The study of groundwater-surface water interaction has attracted growing interest among researchers in recent years due to its wide range of implications from the perspectives of water management, ecology and contamination. Many of the studies shed light on conditions on a local scale only, without exploring a regional angle. To provide a broad and historical overview of groundwater-surface water interaction, a review of research carried out in Denmark was undertaken due to the high density of studies conducted in the country. The extent to which this topic has been investigated is related to Denmark's physiography and climate, the presence of numerous streams and lakes combined with shallow groundwater, and historical, funding, and administrative decisions. Study topics comprise groundwater detection techniques, numerical modeling, and contaminant issues including nutrients, ranging from point studies all the way to studies at national scale. The increase in studies in recent decades corresponds with the need to maintain the good status of groundwater-dependent ecosystems and protect groundwater resources. This review of three decades of research revealed that problems such as the difference in scales between numerical models and field observations, interdisciplinary research integrating hydrological and biological methods, and the effect of local processes in regional systems remain persistent challenges. Technical progress in the use of unmanned aerial vehicles, distributed temperature sensing, and new cost-effective methods for detecting groundwater discharge as well as the increasing computing capacity of numerical models emerge as opportunities for dealing with complex natural systems that are subject to modifications in future triggered by climate change.This article is categorized under:Science of Water > Hydrological ProcessesScience of Water > Water and Environmental ChangeWater and Life > Nature of Freshwater Ecosystems
The effects of streams and drainage representation in 3D numerical catchment scale models on estimated streamflow contribution were investigated. MODFLOW-USG was used to represent complex geology and a stream network with two different conceptualizations—one with equal cell discretization in the entire model domain and another with refined cell discretization along stream reaches. Both models were calibrated against a large data set including hydraulic heads and streamflow measurements. Though the optimized hydraulic parameters and statistical performance of both model conceptualizations were comparable, their estimated streamflow contribution differed substantially. In the conceptualization with equal cell discretization, the drainage contribution to the streamflow was 13% compared to 41% in the conceptualization with refined cell discretization. The increase in drainage contribution to streamflow was attributed to the increase in drainage area in proximity to the stream reaches arising from the refined discretization. e.g., the cell refinement along stream reaches reduced the area occupied by stream cells allowing for increased drain area adjacent to the stream reaches. As such, an increase in drainage area equivalent to 7% yielded a 146% increase in drainage contribution to streamflow. In-stream field measurements of groundwater-surface water exchange fluxes that were qualitatively compared to calculated fluxes from the models indicated that estimates from the refined model discretization were more representative. Hence, the results of this study accentuate the importance of being able to represent stream and drain flow contribution correctly, that is, to achieve representative exchange fluxes that are crucial in simulating groundwater–surface water exchange of both flow and solute transport in catchment scale modeling. To that end, the in-stream measurements of exchange fluxes showed the potential to serve as a proxy to numerically estimate drainage contribution that is not readily available at the catchment scale.
N‐loads from subsurface, drains, and groundwater‐fed surface (bypass) flows via two riparian zones (crop field and wetland) to a second order stream were investigated by sampling of shallow and deep groundwater on both sides and monthly measurements of bypass flows from springs, drains, and stream including water quality (nitrate). A push‐pull test in the crop field gave a first‐order denitrification rate (0.23 day –1 ). Reactive transport modeling evaluated observations of water chemistry and denitrification processes in the groundwater below the crop field showing that nitrate was completely removed by denitrification with pyrite in the aquifer (model rates of 0.6–2.5 mmol NO 3 L −1 yr −1 ). A drain in the crop field routed ∼10% (bypass) of the regional groundwater inflow to the stream. Buffer efficiency was high at 90%. The wetland on the other side of the stream hosts several locations of nitrate‐rich bypass flow from springs, predominantly through a non‐maintained drainage system of drainpipes and ditches with bypass flow accounting for 59% of the regional flow input. Nitrate was completely removed in groundwater by denitrification with dissolved organic matter in shallow groundwater. The regional inflow and N load to the wetland is amongst the highest recorded and data shows that the N load to the stream is very high. The buffer efficiency ranged from 45% to 83% depending on if all bypass flows contributed to the stream or only the two with visible outflow. A conceptual model for nitrate removal efficiency as a function of Damköhler number and percent bypass flow is proposed.
A numerical study demonstrates the effects of flooding on subsurface hydrological flowpaths and nitrate removal in anoxic groundwater in riparian zones with a top peat layer. A series of two-dimensional numerical simulations with changing conditions for flow (steady state or transient with flooding), hydrogeology, denitrification, and duration of flooding demonstrate how flowpaths, residence times, and nitrate removal are affected. In periods with no flooding groundwater flows horizontally and discharges to the river through the riverbed. During periods with flooding, shallow groundwater is forced upwards as discharge through peat layers that often have more optimal conditions for denitrification caused by the presence of highly reactive organic matter. The contrast in hydraulic conductivity between the sand aquifer and the overlying peat layer, as well as the flooding duration, have a significant role in determining the degree of nitrate removal.
The near coastal zone, hosting the saltwater-freshwater interface, is an important zone that nutrients from terrestrial freshwaters have to pass to reach marine environments. This zone functions as a highly reactive biogeochemical reactor, for which nutrient cycling and budget is controlled by the water circulation within and across that interface. This study addresses the seasonal variation in water circulation, salinity pattern and the temporal seawater-freshwater exchange dynamics at the saltwater-wedge. This is achieved by linking geophysical exploration and numerical modeling to hydrochemical and hydraulic head observations from a lagoon site at the west coast of Denmark. The hydrochemical data from earlier studies suggests that increased inland recharge during winter drives a saltwater-wedge regression (seaward movement) whereas low recharge during summer causes a wedge transgression. Transient variable density model simulations reproduce only the hydraulic head dynamics in response to recharge dynamics, while the salinity distribution across the saltwater wedge cannot be reproduced with accuracy. A dynamic wedge is only simulated in the shallow part of the aquifer (<5 m), while the deeper parts are rather unaffected by fluctuations in freshwater inputs. Fluctuating salinity concentrations in the lagoon cause the development of a temporary intertidal salinity cell. This leads to a reversed density pattern in the underlying aquifer and the development of a freshwater containing discharge tube, which is confined by an overlying and underlying zone of saltwater. This process can explain observed trends in the in-situ data, despite an offset in absolute concentrations. Geophysical data indicates the presence of a deeper low hydraulic conductive unit, which coincides with the stagnant parts of the simulated saltwater-wedge. Thus, exchange fluxes refreshing the deeper low permeable areas are reduced. Consequently, this study suggests a very significant seasonal water circulation within the coastal aquifer near the seawater-freshwater interface, which is governed by the hydrogeological setting and the incoming freshwater fluxes, where nutrient delivery is limited to a small corridor of the shallow part of the aquifer.
The estimation of groundwater-driven lacustrine dissloved inorganic phosphorus (DIP) loading is a challenging task associated with uncertainties related to simplifications used in the empirical and numerical methods. A multi-disciplinary approach can result in a better understanding of a system and therefore the improved estimate of external DIP loading into lakes. Groundwater discharge and DIP loading to a naturally eutrophic lake were estimated using three methods based on field measurements: (1) the lake segment approach, (2) threedimensional (3D) flow and transport modelling, and (3) integrating mapped water chemistry with the 3D flow model. Field measurements and 3D flow modelling show the groundwater contribution to the lake water budget 75-81%. The in situ measured spatial distribution of the groundwater discharge rate, based on seepage meters and a conservative tracer (Cl-) budget approach, is well reproduced by the 3D flow model. DIP fluxes between the aquifer and the surface water vary between 220 and 351 kg yr(-1). The integrated approach is associated with the lowest degree of uncertainty and therefore predicts the spatial distribution of the mass loading into the lake with the highest degree of accuracy. 3D hydrological information is crucial to estimate the magnitude of DIP transport. Despite the high measured and simulated DIP concentration in groundwater beneath gyttja covering the lake bottom, the actual contribution of this area into annual groundwater-driven DIP loading is low due to low groundwater discharge rates. DIP loading is concentrated instead in the narrow littoral high discharge zones. Low release rate of DIP within the old lake bottom (0.14 mu g L-1) predicted with the use of the zero-order release term in MT3DMS results in a high average DIP concentration in the groundwater (60 mu g L-1) and is one of the major factors responsible for the long-term lake eutrophication.
Hydrological ProcessesVolume 35, Issue 6 e14226 INVITED COMMENTARY Hydraulic conductivity can no longer be considered a fixed property when quantifying flow between groundwater and surface water Donald O. Rosenberry, Corresponding Author Donald O. Rosenberry rosenber@usgs.gov orcid.org/0000-0003-0681-5641 U.S. Geological Survey, Lakewood, Colorado, USA Correspondence Donald O. Rosenberry, U.S. Geological Survey, MS 413, Denver Federal Center, Lakewood, CO 80225, USA. Email: rosenber@usgs.govSearch for more papers by this authorPeter Engesgaard, Peter Engesgaard orcid.org/0000-0002-5925-8757 Department of Geosciences and Natural Resource Management, University of Copenhagen, Copenhagen, DenmarkSearch for more papers by this authorChristine Hatch, Christine Hatch orcid.org/0000-0002-4996-1617 Department of Geosciences, University of Massachusetts Amherst, Amherst, Massachusetts, USASearch for more papers by this author Donald O. Rosenberry, Corresponding Author Donald O. Rosenberry rosenber@usgs.gov orcid.org/0000-0003-0681-5641 U.S. Geological Survey, Lakewood, Colorado, USA Correspondence Donald O. Rosenberry, U.S. Geological Survey, MS 413, Denver Federal Center, Lakewood, CO 80225, USA. Email: rosenber@usgs.govSearch for more papers by this authorPeter Engesgaard, Peter Engesgaard orcid.org/0000-0002-5925-8757 Department of Geosciences and Natural Resource Management, University of Copenhagen, Copenhagen, DenmarkSearch for more papers by this authorChristine Hatch, Christine Hatch orcid.org/0000-0002-4996-1617 Department of Geosciences, University of Massachusetts Amherst, Amherst, Massachusetts, USASearch for more papers by this author First published: 09 May 2021 https://doi.org/10.1002/hyp.14226Citations: 3Read the full textAboutPDF ToolsRequest permissionExport citationAdd to favoritesTrack citation ShareShare Give accessShare full text accessShare full-text accessPlease review our Terms and Conditions of Use and check box below to share full-text version of article.I have read and accept the Wiley Online Library Terms and Conditions of UseShareable LinkUse the link below to share a full-text version of this article with your friends and colleagues. Learn more.Copy URL Share a linkShare onFacebookTwitterLinkedInRedditWechat Citing Literature Volume35, Issue6June 2021e14226 This article also appears in:HPToday: Invited Commentaries RelatedInformation
δ18O and electrical conductivity (EC) were used successfully to trace the spatial distribution of whole-lake groundwater-lake exchange for a small (four ha) groundwater-fed lake situated in a low relief and low hydraulic gradient area. The method relies on quick sampling of shallow groundwater, direct analysis of EC in the field, and relatively in-expensive analysis of δ18O in the laboratory. Ternary uncertain end-member mixing analysis (precipitation, groundwater, and lake water) quantified the composition of water discharging to and recharging from the lake. The tracer distribution and mixing analysis were in agreement with the interpreted groundwater flow near the lake. The use of only one tracer (either δ18O or EC) gave the same results for the recharge segments, but the discharge segments changed the origin of the water from being groundwater to precipitation controlled. The two tracers complemented each other, especially with different signals in precipitation and groundwater. The uncertain end-members were assessed based on local (groundwater and lake water) and off-site (precipitation) data. The off-site data were found to be useful if it contained representative information on local-site seasonality (uncertainty, variance). Final end-member concentrations could explain the transience of the hydrology at the site (i.e., flooding of the area adjacent to the lake during periods with high precipitation, and variability of the δ18O signal in precipitation). This methodology potentially represents a new option to study groundwater-lake systems. The tracer information collected over only two days is useful by itself for developing the next steps like the quantification of fluxes based on other standard methods (Darcy approach, seepage meters, or temperature). The tracer information can provide quantitative estimation of inputs and outputs by using the mixing analysis.
Awareness of groundwater-borne dissolved inorganic phosphorus (DIP) loadings into lakes and its role in lake eutrophication is increasing, albeit DIP of natural origin is often ignored. Release of geogenic DIP from an adjacent aquifer and its transport with groundwater into a eutrophic lake is described by combining hydrogeochemical data collected in this study (sampling of piezometers, hydrogeochemical profiles, and seepage meters) with groundwater flow and discharge rates from earlier studies. The major part of the DIP that entered the lake with discharging groundwater was mobilized from iron hydroxides reduced by organic matter buried in the sediments of the old lake bottom. This is indicated by the correlation between DIP and ferrous iron (Fe2+) concentrations, with a DIP/Fe(2+)molar ratio of 0.06, and an increase in pH. One-dimensional reactive transport modeling indicated that high discharge rates (> 0.1 m d(-1)) of anoxic groundwater upwelling in areas adjacent to the lakeshore prevent downward diffusion of oxygen into the aquifer and do not leave enough time for DIP to become rebounding to the mineral phases at the sediment-water interface. The groundwater-controlled DIP input into the lake calculated along a two-dimensional cross-section averaged 0.01 mol DIP m(-2)yr(-1). A 2 m wide offshore high discharge zone delivered approximately 13% of the DIP into the lake. The continuous, external loading of geogenic DIP sustains lake eutrophication and explains the failure of two previous lake restoration attempts.
The geological conceptual model is considered a major source of uncertainty in groundwater modelling and well capture zone delineation. However, how to account for it in groundwater policy and management remains largely unresolved. We explore the drivers and barriers to account for geological conceptual uncertainty in groundwater protection amongst decision makers and stakeholders in an agricultural groundwater catchment in Denmark. Using a groundwater model, we analyze the impact of alternative geological conceptual models on capture zone delineation. A focus area, which covers multiple modelled capture zones, is defined and considered for groundwater protection. Model uncertainty and focus area are discussed at two workshops, one with local and national stakeholders and another with local farmers. The drivers to account for model uncertainty include: i) safer drinking water protection by considering a larger area for protection than identified from a single geological model; and ii) stability over time of management plans. The main barrier is the additional cost to the stakeholders for the protection of a larger area. We conclude that integration of geological uncertainty in groundwater protection plans may be improved through: i) better communication between the research community and the national water authority; ii) more constraining guidelines regarding the estimation of geological uncertainty; and iii) the development of a framework ensuring knowledge transfer to the local water authorities and detailing how to integrate uncertainty in management plans.
These proceedings, with cd-rom, present a comprehensive overview of advances in groundwater research. The five main topics covered are: aquifers and contaminant distribution; groundwater quality; natural attenuation; remediation technologies and groundwater protection. Groundwater 2000 is a useful resource to both scientists and to those working in the field.
Wetlands are extremely dynamical systems and their behavior depends on the characteristics of the surroundings (topography, geology and vegetation, among others) as well as on meteorological and hydrological processes. Wetlands receive groundwater through diffuse upwelling and through springs. Studying upwelling is of great importance to e.g. evaluate the overall ecology or capacity to remove nitrate of the wetland system. One problem is that diffuse upwelling is difficult locate and measure. We analyze the temporal dynamics of a groundwater-fed wetland in central Jutland (Denmark) by the use of a range of thermal methods across a lowland stream valley. A monitoring system consisting of Distributed Temperature Sensing (DTS), wells with temperature depth profiles and thermal infrared (TIR) imaging on an unmanned aerial vehicle, in conjunction with hydrological and atmospheric data, provide a quasi 3D time-lapse characterization of the thermal behavior of the system, both on the ground and in the subsurface, over a period of two years. We infer potential locations of groundwater upwelling to the land surface by studying the temperature in both the wetland surface and the groundwater. Each thermal method provides different, partially overlapping estimates of the upwelling location and magnitude, highlighting the need to incorporate classic hydrological metrics to constrain the results obtained using heat as a tracer. The integration of these data indicates that temperature measurements can be used to study groundwater upwelling in stream valleys.
Surface water-groundwater interactions were studied in a coastal lagoon performing 180 seepage meter measurements and using heat as a tracer in 30 locations along a lagoon inlet. The direct seepage meter measurements were compared with the results from analytical solutions for the 1D heat transport equation in three different scenarios: (1) Homogeneous bulk thermal conductivity (Ke); (2) horizontal heterogeneity in Ke; and (3) horizontal and vertical heterogeneity in Ke. The proportion of fresh groundwater and saline recirculated lagoon water collected from the seepage experiment was used to infer the location of the saline wedge and its effect on both the seepage meter results and the thermal regime in the lagoon bed, conditioning the use of the thermal methods. The different scenarios provided the basis for a better understanding of the underlying processes in a coastal groundwater-discharging area, a key factor to apply the best-suited method to characterize such processes. The thermal methods were more reliable in areas with high fresh groundwater discharge than in areas with high recirculation of saline lagoon water. The seepage meter experiments highlighted the importance of geochemical water sampling to estimate the origin of the exchanged water through the lagoon bed.
Submarine groundwater discharge (SGD)—including terrestrial freshwater, density-driven flow at the saltwater–freshwater interface, and benthic exchange—can deliver nutrients to coastal areas, generating a negative effect in the quality of marine water bodies. It is recognized that water stable isotopes (18O and 2H) can be helpful tracers to identify different flow paths and origins of water. Here, we show that they can be also applied when assessing sources of nutrients to coastal areas. A field site near a lagoon (Ringkøbing Fjord, Denmark) has been monitored at a metric scale to test if stable isotopes of water can be used to achieve a better understanding of the hydrochemical processes taking place in coastal aquifers, where there is a transition from freshwater to saltwater. Results show that 18O and 2H differentiate the coastal aquifer into three zones: Freshwater, shallow, and deep saline zones, which corresponded well with zones having distinct concentrations of inorganic phosphorous. The explanation is associated with three mechanisms: (1) Differences in sediment composition, (2) chemical reactions triggered by mixing of different type of fluxes, and (3) biochemical and diffusive processes in the lagoon bed. The different behaviors of nutrients in Ringkøbing Fjord need to be considered in water quality management. PO4 underneath the lagoon exceeds the groundwater concentration inland, thus demonstrating an intra-lagoon origin, while NO3, higher inland due to anthropogenic activity, is denitrified in the study area before reaching the lagoon.
Worldwide, aquifers in low‐lying coastal areas are threatened by saltwater occurrence, as a result of small head gradients, high groundwater abstraction rates, and drain management of the landscape, which is likely to intensify with climate change. Numerical models can serve as tools to identify the sources of the salt and thus to increase understanding of the driving mechanisms and important parameters controlling the extent of saltwater intrusions. This way, areas vulnerable to sea level rise can be identified and managed. Challenges include unknown initial salt concentrations, heterogeneous geology, and anthropogenic alterations. In this study, hydrogeological, geophysical, and geochemical data are used to develop a numerical density‐dependent groundwater flow and transport model with the objective to understand the history of a saltwater‐affected groundwater system and its likely response to historic and future changes. The extent of the simulated saltwater intrusion compares well with Airborne Electromagnetic data that show salt water up to 20 km inland. The results reveal that the salt water originates from a combination of laterally intruding seawater and vertically infiltrating transgression water. Main features controlling the progression of the modern seawater into the coastal aquifers are high permeable, deep Miocene sand aquifers, buried valleys that provide preferential flow paths in combination with extensive Miocene clay layers that delay saltwater intrusion. Anthropogenic activity enhances the saltwater inflow from the ocean and induces transient conditions. Future scenarios show that saltwater progression due to nonstationarity leads to enhanced contamination of the deeper aquifers. Climate change affects primarily the shallow aquifer systems.
A managed riparian lowland in a glacial landscape (Holtum catchment, Denmark) was studied to quantify the relative importance of subsurface and surface flow to the recipient stream. The hydrogeological characterization combined geoelectrical methods, lithological logs, and piezometric heads with monthly flow measurements of springs, a ditch, and a drain, to determine seasonality and thereby infer flow paths. In addition, groundwater discharge through the streambed was estimated using temperature and water-stable isotopes as tracers. The lowland received large groundwater inputs with minimal seasonal variations from adjacent upland aquifers. This resulted in significant amounts of groundwater-fed surface flow to the stream, via man-made preferential flow paths comprising ditches, drainage systems, and a pond, and via two natural springs. Roughly, two thirds of the stream gain was due to surface flow to the stream, mainly via anthropogenic alterations. In contrast, direct groundwater discharge through the streambed accounted for only 4% of the stream flow gain, although bank seepage (not measured) to the straightened and deepened stream potentially accounted for an additional 17%. Comparison to analogous natural flow systems in the catchment substantiate the impact of anthropogenic alterations of riparian lowlands for the subsurface and surface flow components to their streams.