A fundamental understanding of the interactions between mineral surfaces and amphiphilic surface modification agents is needed for better control over production and uses of mineral fillers. Here, we controlled the carboxylic acid layer formation conditions on calcite surfaces with high precision via vapour deposition. The properties of the resulting carboxylic acid layers were analyzed using surface sensitive techniques such as atomic force microscopy (AFM), contact angle measurements, angle resolved X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) and vibrational sum-frequency spectroscopy. A low wettability was achieved with long hydrocarbon chain carboxylic acids, such as stearic acid. The stearic acid layer formed by vapour deposition is initially patchy, but with increasing vapour exposure time, the patches grow and condense into a homogeneous layer with a thickness close to that expected for a monolayer as evaluated by AFM and XPS. The build-up process of the layer occurs more rapidly at higher temperatures due to the higher vapour pressure. The stability of the deposited fatty acid layer in the presence of a water droplet increases with chain length and packing density in the adsorbed layer. Vibrational sum frequency spectroscopy data demonstrate that the stearic acid monolayers on calcite have their alkyl chains in an all-trans conformation and are anisotropically distributed on the plane of the surface, forming epitaxial monolayers. The vibrational spectra also show that the stearic acid molecules interact with the calcite surface through the carboxylic acid headgroup in both its protonated and deprotonated forms. The results presented provide new molecular insights into the properties of adsorbed carboxylic acid layers on calcite.
HYPOTHESIS:Thin films are central structural elements of foams and valuable model systems for probing liquids under confinement. Classical methods relate film thickness to disjoining pressure but rarely resolve molecular origins such as film composition, adsorbed amounts, ion-specific effects, and interfacial structure. Combining complementary spectroscopic techniques with thin film pressure control should provide direct molecular-level insights into confined film structure and the forces governing film stability. EXPERIMENTS:A Thin Film Pressure Balance capable of measuring surface forces was coupled with UV/Vis, infrared (IR), and Raman spectroscopies to characterise foam films under controlled confinement. IR spectroscopy enabled direct, quantitative, model-free determination of water core thickness. Raman spectroscopy probed both the surfactant and aqueous adlayers, revealing adsorbed amounts and structural changes upon confinement. Anion-specific effects and the influence of the alkyl chain length of films stabilised by alkyltrimethylammonium surfactants were systematically investigated by varying the halide counterions (Br-, Cl-, F-) and chain length (C12, C14, C16). FINDINGS:Surfactant surface excess and molecular orientation were independent of disjoining pressure across the studied range, whereas water structural features varied with confinement. Counterion identity strongly influenced monolayer dissociation, following the order Br- < Cl- < F-, consistent with headgroup binding affinities. The combined spectroscopic approach resolved both core water and surfactant layer thicknesses without reliance on model assumptions. This methodology provides a powerful new route to interrogate molecular structure in confined films, extending the scope of foam film studies beyond macroscopic stability to the fundamental chemistry of interfaces.
Hydrophilic anti-icing coatings can be energy-effective passive solutions for combating ice accretion and reducing ice adhesion. However, their underlying mechanisms of action remain inferential and are ill-defined from a molecular perspective. Here, we systematically investigate the influence of the counterion identity on the shear ice adhesion strength to cationic polymer coatings having quaternary alkyl ammonium moieties as chargeable groups. Temperature-dependent molecular information on the hydrated polymer films is obtained using total internal reflection (TIR) Raman spectroscopy, complemented with differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) and ellipsometry. Ice adhesion measurements show a pronounced counterion-specific behavior with a sharp increase in adhesion at temperatures that depend on the anion identity, following the order Cl- < F- < SCN- < Br- < I-. Linked to the freezing of hydration water, the specific ordering results from differences in ion pairing and the amount of water present within the polymer film. Moreover, similar effects can be promoted by varying the cross-linking density in the coating while keeping the anion identity fixed. These findings shed new light on low ice adhesion mechanisms and may inspire novel approaches for improved anti-icing coatings.
We discuss the origin of the breakloose (or static) friction force when an ice block is slid on a hard randomly rough substrate surface. If the substrate has roughness with small enough amplitude (of order a 1 nm or less), the breakloose force may be due to interfacial slip and is determined by the elastic energy per unit area, U-el/A(0), stored at the interface after the block has been displaced a short distance from its original position. The theory assumes complete contact between the solids at the interface and that there is no elastic deformation energy at the interface in the original state before the application of the tangential force. The breakloose force depends on the surface roughness power spectrum of the substrate and is found to be in good agreement with experimental observations. We show that as the temperature decreases, there is a transition from interfacial sliding (mode II crack propagation, where the crack propagation energy G(II) = U-el/A(0)) to opening crack propagation (mode I crack propagation with G(I) the energy per unit area to break the ice-substrate bonds in the normal direction).
A fundamental understanding of the interactions between mineral surfaces and amphiphilic surface modification agents is needed for better control over the production and uses of mineral fillers. Here, we controlled the carboxylic acid layer formation conditions on calcite surfaces with high precision via vapor deposition. The properties of the resulting carboxylic acid layers were analyzed using surface-sensitive techniques, such as atomic force microscopy (AFM), contact angle measurements, angle resolved X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS), and vibrational sum-frequency spectroscopy. A low wettability was achieved with long hydrocarbon chain carboxylic acids such as stearic acid. The stearic acid layer formed by vapor deposition is initially patchy, but with increasing vapor exposure time, the patches grow and condense into a homogeneous layer with a thickness close to that expected for a monolayer as evaluated by AFM and XPS. The build-up process of the layer occurs more rapidly at higher temperatures due to the higher vapor pressure. The stability of the deposited fatty acid layer in the presence of a water droplet increases with the chain length and packing density in the adsorbed layer. Vibrational sum frequency spectroscopy data demonstrate that the stearic acid monolayers on calcite have their alkyl chains in an all-trans conformation and are anisotropically distributed on the plane of the surface, forming epitaxial monolayers. Vibrational spectra also show that the stearic acid molecules interact with the calcite surface through the carboxylic acid headgroup in both its protonated and deprotonated forms. The results presented provide new molecular insights into the properties of adsorbed carboxylic acid layers on calcite.
Calcium carbonate, particularly in the form of calcite and surface modified calcite, is an abundant mineral widely used in both human-made and biological systems.
Specific interactions of yttrium and lanthanum ions with a fatty acid Langmuir monolayer were investigated using vibrational sum frequency spectroscopy (VSFS). The trivalent ions were shown to interact with the charged form of the carboxylic acid group from nanomolar concentrations (<300 nM). Analysis of the spectral features from both the symmetric and the asymmetric carboxylate modes reveals the presence of at least three distinct coordination structures linked to specific binding configurations. Although the same species were identified for both La3+ and Y3+, they display a different concentration dependence, highlighting the ion-specificity of the interaction. From the response of interfacial water molecules, charge reversion, as well as the formation of yttrium hydroxide complexes, were detected upon increasing the amount of salt in the solution. The binding interaction and kinetics of absorption are sensitive to the solution pH, showing a distinct ion speciation in the interfacial region when compared to the bulk. Changing the subphase pH or adding a monovalent background electrolyte that promotes deprotonation of the carboxylic acid headgroup, could further improve the detection limit of La3+ and Y3+ to concentrations <100 nM. These findings demonstrate that nM concentrations of trace metals contaminants, typically found on monovalent salts, can significantly influence the binding structure and kinetics in Langmuir monolayers.
Unlike counterion interactions with charged interfaces, the influence of co-ions is only scarcely reported in the literature. In this work, the effect of SCN– and the halide co-ions in the interactions of Na+ with carboxylic acid Langmuir monolayers is investigated by using vibrational sum frequency spectroscopy. At 1 M concentrations in the subphase, the identity of the anion is shown to have a remarkable influence on the charging behavior and degree of deprotonation of the monolayer, with ions ordering in the sequence I– > SCN– > Cl– ≈ Br–. The same trend is observed at both pH 6 and pH 9 when the monolayer is intrinsically more charged. Spectroscopic evidence is found for both the presence of I– and SCN– in the interfacial region at levels close to their detection limits. The results contradict electrostatic theories on charged interfaces where co-ions are not expected to play any significant role. The higher propensity for the large polarizable anions to deprotonate the monolayer is explained in terms of their ability to modify the cations affinity toward the carboxylic acid groups present at the surface.
Despite the importance of the hydrogen ion in a wide range of biological, chemical, and physical processes, its molecular structure in solution remains lively debated. Progress has been primarily hampered by the extreme diffuse nature of the vibrational signatures of hydrated protons in bulk solution. Using the inherently surface-specific vibrational sum frequency spectroscopy, we show that at selected negatively charged interfaces, a resolved spectral feature directly linked to the H 3 O + core in an Eigen-like species can be readily identified in a biologically compatible pH range. The results offer a new molecular perspective for tracking and understanding the behaviour of hydrated protons at interfaces.
The structure of water adjacent to silica is sensitive to the degree of deprotonation of surface silanol groups. As a result, close inspection of signals originating from these water molecules can be used to reveal the surface charge density. We have used nonlinear vibrational spectroscopy of the water O-H stretching band over a temperature range of 10-75 degrees C to account for the increase in surface potential from deprotonation. We demonstrate that the behavior at the silica surface is a balance between increasing surface charge and a decreasing contribution of water molecules aligned by the surface charge. Together with a model that accounts for two different types of silanol sites, we use our data to report the changes in enthalpy and entropy for deprotonation at each site. This is the first experimental determination of these thermodynamic parameters for hydrated silanol groups at the silica surface, critical to a wide range of geochemical and technological applications.
The molecular origin of overcharging at mineral oxide surfaces remains a cause of contention within the geochemistry, physics, and colloidal chemistry communities owing to competing “chemical” vs “physical” interpretations. Here, we combine vibrational sum frequency spectroscopy and streaming potential measurements to obtain molecular and macroscopic insights into the pH-dependent interactions of calcium ions with a fused silica surface. In 100 mM CaCl 2 electrolyte, we observe evidence of charge neutralization at pH~10.5, as deducted from a minimum in the interfacial water signal. Concurrently, adsorption of calcium hydroxide cations is inferred from the appearance of a spectral feature at ~3610 cm -1 . However, the interfacial water signal increases at higher pH, while adsorbed calcium hydroxide appears to remain constant, indicating that overcharging results from hydrated Ca 2+ ions present within the Stern layer. These findings suggest that both specific adsorption of hydrolyzed ions and ion-ion correlations of hydrated ions govern silica overcharging with increasing pH.
Specific interactions between the carboxylic acid moiety and the monovalent salts CsCl, NaCl, and LiCl, have been investigated in Langmuir monolayers using vibrational sum frequency spectroscopy (VSFS) and complemented with coarse grained and all-atom molecular dynamics simulations. By exploiting VSFS's intrinsic surface specificity, an emphasis was made on targeting headgroup vibrations of both its charged and uncharged forms as well as water molecules in the interfacial layer. The degree of deprotonation of the monolayer as a function of cation concentration and pH was experimentally determined and theoretically rationalized. Starting from 100 mM, the surface charge was overestimated by the Gouy-Chapman model and varied depending on the identity of the cation, highlighting the appearance of ion specific effects. Agreement could be found using a modified Poisson-Boltzmann model that takes into account steric effects, with a fitted effective ion-size compatible with the hydrated ion diameters. The relative affinity of the cations to the carboxylic acid moiety was pH dependent: at pH 4.5 they arranged in the order Cs+ > Na+ > Li+, but fully reversed (Li+ > Na+ > Cs+) at pH 9. Simulations yielded microscopic insight into the origin of this behavior, with the cations showing contrasting interaction preferences for either the uncharged carboxylic acid or the charged carboxylate. Sum frequency spectra also provided evidence that all cations remained hydrated when interacting with the charged headgroup, forming solvent-separated or solvent-shared ion pairs. However, for the specific case of 1 M Li+ at pH 9, contact ion pairs were formed. Finally, the remarkable effect of trace metal multivalent cations in the interpretation of experiments is briefly discussed. The results provide exciting new insights into the complex interactions of alkali metal cations with the biophysically relevant carboxylic acid moiety.
Angle-resolved vibrational sum frequency generation experiments have been used to study the silica-water interface as a function of ionic strength. Well below the critical angle, the sum frequency intensity increases up to 10(-4) M NaCl and then drops. However, near the critical angle, a plateau may be observed up to 10(-4) M. We first demonstrate that this is a result of the interaction of a long Debye length at low ionic strength with a long coherence length near the critical angles. In order to account for the behavior at the lowest concentrations where surface potentials are typically large, it is necessary to consider an electrostatic potential that extends into the bulk aqueous phase beyond the Debye-Huckel approximation. Because the extent of second- and third-order contributions to the nonlinear polarization can vary with ionic strength, but not with the angle of incidence, we perform a global fit to the experimental data using our proposed model to extract the relative magnitude of the two susceptibilities. The ionic strength dependence of this ratio points to the critical nature of the silanol deprotonation and the development of surface charge and illustrates how surface water molecules respond. These results highlight the importance of varying the coherence length in order to probe the water structure at charged interfaces.
Vibrational Spectral Signature of Eigen-like hydrated protonsat negatively charged surfaces
Vibrational sum frequency spectroscopy has beenused to study the molecular properties upon compression of a highly chargedarachidic acid Langmuir monolayer, which displays a first order phasetransition plateau in the surface pressure - molecular area (p-A) isotherm. By targeting vibrational modesfrom the carboxylic acid headgroup, alkyl chain, and interfacial watermolecules, information regarding the surface charge, surface potential, type ofion pair formed, and conformational order of the monolayer could be extracted. Themonolayer in the liquid expanded phase is found to be fully charged untilreaching the 2D-phase transition plateau, where partial reprotonation, as wellas the formation of COO⎺ Na+ contact-ionpairs, start to take place. In the condensed phase after the transition, threeheadgroup species, mainly hydrated COO⎺, COOH, and COO⎺ Na+ contact-ion pairs could beidentified and their proportions quantified. Comparison with theoretical modelsshows that despite the low ionic strengths used (i.e. 10 mM), the predictionsfrom the Gouy Chapman model are only adequate for the lowest surface densities,when the surface charge does not exceed -0.1 C/m2. In contrast, amodified Poisson-Boltzmann (MPB) model that accounts for the steric effectsassociated with the finite ion-size, captures many of the experimentalobservables, including the partial reprotonation, and surface potential changesupon compression. The agreement highlights the importance of hydronium ion –carboxylate interactions, as well as the layer of sodium ions packed at thesteric limit, for explaining the phase transition behavior. The MPB model,however, does not explicitly consider the formation of contact ion pairs withthe sodium counterion. The experimental results provide a quantitative molecularinsight that could be used to test potential extensions to the theory.
Ion interactions with carboxylic acid monolayers : Surface charge, reversed affinities, and contact ion pairing as revealed by non-linear vibrational spectroscopy
The properties of porous material are largely dependent on the size, shape, and connectivity of the pores. Here, we present a method based on confocal Raman spectroscopy to quantify porosity using a cryoporometric approach. We show that the phase transition of water imbibed in porous silica can be accurately determined using two different, but complementary methodologies. The first one relies on integrating the temperature-dependent spectral intensities across the whole OH (H2O) or OD (D2O) stretching region. The second, more quantitative approach, deconvolutes the spectral contributions within the pores in terms of liquid and solid fractions. The results show the expected reciprocal dependence of the average phase transition point with pore size, as well as the typical hysteresis between the freezing and melting transitions. One of the key advantages of the confocal Raman approach is its high spatial resolution, with sampling volumes starting from just a few femtoliters, opening the possibility of mapping the structure in heterogeneous porous materials.