This review provides an up-to-date account of the development of two solid-state (SS)NMR methods for enhancing resolution and sensitivity, fast magic angle spinning (MAS) and dynamic nuclear polarization (DNP), and the resulting progress in surface science. We demonstrate the high resolution and efficiency that can be achieved by using two-dimensional homo- and heteronuclear correlation experiments with small rotors capable of MAS at rates exceeding 100 kHz. DNP has offered significant enhancements in signal sensitivity and allowed access to nuclei and experiments that are beyond the limits of conventional SSNMR. The continuing progress in fast MAS and DNP methodologies in recent years generated an unprecedented shift in SSNMR’s capabilities in the studies of surface and interface regions of solids, especially mesoporous supports and catalysts. We give numerous examples of recent applications and discuss the prospects for further improvements of both methods.
Concentrated solutions of Li salts in acetonitrile are promising alternative electrolytes for the next generation of Li batteries as they may exhibit superior electrochemical properties. However, the reduced mobility of the chemical species is a barrier yet to be overcome, and for this, we explore the utilization of acetone as a cosolvent. Although acetone is a polar compound, we find that its addition to the LiTFSI/acetonitrile solution does not follow the trends expected for a simple dilution process. At a low concentration, acetone subtly shifts acetonitrile from the first to extended solvation sheaths of the ions. Still, most of the original structure of the solution is preserved, and mobile high-concentration clusters are formed in the solution. At higher concentrations, the cosolvation promotes cation-anion interactions but with a different nature from those in the original solution and still allows for a further increase in conductivity. Additionally, the non-coordinating fraction of acetonitrile acquires features resembling the pure solvent, which is a possible additional facilitating factor for ionic diffusion.
Despite having a lower energy density than common batteries, electric double-layer capacitors (EDLCs) offer several advantages for high-power applications, including high power density, quick charge and discharge time, and long cycle life. Room-temperature ionic liquids (RTILs) have been intensely studied as promising electrolytes for applications in ELDCs because of their wide potential window, low volatility, as well as thermal and chemical stability. The main deficiency of neat RTILs in such applications is the sluggish diffusivity, which restricts the EDLCs' power density. To alleviate the slow diffusivity, RTILs can be used in a mixture with organic solvents. In this study, we applied two-dimensional exchange nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy (2D EXSY NMR) and molecular dynamics (MD) simulations to investigate the diffusivity of anions of an RTIL, namely, 1-butyl-3-methyl-imidazolium bis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl)imide (BMIM+-TFSI-), dissolved in five different organic solvents, in the micropores of activated carbon. We determined that the relative concentrations of ions in solutions in the micropores were higher than those in the bulk solutions and were also solvent-dependent. The ion diffusivities in the pores were found to be almost 2 orders of magnitude slower than in the bulk solutions, with methanol showing the largest relative disparity. These results suggested that the interactions of solvents with the activated carbon are critical not only to the power density of EDLCs but also to the energy density. The comparisons of ion diffusivities between the experiments and the MD simulations suggest the need to consider also the surface functionalities of activated carbon for the simulation of ion diffusion in the micropores of activated carbon.
Surface-bound organometallic molecules have recently enabled the development of single-site heterogeneous catalysts, advancing the atomic scale understanding and diversity of heterogeneous catalysis. Here we report that supporting Cp*ZrMe3 (Cat1) on acidic sulfated-alumina (AlS) affords the surface catalyst Cat1/AlS, which was characterized by multi-dimensional solid-state NMR spectroscopies, and is active in ethylene homo- and copolymerizations, as well as propylene and 1-hexene homopolymerizations. In contrast to propylene (or 1-hexene) polymerization by homogeneous Cp*ZrMe2+ B(C6F5)(4)(-) which yields atactic polyolefins, Cat1/AlS promotes remarkable isotacticity with mmmm >95 %. Complementary DFT analysis argues that the restrictive local Cat1/AlS C-1-symmetry favors activation and enchainment at the propylene re enantioface, promoting isotactic polymerization via a "back-skip-like" mechanism.
Despite the growing number of successful applications of dynamic nuclear polarization (DNP)-enhanced magic-angle spinning (MAS) NMR in structural biology and materials science, the nuclear polarizations achieved by current MAS DNP instrumentation are still considerably lower than the theoretical maximum. The method could be significantly strengthened if experiments were performed at temperatures much lower than those currently widely used (∼100 K). Recently, the prospects of helium (He)-cooled MAS DNP have been increased with the instrumental developments in MAS technology that uses cold helium gas for sample cooling. Despite the additional gains in sensitivity that have been observed with He-cooled MAS DNP, the performance of the technique has not been evaluated in the case of surfaces and interfaces that benefit the most from DNP. Herein, we studied the efficiency of DNP at temperatures between ∼30 K and ∼100 K for organically functionalized silica material and a homogeneous solution of small organic molecules at a magnetic field B0 = 16.4 T. We recorded the changes in signal enhancement, paramagnet-induced quenching and depolarization effects, DNP build-up rate, and Boltzmann polarization. For these samples, the increases in MAS-induced depolarization and DNP build-up times at around 30 K were not as severe as anticipated. In the case of the surface species, we determined that MAS DNP at 30 K provided ∼10 times higher sensitivity than MAS DNP at 90 K, which corresponds to the acceleration of experiments by multiplicative factors of up to 100.
Although single-site, supported organometallic catalysts were designed with homogeneity in mind, little is strictly known about their atomic-level structure and uniformity. This is in large part due to the inability of conventional characterization tools to provide structural information with adequate resolution and range for this purpose. Here, we show that dynamic nuclear polarization (DNP)-enhanced solid-state nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) enables the measurement of distances between the surface and individual carbons, making it possible to orient complexes and molecules on surfaces. We use this approach to determine the orientation and configuration of naturally C-13-abundant acetate and supported organoiridium(III) pincer complex, both supported on gamma-Al2O3. By combining solid-state NMR and extended X-ray absorption fine structure spectroscopy (EXAFS) experiments with periodic density functional theory (DFT) calculations, we are able to determine the three-dimensional arrangement of ligands around the metal center and thereby identify the structure of the supported complex at a resolution reminiscent of that associated with single-crystal diffractometry.
Addition of small amounts of water to the organic solvent may result in different promoting or inhibiting effects in aldol condensation reactions depending on the distribution of active sites on the surface. In a combination of liquid-phase catalytic activity measurements, spectroscopies, and theoretical calculations, we have shown that water clusters around the acid site can form bridges with a ketone molecule located close to the activated carbonyl on another site. When the distance between the two acid sites is greater than a distance corresponding to about two watermolecules, the efficiency of the bond polarization of the ketone by a remotely located acid site decreases significantly, and the presence of water no longer promotes the reaction. This work provides a quantitative assessment of how solvent molecules can bridge isolated active sites to enable cooperative catalysis, which offers an additional dimension for engineering catalysis at the nanoscale.
The reaction of To(M)Tl (To(M)=tris(4,4-dimethyl-2-oxazolinyl)phenylborate) and CuBr2 in benzene at 60 degrees C provides To(M)CuBr (1) as an entry-point into tris(oxazolinyl)phenylborato copper chemistry. To(M)CuO(t)Bu (2) and To(M)CuOAc (3) are prepared by the reactions of To(M)CuBr with (KOBu)-Bu-t and NaOAc, respectively. To(M)CuO(t)Bu is transformed into (To(M)CuOH)(2) (4) through hydrolysis. NMR, FT-IR, and EPR spectroscopies are used to determine the electronic and structural properties of these copper(II) compounds, and the solid-state structures were characterized by X-ray crystallography. Reduction of copper is observed upon treatment of To(M)CuO(t)Bu with phenylsilane in an attempt to synthesize monomeric copper(II) hydride. To(M)Cu (5) and To(2)(M)Cu (6) were independently synthesized and characterized for comparison.
Recent studies have shown that dynamic nuclear polarization (DNP) can be used to detect 17 O solid-state NMR spectra of naturally abundant samples within a reasonable experimental time. Observations using indirect DNP, which relies on 1 H mediation in transferring electron hyperpolarization to 17 O, are currently limited mostly to hydroxyls. Direct DNP schemes can hyperpolarize non-protonated oxygen near the radicals; however, they generally offer much lower signal enhancements. In this study, we demonstrate the detection of signals from non-protonated 17 O in materials containing silicon. The sensitivity boost that made the experiment possible originates from three sources: indirect DNP excitation of 29 Si via protons, indirect detection of 17 O through 29 Si nuclei using two-dimensional 29 Si{17 O} D-HMQC, and Carr-Purcell-Meiboom-Gill refocusing of 29 Si magnetization during acquisition. This 29 Si-detected scheme enabled, for the first time, 2D 17 O-29 Si heteronuclear correlation spectroscopy in mesoporous silica and silica-alumina surfaces at natural abundance. In contrast to the silanols showing motion-averaged 17 O signals, the framework oxygens exhibit unperturbed powder patterns as unambiguous fingerprints of surface sites. Along with hydroxyl oxygens, detection of these moieties will help in gaining more atomistic-scale insights into surface chemistry.
Dynamic nuclear polarization (DNP) and indirect detection are two commonly applied approaches for enhancing the sensitivity of solid-state NMR spectroscopy. However, their use in tandem has not yet been investigated. With the advent of low-temperature fast magic angle spinning (MAS) probes with 1.3-mm diameter rotors capable of MAS at 40 kHz it becomes feasible to combine these two techniques. In this study, we performed DNP-enhanced 2D indirectly detected heteronuclear correlation (idHETCOR) experiments on 13C, 15N, 113Cd and 89Y nuclei in functionalized mesoporous silica, CdS nanoparticles, and Y2O3 nanoparticles. The sensitivity of the 2D idHETCOR experiments was compared with those of DNP-enhanced directly-detected 1D cross polarization (CP) and 2D HETCOR experiments performed with a standard 3.2-mm rotor. Due to low CP polarization transfer efficiencies and large proton linewidth, the sensitivity gains achieved by indirect detection alone were lower than in conventional (non-DNP) experiments. Nevertheless, despite the smaller sample volume the 2D idHETCOR experiments showed better absolute sensitivities than 2D HETCOR experiments for nuclei with the lowest gyromagnetic ratios. For 89Y, 2D idHETCOR provided 8.2 times better sensitivity than the 1 D89Y-detected CP experiment performed with a 3.2-mm rotor.
Single-site organolanthanum complexes supported on mesoporous silica nanoparticles, La{C(SiHMe2)(3)}(n)@MSNs, catalyze the ring-opening hydroboration reaction of aliphatic and styrenic epoxides with pinacolborane (HBpin). The surface-bound complexes, synthesized by reaction of the homoleptic tris(alkyl)-lanthanum La{C(SiHMe2)(3)}(3) and SBA-type MSN treated at 700 degrees C (MSN700), are mostly monopodal SiO-La{C(SiHMe2)(3)}(2) and contain an average of one bridging La <- H-Si per alkyl ligand. This structure was established through a combination of solid-state NMR (SSNMR) experiments, including J-resolved SiH coupling and quantitative Si-29 measurements, diffuse reflectance IR, and elemental analysis. These rigorous analyses also established that grafting reactions in pentane provide a preponderance of SiO-La{C(SiHMe2)(3)}(2) sites and are superior to those in benzene and THF, and that grafting onto MSN treated at 550 degrees C (MSN550) results in a mixture of surface species. The single-site supported catalysts are more selective and in most cases more active than the homogeneous analogue, allow easy purification of products from the catalyst, are strongly resistant to leaching into solution phase, and may be recycled for reuse at least five times. After reaction of La{C(SiHMe2)(3)}(n)@MSN and HBpin, species including SiO-La{C(SiHMe2)(3)}(H(2)Bpin) and SiO-La{C(SiHMe2)(3)}{kappa(2)-pinB-O(CMe2)(2)OBH3} are identified by detailed 1D and 2D B-11 SSNMR experiments.
Treatment of Kraft lignin, massive byproduct of pulping industry, with dilute aqueous base followed by catalytic hydrogenation of the extracted monomers at ambient pressure yields KA oil, the precursor of high demand nylon polymer.
Theoretical models aimed at describing magic-angle-spinning (MAS) dynamic nuclear polarization (DNP) NMR have great potential in facilitating the in silico design of DNP polarizing agents and formulations. These models must typically face a trade-off between the accuracy of a strict quantum mechanical description and the need for using realistically large spin systems, for instance, using phenomenological models. Here, we show that the use of aggressive state-space restrictions and an optimization strategy allows full-scale ab initio MAS-DNP simulations of spin systems containing thousands of nuclei. Our simulations are shown to reproduce experimental DNP enhancements quantitatively, including their MAS rate dependence, for both frozen solutions and solid materials. They also reveal the importance of a previously unrecognized structural feature found in some polarizing agents that helps minimize the sensitivity losses imposed by the spin diffusion barrier.
Nanoconfinement imposes physical constraints and chemical effects on reactivity in nanoporous catalyst systems. In the present study, we lay the groundwork for quantitative single-molecule measurements of the effects of chemical environment on heterogeneous catalysis in nanoconfinement. Choosing hydrophobicity as an exemplary chemical environmental factor, we compared a range of essential parameters for an oxidation reaction on platinum nanoparticles (NPs) confined in hydrophilic and hydrophobic nanopores. Single-molecule experimental measurements at the single particle level showed higher catalytic activity, stronger adsorption strength, and higher activation energy in hydrophobic nanopores than those in hydrophilic nanopores. Interestingly, different dissociation kinetic behaviors of the product molecules in the two types of nanopores were deduced from the single-molecule imaging data.
Olefin metathesis is a broadly employed reaction with applications that range from fine chemicals to materials and petrochemicals. The design and investigation of olefin metathesis catalysts have been ongoing for over half a century, with advancements made in terms of activity, stability, and selectivity. Immobilization of organometallic complexes onto solid supports such as silica or alumina is a promising strategy for catalyst heterogenization, often resulting in increased activity and stability. Consequently, a broad range of early transition metal catalysts bearing alkyl, oxide/alkoxide, and amide ligands have been grafted onto silica and their reactivities investigated. Herein, we report a series of silica-supported tungsten and molybdenum dimers (X3M≡MX3, where M = W and Mo; X = neopentyl, tert-butoxide, and dimethyl amide) and their reactivities toward catalytic olefin metathesis. Dynamic nuclear polarization (DNP)-enhanced solid-state nuclear magnetic resonance (SSNMR), diffuse reflectance infrared Fourier transform (DRIFT), UV resonance Raman, and X-ray absorption (XAS) spectroscopies suggest that upon heterogenization the dimers bind to the surface in a monopodal fashion, with the M≡M triple bond remaining intact. These structural assignments were further corroborated by density functional theory (DFT) calculations. While the homogeneous dimer counterparts are inert, the supported low-valent alkyl W and Mo dimers become active for the disproportionative self-metathesis of propylene to ethylene and butenes and 4-nonene to 4-octene and 5-decene under mild conditions. The lack of activity observed for the free and supported tert-butoxide and dimethyl amide dimers likely suggests that the neopentyl groups are necessary for the formation of a putative alkylidene active species. The difference in reactivity between the free and supported dimers could be explained either by the lowering of the activation barrier of the complex through the electronic effects of the surface or by site isolation of catalytically relevant reactive intermediates.
Room-temperature ionic liquids (RTILs) hold promise for applications in electric double layer capacitors (EDLCs), owing to a much wider potential window, lower vapor pressure, and better thermal and chemical stabilities compared to conventional aqueous and organic electrolytes. However, because the low diffusivity of ions in neat RTILs negates the EDLCs' advantage of high power density, the ionic liquids are often used in mixture with organic solvents. In this study, we measured the diffusivity of cations and anions in RTIL, 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium bis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl) ([BMIM+][TFSI-]), mixed with 10 organic solvents, by using the pulsed-field gradient NMR method. The ion diffusivity was found to follow that of neat solvents and in most studied solvents showed an excellent agreement with the predicted values reported in the recent molecular dynamics (MD) study [Thompson, M. W.; J. Phys. Chem. B 2019, 123, 1340-1347]. In two solvents consisting of long-chain molecules, however, the MD simulations predictions slightly underestimated the ionic diffusivities. The degree of ion dissociation was also estimated for each solvent by comparing the ionic conductivity with the molar conductivity derived from the diffusion measurements. The degree of ion dissociation and the hydrodynamic radius of ions suggest that the ions are coordinated by ∼1 solvent molecule. The scarcity of solvent-ion interactions explains the fact that the diffusivity of ions in the mixture significantly depends on the viscosity of the solvent.
Nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy can provide unique, atomic-level insights into the structure and dynamics of materials, but its applications are impeded by the intrinsically low sensitivity. Dynamic nuclear polarization (DNP) is poised to overcome this limitation, and indeed has revolutionized the study of surfaces; however, the current approaches are ill-suited for bulk solids. One potential pathway toward the hyperpolarization of bulk solids by DNP is through the inclusion of paramagnetic metal ions that can serve as polarizing agents. In this work, we compared the relative performance of two such dopants, Mn2+ and Gd3+, in three series of oxide glasses having chemical environments representative of those found in other crystalline and amorphous solids. In our studies, Gd3+ outperformed Mn2+, consistently providing more than one order of magnitude greater time savings. We attributed this difference mainly to the lack of hyperfine interaction to Mn-55.
Most polar solvent molecules are unstable toward electrode materials used in Li-based batteries. Solid electrolytes and ionic liquids are far more stable; however, they have relatively low conductivity, and therefore electrical energy storage devices based on them would suffer from low power. Solvent-in-salt (SIS) systems combine chemical stability with relatively high conductivity. Here, we show how the nature of the employed anion affects the structure and dynamics of SIS systems. The transport of ions in lithium bis(fluorosulfonyl)imide (Li-FSI) systems was determined to be always faster than that in lithium bis(trifluoromethanesulfonyl)imide (Li-TFSI) systems. Moreover, we found that viscosity does not solely control conductivity and that the lower conductivity of TFSI– solutions is related to their stronger interaction with the solvent. This restricts solvent dynamics and slows down ion motions compared to that of FSI–. Interestingly, the TFSI–solvent interaction also leads to better charge separation (weaker ion–ion correlations) and a higher transference number for Li. Our results suggest that the ability to tune the solvent network formed around the anions may further improve electrolyte conductivity and Li transference number for safer and more efficient energy storage devices.