificial intelligence (AI) has been promising for fusion control, its inherent black-box nature will make compliant implementation in regulatory environments a challenge. This study implements and validates a real-time AI-enabled linear and interpretable control system for successful divertor detachment control with the DIII-D lower divertor camera. Using D _2 gas, we demonstrate successful feedback divertor detachment control with a mean absolute difference of 2% from the target for both detachment and reattachment. This automatic training and linear processing framework can be extended to any image-based diagnostic for future fusion reactors.
We report the experimental results of controlling the pedestal-top electron density by applying resonant magnetic perturbation (RMP) with in-vessel control coils and the main gas puff in the 2024-2025 KSTAR experimental campaign. The density is reconstructed using a parameterized ψ N grid and five channels of line-averaged density measured by the two-colored interferometer (TCI). The reconstruction procedure is accelerated by deploying a multi-layer perceptron to run in approximately 120 µ s and is sufficiently fast for real-time control. A proportional-integral controller was adopted, with the controller gains estimated from the system identification procedure. The experimental results demonstrate that the developed controller can follow a dynamic target while exclusively using both actuators. The absolute percentage errors between the electron density at ψ N = 0.89 and the target were approximately 1.5% median and a 2.5% average, respectively. The developed controller can even lower the density by using the pump-out mechanism under RMP, and it can follow a more dynamic range of density targets than a single actuator controller. The developed controller will enable experimental scenario exploration within a shot by dynamically setting the density target or maintaining a constant electron density within a discharge.
Edge transport barriers in magnetically confined fusion plasmas, commonly known as pedestals, play a crucial role in achieving high confinement plasmas. However, their defining characteristic, a steep rise in plasma pressure over short length scales, makes them challenging to diagnose experimentally. In this work, we use Gaussian process regression (GPR) to develop first-principles metrics for quantifying the spatiotemporal resolution limits of inferring differentiable profiles of temperature, pressure, or other quantities from experimental measurements. Although we focus on pedestals, the methods are fully general and can be applied to any setting involving the inference of profiles from discrete measurements. First, we establish a correspondence between GPR and low-pass filtering, giving an explicit expression for the effective ‘cutoff frequency’ associated with smoothing incurred by GPR. Second, we introduce a novel information-theoretic metric, N eff , which measures the effective number of data points contributing to the inferred value of a profile or its derivative. These metrics enable a quantitative assessment of the trade-off between ‘over-fitting’ and ‘over-regularization’, providing both practitioners and consumers of GPR with a systematic way to evaluate the credibility of inferred profiles with respect to their degree of regularization. We apply these tools to develop practical advice for using GPR in both time-independent and time-dependent settings, and demonstrate their usage on inferring pedestal profiles using measurements from the DIII-D tokamak.
KSTAR has recently undergone an upgrade to use a new tungsten divertor to run experiments in ITER-relevant scenarios. Even with a high melting point of tungsten, it is important to control the heat flux impinging on tungsten divertor targets to minimize sputtering and contamination of the core plasma. Heat flux on the divertor is often controlled by increasing the degree of detachment of scrape-off layer plasma from the target plates. In this work, we have demonstrated successful divertor detachment and heat exhaust dissipation control experiments using two different methods. The first method uses attachment fraction as a control variable which is estimated using ion saturation current measurements from embedded Langmuir probes in the divertor. The second method uses a novel machine-learning-based surrogate model of 2D UEDGE simulation database, DivControlNN. We demonstrated running inference operation of DivControlNN in realtime to estimate heat flux at the divertor and use it as the control variable in a feedback loop with impurity gas flow. We present interesting insights from these experiments including a systematic approach to tuning controllers and discuss future improvements in the control infrastructure and control variables for future burning plasma experiments.
Experiments with extrinsic impurity seeding in strongly negative triangularity shapes in DIII-D achieved radiated power fractions (relative to input power) of up to approximate to 85% total radiation and approximate to 55% core radiation in steady-operating conditions. The relationship between core and total radiation was sensitive to impurity species and input power. Attempts to reach higher radiation levels via higher impurity flows resulted in radiative collapse disruptions. Nitrogen, neon, argon, and krypton were tested. Injection was by gas puffing, usually controlled by feeding back real-time estimates for core or total radiating fractions ( Prad/Pinput). Argon and krypton were controlled by feeding back total radiating fraction, whereas neon was controlled by feeding back the core radiating fraction, due to the lower efficiency of neon as a divertor radiator. Nitrogen flows were pre-programmed. Reasonable total Prad control target following was achieved with argon or krypton. Control was more challenging with the neon/core radiation configuration, which was more prone to slow response and overshooting of the control target. Poor particle removal contributed to the control challenge: neon particle inventory within the last closed flux surface was roughly constant for up to 1 s (the longest duration tested) after neon injection was halted. However, separate experiments with laser-blow off of non-recycling impurities measured a short impurity confinement time, on the scale of the energy confinement time of similar to 100 ms. Modeling with the Aurora impurity transport simulation matched experimental neon densityprofiles with full recycling (R = 1.0) and weak pumping but predicted rapid decreases in neon inventory if pumping were increased or recycling decreased. This indicates that changes outside the confined plasma (adding a well-placed pump) would improve controllability for all highly recycling species.
KSTAR has recently undergone an upgrade to use a new Tungsten divertor to run experiments in ITER-relevant scenarios. Even with a high melting point of Tungsten, it is important to control the heat flux impinging on tungsten divertor targets to minimize sputtering and contamination of the core plasma. Heat flux on the divertor is often controlled by increasing the detachment of Scrape-Off Layer plasma from the target plates. In this work, we have demonstrated successful detachment control experiments using two different methods. The first method uses attachment fraction as a control variable which is estimated using ion saturation current measurements from embedded Langmuir probes in the divertor. The second method uses a novel machine-learning-based surrogate model of 2D UEDGE simulation database, DivControlNN. We demonstrated running inference operation of DivControlNN in realtime to estimate heat flux at the divertor and use it to feedback impurity gas to control the detachment level. We present interesting insights from these experiments including a systematic approach to tuning controllers and discuss future improvements in the control infrastructure and control variables for future burning plasma experiments.
The first achievement of highly radiating plasmas in negative triangularity (NT) is shown with an operational space featuring high core radiation at high Greenwald fraction obtained with the injection of reactor-relevant seeded gases. These NT shape diverted discharges reach high values of normalized plasma pressure (beta N > 2) at high radiation fraction with no edge localized modes (ELMs) and a simultaneous reduction of the divertor heat flux. We demonstrate that as long as the impurity level in the core is kept low to avoid excessive fuel dilution and impurity accumulation, integration of NT configuration with high radiation fraction not only is achievable but it can lead to confinement improvement with stabilization effects originating from collisionality, E x B shear and profiles changes due to impurity radiation cooling. The underlying physics mechanism is robust and reproducible and holds for a variety of impurity species. The absence of the requirement to stay in H-mode translates in a higher core radiation fraction potentially allowed in NT shape effectively mitigating the power exhaust issue. The results presented here demonstrate a path to high performance, ELM free and highly radiative regime with reactor-relevant seeding gases making this regime a potential new scenario for reactor design.
The inherent complexity of boundary plasma, characterized by multi-scale and multi-physics challenges, has historically restricted high-fidelity simulations to scientific research due to their intensive computational demands. Consequently, routine applications such as discharge control and scenario development have relied on faster but less accurate empirical methods. This work introduces DivControlNN, a novel machine-learning-based surrogate model designed to address these limitations by enabling quasi-real-time predictions (i.e., ∼0.2 ms) of boundary and divertor plasma behavior. Trained on over 70,000 2D UEDGE simulations from KSTAR tokamak equilibria, DivControlNN employs latent space mapping to efficiently represent complex divertor plasma states, achieving a computational speed-up of over 108 compared to traditional simulations while maintaining a relative error below 20% for key plasma property predictions. During the 2024 KSTAR experimental campaign, a prototype detachment control system powered by DivControlNN successfully demonstrated detachment control on its first attempt, even for a new tungsten divertor configuration and without any fine-tuning. These results highlight the transformative potential of DivControlNN in overcoming diagnostic challenges in future fusion reactors by providing fast, robust, and reliable predictions for advanced integrated control systems.
While artificial intelligence (AI) has been promising for fusion control, its inherent black-box nature will make compliant implementation in regulatory environments a challenge. This study implements and validates a real-time AI enabled linear and interpretable control system for successful divertor detachment control with the DIII-D lower divertor camera. Using D2 gas, we demonstrate feedback divertor detachment control with a mean absolute difference of 2
Real-time magnetic control has been developed to deliver precise control of multiple plasma shape parameters for advanced divertor configurations, including double-null, Super-X, X-point target and X-divertor for the first time on the MAST Upgrade (MAST-U) spherical tokamak. Successful real-time magnetic equilibrium control of different plasma shape variables has been accomplished in the 2022–2023 MAST-U experimental campaign for the advanced MAST-U divertor configurations. Application of the MAST-U boundary reconstruction algorithm, LEMUR, is described and compared with off-line equilibrium reconstruction and diagnostic measurements. The process of design and verification of the axisymmetric magnetic control schemes using a suite of control analysis tools (known collectively as TokSys) is also described.
The tokamak approach, utilizing a toroidal magnetic field configuration to confine a hot plasma, is one of the most promising designs for developing reactors that can exploit nuclear fusion to generate electrical energy(1,2). To reach the goal of an economical reactor, most tokamak reactor designs(3-10) simultaneously require reaching a plasma line-averaged density above an empirical limit-the so-called Greenwald density(11)-and attaining an energy confinement quality better than the standard high-confinement mode(12,13). However, such an operating regime has never been verified in experiments. In addition, a long-standing challenge in the high-confinement mode has been the compatibility between a high-performance core and avoiding large, transient edge perturbations that can cause very high heat loads on the plasma-facing-components in tokamaks. Here we report the demonstration of stable tokamak plasmas with a line-averaged density approximately 20% above the Greenwald density and an energy confinement quality of approximately 50% better than the standard high-confinement mode, which was realized by taking advantage of the enhanced suppression of turbulent transport granted by high density-gradients in the high-poloidal-beta scenario(14,15). Furthermore, our experimental results show an integration of very low edge transient perturbations with the high normalized density and confinement core. The operating regime we report supports some critical requirements in many fusion reactor designs all over the world and opens a potential avenue to an operating point for producing economically attractive fusion energy.
The Korean Superconducting Tokamak Advanced Research has been focused on exploring the key physics and engineering issues for future fusion reactors by demonstrating the long pulse operation of high beta steady-state discharge. Advanced scenarios are being developed with the goal for steady-state operation, and significant progress has been made in high & ell;i, hybrid and high beta scenarios with beta N of 3. In the new operation scenario called fast ion regulated enhanced (FIRE), fast ions play an essential role in confinement enhancement. GK simulations show a significant reduction of the thermal energy flux when the thermal ion fraction decreases and the main ion density gradient is reversed by the fast ions in FIRE mode. Optimization of 3D magnetic field techniques, including adaptive control and real-time machine learning control algorithm, enabled long-pulse operation and high-performance ELM-suppressed discharge. Symmetric multiple shattered pellet injections (SPIs) and real-time disruption event characterization and forecasting are being performed to mitigate and avoid the disruptions associated with high-performance, long-pulse ITER-like scenarios. Finally, the near-term research plan will be addressed with the actively cooled tungsten divertor, a major upgrade of the NBI and helicon current drive heating, and transition to a full metallic wall.
Experiments performed during strongly-shaped high-power diverted negative triangularity (NT) experiments in DIII-D achieved detached divertor conditions and a transient-free edge, showcasing the potential for application of NT to a core-edge integrated reactor-like scenario and providing the first characterization of the parametric dependencies for detachment onset. Detached divertor conditions will be required in future devices to mitigate divertor heat fluxes. Access to dissipative divertor conditions was investigated via an increase in upstream density. Detachment onset at the outer strike point was achieved with H-mode level confinement H98-y2 similar to 1 and reactor-relevant normalized pressures beta N similar to 2 . Confinement degradation was observed with deeper detachment, associated with the loss of an electron temperature pedestal. Differences in geometry, radial transport, impact of cross field drifts are discussed to explain differences in access to detachment in NT discharges. Higher normalized densities, with respect to equivalent discharges in positive triangularity, were necessary to achieve detachment, partially explained by the shorter parallel connection length to the targets. The effect of cross-field particle drifts (ExB, B x del B) on access to detachment was demonstrated by the lower upstream density needed to access detachment with ion B x del B drift directed outside of the active divertor (Greenwald fraction fGw similar to 0.9-1.0 vs fGw similar to 1.3). The upstream density at detachment onset was observed to increase linearly with plasma current with ion B x del B drift into the divertor, consistent with the observed narrowing of the scrape-off layer heat flux width lambda q . Edge fluid simulations capture separatrix densities needed to achieve detachment in NT plasma and their dependence on drift direction. The ability to reproduce detachment dynamics in NT plasma increases the confidence in future design studies for NT divertors.
Extracting reliable information from diagnostic data in tokamaks is critical for understanding, analyzing, and controlling the behavior of fusion plasmas and validating models describing that behavior. Recent interest within the fusion community has focused on the use of principled statistical methods, such as Gaussian process regression (GPR), to attempt to develop sharper, more reliable, and more rigorous tools for examining the complex observed behavior in these systems. While GPR is an enormously powerful tool, there is also the danger of drawing fragile, or inconsistent conclusions from naive GPR fits that are not driven by principled treatments. Here we review the fundamental concepts underlying GPR in a way that may be useful for broad-ranging applications in fusion science. We also revisit how GPR is developed for profile fitting in tokamaks. We examine various extensions and targeted modifications applicable to experimental observations in the edge of the DIII-D tokamak. Finally, we discuss best practices for applying GPR to fusion data.
The DIII-D tokamak has elucidated crucial physics and developed projectable solutions for ITER and fusion power plants in the key areas of core performance, boundary heat and particle transport, and integrated scenario operation, with closing the core-edge integration knowledge gap being the overarching mission. New experimental validation of high-fidelity, multi-channel, non-linear gyrokinetic turbulent transport models for ITER provides strong confidence it will achieve Q 10 operation. Experiments identify options for easing H-mode access in hydrogen, and give new insight into the isotopic dependence of transport and confinement. Analysis of 2,1 islands in unoptimized low-torque IBS demonstration discharges suggests their onset time occurs randomly in the constant beta phase, most often triggered by non-linear 3-wave coupling, thus identifying an NTM seeding mechanism to avoid. Pure deuterium SPI for disruption mitigation is shown to provide favorable slow cooling, but poor core assimilation, suggesting paths for improved SPI on ITER. At the boundary, measured neutral density and ionization source fluxes are strongly poloidally asymmetric, implying a 2D treatment is needed to model pedestal fuelling. Detailed measurements of pedestal and SOL quantities and impurity charge state radiation in detached divertors has validated edge fluid modelling and new self-consistent 'pedestal-to-divertor' integrated modeling that can be used to optimize reactors. New feedback adaptive ELM control minimizes confinement reduction, and RMP ELM suppression with sustained high core performance was obtained for the first time with the outer strike point in a W-coated, compact and unpumped small-angle slot divertor. Advances have been made in integrated operational scenarios for ITER and power plants. Wide pedestal intrinsically ELM-free QH-modes are produced with more reactor-relevant conditions, Low torque IBS with W-equivalent radiators can exhibit predator-prey oscillations in T-e and radiation which need control. High-beta(P) scenarios with q(min) > 2, q(95)-7.9, beta(N) > 4, beta(T)-3.3% and H-98y2 > 1.5 are sustained with high density ((n) over bar = 7E19 m(-3), f(G)-1) for 6 tau(E), improving confidence in steady-state tokamak reactors. Diverted NT plasmas achieve high core performance with a non-ELMing edge, offering a possible highly attractive core-edge integration solution for reactors.
Integration of transient and steady-state divertor heat fluxes control with a high-performance core is necessary for future fusion reactors. In recent DIII-D high- beta(p) experiments, divertor detachment and simultaneous edge localized mode (ELM) suppression are demonstrated while the plasma confinement quality is maintained high in ITER-similar shape. By optimizing the neon injection in high- beta(p) scenario with ITER-similar shape, deep detachment and ELM suppression are achieved with a high-performance core ( beta(N) similar to 2.8, beta(p) similar to 2.3) at q(95) similar to 7.5. Partial divertor detachment and suppression of large ELMs are achieved at q(95) similar to 6. The stability analyses suggest that with low neon injection, the density pedestal becomes higher and steeper and the T-i profile also increases, therefore the increased edge pressure and higher current density destabilize the Peeling-Ballooning mode (PBM), which would lead to a large ELM collapse. With strong neon gas puffing, the significantly reduced pedestal pressure and current density, due to the degraded T-e pedestal, lead to the stabilization of PBM and ELMs are suppressed. For both cases, the coupling between the large radius internal transport barrier (ITB) and edge pedestal is the key reason for maintaining high global performance. The formation of large radius ITB compensates for pedestal degradation. Such results could provide an attractive scenario to well control the transient and steady-state heat flux onto the divertor plates while maintaining good plasma performance, which is an important step toward the steady-state operation of future fusion reactors.
Negative triangularity (NT) is a potentially transformative configuration for tokamak-based fusion energy with its high-performance core, edge localized mode (ELM)-free edge, and low-field-side divertors that could readily scale to an integrated reactor solution. Previous NT work on the TCV and DIII-D tokamaks motivated the installation of graphite-tile armor on the low-field-side lower outer wall of DIII-D. A dedicated multiple-week experimental campaign was conducted to qualify the NT scenario for future reactors. During the DIII-D NT campaign, high confinement (H-98y,H-2 greater than or similar to 1), high current (q(95)< 3), and high normalized pressure plasmas (beta(N)> 2.5) were simultaneously attained in strongly NT-shaped discharges with average triangularity delta(avg) = -0.5 that were stably controlled. Experiments covered a wide range of DIII-D operational space (plasma current, toroidal field, electron density and pressure) and did not trigger an ELM in a single discharge as long as sufficiently strong NT was maintained; in contrast, to other high-performance ELM-suppression scenarios that have narrower operating windows. These strong NT plasmas had a lower outer divertor X-point shape and maintained a non-ELMing edge with an electron temperature pedestal, exceeding that of typical L-mode plasmas. Also, the following was achieved during the campaign: high normalized density (n(e)/n(GW) of at least 1.7), particle confinement comparable to energy confinement with Z(eff)similar to 2, a detached divertor without impurity seeding, and a mantle radiation scenario using extrinsic impurities. These results are promising for a NT fusion pilot plant but further questions on confinement extrapolation and core-edge integration remain, which motivate future NT studies on DIII-D and beyond.
The plasma control system (PCS) is a critical application required for daily operation of the DIII-D tokamak. Continuous expansion and upgrades to its hardware and software require a careful balance between the need to sustain high operations availability and the introduction of new real-time (RT) acquisition and control schemes. A number of new and improved diagnostics and controls have been added to the PCS. Expansion of the Upper Divertor Viewing (UDV) bolometer diagnostic now covers the tokamak upper divertor region and 8 new UDV channels have been added to the PCS data suite. To improve protection of the vessel, heat-flux and surface temperature control using real time infrared (IRTV) diagnostics have been successfully demonstrated. Neural network models have been added to the system to support experiments in disruption avoidance. In response to the increasing demand for software enhancements during operations, a testbed that closely mirrors the production hardware and software has been recently constructed and commissioned. It significantly increases the variety of testing that can be performed. Therefore, it is now possible to simultaneously operate DIII-D while validating new control algorithms for future experiments. In conjunction with an expansion of regular code reviews, the deployment of the testbed has resulted in greater reliability even with an increasing number and frequency of updates. Details of the specific hardware and software enhancements made along with improvements to testing and software quality assurance will be presented.
Divertor detachment without serious core confinement quality loss in DIII-D’s high poloidal β scenario has been combined with impurity-induced ELM mitigation without disruption. Use of Ne previously granted access to a detached, non-ELMing regime that retained high confinement quality due to stimulation of Internal Transport Barrier (ITB) growth, but suffered from on-going core fuel dilution and high disruptivity. Excess Ne accumulation in the core plasma has now been avoided by feeding back core radiated power (Prad) measurements to control Ne seeding, rather than using attachment fraction (Afrac) control with Ne; this also reduces disruptivity. At the same time, N2 seeding is used in a feedback loop with Afrac measurements, which previously posed low disruption risk. In this way, the effect of Ne in the core is managed while avoiding excess seeding, and N2 acts to correct for any excess heat exhaust that might interfere with detachment. The average Ne flow rate was 38% of what was used in pure Ne Afrac control, plus average N2 flow that was 43% of pure N2 Afrac control, even while meeting an even deeper detachment target. Meanwhile, a steep pressure gradient in the core plasma reduces sensitivity to impurity-induced degradation of the pedestal and reasonable confinement quality was maintained despite operational challenges that blocked formation of an ITB in these experiments.
EAST implements the double feedback control experiments of the detachment by using two control systems at the same time to explore the new detachment control way. We hire two PID controllers and two gas puffing valves dividedly to inject impurity gases from different locations, increasing the radiated power of the bulk plasma and reducing the divertor electron temperature (Te,t) simultaneously. This control method is applied in the EAST long-pulse H-mode plasma, the controlled variables of the radiative feedback control is the local radiative intensity and the total radiated power respectively. In the experiments, the longest double control duration has been up to 13.5 s, the divertor heat flux is reduced significantly in the control duration, while the particle flux has an overall drop at the end of the control phase. The chosen impurity species in the control system are Neon (Ne) and Argon (Ar): Ne is injected from the upper divertor to raise the core radiated power, and the Ar is injected from the lower divertor to reduce the Te,t beneath 8 eV. However, the Ar injection is not only decreasing the Te,t, but also generates an unfavorable increment of the core radiated power. This increment makes the bulk radiated power is higher than the target value, the radiative feedback control thus is paused for a long time. This mechanism results in the double feedback control back to the sequential implementations of the two feedback controls, which does not accord with the original expection(the both controls run at the same time), and degrades the control precision. In the future, many mitigating ways will be tested to improve the control effect. We will also develop a dynamic response model of the impurity seeding to simulate the time evolution of the divertor heat load with two kinds of impurities. The modeling results will be used to optimize the double feedback control system to gain a better experimental results.