Electrochemistry is an important approach for controlling and modulating the electronic and electrical properties of molecular materials, even at the single molecule level. Recently, the combination of reliable methodologies for single-molecule measurements in electrochemical environments with increasingly refined computational modelling has greatly advanced understanding of charge transport through single molecules. It also reveals how this is impacted by the redox (electrochemical) state of the molecule and the electrochemical environment. In this study the single-molecule conductance of a phenothiazine-containing molecular wire PTZ-1 is shown to exhibit an electrode potential dependence characterised by a gradual rise over an unusually broad potential window (≈ 1 V). Significantly, the onset of the conductance rise occurs substantially negative of the reversible oxidation potential for the molecule, and therefore the data cannot be attributed to typical mechanisms for electrochemical gating. These processes are modelled using DFT computations, in which the increasing conductance is seen to result from the Fano resonance induced by the phenothiazine group which is gated by electrolyte ions. These electrolyte ions gate the conductance of the molecular wire even though the phenothiazine is not redox switched to its oxidised state. The significance of this work is in identifying this mechanism for gating conductance at the single molecule level, which recognises and includes the role of electrolyte ions in an ab initio computational model. This understanding is of great importance for nanoscale devices, where subtle ion migration plays a role in functionality.
The linear carbon allotrope carbyne has been predicted to display outstanding electrical and mechanical properties, but its preparation and characterization are hindered by synthetic challenges. Although oligoyne and [n]cumulene models of carbyne have been explored, the end-groups used to avoid decomposition have a profound effect on their electronic configuration. Here we show that transmetallation of linear carbon fragments from Au(I) species to Au(0) electrodes delivers stable Au|CC…CC|Au devices. Scanning tunnelling microscope break junction techniques were used to characterize charge-transport behaviour in these one-dimensional carbon chains (up to 16 atoms) free of end-capping groups. Shorter chains exhibited oligoyne-like behaviour, with conductance attenuation as a function of length, whereas longer chains show evidence of bond-length equalization towards a cumulenic structure, with remarkably enhanced charge transport. The direct contact between the electrode and the carbon fragment at the Au|C interfaces grant high conductance and quasi-ballistic transport to one-dimensional carbon chains, providing a pathway to advanced carbon-based nanoelectronics based on the stabilization of carbyne within the junction environment.
It is becoming increasingly evident that transition metal complexes impart desirable qualities in single-molecule electronics, and testing metallic centres in combination with appropriate ligands is salient to building the next generation of single-molecule devices. Metal-phosphine complexes have been the subject of very few studies, despite their extensive use in other areas of chemistry. In this contribution, we fabricated and studied robust single-molecule junctions using linear bis-chelated ligand-metal-ligand complexes of the type [M(PNP)2]PF6 (M = Cu(I), Ag(I) or Au(I); PNP = bis(diphenylphosphino)aniline functionalised with methylthio contact groups). The robustness of the devices was evinced by surface-enhanced Raman spectroscopy (SERS) and scanning-tunnelling microscopy break junction (STM-BJ) methods, and the conductance of the devices was found to be independent of the central transition metal. Quantum transport calculations show consistent HOMO-LUMO gaps between the studied complexes in the transmission plots, supporting the experimental findings. This study shows that bis-chelation is a viable approach to the fabrication of stable and robust metal-phosphine devices.
Flicker noise analysis has found widespread use in the molecular electronics community over the past 9 years. The noise power of the junctions and the value of its scaling exponent n provide information on the spatial overlap of scattering states in single-molecule junctions and give unique insights into quantum transport phenomena at the single-molecule level. The predominant drawback of this analytical tool is the inconsistency of the methodologies employed, resulting in irreproducibility across data sets acquired in different conditions or in different laboratories. Herein, we provide a pathway to a more reproducible methodology, detailing issues with the currently accepted correlation techniques employed and introducing the use of more statistically robust data processing criteria and lower thresholds for data acquisition parameters.
Miniaturised mechanoresistive devices, where charge transport efficiency can be modulated by mechanical displacement, are an important class of electromechanical systems that promise unique sensing accuracy and sensitivity. Single-molecule junctions have emerged in the last decade as the ultimately scaled down system, operating in the quantum realm. Several strategies have been developed to impart mechanoresistivity to a molecular backbone, but all these require structural modifications to the conducting backbone, to introduce either alternative, short-circuiting anchoring points to the electrode, or conformationally flexible moieties. Here, we show a synthetically accessible way to impart mechanoresistivity, by adding silyl-protected ethynyl functional groups that extend the π-system orthogonally to the transport axis. Junctions fabricated with ethynyl-extended acenes demonstrate strong and reproducible mechanoresistivity, with log-linear dependence of conductance on displacement and high conductance modulation amplitude (>10^2 per nanometre). Analytical and Density Functional modelling demonstrate that the compressed junctions are better coupled to the electrodes, due to overlap between the extended π-system and the density of states of the Au electrodes. As ethynyl moieties are trivial to attach to a variety of substrates, we expect this strategy to be widely applicable as a synthetically advantageous way to impart mechanoresistivity – or simply stronger coupling to the electrodes – to a wide variety of molecular wires.
Open‐shell materials bearing multiple spin centres provide a key route to efficient charge transport in single‐molecule electronic devices. They have narrow energy gaps, and their molecular orbitals align closely to the Fermi level of the metallic electrodes, thus allowing efficient electronic transport and higher conductance. Maintaining and stabilising multiple open‐shell states – especially in contact with metallic electrodes – is however very challenging, generally requiring a continuous chemical or electrochemical potential to avoid self‐immolation of the open‐shell character. To overcome this issue, we designed, synthesised, and measured the conductance of a series of bis(indeno) fused acenes, where stability is imparted by a close‐shell quinoidal conformation in resonance with the diradical electronic configuration. We show here that these compounds have anti‐ohmic behaviour, with conductance increasing with increasing molecular length, at an unprecedented rate and across the entire bias window ([[EQUATION]]). Density Functional Theory (DFT) calculations support our findings, showing the rapidly narrowing HOMO‐LUMO gap, unique to these diradicaloid structures, is responsible for the observed behaviour. Our results provide a framework for achieving efficient transport in neutral compounds and demonstrate the promise that diradicaloid materials have in single‐molecule electronics, owing to their great stability and unique electronic structure.
There are several binding groups used within molecular electronics for anchoring molecules to metal electrodes (e.g., R−SMe, R−NH 2 , R−CS 2 − , R−S − ). However, some anchoring groups that bind strongly to electrodes have poor/unknown stability, some have weak electrode coupling, while for some their binding motifs are not well defined. Further binding groups are required to aid molecular design and to achieve a suitable balance in performance across a range of properties. We present an in-depth investigation into the use of carbodithioate esters as contact groups for single-molecule conductance measurements, using scanning tunnelling microscopy break junction measurements (STM-BJ) and detailed surface spectroscopic analysis. We demonstrate that the methyl carbodithioate ester acts as an effective contact for gold electrodes in STM-BJ measurements. Surface enhanced Raman measurements demonstrate that the C=S functionality remains intact when adsorbed on to gold nanoparticles. A gold(I) complex was also synthesised showing a stable C=S→Au I interaction from the ester. Comparison with a benzyl thiomethyl ether demonstrates that the C=S moiety significantly contributes to charge transport in single-molecule junctions. The overall performance of the CS 2 Me group demonstrates it should be used more extensively and has strong potential for the fabrication of larger area devices with long-term stability.
The metal-electrode interface is key to unlocking emergent behaviour in all organic electrified systems, from battery technology to molecular electronics. In the latter, interfacial engineering has enabled efficient transport, higher device stability, and novel functionality. Mechanoresistivity – the change in electrical behaviour in response to a mechanical stimulus and a pathway to extremely sensitive force sensors – is amongst the most studied phenomena in molecular electronics, and the molecule-electrode interface plays a pivotal role in its emergence, reproducibility, and magnitude. In this contribution, we show that organometallic molecular wires incorporating a Pt(II) cation show mechanoresistive behaviour of exceptional magnitude, with conductance modulations of more than three orders of magnitude upon compression by as little as 1 nm. We synthesised series of cyclometalated Pt(II) molecular wires, and used scanning tunnelling microscopy – break junction techniques to characterise their electromechanical behaviour. Mechanoresistivity arises from an interaction between the Pt(II) cation and the Au electrode triggered by mechanical compression of the single-molecule device, and theoretical modelling confirms this hypothesis. Our study provides a new tool for the design of functional molecular wires by exploiting previously unreported ion-metal interactions in single-molecule devices, and develops a new framework for the development of mechanoresistive molecular junctions.
Existing modelling tools, developed to aid the design of efficient molecular wires and to better understand their charge-transport behaviour and mechanism, have limitations in accuracy and computational cost. Further research is required to develop faster and more precise methods that can yield information on how charge transport properties are impacted by changes in the chemical structure of a molecular wire. In this study, we report a clear semilogarithmic correlation between charge transport efficiency and nuclear magnetic resonance chemical shifts in multiple series of molecular wires, also accounting for the presence of chemical substituents. The NMR data was used to inform a simple tight-binding model that accurately captures the experimental single-molecule conductance values, especially useful in this case as more sophisticated density functional theory calculations fail due to inherent limitations. Our study demonstrates the potential of NMR spectroscopy as a valuable tool for characterising, rationalising, and gaining additional insights on the charge transport properties of single-molecule junctions.
Mechanosensitive molecular junctions, where conductance is sensitive to an applied stress such as force or displacement, are a class of nanoelectromechanical systems unique for their ability to exploit quantum mechanical phenomena. Most studies so far relied on reconfiguration of the molecule-electrode interface to impart mechanosensitivity, but this approach is limited and, generally, poorly reproducible. Alternatively, devices that exploit conformational flexibility of molecular wires have been recently proposed. The mechanosensitive properties of molecular wires containing the 1,1'-dinaphthyl moiety are presented here. Rotation along the chemical bond between the two naphthyl units is possible, giving rise to two conformers (transoid and cisoid) that have distinctive transport properties. When assembled as single-molecule junctions, it is possible to mechanically trigger the transoid to cisoid transition, resulting in an exquisitely sensitive mechanical switch with high switching ratio (> 102). Theoretical modeling shows that charge reconfiguration upon transoid to cisoid transition is responsible for the observed behavior, with generation and subsequent lifting of quantum interference features. These findings expand the experimental toolbox of molecular electronics with a novel chemical structure with outstanding electromechanical properties, further demonstrating the importance of subtle changes in charge delocalization on the transport properties of single-molecule devices.
While a multitude of studies have appeared touting the use of molecules as electronic components, the design of molecular switches is crucial for the next steps in molecular electronics. In this work, single-molecule devices incorporating spiropyrans, made using break junction techniques, are described. Linear spiropyrans with electrode-contacting groups linked by alkynyl spacers to both the indoline and chromenone moieties have previously provided very low conductance values, and removing the alkynyl spacer has resulted in a total loss of conductance. An orthogonal T-shaped approach to single-molecule junctions incorporating spiropyran moieties in which the conducting pathway lies orthogonal to the molecule backbone is described and characterized. This approach has provided singlemolecule conductance features with good correlation to molecular length. Additional higher conducting states are accessible using switching induced by UV light or protonation. Theoretical modeling demonstrates that upon (photo)chemical isomerization to the merocyanine, two cooperating phenomena increase conductance: release of steric hindrance allows the conductance pathway to become more planar (raising the mid-bandgap transmission) and a bound state introduces sharp interference near the Fermi level of the electrodes similarly responding to the change in state. This design step paves the way for future use of spiropyrans in single-molecule devices and electrosteric switches.
The present work provides an insight into the effect of connectivity isomerization of metal-2,2 '-bipyridine complexes. For that purpose, two new 2,2 '-bipyridine (bpy) ligand systems, 4,4 '-bis(4-(methylthio)phenyl)-2,2 '-bipyridine (L-meta) and 5,5 '-bis(3,3-dimethyl-2,3-dihydrobenzothiophen-5-yl)-2,2 '-bipyridine (L-para) were synthesized and coordinated to rhenium and manganese to obtain the corresponding complexes MnLmeta(CO)(3)Br, ReLmeta(CO)(3)Br, MnLpara(CO)(3)Br, MoLpara(CO)(4) and ReLpara(CO)(3)Br. The experimental and theoretical results revealed that coordination to the para system, i.e., the metal ion peripheral to the conductance path, gave a slightly increased conductance compared to the free ligand attributed to the reduced highest occupied molecular orbital (HOMO)-least unoccupied molecular orbital (LUMO) gap. The meta-based system formed a destructive quantum interference feature that reduced the conductance of a S center dot center dot center dot S contacted junction to below 10(-5.5) G(o), reinforcing the importance of contact group connectivity for molecular wire conductance.
The final performance of a molecular electronic device is determined by the chemical structure of the molecular wires used in its assembly. Molecular place-exchange was used to incorporate di-thioacetate terminated molecules into ordered arrays of dodecanethiol capped gold nanoparticles. X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy confirmed successful molecular replacement. Room-temperature molecular conductance of a statistically large number of devices reveals that conductance is enhanced by up to two orders of magnitude for the di-thioacetate terminated molecules. Density functional theory transport calculations were performed on five different configurations of the di-thioacetate molecules between gold electrodes, and the calculated average conductance values are in good agreement with the conductance experimentally-observed trend. Our findings highlight important cooperative effects of bridging neighboring gold nanoparticles and choice of appropriate molecular wires when designing devices for efficient transport.
The environment surrounding a molecular junction affects its charge-transport properties and, therefore, must be chosen with care. In the case of measurements in liquid media, the solvent must provide good solvation, grant junction stability, and, in the case of electrolyte gating experiments, allow efficient electrical coupling to the gate electrodes through control of the electrical double layer. We evaluated in this study the deep eutectic solvent mixture (DES) ethaline, which is a mixture of choline chloride and ethylene glycol (1:2), for single-molecule junction fabrication with break-junction techniques. In ethaline, we were able to (i) measure challenging and poorly soluble molecular wires, exploiting the improved solvation capabilities offered by DESs, and (ii) efficiently apply an electrostatic gate able to modulate the conductance of the junction by approximately an order of magnitude within a ∼1 V potential window. The electrochemical gating results on a Au-VDP-Au junction follow exceptionally well the single-level modeling with strong gate coupling (where VDP is 1,2-di(pyridine-4-yl)ethene). Ethaline is also an ideal solvent for the measurement of very short molecular junctions, as it grants a greatly reduced snapback distance of the metallic electrodes upon point-contact rupture. Our work demonstrates that DESs are viable alternatives to often relatively expensive ionic liquids, offering good versatility for single-molecule electrical measurements.
The modification of conjugated organic compounds with organometallic moieties allows the modulation of the electronic and optoelectronic properties of such compounds and lends them to a variety of material applications. The organometallic complexes [M(Cp′)(L)n] (M = Ru or Fe; Cp′ = cyclopentadiene (Cp) or pentamethylcyclopentadiene (Cp*); (L)n = (PPh3)2 or 1,2-bi(diphenylphosphino)ethane (dppe)) and [M(L)n] (M = Ru; (L)n = (dppe)2 or (P(OEt)3)4; or M = Pt; (L)n = (PEt3)2, (PPh3)2 or tricyclohexylphosphine, (PCy3)2) modified with a 5-ethynyl-1,3,3-trimethyl-3H-indole ligand were prepared and characterised by NMR spectroscopy, IR and single-crystal X-ray diffraction. Cyclic voltammetry and IR spectroelectrochemistry of the ruthenium systems showed a single-electron oxidation localised over the M–C≡C–aryl moiety. The N-heteroatom of the indole ligand showed Lewis base properties and was able to extract a proton from a vinylidene intermediate as well as coordinate to CuI. Examples from the wire-like compounds were also studied by single-molecule break junction experiments but molecular junction formation was not observed. This is most likely attributable to the binding characteristics of the substituted terminal indole groups used here to the gold contacts.
Most studies in molecular electronics focus on altering the molecular wire backbone to tune the electrical properties of the whole junction. However, it is often overlooked that the chemical structure of the groups anchoring the molecule to the metallic electrodes influences the electronic structure of the whole system and, therefore, its conductance. We synthesised electron-accepting dithienophosphole oxide derivatives and fabricated their single-molecule junctions. We found that the anchor group has a dramatic effect on charge-transport efficiency: in our case, electron-deficient 4-pyridyl contacts suppress conductance, while electron-rich 4-thioanisole termini promote efficient transport. Our calculations show that this is due to minute changes in charge distribution, probed at the electrode interface. Our findings provide a framework for efficient molecular junction design, especially valuable for compounds with strong electron withdrawing/donating backbones.
Abstract Future applications of single‐molecular and large‐surface area molecular devices require a thorough understanding and control of molecular junctions, interfacial phenomena, and intermolecular interactions. In this contribution the concept of single‐molecule junction and host‐guest complexation to sheath a benchmark molecular wire–namely 4,4′‐(1,4‐phenylenebis(ethyne‐2,1‐diyl))dianiline – with an insulating cage, pillar[5]arene 1,4‐diethoxy‐2‐ethyl‐5‐methylbenzene is presented. The insertion of one guest molecular wire into one host pillar[5]arene is probed by 1H‐NMR (nuclear magnetic resonance), whilst the self‐assembly capabilities of the amine‐terminated molecular wire remain intact after complexation as demonstrated by XPS (X‐ray photoelectron spectroscopy) and AFM (atomic force microscopy). Encapsulation of the molecular wire prevents the formation of π‐ π stacked dimers and permits the determination of the true single molecule conductance with increased accuracy and confidence, as demonstrated here by using the STM–BJ technique (scanning tunneling microscopy– break junction). This strategy opens new avenues in the control of single‐molecule properties and demonstrates the pillararenes capabilities for the future construction of arrays of encapsulated single‐molecule functional units in large‐surface area devices.
The electrical properties of large area molecular devices consisting of gold nanoparticles (GNPs) sandwiched between a double layer of alkanedithiol linkers have been examined. These devices have been fabricated by a facile bottom-up assembly in which an alkanedithiol monolayer is first self-assembled on an underlying gold substrate followed by nanoparticle adsorption and then finally assembly of the top alkanedithiol layer. These devices are then sandwiched between the bottom gold substrates and a top eGaIn probe contact and current-voltage (I-V) curves recorded. Devices have been fabricated with 1,5-pentanedithiol, 1,6-hexanedithiol, 1,8-octanedithiol and 1,10-decanedithiol linkers. In all cases the electrical conductance of the double SAM junctions with GNPs is higher than the corresponding and much thinner single alkanedithiol SAM. Competing models for this enhanced conductance are discussed and it is suggested to have a topological origin arising from how the devices assemble or structure during the fabrication, which gives more efficient cross device electron transport pathways without the GNPs producing short circuits.
Controlling the orientation of complex molecules in molecular junctions is crucial to their development into functional devices. To date, this has been achieved through the use of multipodal compounds (i.e., containing more than two anchoring groups), resulting in the formation of tri/tetrapodal compounds. While such compounds have greatly improved orientation control, this comes at the cost of lower surface coverage. In this study, we examine an alternative approach for generating multimodal compounds by binding multiple independent molecular wires together through metal coordination to form a molecular bundle. This was achieved by coordinating iron(II) and cobalt(II) to 5,5'-bis(methylthio)-2,2'-bipyridine (L1) and (methylenebis(4,1-phenylene))bis(1-(5-(methylthio)pyridin-2-yl)methanimine) (L2) to give two monometallic complexes, Fe-1 and Co-1, and two bimetallic helicates, Fe-2 and Co-2. Using XPS, all of the complexes were shown to bind to a gold surface in a fac fashion through three thiomethyl groups. Using single-molecule conductance and DFT calculations, each of the ligands was shown to conduct as an independent wire with no impact from the rest of the complex. These results suggest that this is a useful approach for controlling the geometry of junction formation without altering the conductance behavior of the individual molecular wires.
The single-molecular conductance of a redox active viologen molecular bridge between Au|graphene electrodes has been studied in an electrochemical gating configuration in an ionic liquid medium. A clear "off-on-off" conductance switching behaviour has been achieved through gating of the redox state when the electrochemical potential is swept. The Au|viologen|graphene junctions show single-molecule conductance maxima centred close to the equilibrium redox potentials for both reduction steps. The peak conductance of Au|viologen|graphene junctions during the first reduction is significantly higher than that of previously measured Au|viologen|Au junctions. This shows that even though the central viologen moiety is not directly linked to the enclosing electrodes, substituting one gold contact for a graphene one nevertheless has a significant impact on junction conductance values. The experimental data was compared against two theoretical models, namely a phase coherent tunnelling and an incoherent "hopping" model. The former is a simple gating monoelectronic model within density functional theory (DFT) which discloses the charge state evolution of the molecule with electrode potential. The latter model is the collective Kuznetsov Ulstrup model for 2-step sequential charge transport through the redox centre in the adiabatic limit. The comparison of both models to the experimental data is discussed for the first time. This work opens perspectives for graphene-based molecular transistors with more effective gating and fundamental understanding of electrochemical electron transfer at the single molecular level.