The original Papineau technique described satisfactory results in treating infection-related pseudarthrosis and chronic osteomyelitis with chronic draining wounds. We described our experience in treating these soft tissue defects using the Papineau-irrigation technique. We retrospectively reviewed the records of patients that were treated with the Papineau-irrigation technique at UZ Leuven, Belgium, between January 2006 and January 2023. All surgical procedures were performed by one senior orthopedic surgeon. There were no exclusion criteria. There was successful healing of the soft tissue defect in 27 out of 32 patients with serial drip irrigation. Additional debridement was often necessary. The Papineau-irrigation technique may provide a useful alternative for treating fracture-related soft tissue defects. In addition, this technique is safe and feasible. Further comparative studies are necessary to validate its efficacy.
We report the results of 22 infected nonunions treated by radical resection and bone transport technique according to Ilizarov with a minimal follow-up period of 2 years. This series involves four fractures of the femur diaphysis, ten at tibial level, four defects of the knee and four of the upper limb. The mean length of the bone defect was 7.7 cm. The mean time from the transport procedure to frame removal was 14.5 months. In 15 cases the docking site was reviewed to refresh the bone ends at the end of the transport procedure, of which eight had a bone graft performed. Five refractures were noticed at the docking site in the nonrevised group and one in the other group. Two of them were treated conservatively and four with a new external fixator. Consolidation was achieved in all but two nonunions at the knee level, which means a succesrate of 91%. The infection could be eradicated in all 22 patients. A revision of the docking site at the end of the bone transport procedure with or without bone grafting is recommended.
OBJECTIVE:Osteoarthritis (OA) is a degenerative disabling joint disease affecting more than 10% of the adult population. No validated disease-modifying treatment is available. Joint distraction is a relatively new approach to the treatment of severe ankle OA. Short-term (3 years) clinical benefit has been proven, but long-term effects remain to be evaluated.METHODS:Patients with severe OA of the tibio-talar joint, who had been treated with Ilizarov joint distraction more than 7 years previously, were included. Pre-treatment data were obtained by retrospective analysis using questionnaires and patients' charts. Post-treatment assessments were undertaken using the same questionnaires and by physical examination. Three approaches were used and results were compared: the van Valburg score, the Ankle Osteoarthritis Scale (AOS), and a patient satisfaction questionnaire. Retrospectively and prospectively obtained data were available from eight patients for comparison.RESULTS:Twenty-five out of 27 patients with severe ankle OA treated with Ilizarov joint distraction could be traced. Appropriate retrospective data could not be obtained from three patients. Six out of the 22 patients (27%) were failures. In 16 patients (73%), significant improvement in all clinical parameters was observed using each of the three approaches. Good correlations were found between the results of the three methods of assessment and retrospectively obtained pre-treatment values were very similar to the prospective data.CONCLUSIONS:In 73% of the patients, significant clinical benefit from joint distraction of severe OA ankles was maintained for at least 7 years. There is, however, a need for further research to try and predict which patients will not respond to this unconventional form of major surgical intervention.
The authors point out the indications for lengthening of short amputation stumps. Referring to their own experience they discuss the problems and pitfalls related to this surgical procedure. Sufficient soft tissue coverage is the most important factor for a good outcome whereas limitation of adjacent joint function may have a detrimental effect on the clinical result.
J Shoulder Elbow Surg 2000;9:148-51.
Congenital tibial pseudarthrosis (CTP) remains one of the most challenging problems in paediatric orthopaedic surgery. With the abandonment of older grafting techniques in favor of vascularized fibular transplants or the Ilizarov method the final outcome has improved and made the prognosis for patients less cumbersome. Using the latter technique in 10 patients, a success rate of 90 % could be reached. Nevertheless, although solid healing occurs in most of the patients nowadays, this is often at the cost of multiple operations before a definite well united, equalized and normally aligned limb can be obtained.
structive treatment after upper limb tumor excision, only a few focus on the management and final outcome in cases of failure. This report describes Ilizarov’s segmental bone transport technique as a salvage procedure in a patient with collapse of an infected osteoarticular allograft of the distal humerus and proximal ulna. Failure caused by collapse and especially infection is well documented in the literature, with an infection frequency between 6% and 14% and failure up to 57%.1,3,4,7-9 The treatment of infected grafts still remains a problem but can be done with excision of infected tissue and reconstruction with bone transport procedures.
Die kongenitale Tibiapseudarthrose (congenital tibial pseudarthrosis, CTP) ist und bleibt eine der größten Herausforderungen der operativen Kinderorthopädie. Nachdem ältere Transplantationstechniken zugunsten von vaskularisierten Fibulatransplantaten und der Methode nach Ilisarov, aufgegeben wurden, haben sich die Ergebnisse verbessert und die Prognose der Patienten ist aussichtsreicher geworden. Mit der neuesten Technik konnte bei 10 Patienten eine Erfolgsrate von 90 % erreicht werden. Obwohl bei den meisten Patienten heutzutage eine solide Ausheilung erreicht werden kann, bedarf es meist mehrfacher Operationen, bevor eine sicher zusammengewachsene, gleichlange und anatomisch korrekte Extremität erreicht werden kann.
Although >80% of the mineral in mammalian bone is present in the collagen fibrils, limited information is available about factors that determine a proper deposition of mineral. This study investigates whether a specific collagen matrix is required for fibril mineralization. Calcifying callus from dog tibias was obtained at various times (3-21 weeks) after fracturing. At 3 weeks, hydroxylysine (Hyl) levels were almost twice as high as in control bone, gradually reaching normal levels at 21 weeks. The decrease in Hyl levels can only be the result of the formation of a new collagen network at the expense of the old one. The sum of the cross-links hydroxylysylpyridinoline (HP) and lysylpyridinoline (LP) in callus matched that of bone at all stages of maturation. However, the ratio HP/LP was 2.5-4.5 times higher in callus at 3-7 weeks than in normal bone and was normalized at 21 weeks. Some 40% of the collagen was nonmineralized at the early stages of healing, reaching control bone values (approximately 10%) at 21 weeks. In contrast, only a small increase in callus mineral content from 20.0 to 22.6 (% of dry tissue weight) from week 3 to 21 was seen, indicating that initially a large proportion of the mineral was deposited between, and not within, the fibrils. A strong relationship (r = 0.80) was found between the ratio HP/LP and fibril mineralization; the lower the HP/LP ratio, the more mineralized the fibrils were. Because the HP/LP ratio is believed to be the result of a specific packing of intrafibrillar collagen molecules, this study implies that mineralization of fibrils is facilitated by a specific orientation of collagen molecules in the fibrils.
The author reports the case of a sixteen year old young lady with heel shortening, due to a growth arrest of the calcaneal epiphysis, secondary to its septic involvement by a heel puncture. At the age of sixteen a lengthening according to Ilizarov's method was performed, using progressive distraction of an osteotomy of the calcaneal tuberosity. The result was satisfying with a cosmetical improvement, a painless function and a more comfortable shoe fitting.
OBJECTIVE:Osteoarthritis (OA) is a degenerative joint disease with an incidence exceeding 10% of the adult population. In end stages, OA can result in severe restriction of activity and consequent disability. For these severe cases of OA, no effective remedy is available yet. Joint distraction is a new experimental approach in treatment of OA. Studied in retrospect it appeared that this treatment results in prolonged clinical improvement in the case of ankle OA. Presently the results of a prospective two-year follow-up are given.METHODS:Patients with severe ankle OA, who were considered for joint fusion (arthrodesis), were treated with distraction, by use of an Ilizarov external ring fixator. Distraction was carried out for 3 months during which full weight bearing (walking) was allowed. Standardized clinical examination was conducted before and at yearly intervals after treatment, including physical examination, functional ability questionnaire, pain scale, joint mobility, and radiographic evaluation.RESULTS:More than two thirds of the patients improved significantly as shown by physical examination, functional ability questionnaires and pain scale; effects were progressive in the second year of follow-up. On average, joint mobility and radiographic joint space were preserved, whilst improvement was observed in a significant number of patients.DISCUSSION:Results of the present prospective study confirm the findings of the previous retrospective study and suggest that Ilizarov joint distraction is a promising treatment for severe ankle OA, at least delaying the need for a joint fusion. Considering the high prevalence of OA and the lack of a remedy for this disorder, Ilizarov joint distraction as a treatment for OA may have great medical, social and economic impact.
The process of fracture healing has been described in detail in many histological studies. Recent work has focused on the mechanisms by which growth and differentiation factors regulate the fracture healing process. Rapid progress in skeletal cellular and molecular biology has led to the identification of many signaling molecules associated with the formation of skeletal tissues, including members of the transforming growth factor-beta (TGF-beta) superfamily and the insulin-like growth factor (IGF) family. Increasing evidence indicates that they are critical regulators of cellular proliferation, differentiation, extracellular matrix biosynthesis and mineralization. Limb lengthening procedure (distraction osteogenesis) is a relevant model to investigate the in vivo correlation between mechanical stimulation and biological responses as the callus is stretched by a proper rate and rhythm of mechanical strain. This model also provides additional insights into the molecular and cellular events during bone fracture repair. TGF-beta 1 was significantly increased in both the distracted callus and the fracture callus. The increased level of TGF-beta 1, together with a low concentration of calcium and an enhanced level of collagen synthesis, was maintained in the distracted callus as long as mechanical strain was applied. Less mineralization is also associated with a low level of osteocalcin production. These observations provide further insights into the molecular basis for the cellular events during distraction osteogenesis.
The symmetry index (SI), as one of methods to evaluate gait pattern in patients with leg-length discrepancy (LLD), helps to estimate the acceptable range of inequality and to determine symmetry in the kinematic and kinetic data before and after a heel lift, although this parameter has a large standard deviation that undermines its accuracy. Thirty patients with LLD were studied by a motion-analysis system and a force plate. Joint motion of the lower extremity in the sagittal plane, back movement in the coronal plane, and three-dimensional ground-reaction forces (GRFs) were registered. From a linearregression analysis, a mean value of inequality of 2.33 cm (range, 2.12-2.54) was found to correspond to an acceptable gait symmetry. After a heel lift, the SI of the pelvic tilt at midstance and of the vertical GRF at initial contact increases significantly, but the SI of the medial GRF at terminal stance decreases. Patients with an inequality of a mean value of 0.51 cm determined by palpating bilaterally the top of the iliac crest (the TIC1 subgroup) showed a lesser value of the SI of the center of pressure in the forward direction during stance compared with the group with a mean value of inequality of 1.39 cm (the TIC2 subgroup). As a result of our findings, we conclude that the effect of the amount of correction by a heel lift on gait symmetry is unpredictable.
Ilizarov's method of monofocal compression was used in 30 humeri with a diaphyseal pseudarthrosis. Twenty-one patients had previous surgery but had loosening of the osteosynthesis material. Nine patients initially were treated with a hanging cast, resulting in interfragmentary distraction. Fourteen nonunions were hypertrophic, and 16 were atrophic, of which six were infected. A complete circular frame was used only in the first nine patients, whereas the remaining 21 patients were treated with the modified semicircular fixator. Union was obtained in all but two patients, with an average consolidation time of 4.5 months (range, 2.5-10 months). No patient required additional bone grafting. Apart from superficial pin tract infection seen in most of the patients, three had a minor temporary sensory neurologic problem. Four patients experienced a second fracture after removal of the fixator that required a second application of an Ilizarov frame. Although similar results with regard to union are reported after plate osteosynthesis, there was no radial nerve palsy or deep infection in this series, indicating that the treatment by the Ilizarov technique is associated with less complications. The authors' findings suggest that the Ilizarov method is a reliable treatment for humeral nonunions, even after multiple previous operations or in the event of infection.
This study investigates the biochemical changes in a canine tibia lengthening model in comparison with a nonlengthened osteotomy model. The lengthened and the osteotomized callus and a contralateral corresponding segment were analyzed for their mineralization profile, collagen content, osteocalcin, insulin‐like growth factor I (IGF‐I), and transforming growth factor β1 (TGF‐β1). Examinations of bone samples were performed using specimens excised at different time intervals (respectively at 3, 5, 7, 9, and 13 weeks postoperatively). Several serum parameters (alkaline phosphatase [ALP], osteocalcin, IGF‐I, and TGF‐β1) were also measured during the experimental period. A progressive increase in mineral parameters was noticed in both the lengthened and the osteotomized areas. A higher level of hydroxyproline and TGF‐β1 was observed in the lengthened area compared with the osteotomized area. IGF‐I showed a significant increase in both the lengthened and contralateral control area at the later stage of the experimental period in the lengthened group. In serum, a high level of TGF‐β1 and a progressively increasing osteocalcin concentration were observed in the lengthened dogs in comparison with the osteotomized dogs. Serum ALP was significantly increased in both models during the experimental period. Serum IGF‐I was increased in the lengthened models during the distraction period and decreased in the osteotomized models at the early stage of the experimental period. These results suggest that the mechanical strain induced by the Ilizarov distraction procedure stimulates osteoblast proliferation and promotes biosynthesis of bone extracellular matrix in distracted callus. Our data furthermore show that this process is different compared with normal fracture healing.
Biochemical changes in a canine bone-lengthening model were characterized 5 months after surgery. The mineral content and the total amount of EDTA-extractable noncollagenous proteins, insulin-like growth factor-I, and osteocalcin were determined for the lengthened callus, and a gradient density fractionation analysis of bone powder particles was performed, The results were compared with two other areas of the lengthened tibia and one region of the contralateral tibia. The mineral and osteocalcin contents showed significant decreases, whereas the hydroxyproline concentration was significantly increased, Neither the insulinlike growth factor-I content nor the concentration of EDTA-extractable proteins was significantly different in any of the examined regions.
Sixteen quadricepsplasties performed for severe extension contractures of the knee were reviewed. Preoperatively all cases showed a severe extension contracture with an average of 23 degrees flexion. Only two patients had more than 30 degrees flexion preoperatively. The average improvement in knee flexion at follow-up was 69 degrees with 11 (68.7%) patients achieving a final flexion of 90 degrees or more. In four cases there was a 15 degrees loss of terminal active extension. In one case a rapid recurrence of the contracture was seen during the initial postoperative weeks. One patient developed a deep infection, and another an acute compartment syndrome.
We reviewed 59 hips in 44 children with slipped capital femoral epiphysis (SCFE), all treated by in situ pinning. The average clinical and radiographic follow-up was 11.4 years. Fifty-three hips (90%) were rated as either excellent or good. Osteonecrosis or chondrolysis developed in five patients. Postoperative remodeling was noted, not only by a process of local resorption and apposition of bone, but also by correction of the disturbed anatomic axes, in proportion to the severity of the slip, together with global thickening of the femoral neck. We believe that the good long-term results after in situ pinning are the consequence of this important remodeling process.
Paget's disease of bone may cause progressive bowing of affected femurs and tibiae. Fractures or osteotomies in these patients technically are difficult to treat and may lead to delayed union or nonunion. The authors report their early results with the use of the Ilizarov external fixator to affix 3 corrective closing wedge osteotomies, 1 fracture, and 1 delayed union. Deformities were corrected fully during the surgery, with an option to correct remaining deformation progressively during the rest of treatment. Compression of the healing bone was applied to enhance osseous healing, when necessary. Three-dimensional control is possible, and the stability of the fixation is excellent in this structurally weak bone. Bony union was achieved without complications in all patients within 4 months.