Aviation emissions have been the focus of research and regulation since the 1970s. Switzerland's Federal Office of Civil Aviation (FOCA) and research groups in Switzerland have contributed significantly to an improved understanding of these emissions and their impact on the environment and health. This paper presents a brief history of aviation emissions research in Switzerland. We also present the direction of future research on aviation emissions using the Swiss mobile aircraft emissions measurement system (SMARTEMIS).
[This retracts the article DOI: 10.1021/acsestair.4c00309.].
The impact of aircraft exhaust particles on human health and climate are raising concerns globally. Particle number concentrations in exhaust plumes of turbofan jet engines, which are commonly used in civil aviation, are generally dominated by volatile particles (sulfates or organics) rather than nonvolatile particles (mostly soot). However, the mechanism of emission and formation of volatile particles are unclear. Here, we evaluated the exhaust particles from turbofan engines at the engine exit and downstream. In downstream samples, the number of soot particles with scattering-layered graphene-like structures, typically generated by combustion, was <1% of the total number of particles analyzed. The remaining fraction predominantly contained trace amorphous, amorphous, and onion-like particles that partially contain graphene-like circular layers. The microphysical structures of these three types of particles in aircraft exhaust plumes were newly identified. They were mainly single spherical particles with diameters of ∼10-20 nm, suggesting that they were formed via nucleation and partial pyrolysis and were not significantly affected by coagulation with preexisting soot particles. The unique internal structures of these particles may affect their physicochemical properties, including volatility, surface reactivity, and solubility, and potentially impact their interaction with the human respiratory tract.
Aviation soot surrogates processed in contrails are believed to become potent ice nuclei at cirrus temperatures. This is not verified for real aviation soot, which can have vastly different physico-chemical properties. Here, we sampled soot particles from in-use commercial aircraft engines and quantified the effect of contrail processing on their ice nucleation ability at T< 228 K. We show that aviation soot becomes compacted upon contrail processing, but that does not change their ice nucleation ability in contrast to other soot types. The presence of H2SO4 condensed in soot pores, the highly fused nature of the soot primary particles and their arrangement are what limit the volume of pores generated upon contrail processing, in turn limiting sites for ice nucleation. Furthermore, we hypothesized that contrail-processed aviation soot particles emitted from alternative jet fuel would also be poor ice-nucleating particles if their emission sizes remain small (< 150 nm).
Ice-nucleating particles catalyze ice formation in clouds, affecting climate through radiative forcing from aerosol–cloud interactions. Aviation directly emits particles into the upper troposphere where ice formation conditions are favorable. Previous studies have used proxies of aviation soot to estimate their ice nucleation activity; however, investigations with commercial aircraft soot from modern in-use aircraft engines have not been quantified. In this work, we sample aviation soot particles at ground level from different commercial aircraft engines to test their ice nucleation ability at temperatures ≤228 K as a function of engine thrust and soot particle size. Additionally, soot particles were catalytically stripped to reveal the impact of mixing state on their ice nucleation ability. Particle physical and chemical properties were further characterized and related to the ice nucleation properties. The results show that aviation soot nucleates ice at or above relative humidity conditions required for homogeneous freezing of solution droplets (RHhom). We attribute this to a mesopore paucity inhibiting pore condensation and the sulfur content which suppresses freezing. Only large soot aggregates (400 nm) emitted under 30 %–100 % thrust conditions for a subset of engines (2 out of 10) nucleate ice via pore condensation and freezing. For those specific engines, the presence of hydrophilic chemical groups facilitates the nucleation. Aviation soot emitted at thrust ≥ 100 % (sea level thrust) nucleates ice at or above RHhom. Overall, our results suggest that aviation soot will not contribute to natural cirrus formation and can be used in models to update impacts of soot–cirrus clouds.
Concerns about civil aviation's air quality and environmental impacts have led to recent regulations on nonvolatile particulate matter (nvPM) mass and number emissions. Although these regulations do not mandate measuring particle size distribution (PSD), understanding PSDs is vital for assessing the environmental impacts of aviation nvPM. This study introduces a comprehensive data set detailing PSD characteristics of 42 engines across 19 turbofan types, ranging from unregulated small business jets to regulated large commercial aircraft. Emission tests were independently performed by using the European and Swiss reference nvPM sampling and measurement systems with parallel PSD measurements. The geometric mean diameter (GMD) at the engine exit strongly correlated with the nvPM number-to-mass ratio (N/M) and thrust, varying from 7 to 52 nm. The engine-exit geometric standard deviation ranged from 1.7 to 2.5 (mean of 2.05). The study proposes empirical correlations to predict GMD from N/M data of emissions-certified engines. These predictions are expected to be effective for conventional rich-burn engines and might be extended to novel combustor technologies if additional data become available. The findings support the refinement of emission models and help in assessing the aviation non-CO2 climate and air quality impacts.
Ice nucleating particles catalyse ice formation in clouds, affecting climate through radiative forcing from aerosol-cloud interactions. Aviation directly emits particles into the upper troposphere where ice formation conditions are favourable. Previous studies have used proxies of aviation soot to estimate their ice nucleation activity, however the investigations with commercial aircraft soot from modern in-use aircraft engine have not been quantified. In this work, we sample aviation soot particles at ground level from different commercial aircraft engines to test their ice nucleation ability at temperatures ≤ 228 K, as a function of engine thrust and soot particle size. Additionally soot particles were catalytically stripped to reveal the impact of mixing state on their ice nucleation ability. Particle physical and chemical properties were further characterised and related to the ice nucleation properties. The results show that aviation soot nucleates ice at or above relative humidity conditions required for homogeneous freezing of solution droplets (RHhom).We attribute this to a mesopore paucity inhibiting pore condensation and the sulfur content which suppresses freezing. Only large soot aggregates (400 nm) emitted under 30–100 % thrust conditions for a subset of engines (2/10) nucleate ice via pore condensation and freezing. For those specific engines, the presence of hydrophilic chemical groups facilitates the nucleation. Aviation soot emitted at thrust ≥100 % (sea level thrust) nucleates ice at or above RHhom. Overall our results suggest that aviation soot will not contribute to natural cirrus formation and can be used in models to update impacts of soot-cirrus clouds.
To reduce the adverse impact of civil aviation on local air quality and human health, a new in-ternational standard for non-volatile Particulate Matter (nvPM) number and mass emissions was recently adopted. A system loss correction method, which accounts for the significant size-dependent particle loss, is also detailed to predict nvPM emissions representative of those at engine exit for emissions inventory purposes. As Particle-Size-Distribution (PSD) measurement is currently not prescribed, the existing loss correction method uses the nvPM number and mass measurements along with several assumptions to predict a PSD, resulting in significant uncertainty.Three new system loss correction methodologies using measured PSD were developed and compared with the existing regulatory method using certification-like nvPM data reported by the Swiss and European nvPM reference systems for thirty-two civil turbofan engines representative of the current fleet. Additionally, the PSD statistics of three sizing instruments typically used in these systems (SMPS, DMS500 and EEPS) were compared on a generic aero-engine combustor rig.General agreement between the three new PSD loss correction methods was observed, with both nvPM number-and mass-based system loss correction factors (kSL_num and kSL_mass) within +/- 10% reported across the engines tested. By comparison, the existing regulatory method was seen to underpredict kSL_num by up to 67% and overpredict kSL_mass by up to 49% when compared with the measured-PSD-based methods, typically driven by low nvPM mass concentrations and small particle size. In terms of the particle sizing instrument inter-comparison, an agreement of +/- 2 nm for the GMD and +/- 0.08 for the GSD was observed across a range of particle sizes on the combustor rig. However, it was seen that these differences can result in a 19% bias for kSL_num and 8% for kSL_mass for the measured-PSD-based methods, highlighting the need for further work to-wards the standardisation of PSD measurement for regulatory purposes.
Nitryl chloride (ClNO2) is a radical reservoir that forms and accumulates in the nocturnal atmospheric boundary layer influenced by combustion emissions and chloride (e.g., sea salt and road salt). Upon sunrise, ClNO2 rapidly photolyzes to generate highly reactive chlorine radicals (Cl-center dot) that affect the air quality by generating secondary air pollutants. Recent studies have shown road salt aerosols and saline snowpack to be sources of ClNO2 in the wintertime urban environment; however, the quantitative contributions of each chloride source are not known. In this study, we examine the vertically resolved contributions of aerosol particles and saline snowpack as sources of ClNO2 by using an observationally constrained snow-atmosphere coupled one-dimensional model applied to wintertime Kalamazoo, Michigan, U.S. Model simulations show that ClNO2 emitted from urban snowpack can be vertically transported throughout the entire atmospheric boundary layer and can be a significant source of ClNO2, contributing up to similar to 60% of the ClNO2 budget near the surface. Modeled snowpack ClNO2 emission rates were 6 (+/- 7) times higher than the observationally derived emission rates, suggesting that not all snow chloride is available for reaction. ClNO2 production from both aerosol particles and snow emissions are required to best simulate the observed surface-level ClNO2. Using the traditional bulk parameterization for ClNO2 produced from particles significantly overestimated ClNO2 due to the assumption of having equivalent dinitrogen pentoxide (N2O5) uptake and chloride availability for the entire particle population. In comparison, the chemically resolved surface area-based parameterization slightly underestimated the observations and had uncertainties deriving from ClNO2 production from residential wood burning particles.
Objective: To assess the spatiotemporal heterogeneity of lung-deposited particle surface area concentration (LDSA), while testing the long-term performance of a prototype of low-cost-low-maintenance LDSA sensors. One factor hampering epidemiological studies on fine to ultrafine particles (F-to-UFP) exposure is exposure error due to their high spatiotemporal heterogeneity, not reflected in particle mass. Though LDSA shows consistent associations between F-to-UFP exposure and health effects, LDSA data are limited. Methods: We measured LDSA in a network of ten sensors, including urban, suburban, and rural environments in Zurich, Switzerland. With traffic counts, traffic co-pollutant concentrations, and meteorological parameters, we assessed the drivers of the LDSA observations. Results: LDSA reflected the high spatiotemporal heterogeneity of F-to-UFP. With micrometeorological influences, local sources like road traffic, restaurants, air traffic, and residential combustion drove LDSA. The temporal pattern of LDSA reflected that of the local sources. Conclusion: LDSA may be a viable metric for inexpensively characterizing F-to-UFP exposure. The tested devices generated sound data and may significantly contribute to filling the LDSA exposure data gap, providing grounds for more statistically significant epidemiological studies and regulation of F-to-UFP.
The atmospheric multiphase reaction of dinitrogen pentoxide (N2O5) with chloride-containing aerosol particles produces nitryl chloride (ClNO2), which has been observed across the globe. The photolysis of ClNO2 produces chlorine radicals and nitrogen dioxide (NO2), which alter pollutant fates and air quality. However, the effects of local meteorology on near-surface ClNO2 production are not yet well understood, as most observational and modeling studies focus on periods of clear conditions. During a field campaign in Kalamazoo, Michigan, from January–February 2018, N2O5 and ClNO2 were measured using chemical ionization mass spectrometry, with simultaneous measurements of atmospheric particulate matter and meteorological parameters. We examine the impacts of atmospheric turbulence, precipitation (snow, rain) and fog, and ground cover (snow-covered and bare ground) on the abundances of ClNO2 and N2O5. N2O5 mole ratios were lowest during periods of lower turbulence and were not statistically significantly different between snow-covered and bare ground. In contrast, ClNO2 mole ratios were highest, on average, over snow-covered ground, due to saline snowpack ClNO2 production. Both N2O5 and ClNO2 mole ratios were lowest, on average, during rainfall and fog because of scavenging, with N2O5 scavenging by fog droplets likely contributing to observed increased particulate nitrate concentrations. These observations, specifically those during active precipitation and with snow-covered ground, highlight important processes, including N2O5 and ClNO2 wet scavenging, fog nitrate production, and snowpack ClNO2 production, that govern the variability in observed atmospheric chlorine and nitrogen chemistry and are missed when considering only clear conditions.
The contribution of aircraft operations to ambient ultrafine particle (UFP) concentration at and around airports can be significant. This review article considers the volatile and non-volatile elements of particulate matter emissions from aircraft engines, their characteristics and quantification and identifies gaps in knowledge. The current state of the art emission inventory methods and dispersion modelling approaches are reviewed and areas for improvement and research needs are identified. Quantification of engine non-volatile particulate matter (nvPM) is improving as measured certification data for the landing and take-off cycle are becoming available. Further work is needed: to better estimate nvPM emissions during the full-flight; to estimate non-regulated (smaller) engines; and to better estimate the emissions and evolution of volatile particles (vPM) in the aircraft exhaust plume. Dispersion modelling improvements are also needed to better address vPM. As the emissions inventory data for both vPM and nvPM from aircraft sources improve, better estimates of the contribution of aircraft engine emissions to ambient particulate concentrations will be possible.
Aircraft operate mainly in the upper troposphere/lower stratosphere — altitudes where the aerosol loading is rather low — emitting gases (mainly H2O and CO2) and soot particles (a result of the incomplete combustion of aviation fuel). At these altitudes, clouds composed of micrometric ice crystals (known as cirrus clouds) originate from the freezing of small liquid droplets and/or from the deposition of water vapor onto solid particles (called ice nucleating particles, INPs). Aircraft soot particles are thought to be efficient INPs for cirrus-cloud formation, therefore potentially disturbing the cirrus cloud coverage, resulting in a modified cloud radiative budget, hence affecting climate. To date, the ice-nucleating abilities (INAs) of aircraft soot have not been quantified partly because of the challenge to sample such particles behind a turbine engine. In this work, we present a series of experiments conducted at the aircraft engine test cell of SR Technics at Zurich airport, aiming at quantifying the INAs of aircraft turbine soot particles. Exhaust from commercial turbofan engines was sampled using a traversable probe within 1.5 m downstream of the exhaust nozzle over a range over power levels from medium to high thrust. The exhaust sample was drawn through trace-heated lines and a series of driers into a stirred stainless steel tank, allowing the coagulation of the particles, similar to that thought to occur in the restricted volume between aircraft wingtip vortices. The stainless steel tank also acts as a reservoir for the rest of the ice nucleation experiment. The coagulated particles were then size-selected according to their electrical mobility diameters in all experiments and injected into a cloud chamber where they experienced cirrus-relevant temperature (T < -40 °C) and relative humidity (RHice > 100%) conditions, allowing them to form ice crystals. Together with the inline particle size and mass distribution measurements, the fraction of soot particles forming ice crystals at different RHice levels has been measured. A catalytic stripper operating at 350°C removing volatile material and sulfur was used upstream of the cloud chamber, helping to infer the effect of the mixing state on the soot INAs. In parallel, soot samples were collected for additional offline measurements. Microscopy and gas adsorption techniques were used to characterize the morphology of the soot particles (e.g., primary particle size, pore size distribution) as well as their surface properties (e.g., water affinity, organic/inorganic content) which are known to be critical parameters for the freezing mechanism of soot particles in the cirrus regime. Preliminary results show that samples after the conditioning with the catalytic stripper are more active INPs than the unstripped, suggesting that mixing state and organic/sulfur content could be important for determining the role of aircraft soot as INPs in the upper troposphere.
Nitryl chloride (ClNO2), a precursor to highly reactive chlorine radicals and a reservoir for nitrogen dioxide (NO2), is formed from the reaction of chloride with N2O5, which has a longer atmospher...
The fifth version of the Emission Database for Global Atmospheric Research (EDGAR 5.0) provides an impressive inventory of various pollutants. Pollutants from different emission sectors are available with daily, monthly and yearly temporal profiles at a high global resolution of 0.1°×0.1°. Although this resolution has been sufficient for regional air quality studies, the emissions appeared to be too coarse for local air quality studies in areas with complex topography. With Switzerland as a case study, we present our approach for downscaling EDGAR emission data to a much finer resolution of 0.02°×0.02° with the aim of modelling local air quality. We downscaled the EDGAR emissions using a combination of GIS tools including QGIS, ArcGIS, and a series of python scripts. We obtained the surface coverage of different land use features within the defined EDGAR emission sectors from Open Street Map (OSM) using the QuickOSM tool in QGIS. With the calculated local surface area coverage of the emissions sectors, we downscaled the EDGAR inventory data within ArcGIS using a set of developed Arcpy script tools. The outcome was a much finer resolved emission dataset which we fed into the WRF-CHEM air quality model within a pilot project. A comparison of the modelled pollutant concentrations using the two datasets (original EDGAR data and the downscaled data) shows an improved agreement between the downscaled dataset and the measurement data. Studies investigating the impact of urbanization, land use change or traffic pattern on air quality may benefit from our downscaling solution, which, thanks to the global coverage of OSM, can be globally applied.
The reaction of ozone with sea-salt derived bromide is relevant for marine boundary layer atmospheric chemistry. The oxidation of bromide by ozone is enhanced at aqueous interfaces. Ocean surface water and sea spray aerosol are enriched in organic compounds, which may also have a significant effect on this reaction at the interface. Here, we assess the surface propensity of cationic tetrabutylammonium at the aqueous liquid-vapor interface by liquid microjet X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) and the effect of this surfactant on ozone uptake to aqueous bromide solutions. The results clearly indicate that the positively charged nitrogen group in tetrabutylammonium (TBA), along with its surface activity, leads to an enhanced interfacial concentration of both bromide and the bromide ozonide reaction intermediate. In parallel, off-line kinetic experiments for the same system demonstrate a strongly enhanced ozone loss rate in the presence of TBA, which is attributed to an enhanced surface reaction rate. We used liquid jet XPS to obtain detailed chemical composition information from the aqueous-solution-vapor interface of mixed aqueous solutions containing bromide or bromide and chloride with and without TBA surfactant. Core level spectra of Br 3d, C 1s, Cl 2p, N 1s, and O 1s were used for this comparison. A model was developed to account for the attenuation of photoelectrons by the carbon-rich layer established by the TBA surfactant. We observed that the interfacial density of bromide is increased by an order of magnitude in solutions with TBA. The salting-out of TBA in the presence of 0.55 M sodium chloride is apparent. The increased interfacial bromide density can be rationalized by the association constants for bromide and chloride to form ion-pairs with TBA. Still, the interfacial reactivity is not increasing simply proportionally with the increasing interfacial bromide concentration in response to the presence of TBA. The steady state concentration of the bromide ozonide intermediate increases by a smaller degree, and the lifetime of the intermediate is 1 order of magnitude longer in the presence of TBA. Thus, the influence of cationic surfactants on the reactivity of bromide depends on the details of the complex environment at the interface.
Earth's snow cover is very dynamic on diurnal timescales. The changes to the snow structure during this metamorphism have wide-ranging impacts on processes such as avalanche formation and on the capacity of surface snow to exchange trace gases with the atmosphere. Here, we investigate the influence of dry metamorphism, which involves fluxes of water vapour, on the chemical reactivity of bromide in the snow. To this end, the heterogeneous reactive loss of ozone in the dark at a concentration of 5×1012–6×1012 molec. cm−3 is investigated in artificial, shock-frozen snow samples doped with 6.2 µM sodium bromide and with varying metamorphism history. The oxidation of bromide in snow is one reaction initiating polar bromine releases and ozone depletion. We find that the heterogeneous reactivity of bromide is completely absent from the air–ice interface in snow after 12 d of temperature gradient metamorphism, and we suggest that the burial of non-volatile bromide salts occurs when the snow matrix is restructuring during metamorphism. Impacts on polar atmospheric chemistry are discussed.