Background Only one out of every ten Nigerian adults with hypertension has their blood pressure controlled. Health worker training is essential to improve hypertension diagnosis and treatment. In-person training has limitations that mobile, on-demand training might address. This pilot study evaluated a self-paced, case-based, mobile-optimized online training to diagnose and manage hypertension for Nigerian health workers. Methods Twelve hypertension training modules were developed, based on World Health Organization and Nigerian guidelines. After review by local academic and government partners, the course was piloted by Nigerian health workers at government-owned primary health centers. Primary care physician, nurse, and community health worker participants completed the course on their own smartphones. Before and after the course, hypertension knowledge was evaluated with multiple-choice questions. Learners provided feedback by responding to questions on a Likert scale. Results Out of 748 users who sampled the course, 574 enrolled, of whom 431 (75%) completed the course. The average pre-test score of completers was 65.4%, which increased to 78.2% on the post-test (P < 0.001, paired t-test). Health workers who were not part of existing hypertension control programs had lower pre-test scores and larger score gains. Most participants (96.1%) agreed that the training was applicable to their work, and nearly all (99.8%) agreed that they enjoyed the training. Conclusions An on-demand mobile digital hypertension training increases knowledge of hypertension management among Nigerian health workers. If offered at scale, such courses can be a tool to build health workforce capacity through initial and refresher training on current clinical guidelines in hypertension and other chronic diseases in Nigeria as well as other countries.
Introduction: Currently only 2.8% of Nigerian adults with HTN have their blood pressure treated and controlled. Training health workers in HTN management is crucial for improving diagnosis and treatment, but in-person training has limitations. Objectives: The objective of this study is to evaluate the effectiveness of a self-paced, on-demand digital mobile course for training Nigerian health workers in HTN diagnosis and management. Materials & Methods: Twelve HTN training modules based on World Health Organization and Nigerian guidelines were drafted by the investigators. After review by local academic and government partners, Nigerian health workers staffing government-owned primary health care centers piloted the app. Participants were doctors, nurses, and community health workers who completed the course on their own smart phones. Multiple choice questions assessed HTN knowledge before and after the course. Learner feedback was collected in the last module of the course with Likert scale and open response questions. Results: Of 748 users who sampled the course, 574 enrolled. Of those enrolled, 431 completed the course (75% completion rate). Among completers, mean pre-test score was 65.4%, which increased to 78.2% post-test ( P <0.001, paired t test). Health workers not part of existing HTN control programs had lower pre-test scores and greater score gains. Most learners (96.1%) strongly agreed the training was relevant to their work, and almost all (99.8%) agreed that they enjoyed the training. Conclusions: This pilot project developed an on-demand mobile digital HTN training course for Nigerian health workers. If deployed by the Nigerian government, the course will provide an easy way for health workers of all cadres (doctors, nurses, and community health workers) to participate in either induction or refresher training in HTN management.
Introduction: Currently only 2.8% of Nigerian adults with HTN have their blood pressure treated and controlled. Training health workers in HTN management is crucial for improving diagnosis and treatment, but in-person training has limitations. Objectives: The objective of this study is to evaluate the effectiveness of a self-paced, on-demand digital mobile course for training Nigerian health workers in HTN diagnosis and management. Materials & Methods: Twelve HTN training modules based on World Health Organization and Nigerian guidelines were drafted by the investigators. After review by local academic and government partners, Nigerian health workers staffing government-owned primary health care centers piloted the app. Participants were doctors, nurses, and community health workers who completed the course on their own smart phones. Multiple choice questions assessed HTN knowledge before and after the course. Learner feedback was collected in the last module of the course with Likert scale and open response questions. Results: Of 748 users who sampled the course, 574 enrolled. Of those enrolled, 431 completed the course (75% completion rate). Among completers, mean pre-test score was 65.4%, which increased to 78.2% post-test ( P <0.001, paired t test). Health workers not part of existing HTN control programs had lower pre-test scores and greater score gains. Most learners (96.1%) strongly agreed the training was relevant to their work, and almost all (99.8%) agreed that they enjoyed the training. Conclusions: This pilot project developed an on-demand mobile digital HTN training course for Nigerian health workers. If deployed by the Nigerian government, the course will provide an easy way for health workers of all cadres (doctors, nurses, and community health workers) to participate in either induction or refresher training in HTN management.
Background Health workers (HWs) in Africa face challenges accessing and learning from existing online training opportunities. To address these challenges, we developed a modular, self-paced, mobile-ready and work-relevant online course covering foundational infection prevention and control (IPC) concepts. Here, we evaluate the first pilot of this course, conducted with HWs in Nigeria. Methods We used a learner-centered design and prototyping process to create a new approach to delivering online training for HWs. The resulting course comprised 10 self-paced modules optimized for use on mobile devices. Modules presented IPC vignettes in which learning was driven by short assessment questions with feedback. Learners were recruited by distributing a link to the training through Nigeria-based email lists, WhatsApp groups and similar networks of HWs, managers and allied professionals. The course was open to learners for 8 weeks. We tracked question responses and time on task with platform analytics and assessed learning gains with pre- and post-testing. Significance was evaluated with the Wilcoxon signed-rank test, and effect size was calculated using Cohen’s d . Results Three hundred seventy-two learners, with roles across the health system, enrolled in the training; 59% completed all 10 modules and earned a certificate. Baseline knowledge of foundational IPC concepts was low, as measured by pre-test scores (29%). Post-test scores were significantly higher at 54% (effect size 1.22, 95% confidence interval 1.00-1.44). Learning gains were significant both among learners with low pre-test scores and among those who scored higher on the pre-test. We used the Net Promoter Score (NPS), a common user experience metric, to evaluate the training. The NPS was + 62, which is slightly higher than published scores of other self-paced online learning experiences. Conclusions High completion rates, significant learning gains and positive feedback indicate that self-paced, mobile-ready training that emphasizes short, low-stakes assessment questions can be an effective, scalable way to train HWs who choose to enroll. Low pre-test scores suggest that there are gaps in IPC knowledge among this learner population.
BackgroundWhether medical education research (MER) is primarilyconducted in wealthy countries (in the Realm of the Rich) is the subject of an ongoing debate. Previous studies of the geography of MER publication output have relied upon proprietary databases, have not compared MER with other fields of study, and have not studied the relationship between authorship geography and topics of study.This study was designed to evaluate the geographic distribution ofMERauthorship and to relate this to thetopics studied in MER.MethodsAuthors' countries of affiliation were identified from PubMed records by parsing and cleaning the text of affiliations and submitting them to the google maps geocoding API. The geography of publication output in MER was compared to other fields using the chi-square goodness-of-fit test. Country income classifications and medical subject heading (MeSH) terms were used to evaluate the topical contributions of countries at different income levels, and simulation was used to compute significance of MeSH term enrichment in MER papers from low income and lower middle income countries.ResultsThe vast majority of MER papers were contributed by authors based in high income countries. The top four countries were the United States, the United Kingdom, Canada, and Australia, with listed author affiliations in 80% of all MER papers. This percentage was greater in MER than in several other categories, including Biological Science Disciplines (48%), Medicine (69%) and Education (74%), which is a parent category of MER. Authors from low income countries contributed significantly to the topical diversity of MER. MeSH terms associated with government, community health, and health delivery were enriched in papers from low income countries, while terms associated with specialty and clinical training, technology in teaching, and professional obligations (such as workload, burnout, and empathy) were enriched in papers from high income countries.ConclusionsGeographic disparities in publication output are greater in MER than in any other field examined. The historical origins of MER in North America might explain disproportionate publication output by authors from this region. This study suggests that the MER field benefits from research contributed by authors from low income countries, and also points to potential gaps in MER (and medical education as a whole) in the developing world.
Open access publication rates have been steadily increasing over time. In spite of this growth, academics in low income settings struggle to gain access to the full canon of research literature. While the vast majority of open access repositories and funding organizations with open access policies are based in high income countries, the geographic patterns of open access publication itself are not well characterized. In this study, we developed a computational approach to better understand the topical and geographical landscape of open access publications in the biomedical research literature. Surprisingly, we found a strong negative correlation between country per capita income and the percentage of open access publication. Open access publication rates were particularly high in sub-Saharan Africa, but vastly lower in the Middle East and North Africa, South Asia, and East Asia and the Pacific. These effects persisted when considering papers only bearing authors from within each region and income group. However, papers resulting from international collaborations did have a higher percentage of OA than single-country papers, and inter-regional collaboration increased OA publication for all world regions. There was no clear relationship between the number of open access policies in a region and the percentage of open access publications in that region. To understand the distribution of open access across topics of biomedical research, we examined keywords that were most enriched and depleted in open access papers. Keywords related to genomics, computational biology, animal models, and infectious disease were enriched in open access publications, while keywords related to the environment, nursing, and surgery were depleted in open access publications. This work identifies geographic regions and fields of research that could be priority areas for open access advocacy. The finding that open access publication rates are highest in sub-Saharan Africa and low income countries suggests that factors other than open access policy strongly influence authors' decisions to make their work openly accessible. The high proportion of OA resulting from international collaborations indicates yet another benefit of collaborative research. Certain applied fields of medical research, notably nursing, surgery, and environmental fields, appear to have a greater proportion of fee-for-access publications, which presumably creates barriers that prevent researchers and practitioners in low income settings from accessing the literature in those fields.
As online courses become more common, practitioners are in need of clear guidance on how to translate best educational practices into web-based instruction. Moreover, student engagement is a pressing concern in online courses, which often have high levels of dropout. Our goals in this work were to experimentally study routine instructional design choices and to measure the effects of these choices on students’ subjective experiences (engagement, mind wandering, and interest) in addition to objective learning outcomes. Using randomized controlled trials, we studied the effect of varying instructional activities (namely, assessment and a step-through interactive) on participants’ learning and subjective experiences in a lesson drawn from an online immunology course. Participants were recruited from Amazon Mechanical Turk. Results showed that participants were more likely to drop out when they were in conditions that included assessment. Moreover, assessment with minimal feedback (correct answers only) led to the lowest subjective ratings of any experimental condition. Some of the negative effects of assessment were mitigated by the addition of assessment explanations or a summary interactive. We found no differences between the experimental conditions in learning outcomes, but we did find differences between groups in the accuracy of score predictions. Finally, prior knowledge and self-rated confusion were predictors of post-test scores. Using student behavior data from the same online immunology course, we corroborated the importance of assessment explanations. Our results have a clear implication for course developers: the addition of explanations to assessment questions is a simple way to improve online courses.
Mammalian stress granules (SGs) contain stalled translation preinitiation complexes that are assembled into discrete granules by specific RNA-binding proteins such as G3BP. We now show that cells lacking both G3BP1 and G3BP2 cannot form SGs in response to eukaryotic initiation factor 2α phosphorylation or eIF4A inhibition, but are still SG-competent when challenged with severe heat or osmotic stress. Rescue experiments using G3BP1 mutants show that G3BP1-F33W, a mutant unable to bind G3BP partner proteins Caprin1 or USP10, rescues SG formation. Caprin1/USP10 binding to G3BP is mutually exclusive: Caprin binding promotes, but USP10 binding inhibits, SG formation. G3BP interacts with 40S ribosomal subunits through its RGG motif, which is also required for G3BP-mediated SG formation. We propose that G3BP mediates the condensation of SGs by shifting between two different states that are controlled by binding to Caprin1 or USP10.
Apoptosis is a tightly coordinated cell death program that damages mitochondria, DNA, proteins, and membrane lipids. Little is known about the fate of RNA as cells die. Here, we show that mRNAs, but not noncoding RNAs, are rapidly and globally degraded during apoptosis. mRNA decay is triggered early in apoptosis, preceding membrane lipid scrambling, genomic DNA fragmentation, and apoptotic changes to translation initiation factors. mRNA decay depends on mitochondrial outer membrane permeabilization and is amplified by caspase activation. 3 ' truncated mRNA decay intermediates with nontemplated uridylate-rich tails are generated during apoptosis. These tails are added by the terminal uridylyl transferases (TUTases) ZCCHC6 and ZCCHC11, and the uridylated transcript intermediates are degraded by the 3 ' to 5 ' exonuclease DIS3L2. Knockdown of DIS3L2 or the TUTases inhibits apoptotic mRNA decay, translation arrest, and cell death, whereas DIS3L2 overexpression enhances cell death. Our results suggest that global mRNA decay is an overlooked hallmark of apoptosis.
The miR-200 family promotes the epithelial state by suppressing the Zeb1/Zeb2 epithelial gene transcriptional repressors. To identify other miR-200-regulated genes, we isolated mRNAs bound to transfected biotinylated miR-200c in mouse breast cancer cells. In all, 520 mRNAs were significantly enriched in miR-200c binding at least twofold. Putative miR-200-regulated genes included Zeb2, enriched 3.5-fold in the pull down. However, Zeb2 knockdown does not fully recapitulate miR-200c overexpression, suggesting that regulating other miR-200 targets contributes to miR-200’s enhancement of epithelial gene expression. Candidate genes were highly enriched for miR-200c seed pairing in their 3′UTR and coding sequence and for genes that were downregulated by miR-200c overexpression. Epidermal growth factor receptor and downstream MAPK signaling pathways were the most enriched pathways. Genes whose products mediate transforming growth factor (TGF)-β signaling were also significantly overrepresented, and miR-200 counteracted the suppressive effects of TGF-β and bone morphogenic protein 2 (BMP-2) on epithelial gene expression. miR-200c regulated the 3′UTRs of 12 of 14 putative miR-200c-binding mRNAs tested. The extent of mRNA binding to miR-200c strongly correlated with gene suppression. Twelve targets of miR-200c (Crtap, Fhod1, Smad2, Map3k1, Tob1, Ywhag/14-3-3γ, Ywhab/14-3-3β, Smad5, Zfp36, Xbp1, Mapk12, Snail1) were experimentally validated by identifying their 3′UTR miR-200 recognition elements. Smad2 and Smad5 form a complex with Zeb2 and Ywhab/14-3-3β and Ywhag/14-3-3γ form a complex with Snail1. These complexes that repress transcription assemble on epithelial gene promoters. miR-200 overexpression induced RNA polymerase II localization and reduced Zeb2 and Snail1 binding to epithelial gene promoters. Expression of miR-200-resistant Smad5 modestly, but significantly, reduced epithelial gene induction by miR-200. miR-200 expression and Zeb2 knockdown are known to inhibit cell invasion in in vitro assays. Knockdown of each of three novel miR-200 target genes identified here, Smad5, Ywhag and Crtap, also profoundly suppressed cell invasion. Thus, miR-200 suppresses TGF-β/BMP signaling, promotes epithelial gene expression and suppresses cell invasion by regulating a network of genes.
Killer lymphocyte granzyme (Gzm) serine proteases induce apoptosis of pathogen-infected cells and tumor cells. Many known Gzm substrates are nucleic acid binding proteins, and the Gzms accumulate in the target cell nucleus by an unknown mechanism. In this study, we show that human Gzms bind to DNA and RNA with nanomolar affinity. Gzms cleave their substrates most efficiently when both are bound to nucleic acids. RNase treatment of cell lysates reduces Gzm cleavage of RNA binding protein targets, whereas adding RNA to recombinant RNA binding protein substrates increases in vitro cleavage. Binding to nucleic acids also influences Gzm trafficking within target cells. Preincubation with competitor DNA and DNase treatment both reduce Gzm nuclear localization. The Gzms are closely related to neutrophil proteases, including neutrophil elastase (NE) and cathepsin G. During neutrophil activation, NE translocates to the nucleus to initiate DNA extrusion into neutrophil extracellular traps, which bind NE and cathepsin G. These myeloid cell proteases, but not digestive serine proteases, also bind DNA strongly and localize to nuclei and neutrophil extracellular traps in a DNA-dependent manner. Thus, high-affinity nucleic acid binding is a conserved and functionally important property specific to leukocyte serine proteases. Furthermore, nucleic acid binding provides an elegant and simple mechanism to confer specificity of these proteases for cleavage of nucleic acid binding protein substrates that play essential roles in cellular gene expression and cell proliferation.
When released from cytotoxic T lymphocytes and natural killer cells, Granzyme (Gzm) serine proteases induce programmed cell death of pathogen-infected cells and tumor cells. The Gzms rapidly accumulate in the target cell nucleus by an unknown mechanism. Many of the known substrates of GzmA and GzmB, the most abundant killer cell proteases, bind to DNA or RNA. Gzm substrates predicted by unbiased proteomics studies are also highly enriched for nucleic acid binding proteins. Here we show by fluorescence polarization assays that Gzms bind DNA and RNA with nanomolar affinity. We hypothesized that Gzm binding to nucleic acids enhances nuclear accumulation in target cells and facilitates their cleavage of nucleic acid-binding substrates. In fact, RNase treatment of cell lysates reduced cleavage of RNA binding protein (RBP) targets by GzmA and GzmB. Moreover, adding RNA to recombinant RBP substrates greatly enhanced in vitro cleavage by GzmB, but adding RNA to non-nucleic acid binding proteins did not. For example, exogenous RNA enhanced GzmB cleavage of recombinant hnRNP C1 (an RBP) but not LMNB1 (a non-RBP). In addition, GzmB cleaved the RNA-binding HuR protein efficiently only when it was bound to an HuR-binding RNA oligonucleotide, but not in the presence of an equal amount of non-binding RNA. Thus, nucleic acids facilitate Gzm cleavage of nucleic acid binding substrates.
Studies of the regulation of gene expression historically focused on transcription. However, during stress and apoptosis, profound gene expression changes occur more rapidly and globally than is possible by regulating transcription. Posttranscriptional changes in mRNA processing and translation in response to diverse stresses shut down most protein translation to conserve energy and lead to rapid remodeling of the proteome to promote repair. Pre-mRNA splicing and mRNA stability are fundamentally altered under some stress conditions. Stress pathways coordinate a cytoprotective repair response, while simultaneously initiating signaling that can ultimately trigger cell death. How the cell mediates the decision between repair and apoptosis is largely not understood. In some stresses, microRNAs may tip the balance. Here, we review what is known about posttranscriptional gene regulation during stress, focusing on what is still unknown and how new technologies might be used to understand what changes are most physiologically important in different forms of stress and death.
During immune-mediated death, death-inducing granzyme (Gzm) proteases concentrate in the nucleus of cells targeted for immune elimination, suggesting that nuclear processes are important targets. Here we used differential 2D proteomics of GzmA-treated nuclei to identify potential GzmA substrates. Of 44 candidates, 33 were RNA-binding proteins important in posttranscriptional RNA processing, including 14 heterogeneous nuclear ribonucleoproteins (hnRNP). Multiple hnRNPs were degraded in cells undergoing GzmA-, GzmB-, or caspase-mediated death. GzmA and caspase activation impaired nuclear export of newly synthesized RNA and disrupted pre-mRNA splicing. Expressing GzmA-resistant hnRNP A1 inhibited GzmA-mediated cell death and rescued pre-mRNA splicing, suggesting that hnRNP A1 is an important GzmA substrate. Cellular stresses are known to inhibit initiation of cap-dependent translation. Disrupting pre-mRNA processing should block further new protein synthesis and promote death by interfering with pathways induced to protect cells from death.
A simple biochemical method to isolate mRNAs pulled down with a transfected, biotinylated microRNA was used to identify direct target genes of miR‐34a, a tumor suppressor gene. The method reidentified most of the known miR‐34a regulated genes expressed in K562 and HCT116 cells. The transcripts pulled down with miR‐34a were highly enriched for their roles in growth factor signaling and regulation of p53 activity. These genes regulate multiple signal transduction pathways that orchestrate the proliferative response to external growth stimuli. Multiple candidate miR‐34a‐regulated genes participate in RAS‐RAF‐MAPK signaling. Ectopic miR‐34a expression reduced basal ERK and AKT phosphorylation and enhanced sensitivity to serum growth factor withdrawal, while cells genetically deficient in miR‐34a were less sensitive. Several novel direct targets of miR‐34a were experimentally validated, including genes that participate in growth factor signaling as well as genes that regulate p53 activity. Thus miR‐34a tempers the proliferative and pro‐survival effect of growth factor stimulation by interfering with growth factor signal transduction and downstream pathways required for cell division.
Here we report the generation and characterization of 84 mouse ES cell lines with doxycycline-controllable transcription factors (TFs) which, together with the previous 53 lines, cover 7–10% of all TFs encoded in the mouse genome. Global gene expression profiles of all 137 lines after the induction of TFs for 48 hrs can associate each TF with the direction of ES cell differentiation, regulatory pathways and mouse phenotypes. These cell lines and microarray data provide building blocks for a variety of future biomedical research applications as a community resource.
A simple biochemical method to isolate mRNAs pulled down with a transfected, biotinylated microRNA was used to identify direct target genes of miR-34a, a tumor suppressor gene. The method reidentified most of the known miR-34a regulated genes expressed in K562 and HCT116 cancer cell lines. Transcripts for 982 genes were enriched in the pull-down with miR-34a in both cell lines. Despite this large number, validation experiments suggested that ~90% of the genes identified in both cell lines can be directly regulated by miR-34a. Thus miR-34a is capable of regulating hundreds of genes. The transcripts pulled down with miR-34a were highly enriched for their roles in growth factor signaling and cell cycle progression. These genes form a dense network of interacting gene products that regulate multiple signal transduction pathways that orchestrate the proliferative response to external growth stimuli. Multiple candidate miR-34a-regulated genes participate in RAS-RAF-MAPK signaling. Ectopic miR-34a expression reduced basal ERK and AKT phosphorylation and enhanced sensitivity to serum growth factor withdrawal, while cells genetically deficient in miR-34a were less sensitive. Fourteen new direct targets of miR-34a were experimentally validated, including genes that participate in growth factor signaling (ARAF and PIK3R2) as well as genes that regulate cell cycle progression at various phases of the cell cycle (cyclins D3 and G2, MCM2 and MCM5, PLK1 and SMAD4). Thus miR-34a tempers the proliferative and pro-survival effect of growth factor stimulation by interfering with growth factor signal transduction and downstream pathways required for cell division.
BACKGROUND:In addition to determining static states of gene expression (high vs. low), it is important to characterize their dynamic status. For example, genes with H3K27me3 chromatin marks are not only suppressed but also poised for activation. However, the responsiveness of genes to perturbations has never been studied systematically. To distinguish gene responses to specific factors from responsiveness in general, it is necessary to analyze gene expression profiles of cells responding to a large variety of disturbances, and such databases did not exist before.RESULTS:We estimated the responsiveness of all genes in mouse ES cells using our recently published database on expression change after controlled induction of 53 transcription factors (TFs) and other genes. Responsive genes (N=4746), which were readily upregulated or downregulated depending on the kind of perturbation, mostly have regulatory functions and a propensity to become tissue-specific upon differentiation. Tissue-specific expression was evaluated on the basis of published (GNF) and our new data for 15 organs and tissues. Non-responsive genes (N=9562), which did not change their expression much following any perturbation, were enriched in housekeeping functions. We found that TF-responsiveness in ES cells is the best predictor known for tissue-specificity in gene expression. Among genes with CpG islands, high responsiveness is associated with H3K27me3 chromatin marks, and low responsiveness is associated with H3K36me3 chromatin, stronger tri-methylation of H3K4, binding of E2F1, and GABP binding motifs in promoters.CONCLUSIONS:We thus propose the responsiveness of expression to perturbations as a new way to define the dynamic status of genes, which brings new insights into mechanisms of regulation of gene expression and tissue specificity.