Phosphate (Pi) is an essential nutrient for plant growth, and understanding how Arabidopsis thaliana root cells respond to Pi deficiency is crucial to decipher whole plant responses. We perform high-resolution transcriptomic profiling across five distinct root cell types, identifying differentially expressed genes (DEGs) and differential alternative splicing (DAS) events that define cell-type-specific Pi-responsive regulatory layers. We identify over 7000 DEGs and 733 DAS that act largely independently and are cell-type-specific, affecting distinct loci and biological pathways. Transcription factors such as LHY, REV7 and MYB88, linked to circadian rhythms, stomatal regulation and ABA perception, acquire novel functions under Pi starvation. We show that the splicing factor SR45, previously associated with iron homeostasis, regulates Pi allocation. The sr45-1 mutant displays increased root-to-shoot Pi ratio and reduced biomass. A substantial number of Pi-responsive DAS transcripts are SR45 bound, indicating that SR45 operates as a regulatory hub for Pi transport and homeostasis. This cell-type-resolved dataset provides a detailed molecular map of Pi deficiency responses and highlights the importance of post-transcriptional regulation in shaping root adaptive strategies. Transcriptional regulation and alternative splicing emerge as coordinated mechanisms orchestrating plant adaptation to Pi starvation.
The integration of 3D bioprinting into plant science and biotechnology is revolutionizing research and applications. While many high-throughput techniques have advanced plant biology, replicating the complex 3D organization and cellular environments of plant tissues remains a significant challenge. Traditional 2D culture systems fall short of capturing the necessary spatial context for accurate studies of cell behavior, gene expression, and tissue development. Additionally, the lack of precise simulation of plant microenvironments limits control over cellular interactions and responses to external stimuli. Recent advancements in 3D bioprinting address these limitations by allowing precise control over cell positioning and biomaterial arrangement, thereby better replicating natural plant environments. This enables more accurate studies of gene expression, developmental processes, and stress responses. The technology also enhances our ability to test genetic modifications and biotechnological interventions, advancing crop improvement, sustainable agriculture, and precision breeding. This review examines the current state of 3D bioprinting in plant science, discusses its limitations, and explores its potential to transform research and applications in the field.
Regeneration is a unique feature of postembryonic development extensively observed in plants. The capacity to induce regeneration exogenously is limited and usually confined to meristematic-like tissues. We show that bacterial cellulose (BC), but not other structurally similar matrixes, induces postwounding regeneration in nonmeristematic plant tissues via a distinctive route to callus-mediated regenerative programs. The BC-specific program involves cytokinin operating concurrently with strongly activated plant biotic response genes to induce plant regeneration. A reactive oxygen species (ROS) burst, normally associated with defense responses, is sustained upon BC application, involving a network of tightly interconnected transcription factors, where WRKY8, known for regulating stress responses, shows a clustering and hierarchical prevalence. WRKY8 regulates BC-mediated plant regeneration and ROS homeostasis, including superoxide anion accumulation, to potentially promote cell proliferation after wounding. Collectively, our results demonstrate that the cytokinin- and ROS-associated defense responses can be targeted by BC application to promote plant wound regeneration through alternative regenerative programs.
Understanding root development is critical for enhancing plant growth and health, and advanced technologies are essential for unraveling the complexities of these processes. In this review, we highlight select technological innovations in the study of root development, with a focus on the transformative impact of single-cell gene expression analysis. We provide a high-level overview of recent advancements, illustrating how single-cell RNA sequencing (scRNA-seq) has become a pivotal tool in plant biology. scRNA-seq has revolutionized root biology by enabling detailed, cell-specific analysis of gene expression. This has allowed researchers to create comprehensive root atlases, predict cell development, and map gene regulatory networks (GRNs) with unprecedented precision. Complementary technologies, such as multimodal profiling and bioinformatics, further enrich our understanding of cellular dynamics and gene interactions. Innovations in imaging and modeling, combined with genetic tools like CRISPR, continue to deepen our knowledge of root formation and function. Moreover, the integration of these technologies with advanced biosensors and microfluidic devices has advanced our ability to study plant-microbe interactions and phytohormone signaling at high resolution. These tools collectively provide a more comprehensive understanding of root system architecture and its regulation by environmental factors. As these technologies evolve, they promise to drive further breakthroughs in plant science, with substantial implications for agriculture and sustainability.
Auxin dictates root architecture via the Auxin Response Factor (ARF) family of transcription factors, which control lateral root (LR) formation. In Arabidopsis, ARF7 regulates the specification of prebranch sites (PBS) generating LRs through gene expression oscillations and plays a pivotal role during LR initiation. Despite the importance of ARF7 in this process, there is a surprising lack of knowledge about how ARF7 turnover is regulated and how this impacts root architecture. Here, we show that ARF7 accumulates in autophagy mutants and is degraded through NBR1-dependent selective autophagy. We demonstrate that the previously reported rhythmic changes to ARF7 abundance in roots are modulated via autophagy and might occur in other tissues. In addition, we show that the level of co-localization between ARF7 and autophagy markers oscillates and can be modulated by auxin to trigger ARF7 turnover. Furthermore, we observe that autophagy impairment prevents ARF7 oscillation and reduces both PBS establishment and LR formation. In conclusion, we report a novel role for autophagy during development, namely by enacting auxin-induced selective degradation of ARF7 to optimize periodic root branching.
The root system plays an essential role in plant growth and adaptation to the surrounding environment. The root clock periodically specifies lateral root prebranch sites (PBS), where a group of pericycle founder cells (FC) is primed to become lateral root founder cells and eventually give rise to lateral root primordia or lateral roots (LRs). This clock-driven organ formation process is tightly controlled by modulation of auxin content and signaling. Auxin perception entails the physical interaction of TRANSPORT INHIBITOR RESPONSE 1 (TIR1) or AUXIN SIGNALING F-BOX (AFBs) proteins with AUXIN/INDOLE-3-ACETIC ACID (Aux/IAA) repressors to form a co-receptor system. Despite the apparent simplicity, the understanding of how specific auxin co-receptors are assembled remains unclear. We identified the compound bis-methyl auxin conjugated with N-glucoside, or BiAux, in Arabidopsis (Arabidopsis thaliana) that specifically induces the formation of PBS and the emergence of LR, with a slight effect on root elongation. Docking analyses indicated that BiAux binds to F-box proteins, and we showed that BiAux function depends on TIR1 and AFB2 F-box proteins and AUXIN RESPONSE FACTOR 7 activity, which is involved in FC specification and LR formation. Finally, using a yeast (Saccharomyces cerevisiae) heterologous expression system, we showed that BiAux favors the assemblage of specific co-receptors subunits involved in LR formation and enhances AUXIN/INDOLE-3-ACETIC ACID 28 protein degradation. These results indicate that BiAux acts as an allosteric modulator of specific auxin co-receptors. Therefore, BiAux exerts a fine-tune regulation of auxin signaling aimed to the specific formation of LR among the many development processes regulated by auxin.
Plants grow continuously by developing new organs, a complex process that requires the formation of specific and functional tissue patterns. Tap root systems, as observed in Arabidopsis thaliana , undergo lateral root formation, a developmental mechanism that necessitates the establishment of stem cell lineages. However, the underlying mechanisms remain poorly understood. We have reconstructed a spatiotemporal cell-type-specific transcriptional map of early lateral root organogenesis in Arabidopsis, profiling single and double fluorescent markers across 8 different cell types in the root stem cell lineage. Employing dynamic Bayesian network inference, based on time-course experiments and developmental time, alongside tree-based methods, we investigated lineage developmental progression and precursor stem-cell specification. Our results reveal a morphogenic cascade of hierarchical interdependent transcription factors driving stem cell initiation, and identify the QC/Endodermis transitioning cells as root stem cell progenitors. The associated formative program involves a profound transcriptomic re-arrangement, which, remarkably, precedes the activation of known stem-cell transcriptional signatures. Our data support a model in which root-stem-cell networks do not initiate stem formation, although various stem cell regulators are involved. Collectively, our study identifies core transcriptional signatures associated with stem cell induction and elucidates the dynamic regulatory mechanism driving early stem cell lineage establishment. ### Competing Interest Statement The authors have declared no competing interest.
Cysts (CNs) and root-knot nematodes (RKNs) induce specialized feeding cells, syncytia, and giant cells (GCs), respectively, within plant roots. The plant tissues around the GCs usually by respond forming a root swelling called a gall that contains the GCs. The ontogenesis of feeding cells is different. GC formation is a process of new organogenesis from vascular cells, which are still not well characterized, that differentiate into GCs. In contrast, syncytia formation involves the fusion of adjacent cells that have already differentiated. Nonetheless, both feeding sites show an auxin maximum pertinent to feeding site formation. However, data on the molecular divergences and similarities between the formation of both feeding sites regarding auxin-responsive genes are still scarce. We studied genes from the auxin transduction pathways that are crucial during gall and lateral root (LR) development in the CN interaction by using promoter-reporter (GUS/LUC)transgenic lines, as well as loss of function lines of Arabidopsis. The promoters pGATA23 and several deletions of pmiR390a were active in syncytia, as were in galls, but pAHP6 or putative up-stream regulators as ARF5/7/19 were not active in syncytia. Additionally, none of these genes seemed to play a key role during cyst nematode establishment in Arabidopsis, as the infection rates in loss of function lines did not show significant differences compared to control Col-0 plants. Furthermore, the presence of only canonical AuxRe elements in their proximal promoter regions is highly correlated with their activation in galls/GCs (AHP6, LBD16), but those promoters active in syncytia (miR390, GATA23) carry AuxRe overlapping core cis-elements for other transcription factor families (i.e., bHLH, bZIP). Strikingly, in silico transcriptomic analysis showed very few genes upregulated by auxins common to those induced in GCs and syncytia, despite the high number of upregulated IAA responsive genes in syncytia and galls. The complex regulation of auxin transduction pathways, where different members of the auxin response factor (ARF) family may interact with other factors, and the differences in auxin sensitivity, as indicated by the lower induction of the DR5 sensor in syncytia than galls, among other factors, may explain the divergent regulation of auxin responsive genes in the two types of nematode feeding sites.
Nitrogen (N) is an essential macronutrient and its bioavailability plays a major role in how plant development is tuned to environmental nutrient status. To find novel factors in early root system architecture responses to N conditions, we performed Arabidopsis thaliana root transcriptome profiling of a short-term time course in limiting and sufficient N conditions. Using this data, we inferred transcriptional regulatory networks in each condition, which revealed the N-condition specific responses of jasmonate regulation; transcriptional factor (TF) ERF107 plays a more generalized role in lateral root development while TF LBD13 is specific to N-limiting conditions. Further, we used a single cell LR cell-type specific transcriptome dataset to model and analyze the roles of TFs LBD13, ERF107, and PDF2 in early stages of LR development. Linking the N time course transcriptomics, LR mutant phenotypes, and cell-type specific single cell profiling, these approaches provide multiple lines of evidence to find and test the roles of TFs that are involved in early root patterning responses to N conditions.
1. ABSTRACT Lateral root growth occurs from primed xylem pole pericycle cells that can be specified as founder cells, but how these cells acquire the pluripotency state to initiate a root organogenesis program is not fully understood. Here, we find that the EMS 204 mutant is unable to specify founder cells due to a point mutation affecting the C-terminal HDS3 domain of the GNOM protein. We used genetics and cell biology to study the trafficking machinery of xylem pole pericycle cells, cells in which GNOM is primarily associated with recycling endosomes. We found that the lack of the HDS3 domain negatively affects the stability of the GNOM protein within the cells of the xylem pole pericycle and, subsequently, the integrity of the trafficking machinery of these cells. We determined that GNOM is responsible for the recycling of AUX1 toward the plasma membrane at the xylem pole pericycle and impairment of this recycling results in premature accumulation of AUX1 in the vacuole. In this work, we describe a cell type-specific cellular mechanism and the role of a particular domain during lateral root development.
Plant growth and development involve the specification and regeneration of stem cell niches (SCNs). Although plants are exposed to disparate environmental conditions, how environmental cues affect developmental programs and stem cells is not well understood. Root stem cells are accommodated in meristems in SCNs around the quiescent center (QC), which maintains their activity. Using a combination of genetics and confocal microscopy to trace morphological defects and correlate them with changes in gene expression and protein levels, we show that the cold-induced transcription factor (TF) C-REPEAT BINDING FACTOR 3 (CBF3), which has previously been associated with cold acclimation, regulates root development, stem cell activity, and regeneration. CBF3 is integrated into the SHORT-ROOT (SHR) regulatory network, forming a feedback loop that maintains SHR expression. CBF3 is primarily expressed in the root endodermis, whereas the CBF3 protein is localized to other meristematic tissues, including root SCNs. Complementation of cbf3-1 using a wild-type CBF3 gene and a CBF3 fusion with reduced mobility show that CBF3 movement capacity is required for SCN patterning and regulates root growth. Notably, cold induces CBF3, affecting QC activity. Furthermore, exposure to moderate cold around 10°C-12°C promotes root regeneration and QC respecification in a CBF3-dependent manner during the recuperation period. By contrast, CBF3 does not appear to regulate stem cell survival, which has been associated with recuperation from more acute cold (∼4°C). We propose a role for CBF3 in mediating the molecular interrelationships among the cold response, stem cell activity, and development.
Oscillatory mechanisms are present in most life forms and regulate biological processes periodically. In multicellular organisms where more than one oscillatory mechanism is present, they are organized forming a hierarchical coordinated system even at the cellular level. Here, we focus on the Root Clock, an oscillatory mechanism located at the tip of roots that patterns the spacing of lateral organs through oscillating gene expression. We present a series of recent findings and hypotheses about the cellular mechanisms driving the oscillations, how oscillatory information is transmitted within this clock and similarities with other oscillatory systems. Next, we review principles of communication in other pulsatile mechanisms such as circadian rhythms in plants and mammals, and address the possible communication between plant circadian rhythms and the Root Clock. Finally, we advocate for the use of single-cell approaches to address cell communication, synchronization and integration of external outputs into the Root Clock system.
The root system is essential for the survival of terrestrial plants, plant development, and adaptation to changing environments. The development of the root system relies on post-embryonic organogenesis and more specifically on the formation and growth of lateral roots (LR). The spacing of LR along the main root is underpinned by a precise prepatterning mechanism called the Root Clock. In Arabidopsis, the primary output of this mechanism involves the generation of periodic gene expression oscillations in a zone close to the root tip called the Oscillation Zone (OZ). Because of these oscillations, pre-branch sites (PBS) are established in the positions from which LR will emerge, although the oscillations can also possibly regulate the root wavy pattern and growth. Furthermore, we show that the Root Clock is present in LR. In this review, we describe the recent advances unraveling the inner machinery of Root Clock as well as the new tools to track the Root Clock activity. Moreover, we discuss the basis of how Arabidopsis can balance the creation of a repetitive pattern while integrating both endogenous and exogenous signals to adapt to changing environmental conditions. These signals can work as entrainment signals, but in occasions they also affect the periodicity and amplitude of the oscillatory dynamics in gene expression. Finally, we identify similarities with the Segmentation Clock of vertebrates and postulate the existence of a determination front delimiting the end of the oscillations in gene expression and initiating LR organogenesis through the activation of PBS in an ARF7 dependent-manner.
The root system is essential for the survival of terrestrial plants, plant development, and adaptation to changing environments. The development of the root system relies on post-embryonic organogenesis and more specifically on the formation and growth of lateral roots (LR). The spacing of LR along the main root is underpinned by a precise prepatterning mechanism called the Root Clock. In Arabidopsis, the primary output of this mechanism involves the generation of periodic gene expression oscillations in a zone close to the root tip called the Oscillation Zone (OZ). Because of these oscillations, pre-branch sites (PBS) are established in the positions from which LR will emerge, although the oscillations can also possibly regulate the root wavy pattern and growth. Furthermore, we show that the Root Clock is present in LR. In this review, we describe the recent advances unraveling the inner machinery of Root Clock as well as the new tools to track the Root Clock activity. Moreover, we discuss the basis of how Arabidopsis can balance the creation of a repetitive pattern while integrating both endogenous and exogenous signals to adapt to changing environmental conditions. These signals can work as entrainment signals, but in occasions they also affect the periodicity and amplitude of the oscillatory dynamics in gene expression. Finally, we identify similarities with the Segmentation Clock of vertebrates and postulate the existence of a determination front delimiting the end of the oscillations in gene expression and initiating LR organogenesis through the activation of PBS in an ARF7 dependent-manner.
Postembryonic organogenesis is critical for plant development. Underground, lateral roots (LRs) form the bulk of mature root systems, yet the ontogeny of the LR primordium (LRP) is not clear. In this study, we performed the single-cell RNA sequencing through the first four stages of LR formation in Arabidopsis. Our analysis led to a model in which a single group of precursor cells, with a cell identity different from their pericycle origins, rapidly reprograms and splits into a mixed ground tissue/stem cell niche fate and a vascular precursor fate. The ground tissue and stem cell niche fates soon separate and a subset of more specialized vascular cells form sucrose transporting phloem cells that appear to connect to the primary root. We did not detect cells resembling epidermis or root cap, suggesting that outer tissues may form later, preceding LR emergence. At this stage, some remaining initial precursor cells form the primordium flanks, while the rest create a reservoir of pluripotent cells that are able to replace the LR if damaged. Laser ablation of the central and lateral LRP regions showed that remaining cells restart the sequence of tissue initiation to form a LR. Collectively, our study reveals an ontological hierarchy for LR formation with an early and sequential split of main root tissues and stem cells.
Over the last decades, research on postembryonic root development has been facilitated by “omics” technologies. Among these technologies, microarrays first, and RNA sequencing (RNA-seq) later, have provided transcriptional information on the underlying molecular processes establishing the basis of System Biology studies in roots. Cell fate specification and development have been widely studied in the primary root, which involved the identification of many cell type transcriptomes and the reconstruction of gene regulatory networks (GRN). The study of lateral root (LR) development has not been an exception. However, the molecular mechanisms regulating cell fate specification during LR formation remain largely unexplored. Recently, single-cell RNA-seq (scRNA-seq) studies have addressed the specification of tissues from stem cells in the primary root. scRNA-seq studies are anticipated to be a useful approach to decipher cell fate specification and patterning during LR formation. In this review, we address the different scRNA-seq strategies used both in plants and animals and how we could take advantage of scRNA-seq to unravel new regulatory mechanisms and reconstruct GRN. In addition, we discuss how to integrate scRNA-seq results with previous RNA-seq datasets and GRN. We also address relevant findings obtained through single-cell based studies and how LR developmental studies could be facilitated by scRNA-seq approaches and subsequent GRN inference. The use of single-cell approaches to investigate LR formation could help to decipher fundamental biological mechanisms such as cell memory, synchronization, polarization, or pluripotency.
In Arabidopsis, the root clock regulates the spacing of lateral organs along the primary root through oscillating gene expression. The core molecular mechanism that drives the root clock periodicity and how it is modified by exogenous cues such as auxin and gravity remain unknown. We identified the key elements of the oscillator (AUXIN RESPONSE FACTOR 7, its auxin-sensitive inhibitor IAA18/POTENT, and auxin) that form a negative regulatory loop circuit in the oscillation zone. Through multilevel computer modeling fitted to experimental data, we explain how gene expression oscillations coordinate with cell division and growth to create the periodic pattern of organ spacing. Furthermore, gravistimulation experiments based on the model predictions show that external auxin stimuli can lead to entrainment of the root clock. Our work demonstrates the mechanism underlying a robust biological clock and how it can respond to external stimuli.
Fluorescence-activated cell sorting (FACS) is a technique used to isolate specific cell populations based on characteristics detected by flow cytometry. FACS has been broadly used in transcriptomic analyses of individual cell types during development or under different environmental conditions. Different protoplast extraction protocols are available for plant roots; however, they were designed for accessible cell populations, which normally were grown in the presence of light, a non-natural and stressful environment for roots. Here, we report a protocol using FACS to isolate root protoplasts from Arabidopsis green fluorescent protein (GFP)-marked lines using the minimum number of enzymes necessary for an optimal yield, and with the root system grown in darkness in the D-Root device. This device mimics natural conditions as the shoot grows in the presence of light while the roots grow in darkness. In addition, we optimized this protocol for specific patterns of scarce cell types inside more differentiated tissues using the mCherry fluorescent protein. We provide detailed experimental protocols for effective protoplasting, subsequent purification through FACS, and RNA extraction. Using this RNA, we generated cDNA and sequencing libraries, proving that our methods can be used for genome-wide transcriptomic analyses of any cell-type from roots grown in darkness.
Stem cells divide and differentiate to form all of the specialized cell types in a multicellular organism. In the Arabidopsis root, stem cells are maintained in an undifferentiated state by a less mitotically active population of cells called the quiescent center (QC). Determining how the QC regulates the surrounding stem cell initials, or what makes the QC fundamentally different from the actively dividing initials, is important for understanding how stem cell divisions are maintained. Here we gained insight into the differences between the QC and the cortex endodermis initials (CEI) by studying the mobile transcription factor SHORTROOT (SHR) and its binding partner SCARECROW (SCR). We constructed an ordinary differential equation model of SHR and SCR in the QC and CEI which incorporated the stoichiometry of the SHR-SCR complex as well as upstream transcriptional regulation of SHR and SCR. Our model prediction, coupled with experimental validation, showed that high levels of the SHR-SCR complex are associated with more CEI division but less QC division. Furthermore, our model prediction allowed us to propose the putative upstream SHR regulators SEUSS and WUSCHEL-RELATED HOMEOBOX 5 and to experimentally validate their roles in QC and CEI division. In addition, our model established the timing of QC and CEI division and suggests that SHR repression of QC division depends on formation of the SHR homodimer. Thus, our results support that SHR-SCR protein complex stoichiometry and regulation of SHR transcription modulate the division timing of two different specialized cell types in the root stem cell niche.