We examine the spatial distributions of luminous blue variables (LBVs), B [ e ] supergiants, and Wolf–Rayet stars (WR) stars in the Large Magellanic Cloud (LMC) to clarify their relative ages, evolutionary states, and relationships. This survey employs a reference catalog that was not available for previous work, comprising more than 3900 of the LMC’s most luminous stars. Our analysis shows that LBVs, B [ e ] supergiants, and WRs have spatial distributions like normal stars with the same spectral types and luminosities. Most LBVs are not isolated, nor do they require binary or multiple status to explain their spatial relationship to other populations. There are two likely exceptions: one lower-luminosity LBV and one LBV candidate are relatively isolated and may have velocities that require additional acceleration. The B [ e ] supergiants are spatially and kinematically more dispersed than LBVs, suggesting that they belong to an older population. The most luminous early-type WNs are most closely associated with the evolved late O-type supergiants. The high luminosity late-WNs and WNh stars, however, are highly concentrated in the 30 Dor region, which biases the analysis. The less-luminous WNs and WCs are associated with a mix of evolved late-B, A-type, and yellow supergiants which may be in a post-red-supergiant phase. Spatial distributions of the less-luminous WN, WC, and WN3/O3 stars reinforce proposed evolutionary links among these subtypes. Our analysis also demonstrates the importance of using a comprehensive census, with reference populations clearly defined by spectral type and luminosity, and how small number statistics, especially when combined with spatial clustering, can invalidate some commonly cited statistical tests.
We review the observational evidence for the empirical upper luminosity limit in the Hertzsprung-Russell Diagram. We discuss its impact on our understanding of the evolution of the most massive stars, the importance of the high mass loss events that shape the upper limit, and the instabilities that may tigger the eruptions in stars close to their Eddington Limit.
The red hypergiant VY CMa is remarkable for its very visible record of high-mass-loss events observed over the range of wavelengths from the optical and infrared to the submillimeter region with Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array (ALMA). The SW Clump or SW knots are unique in the ejecta of VY CMa. Except for the central star, they are the brightest sources of dusty infrared emission in its complex ejecta. In this paper we combine the proper motions from the Hubble Space Telescope images, and infrared fluxes from 2 to 12 μ m with the ^12 CO images from ALMA to determine their ages and mass estimates. The SW knots were ejected more than 200 yr ago with an active period lasting about 30 yr, and with a total mass in the Clump > 2 × 10 ^−2 M _⊙ .
The red hypergiant VY CMa is famous for its very visible record of high mass loss events. Recent CO observations with ALMA revealed three previously unknown large scale outflows (Paper I). In this paper we use the CO maps to investigate the motions of a cluster of four clumps close to the star, not visible in the optical or infrared images. We present their proper motions measured from two epochs of ALMA images and determine the line of sight velocities of the gas in emission at the clumps. We estimate their masses and ages, or time since ejection, and conclude that all four were ejected during VY CMa's active period in the early 20th century. Together with two additional knots observed with HST, VY CMa experienced at least six massive outflows during a 30 year period with a total mass lost greater than 0.07 Msun. The position-velocity map of the ^12CO emission reveals previously unnoticed attributes of the older outer ejecta. In a very narrow range of Doppler velocities, ^12CO absorption and emission causes some of this outer material to be quite opaque. At those frequencies the inner structure is hidden and we see only emission from an extended outer region. This fact produces a conspicuous but illusory dark spot if one attempts to subtract the continuum in a normal way.
Hubble Space Telescope photometry of η Carinae spans 23 yr, including five spectroscopic events. The rapid brightening rate decreased after 2010, and the spectroscopic events in 2014 and 2020 had light curves different from their predecessors. Together with other indicators, these developments probably foretell the conclusion of η Car’s change of state.
Imaging and spectroscopy of the knots, clumps, and extended arcs in the complex ejecta of VY CMa confirm a record of high mass-loss events over the past few hundred years. Hubble Space Telescope/Space Telescope Imaging Spectrograph spectroscopy of numerous small knots close to the star allow us to measure their radial velocities from the strong K i emission and determine their separate motions, spatial orientations, and time since ejecta. Their ages concentrate around 70, 120, 200, and 250 yr ago. A K i emission knot only 50 mas from the star ejected as recently as 1985–1995 may coincide with an H 2 O maser. Comparison with VY CMa’s historic light curve from 1800 to the present shows several knots with ejection times that correspond with extended periods of variability and deep minima. The similarity of this correspondence in VY CMa with the remarkable recent dimming of Betelgeuse and an outflow of gas is apparent. The evidence for similar outflows from the surface of a more typical red supergiant suggests that discrete ejections are more common and surface or convective activity is a major source of mass loss for red supergiants.
Very massive stars occasionally expel material in colossal eruptions, driven by continuum radiation pressure rather than blast waves. Some of them rival supernovae in total radiative output, and the mass loss is crucial for subsequent evolution. Some are supernova impostors, including SN precursor outbursts, while others are true SN events shrouded by material that was ejected earlier. Luminous Blue Variable stars (LBV's) are traditionally cited in relation with giant eruptions, though this connection is not well established. After four decades of research, the fundamental causes of giant eruptions and LBV events remain elusive. This review outlines the basic relevant physics, with a brief summary of essential observational facts. Reasons are described for the spectrum and emergent radiation temperature of an opaque outflow. Proposed mechanisms are noted for instabilities in the star's photosphere, in its iron opacity peak zones, and in its central region. Various remarks and conjectures are mentioned, some of them relatively unfamiliar in the published literature.
We present the results of spectroscopy and multi-wavelength photometry of luminous and variable star candidates in the nearby spiral galaxies NGC 2403 and M81. We discuss specific classes of stars, the Luminous Blue Variables (LBVs), B[e] supergiants (sgB[e]), and the high-luminosity yellow hypergiants. We identify two new LBV candidates, and three sgB[e] stars in M81. We also find that some stars that were previously considered LBV candidates are actually field stars. The confirmed and candidate LBVs and sgB[e] stars together with the other confirmed members are shown on the HR Diagrams for their respective galaxies. We also present the HR Diagrams for the two "SN impostors", V37 (SN2002kg) and V12(5N1954J) in NGC 2403 and the stars in their immediate environments.
We employ Gaia Data Release 2 (Brown et al. 2018; Luri et al. 2018), assuming that the error estimates σi have the characteristics described by those authors. We assembled a list of fifty stars which are said to be members of Tr 16 (Walborn 1973, 1995; Massey & Johnson 1993), all having Gaia parallaxes ̟i with standard errors σi < 0.050 mas (Fig. 1). Their weighted average is ̟av ≈ 0.373 mas and their r.m.s. σi is 0.034 mas. (Each ̟i has relative statistical weight 1/σi .)
We present HR Diagrams for the massive star populations in M31 and M33 including several different types of emission-line stars: the confirmed Luminous Blue Variables (LBVs), candidate LBVs, B[e] supergiants and the warm hypergiants. We estimate their apparent temperatures and luminosities for comparison with their respective massive star populations and to evaluate the possible relationships of these different classes of evolved, massive stars, and their evolutionary state. Several of the LBV candidates lie near the LBV/S Dor instability strip which supports their classification. Most of the B[e] supergiants, however, are less luminous than the LBVs. Many are very dusty with the infrared flux contributing one-third or more to their total flux. They are also relatively isolated from other luminous OB stars. Overall, their spatial distribution suggests a more evolved state. Some may be post-RSGs like the warm hypergiants, and there may be more than one path to becoming a B[e] star. There are sufficient differences in the spectra, luminosities, spatial distribution, and the presence or lack of dust between the LBVs and B[e] supergiants to conclude that one group does not evolve into the other. Subject headings: galaxies:individual(M31,M33) – stars:massive – supergiants
Existing Hubble Space Telescope UV data offer many previously neglected clues to. Car's behavior since 2000. Here we examine a subset of observations with diverse results. (1) The star's rapid change of state is confirmed by major changes in UV absorption lines, circumstellar extinction, and other features. (2) N III]lambda 1750 is one of the two most luminous emission features in. Car's observable spectrum, comparable to Ha. This and other semi-forbidden lines are useful because they have no P Cyg absorption. (3) N III] multiplet ratios provide the first direct diagnostic of gas densities in. Car's outflow. They strongly suggest that high-excitation lines originate in condensations within the colliding-wind shocked region. The parameters imply that published models have not adequately represented the essential small size scales. (4) In 2002-2004, a very large amount of N III] emission had anomalous Doppler velocities from +400 to +1200 km s(-1). This is a mystery; we conjecture that it may have resulted from a burst of mass ejection in the 2003.5 periastron event. Various other effects are also difficult to explain and merit further investigation.
Gaia parallaxes for the star cluster Tr 16 reveal a discrepancy in the oft-quoted distance of Eta Carinae. It is probably more distant and more luminous. Moreover, many presumed members may not belong to Tr 16.
We present HR Diagrams for the massive star populations in M31 and M33 including several different types of emission-line stars: the confirmed Luminous Blue Variables (LBVs), candidate LBVs, B[e] supergiants and the warm hypergiants. We estimate their apparent temperatures and luminosities for comparison with their respective massive star populations and to evaluate the possible relationships of these different classes of evolved, massive stars, and their evolutionary state. Several of the LBV candidates lie near the LBV/S Dor instability strip which supports their classification. Most of the B[e] supergiants, however, are less luminous than the LBVs. Many are very dusty with the infrared flux contributing one-third or more to their total flux. They are also relatively isolated from other luminous OB stars. Overall, their spatial distribution suggests a more evolved state. Some may be post-RSGs like the warm hypergiants, and there may be more than one path to becoming a B[e] star. There are sufficient differences in the spectra, luminosities, spatial distribution, and the presence or lack of dust between the LBVs and B[e] supergiants to conclude that one group does not evolve into the other.
We describe new results on two supernova impostors in NGC 2403, SN 1954J(V12) and SN 2002kg(V37). For the famous object SN 1954J, we combine four critical observations: its current SED, its Hα emission line profile, the Ca ii triplet in absorption in its red spectrum, and the brightness compared to its pre-event state. Together, these strongly suggest that the survivor is now a hot supergiant with T ∼ 20,000 K, a dense wind, substantial circumstellar extinction, and a G-type supergiant companion. The hot star progenitor of V12's giant eruption was likely in the post-red supergiant stage and had already shed a lot of mass. V37 is a classical LBV/S Dor variable. Our photometry and spectra observed during and after its eruption show that its outburst was an apparent transit on the HR Diagram due to enhanced mass loss and the formation of a cooler, dense wind. V37 is an evolved hot supergiant at ≈106 with a probable initial mass of 60–80 .
Giant eruptions or supernova-impostor events are far more mysterious than true supernovae. An extreme example can release as much radiative energy as a SN, ejecting several M_sun of material. These events involve continuous radiation-driven outflows rather than blast waves. They constitute one of the main unsolved problems in stellar astrophysics, but have received surprisingly little theoretical effort. Here I note some aspects that are not yet familiar to most astronomers.