Abstract 3D laser scanning is a cornerstone of modern forest and ecological research, allowing detailed insight into forest structures and dynamics. Although point cloud processing and noise management are crucial steps in the exploitation of LiDAR data, traditional denoising methods are usually based on the assumption of a Gaussian noise distribution, whereas many factors (including structural complexity of forest environments) lead to the opposite By overlooking the complexity of noise distribution within point clouds, these methods often fail to distinguish noise correctly, resulting in a loss of relevant information and introducing potential biases. This is particularly problematic in areas with smaller stems and branches, where their pronounced curvature leads to light diffraction, complicating reliable detection. To address these issues, we propose a new noise compression method designed to better distinguish noise from information‐bearing points within MLS‐point clouds. By self‐optimizing its parameters against ground‐truth data, our method significantly enhances the accuracy and reliability of MLS‐derived metrics while preserving essential structural details. Compared to previous denoising methods, our approach minimizes data loss and ensures a more accurate representation of forest structures across diverse conditions (including small stems and branches), widening the potential contributions of 3D mapping to other ecological spheres.
For several decades, the proportion of American beech (Fagus grandifolia) has increased in sugar maple (Acer saccharum) stands in North America, particularly in the understory, where it can hinder the regeneration of other species. Although this dominance is well documented, the underlying mechanisms by which it develops remain poorly understood. We aimed to determine whether the spatial relationships between beech saplings, mature beech trees, and canopy openness, previously observed among stands using discontinuous plot-based sampling, also applies within stands using continuous sampling of full stands. Our objective was to better understand how this dominance develops, as it is uncertain whether these relationships hold at finer spatial scales within stands, i. e., whether beech dominance within a stand is spatially related to canopy gaps and/or mature beech density. We created 3D-maps of 11 1-ha stands in Quebec, Canada using mobile laser scanning (MLS) technology and developed a new method for analyzing regeneration which allowed us to map a total of 8455 trees and 30,498 saplings and to investigate the relationship between beech saplings and mature beech trees as well as canopy openness at various spatial scales. Contrary to our expectations, we found very little to no relationship between beech saplings and canopy openness, and a highly variable relationship with mature beech trees among sites. Our findings underscore the importance of spatial scale in regeneration studies and suggest that beech proliferation may be difficult to reverse, as sexual reproduction appears to play a more important role in beech regeneration than previously thought.
Interest in forestry automation is growing alongside rapid advances in deep learning. In particular, tree detection and taxonomic classification are seen as core tasks required for automating field surveys and forestry equipment. These operations must often be performed in under-canopy settings, which pose challenging conditions for perception systems, including heavy occlusion, variable lighting, and dense vegetation. Despite this necessity, current work has yet to properly establish the feasibility of simultaneously executing tree detection and taxonomic classification in natural forests, as available datasets primarily focus on urban settings or on a limited number of species. To address this gap, we present SilvaScenes, a benchmark dataset for instance segmentation of tree species from under-canopy images in natural forests. Collected across five bioclimatic domains in Quebec, Canada, our dataset features 1421 trees from 28 species, with segmentation masks for pixel-precise tree trunk detection and fine-grained species annotations from forestry experts. We demonstrate the relevance and difficult nature of SilvaScenes by evaluating modern deep learning approaches, showing that while trunk segmentation is feasible, with a top mean average precision (mAP) of 69.9
Understanding carbon dynamics in managed forest ecosystems is increasingly crucial for formulating informed recommendations in the context of climate change. Silviculture significantly impacts forest carbon pools, though these effects can vary depending on the type of treatment applied. In recent decades, partial cuttings have been proposed as an alternative to more intensive treatments like clearcutting to mitigate negative impacts on forest function and enhance carbon sequestration. In this study, we conducted a meta-analysis comparing the effects of clearcutting and partial cuttings across North America on six forest carbon pools: live trees, snags, understory vegetation, coarse woody debris, forest floor, and soil mineral horizons. The analysis was based on a database of 558 carbon observations from temperate and boreal forests in eastern North America. Our findings indicate a -30% difference in total carbon post-harvesting, predominantly influenced by changes in the overstory carbon pool. Only the live tree carbon pool was significantly affected by cutting intensity, with clearcutting resulting in lower total carbon values (-78% relative to the reference) compared to partial cuttings (-45%). However, after 30-40 years, live tree carbon levels were similar between clearcutting and partial cuttings. The primary factor influencing differences in deadwood carbon pools was the time since treatment, while soil carbon pools showed minimal variation with no significant differences compared to unmanaged forests. This meta-analysis suggests that using partial cuttings instead of clearcutting to mitigate the effects of forest management on carbon pools may be more complex than previously thought and will depend on site conditions and allowing sufficient time for the forest to recover. Further studies are needed to identify suitable forest stands for partial cuttings and evaluate tree selection strategies that optimize forest productivity and carbon sequestration.
Forests face an escalating threat from the increasing frequency of extreme drought events driven by climate change. To address this challenge, it is crucial to understand how widely distributed species of economic or ecological importance may respond to drought stress. In this study, we examined the transcriptome of white spruce (Picea glauca (Moench) Voss) to identify key genes and metabolic pathways involved in the species’ response to water stress. We assembled a de novo transcriptome, performed differential gene expression analyses at four time points over 22 days during a controlled drought stress experiment involving 2-year-old plants and three genetically distinct clones, and conducted gene enrichment analyses. The transcriptome assembly and gene expression analysis identified a total of 33,287 transcripts corresponding to 18,934 annotated unique genes, including 4,425 genes that are uniquely responsive to drought. Many transcripts that had predicted functions associated with photosynthesis, cell wall organization, and water transport were down-regulated under drought conditions, while transcripts linked to abscisic acid response and defense response were up-regulated. Our study highlights a previously uncharacterized effect of drought stress on lipid metabolism genes in conifers and significant changes in the expression of several transcription factors, suggesting a regulatory response potentially linked to drought response or acclimation. Our research represents a fundamental step in unraveling the molecular mechanisms underlying short-term drought responses in white spruce seedlings. In addition, it provides a valuable source of new genetic data that could contribute to genetic selection strategies aimed at enhancing the drought resistance and resilience of white spruce to changing climates.
As the Anthropocene tightens its grip on the world, forests are facing escalating disturbance rates, tree mortality, degradation and risks of catastrophic collapses. A popular and controversial proposition is to enhance forests’ response diversity by adding novel tree species with missing functional traits through forest assisted migration (FAM). Beyond tests of the survival and growth of southern species or provenances in colder regions and studies of the socio-ecological challenges facing FAM, little interest has been paid to the silvicultural system for FAM implementation. Yet, the topic could influence its biological success, social acceptability, and economic feasibility. For example, southern light-intolerant tree species introduced into northern uneven-aged forests may experience a lack of light availability. Likewise, implementing FAM in clearcuts raises social acceptability issues. The patch-cut system combines advantages of even- and uneven-aged systems useful for FAM; however, perhaps due to the difficulty of its operationalization, it is rarely used. We propose a new way to implement the patch-cut system, enabling from the get-go to plan the location and timing of treatment of each patch in a stand. We discuss the advantages that this revisited patch-cut system presents for FAM: (i) the testing of various planting environments, (ii) easy monitoring in an adaptative management context where each patch is a replicate of a repeated-measure experiment and (iii) low intensity planting for efficient future dispersion of species adapted to a changing climate. We end with a call for the development of an international network of FAM trials within the revised patch-cut system.
The formation of a single species, recalcitrant understory vegetation layer can limit tree regeneration and, in the long term, modify the composition of forests. Few studies have investigated how recalcitrant vegetation influences competition for water resources although the formation of a dense understory is likely to modify the forest water balance. In eastern North American hardwood forests, the development of a dense understory layer of American beech (Fagus grandifolia) has been observed in stands dominated by sugar maple (Acer saccharum), a phenomenon that shares many characteristics associated with recalcitrant vegetation. Given that water availability is generally negatively correlated with stand density, we hypothesized that the formation of a dense understory beech layer increased competition for water resources, thus leading to reduced water use by sugar maple trees in beech-dominated stands. Using thermal dissipation sensors, we measured sap flux density (Fd) of two sugar maple trees at three beech-dominated sites and three control sites. During the growing season, Fd of sugar maple trees was significantly larger at beech-dominated sites compared to control sites, indicating a greater rate of water use by sugar maples in stands with a dense understory beech layer. We provide two hypotheses to explain our results at the tree scale: (i) reduced cover by forest floor vegetation could limit transpiration by this layer, thus allowing increased water availability to supply transpiration by overstory trees, or (ii) increased tree transpiration rate could be a mechanism to satisfy nutrient requirements in beech-dominated stands often associated with lower soil fertility.
With global change, forest trees will be exposed to increasing stress in the coming decades with various studies demonstrating that stress-related mortality will increase in forests. While tree death can be triggered by a single factor, it is often caused by the accumulation and the complex interaction of various stressors. Several silvicultural strategies have been developed to cope with global change but very few studies have addressed the ways in which silvicultural regimes interact with various stressors to influence tree mortality. This lack of research on the effects of forest management regimes on tree mortality may be due to the challenge of acquiring large (or long-term) datasets to assess tree mortality in forests. Within this context and using a mobile terrestrial LiDAR approach for rapid 3D-mapping of forest stands, we aimed to (i) compare recent tree mortality patterns in temperate forests among contrasting forest management regimes (even-aged silviculture, uneven-aged silviculture and unmanaged forests), and (ii) evaluate the relative influence of regeneration harvest severity on tree mortality compared to other spatially explicit factors (i.e., localized competition and slope position) and non-spatially explicit factors (i.e. tree DBH -diameter at breast height- and tree species group). In a permanent sample plot network, we mapped 15 508 dead and living trees (>9.1 cm DBH) within 37 sugar maple-dominated stands: 14 even-aged, 16 uneven-aged and 7 unmanaged stands. We separated the relative role of forest management on individual tree mortality from other factors such as size, species, slope position, and localized competition by modeling the probability of mortality for each tree. Localized competition or slope position were not significant factors describing tree mortality. Results showed that tree mortality was influenced by tree species, DBH and forest management regime. Models indicated that forest management regime, by itself, had a strong effect on tree mortality proportion. Results also indicated that trees in uneven-aged stands had a higher probability of dying than the those in even-aged or unmanaged stands. However, we do not advocate for the replacement of uneven-aged regimes in favour of even-aged ones. Instead, we believe that, in the context of global change, adjustments should be made to uneven-aged regimes to reduce risk of mortality. Moreover, our study reinforces the idea that silviculture can be applied in such a way as to enhance stand resistance and resilience to cope with global change; for example, by influencing size structure and species composition, which greatly influence tree mortality.
Process-based forest growth models with spatially explicit representation are relevant tools to investigate innovative silviculture practices and/or climate change effects because they are based on key ecophysiological processes and account for the effects of local competition for resources on tree growth. Such models are rare and are often calibrated for a very limited number of species and rarely for mixed and/or uneven-aged stands, and none are suitable for the temperate forests of Québec. The aim of this study was to calibrate and evaluate HETEROFOR (HETEROgeneous FORest), a process-based and spatially explicit model based on resource sharing, for 23 functionally diverse tree species in forest stands with contrasting species compositions and environmental conditions in southern Quebec. Using data from the forest inventory of Quebec, we evaluated the ability of HETEROFOR to predict the short-term growth (5–16 years) of these species at the tree and stand levels and the long-term dynamics (120 years) of red and sugar maple stands. The comparison between the prediction quality of the calibration and evaluation datasets showed the robustness of the model performance in predicting individual-tree growth. The model reproduced correctly the individual basal area increment (BAI) of the validation dataset, with a mean Pearson's correlation coefficient of 0.56 and a mean bias of 18 %. Our results also highlighted that considering tree position is of importance for predicting individual-tree growth most accurately in complex stands with both vertically and horizontally heterogeneous structures. The model also showed a good ability to reproduce BAI at the stand level, both for monospecific (bias of −3.7 %; Pearson's r=0.55) and multi-species stands (bias of −9.1 %; Pearson's r=0.62). Long-term simulations of red maple and sugar maple showed that HETEROFOR was able to accurately predict the growth (basal area and height) and mortality processes from the seedling stage to the mature stand. Our results suggest that HETEROFOR is a reliable option to simulate forest growth in southern Quebec and to test new forestry practices under future climate scenarios.
Ephemeral ponds in cold and humid forested regions are often vulnerable because of their small size and ephemeral nature. The aim of this study was to identify the geomorphological and meteorological drivers of ephemeral pond hydrology in the forests of cold and humid climates. A multi‐year study of 40 ponds was conducted in the Kenauk forest located in the Canadian Shield of the Outaouais region (Quebec, Canada). Pond bathymetry, mineral and organic sediment thickness, watershed area, slope, canopy cover and maximum depth were measured in‐situ. The spring hydroperiod (the period during which there is water in the ponds between April and October) as well as the surface and groundwater recession rates were measured throughout the study period, from 2016 to 2020. Data from this study show that ponds located at lower altitudes in the landscape are larger, receive water from a larger area, and have longer hydroperiods than ponds located at higher altitudes. The results demonstrated a connection between the ponds and the surrounding aquifer. Spring and early summer precipitation was shown to affect hydroperiods the most, while summer precipitation influenced the presence of water in the ponds from April to October. Winter precipitation appear determinant for pond recession rates. Simple multiple regression models were able to simulate hydroperiods and hydroperiod indices relatively well, but pond recession rates were not well represented by the models. This study brings original multi‐year and multi‐site data identifying parameters and variables that determine ephemeral pond hydrology in cold and humid climates. The results provide new insights into their resilience on the landscape and bring new arguments for their long‐term protection.
An increase in the frequency and magnitude of drought events threatens the health of forests and the economic, ecological, and societal services they provide. It has been widely demonstrated that trees undergoing a succession of stresses may accumulate lesions that in turn lead to a decrease in their vigor and eventually to death. However, recent studies have shown that a nonlethal stress should also initiate a stress memory, which triggers a faster and stronger plant defensive response when a new stress occurs. Although this mechanism is well understood in many herbaceous plants, a better understanding in trees is needed. The aim of our study was to explore the capacity of two forest tree species to develop a stress memory. A greenhouse experiment was conducted to evaluate the tree seedlings' vigor after one or two consecutive droughts separate from a rehydration period during the same growing season. No stress memory pattern was observed for the two tree species as, on the contrary, we even observed a stress accumulation pattern in sugar maple. It remains possible that some individuals in our study developed stress memory, but that we were not able to detect it. The fine-tuning of experimental parameters and the conducting of longitudinal studies would be helpful to detect individual capacity in stress memory activation.
Ephemeral pools are geographically isolated wetlands commonly found in temperate forests of northeastern North America. These wetlands are usually hydrologically isolated from the surface water network but in some conditions can be connected to local groundwater flow. They fill at maximal capacity following spring snowmelt and dry out during summer. They contribute to forest biodiversity by providing breeding habitats for amphibians during their spring and early summer period of hydrological activity. However, ephemeral pools are poorly understood and rarely studied because of their small dimensions and temporary hydrology. This work presents the final results of a five-year study aimed to acquire new knowledge on ephemeral pool hydrology to go beyond the anecdotical pool and to understand the conditions and processes that driving their hydrology. A large number of pools (39) located in the Canadian Shield forest were instrumented to monitor hourly water level variations in the pool and in the neighboring and underlying fractured bedrock aquifer. They were also described in extensive details for their geomorphological features and water levels over a period from one to five years (April 2016 to July 2020). The first rather surprising result from this work is that, although the pools are all located in bedrock depressions, they cover a wide range of morphologies. Their maximum sizes vary from 29 to 1866 m2 and their maximal volumes vary from 4 to 654 m3. Their maximum water depths are also highly contrasted, ranging from 0.14 m to 2.03 m. The pool depressions are overlain by mineral sediments (silt to fine sand with occurrences of coarse sand and gravel) of contrasted thicknesses (0 m to 1.70 m). An organic matter layer of highly varying thickness (0.12 m to 1.24 m) was observed at all sites above the mineral sediments. Despite these varied morphological conditions, all the pools have similar hydrological patterns throughout the year and these patterns are highly resilient to meteorological conditions. They dry out between the end of May and the end of July, rapid temporary refilling during important summer rainfall events, and partially refilling in autumn following more frequent rainfall events and lower evapotranspiration. The results show that surface water levels are maintained when the underlying sediments are saturated. Otherwise, the ephemeral pools lose water by infiltration to the underlying aquifer. Water level variations within the pools are positively and significantly correlated with net precipitation (P – PET). Hydroperiods vary between 28 days (2020) and 86 days (2017), reflecting the year-to-year meteorological variability. The mean hydroperiod is significantly correlated to spring rainfall (April to June), but also to the volume of water stored in the pool, and to the pool surface area. This study provides a unique and original dataset that contribute to better understand the hydrodynamics and resilience to anthropogenic (forestry) and natural (climate change) impacts of a wetland type that is rarely studied but provide crucial habitats for forest biodiversity.
Climate change is threatening our ability to manage forest ecosystems sustainably. Despite strong consensus on the need for a broad portfolio of options to face this challenge, diversified management options have yet to be widely implemented. Inspired by functional zoning, a concept aimed at optimizing biodiversity conservation and wood production in multiple-use forest landscapes, we present a portfolio of management options that intersects management objectives with forest vulnerability to better address the wide range of goals inherent to forest management under climate change. Using this approach, we illustrate how different adaptation options could be implemented when faced with impacts related to climate change and its uncertainty. These options range from establishing ecological reserves in climatic refuges, where self-organizing ecological processes can result in resilient forests, to intensive plantation silviculture that could ensure a stable wood supply in an uncertain future. While adaptation measures in forests that are less vulnerable correspond to the traditional functional zoning management objectives, forests with higher vulnerability might be candidates for transformative measures as they may be more susceptible to abrupt changes in structure and composition. To illustrate how this portfolio of management options could be applied, we present a theoretical case study for the eastern boreal forest of Canada. Even if these options are supported by solid evidence, their implementation across the landscape may present some challenges and will require good communication among stakeholders and with the public.
The importance of tree genetic variability in the ability of forests to respond and adapt to environmental changes is crucial in forest management and conservation. Along with genetics, recent advances have highlighted “epigenetics” as an emerging and promising field of research for the understanding of tree phenotypic plasticity and adaptive responses. In this paper, we review recent advances in this emerging field and their potential applications for tree researchers and breeders, as well as for forest managers. First, we present the basics of epigenetics in plants before discussing its potential for trees. We then propose a bibliometric and overview of the literature on epigenetics in trees, including recent advances on tree priming. Lastly, we outline the promises of epigenetics for forest research and management, along with current gaps and future challenges. Research in epigenetics could use highly diverse paths to help forests adapt to global change by eliciting different innovative silvicultural approaches for natural- and artificial-based forest management.
Despite recent advances in understanding tree species sensitivities to climate change, ecological knowledge on different species remains scattered across disparate sources, precluding their inclusion in vulnerability assessments. Information on potential sensitivities is needed to identify tree species that require consideration, inform changes to current silvicultural practices and prioritize management actions. A trait-based approach was used to overcome some of the challenges involved in assessing sensitivity, providing a common framework to facilitate data integration and species comparisons. Focusing on 26 abundant tree species from eastern Canada, we developed a series of trait-based indices that capture a species’ ability to cope with three key climate change stressors—increased drought events, shifts in climatically suitable habitat, increased fire intensity and frequency. Ten indices were developed by breaking down species’ response to a stressor into its strategies, mechanisms and traits. Species-specific sensitivities varied across climate stressors but also among the various ways a species can cope with a given stressor. Of the 26 species assessed, Tsuga canadensis (L.) Carrière and Abies balsamea (L.) Mill are classified as the most sensitive species across all indices while Acer rubrum L. and Populus spp. are the least sensitive. Information was found for 95% of the trait-species combinations but the quality of available data varies between indices and species. Notably, some traits related to individual-level sensitivity to drought were poorly documented as well as deciduous species found within the temperate biome. We also discuss how our indices compare with other published indices, using drought sensitivity as an example. Finally, we discuss how the information captured by these indices can be used to inform vulnerability assessments and the development of adaptation measures for species with different management requirements under climate change.
Human impacts on Earth's ecosystems have greatly intensified in the last decades. This is reflected in unexpected disturbance events, as well as new and increasing socio-economic demands, all of which are affecting the resilience of forest ecosystems worldwide and the provision of important ecosystem services. This Anthropocene era is forcing us to reconsider past and current forest management and silvicultural practices, and search for new ones that are more flexible and better at dealing with the increasing uncertainty brought about by these accelerating and cumulative global changes. Here, we briefly review the focus and limitations of past and current forest management and silvicultural practices mainly as developed in Europe and North America. We then discuss some recent promising concepts, such as managing forests as complex adaptive systems, and approaches based on resilience, functional diversity, assisted migration and multi-species plantations, to propose a novel approach to integrate the functionality of species-traits into a functional complex network approach as a flexible and multi-scale way to manage forests for the Anthropocene. This approach takes into consideration the high level of uncertainty associated with future environmental and societal changes. It relies on the quantification and dynamic monitoring of functional diversity and complex network indices to manage forests as a functional complex network. Using this novel approach, the most efficient forest management and silvicultural practices can be determined, as well as where, at what scale, and at what intensity landscape-scale resistance, resilience and adaptive capacity of forests to global changes can be improved.
Increasing extreme events that are related to global change are expected to affect the dynamics of forest ecosystems. If disruptive stressors (e.g., insects, drought) affect tree vigor without causing mortality, the ecological effects may be subtle, making subsequent ecosystem dynamics more difficult to predict than in the case of disturbances causing death. Based on the literature and our personal observations, we expected that such a subtle change could have occurred in the dynamics between sugar maple and American beech. We implemented a targeted paired-sampling design (1) to verify whether a change occurred (gradual or abrupt, recovered or not) in the growth dynamics between the two species over a 57-yr period, (2) to identify the likely causes of this change, and (3) to investigate whether such changes could trigger other long-time ecological consequences. We found that sugar maple growth was negatively affected by an extreme event (or a few events) between 1986 and 1989, while American beech was not affected. Twenty years after the 1986-1989 abrupt growth decrease, sugar maple (1) had a slower growth than American beech, although it was previously similar, (2) did not respond to monthly climatic variations as it did prior to the abrupt growth decrease, and (3) had lower resilience when faced with a new stress event. Overall, our study, besides showing that extreme events with subtle effects may change the dynamics of an ecosystem, also illustrates that these events may accelerate ecosystem misadaptation to climate. Fine-scale targeted monitoring is essential to complement broad-scale monitoring to detect such misadaptations in a global change context.
Two concomitant phenomena currently affect the dynamics of sugar maple-American beech (AB) stands in northeastern North America: beech bark disease (BBD), and increased AB understory density. Many studies suggest a causal link between the two phenomena, i.e., BBD favouring beech regeneration. But this link has yet to be experimentally demonstrated. To address the question, we compared regeneration composition between recently BBD-affected and -unaffected stands. A total of 109 stands were sampled; half were affected by BBD. Seedling and sapling density were assessed, together with the origin (seedling or sprout). While BBD affects stands in the eastern part of the study region, AB was observed in the understory across the entire region. No clear difference in AB sprout density between BBD-affected and -unaffected stands was observed while AB seedling density—as well as pooled AB seedling and sprout density were higher in unaffected stands. Findings suggests that BBD, in its early stage, is not a necessary trigger of AB understory establishment. Yet, AB sapling basal area generally was higher in stands affected by BBD, likely indicating a greater rate of AB understory development due to increased light availability beneath a more open crown canopy. That development can lead to AB understory dominance. This distinction—BBD not necessarily triggering AB root sucker establishment but favoring AB advance regeneration development—also questions the generalized perception that dense AB thickets necessarily originate from root suckers.