Ultrasound imaging plays an important role in the early detection and management of breast cancer. This study aimed to evaluate the imaging performance of a range of clinically-used breast ultrasound systems using a set of novel spherical lesion contrast-detail (C-D) and anechoic-target (A-T) phantoms. METHODS:C-D and A-T phantoms were imaged using a range of clinical breast ultrasound systems and imaging modes. A novel sensitive imaging performance metric, the Detectability Score (DS), was proposed which encompasses the Lesion Contrast to Noise Ratio (LCNR) weighted by the lesion depth and diameter. A geometry-based theoretical model comparing LCNR measured using spherical and cylindrical phantom anechoic/lesion targets was developed to investigate the influence of slice thickness on focal lesion detectability. RESULTS:LCNR and DS metrics derived from phantom image measurments were capable of differentiating the imaging performance of a range of ultrasound systems and advanced imaging modes, with the -2 dB contrast lesion targets offered as the most challenging to resolve. The geometry-based theoretical model, validated against phantom measurements, demonstrated the significant influence of slice thickness on focal lesion detectability, highlighting the need for increased availability of low contrast resolution spherical target phantoms for clinically realistic performance evaluation. CONCLUSIONS:The performance metrics coupled with the -1 dB contrast targets provide scope for evaluating future technological improvements in ultrasound systems. Given the high dependence of breast cancer care on high quality ultrasound imaging techniques, there is a need for evaluating imaging performance using clinically relevant test objects.
CONTEXT:The goal of quality assurance (QA) for transrectal ultrasound (TRUS) prostate brachytherapy is to ensure optimum patient outcomes by providing a high-quality service using equipment that is operating at optimum performance levels. There are specific recommendations from professional organisations that outline the QA parameters that need to be considered specifically for ultrasound guided prostate brachytherapy. However, these recommendations are heavily based on the guidance made for the general application of ultrasound to all relevant clinical applications. Additionally, there is a lack of consensus on the optimum QA test device to conduct the schedule of testing for this specific application of TRUS image guided interventional procedures. PROCEDURES:In this study, we describe a task-specific testing schedule for TRUS QA, detailing the QA test protocol, and the recommended equipment set-up, and scan parameters to evaluate these systems. Also described are the commercially available test devices, as well as custom made devices including the design and acoustic characteristics of the materials used to design the custom devices. This QA test protocol was used to evaluate nine TRUS systems used on the island of Ireland in prostate brachytherapy treatment. MAIN FINDINGS:The evaluation revealed significant differences among the nine TRUS scanners, highlighting variations in manufacturer pre-sets and their potential limitations in effectively guiding prostate brachytherapy. CONCLUSION:This study highlights the urgent need for application specific QA test devices for TRUS systems used to guide prostate brachytherapy, and the need for the optimization of scanning parameters during these procedures.
Cardiovascular pathology is the leading cause of death and disability in the Western world, and current diagnostic testing usually evaluates the anatomy of the vessel to determine if the vessel contains blockages and plaques. However, there is a growing school of thought that other measures, such as wall shear stress, provide more useful information for earlier diagnosis and prediction of atherosclerotic related disease compared to pulsed-wave Doppler ultrasound, magnetic resonance angiography, or computed tomography angiography. A novel algorithm for quantifying wall shear stress (WSS) in atherosclerotic plaque using diagnostic ultrasound imaging, called Multifrequency ultrafast Doppler spectral analysis (MFUDSA), is presented. The development of this algorithm is presented, in addition to its optimisation using simulation studies and in-vitro experiments with flow phantoms approximating the early stages of cardiovascular disease. The presented algorithm is compared with commonly used WSS assessment methods, such as standard PW Doppler, Ultrafast Doppler, and Parabolic Doppler, as well as plane-wave Doppler. Compared to an equivalent processing architecture with one-dimensional Fourier analysis, the MFUDSA algorithm provided an increase in signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) by a factor of 4-8 and an increase in velocity resolution by a factor of 1.10-1.35. The results indicated that MFUDSA outperformed the others, with significant differences detected between the typical WSS values of moderate disease progression (p = 0.003) and severe disease progression (p = 0.001). The algorithm demonstrated an improved performance for the assessment of WSS and has potential to provide an earlier diagnosis of cardiovascular disease than current techniques allow.
The acoustic output of clinical therapeutic ultrasound equipment requires regular quality assurance (QA) testing to ensure the safety and efficacy of the treatment and that any potentially harmful deviations from the expected output power density are detected as soon as possible. A hologram, consisting of a reflection grating fabricated in an acrylate photopolymer film, has been developed to produce an immediate, visible, and permanent change in the color of the reconstructed hologram from red to green in response to incident ultrasound energy. The influence of the therapeutic ultrasound insonation parameters (exposure time, ultrasound power density, and proximity to the point of maximum acoustic pressure) on the hologram's response has been investigated for two types of therapeutic ultrasound systems: a sonoporation system and an ultrasound physiotherapy system. Findings show that, above a switching temperature of 45 °C, the ultrasound-induced temperature rise produces a structural change in the hologram, which manifests as a visible color change. The area of the color change region correlates with the ultrasound exposure conditions. The suitability of the hologram as a simple and quick QA test tool for therapeutic ultrasound systems has been demonstrated. A prototype ultrasound testing unit which facilitates user-friendly, reproducible testing of the holograms in a clinical setting is also reported.
Purpose: Ultrasound imaging training is not required as part of radiation oncology training programs nor does any objective competency measure exist to independently assess performance. Physical simulation training can provide a structured approach to this training but only if suitably challenging training simulators exist. This study describes the design and preliminary evaluation of a simulation-based transrectal ultrasound (TRUS) imaging training workshop developed for medical physicists involved in low-dose-rate (LDR) prostate brachytherapy (PBT).Methods: The study incorporated novel high-fidelity anthropomorphic PBT TRUS training simulators and a TRUS imaging module with a blended-learning pedagogical approach, to address TRUS image optimisation and managing image quality.Results: Results demonstrated a significant improvement in knowledge, with an average increase in multiple choice question score of 61% (P < 0.0002), and that there was a 46% (P < 0.0001) average increase in the participants perceived understanding of TRUS scanner operation, and an increase of 36% (P < 0.001) in participants readiness to optimise image quality and mitigate image artefacts. Focus group data explored participants' experiences, perceptions and challenges with TRUS LDR PBT.Conclusions: This study suggests a benefit in offering a simulation training workshop to medical physicists and the potential benefit to other healthcare professionals involved in prostate brachytherapy, by incorporating novel high-fidelity anthropomorphic PBT TRUS training simulators, in a simulated environment to practice ultrasound image optimisation for PBT image guidance. This approach to training would enable competency-based skill acquisition and continued proficiency or health professionals in the TRUS PBT procedure, outside of the surgical environment without direct exposure to patients.
Purpose: Contrast-detail (C-D) and anechoic-target (A-T) detectability are measures of an ultrasound scanner's ability to image lesions of varying contrast and size from background tissue and, as such, they are important tools for grading the imaging capabilities of ultrasound scanners. The objective of this study was to develop a range of contrast-and anechoic-detail phantoms with clinically relevant lesions, of various contrast and sizes, for performance testing of breast ultrasound equipment. Methods: Tissue mimicking materials that represent the acoustic properties of breast fibroglandular tissue were produced and moulded to construct a range of C-D and A-T phantoms. Two phantom designs were produced, containing cylindrical and spherical targets. Both phantom types were constructed with contrast targets covering the range anechoic,-1,-2,-3 and-4 dB, with lesion diameters of 1-4 mm, positioned at four clinically relevant depths (10, 25, 40 and 55 mm). An image analysis program was developed to objectively analyse the lesion images and to determine the lesion-signal-noise-ratio (LSNR). Results: Both phantoms were used to evaluate the performance of a breast ultrasound scanner. The use of cylindrical phantoms led to an artificially higher image quality performance compared with the more clinically relevant spherical lesion phantom, thus indicating the importance of using the appropriate targets in ultrasound phantoms. Conclusion: The spherical lesion phantoms, coupled with the quantitative metric of LSNR, provides a comprehensive approach for performance and quality control testing, as well as the evaluation of advanced ultrasound imaging modes and technologies.
Brachytherapy is an efficacious treatment option because of its benefits for patient recovery, dose localization and conformity, but these favorable outcomes can be ensured only if the transrectal ultrasound (TRUS) system is optimized for the specific application of ultrasound-guided prostate brachytherapy. The ability to delineate the prostate from surrounding tissue during TRUS-guided prostate brachytherapy is vital for treatment planning, and consequently, so is the contrast resolution. This study describes the development of task-specific contrast-detail phantoms with clinically relevant contrast and spherical target sizes for contrast-detail performance evaluation of TRUS systems used in the brachytherapy procedure. The procedure for objective assessment of the contrast detectability of the TRUS systems is also described; a program was developed in MATLAB (R2017a, The MathWorks, Natick, MA, USA) to quantitatively analyze image quality in terms of the lesion signal-to-noise ratio (LSNR) and validated with representative control test images. The LSNR of the Hitachi EUB-7500A (2013, Hitachi, Ltd, Tokyo, Japan) TRUS system was measured on sagittal and transverse TRUS images of the contrast-detail phantoms described in this work. Results revealed the efficacy of the device as an image quality evaluation tool and the impact of the size, depth and relative contrast of the targets to the surrounding tissue on the contrast detectability of a TRUS system for both transducer arrays. The MATLAB program objectively measured the contrast detectability of the TRUS system and has the potential to determine optimized imaging parameters that could be designed as part of standardization of the imaging protocol used in TRUS-guided prostate brachytherapy for prostate cancer.
In this paper we consider radar approaches for breast cancer detection. The aim is to give a brief review of the main features of incoherent methods, based on beam-forming and Multiple SIgnal Classification (MUSIC) algorithms, that we have recently developed, and to compare them with classical coherent beam-forming. Those methods have the remarkable advantage of not requiring antenna characterization/compensation, which can be problematic in view of the close (to the breast) proximity set-up usually employed in breast imaging. Moreover, we proceed to an experimental validation of one of the incoherent methods, i.e., the I-MUSIC, using the multimodal breast phantom we have previously developed. While in a previous paper we focused on the phantom manufacture and characterization, here we are mainly concerned with providing the detail of the reconstruction algorithm, in particular for a new multi-step clutter rejection method that was employed and only barely described. In this regard, this contribution can be considered as a completion of our previous study. The experiments against the phantom show promising results and highlight the crucial role played by the clutter rejection procedure.
Purpose: To investigate cryoneedle heating risks during magnetic resonance (MR)-guided cryoablation and potential strategies to mitigate these risks. Materials and Methods: Ex vivo experiments were performed on a 1.5-Tesla (T) MR scanner using an MR conditional cryoablation system on porcine tissue phantoms. Cryoneedles were placed inside the tissue phantom either with or without an angiocatheter. Typical cryoneedle geometric configurations (including gas supply line) encountered in clinical procedures with low to high expected heating risks were investigated. Up to 4 fiber optic temperature sensors were attached to the cryoneedle/angiocatheter to measure the MR-induced cryoneedle heating at different locations during MR with different estimated specific absorption rates (SARs). The impact of cryoneedle heating on cryoablation treatment was studied by comparing temperature changes during 10-min freeze-thaw cycles with and without MR. Results: Rapid temperature increases of >100 degrees C in < 2 minutes were observed during MR with a SAR of 2.1 W/kg. The temperature changes during a typical freeze-thaw cycle were also affected by cryoneedle heating when MR was used to monitor the ice-ball evolution. The observed cryoneedle heating was affected by multiple factors; including cryoneedle geometric configurations, sequence SAR, whether an angiocatheter was used, and whether the cryoneedle was connected to the rest of the cryoablation system. Conclusions: The ex vivo experiments demonstrated that MR could induce significant cryoneedle heating risks. Furthermore, MR-induced cryoneedle heating can affect temperatures in the ice-ball evolution during the freeze-thaw cycle. Several practical strategies to reduce the cryoneedle heating have been proposed.
The quality of the trans-rectal ultrasound (TRUS) image, and thus seed placement during the prostate brachytherapy (PBT) procedure, relies on the user's technical and clinical competency. Simulation-based medical education can provide a structured approach for the acquisition of clinical competencies, but the efficacy of the training relies on the fidelity of the training simulators. In this work, the design, development and preliminary evaluation of an anthropomorphic training phantom for TRUS PBT is described. TRUS clinical patient data informed the design of 3-D printed moulds to fabricate prostate targets. Tissue-mimicking materials were included that had the sonographic characteristics of the prostate and overlying tissues, as well as the clinically relevant physical response, to provide haptic feedback to the user. Through an iterative design process, prototypes were constructed. These prototypes were quantitatively evaluated using a specification list and evaluated by an experienced clinical brachytherapy oncologist; their feedback was implemented, and the results of this evaluation are presented.
In this contribution we briefly present the experimental verification of incoherent radar imaging approaches recently developed in the framework of medical imaging. In particular, a prototype radar system is described and breast and head phantoms are developed and employed to collect the measurements.
Current methods for diagnosis of cardiovascular disease (CVD) rely on detecting the obstruction of an artery the disease is already well established. The purpose of this work was to design and assess an early screening technique for CVD using the wall shear stress (WSS) biomarker prior to arterial obstruction.
AbstractIt is important to employ radiation dose reduction techniques in pediatric computed tomography (CT) to reduce potential risks of radiation‐induced malignancy. Automatic tube potential (kV) selection tools have been developed and become available on many CT scanners, which select the optimum kV based on the patient size and clinical task to improve the radiation dose efficiency. However, its use in pediatric CT has been mostly empirical, following manufacturer’s default recommendation without solid demonstration for quality improvement. This study aimed to implement an automatic tube potential tool (CAREkV, Siemens Healthcare) into routine pediatric CT practice, using the “Plan‐Do‐Study‐Act” quality improvement process, in place of an existing kV/mAs technique chart. The design of this quality improvement project involved Plan‐Do‐Study‐Act stages. Plan and Do stages identified the criteria for optimal automatic kV selection; a range of phantoms representing typical pediatric groups were scanned on a dual‐source 128‐slice scanner using a fast‐pitch scanning mode. The identified CAREkV settings were implemented into the CT protocol and evaluated after a 6‐month period. In the Study stage, an objective evaluation of the image metrics and radiation dose for two similar patient cohorts using CAREkV and the technique‐chart, respectively, were compared. The kV selected, image quality and radiation dose determined by CAREkV were comparable to those obtained while using the technique‐chart. The CAREkV was successfully implemented into our pediatric abdominopelvic CT practice. By utilizing the “PDSA” process optimal image quality and radiation dose reduction were achieved with an automatic kV selection tool to improve CT workflow.
OBJECTIVE:To provide an initial report that patients with magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) non-conditional cardiac implanted electronic device (CIED) can undergo state-of-the-art magnetic resonance imaging-guided focused (MRgFUS) ablation procedures with careful planning and integration of the procedure into an established CIED MRI practice. PATIENT AND METHODS:We describe an MRgFUS ablation treatment of lumbar facet joints in a patient with an MRI non-conditional CIED (pacemaker), completed in accordance with our institutional CIED/MRI practice guidelines. RESULTS:A risk-benefit analysis by a coordinated multidisciplinary team before this treatment was performed to account for the risks associated with the MRI non-conditional pacemaker in the context of the MRgFUS procedure. CONCLUSION:The patient had no adverse cardiac event during or following this procedure.
PURPOSE:The stiffness of Polyvinyl-alcohol cryogel can be adjusted through application of consecutive freeze-thaw cycles. This material has potential applications in the production of tissue mimicking phantoms in diagnostic ultrasound. The aim of this study was to use PVA-c to produce a range of geometrically and acoustically identical vessel phantoms modelling stages of atherosclerosis which could be verified through mechanical testing, thus allowing for more precision in quantitative in-vitro flow analysis of atherosclerosis.METHODS:A series of anatomically realistic walled renal artery flow phantoms were constructed using PVA-c. In order to ensure precise modelling of atherosclerosis, a modified procedure of ISO27:2017 was used to compare the mechanical properties of PVA-c. Results were compared for the standard "dumbbell" test object and a modified vessel test object. The geometric accuracy and reproducibility of the vessel models were tested before and after implantation in flow phantoms.RESULTS:No significant difference was found between the mechanical properties of the dumbbell test samples and the vessels for any number of freeze thaw cycles, with a correlation coefficient of R2 = 0.9767 across the dataset, indicating that a direct comparison between the mechanical properties of the dumbbell test samples and the phantom vessels was established. The geometric reproducibility showed that before and after implantation there was no significant difference between individual vessel geometries (p = 0.337 & p = 0.176 respectively).CONCLUSIONS:Polyvinyl-alcohol cryogel is a useful material for the production of arterial flow phantoms. Care should be taken when using this material to ensure its mechanical properties have been correctly characterised. The guidelines of ISO37:2017 potentially provide the best procedure to ensure this.
The aim of this work was to establish the optimum acoustic characterisation approach and insonation transmit beam parameters for subharmonic signal generation with 'native' and 'altered' populations of a commonly-used microbubble contrast agent. Dynamic contrast-enhanced (DCE) ultrasound is a non-invasive method of imaging the microvasculature, typically implemented using harmonic imaging. Subharmonic imaging, in which echoes at half the fundamental frequency are detected, detects signals which are generated by the ultrasound contrast agents (UCAs) but not by tissue. However, optimal transmission parameters and furthermore, the optimum acoustic characterisation method have not been established. The subharmonic response of 'native' and 'altered' UCA, altered through decantation, was investigated at transmit centre frequencies 1.8-5 MHz and pulse lengths 1-8 cycles. The 'altered' UCA had reduced polydispersity (1-4 µm: 82% bubble volume), compared to 'native' (4-10 µm: 57% bubble volume). A custom-built narrow-band acoustic characterisation system was found to be more appropriate for acoustic characterisation compared to the commonly used broadband pulse-echo approach. Both UCA generated the highest subharmonic signal at pulse length of 3-cycles. The maximum 'native' subharmonic signal was generated at a transmit centre frequency of 1.9 MHz, corresponding to a subharmonic at 0.95 MHz. This optimal frequency increased in the 'altered' population to 2.3-2.5 MHz, bringing the subharmonic above 1 MHz and hence into a range amenable to clinical abdominal imaging transducers. The use of subharmonic signal detection coupled with a modified UCA size distribution has potential to significantly improve the quantification sensitivity and accuracy of DCE ultrasound imaging.