Objective: To study sural nerve biopsy utility based on different histopathologic techniques. Background: Nerve biopsies in select patients assist neuropathy diagnosis. Systematic study of their value to inform and alter treatment recommendations quantifying the value of separate histologic preparations is lacking in evidence-based practice. Design/Methods: Consecutive sural nerve biopsies (50 internal and 50 external referrals) were reviewed. Standard histological preparations plus graded teased nerve fibres (GTNF), immunohistochemistry, and epoxy-semithin morphometric analysis were studied. Nerve fibre and interstitial abnormalities were scored for each preparation by three examiners masked to case identification. Multivariate modeling was used to inform on the best combination of tests vs a gold standard of the full biopsy report plus morphometric analysis. Resulting clinicopathological diagnosis and treatment recommendations were reviewed. Results: Paraffin-stained sections best recognized interstitial abnormalities: Epineurial inflammation (n=59); vasculitis with vessel wall destruction (n=14); amyloidosis (n=2); and noncaseating granuloma (n=1). Vasculitic neuropathy associated with GTNF axonal degeneration (79%) with OR 3.8, 95%CI [1.001, 14.7], p=0.04, not significantly seen with the other preparations. Teased fibre abnormalities correlated with clinicopathologic diagnosis in demyelinated fibers in chronic inflammatory demyelinating polyradiculoneuropathy, 80% (8/10); amyloidosis, 50% (1/2); adult-onset polyglucosan disease 100% (1/1). GTNF and paraffin stains significantly correlated with fibre density determined by morphometric analysis (GTNF: OR 9.9, p<0.0001, paraffin: OR 3.8, p=0.03), not significant with semithin epoxy: OR 1.1, p=0.90, or immunohistochemistry: OR 2.4, p=0.18). GTNF combined with paraffin sections had the highest accuracy for predicting clinicopathologic diagnosis and fibre density with 0.86 C-stat prediction versus morphometric analysis. Among internal cases sural biopsy aided clinicopathologic diagnosis: immunotherapy initiation (44%); reduced immunotherapy (18%); and escalated immunotherapy (8%). Conclusions: Sural nerve biopsy have high diagnostic utility frequently altering treatment recommendations in select patients. Paraffin stains combined with GTNF provide highest diagnostic utility, confidence, inter-rater reliability, and accuracy for diagnosis. Immunostains and epoxy sections have focused utility. Disclosure: Dr. Soontrapa has nothing to disclose. Dr. Dyck has nothing to disclose. Dr. Dyck has received personal compensation in the range of $500-$4,999 for serving as a Consultant for Akcea/Ionis. JaNean Engelstad has nothing to disclose. An immediate family member of Jenny Davies has received personal compensation for serving as an employee of IBM. An immediate family member of Jenny Davies has stock in IBM. An immediate family member of Jenny Davies has stock in Kyndryl. Dr. Shelly has nothing to disclose. Mr. Harmsen has nothing to disclose. Dr. Mandrekar has nothing to disclose. Robert Spinner has received personal compensation for serving as an employee of Mayo Clinic. Cris M. Ida, 4790 has nothing to disclose. Dr. Klein has a non-compensated relationship as a Klein with Neurology Journal that is relevant to AAN interests or activities.
Background and AimsComprehensive study of sural nerve biopsy utility based on individual histopathologic preparations is lacking. We aimed to quantify the value of different histologic preparations in diagnosis. MethodsOne hundred consecutive sural nerves were studied by standard histological preparations plus graded teased nerve fibers (GTNF), immunohistochemistry, and epoxy-semithin morphometry. Three examiners scored the individual preparations separately by a questionnaire of neuropathic and interstitial abnormalities, masked to the biopsy number, versus a gold-standard of all preparations. Multivariate modeling was utilized to determine best approach versus the gold-standard. ResultsHighest confidence (range 8-9 of 10) and inter-rater reliability (99%) for fiber abnormalities came from GTNF, and interstitial abnormalities from paraffin stains (range 7-8, 99%). Vasculitic neuropathy associated with GTNF axonal degeneration (moderate to severe 79%) with OR 3.8, 95% CI (1.001-14.7), p = .04, but not significantly with the other preparations. Clinicopathologic diagnoses associated with teased fiber abnormalities in chronic inflammatory demyelinating polyradiculoneuropathy, 80% (8/10); amyloidosis, 50% (1/2); adult-onset polyglucosan disease 100% (1/1). GTNF and paraffin stains significantly correlated with fiber density determined by morphometric analysis (GTNF: OR 9.9, p < .0001, paraffin: OR 3.8, p = .03). GTNF combined with paraffin sections had highest accuracy for clinicopathologic diagnoses and fiber density with 0.86 C-stat prediction versus morphometric analysis. Pathological results lead to initiation or changes of immunotherapy in 70% (35/50; initiation n = 22, reduction n = 9, escalation n = 4) with the remaining having alternative intervention or no change. InterpretationNerve biopsy paraffin stains combined with GTNF have highest diagnostic utility, confidence, inter-rater reliability, improving accuracy for a pathologic diagnosis aiding treatment recommendations. Immunostains and epoxy preparations are also demonstrated useful supporting consensus guidelines. This study provides class II evidence for individual nerve preparation utility.
INTRODUCTION/AIMS:In the Diabetes Control and Complications Trial (DCCT), the minimal nerve conduction (NC) criterion for diabetic sensorimotor polyneuropathy (DSPN) was abnormality of NC in more than one peripheral nerve without specifying the attributes of NCs to be evaluated. In the present study, we assess individual and composite scores of NCs meeting the DCCT criterion and signs for improved diagnosis and assessment of DSPN severity. METHODS:Evaluated were 13 attributes and 6 composite NC scores and signs and symptoms in 395 healthy subjects (HS) and 388 persons with diabetes (DM). RESULTS:Percent abnormality between subjects with DM and HS was remarkably different among individual attributes and the six composite NC scores. For diagnosis of DSPN using the DCCT criterion, assessment of conduction velocities (CVs) and distal latencies (DLs) provided sensitive diagnoses of DSPN. NC amplitudes provided stronger measures of severity. In studied cohorts, DSPN was staged: N0, no NC abnormality using NC score 2 (CVs and DLs), 60.0%; N1, NC abnormality only, 18.4%; N2, NC abnormality and signs of feet or legs, 16.3%; and N3, NC abnormality and signs of thighs, 5.3%. DISCUSSION:For sensitive and standard diagnosis of DSPN using the DCCT NC criterion, specifically defined composite scores of CVs and DLs, e.g., score 2, is recommended. A composite score of amplitudes, e.g., score 4, provides a stronger measure of neuropathy severity. Also, provided are HS reference values of evaluated attributes of NCs and estimates of staged severity of DSPN of mid North American DM cohorts.
Variable differences of nerve conduction amplitudes vs velocities and distal latencies (DLs) of healthy subjects assessed in ethnic cohorts. Introduction/Aims The variables affecting reference compound muscle (CMAP) and sensory nerve action potential (SNAP) amplitudes as compared to ones affecting conduction velocities and DLs have not been adequately evaluated in previous studies. In this report, this subject is studied in healthy subject cohorts mainly of Northern European extraction, Northern Plains Indians, and Latinos. Methods Nineteen variables and 18 attributes of nerve conductions (NCs) were assessed using highly standard testing conditions and techniques. Classification and Regression Tree analyses were used to assess variable differences among amplitudes, conduction velocities, and DLs. Results The most important variable affecting CMAP and SNAP amplitudes was age. For conduction velocities (CVs) and DLs, the variables were height, ethnic cohort, and age. Discussion The variables affecting attributes of NCs were similar for the three ethnic cohorts evaluated. The differences of variables affecting amplitudes compared to CVs and DLs need to be taken into account in interpretation of NC results and in setting reference limits for use in medical practice, epidemiology surveys, and therapeutic trials. Scores of CMAP and SNAP amplitudes are suitable measures of sensorimotor polyneuropathy severity, whereas conduction velocities and DLs reflect physiologic/pathologic abnormality of nerve fibers.
OBJECTIVE:To evaluate the associated diseases, polyneuropathy correlates, and risk covariates of neuropathic plantar ulcers (PUs) and neuropathic arthropathies (NAs).DESIGN:The authors conducted a retrospective, observational study over 3.5 years of 69 patients with neuropathy, NA, or PU seen in a wound clinic who also had a comprehensive neurologic evaluation and neurophysiologic testing. Comparisons were made to a population representative cohort of patients with diabetes mellitus (DM; n = 259).RESULTS:Of the 69 wound clinic patients, 32 had PUs, 14 had NAs, and 23 had both. Of the 61 adequately assessed patients, 37 (61%) had DM, 22 (36%) had no known associated disease, and 2 (3%) had hereditary sensory and autonomic neuropathy. Of the 37 patients with DM, 35 had distal polyneuropathy, and 2 did not. In 22 patients with chronic idiopathic axonal polyneuropathy, 20 had distal polyneuropathy.CONCLUSIONS:Although DM was the disease most commonly associated with PUs and NAs, chronic hyperglycemia may not have been the major underlying risk factor. The major risk covariates are sensation loss from polyneuropathy, old age, obesity, repetitive foot injury, and inadequate foot care or treatment. Physicians and other healthcare providers can help by identifying patients at risk and instituting measures such as adequate foot care to decrease these risks.
ABSTRACTIntroduction: For sequential and somatotopic assessment of small fiber neuropathy, heat pain (HP) tests of hypoalgesia might be used instead of decreased counts of epidermal nerve fibers (ENFs), but then healthy subject reference values of HP thresholds are needed. Methods: Using the Computer Assisted Sensation Evaluator IVc system, HP thresholds of hypoalgesia were estimated for 10 unilateral sites and counts of ENFs for 4 of them in healthy subjects. Results: In healthy subjects, small but statistically significant differences of both HP thresholds of hypoalgesia and counts of ENFs were observed among tested sites. Significant correlations between HP thresholds and counts of ENFs were not found. Discussion: For the studied somatotopic sites, we provide ≥95th and ≥99th percentile reference limits for HP 0.5 and 5 of 1–10 HP thresholds of hypoalgesia and decreased counts of ENFs at ≤5th and ≤1st percentile levels. Muscle Nerve 58: 509–516, 2018
A system to evaluate and follow morphologic changes in number, size, shape and other histological measurements of transverse myelinated fiber profiles in nerves and fiber tracts has proven to be a useful analysis tool. Applications of the system include the enumeration and sizing of peripheral nerves and central nervous system tracts for the morphologic study of development, aging, regeneration, neurotoxicity, pathologic conditions, also, the morphometric assessment of intra-epidermal nerve fiber densities, IENFD. The primary aim of the system is to provide both an operator-interactive and automated method for the detection, sizing and measurement of myelinated fibers. The system, Imaging System for Nerve Morphometry, was shown, to provide the specific functionality required to perform morphometric studies of peripheral nerve, compared to commercial systems which perform a more general estimate of histological features. The system consists of the tissue preparation process, a video camera-ready microscope capable of various resolutions, and a computer system for image acquisition, data analysis, data display and statistical analysis. The morphometric measurements obtained from this system have been used for quality control by clinical nerve pathologists, in the study of human peripheral neuropathies and the clinical assessment of IENFDs. In assessment of test retest reproducibility of periodically-sampled nerves, high degrees of reproducibility were achieved for most morphometric measurements.
ABSTRACTIntroductionPolyneuropathy signs (Neuropathy Impairment Score, NIS), neurophysiologic tests (m+7Ionis), disability, and health scores were assessed in baseline evaluations of 100 patients entered into an oligonucleotide familial amyloidotic polyneuropathy (FAP) trial.MethodsWe assessed: (1) Proficiency of grading neurologic signs and correlation with neurophysiologic tests, and (2) clinometric performance of modified NIS+7 neurophysiologic tests (mNIS+7Ionis) and its subscores and correlation with disability and health scores.ResultsThe mNIS+7Ionis sensitively detected, characterized, and broadly scaled diverse polyneuropathy impairments. Polyneuropathy signs (NIS and subscores) correlated with neurophysiology tests, disability, and health scores. Smart Somatotopic Quantitative Sensation Testing of heat as pain 5 provided a needed measure of small fiber involvement not adequately assessed by other tests.ConclusionsSpecially trained neurologists accurately assessed neuropathy signs as compared to referenced neurophysiologic tests. The score, mNIS+7Ionis, broadly detected, characterized, and scaled polyneuropathy abnormality in FAP, which correlated with disability and health scores. Muscle Nerve 56: 901–911, 2017
Objective: Recognizing that wild type transthyretin (TTR) cardiomyopathy may be associated with polyneuropathy, we have begun a systematic study of the association between "senile cardiomyopathy" and peripheral polyneuropathy. Background: Mutant TTR is an important cause of familial amyloidotic polyneuropathy [FAP]. More than 100 point mutations of TTR cause polyneuropathy [FAP], cardiomyopathy, and other organ involvement. Orthotopic liver transplantation and protein stabilizing drugs are known to slow FAP disease progression. Oligonucleotide therapies which block the formation of TTR [Isis, Inc. and Alnylam, Inc.] are undergoing phase 2 and 3 pharmaceutical trials. In research of FAP patients it has become known that both mutant and wild transthyretin are constituents in amyloid deposits. Additionally, wild type TTR is known to be implicated in development of "senile cardiomyopathy." Methods: Patients with wild type TTR causing senile cardiomyopathy were screened for peripheral neuropathy by use of clinical history and neurological examination, neurophysiological tests and skin and nerve biopsies. Results: In the first two patients studied we have found wild type transthyretin deposits in nerve or in skin biopsies, making it likely that polyneuropathy is due to wild type TTR amyloid deposition. Conclusion: By the time of the AAN meeting, we plan to have evaluated more than 25 patients with TTR cardiomyopathy looking for coexisting peripheral neuropathy. We will report on the neurologic examination findings [neuropathy impairment score], Smart Somatotopic QSTing, Nerve Conduction studies, autonomic Tests, nerve or skin biopsies and molecular genetic studies. Our study will answer whether senile cardiomyopathy due to wild TTR is associated with polyneuropathy and whether the associated polyneuropathy is due to "wild" TTR.
BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES:The association between prediabetes and distal polyneuropathy (DPN) remains controversial. Here we test whether the prevalence of small fiber sensory distal polyneuropathy is increased in prediabetes.METHODS:Prospectively recruited cohorts of healthy subjects and those with prediabetes from Olmsted County, Minnesota, were assessed for positive neuropathic sensory symptoms, or pain symptoms characteristic of small fiber sensory DPN. Hyperalgesia and hypoalgesia were assessed by "smart" quantitative sensation testing (QST). The prevalence of symptoms and QST abnormalities were compared among the groups.RESULTS:There was no significant increase in the prevalence of positive neuropathic sensory or pain symptoms, nor of hyper- or hypoalgesia in the prediabetes group. There was an increased prevalence of hypoalgesia of the foot only in newly diagnosed diabetes.CONCLUSIONS:Based on positive sensory and pain symptoms and QSTs, we did not find an increase in small fiber sensory DPN in prediabetes. Recognizing that obesity and diabetes mellitus are implicated in macro- and microvessel complications, physicians should encourage healthy living and weight loss in patients with prediabetes. In medical practice, alternate causes should be excluded before concluding that small fiber sensory distal neuropathy is secondary to prediabetes.
ABSTRACT Intravenous immunoglobulin [IVIg], plasma exchange [PE], and corticosteroids are efficacious treatment in chronic inflammatory demyelinating polyneuropathy [CIDP]. IVIg is effective in multifocal motor neuropathy [MMN]. NIS, NIS‐weakness, sum scores of raw amplitudes of motor fiber (CMAPs) amplitudes, and Dyck/Rankin score provided reliable measures to detect and scale abnormality and reflect change; they are therefore ideal for office management of response‐based immunotherapy (R‐IRx) of CIDP. Using efficacious R‐IRx, a large early and late therapeutic response (≥ one‐fourth were in remission or had recovered) was demonstrated in CIDP. In MMN only an early improvement with late non‐significant worsening was observed. The difference in immunotherapy response supports a fundamental difference between CIDP (immune attack on Schwann cells and myelin) and MMN (attack on nodes of Ranvier and axons). Muscle Nerve 52: 488–497, 2015
Introduction: We assessed proficiency (accuracy and intra- and intertest reproducibility) of smart quantitative sensation tests (smart QSTs) in subjects without and with diabetic sensorimotor polyneuropathy (DSPN). Methods: Technologists from 3 medical centers using different but identical QSTs independently assessed 6 modalities of sensation of the foot (or leg) twice in patients without (n=6) and with (n=6) DSPN using smart computer assisted QSTs. Results: Low rates of test abnormalities were observed in health and high rates in DSPN. Very high intraclass correlations were obtained between continuous measures of QSTs and neuropathy signs, symptoms, or nerve conductions (NCs). No significant intra- or intertest differences were observed. Conclusions: These results provide proof of concept that smart QSTs provide accurate assessment of sensation loss without intra- or intertest differences useful for multicenter trials. Smart technology makes possible efficient testing of body surface area sensation loss in symmetric length-dependent sensorimotor polyneuropathies. Muscle Nerve49: 645-653, 2014
ABSTRACTIntroductionThe Cl. NPhys Trial 3 showed that attributes of nerve conduction (NC) were without significant intraobserver differences, although there were significant interobserver differences. Methods: Trial 4 tested whether use of written instructions and pretrial agreement on techniques and use of standard reference values, diagnostic percentile values, or broader categorization of abnormality could reduce significant interobserver disagreement and improve agreement among clinical neurophysiologists. Results: The Trial 4 modifications markedly decreased, but did not eliminate, significant interobserver differences of measured attributes of NC. Use of standard reference values and defined percentile values of abnormality decreased interobserver disagreement and improved agreement of judgment of abnormality among evaluators. Therefore, the same clinical neurophysiologist should perform repeat NCs of therapeutic trial patients. Conclusions: Differences in interobserver judgment of abnormality decrease with use of common standard reference values and a defined percentile level of abnormality, providing a rationale for their use in therapeutic trials and medical practice. Muscle Nerve 50: 900–908, 2014
ABSTRACTIntroductionThe aim of this study was to test the proficiency (accuracy among evaluators) of measured attributes of nerve conduction (NC).MethodsExpert clinical neurophysiologists, without instruction or consensus development, from 4 different medical centers, independently assessed 8 attributes of NC in 24 patients with diabetes mellitus (DM) on consecutive days.ResultsNo significant intraobserver differences between days 1 and 2 were found, but significant interobserver differences were seen. Use of standard reference values did not correct for these observed differences.ConclusionsInterobserver variability was attributed to differences in performance of NC. It was of sufficient magnitude that it is of concern for the conduct of therapeutic trials. To deal with interrater variability in therapeutic trials, the same electromyographers should perform all NC assessments of individual patients or, preferably, NC procedures should be more standardized. A further trial is needed to test whether such standardization would eliminate interobserver variability. Muscle Nerve 48: 369–374, 2013
OBJECTIVE To repeat the Clinical vs Neurophysiology (Cl vs N Phys) trial using "unequivocally abnormal" signs and symptoms (Trial 2) compared with the earlier trial (Trial 1), which used "usual" signs and symptoms. DESIGN Standard and referenced nerve conduction abnormalities were used in both Trials 1 and 2 as the standard criterion indicative of diabetic sensorimotor polyneuropathy. Physician proficiency (accuracy among evaluators) was compared between Trials 1 and 2. SETTING Academic medical centers in Canada, Denmark, England, and the United States. PARTICIPANTS Thirteen expert neuromuscular physicians. One expert was replaced in Trial 2. RESULTS The marked overreporting, especially of signs, in Trial 1 was avoided in Trial 2. Reproducibility of diagnosis between days 1 and 2 was significantly (P = .005) better in Trial 2. The correlation of the following clinical scores with composite nerve conduction measures spanning the range of normality and abnormality was improved in Trial 2: pinprick sensation (P = .03), decreased reflexes (P = .06), touch-pressure sensation (P = .06), and the sum of symptoms (P = .06). CONCLUSIONS The simple pretrial decision to use unequivocally abnormal signs and symptoms-taking age, sex, and physical variables into account-in making clinical judgments for the diagnosis of diabetic sensorimotor polyneuropathy (Trial 2) improves physician proficiency compared with use of usual elicitation of signs and symptoms (Trial 1); both compare to confirmed nerve conduction abnormality.
OBJECTIVE-To test whether diabetic polyneuropathies (DPNs), retinopathy, or nephropathy is more prevalent in subjects with impaired glycemia (IG) (abnormality of impaired fasting glucose [IFG], impaired glucose tolerance [IGT), or impaired HbA(1c) [IA1C] than in healthy subjects (non-IG).RESEARCH DESIGN AND METHODS-Matched IG and non-IG volunteers were randomly identified from population-based diagnostic and laboratory registries, restudied, and reclassified as non-IG (n = 150), IG (n = 174), or new diabetes (n = 218).RESULTS-Frequency (%) of DPN in non-IG, IG, and new diabetes was 3 (2.0%), 3 (1.7%), and 17 (7.8%) narrowly defined (no other cause for polyneuropathy) and 19 (12.7%), 22 (12.6%), and 38(17.4%) broadly defined. Mean and frequency distribution of composite scores of nerve conduction and quantitative sensation tests were not significantly different between IG and non-IG but were worse in new diabetes. Frequency of retinopathy and nephropathy was significantly increased only in new diabetes. In secondary analysis, small but significant increases in retinopathy and nephropathy were found in IGT, IFG, and IGT combined groups.CONCLUSIONS-In population studies of Olmsted County, Minnesota, inhabitants, prevalence of typical DPN, retinopathy, and nephropathy was significantly increased only in subjects with new diabetes-not in subjects with IG as defined by American Diabetes Association (ADA) criteria of abnormality of IFG,IGT, or IA1C. For atypical DPN, such an increase was not observed even in subjects with new diabetes. In medical practice, explanations other than IG should be sought for patients with atypical DPN (chronic idiopathic axonal polyneuropathy) who have IG.
OBJECTIVES:Our first objective was to explore the value of estimating 95% confidence intervals (CIs) of epidermal nerve fibers (ENFs)/mm for number of sections to be evaluated and for confidently judging normality or abnormality. Our second objective was to introduce a new continuous measure combining nerve conduction and ENFs/mm. METHODS:The 95% CI studies were performed on 1, 1-2, 1-3 - - - 1-10 serial skip sections of 3-mm punch biopsies of leg and thigh of 67 healthy subjects and 23 patients with diabetes mellitus. RESULTS:Variability of differences of ENFs/mm counts (and 95% CIs) from evaluation of 1, 1-2, 1-3 - - - 1-9 compared with 1-10 serial skip sections decreased progressively without a break point with increasing numbers of sections evaluated. Estimating 95% CIs as sections are evaluated can be used to judge how many sections are needed for adequate evaluation, i.e., only a few when counts and 95% CIs are well within the range of normality or abnormality and more when values are borderline. Also provided is a methodology to combine results of nerve conduction and ENFs/mm as continuous measures of normality or abnormality. CONCLUSION:Estimating 95% CIs of ENFs/mm is useful to judge how many sections should be evaluated to confidently declare counts to be normal or abnormal. Also introduced is a continuous measure of both large-fiber (nerve conduction) and small-fiber (ENFs/mm) normal structures/functions spanning the range of normality and abnormality for use in therapeutic trials.