Signaling receptors can exit cilia either by retrieval back into the cell or by secretion in extracellular vesicles (EVs), a process known as ectocytosis. The mechanisms that govern ectocytosis remain poorly understood. Here, we leverage quantitative proteomic profiling to identify the Hedgehog signaling receptor Smoothened (SMO) as a major cargo of cilia-derived EVs. Surprisingly, ligands that promote ciliary accumulation of SMO strongly suppressed its packaging into EVs, indicating that ectocytosis selectively packages specific conformational states of SMO. We further find that SMO packaged into EVs is extensively modified with K63linked ubiquitin chains. Preventing SMO ubiquitination or selectively removing K63-linked ubiquitin chains from SMO markedly reduced its secretion into EVs and caused SMO accumulation within cilia. Together, these results identify K63-linked ubiquitin chains as a sorting signal for ciliary ectocytosis and indicate that ubiquitin-dependent packaging of inactive SMO contributes to the dynamic redistribution of SMO during Hedgehog signaling.
Understanding the dynamic protein composition of cilia, crucial sensory organelles implicated in ciliopathies, is essential for comprehending cellular function and disease mechanisms. This Review summarizes advancements in methodologies for characterizing cilia proteomes. Traditional biochemical methods for isolating cilia from various model organisms have yielded informative protein inventories of cilia. These approaches worked particularly well for motile cilia but face challenges when investigating sparse primary cilia in various mammalian cells and tissues. The advent of protein-protein interaction mapping approaches employing genetically encoded affinity purification tags followed by mass spectrometry (AP-MS), has elucidated crucial ciliopathy-associated protein modules such as the BBSome, leading to new gene discoveries. More recently, proximity labeling techniques (APEX, BioID and TurboID) have revolutionized the field, enabling high-resolution and dynamic mapping of ciliary proteomes and signaling pathways, and dissecting protein trafficking defects in ciliopathy models. Despite technical variations, these methods offer novel insights into the ciliary and sub-ciliary protein environment. Further advancements in spatial proteomic technologies and mass spectrometry sensitivity might ultimately allow us to delineate dynamic proteomic profiles of specific cilia accurately across different cell types and tissues.
Ascorbate peroxidase (APEX) is a proximity labeling enzyme used for subcellular proteomics at high spatial and temporal resolution. However, toxicity of its substrate hydrogen peroxide and background labeling by endogenous peroxidases limit its use to in vitro studies of specific cell types. To minimize toxicity and reduce non-specific background labeling we establish a more versatile in situ APEX activation (iAPEX) workflow by combining APEX2 with a D-amino acid oxidase to locally produce hydrogen peroxide. Using iAPEX, we profile the proteomes of a cellular microdomain, the primary cilium, in cell lines not readily accessible to conventional APEX labeling and identify unknown ciliary proteins. Our study validates common ciliary proteins across two distinct cell lines, while observed differences may reflect heterogeneity in primary cilia proteomes. Furthermore, iAPEX proximity labeling is applicable to a range of cellular compartments including mitochondria and lipid droplets and can be employed in Xenopus laevis, which provides a proof-of-concept for future in vivo applications.
Ascorbate peroxidase (APEX) is a versatile labeling enzyme used for live-cell proteomics at high spatial and temporal resolution. However, toxicity of its substrate hydrogen peroxide and background labeling by endogenous peroxidases limit its use to in vitro studies of specific cell types. By combining APEX2 with a D-amino acid oxidase to locally produce hydrogen peroxide, we establish a more versatile, improved APEX (iAPEX) workflow that minimizes hydrogen peroxide toxicity and reduces non-specific background labeling. We employ iAPEX to perform live-cell proteomics of a cellular microdomain, the primary cilium, in previously inaccessible cell lines, leading to the identification of new ciliary proteins. Our study robustly validates common ciliary proteins across two distinct cell lines, while observed differences may reflect heterogeneity in primary cilia proteomes. iAPEX proximity labeling in Xenopus laevis provides a proof-of-concept for future in vivo applications. ### Competing Interest Statement The authors have declared no competing interest.
Primary cilia are hair-like sensory organelles that project from the cell bodies of most cell types, including appetite-regulatory hypothalamic neurons where they likely help sense metabolic factors to regulate food intake. We hypothesized that characterising the proteins present in the primary cilia of hypothalamic neurons would shed mechanistic insights into their sensory role and identify new therapeutic targets for obesity. We therefore targeted the ascorbate peroxidase APEX2 to primary cilia in human induced pluripotent stem cells (hiPSC)-derived hypothalamic neurons to biotinylate and identify ciliary proteins. Among the cilia-enriched proteins, we identified synaptic proteins, neurotransmitter receptors, and cell-cell adhesion and axon guidance proteins, extending recent findings that primary cilia interact with neuronal synapses. We also found genes associated with increased body weight and metabolic phenotypes that could represent new therapeutic targets including the lysophosphatidic receptor 1 (LPAR1), which we validated is cilia-localized and we confirmed that its ligand (LPA) mediates ciliary shortening. These findings provide insights into the molecular mechanisms by which primary cilia functionally impact appetite-regulatory neurons. ### Competing Interest Statement The authors have declared no competing interest.
Primary cilia project from the surface of most vertebrate cells and are key in sensing extracellular signals and locally transducing this information into a cellular response. Recent findings show that primary cilia are not merely static organelles with a distinct lipid and protein composition. Instead, the function of primary cilia relies on the dynamic composition of molecules within the cilium, the context‐dependent sensing and processing of extracellular stimuli, and cycles of assembly and disassembly in a cell‐ and tissue‐specific manner. Thereby, primary cilia dynamically integrate different cellular inputs and control cell fate and function during tissue development. Here, we review the recently emerging concept of primary cilia dynamics in tissue development, organization, remodeling, and function.
Many G protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs) reside within cilia of mammalian cells and must undergo regu-lated exit from cilia for the appropriate transduction of signals such as hedgehog morphogens. Lysine 63-linked ubiquitin (UbK63) chains mark GPCRs for regulated removal from cilia, but the molecular basis of UbK63 recognition inside cilia remains elusive. Here, we show that the BBSome-the trafficking complex in charge of retrieving GPCRs from cilia-engages the ancestral endosomal sorting factor target of Myb1-like 2 (TOM1L2) to recognize UbK63 chains within cilia of human and mouse cells. TOM1L2 directly binds to UbK63 chains and the BBSome, and targeted disruption of the TOM1L2/BBSome interaction results in the accumulation of TOM1L2, ubiquitin, and the GPCRs SSTR3, Smoothened, and GPR161 inside cilia. Further-more, the single-cell alga Chlamydomonas also requires its TOM1L2 ortholog in order to clear ubiquitinated proteins from cilia. We conclude that TOM1L2 broadly enables the retrieval of UbK63-tagged proteins by the ciliary trafficking machinery.
The primary cilium constitutes an organelle that orchestrates signal transduction independently from the cell body. Dysregulation of this intricate molecular architecture leads to severe human diseases, commonly referred to as ciliopathies. However, the molecular underpinnings how ciliary signaling orchestrates a specific cellular output remain elusive. By combining spatially resolved optogenetics with RNA sequencing and imaging, we reveal a novel cAMP signalosome that is functionally distinct from the cytoplasm. We identify the genes and pathways targeted by the ciliary cAMP signalosome and shed light on the underlying mechanisms and downstream signaling. We reveal that chronic stimulation of the ciliary cAMP signalosome transforms kidney epithelia from tubules into cysts. Counteracting this chronic cAMP elevation in the cilium by small molecules targeting activation of phosphodiesterase-4 long isoforms inhibits cyst growth. Thereby, we identify a novel concept of how the primary cilium controls cellular functions and maintains tissue integrity in a specific and spatially distinct manner and reveal novel molecular components that might be involved in the development of one of the most common genetic diseases, polycystic kidney disease.
The primary cilium is a signaling compartment that interprets Hedgehog signals through changes of its protein, lipid, and second messenger compositions. Here, we combine proximity labeling of cilia with quantitative mass spectrometry to unbiasedly profile the time-dependent alterations of the ciliary proteome in response to Hedgehog. This approach correctly identifies the three factors known to undergo Hedgehog-regulated ciliary redistribution and reveals two such additional proteins. First, we find that a regulatory subunit of the cAMP-dependent protein kinase (PKA) rapidly exits cilia together with the G protein-coupled receptor GPR161 in response to Hedgehog, and we propose that the GPR161/PKA module senses and amplifies cAMP signals to modulate ciliary PKA activity. Second, we identify the phosphatase Paladin as a cell type-specific regulator of Hedgehog signaling that enters primary cilia upon pathway activation. The broad applicability of quantitative ciliary proteome profiling promises a rapid characterization of ciliopathies and their underlying signaling malfunctions.
The primary cilium is a solitary, microtubule-based membrane protrusion extending from the surface of quiescent cells that senses the cellular environment and triggers specific cellular responses. The functions of primary cilia require not only numerous different components but also their regulated interplay. The cilium performs highly dynamic processes, such as cell cycle-dependent assembly and disassembly as well as delivery, modification, and removal of signaling components to perceive and process external signals. On a molecular level, these processes often rely on a stringent control of key modulatory proteins, of which the activity, localization, and stability are regulated by post-translational modifications (PTMs). While an increasing number of PTMs on ciliary components are being revealed, our knowledge on the identity of the modifying enzymes and their modulation is still limited. Here, we highlight recent findings on cilia-specific phosphorylation and ubiquitylation events. Shedding new light onto the molecular mechanisms that regulate the sensitive equilibrium required to maintain and remodel primary cilia functions, we discuss their implications for cilia biogenesis, protein trafficking, and cilia signaling processes.
The primary cilium projects from the surface of most vertebrate cells, where it senses extracellular signals to regulate diverse cellular processes during tissue development and homeostasis. Dysfunction of primary cilia underlies the pathogenesis of severe diseases, commonly referred to as ciliopathies. Primary cilia contain a unique protein repertoire that is distinct from the cell body and the plasma membrane, enabling the spatially controlled transduction of extracellular cues. G-protein coupled receptors (GPCRs) are key in sensing environmental stimuli that are transmitted via second messenger signaling into a cellular response. Here, we will give an overview of the role of GPCR signaling in primary cilia, and how ciliary GPCR signaling can be targeted by pharmacology, chemogenetics, and optogenetics.
ABSTRACTThe primary cilium is a signaling compartment that interprets Hedgehog signals through changes of its protein, lipid and second messenger compositions. Here, we combine proximity labeling of cilia with quantitative mass spectrometry to unbiasedly profile the time-dependent alterations of the ciliary proteome in response to Hedgehog. This approach correctly identifies the three factors known to undergo Hedgehog-regulated ciliary redistribution and reveals two such additional proteins. First, we find that a regulatory subunit of the cAMP-dependent protein kinase (PKA) rapidly exits cilia together with the G protein-coupled receptor GPR161 in response to Hedgehog; and we propose that the GPR161/PKA module senses and amplifies cAMP signals to modulate ciliary PKA activity. Second, we identify the putative phosphatase Paladin as a cell type-specific regulator of Hedgehog signaling that enters primary cilia upon pathway activation. The broad applicability of quantitative ciliary proteome profiling promises a rapid characterization of ciliopathies and their underlying signaling malfunctions.
Compartmentalization of cellular signaling forms the molecular basis of cellular behavior. The primary cilium constitutes a subcellular compartment that orchestrates signal transduction independent from the cell body. Ciliary dysfunction causes severe diseases, termed ciliopathies. Analyzing ciliary signaling has been challenging due to the lack of tools to investigate ciliary signaling. Here, we describe a nanobody-based targeting approach for optogenetic tools in mammalian cells and in vivo in zebrafish to specifically analyze ciliary signaling and function. Thereby, we overcome the loss of protein function observed after fusion to ciliary targeting sequences. We functionally localized modifiers of cAMP signaling, the photo-activated adenylyl cyclase bPAC and the light-activated phosphodiesterase LAPD, and the cAMP biosensor mlCNBD-FRET to the cilium. Using this approach, we studied the contribution of spatial cAMP signaling in controlling cilia length. Combining optogenetics with nanobody-based targeting will pave the way to the molecular understanding of ciliary function in health and disease.
Proximity labeling by ascorbate peroxidase (APEX) requires appropriate experimental setups that generate sufficient signal over background as a prerequisite for downstream analyses by mass spectrometry. Cell culture-based systems are easily accessible, yet, for proximity labeling of small structures must be carefully optimized in order to give satisfying results. How to establish and characterize APEX cell lines will be the topic of this chapter.
The primary cilium is a hair-like surface-exposed organelle of the eukaryotic cell that decodes a variety of signals-such as odorants, light and Hedgehog morphogens-by altering the local concentrations and activities of signalling proteins. Signalling within the cilium is conveyed through a diverse array of second messengers, including conventional signalling molecules (such as cAMP) and some unusual intermediates (such as sterols). Diffusion barriers at the ciliary base establish the unique composition of this signalling compartment, and cilia adapt their proteome to signalling demands through regulated protein trafficking. Much progress has been made on the molecular understanding of regulated ciliary trafficking, which encompasses not only exchanges between the cilium and the rest of the cell but also the shedding of signalling factors into extracellular vesicles.
The mitochondrial cytochrome c oxidase assembles in the inner membrane from subunits of dual genetic origin. The assembly process of the enzyme is initiated by membrane insertion of the mitochondria-encoded Cox1 subunit. During complex maturation, transient assembly intermediates, consisting of structural subunits and specialized chaperone-like assembly factors, are formed. In addition, cofactors such as heme and copper have to be inserted into the nascent complex. To regulate the assembly process, the availability of Cox1 is under control of a regulatory feedback cycle in which translation of COX1 mRNA is stalled when assembly intermediates of Cox1 accumulate through inactivation of the translational activator Mss51. Here we isolate a cytochrome c oxidase assembly intermediate in preparatory scale from coa1Δ mutant cells, using Mss51 as bait. We demonstrate that at this stage of assembly, the complex has not yet incorporated the heme a cofactors. Using quantitative mass spectrometry, we define the protein composition of the assembly intermediate and unexpectedly identify the putative methyltransferase Oms1 as a constituent. Our analyses show that Oms1 participates in cytochrome c oxidase assembly by stabilizing newly synthesized Cox1.
While cilia are recognized as important signaling organelles, the extent of ciliary functions remains unknown because of difficulties in cataloguing proteins from mammalian primary cilia. We present a method that readily captures rapid snapshots of the ciliary proteome by selectively biotinylating ciliary proteins using a cilia-targeted proximity labeling enzyme (cilia-APEX). Besides identifying known ciliary proteins, cilia-APEX uncovered several ciliary signaling molecules. The kinases PKA, AMPK, and LKB1 were validated as bona fide ciliary proteins and PKA was found to regulate Hedgehog signaling in primary cilia. Furthermore, proteomics profiling of Ift27/Bbs19 mutant cilia correctly detected BBSome accumulation inside Ift27(-/-) cilia and revealed that β-arrestin 2 and the viral receptor CAR are candidate cargoes of the BBSome. This work demonstrates that proximity labeling can be applied to proteomics of non-membrane-enclosed organelles and suggests that proteomics profiling of cilia will enable a rapid and powerful characterization of ciliopathies.
Cox1, the core subunit of the cytochrome c oxidase, receives two heme a cofactors during assembly of the 13-subunit enzyme complex. However, at which step of the assembly process and how heme is inserted into Cox1 have remained an enigma. Shy1, the yeast SURF1 homolog, has been implicated in heme transfer to Cox1, whereas the heme a synthase, Cox15, catalyzes the final step of heme a synthesis. Here we performed a comprehensive analysis of cytochrome c oxidase assembly intermediates containing Shy1. Our analyses suggest that Cox15 displays a role in cytochrome c oxidase assembly, which is independent of its functions as the heme a synthase. Cox15 forms protein complexes with Shy1 and also associates with Cox1-containing complexes independently of Shy1 function. These findings indicate that Shy1 does not serve as a mobile heme carrier between the heme a synthase and maturing Cox1 but rather cooperates with Cox15 for heme transfer and insertion in early assembly intermediates of cytochrome c oxidase.
Mitochondrial respiratory-chain complexes assemble from subunits of dual genetic origin assisted by specialized assembly factors. Whereas core subunits are translated on mitochondrial ribosomes, others are imported after cytosolic translation. How imported subunits are ushered to assembly intermediates containing mitochondria-encoded subunits is unresolved. Here, we report a comprehensive dissection of early cytochrome c oxidase assembly intermediates containing proteins required for normal mitochondrial translation and reveal assembly factors promoting biogenesis of human respiratory-chain complexes. We find that TIM21, a subunit of the inner-membrane presequence translocase, is also present in the major assembly intermediates containing newly mitochondria-synthesized and imported respiratory-chain subunits, which we term MITRAC complexes. Human TIM21 is dispensable for protein import but required for integration of early-assembling, presequence-containing subunits into respiratory-chain intermediates. We establish an unexpected molecular link between the TIM23 transport machinery and assembly of respiratory-chain complexes that regulate mitochondrial protein synthesis in response to their assembly state.
Mitochondrial ribosomes synthesize core subunits of the inner membrane respiratory chain complexes. In mitochondria, translation is regulated by mRNA‐specific activator proteins and occurs on membrane‐associated ribosomes. Mdm38/Letm1 is a conserved membrane receptor for mitochondrial ribosomes and specifically involved in respiratory chain biogenesis. In addition, Mdm38 and its higher eukaryotic homolog Letm1, function as K+/H+ or Ca2+/H+ antiporters in the inner membrane. Here, we identify the conserved ribosome‐binding domain (RBD) of Mdm38 and determine the crystal structure at 2.1 Å resolution. Surprisingly, Mdm38RBD displays a 14‐3‐3‐like fold despite any similarity to 14‐3‐3‐proteins at the primary sequence level and thus represents the first 14‐3‐3‐like protein in mitochondria. The 14‐3‐3‐like domain is critical for respiratory chain assembly through regulation of Cox1 and Cytb translation. We show that this function can be spatially separated from the ion transport activity of the membrane integrated portion of Mdm38. On the basis of the phenotypes observed for mdm38Δ as compared to Mdm38 lacking the RBD, we suggest a model that combining ion transport and translational regulation into one molecule allows for direct coupling of ion flux across the inner membrane, and serves as a signal for the translation of mitochondrial membrane proteins via its direct association with the protein synthesis machinery.