Although Oparin used coacervate droplets from two or more types of polymer to model the first cell, he hypothesized homacervation from protein, consistent with Pasteur and Darwin. Herrera made two amino acids and numerous cell-like structures (''sulfobes'') in the laboratory, which probably arose from intermediate polymers. Our experiments have conformed with a homoacervation of thermal proteinoid, in which amino acid sequences are determined by the reacting amino acids themselves. All proteinoids that have been tested assemble themselves alone in water to protocells. The protocells have characteristics of life defined by Webster's Dictionary: metabolism, growth, reproduction and response to stimuli in the environment. The protocells are able also to evolve to more modern cells including the initiation of a nucleic acid coding system.

Recent reports suggest that the ribosome retains considerable peptidyl transferase activity even when much of the protein of the ribosome is removed and further suggests that rRNA may be the peptidyl transferase. The work here suggests that the AMP residue at the 3' terminus of each tRNA has some catalytic activity both in the esterification reaction and in forming a pseudopeptide, AcGly, and further suggests that whatever peptidyl transferase is, it finds a cooperative substrate in the aminoacyl-AMP at the 3' terminus of tRNA.

Data from the literature and new data presented here suggest that the genetic system (coding and protein synthesis) is based on relationships of character and structure between amino acids and nucleic acids. Character relationships seem to be anticodonic and structurally the greatest preferences are seen between the heteropair, l-amino acids and d-ribose nucleic acids. However, living systems using the other heteropair must have been equally likely. Homopairing (l-l and d-d) in living systems seems unlikely. Awareness of the heterocoupling of steric forms narrows somewhat the problem of understanding the origin of chirality.

We recently reported that esterification of 5'-AMP with N-acetyl amino acids proceeds with a preference for D-amino acids, and the D/L ratio in products declines as the hydrophobicity of the amino acid declines. Using one amino acid, Ac-Val, we now show that esterification of all four nucleotides proceeds with a preference for the D-isomer and the preference declines as the hydrophobicity of the nucleotide declines. So, in both types of experiments, the preferences seem determined by hydrophobic interactions.

Procedures for the formation of aminoacyl esters of monoribonucleotides with aminoacyl imidazolides were first reported by Gottikhet al. and summarized in 1970. This reaction has been widely used by us and numbers of other workers as a convenient means of preparing aminoacyl esters of nucleotides. We have previously reported that, under conditions of excess imidazolide, large amounts of bis 2′, 3′ esters are formed in addition to the monoesters, (Laceyet al., 1991). However, to our knowledge, no one has reported that in addition to the esters, relatively large amounts of the mixed anhydride, with the amino acid carboxyl attached to the phosphate, are also formed at short reaction times. We report here on the relative amounts of anhydride and esters formed in this reaction of racemic mixtures of eleven N-acetyl amino acid imidazolides with 5′-AMP and discuss the relevance of the findings to the origin of protein synthesis.

This article is an update of our earlier review (Lacey and Mullins, 1983) in this journal on the origin of the genetic code and the process of protein synthesis. It is our intent to discuss only experimental evidence published since then although there is the necessity to mention the old enough to place the new in context. We do not include theoretical nor hypothetical treatments of the code or protein synthesis. Relevant data regarding the evolution of tRNAs and the recognition of tRNAs by aminoacyl-tRNA-synthetases are discussed. Our present belief is that the code arose based on a core of early assignments which were made on a physico-chemical and anticodonic basis and this was expanded with new assignments later. These late assignments do not necessarily show an amino acid-anticodon relatedness. In spite of the fact that most data suggest a code origin based on amino acid-anticodon relationships, some new data suggesting preferential binding of Arg to its codons are discussed. While information regarding coding is not increasing very rapidly, information regarding the basic chemistry of the process of protein synthesis has increased significantly, principally relating to aminoacylation of mono- and polyribonucleotides. Included in those studies are several which show stereoselective reactions of L-amino acids with nucleotides having D-sugars. Hydrophobic interactions definitely play a role in the preferences which have been observed.

It is generally true that evolving systems begin simply and become more complex in the evolutionary process. For those who try to understand the origin of a biochemical system, what is required is the development of an idea as to what simpler system preceeded the present one. Here we present an hypotheis that a universal tRNA molecule, capable of reading many codons may have preceeded the appearance of individual tRNAs. Evidence seems to suggest that this molecule may have been derived from a common ancestor of the contemporary 5S rRNAs and tRNAs.

We describe experiments here which show that chemical esterification of 5′-adenylic acid (5′-AMP) withN-acetylD-orL-phenylalanine (Ac-D- or Ac-L-Phe) imidazolide occurs principally, if not exclusively, at the 2′ position. Furthermore, in experiments with the formation of the 2′–3′ diester with butyric acid andN-acetyl glycine (Ac-Gly), we found the second esterification was also predominantly at the 2′ position. This means that mixed diesters can be predictably prepared with the positions of the substituents known. The results are consistent with a model for the preferential catalytic synthesis ofL-based peptides via a 2′–3′ diester intermediate of purine monoribonucleotides.

This minireview is a summary of the basic concepts and pieces of experimental evidence supporting a hypothesis that suggests a mechanism whereby purine monoribonucleotides havingd-ribose may be able to preferentially catalyze the synthesis ofl-amino acid peptides. The proposed mechanism involves a 2′–3′ diaminoacyl intermediate and the preference accrues from several factors that favor thel-isomer, principally for hydrophobic amino acids. Although the hypothesis has not been fully tested, some crucial evidence has been published. Other pieces of evidence are now being submitted or are in press for publication and still other experiments, principally on the step of peptide bond formation, are in the process of being carried out. The purpose of a review at this point is to present the hypothesis to the scientific community in hopes of generating discussion, suggestions, and evaluation by other workers. Should the hypothesis prove correct, it may represent the most primitive and fundamental relationship between the nucleic acid and protein systems. In addition, it would represent another important example of the catalytic ability of RNA.

A model for the origin of protein synthesis. The essential features of the model are that 5'-AMP and perhaps other monoribonucleotides can serve as catalysts for the selective synthesis of L-based peptides. A unique set of characteristics of 5'-AMP is responsible for the selective catalysts and these characteristics are described in detail. The model involves the formation of diesters as intermediates and selectivity for use of the L-isomer occurs principally at the step of forming the diester. However, in the formation of acetyl phenylalanine-AMP monoester there is a selectivity for esterification by the D-isomer. Data showing this selectivity is presented. This selectivity for D-isomer disappears after the first step. The identity was confirmed of all four of possible diesters of acetyl-D- and -L phenylaline with 5'-AMP by nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR). The data using flourescence and NMR show the Trp ring can associate with the adenine ring more strongly when the D-isomer is in the 2' position than it can when in the 3' position. These same data also suggest a molecular mechanisim for the faster esterificaton of 5'-AMP by acetyl-D-phenylaline. Some new data is also presented on the possible structure of the 2' isomer of acetyl-D-tryptophan-AMP monoester. The HPLC elution times of all four possible acetyl diphenylalanine esters of 5'-AMP were studied, these peptidyl esters will be products in the studies of peptide formation on the ribose of 5'-AMP. Other studies were on the rate of synthesis and the identity of the product when producing 3'Ac-Phe-2'tBOC-Phe-AMP diester. HPLC purification and identification of this product were accomplished.

Amino acids esterified to the ribose group of 5'-adenylic acid (AMP) constantly migrate between the 2' and 3' positions of the ribose at a rate of several times per second, which is slower than the rate of peptide-bond synthesis (15-20 per sec). Because the contemporary protein-synthesizing system only incorporates amino acids into protein when they are at the 3' position of the AMP at the terminus of tRNA, the value of the equilibrium constant relative to the 2' and 3' positions is of considerable interest. Differences between D and L isomers in this regard might be especially revealing. We have used N-acetylaminoacyl esters of AMP as models for the 3' terminus of tRNA and find that glycine and the L amino acids consistently distribute predominantly to the 3' position (approximately equal to 67% 3', approximately equal to 33% 2'), but D amino acids distribute to that position generally to a lesser extent and in a manner inversely related to the hydrophobicity of the amino acid side chain. This consistency of the L amino acid preference for the 3' position, combined with the inconsistency of the D amino acid preference, may be one reason for the origin of our contemporary protein-synthesizing system, which forms the peptide bond preferentially with L amino acids and only when they are in the 3' position of the ribose moiety of the AMP residue at the 3' terminus of every tRNA.

We have continued our program aimed at understanding the origin and evolution of the genetic code and the process of protein synthesis by comparing the rates of esterification of 5′-AMP by a series of hydrophobic N-acetylamino acids. The reaction clearly shows differences in reaction rate (AcPhe>AcLeu>AcVal>AcIle) among the amino acids having A as middle letter of their anticodons. However, there were no significant differences in reaction rate between AcLeu, AcNorleu, and Ac-α-aminobutyric acid, and AcGly reacted faster than all of these and AcPhe. Consequently, this simple reaction with AMP can distinguish only among those amino acids that actually have A as the middle anticodonic nucleotide. The relevance of these studies to the origins of the process of protein synthesis and of the genetic code is discussed in conjunction with results from other studies of a similar nature.

Cellular organisms store information as sequences of nucleotides in double stranded DNA. This information is useless unless it can be converted into the active molecular species, protein. This is done in contemporary creatures first by transcription of one strand to give a complementary strand of mRNA. The sequence of nucleotides is then translated into a specific sequence of amino acids in a protein. Translation is made possible by a genetic coding system in which a sequence of three nucleotides codes for a specific amino acid. The origin and evolution of any chemical system can be understood through elucidation of the properties of the chemical entities which make up the system. There is an underlying logic to the coding system revealed by a correlation of the hydrophobicities of amino acids and their anticodonic nucleotides (i.e., the complement of the codon). Its importance lies in the fact that every amino acid going into protein synthesis must first be activated. This is universally accomplished with ATP. Past studies have concentrated on the chemistry of the adenylates, but more recently we have found, through the use of NMR, that we can observe intramolecular interactions even at low concentrations, between amino acid side chains and nucleotide base rings in these adenylates. The use of this type of compound thus affords a novel way of elucidating the manner in which amino acids and nucleotides interact with each other. In aqueous solution, when a hydrophobic amino acid is attached to the most hydrophobic nucleotide, AMP, a hydrophobic interaction takes place between the amino acid side chain and the adenine ring. The studies to be reported concern these hydrophobic interactions.

The genetic code appears to be a logic matrix in which, generally speaking, there is a correlation between the hydrophobicities of amino acids and their anticodonic nucleotides. There are several exceptions to this generality, however, and using previous data on hydrophobicity and binding constants, coupled with new data on reaction rates, we rationalize several of the anticodonic assignments.

Enthalpies (ΔH‡) and entropies (ΔS‡) of activation for the reaction of 18 N′-hydroxysuccinimide esters of N-protected proteinaceous amino acids with p-anisidine were measured and free enthalpies of activation (ΔG‡) at 25°C were calculated on this basis. A regular correlation between ΔG‡s and the corresponding amino acid codons was found. To obtain this correlation all the codons had to be arranged in a closed ring in which the consecutive codons were connected by one-step mutational changes. One-step mutations appeared as a regular series: 2,3,3,3,1,3,3,3,1,3,3,3,1,3,3,3,2,3,3,3. (the numbers denote a codon position in which a change took place). There were three such ‘one-step mutation periods’ in the ring, each containing 20 codons (in each block of 16 codons with A, U and C, in the central position and 4 codons containing G in the central position). The end of the third period (UG) and the beginning of the first period were bridged by the four codons of glycine with G in the second position. The values of ΔG‡ change similarly in each period, increasing upon approaching Lys, Pro, and Ile. The periodical relation between the chemical reactivities of the coded amino acids (reflected by ΔG‡s) and the structure of their codons could be of importance for the origin of the genetic code i.e. for selection of proper codons for the definite amino acids.

All earthly creatures use only L-amino acids in template directed protein synthesis. The reason for this exclusive use of the L-isomer is not yet apparent, although recent experiments by Usher and his colleagues have shown some stereoselctivity in the aminoacylation of di- and polynucleotides [1–3]. We have separately reported on intramolecular interactions between hydrophobic amino acid side chains and the adenine ring in aminoacyl adenylates [4]. There was a preferential association of Phe > Leu = Ile > Val with the adenine in these studies, but we made no attempts to address the question of D, L selectivity. Recently, in1H NMR studies of N-acetylphenylalanyl adenylate anhydride, we noticed evidence that both D- and L-isomers of the amino acid were present and, furthermore, that one isomer seemed to be associating with the adenine ring more strongly than the other. Using HPLC, we have separated the two diastereoisomers and have enzymatically determined that the isomer which associates more strongly is the biologically important one, the L-isomer. We present those studies here and discuss the evolutionary significance of this finding.