Hypocenters of main shock and aftershocks of the March 20, 2006 Laalam earthquake are relocated using HypoDD double-difference technique. We combined accelerogram and seismogram data of the National Center of Applied Research in Earthquake Engineering (CGS). Among about 191 aftershocks, recorded at least by 4 stations, 141 aftershocks of Md 1.2–2.7 were relocated using HypoDD. The obtained swarm of epicenters occupying a crustal volume of 5 km × 3 km × 5 km and the focal mechanism corresponds to an unknown pure left lateral strike slip, trending N174°E. We were able to calculate focal mechanisms for only seven aftershocks with more than seven polarity readings, which give a P axis oriented NNW–SSE. The waveform inversion also provided values of Mw 5.1, M0 5.9 10−16 Nm and the depth 4.9 km. The dislocation and the stress drop were estimated to 90 cm and 16.5 bars, respectively.
We use the recorded seismicity, confined to the Dead Sea basin and its boundaries, by the Dead Sea Integrated Research (DESIRE) portable seismic network and the Israel and Jordan permanent seismic networks for studying the mechanisms of earthquakes in the Dead Sea basin. The observed seismicity in the Dead Sea basin is divided into nine regions according to the spatial distribution of the earthquakes and the known tectonic features. The large number of recording stations and the adequate station distribution allowed the reliable determinations of 494 earthquake focal mechanisms. For each region, based on the inversion of the observed polarities of the earthquakes, we determine the focal mechanisms and the associated stress tensor. For 159 earthquakes, out of the 494 focal mechanisms, we could determine compatible fault planes. On the eastern side, the focal mechanisms are mainly strike-slip mechanism with nodal planes in the N-S and E-W directions. The azimuths of the stress axes are well constrained presenting minimal variability in the inversion of the data, which is in agreement with the Eastern Boundary fault on the east side of the Dead Sea basin and what we had expected from the regional geodynamics. However, larger variabilities of the azimuthal and dip angles are observed on the western side of the basin. Due to the wider range of azimuths of the fault planes, we observe the switching of σ1 and σ2 or the switching of σ2 and σ3 as major horizontal stress directions. This observed switching of stress axes allows having dip-slip and normal mechanisms in a region that is dominated by strike-slip motion.
The recent tomography results obtained within the scope of the Enhanced Geothermal System (EGS) European Soultz project led us to revisit the meso-fracturing properties of Soultz test site. In this paper, we develop a novel approach coupling effective medium modeling and shear-wave splitting to characterize the evolution of crack properties throughout the hydraulic stimulation process. The stimulation experiment performed in 2000 consisted of 3 successive injection steps spanning over 6 days. An accurate 4-D tomographic image was first carried out based upon the travel-times measured for the induced seismicity [Calò M., Dorbath C., Cornet F.H., Cuenot N. (2011) Large-scale aseismic motion identified through 4-D P-wave tomography, Geophys. J. Int. 186, 1295-1314]. The current study shows how to take advantage of the resulting compressional wave (Calò et al., 2011) and shear-wave velocity models. These are given as input data to an anisotropic effective medium model and converted into crack properties. In short, the effective medium model aims to estimate the impact of cracks on velocities. It refers to a crack-free matrix and 2 families of penny-shaped cracks with orientations in agreement with the main observed geological features: North-South strike and dip of 65°East and 65°West [Genter A., Traineau H. (1996) Analysis of macroscopic fractures in granite in the HDR geothermal well EPS-1, Soultz-sous-Forêts, France, J. Vol. Geoth. Res. 72, 121-141], respectively. The resulting output data are the spatial distributions of crack features (lengths and apertures) within the 3-D geological formation. We point out that a flow rate increase results in a crack shortening in the area imaged by both compressional and shear waves, especially in the upper part of the reservoir. Conversely, the crack length, estimated during continuous injection rate phases, is higher than during the increasing injection rate phases. A possible explanation for this is that cracks remain large because the system has time to relax. We also calculate the extension and opening rates during all hydraulic stimulation sets. While the opening rate is unchanged, the extension rate varies depending on the stimulation phase. It is also shown to be higher around and above the open-hole section than below. This can indicate a potential upward path that makes fluid percolation easier within the granite formation, this path being induced by the temperature gradient. We also compare the evolution of crack extension during injection with shear-wave splitting. Split shear waves were recorded at 2 stations during hydraulic stimulation and processed in terms of splitting parameters. The fast shear-wave polarization remains constant and parallel to the maximum horizontal stress orientation while the amplitude of splitting varies with time. We observe a good agreement between travel-time differences and crack extension rates during the first 4 days of the stimulation experiment. Afterwards, these two parameters depart from each other. This study emphasizes the added value of the coupling between effective medium modeling and shear-wave splitting to monitor meso-scale cracks in reservoirs submitted to hydraulic stimulation.
The occurrence of induced seismicity during reservoir stimulation requires robust real-time monitoring and forecasting methods for risk mitigation. We propose to derive an estimation of M-max (here defined as the largest single seismic event occurring during or after reservoir stimulation) using hydraulic energy as a proxy to forecast the total induced seismic moment and to model the transient evolution of the seismic moment distribution (based on the Gutenberg-Richter relation). The study is applied to the vast dataset assembled at the European pilot research project at Soultz-sous-Forets (Alsace, France), where four major hydraulic stimulations were conducted at 5 km depth. Although the model could reproduce the transient evolution trend of M-max for every dataset, detailed results show different agreement with the observations from well to well. This might reveal the importance of mechanical and geological conditions that may show strong local variations in the same EGS. (C) 2014 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
The recent new tomography results obtained within the scope of the Enhanced Geothermal System (EGS) European Soultz project led us to revisit the meso-fracturation features of the reservoir. In this paper, we develop a novel approach based on effective medium modeling to characterize the evolution of crack properties all along the hydraulic stimulation process. The stimulation experiment performed in 2000 actually consisted of 3 successive injection steps. An accurate 4-D tomography was previously conducted using the travel-times measured for the induced seismicity. The present study focuses on the exploitation of the resulting P-wave and S-wave velocity models. They are given as input data in an effective medium model and converted into crack properties. The effective medium model refers to a crack-free matrix and 2 families of penny-shaped cracks whose orientations are in agreement with geological features. The resulting output data are the spatial distribution of crack aspect ratios within the 3-D reservoir. This study emphasizes the added value of the coupling between effective medium modelling and geophysical studies to monitor meso-scale cracks in reservoirs submitted to hydraulic stimulation.
The October 27, 1985 Constantine earthquake of magnitude MS 5.9 (NEIC) although moderate is the strongest earthquake recorded in the eastern Tellian Atlas (northeast Algeria) since the beginning of instrumental seismology. The main shock locations given by different institutions are scattered and up to 10 km away northwest from the NE–SW 30 km long elongated aftershocks cloud localized by a dedicated temporary portable network. The focal mechanism indicates left-lateral strike-slip on an almost vertical fault with a small reverse component on the northwest dipping plane. This paper presents relocations of the main shock and aftershocks using TomoDD. One hundred thirty-eight individual focal mechanisms have been built allowing the determination of the stress tensor at different scales. A rupture model has been suggested, which explains the different observations of aftershock distribution and stress tensor rotation.
Understanding of induced seismicity during stimulation and production of geothermal reservoirs is a key aspect towards future large-scale application of deep geothermal energy. At the European research project at Soultz-sous-Forêts (Alsace, France) several well stimulation experiments have been conducted and a unique dataset has been assembled. In this study we analyze changes of Coulomb stress due to induced seismicity during stimulation. For this purpose we developed an efficient method to calculate coseismic stress changes from an elliptical slip distribution on a circular fracture using superposition of rectangular sources. This method is applied on a dataset of 715 focal mechanisms derived from seismic recordings of the GPK2 stimulation in the year 2000 to calculate temporal evolution of change of Coulomb stress. We find stress changes that align with the microseismic cloud but exhibit heterogeneously distributed stress changes in the order of ±1 MPa.
During creation of an Enhanced Geothermal System, massive fluid injections are conducted to induce fracture shear which generates reservoir permeability. In this study we analyze coseismic static stress transfer caused by induced seismic events during a stimulation at the European research project at Soultz‐sous‐Forêts (Alsace, France). For this purpose we developed an efficient method to calculate coseismic static stress changes from an elliptical slip distribution on a circular fracture using superposition of rectangular sources, which enables us to apply an analytical solution for fast computation. This method is applied on a data set of 715 focal mechanisms derived from seismic recordings of the stimulation of the well GPK2 to calculate temporal evolution of static stress transfer. We find that the resulting structure of coseismic stress changes can be divided into three parts: a quiet zone where no spreading of seismicity occurs, an active zone within the created reservoir with ongoing fracturing and a process zone where the growth of the reservoir occurs. Static stress changes in the active zone are of the order of 1 MPa, both positive and negative, but may exceed this value considerably on a local scale. Analysis of stress changes from a cluster of events that occurred after shut‐in lets us conclude that triggering by coseismic static stress changes is possible for some events. Our analysis shows that triggering by static stress transfer plays a minor role for injection induced seismicity in a volumetric reservoir, whereas it can be quite effective for rupture propagation along single large fault zones.
We have inverted the peak amplitudes of direct P waves of 45 micro earthquakes with magnitudes of between M = 1.4 and 2.9 which occurred during the 2003 massive fluid injection in the borehole of the Soultz site. The full moment tensor expression of the mechanism was applied. Surprisingly, the mechanisms of all are dominantly pure shears. The T-axes are fairly stable, being concentrated subhorizontally roughly in the EW direction. On the contrary, the P-axes are ill-constrained varying in the NS direction from nearly vertical to nearly horizontal, which points to heterogeneous stress in the Soultz injected volume. This is in agreement with the stress pattern from in-situ measurements. The time-space distribution of the events analysed suggests that the injection activated two segments of the natural faults existing in the area showing different source mechanism patterns. The dip-slip regime is characteristic for fault segment I where the seismicity occurred during and also after injection, while the strike-slip regime prevails in segment II where the seismicity was triggered only after the injection shut in. This indicates that the tensile fractures may have occurred on a smaller scale than the pure shear microearthqukes investigated.
The magnitude M-w=6.3 earthquake in Al Hoceima, Morocco of 24 February, 2004 occurred in the active plate boundary accommodating the oblique convergence between Africa and Eurasia. Three different sets of estimates of its source parameters have already been published. We try to resolve the discrepancies between them by using additional data including two remote sensing satellite systems (ENVISAT and SPOTS). Using a model with a dislocation in an elastic half-space, we constrain the source parameters. The hypothesis of two subevents on distinct faults as inferred from seismological inversions is confirmed here by adopting a cross-fault mechanism. The rupture began on a left-lateral strike-slip fault striking at N10 degrees azimuth with 90 cm of horizontal slip and then transferred to a right-lateral strike-slip fault striking at N312 degrees azimuth with 85 cm of horizontal slip. The first fault is at 500 m depth from the free surface and the second fault is at 3 km depth. This model is consistent with ground-based observations, including GPS, seismology, and mapped surface fissures. The pair of faults activated in 2004 appears to constitute part of a complex seismogenic structure striking NNE-SSW that separates the Rif tectonic blocks. (C) 2008 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
Mount Cameroon is an active volcano located in the Gulf of Guinea, west of Central Africa. After the March-April 1999 eruption on the SW flank, another eruption of the volcano occurred in 2000. It took place from three sites on the southwest flank and near the summit. The first eruptive site was located 500 m to the southwest of the summit, at 3900 m altitude. Activity on this site was mainly explosive with no lava flow. The second site was located between 3220 and 3470 m altitude. Lava was emitted along NNE-SSE fissures from this site and flew towards Buea, the main city of the area, stopping similar to 4 km from the first houses. The last site was located in the south western flank at 2750 m altitude. The lava ejected from an old cone near the first 1999 eruptive site was divided into two branches, for a total length of around 1 km. The location of active volcanic cones in 1999 and 2000 seems to be linked to the local tectonics. The pre-eruptive period was characterized by a seismic swarm which may be a precursor recorded in March 2000 by an analogue seismic station. The main shock was a magnitude 3.2 event, and was felt by the population in Ekona town located on the eastern flank. It had a Modified Mercalli intensity of III-IV. When the eruption started, a temporary network of short period 3-component seismic stations was set up around the volcano to improve the monitoring of seismic activity. The co-eruptive period from late May to September was characterized by sequences of earthquake swarms, volcanic tremor and a family of earthquakes having similar waveform and appearing regularly in August and early September. Some of the earthquakes were felt by the population in Buea and its environments. The largest seismic event recorded had a magnitude of 4. During the post-eruptive period from mid-September to December, seismicity returned to its background level of 1-3 earthquakes per 3 days. Hypocenter locations reveal a linear narrow structure under the summit zone which could represent the magmatic conduit of the volcano. The frequency/magnitude relationship revealed a b-value of 1.43 higher than those previously determined, but more representative of volcanic media. Seismic energy release was gradual after the 2000 eruption started. (C) 2008 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
The Asal‐Ghoubbet (AG) Rift has sustained a major volcano‐tectonic rifting episode in 1978 and has been subsequently monitored with continuous geodetic and seismological surveys. It is therefore an ideal place to study the transient magmato‐tectonic processes that operate after a rifting episode. We examine the space‐time evolution of ∼2500 Md ≤ 2.8 earthquakes recorded in the rift from 1979 to 2001. We focus on the relationships between this seismic activity and both the three‐dimensional structure of the rift and its postrifting behavior depicted from geodesy. The results highlight the major role of the central magmatic system (Fieale‐Shark Bay) on the structure, seismic activity, and overall behavior of the rift. From 1978 to 1986, the rift opens at a fast rate, yet mainly aseismically; the opening is magmatically driven and accommodated. Since 1986, when the opening rate abruptly decreased, the seismicity is concentrated in the central part of the rift and reveals pulses of activity of the central volcanic system. These pulses result from that magmatic zone undergoing alternating stretching and inflating episodes. Thus, while the plate‐driven induced stresses have been rebuilding in the rift since 1987, the rift opening is still essentially accommodated in the axial magmatic zone. The AG Rift has thus sustained a postrifting unsteady opening over more than 23 years following its stretching episode. That transient opening has essentially occurred aseismically, and most tectonic faults remain relaxed and locked.
The July 24, 2001, Mw=6.3 earthquake in Aroma, Chile, is one of the few moderately shallow earthquakes to occur recently in northern Chile. This study uses different seismological data (short-period, broadband, strong-motion) to locate the event and its corresponding aftershocks. In addition, it carefully constrains the focal depth using SP phase and the focal mechanism of the main-shock. Finally, a model of the strong-motion waveforms discriminates the activated fault plane among the two nodal planes. The main-shock fault plane solution obtained from the strong-motion analysis is (strike, dip, rake)=(14°±10°, 53°±15°, −163°±15°), which indicates a right-lateral motion on an inclined fault, in agreement with the aftershock distribution, which also indicates a fault striking N14°E and dipping about 50°E.
We seek to characterize how magmatic and tectonic activities combine and interact during the continental rifting process. We address this question in two companion papers. In both, we analyze the seismicity that occurs in an active magmato‐tectonic rift, Asal‐Ghoubbet (East Africa), to identify the features and/or processes responsible for its activity. Here, we report results from a 5‐month experiment that we conducted in the rift. Eleven seismometers were deployed to complement the eight‐station permanent network. This allowed recording ∼400 earthquakes in the rift; 200 events could be well located (precision <40 m) and used in a tomographic inversion. Focal mechanisms were also determined for 71 events. The results show that current activity in the rift is mainly magmatically induced or accommodated. A ∼2‐km‐wide pipe of hot rock is evidenced below the central Fieale‐Shark Bay volcanic complex, likely above a deeper (>5–6 km) magma reservoir. Most events concentrate at the roof of the pipe (at 3–4 km) and result from up and down slip ruptures on both the volcanic (ring) and tectonic faults that enclose the pipe at depth. The up and down motions are likely driven by pressure changes in the magma reservoir. Hence, although a few rift faults were associated with seismicity, most remained seismically silent during the experiment. In the companion paper, we analyze the seismic activity in the rift over the 23 years that followed its last rifting episode. This confirms the importance of the Fieale‐Shark Bay plumbing system in the overall rift behavior.
Several deep wells were drilled in the Rhine Graben (Soultz-sous-Forêts, France) to evaluate the geothermal Hot Dry Rock potential of a deep fractured granite reservoir. Three main boreholes, which reached about 5km depth, intersected a crystalline basement overlain by 1.4km of Cenozoic and Mesozoic sediments. Stimulations of these three wells were carried out in 2000 for GPK2, 2003 for GPK3 and 2004, and 2005 for GPK4. During these stimulations and other hydraulic activities a seismological surface network was installed in order to monitor the seismicity induced by the massive fluid injection.Here we analyse the seismicity of magnitude larger than or equal to 1.4, which is the lowest magnitude felt by the population. Based on a spectral analysis of the displacement recorded by a Güralp velocimeter at a depth of 200m, we know that the source dimensions range from tens to hundreds of metres. We analyse several parts of the reservoir where obvious correlation between the fluid path and tectonic features has been pointed out. Based on seismological arguments such as location and focal mechanisms, we show that this activity is linked with tectonic features, or at least with large fractures that control the behaviour of the geothermal reservoir. To constrain the hypothesis, we study 391 events and focal mechanisms to argue in favour of the existence and stability of tectonic features that can be compared to geological data. We show that the largest events recorded on the site occurred after the shut-in. Their spatial distribution appears not to be random within the reservoir, and the focal mechanisms of these events also confirm the non-randomness of their distribution. Given their source dimensions, the largest events can only occur on large structures, such as tectonic ones. Therefore, the behaviour of the reservoir is controlled by these main fractured zones, which either lead the fluid or hinder its path.