BACKGROUND:Conventional dendritic cells (cDCs), are central to antitumour immunity, but their low prevalence in tumours limits the efficacy of immunotherapies. FLT3L is a key growth factor regulating cDCs development in the bone marrow. It expands cDCs when administered exogenously, favouring antitumour T cell priming and tumour control. Currently, FLT3L pharmacokinetic (PK) and pharmacodynamic (PD) properties require daily dosing for up to 14 days, which may limit its clinical use. In the present study, we developed and characterised a therapeutic modality named FLT3L-Fc NG2LH. METHODS:We improved human FLT3L PK properties by fusing it with a modified fragment crystallisable (Fc) domain of IgG1. To prevent Fc gamma receptor (FcγR) mediated effector function, we engineered an effectorless Fc format called NG2LH, consisting of the aglycosylation substitution N297G, combined with a graft of the lower hinge region of IgG2 onto an otherwise IgG1 Fc. FINDINGS:FLT3L-Fc NG2LH had limited binding to FcγRs and failed to elicit antibody dependent cellular cytotoxicity (ADCC) and cellular phagocytosis (ADCP). PK/PD studies using a mouse effectorless equivalent, mFLT3L-Fc, showed that a single injection of mFLT3L-Fc leads to sustained expansion of cDCs in blood, spleen, and B16F10 tumours. When combined with polyI:C and anti-PD-L1, a single mFLT3L-Fc injection delays the growth of B16F10 tumours and reinvigorates CD8+ T cell immunity. INTERPRETATION:The improved properties of FLT3L-Fc NG2LH are expected to mitigate the practical limitations of FLT3L usage in the clinic, and constitute an asset for future cancer immunotherapy combination regimens leveraging cDC biology in situ. FUNDING:This work was performed at, and funded by Genentech Inc. South San Francisco, CA 94080, USA.
Immunogenicity to biologic drugs manifests as the generation of anti-drug antibodies (ADAs), which can significantly impact the safety, efficacy, pharmacokinetics, and pharmacodynamics of biotherapeutic products, potentially rendering them ineffective. Understanding the causes of immunogenicity is necessary to mitigate the risks associated with drug candidates. To characterize the cellular and molecular processes initiated during an immune response to human biologics, we performed single-cell transcriptome and surface proteome analysis of over 150,000 peripheral blood mononuclear cells, treated with biotherapeutics exhibiting varying degrees of clinical immunogenicity. Our findings highlight CD14+ monocytes as the primary cells initiating an immune response against a biotherapeutic. These cells preferentially internalize immunogenic biotherapeutics at higher rates leading to activation and secretion of key pro-inflammatory mediators. Furthermore, we identified a biomarker of immunogenicity, RNASE 1. The expression of this enzyme is suppressed during an immunogenic response in vitro, as well as in vivo in clinical ADA+ patients. Perturbation of the extracellular availability of RNASE 1 also regulated therapeutic protein-dependent T cell activation. This study provides critical insights into antigen processing mechanisms by CD14+ monocytes, emphasizing their role in biologic immunogenicity and highlighting a potential biomarker for predicting immunogenicity. Antigen and Dendritic Cell Processing, Presentation, and Biology (AGDC)
IntroductionAs a crucial asset for human health and modern medicine, an increasing number of biotherapeutics are entering the clinic. However, due to their complexity, these drugs have a higher potential to be immunogenic, leading to the generation of anti-drug antibodies (ADAs). Clinically significant ADAs have an impact on pharmacokinetics (PK), pharmacodynamics (PD), effectiveness, and/or safety. Thus, it is crucial to understand, manage and minimize the immunogenicity potential during drug development, ideally starting from the molecule design stage.MethodsIn this study, we utilized various immunogenicity risk assessment methods, including in silico prediction, dendritic cell internalization, MHC-associated peptide proteomics, in vitro HLA peptide binding, and in vitro T cell proliferation, to assess the immunogenicity risk of FLT3L-Fc variants.ResultsWe identified a single point mutation in the human FLT3L-Fc protein that introduced highly immunogenic T cell epitopes, leading to the induction of T cell responses and thereby increasing the immunogenicity risk in clinical settings. Consequently, the variant with this point mutation was removed from further consideration as a clinical candidate.DiscussionThis finding underscores the necessity for careful evaluation of mutations during the engineering of protein therapeutics. The integration of multiple immunogenicity risk assessment tools offers critical insights for informed decision-making in candidate sequence design and therapeutic lead selection.
Monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) have transformed therapeutic strategies for various diseases. Their high specificity to target antigens makes them ideal therapeutic agents for certain diseases. However, a challenge to their application in clinical practice is their potential risk to induce unwanted immune response, termed immunogenicity. This challenge drives the continued efforts to deimmunize these protein therapeutics while maintaining their pharmacokinetic properties and therapeutic efficacy. Because mAbs hold a central position in therapeutic strategies against an array of diseases, the importance of conducting comprehensive immunogenicity risk assessment during the drug development process cannot be overstated. Such assessment necessitates the employment of in silico, in vitro, and in vivo strategies to evaluate the immunogenicity risk of mAbs. Understanding the intricacies of the mechanisms that drive mAb immunogenicity is crucial to improving their therapeutic efficacy and safety and developing the most effective strategies to determine and mitigate their immunogenic risk. This review highlights recent advances in immunogenicity prediction strategies, with a focus on protein engineering strategies used throughout development to reduce immunogenicity.
Bispecific antibodies, including bispecific IgG, are emerging as an important new class of antibody therapeutics. As a result, we, as well as others, have developed engineering strategies designed to facilitate the efficient production of bispecific IgG for clinical development. For example, we have extensively used knobs-into-holes (KIH) mutations to facilitate the heterodimerization of antibody heavy chains and more recently Fab mutations to promote cognate heavy/light chain pairing for efficient in vivo assembly of bispecific IgG in single host cells. A panel of related monospecific and bispecific IgG1 antibodies was constructed and assessed for immunogenicity risk by comparison with benchmark antibodies with known low (Avastin and Herceptin) or high (bococizumab and ATR-107) clinical incidence of anti-drug antibodies. Assay methods used include dendritic cell internalization, T cell proliferation, and T cell epitope identification by in silico prediction and MHC-associated peptide proteomics. Data from each method were considered independently and then together for an overall integrated immunogenicity risk assessment. In toto, these data suggest that the KIH mutations and in vitro assembly of half antibodies do not represent a major risk for immunogenicity of bispecific IgG1, nor do the Fab mutations used for efficient in vivo assembly of bispecifics in single host cells. Comparable or slightly higher immunogenicity risk assessment data were obtained for research-grade preparations of trastuzumab and bevacizumab versus Herceptin and Avastin, respectively. These data provide experimental support for the common practice of using research-grade preparations of IgG1 as surrogates for immunogenicity risk assessment of their corresponding pharmaceutical counterparts.
Antigen presentation on MHC class II (pMHCII presentation) plays an essential role in the adaptive immune response to extracellular pathogens and cancerous cells. But it can also reduce the efficacy of large-molecule drugs by triggering an anti-drug response. Significant progress has been made in pMHCII presentation modeling due to the collection of large-scale pMHC mass spectrometry datasets (ligandomes) and advances in machine learning. Here, we develop graph-pMHC, a graph neural network approach to predict pMHCII presentation. We derive adjacency matrices for pMHCII using Alphafold2-multimer and address the peptide-MHC binding groove alignment problem with a simple graph enumeration strategy. We demonstrate that graph-pMHC dramatically outperforms methods with suboptimal inductive biases, such as the multilayer-perceptron-based NetMHCIIpan-4.0 (+20.17% absolute average precision). Finally, we create an antibody drug immunogenicity dataset from clinical trial data and develop a method for measuring anti-antibody immunogenicity risk using pMHCII presentation models. Our model increases receiver operating characteristic curve (ROC)-area under the ROC curve (AUC) by 2.57% compared to just filtering peptides by hits in OASis alone for predicting antibody drug immunogenicity.
Biotin- and digoxigenin (DIG)-conjugated therapeutic drugs are critical reagents used for the development of anti-drug antibody (ADA) assays for the assessment of immunogenicity. The current practice of generating biotin and DIG conjugates is to label a therapeutic antibody with biotin or DIG via primary amine groups on lysine or N-terminal residues. This approach modifies lysine residues nonselectively, which can impact the ability of an ADA assay to detect those ADAs that recognize epitopes located at or near the modified lysine residue(s). The impact of the lysine modification is considered greater for therapeutic antibodies that have a limited number of lysine residues, such as the variable heavy domain of heavy chain (VHH) antibodies. In this paper, for the first time, we report the application of site-specifically conjugated biotin- and DIG-VHH reagents to clinical ADA assay development using a model molecule, VHHA. The site-specific conjugation of biotin or DIG to VHHA was achieved by using an optimized reductive alkylation approach, which enabled the majority of VHHA molecules labeled with biotin or DIG at the desirable N-terminus, thereby minimizing modification of the protein after labeling and reducing the possibility of missing detection of ADAs. Head-to-head comparison of biophysical characterization data revealed that the site-specific biotin and DIG conjugates demonstrated overall superior quality to biotin- and DIG-VHHA prepared using the conventional amine coupling method, and the performance of the ADA assay developed using site-specific biotin and DIG conjugates met all acceptance criteria. The approach described here can be applied to the production of other therapeutic-protein- or antibody-based critical reagents that are used to support ligand binding assays.
Therapeutic antibodies can elicit unwanted immune responses in a subset of patients, which leads to the production of anti-drug antibodies (ADA). Some of these ADAs have been reported to effect the pharmacokinetics, efficacy and/or safety of the therapeutic antibodies. The sequence diversity of antibodies are generated by VDJ recombination and mutagenesis. While the antibody generation process can create a large candidate pool for identifying high-affinity antibodies, it also could produce sequences that are foreign to the human immune system. However, it is not clear how VDJ recombination and mutagenesis impact the clinical ADA rate of therapeutic antibodies. In this study, we identified a positive correlation between the clinical ADA rate and the number of introduced mutations in the antibody sequences. We also found that the use of rare V alleles in human-origin antibody therapeutics is associated with higher risk of immunogenicity. The results suggest that antibody engineering projects should start with frameworks that contain commonly used V alleles and prioritize antibody candidates with low number of mutations to reduce the risk of immunogenicity.
Despite the recent progress, multiple myeloma (MM) is still essentially incurable and there is a need for additional effective treatments with good tolerability. RO7297089 is a novel bispecific BCMA/CD16A-directed innate cell engager (ICE®) designed to induce BCMA+ MM cell lysis through high affinity binding of CD16A and retargeting of NK cell cytotoxicity and macrophage phagocytosis. Unlike conventional antibodies approved in MM, RO7297089 selectively targets CD16A with no binding of other Fcγ receptors, including CD16B on neutrophils, and irrespective of 158V/F polymorphism, and its activity is less affected by competing IgG suggesting activity in the presence of M-protein. Structural analysis revealed this is due to selective interaction with a single residue (Y140) uniquely present in CD16A opposite the Fc binding site. RO7297089 induced tumor cell killing more potently than conventional antibodies (wild-type and Fc-enhanced) and induced lysis of BCMA+ cells at very low effector-to-target ratios. Preclinical toxicology data suggested a favorable safety profile as in vitro cytokine release was minimal and no RO7297089-related mortalities or adverse events were observed in cynomolgus monkeys. These data suggest good tolerability and the potential of RO7297089 to be a novel effective treatment of MM patients.
Biotherapeutics, which are biologic medications that are natural or bioengineered products of living cells, have revolutionized the treatment of many diseases. However, unwanted immune responses still present a major challenge to their widespread adoption. Many patients treated with biotherapeutics develop antigen-specific anti-drug antibodies (ADAs) that may reduce the efficacy of the therapy or cross-react with the endogenous counterpart of a protein therapeutic, or both. Here, we describe an in vitro method for assessing the immunogenic risk of a biotherapeutic. We found a correlation between clinical immunogenicity and the frequency with which a biotherapeutic stimulated an increase in CD134, CD137, or both cell surface markers on CD4+ T cells. Using high-throughput flow cytometry, we examined the effects of 14 biotherapeutics with diverse rates of clinical immunogenicity on peripheral blood mononuclear cells from 120 donors with diverse human leukocyte antigen class II-encoding alleles. Biotherapeutics with high rates of ADA development in the clinic had higher proportions of CD4+ T cells positive for CD134 or CD137 than biotherapeutics with low clinical immunogenicity. This method provides a rapid and simple preclinical test of the immunogenic potential of a new candidate biotherapeutic or biosimilar. Implementation of this approach during biotherapeutic research and development enables rapid elimination of candidates that are likely to cause ADA-related adverse events and detrimental consequences.
Development of antidrug antibodies (ADAs) is an undesirable potential outcome of administration of biotherapeutics and involves the innate and adaptive immune systems. ADAs can have detrimental clinical consequences: they can reduce biotherapeutic efficacy or produce adverse events. Because animal models are considered poor predictors of immunogenicity in humans, in vitro assays with human innate and adaptive immune cells are commonly used alternatives that can reveal cell-mediated unwanted immune responses. Multiple methods have been developed to assess the immune cell response following exposure to biotherapeutics and estimate the potential immunogenicity of biotherapeutics. This review highlights the role of innate and adaptive immune cells as the drivers of immunogenicity and summarizes the use of these cells in assays to predict clinical ADA.
Bispecific antibodies (bsAbs) recognize and bind two different targets or two epitopes of the same antigen, making them an attractive diagnostic and treatment modality. Compared to the production of conventional bivalent monospecific antibodies, bsAbs require greater engineering and manufacturing. Therefore, bsAbs are more likely to differ from endogenous immunoglobulins and contain new epitopes that can increase immunogenic risk. Anti-A/B is a bsAb designed using a 'knobs-into-holes' (KIH) format. Anti-A/B exhibited an unexpectedly high immunogenicity in both preclinical and clinical studies, resulting in early termination of clinical development. Here, we used an integrated approach that combined in silico analysis, in vitro assays, and an in vivo study in non-human primates to characterize anti-A/B immunogenicity. Our findings indicated that the immunogenicity is associated with epitopes in the anti-B arm and not with mutations engineered through the KIH process. Our results showed the value of this integrated approach for performing immunogenicity risk assessment during clinical candidate selection to effectively mitigate risks during bsAb development.
Abstract RO7297089 is a bispecific antibody (IgG-scFv) targeting Bcell maturation antigen (BCMA) and CD16a (FcγRIIIA) that is being developed for the treatment of multiple myeloma (MM). BCMA is exclusively expressed on plasmablasts and differentiated plasma cells (PCs), and is overexpressed on malignant PCs in MM patients. CD16a is expressed on natural killer (NK) cells, monocytes, mast cells, and macrophages. Herein, we characterized the mode of action and safety profile of RO7297089 in vitro and in vivo. RO7297089 showed potent cell killing when using BCMA+ MM tumor cell lines as target cells and human peripheral blood mononuclear cells, NK cells or macrophages as effector cells. Minimal increases in TNFα (2x) and IFNγ (4x), but not other cytokines/chemokines, were observed compared to the vehicle control treatment only in the presence of the BCMA+ MM tumor cell line up to the concentration tested. This suggests that, unlike T-cell engagers, the risk of cytokine release syndrome in patients receiving RO7297089 is low. Cynomolgus monkey is the only relevant nonclinical species for RO7297089 as it showed binding to both recombinant CD16 and BCMA with comparable affinity to human antigens. Following five weekly intravenous administrations to monkeys at 0, 15, and 50 mg/kg, RO7297089 was well tolerated. In line with the mechanism of action, there were no test article-related cytokine increases or adverse findings observed in both dose levels. Systemic exposure of RO7297089 was approximately dose proportional from 15 to 50 mg/kg. Anti-drug antibodies (ADA) were observed in some animals at both dose levels, and ADA-related decreases in concentrations were observed at only 15 mg/kg. To evaluate in vivo activity, RO7297089-related effects on total plasma sBCMA and PCs were assessed. Elevations of sBCMA levels (100x) were observed post dose at both dose levels, and these effects returned to predose levels in animals that did not maintain concentrations at 15 mg/kg, suggesting that RO7297089 bound to and stabilized circulating cynomolgus sBCMA. Time- and dose-dependent reductions in serum IgM levels were observed at both dose levels. Changes in PC numbers were not detected by immunophenotyping; however, gene expression analysis of PC markers was included and demonstrated clear reductions in mRNA expression levels of PC markers including BCMA and J-chain in blood at both dose levels, suggesting reductions in BCMA+ cells. Collectively, these studies suggest that RO7297089 selectively kills BCMA+ cells by engaging CD16a-positive immune cells and has a favorable safety profile. Citation Format: Satoko Kakiuchi-Kiyota, Melissa M. Schutten, Adeyemi O. Adedeji, Hao Cai, Robert Hendricks, Luna Liu, Sivan Cohen, Aaron M. Fullerton, Nicholas Corr, Lanlan Yu, Denise de Almeida Nagata, Shelly Zhong, Michael Dillon, Christoph Spiess, Steve R. Leong, Bing Zheng, Susanne Wingert, Uwe Reusch, Stefan Knackmuss, Thorsten Ross, Andrew Polson, Ayse M. Ovacik. Preclinical pharmacology and safety of RO7297089, a novel anti-BCMA/CD16a bispecific antibody for the treatment of multiple myeloma [abstract]. In: Proceedings of the Annual Meeting of the American Association for Cancer Research 2020; 2020 Apr 27-28 and Jun 22-24. Philadelphia (PA): AACR; Cancer Res 2020;80(16 Suppl):Abstract nr 4556.
The control of lymphoid homeostasis is the result of a very fine balance between lymphocyte production, proliferation, and apoptosis. In this study, we focused on the role of T cells in the maintenance/survival of the mature naive peripheral B cell population. We show that naive B and T cells interact via the signaling lymphocyte activation molecule (SLAM) family receptor, SLAMF6. This interaction induces cell type-specific signals in both cell types, mediated by the SLAM-associated protein (SAP) family of adaptors. This signaling results in an upregulation of the expression of the cytokine migration inhibitory factor in the T cells and augmented expression of its receptor CD74 on the B cell counterparts, consequently enhancing B cell survival. Furthermore, in X-linked lymphoproliferative disease patients, SAP deficiency reduces CD74 expression, resulting in the perturbation of B cell maintenance from the naive stage. Thus, naive T cells regulate B cell survival in a SLAMF6- and SAP-dependent manner.
T cells are highly influenced by nutrient uptake from their environment, and changes in overall nutritional status, such as malnutrition or obesity, can result in altered T‐cell metabolism and behavior. In states of severe malnutrition or starvation, T‐cell survival, proliferation, and inflammatory cytokine production are all decreased, as is T‐cell glucose uptake and metabolism. The altered T‐cell function and metabolism seen in malnutrition is associated with altered adipokine levels, most particularly decreased leptin. Circulating leptin levels are low in malnutrition, and leptin has been shown to be a key link between nutrition and immunity. The current view is that leptin signaling is required to upregulate activated T‐cell glucose metabolism and thereby fuel T‐cell activation. In the setting of obesity, T cells have been found to have a key role in promoting the recruitment of inflammatory macrophages to adipose depots along with the production of inflammatory cytokines that promote the development of insulin resistance leading to diabetes. Deletion of T cells, key T‐cell transcription factors, or pro‐inflammatory T‐cell cytokines prevents insulin resistance in obesity and underscores the importance of T cells in obesity‐associated inflammation and metabolic disease. Altogether, T cells have a critical role in nutritional immunometabolism.
Chemokines and chemokine receptors establish a complex network modulating immune cell migration and localization. These molecules were also suggested to mediate the differentiation of leukocytes; however, their intrinsic, direct regulation of lymphocyte fate remained unclear. CCR2 is the main chemokine receptor inducing macrophage and monocyte recruitment to sites of inflammation, and it is also expressed on T cells. To assess whether CCR2 directly regulates T cell responses, we followed the fates of CCR2 (-/-) T cells in T cell-specific inflammatory models. Our in vitro and in vivo results show that CCR2 intrinsically mediates the expression of inflammatory T cell cytokines, and its absence on T cells results in attenuated colitis progression. Moreover, CCR2 deficiency in T cells promoted a program inducing the accumulation of Foxp3 + regulatory T cells, while decreasing the levels of Th17 cells in vivo, indicating that CCR2 regulates the immune response by modulating the effector/regulatory T ratio.
T cell acute lymphoblastic leukemia (T-ALL) is an aggressive malignancy associated with Notch pathway mutations. While both normal activated and leukemic T cells can utilize aerobic glycolysis to support proliferation, it is unclear to what extent these cell populations are metabolically similar and if differences reveal T-ALL vulnerabilities. Here we show that aerobic glycolysis is surprisingly less active in T-ALL cells than proliferating normal T cells and that T-ALL cells are metabolically distinct. Oncogenic Notch promoted glycolysis but also induced metabolic stress that activated 5' AMP-activated kinase (AMPK). Unlike stimulated T cells, AMPK actively restrained aerobic glycolysis in T-ALL cells through inhibition of mTORC1 while promoting oxidative metabolism and mitochondrial Complex I activity. Importantly, AMPK deficiency or inhibition of Complex I led to T-ALL cell death and reduced disease burden. Thus, AMPK simultaneously inhibits anabolic growth signaling and is essential to promote mitochondrial pathways that mitigate metabolic stress and apoptosis in T-ALL.
Chronic lymphocytic leukemia (CLL) is a malignant disease of small mature lymphocytes. Signals from the CLL microenvironment promote progression of the disease and induce drug resistance. This phenomenon is largely dependent on direct contact between the malignant B cells and stromal cells. CD84 belongs to the signaling lymphocyte activation molecule family of immunoreceptors, which self-associates, forming an orthogonal homophilic dimer. We therefore hypothesized that CD84 may bridge between CLL cells and their microenvironment, promoting cell survival. Our in vitro results show that CD84 expressed on CLL cells interact with CD84 expressed on cells in their microenvironment, inducing cell survival in both sides. Blocking CD84 in vitro and in vivo disrupt the interaction of CLL cells with their microenvironment, resulting in induced cell death. Thus, our findings suggest novel therapeutic strategies based on the blockade of this CD84-dependent survival pathway.