Plasmid-based (naked DNA) genetic vaccines are now entering clinical trials to test their safety and efficacy in healthy human volunteers. A safety concern unique to this new class of vaccines is the potential risk of deleterious integration into host cell genomic DNA following direct intramuscular injection. To address this issue experimentally, a preclinical safety study was conducted in mice to determine the structural nature of plasmid DNA sequences persisting in total muscle DNA at both 30 and 60 days following a single intramuscular injection of a plasmid expressing the Plasmodium falciparum circumsporozoite protein. In a protocol described for the first time, total DNA was extracted from muscle tissue and was subsequently linearized with a restriction endonuclease to enable agarose gel size fractionation of all extrachromosomal plasmid DNAs from high molecular weight mouse genomic DNA. Using PCR assays to quantitate plasmid-specific sequences, it was found that the amount of plasmid DNA persisting in muscle tissue varied but averaged about 10 fg per microgram of genomic DNA (in the range of 1500 copies per 150,000 genomes). In two of four separate experimental injections of mouse muscle, PCR assays of genomic DNA fractions indicated that agarose gel purification removed plasmid DNA down to a level of < or =3 copies per 150,000 mouse genomes. In the two other experimental samples, 3-30 copies of plasmid DNA remained associated with purified genomic DNA. The time following injection (i.e., 30 or 60 days) was not a factor in the number of copies of plasmid associating with genomic DNA and it was not possible to conclude if such sequences were covalently linked to genomic DNA or simply adventitiously associated with the genomic DNA. However, if an assumption is made that the highest level plasmid DNA found associated with genomic DNA (i.e., 30 copies) represented covalently integrated plasmid inserts and that each insert resulted in a mutational event, the calculated rate of mutation would be 3000 times less than the spontaneous mutation rate for mammalian genomes. This level of integration, if it should occur, was not considered to pose a significant safety concern.

The plasmid DNA vector pVCL-1102 containing the coding sequence for the human IL-2 gene was evaluated for expression in tumor cells in vitro and in vivo. In vitro transfection of murine B16 tumor cells with pVCL-1102 resulted in the expression of 36,000 IU (5.7 mu g) of biologically active IL-2/10(6) cells/48 h. In vitro transfection of human tumor lines and primary cultures from human biopsies with pVCL-1102 resulted in the expression of 1,289 to 9345 IU of IL-2/10(6) cells/48 h and 30 to 794 IU of IL-2/10(6) cells/48 h, respectively. In vivo, direct intratumor injection of pVCL-1102 resulted in retention of intact plasmid DNA in the tumor tissue and IL-2 secretion by cell cultures derived from the injected tumors. Formulation of pVCL-1102 with the cationic lipid DMRIE/DOPE inhibited DNA degradation and enhanced in vivo transfection efficiency over plasmid DNA alone. Antitumor activity of the pVCL-1102/DMRIE/DOPE complex was evaluated in a B16 melanoma model in mice. An IL-2-specific effect could not be demonstrated in a subcutaneous model because the intratumor injection of plasmid DNA lacking the IL-2 coding sequence also resulted in a significant reduction in tumor volume. However, an IL-2-specific effect was observed when B16 cells were transfected in vitro prior to implantation into the mouse. Transient transfection of B16 cells with pVCL-1102 rendered the cells less tumorigenic in vivo and produced a significant reduction in tumor volume. These data demonstrate that a plasmid DNA expression vector can be used to deliver the IL-2 gene to tumor cells in vitro and in vivo, resulting in the expression of significant levels of IL-2 protein. These data also illustrate the need for the use of appropriate controls when evaluating the in vivo biological activity of plasmid DNA in murine tumor models.

The fate of plasmid DNA complexed with cationic lipids delivered intravenously in mice was evaluated at selected timepoints up to 6 months postinjection. Blood half-life and tissue distribution of plasmid DNA and potential expression in tissues were examined. Southern blot analyses of blood indicated that intact plasmid DNA was rapidly degraded, with a half-life of less than 5 min for intact plasmid, and was no longer detectable at 1 hr postinjection. Southern analyses of tissue demonstrated that intact DNA was differentially retained in the lung, spleen, liver, heart, kidney, marrow, and muscle up to 24 hr postinjection. After 7 days, no intact plasmid DNA was detectable by Southern blot analysis; however, the plasmid was detectable by the polymerase chain reaction (PCR) in all tissues examined at 7 and 28 days postinjection. At 6 months postinjection, femtogram levels of plasmid were detected only in muscle. Immunohistochemical analyses did not detect encoded protein in the tissues harboring residual plasmid at 1 or 7 days postinjection.

To evaluate the safety of a plasmid DNA-lipid complex, a series of good laboratory practice (GLP) safety studies were conducted with VCL-1005, a plasmid DNA expression vector containing both the human class I MHC HLA-B7 heavy-chain and the beta 2-microglobulin (beta 2m) light-chain genes formulated with the cationic lipid, DMRIE/DOPE. In mice, the repeated intravenous injection of VCL-1005 at plasmid DNA doses of 0.1, 1.0, or 10 micrograms for 14 days had only incidental effects on clinical chemistry and hematology, and did not result in any organ pathology. Repeated intrahepatic injections of VCL-1005 in mice did not result in significant liver histopathology or significant alterations in liver enzymes. In cynomolgus monkeys, the repeated intravenous administration of VCL-1005 at a cumulative dose of 720 micrograms of DNA had no effects on clinical chemistry, hematology, or organ pathology. Thus, systemic administration of a plasmid DNA expression vector containing the coding sequence for a foreign MHC class I molecule did not result in significant toxicity or a pathological immune response in animals. These results suggest that the direct transfer of VCL-1005, a plasmid DNA-lipid complex, could be used for the safe in vivo delivery of recombinant DNA for a cancer gene therapy trial.

Human Gene TherapyVol. 6, No. 5 EditorialsPreclinical Pharmacokinetics, Manufacturing, and Safety Studies Supporting a Multicenter Cancer Gene Therapy TrialJon A. Norman, Suezanne Parker, Denise Lew, Marston Manthorpe, and Magda MarquetJon A. NormanSearch for more papers by this author, Suezanne ParkerSearch for more papers by this author, Denise LewSearch for more papers by this author, Marston ManthorpeSearch for more papers by this author, and Magda MarquetSearch for more papers by this authorPublished Online:19 Mar 2008https://doi.org/10.1089/hum.1995.6.5-549AboutSectionsPDF/EPUB ToolsPermissionsDownload CitationsTrack CitationsAdd to favorites Back To Publication ShareShare onFacebookTwitterLinked InRedditEmail "Preclinical Pharmacokinetics, Manufacturing, and Safety Studies Supporting a Multicenter Cancer Gene Therapy Trial." , 6(5), pp. 549–550FiguresReferencesRelatedDetailsCited ByAnimal Models for Target Diseases in Gene Therapy — using DNA and siRNA Delivery Strategies8 October 2008 | Pharmaceutical Research, Vol. 26, No. 1Are Vaccinations for Prostate Cancer Realistic?Cutting Edge: Restoration of the Ability to Generate CTL in Mice Immune to Adenovirus by Delivery of Virus in a Collagen-Based Matrix15 January 2001 | The Journal of Immunology, Vol. 166, No. 2GENE THERAPY FOR PROSTATE CANCERUrologic Clinics of North America, Vol. 26, No. 2Gene therapy—the future is here: a guide to the practicing urologistUrology, Vol. 51, No. 3Macromolecular versus smallmolecule therapeutics: drug discovery, development and clinical considerationsTrends in Biotechnology, Vol. 14, No. 5 Volume 6Issue 5May 1995 InformationCopyright 1995, Mary Ann Liebert, Inc.To cite this article:Jon A. Norman, Suezanne Parker, Denise Lew, Marston Manthorpe, and Magda Marquet.Preclinical Pharmacokinetics, Manufacturing, and Safety Studies Supporting a Multicenter Cancer Gene Therapy Trial.Human Gene Therapy.May 1995.549-550.http://doi.org/10.1089/hum.1995.6.5-549Published in Volume: 6 Issue 5: March 19, 2008PDF download

The skin and mucous membranes are the anatomical sites were most viruses are first encountered by the immune system. Previous experiments have suggested that striated muscle cells are unique among mammalian cell types in their capacity to take up and express free DNA in the absence of a viral vector or physical carrier. However, we have found that mice injected into the superficial skin with free (naked) plasmid DNA encoding the influenza nucleoprotein gene had discrete foci of epidermal and dermal cells, including cells with dendritic morphology, that contained immunoreactive nucleoprotein antigen. A single intradermal administration of 0.3-15 micrograms of free plasmid DNA induced anti-nucleoprotein-specific antibody and cytotoxic T lymphocytes that persisted for at least 68-70 weeks after vaccination. Intradermal gene administration induced higher antibody titers than did direct gene injection into skeletal muscle and did not cause local inflammation or necrosis. Compared with control animals, the gene-injected mice were resistant to challenge with a heterologous strain of influenza virus. These results indicate that the cells of the skin can take up and express free foreign DNA and induce cellular and humoral immune responses against the encoded protein. We suggest that DNA uptake by the skin-associated lymphoid tissues may play a role in the induction of cytotoxic T cells against viruses and other intracellular pathogens.