Excessive protease activity and impaired tissue regeneration are hallmarks of many disease states. Elevated matrix metalloproteinase-9 (MMP-9) plays a key role in adverse tissue remodeling by excessively degrading extracellular matrix (ECM) components and growth factors. Tissue inhibitor of metalloproteinase-3 (TIMP-3) regulates ECM turnover, and its bioavailability is influenced by glycosaminoglycans (GAGs). This study aimed to develop a methacrylated gelatin (GelMA)-based hydrogel functionalized with acrylated sulfated hyaluronan (sHAc) as a TIMP-3 delivery system to decrease ECM degradation under pathophysiological conditions. sHAc incorporation enhanced hydrogel stiffness, reduced degradation rates and yielded sustained TIMP-3 release for up to 28 days. Molecular modeling and surface plasmon resonance demonstrated preferential binding of TIMP-3 to sHAc over hyaluronan methacrylates, together providing a molecular rationale for the reduced and sustained release of TIMP-3 from sHAc-containing hydrogels. Angiogenesis-related functional assays, supported by molecular modeling studies, indicate that sHAc modulates the anti-angiogenic activity of TIMP-3 by altering vascular endothelial growth factor receptor-associated signaling, while preserving metalloproteinase inhibition. Released TIMP-3 from GelMA/sHAc hydrogels retained bioactivity, effectively inhibiting MMP-9 activity and mitigating ECM degradation in-vitro and in human ex-vivo models. In a murine subcutaneous implantation model, sHAc-functionalized TIMP-3-loaded hydrogels were associated with reduced inflammatory cell presence and altered vascular- and matrix-related tissue signatures compared with GelMA controls. These findings underscore the potential of sHAc-functionalized GelMA hydrogels as biomaterials for therapeutics delivery, offering controlled TIMP-3 release and sustained bioactivity to promote ECM stability and on-demand MMP inhibition. This system represents a promising strategy for addressing the challenges of excessive MMP activity.
The demand for off-the-shelf biocompatible bone substitutes has driven the development of numerous independent in vitro technologies to generate products resembling physiological tissues. Due to technical challenges and overly simplified cultivation approaches/niches, the end-products are often uniformly shaped and inferior to native bone tissue. In this report, three major technologies are implemented cohesively to address these shortfalls: (1) Spinner flasks for scaled-up stem cell expansion, (2) Manufacturing via 3D-printing and cast-molding processes, large modular collagen-based (COL) scaffolds +/- chondroitin sulfate A (CSA) of tailored dimensions, (3) Perfusion bioreactor with controlled oxygen tension (pO2) to support high cell density and osteochondral differentiation. We report an oxygenated in vitro niche within the bioreactor that supports high cell density and self-induced osteogenic differentiation for 60 days. Enhanced mineralization and osteogenic gene expression in COL scaffolds were observed, while COL + CSA scaffolds exhibited elevated Col10a gene expression for hypertrophic chondrocytes, a representative indicator of active endochondral ossification. In summary, this report describes an integral approach to consistently and rapidly achieve physiologically relevant bone substitutes of tailored dimensions. Furthermore, the pivotal effect of recapitulating endochondral ossification in vitro through dynamic bioreactor culture is demonstrated, paving the way to generate complex tissue structures in the future.
Nanofiber scaffolds have gained significant attention as bone substitutes due to the high surface area and interconnected pore structure closely resembling the extracellular matrix (ECM), thereby supporting cell growth and promoting tissue regeneration. This study specifically focused on developing new electrospun scaffolds using silica and fibrillated collagen (SifCo), a key biopolymer in the natural bone matrix, targeting bone tissue engineering applications. The hybrid scaffolds were fabricated using a dual-nozzle electrospinning device equipped with two syringes, each separately filled with silica and collagen. Our findings demonstrated that the involvement of collagen nanofibers (NFs) within silica NFs significantly modifies silica-based scaffold characteristics, thus enhancing Young’s modulus from 13 ± 1 MPa for silica to 69 ± 25 MPa for SifCo NFs and improving cell proliferation compared to pure silica scaffolds. Besides, these hybrid NFs showed a lower degradation rate (15.24 ± 4.75 %) than their pure collagen NFs (83.44 ± 12.95 %) after 14 days, providing more sustained support for tissue growth. This combination of silica and collagen in the hybrid scaffolds benefited both materials’ strengths while modifying their limitations. This balanced approach can offer an effective strategy for bone tissue replacements, potentially addressing the need for scaffolds that can provide both adequate stability and favorable biological properties.
Delayed or non-healing of bone defects in an aging, multi-morbid population is still a medical challenge. Current replacement materials, like autografts, are limited. Thus, artificial substitutes from biodegradable polymers and bioactive glasses (BGs) are promising alternatives. Here, novel cerium-doped mesoporous BG microparticles (Ce-MBGs) with different cerium content were included in photocrosslinkable, methacrylated gelatin (GelMA) for promoting cellular functions of human mesenchymal stem cells (hBMSCs). The composites were studied for intrinsic morphology and Ce-MBGs distribution by scanning electron microscopy (SEM) and energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (EDX). They were gravimetrically analyzed for swelling and stability, compressive modulus via Microsquisher® and bioactivity by Fluitest® calcium assay and inductively coupled plasma-optical emission spectrometry (ICP-OES), also determining silicon and cerium ion release. Finally, seeding, proliferation, and differentiation of hBMSCs was investigated. Ce-MBGs were evenly distributed within composites. The latter displayed a concentration-dependent but cerium-independent decrease in swelling, while mechanical properties were comparable. A MBG type-dependent bioactivity was shown, while an enhanced osteogenic differentiation of hBMSCs was achieved for Ce-MBG-composites and related to different ion release profiles. These findings show their strong potential in promoting bone regeneration. Still, future work is required, e.g., analyzing the expression of osteogenic genes, providing further evidence for the composites’ osteogenic effect.
Micrometastases are challenging to resect surgically and to detect with in vivo imaging. Immunotherapy is highly anticipated to revolutionize their treatment, but its overall efficacy still remains limited for solid tumors. Here, a 3D micrometastases model is developed to mimic key microenvironmental cues, enabling in vitro evaluation of chimeric antigen receptor (CAR) T cell immunotherapy. Prostate cancer that preferentially metastasizes to, e.g., liver or bone marrow, is utilized as a model. Hydrogel beads with an elastic modulus matching those of soft organs are used to support long-term culturing, immunostaining, and monitoring of the spheroids. As a biochemical cue, the impact of fibroblast activation protein (FAP), an emerging target in the tumor microenvironment, is investigated on prostate cancer spheroids and on the efficacy of CAR T cell therapy. The multi-spheroid model consists of prostate stem cell antigen (PSCA)-expressing prostate cancer cells and FAP-producing fibrosarcoma cells in varying ratios. The morphological features of the model are compared to clinical histopathology and metastatic murine model samples. Finally, CAR T cell trials demonstrate successful chemoattraction and infiltration through the hydrogel matrix, with a dual-targeting approach against FAP and PSCA antigens showing synergistic efficacy. This research provides invaluable insights for engineering 3D tumor models and modeling therapies targeting small metastatic or residual tumors, suggesting that co-targeting may be a more effective strategy to unlock the tumor microenvironment's suppression.
The role of bioelectricity in regulating various physiological processes has attracted increasing scientific interest in implementing exogenous electrical stimulations as a therapeutic approach. In particular, electrical stimuli are used clinically in pre-/post-surgery patient care for the musculoskeletal tissues. The reported potential of electric fields (EF) to regulate bone cell homeostasis and kineticsin vitrohas further provoked more studies in this field of research. Various customised apparatuses have been developed, and a range of parameters for the applied EFs have been investigatedin vitrowith bone cells or mesenchymal stem cells. Additionally, biomaterials with conductive or piezo-electric properties have been designed to complement the enhancing effects of the EF on bone regeneration. Despite much research, there remained a significant gap in knowledge due to the diverse range of EF parameters available. Mathematical models are built to facilitate further understanding and zero in on an effective range of EF parametersin silico. However, the diverse range of EF parameters, experimental conditions, and reported analytical output of different works of literature were reported to possess significant variance, making it challenging to accurately model the fieldin silico. This review categorises the existing experimental approaches and the parameters used to distinguish the potential variables that apply to mathematical modelling. Furthermore, we will discuss existing modelling approaches and models available in the literature. With this, we will concisely highlight the need to categorise EF parameters, osteogenic differentiation initiators and research output.
The efficiency of immunotherapy stays limited for solid tumors. It is mainly caused by the tumoral structural heterogeneity and its complex microenvironment, which impede the infiltration of immune cells into malignant tissues. Mimicking this environment in frames of microphysiological models remains a challenge, significantly increasing costs of the clinical translation for the new therapies. Here, we study a 3D multi-spheroid model incorporating prostate stem cell antigen (PSCA) modified PC3 human prostate cancer cells and fibroblast activation protein (FAP) expressing fibrosarcoma HT1080 cells embedded within the soft hydrogel microbeads. We use this model to trial the immunotherapy based on the universal chimeric antigen receptor (UniCAR) T cells, and to better understand the impact of FAP on the immunotherapeutic treatment of solid tumors. First, we demonstrate the successful chemoattraction and infiltration of UniCAR T cells into the area of solid tumors, as well as the ability of UniCAR T cells to navigate through artificial extracellular matrix barriers. We further observe the synergistic efficacy of a dual-targeting UniCAR T cell approach against FAP and PSCA antigens, which represent the tumor microenvironment and the tumor, respectively. The results of our studies offer valuable methodologies and insights for engineering different 3D tumor models and studying immunotargeting of small-sized solid tumors (e.g., metastases and residual tumors). The developed microphysiological system has great potential to advance cancer research efforts aiming to elucidate the pivotal role of microenvironment in solid tumor development, enabling therapy trials and more precise prognosis for patients. ### Competing Interest Statement The authors have declared no competing interest.
Biopolymer hydrogels have become an important group of biomaterials in experimental and clinical use. However, unlike metallic or mineral materials, they are quite sensitive to sterilization. The aim of this study was to compare the effects of gamma irradiation and supercritical carbon dioxide (scCO2) treatment on the physicochemical properties of different hyaluronan (HA)- and/or gelatin (GEL)-based hydrogels and the cellular response of human bone marrow-derived mesenchymal stem cells (hBMSC). Hydrogels were photo-polymerized from methacrylated HA, methacrylated GEL, or a mixture of GEL/HA. The composition and sterilization methods altered the dissolution behavior of the biopolymeric hydrogels. There were no significant differences in methacrylated GEL release but increased methacrylated HA degradation of gamma-irradiated samples. Pore size/form remained unchanged, while gamma irradiation decreased the elastic modulus from about 29 kPa to 19 kPa compared to aseptic samples. HBMSC proliferated and increased alkaline phosphatase activity (ALP) particularly in aseptic and gamma-irradiated methacrylated GEL/HA hydrogels alike, while scCO2 treatment had a negative effect on both proliferation and osteogenic differentiation. Thus, gamma-irradiated methacrylated GEL/HA hydrogels are a promising base for multi-component bone substitute materials.
Increasing research has incorporated bioactive glass nanoparticles (BGN) and electric field (EF) stimulation for bone tissue engineering and regeneration applications. However, their interplay and the effects of different EF stimulation regimes on osteogenic differentiation of human mesenchymal stem cells (hMSC) are less investigated. In this study, we introduced EF with negligible magnetic field strength through a well-characterized transformer-like coupling (TLC) system, and applied EF disrupted (4/4) or consecutive (12/12) regime on type I collagen (Col) coatings with/without BGN over 28 days. Additionally, dexamethasone was excluded to enable an accurate interpretation of BGN and EF in supporting osteogenic differentiation. Here, we demonstrated the influences of BGN and EF on collagen topography and maintaining coating stability. Coupled with the release profile of Si ions from the BGN, cell proliferation and calcium deposition were enhanced in the Col-BGN samples after 28 days. Further, osteogenic differentiation was initiated as early as d 7, and each EF regime was shown to activate distinct pathways. The disrupted (4/4) regime was associated with the BMP/Smad4 pathways that up-regulate Runx2/OCN gene expression on d 7, with a lesser effect on ALP activity. In contrast, the canonical Wnt/β-Catenin signaling pathway activated through mechanotransduction cues is associated with the consecutive (12/12) regime, with significantly elevated ALP activity and Sp7 gene expression reported on d 7. In summary, our results illustrated the synergistic effects of BGN and EF in different stimulation regimes on osteogenic differentiation that can be further exploited to enhance current bone tissue engineering and regeneration approaches. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE: The unique release mechanisms of silica from bioactive glass nanoparticles (BGN) were coupled with pulsatile electric field (EF) stimulation to support hMSC osteogenic differentiation, in the absence of dexamethasone. Furthermore, the interplay with consecutive (12/12) and disrupted (4/4) stimulation regimes was investigated. The reported physical, mechanical and topographical effects of BGN and EF on the collagen coating, hMSC and the distinct progression of osteogenic differentiation (canonical Wnt/β-Catenin and BMP/Smad) triggered by respective stimulation regime were not explicitly reported previously. These results provide the fundamentals for further exploitations on BGN composites with metal ions and rotation of EF regimes to enhance osteogenic differentiation. The goal is sustaining continual osteogenic differentiation and achieving a more physiologically-relevant state and bone constructs in vitro.
Mesenchymal stem cell dynamics involve cell proliferation and cell differentiation into cells of distinct functional type, such as osteoblasts, adipocytes, or chondrocytes. Electrically active implants influence these dynamics for the regeneration of the cells in damaged tissues. How applied electric field influences processes of individual stem cells is a problem mostly unaddressed. The mathematical approaches to study stem cell dynamics have focused on the stem cell population as a whole, without resolving individual cells and intracellular processes. In this paper, we present a theoretical framework to describe the dynamics of a population of stem cells, taking into account the processes of the individual cells. We study the influence of the applied electric field on the cellular processes. We test our mean-field theory with the experiments from the literature, involving in vitro electrical stimulation of stem cells. We show that a simple model can quantitatively describe the experimentally observed time-course behavior of the total number of cells and the total alkaline phosphate activity in a population of mesenchymal stem cells. Our results show that the stem cell differentiation rate is dependent on the applied electrical field, confirming published experimental findings. Moreover, our analysis supports the cell density-dependent proliferation rate. Since the experimental results are averaged over many cells, our theoretical framework presents a robust and sensitive method for determining the effect of applied electric fields at the scale of the individual cell. These results indicate that the electric field stimulation may be effective in promoting bone regeneration by accelerating osteogenic differentiation.
Bone development and homeostasis are intricate processes that require co-existence and dynamic interactions among multiple cell types. However, controlled dynamic niches that derive and support stable propagation of these cells from single stem cell source is not sustainable in conventional culturing vessels. In bioreactor cultures that support dynamic niches, the limited source and stability of growth factors are often a major limiting factor for long-term in vitro cultures. Hence, alternative growth factor-free differentiation approaches are designed and their efficacy to achieve different osteochondral cell types is investigated. Briefly, a dynamic niche is achieved by varying medium pH, oxygen tension (pO2 ) distribution in bioreactor, initiating chondrogenic differentiation with chondroitin sulphate A (CSA), and implementing systematic differentiation regimes. In this study, we demonstrated that CSA is a potent chondrogenic inducer, specifically in combination with acidic medium and low pO2 . Further, endochondral ossification is recapitulated through a systematic chondrogenic-osteogenic (ch-os) differentiation regime, and multiple osteochondral cell types are derived. Chondrogenic hypertrophy was also enhanced specifically in high pO2 regions. Consequently, mineralised constructs with higher structural integrity, volume, and tailored dimensions are achieved. In contrast, a continuous osteogenic differentiation regime (os-os) has derived compact and dense constructs, whereas a continuous chondrogenic differentiation regime (ch-ch) has attenuated construct mineralisation and impaired development. In conclusion, a growth factor-free differentiation approach is achieved through interplay of pO2 , medium pH, and systematic differentiation regimes. The controlled dynamic niches have recapitulated endochondral ossification and can potentially be exploited to derive larger bone constructs with near physiological properties.
Here, we investigated the synergistic effect of electrospun nanofibrous scaffolds made of gelatin /sulfated hyaluronan (sHA) or native hyaluronan (HA)/chondroitin sulfate (CS) and, keratinocytes (HaCaT)—human mesenchymal stem cells (hMSCs) contact co-culture on epithelial differentiation of hMSCs. The hMSCs were co-cultured in contact with HaCaT cells for 5 days on electrospun scaffold. Results show that electrospun scaffolds containing sulfated glycosaminoglycans (GAGs) stimulate epithelial differentiation in terms of various protein expression markers (keratin 14, ΔNp63α and Pan-cytokeratin) and gene expression of several dermal proteins (keratin 14, ΔNp63α). Electrospun scaffold independent of GAGs alone did not affect the epithelial differentiation of hMSCs but combination of keratinocyte-hMSC contact co-culture and electrospun scaffold promotes the epithelial differentiation of hMSCs.
Incorporation of bioactive components like glycosaminoglycans (GAGs) into tissue engineering scaffolds, is a promising approach towards developing new generation functional biomaterial. Here, we have designed electrospun nanofibrous scaffolds made of gelatin and different concentrations of chemically sulfated or non-sulfated hyaluronan (sHA or HA) and chondroitin sulfate (CS). Evenly distributed fiber morphology was observed with no differences between varying concentrations and types of GAGs. In vitro release kinetics revealed that GAGs release is driven by diffusion. The effects of these scaffolds were analyzed on human keratinocyte (HaCaT), fibroblast (Hs27) and mesenchymal stem cells (hMSCs) adhesion and proliferation. A significant increase in cell number (~5 fold) was observed when cultivating all three cell types alone on scaffolds containing sHA and CS. These findings suggest that sulfated GAG-containing electrospun nanofibrous scaffolds might be beneficial for the development of effective skin tissue engineered constructs by stimulating cellular performance and therefore accelerate epidermal-dermal regeneration processes.
Skeletal development is a multistep process that involves the complex interplay of multiple cell types at different stages of development. Besides biochemical and physical cues, oxygen tension also plays a pivotal role in influencing cell fate during skeletal development. At physiological conditions, bone cells generally reside in a relatively oxygenated environment whereas chondrocytes reside in a hypoxic environment. However, it is technically challenging to achieve such defined, yet diverse oxygen distribution on traditional in vitro cultivation platforms. Instead, engineered osteochondral constructs are commonly cultivated in a homogeneous, stable environment. In this study, we describe a customized perfusion bioreactor having stable positional variability in oxygen tension at defined regions. Further, engineered collagen constructs were coaxed into adopting the shape and dimensions of defined cultivation platforms that were precasted in 1.5% agarose bedding. After cultivating murine embryonic stem cells that were embedded in collagen constructs for 50 days, mineralized constructs of specific dimensions and a stable structural integrity were achieved. The end-products, specifically constructs cultivated without chondroitin sulfate A (CSA), showed a significant increase in mechanical stiffness compared with their initial gel-like constructs. More importantly, the localization of osteochondral cell types was specific and corresponded to the oxygen tension gradient generated in the bioreactor. In addition, CSA in complementary with low oxygen tension was also found to be a potent inducer of chondrogenesis in this system. In summary, we have demonstrated a customized perfusion bioreactor prototype that is capable of generating a more dynamic, yet specific cultivation environment that could support propagation of multiple osteochondral lineages within a single engineered construct in vitro. Our system opens up new possibilities for in vitro research on human skeletal development.
The influences of physical stimuli such as surface elasticity, topography, and chemistry over mesenchymal stem cell proliferation and differentiation are well investigated. In this context, a fundamentally different approach was adopted, and we have demonstrated the interplay of inherent substrate conductivity, defined chemical composition of cellular microenvironment, and intermittent delivery of electric pulses to drive mesenchymal stem cell differentiation toward osteogenesis. For this, conducting polyaniline (PANI) substrates were coated with collagen type 1 (Coll) alone or in association with sulfated hyaluronan (sHya) to form artificial extracellular matrix (aECM), which mimics the native microenvironment of bone tissue. Further, bone marrow derived human mesenchymal stem cells (hMSCs) were cultured on these moderately conductive (10(-4)-10(-3) S/cm) aECM coated PANI substrates and exposed intermittently to pulsed electric field (PEF) generated through transformer-like coupling (TLC) approach over 28 days. On the basis of critical analysis over an array of end points, it was inferred that Coll/sHya coated PANI (PANI/Coll/sHya) substrates had enhanced proliferative capacity of hMSCs up to 28 days in culture, even in the absence of PEF stimulation. On the contrary, the adopted PEF stimulation protocol (7 ms rectangular pulses, 3.6 mV/cm, 10 Hz) is shown to enhance osteogenic differentiation potential of hMSCs. Additionally, PEF stimulated hMSCs had also displayed different morphological characteristics as their nonstimulated counterparts. Concomitantly, earlier onset of ALP activity was also observed on PANI/Coll/sHya substrates and resulted in more calcium deposition. Moreover, real-time polymerase chain reaction results indicated higher mRNA levels of alkaline phosphatase and osteocalcin, whereas the expression of other osteogenic markers such as Runt-related transcription factor 2, Col1A, and osteopontin exhibited a dynamic pattern similar to control cells that are cultured in osteogenic medium. Taken together, our experimental results illustrate the interplay of multiple parameters such as substrate conductivity, electric field stimulation, and aECM coating on the modulation of hMSC proliferation and differentiation in vitro.
Osteoarthritis (OA) is a multifactorial, often progressive, painful disease. OA often progresses with an apparent irreversible loss of articular cartilage, exposing underlying bone, resulting in pain and loss of mobility. This cartilage loss is thought to be permanent due to ineffective repair and apparent lack of stem/progenitor cells in that tissue. However, the adjacent synovial lining and synovial fluid are abundant with mesenchymal progenitor/stem cells (synovial mesenchymal progenitor cells [sMPCs]) capable of differentiating into cartilage both in vitro and in vivo. Previous studies have demonstrated that MPCs can home to factors such as monocyte chemotactic protein 1 (MCP-1/CCL2) expressed after injury. While MCP-1 (and its corresponding receptors) appears to play a role in recruiting stem cells to the site of injury, in this study, we have demonstrated that MCP-1 is upregulated in OA synovial fluid and that exposure to MCP-1 activates sMPCs, while concurrently inhibiting these cells from undergoing chondrogenesis in vitro. Furthermore, exposure to physiological (OA knee joint synovial fluid) levels of MCP-1 triggers changes in the transcriptome of sMPCs and prolonged exposure to the chemokine induces the expression of MCP-1 in sMPCs, resulting in a positive feedback loop from which sMPCs cannot apparently escape. Therefore, we propose a model where MCP-1 (normally expressed after joint injury) recruits sMPCs to the area of injury, but concurrently triggers changes in sMPC transcriptional regulation, leading to a blockage in the chondrogenic program. These results may open up new avenues of research into the lack of endogenous repair observed after articular cartilage injury and/or arthritis.
Embryonic stem cells are actively explored as a cell source in tissue engineering and regenerative medicine involving bone repair. Basic fibroblast growth factor (bFGF) has been a valuable growth factor to support the culture of human stem cells as well as their osteogenic differentiation, but the influence of bFGF on mouse embryonic stem (mES) cells is not known. Towards this goal, D3 cells were treated with bFGF during maintenance conditions and during spontaneous and osteogenic differentiation. In feeder-free monolayers, up to 40ng/ml of exogenous bFGF did not support self-renewal of mES without LIF during cell expansion. During spontaneous differentiation in high-density cultures, bFGF stimulated cell proliferation under certain conditions but did not influence differentiation, as judged by stage-specific embryonic antigen-1 expression. The addition of bFGF reduced the alkaline phosphatase (ALP) activity associated with osteoblast activity during differentiation induced by osteogenic supplements, although the extent of mineralization was unaffected by bFGF. The bFGF increased the mesenchymal stem cell marker Sca-1 in an mES cell population and led to an enhanced increase in osteocalcin and runx2 expression in combination with BMP-2. These results suggest that bFGF could be utilized to expand the cell population in high-density cultures in addition to enriching the BMP-2 responsiveness of mES cells. Copyright (c) 2012 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.