Protofibrils (PFs) represent the earliest fibrillar species that occur in the course of amyloid fibril formation. Using apomyoglobin, we report here that PFs arise from a multi-step reaction and that they are preceded by an ensemble of non-fibrillar particles (NFPs). These intermediate aggregates encompass nascent elements of amyloid structure and can act as seeds in PF formation. Taken together with the observation that PFs often protrude from NFPs, our data suggest that PFs form by a random nucleation mechanism in which the polypeptide chains sample many different aggregated conformations. Once the appropriate structural characteristics are acquired, PFs are formed by addition of further polypeptide chains.

Observations that β-sheet proteins form amyloid fibrils under at least partially denaturing conditions has raised questions as to whether these fibrils assemble by docking of preformed β-structure or by association of unfolded polypeptide segments. By using α-helical protein apomyoglobin, we show that the ease of fibril assembly correlates with the extent of denaturation. By contrast, monomeric β-sheet intermediates could not be observed under the conditions of fibril formation. These data suggest that amyloid fibril formation from apomyoglobin depends on disordered polypeptide segments and conditions that are selectively unfavorable to folding. However, it is inevitable that such conditions often stabilize protein folding intermediates.