Regulators and industry are actively seeking improvements and alternatives to current models and approaches to evaluate potential carcinogenicity of gene therapies (GTs). A meeting of invited experts was organized by NC3Rs/UKEMS (London, March 2023) to discuss this topic. This article describes the consensus reached among delegates on the definition of vector genotoxicity, sources of uncertainty, suitable toxicological endpoints for genotoxic assessment of GTs, and future research needs. The collected recommendations should inform the further development of regulatory guidelines for the nonclinical toxicological assessment of GT products.

Genetic modification of cells using viral vectors has shown huge therapeutic benefit in multiple diseases. However, inefficient transduction contributes to the high cost of these therapies. Several transduction-enhancing small molecules have previously been identified; however, some may be toxic to the cells or patient, otherwise alter cellular characteristics, or further increase manufacturing complexity. In this study, we aimed to identify molecules capable of enhancing lentiviral transduction of T cells from available small-molecule libraries. We conducted a high-throughput flow-cytometry-based screen of 27,892 compounds, which subsequently was narrowed down to six transduction-enhancing small molecules for further testing with two therapeutic lentiviral vectors used to manufacture GSK's clinical T cell therapy products. We demonstrate enhanced transduction without a negative impact on other product attributes. Furthermore, we present results of transcriptomic analysis, suggesting alteration of ribosome biogenesis, resulting in reduced interferon response, as a potential mechanism of action for the transduction-enhancing activity of the lead compound. Finally, we demonstrate the ability of the lead transduction enhancer to produce a comparable T cell product using a 3-fold reduction in vector volume in our clinical manufacturing process, resulting in a predicted 15% reduction in the overall cost of goods.

The antitumor activity of adoptive T cell therapies (ACT) is highly dependent on the expansion, persistence, and continued activity of adoptively transferred cells. Clinical studies using ACTs have revealed that products that possess and maintain less differentiated phenotypes, including memory and precursor T cells, show increased antitumor efficacy and superior patient outcomes owing to their increased expansion, persistence, and ability to differentiate into effector progeny that elicit antitumor responses. Strategies that drive the differentiation into memory or precursor-type T cell subsets with high potential for persistence and self-renewal will enhance adoptively transferred T cell maintenance and promote durable antitumor efficacy. Because of the high costs associated with ACT manufacturing, ACTs are often only offered to patients after multiple rounds of systemic therapy. An essential factor to consider in producing autologous ACT medicinal products is the impact of the patient’s initial T cell fitness and subtype composition, which will likely differ with age, disease history, and treatment with prior anti-cancer therapies. This study evaluated the impact of systemic anti-cancer therapy for non-small cell lung cancer treatment on the T cell phenotype of the patient at baseline and the quality and characteristics of the genetically modified autologous T cell therapy product after manufacturing.

Retroviral insertional mutagenesis (RIM) is both a relevant risk in gene therapy and a powerful tool for identifying genes that enhance the competitiveness of repopulating hematopoietic stem and progenitor cells (HSPCs). However, focusing only on the gene closest to the retroviral vector insertion site (RVIS) may underestimate the effects of RIM, as dysregulation of distal and/or multiple genes by a single insertion event was reported in several studies. As a proof of concept, we examined the common insertion site (CIS) Bcl-x(L), which revealed seven genes located within +/- 150 kb from the RVIS for our study. We confirmed that Bcl-x(L) enhanced the competitiveness of HSPCs, whereas the Bcl-x(L) neighbor Id1 hindered HSPC long-term repopulation. This negative influence of Id1 could be counteracted by co-expressing Bcl-x(L). Interestingly, >90% of early reconstituted myeloid cells were found to originate from transduced HSPCs upon simultaneous overexpression of Bcl-x(L) and Id1, which implies that Bcl-x(L) and Id1 can collaborate to rapidly replenish the myeloid compartment under stress conditions. To directly compare the competitiveness of HSPCs conveyed by multiple transgenes, we developed a multiple competitor competitive repopulation (MCCR) assay to simultaneously screen effects on HSPC repopulating capacity in a single mouse. The MCCR assay revealed that multiple genes within a CIS can have positive or negative impact on hematopoiesis. Furthermore, these data highlight the importance of studying multiple genes located within the proximity of an insertion site to understand complex biological effects, especially as the number of gene therapy patients increases.

Stable suspension producer cell lines for the production of vesicular stomatitis virus envelope glycoprotein (VSVg)-pseudotyped lentiviral vectors represent an attractive alternative to current widely used production methods based on transient transfection of adherent 293T cells with multiple plasmids. We report here a method to rapidly generate such producer cell lines from 293T cells by stable transfection of a single DNA construct encoding all lentiviral vector components. The resulting suspension cell lines yield titers as high as can be achieved with transient transfection, can be readily scaled up in single-use stirred-tank bioreactors, and are genetically and functionally stable in extended cell culture. By removing the requirement for efficient transient transfection during upstream processing of lentiviral vectors and switching to an inherently scalable suspension cell culture format, we believe that this approach will result in significantly higher batch yields than are possible with current manufacturing processes and enable better patient access to medicines based on lentiviral vectors.

The aged hematopoietic system is characterized by decreased immuno-competence and by a reduced number of hematopoietic stem cells (HSCs) that actively generates new blood cell (age-related clonal hematopoiesis, ARCH). While both aspects are commonly associated with an increased risk of aging-related diseases, it is currently unknown to what extent these aspects co-occur during exceptional longevity. Here, we investigated these aspects in blood cells of an immuno-hematopoietically normal female who reached 111 years. Blood samples were collected across a 9-year period at ages 103, 110 and 111 years. We applied several genetic sequencing approaches to investigate clonality in peripheral blood samples and sorted cell subsets. Immuno-competence was characterized using flow cytometry, T-cell receptor excision circle (TREC) assays, and in vitro proliferation assays. We identified a single DNMT3A -mutated HSC clone with a complex subclonal architecture and observed ongoing subclonal dynamics within the 9-year timeframe of our sampling. The mutated HSC generated 78-87% myeloid cells, 6-7% of the B-cells, 6% of CD8+ T-cells, and notably 22% of the CD4+ T-cells. Intriguingly, we found that T-cells were capable of robust proliferation when challenged in vitro . Moreover, we observed a surprisingly high TREC content, indicative of recent generation of naive T-cells. Concluding, we observed long-term stability of extreme ARCH with ongoing clonal dynamics combined with functional T-cell immunity. Our results indicate that extreme ARCH does not compromise immuno-competence and that a clonally expanded CD4+ T-cell subset may serve as a potential hallmark of the supercentenarian immune system. Key points 1. Longitudinal blood sampling from a female aged 103-111 revealed a dynamic clonal hematopoiesis contributing to myeloid and lymphoid subsets 2. Despite the highly advanced age and extreme clonal hematopoiesis we observed functional T-cell immunity ### Competing Interest Statement The authors have declared no competing interest.

T cell factor 1 (Tcf1) is the first T cell-specific protein induced by Notch signaling in the thymus, leading to the activation of two major target genes, Gata3 and Bcl11b. Tcf1 deficiency results in partial arrests in T cell development, high apoptosis, and increased development of B and myeloid cells. Phenotypically, seemingly fully T cell-committed thymocytes with Tcf1 deficiency have promiscuous gene expression and an altered epigenetic profile and can dedifferentiate into more immature thymocytes and non-T cells. Restoring Bcl11b expression in Tcf1-deficient cells rescues T cell development but does not strongly suppress the development of non-T cells; in contrast, expressing Gata3 suppresses their development but does not rescue T cell development. Thus, T cell development is controlled by a minimal transcription factor network involving Notch signaling, Tcf1, and the subsequent division of labor between Bcl11b and Gata3, thereby ensuring a properly regulated T cell gene expression program.

Lentiviral vector genomic RNA requires sequences that partially overlap wild-type HIV-1 gag and env genes for packaging into vector particles. These HIV-1 packaging sequences constitute 19.6% of the wild-type HIV-1 genome and contain functional cis elements that potentially compromise clinical safety. Here, we describe the development of a novel lentiviral vector (LTR1) with a unique genomic structure designed to prevent transfer of HIV-1 packaging sequences to patient cells, thus reducing the total HIV-1 content to just 4.8% of the wild type genome. This has been achieved by reconfiguring the vector to mediate reverse-transcription with a single strand transfer, instead of the usual two, and in which HIV-1 packaging sequences are not copied. We show that LTR1 vectors offer improved safety in their resistance to remobilization in HIV-1 particles and reduced frequency of splicing into human genes. Following intravenous luciferase vector administration to neonatal mice, LTR1 sustained a higher level of liver trans gene expression than an equivalent dose of a standard lentivirus. LTR1 vectors produce reverse-transcription products earlier and start to express transgenes significantly quicker than standard lentiviruses after transduction. Finally, we show that LTR1 is an effective lentiviral gene therapy vector as demonstrated by correction of a mouse hemophilia B model.

SignificanceRefractory celiac disease type II (RCDII) is a severe variant of celiac disease, an autoimmune disorder of the small intestine caused by inflammatory T-cell responses to gluten, a common food protein. Typical of RCDII is the presence of aberrant lymphocytes in the duodenal epithelium, which often give rise to a lethal lymphoma. A single growth factor promoting the expansion of aberrant cells has been identified: epithelial cell-derived IL-15. The experiments described in this paper identify three additional growth factors—TNF, IL-2, and IL-21—produced by gluten-specific T cells. Thus, these findings suggest a potential mechanism for the contribution of gluten-specific T cells to RCDII.

Overexpression of LMO2 is known to be one of the causes of T-cell acute lymphoblastic leukemia (T-ALL) development; however, the mechanisms behind its oncogenic activity are incompletely understood. LMO2-overexpressing transgenic mouse models suggest an accumulation of immature T-cell progenitors in the thymus as the main preleukemic event. The effects of LMO2 overexpression on human T-cell development in vivo are unknown. Here, we report studies of a humanized mouse model transplanted with LMO2-transduced human hematopoietic stem/progenitor cells. The effects of LMO2 overexpression were confined to the T-cell lineage; however; initially, multipotent cells were transduced. Three effects of LMO2 on human T-cell development were observed: (1) a block at the double-negative/immature single-positive stage, (2) an accumulation of CD4(+)CD8(+) double-positive CD3(-) cells, and (3) an altered CD8/CD4 ratio with enhanced peripheral T lymphocytes. Microarray analysis of sorted double-positive cells overexpressing LMO2 led to the identification of an LMO2 gene set that clustered with human T-ALL patient samples of the described "proliferative" cluster. In this article, we demonstrate previously unrecognized mechanisms by which LMO2 alters human T-cell development in vivo; these mechanisms correlate with human T-ALL leukemogenesis. Copyright (C) 2016 ISEH - International Society for Experimental Hematology. Published by Elsevier Inc.

In contrast to all other blood and immune cells, T lymphocytes do not develop in the bone marrow (BM), but in the specialized microenvironment provided by the thymus. Similar to the other lineages, however, all T cells arise from multipotent hematopoietic stem cells (HSCs) that reside in the BM. Not all HSCs give rise to T cells; but how many and what kind of developmental checkpoints are located along this intricate differentiation path is the subject of intense research. Traditionally, this process has been studied almost exclusively using mouse cells, but recent advances in immunodeficient mouse models, high‐speed cell sorting, lentiviral transduction protocols, and deep sequencing techniques have allowed these questions to be addressed using human cells. Here we review the process of thymic seeding by BM‐derived cells and T cell commitment in humans, discussing recent insights into the clonal composition of the thymus and the definition of developmental checkpoints, on the basis of insights from human severe combined immunodeficiency patients.

Background: Severe combined immunodeficiency (SCID) represents congenital disorders characterized by a deficiency of T cells caused by arrested development in the thymus. Yet the nature of these developmental blocks has remained elusive because of the difficulty of taking thymic biopsy specimens from affected children.Objective: We sought to identify the stages of arrest in human T-cell development caused by various major types of SCID. Methods: We performed transplantation of SCID CD34(+) bone marrow stem/progenitor cells into an optimized NSG xenograft mouse model, followed by detailed phenotypic and molecular characterization using flow cytometry, immunoglobulin and T-cell receptor spectratyping, and deep sequencing of immunoglobulin heavy chain (IGH) and T-cell receptor delta (TRD) loci.Results: Arrests in T-cell development caused by mutations in IL-7 receptor alpha (IL7RA) and IL-2 receptor gamma (IL2RG) were observed at the most immature thymocytes much earlier than expected based on gene expression profiling of human thymocyte subsets and studies with corresponding mouse mutants. T-cell receptor rearrangements were functionally required at the CD4(-)CD8(-)CD7(+)CD5(+) stage given the developmental block and extent of rearrangements in mice transplanted with Artemis-SCID cells. The xenograft model used is not informative for adenosine deaminase-SCID, whereas hypomorphic mutations lead to less severe arrests in development.Conclusion: Transplanting CD34(+) stem cells from patients with SCID into a xenograft mouse model provides previously unattainable insight into human T-cell development and functionally identifies the arrest in thymic development caused by several SCID mutations.

Canonical Wnt signaling regulates the self-renewal of most if not all stem cell systems. In the blood system, the role of Wnt signaling has been the subject of much debate but there is consensus that high Wnt signals lead to loss of reconstituting capacity. To better understand this phenomenon, we have taken advantage of a series of hypomorphic mutant Apc alleles resulting in a broad range of Wnt dosages in hematopoietic stem cells (HSCs) and performed whole-genome gene expression analyses. Gene expression profiling and functional studies show that HSCs with APC mutations lead to high Wnt levels, enhanced differentiation, and diminished proliferation but have no effect on apoptosis, collectively leading to loss of stemness. Thus, we provide mechanistic insight into the role of APC mutations and Wnt signaling in HSC biology. As Wnt signals are explored in various in vivo and ex vivo expansion protocols for HSCs, our findings also have clinical ramifications.

Objective Coeliac disease (CD), a gluten-induced enteropathy, alters the composition and function of duodenal intraepithelial T cells. The intestine also harbours four types of CD3-negative intraepithelial lymphocytes (IELs) with largely unknown function: CD56(-)CD127(-), CD56(-)CD127(+), CD56(+)CD127(-) and CD56(+)CD127(+). Here we aimed to gain insight into the potential function of these innate IELs in health and disease.Design We determined the phenotypes, relative abundance and differentiation potential of these innate IEL subsets in duodenal biopsies from controls and patients with CD or patients with refractory CD type II (RCDII).Results Hierarchical clustering analysis of the expression of 15 natural killer and T cell surface markers showed that innate IELs differed markedly from innate peripheral blood lymphocytes and divided innate IEL subsets into two main branches: a CD127(-) branch expressing high levels of interleukin (IL) 2/15R beta but no IL-21R, and a CD127(+) branch with the opposite phenotype. While CD was characterised by the contraction of all four innate IEL subsets, a selective expansion of CD56(-)CD127(-) and CD56(-)CD127(+) innate IEL was detected in RCDII. In vitro, in the presence of IL-15, CD56(-)CD127(-) IEL from controls and patients with CD, but not from patients with RCDII, differentiated into functional natural killer and T cells, the latter largely dependent on notch-signalling. Furthermore, compared with non-coeliac controls, CD56(-)CD127(-) IEL from patients with CD expressed more intracellular CD3 epsilon and CD3 gamma and gave more pronounced T cell differentiation.Conclusions Thus, we demonstrate previously unappreciated diversity and plasticity of the innate IEL compartment and its loss of differentiation potential in patients with RCDII.

Thrombopoietin (Thpo) signals via its receptor Mpl and regulates megakaryopoiesis, hematopoietic stem cell (HSC) maintenance and post-transplant expansion. Mpl expression is tightly controlled and deregulation of Thpo/Mpl-signaling is linked to hematological disorders. Here, we constructed an intracellular-truncated, signaling-deficient Mpl protein which is presented on the cell surface (dnMpl). The transplantation of bone marrow cells retrovirally transduced to express dnMpl into wildtype mice induced thrombocytopenia, and a progressive loss of HSC. The aplastic BM allowed the engraftment of a second BM transplant without further conditioning. Functional analysis of the truncated Mpl in vitro and in vivo demonstrated no internalization after Thpo binding and the inhibition of Thpo/Mpl-signaling in wildtype cells due to dominant-negative (dn) effects by receptor competition with wildtype Mpl for Thpo binding. Intracellular inhibition of Mpl could be excluded as the major mechanism by the use of a constitutive-dimerized dnMpl. To further elucidate the molecular changes induced by Thpo/Mpl-inhibition on the HSC-enriched cell population in the BM, we performed gene expression analysis of Lin-Sca1+cKit+ (LSK) cells isolated from mice transplanted with dnMpl transduced BM cells. The gene expression profile supported the exhaustion of HSC due to increased cell cycle progression and identified new and known downstream effectors of Thpo/Mpl-signaling in HSC (namely TIE2, ESAM1 and EPCR detected on the HSC-enriched LSK cell population). We further compared gene expression profiles in LSK cells of dnMpl mice with human CD34+ cells of aplastic anemia patients and identified similar deregulations of important stemness genes in both cell populations. In summary, we established a novel way of Thpo/Mpl inhibition in the adult mouse and performed in depth analysis of the phenotype including gene expression profiling.

Standard lentiviral vectors (LVs) require sequences from the wild-type virus (most commonly HIV-1) for effective packaging of vector genomes into viral particles. These sequences are preserved in reverse-transcribed proviral DNA, maintaining the packaging signal, major splice sites, the REV-response element (RRE) and CpG islands which amount to approximately 19% of HIV-1 genome in 3rd generation vectors. For gene therapy applications, these regions have been shown to be problematic, or pose potential risks. Vector integrations in proximity to host-cell genes have produced aberrant transcripts through genome-vector splicing. Transcriptional silencing of delivered transgenes can occur through methylation of viral CpG islands and the presence of the packaging signal allows remobilisation of vector genomes in cells expressing LV proteins which could be detrimental in HIV-positive patients. In an attempt to reduce these risks and minimise HIV-1 sequence in the provirus, we have developed the novel LTR-1 vector in which the packaging sequences and RRE are located downstream of the 3' Long Terminal Repeat (LTR). This location means that the essential cis-elements are contained within the RNA genome for efficient processing and encapsidation, but eliminated from the delivered provirus following reverse transcription. This reduces the amount of HIV-1 genome in the integrated provirus to 4.9%. These vectors can be produced to high titre (>108 TU/ml by eGFP flow cytometry) and the proportion of eGFP positive cells is stable between 3 and 14 days post-transduction. Clonal analysis of plasmid rescue experiments confirm LTR-1 proviral sequences lack HIV packaging and RRE sequences following reverse transcription and sequencing confirms the expected structure. Unlike the 3rd generation vector, LTR-1 cannot be remobilised when transduced cells are transfected with HIV-1 packaging constructs. Investigations into safety improvements produced by the LTR-1 modifications are ongoing. Live bioimaging experiments and immunohistochemistry confirm that LTR-1 also functions effectively in vivo when measured for up to 5 weeks post-injection: intracranial or intravenous injections into neonatal mice result in comparable expression levels to standard 3rd generation vectors in the brain and liver respectively. We suggest that this LTR-1 configuration could have an improved safety profile for the next generation of retroviral gene therapy vectors.