The actin cytoskeleton plays a key integrative role in immunological synapse (IS) formation during T cell activation, but how these dynamics are altered in chimeric antigen receptor (CAR)-T cells remains unclear. Here, we used stimulated emission depletion (STED) microscopy to perform the first super-resolution analysis of actin remodeling at the IS in single- and dual (CD19/CD22) CAR-T cells, activated on supported lipid bilayers across different time points. Quantitative imaging reveals that CAR-T cells form structurally distinct synapses to untransduced cells, characterized by reduced actin-depleted regions, fewer actin foci, and persistent microvilli-like protrusions. These features indicate incomplete cytoskeletal contraction and impaired actin network reorganization, leading to partial synapse maturation. Our findings highlight fundamental differences in actin dynamics between CAR- and TCR-mediated signaling and suggest that defective actin remodeling may contribute to unstable synapse formation, altered signaling integration, and dysregulated responses or off-target effects. These insights could inform future CAR-T engineering strategies to enhance safety and efficacy.
Outcomes with CAR T-cells for acute myeloid leukaemia (AML) have been disappointing to date. Targeting of leukaemic stem cells (LSC) is crucial to prevent relapse, but their heterogeneous antigen expression has precluded the discovery of an ideal CAR target. Moreover, existing targets (e.g. CD33, CD123, CLL1) are also expressed on normal haematopoietic stem and progenitor cells (HSPC) -requiring consolidative transplant- and paediatric AML (pAML) LSC knowledge is primarily derived from adults. We generated a single cell pAML dataset, unique in that it is highly enriched for LSC and characterises both their transcriptome and surface proteome (CITEseq). With this high-resolution dataset, we develop a framework for LSC characterisation and identification of targets specifically tailored to pAML LSC. The dataset comprises >210 000 high-quality single cells from 15 pAML patients (15 diagnostic, 2 serial post-induction and 7 serial relapse samples) and 5 healthy controls (3 bone marrow and 2 cord blood). Median age was 4 years (range 0.2-18) and cytogenetic heterogeneity was well represented: 4 KMT2Ar, 2 inv(16), 2 NUP98::NSD1, 1 t(8;21), 1 CBFA2::GLIS2, 1 t(6;9) and 1 t(7;12)+19 (cytogenetic information was unavailable for 3 patients). Cells were stained with a custom panel of 81 CITEseq antibodies against potential LSC markers, sorted and enriched for CD34 (median 70%). Transcriptome and surface proteome libraries were generated with 10X Genomics. We first differentiated malignant from healthy cells using an occupancy score, presence of copy number variations and a 7-gene pAML blast signature (PMID: 37798266) and validated this annotation with a machine learning classifier (scANVI). Cell-types/states were obtained by mapping our single cell transcriptomes to published datasets. Our integrated analysis identified a cell cluster highly enriched in functionally derived LSC gene expression signatures, with contributions from all AML samples (median 4.7% LSC, IQR 1.3-6.7). These cells express a unique gene program (e.g., higher MSI2, RUNX1 and IGF2BP2 expression) that is distinct from adult LSC and adult healthy HSPC signatures, but is recapitulated in cord blood, potentially reflecting their cell of origin. This may allow preferential targeting of pAML LSC over mature HSPC. By analysing the surface proteome (custom CITEseq panel) and leveraging transcriptomes to discover surface-protein-coding genes, we identified targets overexpressed in LSC vs healthy HSPC, at the transcript (181) and protein (37) levels. Among these is CD84, a recently proposed pAML CAR target (Pigazzi et al., ASH 2022), restricted to haematopoietic tissue. High expression in LSC (56% across all patients, IQR 37-77) and blasts (83%, IQR 56-92) and low levels in healthy HSPC (21%, IQR 18-23, p<2.2-16) and lymphocytes are in contrast with CD33, CD123 and CLL1, which -while expressed in 51-65% of LSC- are expressed by 47-82% HSPC (p<0.05). These data suggest that CD84 may be ideal to target AML LSC whilst preserving normal HSPC, overriding the need for consolidative transplant. Further, other LSC targets are enriched in distinct pAML groups driven by cytogenetics and cellular hierarchies (PMID: 35618837), paving the way for rationally designing combinatorial strategies that enhance efficacy and limit toxicity. Here we present a unique dataset to profile vulnerabilities in pAML LSC and provide a framework to identify pAML LSC-specific targets and tailor CAR target combinations, with CD84 emerging as a potential near-universal LSC marker. We are currently validating and expanding our findings in silico by applying our paediatric LSC signature to other AML datasets and using predictive algorithms to infer protein levels from single cell transcriptomes lacking protein information. A systematic analysis to elicit optimal target combinations, as well as functional validation of candidate and previously undescribed paediatric LSC markers are underway. *MOE and SK contributed equally
Hematopoietic stem cells (HSCs) residing in specialized niches in the bone marrow are responsible for the balanced output of multiple short-lived blood cell lineages in steady-state and in response to different challenges. However, feedback mechanisms by which HSCs, through their niches, sense acute losses of specific blood cell lineages remain to be established. While all HSCs replenish platelets, previous studies have shown that a large fraction of HSCs are molecularly primed for the megakaryocyte-platelet lineage and are rapidly recruited into proliferation upon platelet depletion. Platelets normally turnover in an activation-dependent manner, herein mimicked by antibodies inducing platelet activation and depletion. Antibody-mediated platelet activation upregulates expression of Interleukin-1 (IL-1) in platelets, and in bone marrow extracellular fluid in vivo. Genetic experiments demonstrate that rather than IL-1 directly activating HSCs, activation of bone marrow Lepr+ perivascular niche cells expressing IL-1 receptor is critical for the optimal activation of quiescent HSCs upon platelet activation and depletion. These findings identify a feedback mechanism by which activation-induced depletion of a mature blood cell lineage leads to a niche-dependent activation of HSCs to reinstate its homeostasis.
We recently described a low-affinity second-generation CD19 chimeric antigen receptor (CAR) CAT that showed enhanced expansion, cytotoxicity, and antitumor efficacy compared with the high-affinity (FMC63-based) CAR used in tisagenlecleucel, in preclinical models. Furthermore, CAT demonstrated an excellent toxicity profile, enhanced in vivo expansion, and long-term persistence in a phase 1 clinical study. To understand the molecular mechanisms behind these properties of CAT CART cells, we performed a systematic in vitro characterization of the transcriptomic (RNA sequencing) and protein (cytometry by time of flight) changes occurring in T cells expressing low-affinity vs high-affinity CD19 CARs following stimulation with CD19-expressing cells. Our results show that CAT CAR T cells exhibit enhanced activation to CD19 stimulation and a distinct transcriptomic and protein profile, with increased activation and cytokine polyfunctionality compared with FMC63 CART cells. We demonstrate that the enhanced functionality of low-affinity CAT CART cells is a consequence of an antigen-dependent priming induced by residual CD19-expressing B cells present in the manufacture.
Here, we present a comprehensive protocol for the generation and functional characterization of chimeric antigen receptor (CAR) T cells and their products by mass cytometry in a reproducible and scalable manner. We describe the production of CAR T cells from human peripheral blood mononuclear cells. We then detail a three-step staining protocol with metal-labeled antibodies and the subsequent mass cytometry analysis. This protocol allows simultaneous characterization of CAR T cell intracellular signaling, activation, proliferation, cytokine production, and phenotype in a single assay.
Acute Myeloid Leukaemia (AML) is a phenotypically and genetically heterogenous blood cancer characterised by very poor prognosis, with disease relapse being the primary cause of treatment failure. AML heterogeneity arise from different genetic and non-genetic sources, including its proposed hierarchical structure, with leukemic stem cells (LSCs) and progenitors giving origin to a variety of more mature leukemic subsets. Recent advances in single-cell molecular and phenotypic profiling have highlighted the intra and inter-patient heterogeneous nature of AML, which has so far limited the success of cell-based immunotherapy approaches against single targets. Machine Learning (ML) can be uniquely used to find non-trivial patterns from high-dimensional datasets and identify rare sub-populations. Here we review some recent ML tools that applied to single-cell data could help disentangle cell heterogeneity in AML by identifying distinct core molecular signatures of leukemic cell subsets. We discuss the advantages and limitations of unsupervised and supervised ML approaches to cluster and classify cell populations in AML, for the identification of biomarkers and the design of personalised therapies.
Current treatment outcome for acute myeloid leukemia (AML) patients is unsatisfactory and characterized by high rates of relapse and poor overall survival. Increasing evidence points to a crucial role of leukemic stem cells (LSC) and the bone marrow (BM) leukemic niche, in which they reside, in AML evolution and chemoresistance. Thus, future strategies aiming at improving AML therapeutic protocols are likely to be directed against LSC and their niche. Chimeric antigen receptor (CAR) T-cells have been extremely successful in the treatment of relapsed/refractory acute lymphoblastic leukemia and B-cell non-Hodgkin lymphoma and comparable results in AML are highly desirable. At present, we are at the dawn of CAR T-cell application in AML, with several preclinical studies and few early phase clinical trials. However, the lack of leukemia-specific targets and the genetic and phenotypic heterogeneity of the disease combined with the leukemia-induced remodeling of the BM microenvironment are limiting CAR T-cell exploitation in AML. Here, we reviewed AML-LSC and AML-BM niche features in the context of their therapeutic targeting using CAR T-cells. We summarized recent progress in CAR T-cell application to the treatment of AML, and we discussed the remaining therapeutic challenges and promising novel strategies to overcome them.
We have recently described a low-affinity second-generation anti-CD19 Chimeric Antigen Receptor (CAR) (CAT), characterized by faster antigen dissociation rate which showed enhanced expansion, cytotoxicity and anti-tumour efficacy compared with the high affinity (FMC63 based) CAR used in Tisagenlecleucel in pre-clinical models. Furthermore, CAT CAR T cells showed an excellent toxicity profile, enhanced in vivo expansion and long-term persistence in a Phase I clinical study (Ghorashian et al Nature Med 2019). However the molecular mechanisms behind the improved properties of CAT CAR T cells remain unknown. Herein, we performed a systematic in vitro characterization of the transcriptomic (bulk RNA-seq) and protein (CyTOF) changes occurring in CAR T cells expressing a low-affinity (CAT) vs high affinity (FMC63) anti-CD19 CARs following stimulation with CD19 expressing targets. Untransduced (UT) controls and T cells lentivirally transduced to express CAT or FMC63 CD19 CARs were compared both at baseline and following stimulation with CD19+ Acute Lymphoblastic Leukaemia cell line NALM6. In Principal Component Analysis for both RNA-seq and protein results, we found that the major variance across conditions was explained by CD19-mediated CAR T activation. Strikingly, unstimulated CAT CAR T cells showed an intermediate degree of activation between UT T cells and antigen stimulated CAR T cells. Indeed, when comparing RNA-seq results of unstimulated CAT vs FMC63, we found enhanced expression (FDR <0.1) of genes involved in cytotoxicity (GNLY, GZMK) and T cell activation (HLA-DRA and HLA-DPA1) (Figure 1a), confirmed at protein level by CyTOF. This "activation priming" observed in CAT CAR T cells was associated with and may be driven by residual CD19-expressing B-cells present in the manufacture product, preferentially inducing a T Central Memory (TCM) phenotype in CAT vs FMC63, in both CD4 and CD8 T cells. Such priming is likely to be instrumental to CAT CAR T cells more potent cytotoxic response upon NALM6 stimulation, when they displayed further increase in the expression of immune stimulatory cytokines (IFNG, CSF2), chemokines (CCL3L1, CCL4, CXCL8) and IFNg responsive genes (CIITA) by RNA-seq, as well as augmented T cell activation (CD25, NFAT1) and proliferation (pRB) markers by CyTOF. To identify the mechanisms underlying the stronger basal activation of CAT CAR T cells, we analysed cytokine expression at the single cell level by mass cytometry. Interestingly, rather than an increment in the expression of individual cytokines, we found that the distinctive feature of CAT CAR T cells was a shift toward a cytokine polyfunctional phenotype, with a marked increase in the proportion of cells co-expressing 3 or more cytokines (17.50% CAT vs 7.33% FMC63) (Figure 1b). Of note, cytokine polyfunctionality (expression of more than 1 cytokine/cell) in pre-infusion CAR T cell products has been associated to improved clinical efficacy. The functional phenotype observed in CAT CAR T cells was linked to the preferential activation of the p38 MAPK phospo-signalling, which is activated downstream of TCR CD3ζ chain (present in the CARs) but is also central to cytokine-dependent T cell activation in memory T cells. Interestingly, cytokine polyfunctional CAT CAR T cells were enriched in the CD3+CD19+ trogocytic (trog+) population, found at higher proportion in CAT vs FMC63 at 24h post antigen stimulation. Although trogocytosis has been associated to CAR T cell fratricide killing, trog+ CAT CAR T cells displayed higher levels of proliferation (pRB), activation (CD25, NFAT1) and cytotoxic (Granzyme B, Perforin B) markers, pointing at a stimulatory role of trogocytosis over fratricide killing, potentially due to the low-affinity CAR T cells distinctive property of better discriminating between low (trog+ CAR T cells) and high (tumour cells) target expression levels. In conclusion, we described the molecular mechanisms underlying the low affinity CAT CAR T cells functional phenotype. Our results show that the potent and long-term anti-tumour responses observed with CAT may be sustained by the establishment of CAR T cells self-reinforcing circuits activated through polyfunctional cytokine crosstalk. This work may inform the future design of versatile CAR T cells, capable of balancing safety, efficacy and long-term persistence. Disclosures Ghorashian: Amgen: Honoraria; UCLB: Patents & Royalties; Novartis: Honoraria. Pule:Autolus: Current Employment, Other: owns stock in and receives royalties, Patents & Royalties; UCLB: Patents & Royalties; Mana Therapeutics: Other: entitled to share of revenue from patents filed by UCL.
COVID-19 has unfortunately halted lab work, conferences, and in-person networking, which is especially detrimental to researchers just starting their labs. Through social media and our reviewer networks, we met some early-career stem cell investigators impacted by the closures. Here, they introduce themselves and their research to our readers.
Single-cell RNA sequencing (scRNA-seq) has emerged as a powerful tool for resolving transcriptional heterogeneity. However, its application to studying cancerous tissues is currently hampered by the lack of coverage across key mutation hotspots in the vast majority of cells; this lack of coverage prevents the correlation of genetic and transcriptional readouts from the same single cell. To overcome this, we developed TARGET-seq, a method for the high-sensitivity detection of multiple mutations within single cells from both genomic and coding DNA, in parallel with unbiased whole-transcriptome analysis. Applying TARGET-seq to 4,559 single cells, we demonstrate how this technique uniquely resolves transcriptional and genetic tumor heterogeneity in myeloproliferative neoplasms (MPN) stem and progenitor cells, providing insights into deregulated pathways of mutant and non-mutant cells. TARGET-seq is a powerful tool for resolving the molecular signatures of genetically distinct subclones of cancer cells.
Single-cell RNA-sequencing has emerged as a powerful tool to resolve transcriptional heterogeneity in the hematopoietic system. However, its application to the study of clonal hematopoietic malignancies is currently hampered by lack of coverage across key mutation hotspots, which prevents correlation of genetic and transcriptional readouts from the same single cell. To overcome this problem, we developed TARGET-seq, a method for the high-sensitivity detection of multiple mutations within single cells in parallel with whole transcriptome analysis. Following extensive validation in cell lines, we applied this technique to study myeloproliferative neoplasms (MPNs), which are clonal disorders driven by mutant-positive hematopoietic stem/progenitor cells (HSPC). Resolving the multiple layers of heterogeneity encompassed within the MPN-HSPC compartment has crucial implications for MPN biology, yet very little is currently known about HSPC heterogeneity in MPNs. TARGET-seq analysis of over 2500 Lineage-CD34+ HSPCs (indexed for CD38/90/45RA/49f/123) from MPN patients revealed marked differences in the subclonal composition of this compartment, uniquely allowing us to identify distinct molecular signatures corresponding to genetically-distinct subclones, including patients acquiring multiple mutations in different orders. Moreover, we identified putative biomarkers of JAK2V617F mutant cells such as GAS2, RXFP1 and WDR86. Crucially, we were also able to characterize disruption of gene expression in non-mutant HSPCs, showing enrichment of inflammatory signatures. Analysis of HSPCs from MPN patients undergoing disease transformation revealed striking patterns of clonal evolution in different immunophenotypic subsets, including the emergence of resistant subpopulations during the selective pressure of therapy and the identification of pre-leukemic and leukemic subclones. In summary, TARGET-seq allowed us to identify distinct and biologically relevant molecular signatures of HSPCs in MPN, representing a powerful tool for biomarker and therapeutic target discovery that could also be broadly applied to other types of tumours.
Lympho-myeloid restricted early thymic progenitors (ETPs) are postulated to be the cell of origin for ETP leukemias, a therapy-resistant leukemia associated with frequent co-occurrence of EZH2 and RUNX1 inactivating mutations, and constitutively activating signaling pathway mutations. In a mouse model, we demonstrate that Ezh2 and Runx1 inactivation targeted to early lymphoid progenitors causes a marked expansion of pre-leukemic ETPs, showing transcriptional signatures characteristic of ETP leukemia. Addition of a RAS-signaling pathway mutation (Flt3-ITD) results in an aggressive leukemia co-expressing myeloid and lymphoid genes, which can be established and propagated in vivo by the expanded ETPs. Both mouse and human ETP leukemias show sensitivity to BET inhibition in vitro and in vivo, which reverses aberrant gene expression induced by Ezh2 inactivation.
Recent advances in single-cell transcriptomics are ideally placed to unravel intratumoral heterogeneity and selective resistance of cancer stem cell (SC) subpopulations to molecularly targeted cancer therapies. However, current single-cell RNA-sequencing approaches lack the sensitivity required to reliably detect somatic mutations. We developed a method that combines high-sensitivity mutation detection with whole-transcriptome analysis of the same single cell. We applied this technique to analyze more than 2,000 SCs from patients with chronic myeloid leukemia (CML) throughout the disease course, revealing heterogeneity of CML-SCs, including the identification of a subgroup of CML-SCs with a distinct molecular signature that selectively persisted during prolonged therapy. Analysis of nonleukemic SCs from patients with CML also provided new insights into cell-extrinsic disruption of hematopoiesis in CML associated with clinical outcome. Furthermore, we used this single-cell approach to identify a blast-crisis-specific SC population, which was also present in a subclone of CML-SCs during the chronic phase in a patient who subsequently developed blast crisis. This approach, which might be broadly applied to any malignancy, illustrates how single-cell analysis can identify subpopulations of therapy-resistant SCs that are not apparent through cell-population analysis.
Although previous studies suggested that the expression of FMS-like tyrosine kinase 3 (Flt3) initiates downstream of mouse hematopoietic stem cells (HSCs), FLT3 internal tandem duplications (FLT3 ITDs) have recently been suggested to intrinsically suppress HSCs. Herein, single-cell interrogation found Flt3 mRNA expression to be absent in the large majority of phenotypic HSCs, with a strong negative correlation between Flt3 and HSC-associated gene expression. Flt3-ITD knock-in mice showed reduced numbers of phenotypic HSCs, with an even more severe loss of long-term repopulating HSCs, likely reflecting the presence of non-HSCs within the phenotypic HSC compartment. Competitive transplantation experiments established that Flt3-ITD compromises HSCs through an extrinsically mediated mechanism of disrupting HSC-supporting bone marrow stromal cells, with reduced numbers of endothelial and mesenchymal stromal cells showing increased inflammation-associated gene expression. Tumor necrosis factor (TNF), a cell-extrinsic potent negative regulator of HSCs, was overexpressed in bone marrow niche cells from FLT3-ITD mice, and anti-TNF treatment partially rescued the HSC phenotype. These findings, which establish that Flt3-ITD–driven myeloproliferation results in cell-extrinsic suppression of the normal HSC reservoir, are of relevance for several aspects of acute myeloid leukemia biology.
Differentiation of lineage-committed cells from multipotent progenitors requires the establishment of accessible chromatin at lineage-specific transcriptional enhancers and promoters, which is mediated by pioneer transcription factors that recruit activating chromatin remodeling complexes. Here we show that the Mbd3/nucleosome remodeling and deacetylation (NuRD) chromatin remodeling complex opposes this transcriptional pioneering during B cell programming of multipotent lymphoid progenitors by restricting chromatin accessibility at B cell enhancers and promoters. Mbd3/NuRD-deficient lymphoid progenitors therefore prematurely activate a B cell transcriptional program and are biased toward overproduction of pro–B cells at the expense of T cell progenitors. The striking reduction in early thymic T cell progenitors results in compensatory hyperproliferation of immature thymocytes and development of T cell lymphoma. Our results reveal that Mbd3/NuRD can regulate multilineage differentiation by constraining the activation of dormant lineage-specific enhancers and promoters. In this way, Mbd3/NuRD protects the multipotency of lymphoid progenitors, preventing B cell–programming transcription factors from prematurely enacting lineage commitment. Mbd3/NuRD therefore controls the fate of lymphoid progenitors, ensuring appropriate production of lineage-committed progeny and suppressing tumor formation.
The final stages of restriction to the T cell lineage occur in the thymus after the entry of thymus-seeding progenitors (TSPs). The identity and lineage potential of TSPs remains unclear. Because the first embryonic TSPs enter a non-vascularized thymic rudiment, we were able to directly image and establish the functional and molecular properties of embryonic thymopoiesis-initiating progenitors (T-IPs) before their entry into the thymus and activation of Notch signaling. T-IPs did not include multipotent stem cells or molecular evidence of T cell restricted progenitors. Instead, single-cell molecular and functional analysis demonstrated that most fetal T-IPs expressed genes of and had the potential to develop into lymphoid as well as myeloid components of the immune system. Moreover, studies of embryos deficient in the transcriptional regulator RBPJ demonstrated that canonical Notch signaling was not involved in pre-thymic restriction to the T cell lineage or the migration of T-IPs.
Thymic T cell development is initiated from bone-marrow-derived multi potent thymus-seeding progenitors. During the early stages of thymocyte differentiation, progenitors become T cell restricted. However, the cellular environments supporting these critical initial stages of T cell development within the thymic cortex are not known. Here we use the dependence of early, c-Kit-expressing thymic progenitors on Kit ligand (KitL) to show that CD4(-)CD8(-)c-Kit(+)CD25(-) DN1-stage progenitors associate with, and depend on, the membrane-bound form of KitL (mKitL) provided by a cortex-specific KitL-expressing vascular endothelial cell (VEC) population. In contrast, the subsequent CD4(-)CD8(-)c-Kit(+)CD25(+) DN2-stage progenitors associate selectively with cortical thymic epithelial cells (cTECs) and depend on cTEC-presented mKitL. These results show that the dynamic process of early thymic progenitor differentiation is paralleled by migration-dependent change to the supporting niche, and identify VECs as a thymic niche cell, with mKitL as a critical ligand.