Comparative study of the structural asymmetry of the human and chimpanzee brain may shed light on the evolution of language and other cognitive abilities in humans. Here we report the results of vertex-wise and ROI-based analyses that compared surface area (SA) and cortical thickness (CT) asymmetries in 3D MR images obtained for 91 humans and 77 chimpanzees. The human brain is substantially more asymmetric than the chimpanzee brain. In particular, the human brain has 1) larger total SA in the right compared with the left cerebral hemisphere, 2) a global torque-like asymmetry pattern of widespread thicker cortex in the left compared with the right frontal and the right compared with the left temporo-parieto-occipital lobe, and 3) local asymmetries, most notably in medial occipital cortex and superior temporal gyrus, where rightward asymmetry is observed for both SA and CT. There is also 4) a prominent asymmetry specific to the chimpanzee brain, namely, rightward CT asymmetry of precentral cortex. These findings provide evidence of there being substantial differences in asymmetry between the human and chimpanzee brain. The unique asymmetries of the human brain are potential neural substrates for cognitive specializations, and the presence of significant CT asymmetry of precentral gyrus in the chimpanzee brain should be further investigated.
Studies applying Free Water Imaging have consistently reported significant global increases in extracellular free water (FW) in populations of individuals with early psychosis. However, these published studies focused on homogenous clinical participant groups (e.g., only first episode or chronic), thereby limiting our understanding of the time course of free water elevations across illness stages. Moreover, the relationship between FW and duration of illness has yet to be directly tested. Leveraging our multi-site diffusion magnetic resonance imaging(dMRI) harmonization approach, we analyzed dMRI scans collected by 12 international sites from 441 healthy controls and 434 individuals diagnosed with schizophrenia-spectrum disorders at different illness stages and ages (15–58 years). We characterized the pattern of age-related FW changes by assessing whole brain white matter in individuals with schizophrenia and healthy controls. In individuals with schizophrenia, average whole brain FW was higher than in controls across all ages, with the greatest FW values observed from 15 to 23 years (effect size range = [0.70–0.87]). Following this peak, FW exhibited a monotonic decrease until reaching a minima at the age of 39 years. After 39 years, an attenuated monotonic increase in FW was observed, but with markedly smaller effect sizes when compared to younger patients (effect size range = [0.32–0.43]). Importantly, FW was found to be negatively associated with duration of illness in schizophrenia ( p = 0.006), independent of the effects of other clinical and demographic data. In summary, our study finds in a large, age-diverse sample that participants with schizophrenia with a shorter duration of illness showed higher FW values compared to participants with more prolonged illness. Our findings provide further evidence that elevations in the FW are present in individuals with schizophrenia, with the greatest differences in the FW being observed in those at the early stages of the disorder, which might suggest acute extracellular processes.
Background While adolescent-onset schizophrenia (ADO-SCZ) and adolescent-onset bipolar disorder with psychosis (psychotic ADO-BPD) present a more severe clinical course than their adult forms, their pathophysiology is poorly understood. Here, we study potentially state- and trait-related white matter diffusion-weighted magnetic resonance imaging (dMRI) abnormalities along the adolescent-onset psychosis continuum to address this need. Methods Forty-eight individuals with ADO-SCZ (20 female/28 male), 15 individuals with psychotic ADO-BPD (7 female/8 male), and 35 healthy controls (HCs, 18 female/17 male) underwent dMRI and clinical assessments. Maps of extracellular free-water (FW) and fractional anisotropy of cellular tissue (FA(T)) were compared between individuals with psychosis and HCs using tract-based spatial statistics and FSL's Randomise. FA(T) and FW values were extracted, averaged across all voxels that demonstrated group differences, and then utilized to test for the influence of age, medication, age of onset, duration of illness, symptom severity, and intelligence. Results Individuals with adolescent-onset psychosis exhibited pronounced FW and FA(T) abnormalities compared to HCs. FA(T) reductions were spatially more widespread in ADO-SCZ. FW increases, however, were only present in psychotic ADO-BPD. In HCs, but not in individuals with adolescent-onset psychosis, FA(T) was positively related to age. Conclusions We observe evidence for cellular (FA(T)) and extracellular (FW) white matter abnormalities in adolescent-onset psychosis. Although cellular white matter abnormalities were more prominent in ADO-SCZ, such alterations may reflect a shared trait, i.e. neurodevelopmental pathology, present across the psychosis spectrum. Extracellular abnormalities were evident in psychotic ADO-BPD, potentially indicating a more dynamic, state-dependent brain reaction to psychosis.
Cognitive deficits are among the best predictors of real-world functioning in schizophrenia. However, our understanding of how cognitive deficits relate to neuropathology and clinical presentation over the disease lifespan is limited. Here, we combine multi-site, harmonized cognitive, imaging, demographic, and clinical data from over 900 individuals to characterize a) cognitive deficits across the schizophrenia lifespan and b) the association between cognitive deficits, clinical presentation, and white matter (WM) microstructure. Multimodal harmonization was accomplished using T-scores for cognitive data, previously reported standardization methods for demographic and clinical data, and an established harmonization method for imaging data. We applied t-tests and correlation analysis to describe cognitive deficits in individuals with schizophrenia. We then calculated whole-brain WM fractional anisotropy (FA) and utilized regression-mediation analyses to model the association between diagnosis, FA, and cognitive deficits. We observed pronounced cognitive deficits in individuals with schizophrenia (p < 0.006), associated with more positive symptoms and medication dosage. Regression-mediation analyses showed that WM microstructure mediated the association between schizophrenia and language/processing speed/working memory/non-verbal memory. In addition, processing speed mediated the influence of diagnosis and WM microstructure on the other cognitive domains. Our study highlights the critical role of cognitive deficits in schizophrenia. We further show that WM is crucial when trying to understand the role of cognitive deficits, given that it explains the association between schizophrenia and cognitive deficits (directly and via processing speed).
Schizophrenia is associated with widespread alterations in subcortical brain structure. While analytic methods have enabled more detailed morphometric characterization, findings are often equivocal. In this meta‐analysis, we employed the harmonized ENIGMA shape analysis protocols to collaboratively investigate subcortical brain structure shape differences between individuals with schizophrenia and healthy control participants. The study analyzed data from 2,833 individuals with schizophrenia and 3,929 healthy control participants contributed by 21 worldwide research groups participating in the ENIGMA Schizophrenia Working Group. Harmonized shape analysis protocols were applied to each site's data independently for bilateral hippocampus, amygdala, caudate, accumbens, putamen, pallidum, and thalamus obtained from T1‐weighted structural MRI scans. Mass univariate meta‐analyses revealed more‐concave‐than‐convex shape differences in the hippocampus, amygdala, accumbens, and thalamus in individuals with schizophrenia compared with control participants, more‐convex‐than‐concave shape differences in the putamen and pallidum, and both concave and convex shape differences in the caudate. Patterns of exaggerated asymmetry were observed across the hippocampus, amygdala, and thalamus in individuals with schizophrenia compared to control participants, while diminished asymmetry encompassed ventral striatum and ventral and dorsal thalamus. Our analyses also revealed that higher chlorpromazine dose equivalents and increased positive symptom levels were associated with patterns of contiguous convex shape differences across multiple subcortical structures. Findings from our shape meta‐analysis suggest that common neurobiological mechanisms may contribute to gray matter reduction across multiple subcortical regions, thus enhancing our understanding of the nature of network disorganization in schizophrenia.
Diffusion MRI studies consistently report group differences in white matter between individuals diagnosed with schizophrenia and healthy controls. Nevertheless, the abnormalities found at the group-level are often not observed at the individual level. Among the different approaches aiming to study white matter abnormalities at the subject level, normative modeling analysis takes a step towards subject-level predictions by identifying affected brain locations in individual subjects based on extreme deviations from a normative range. Here, we leveraged a large harmonized diffusion MRI dataset from 512 healthy controls and 601 individuals diagnosed with schizophrenia, to study whether normative modeling can improve subject-level predictions from a binary classifier. To this aim, individual deviations from a normative model of standard (fractional anisotropy) and advanced (free-water) dMRI measures, were calculated by means of age and sex-adjusted z-scores relative to control data, in 18 white matter regions. Even though larger effect sizes are found when testing for group differences in z-scores than are found with raw values (p < .001), predictions based on summary z-score measures achieved low predictive power (AUC < 0.63). Instead, we find that combining information from the different white matter tracts, while using multiple imaging measures simultaneously, improves prediction performance (the best predictor achieved AUC = 0.726). Our findings suggest that extreme deviations from a normative model are not optimal features for prediction. However, including the complete distribution of deviations across multiple imaging measures improves prediction, and could aid in subject-level classification.
Studies applying advanced diffusion magnetic resonance imaging (dMRI) methodologies, specifically Free Water Imaging, have found significant increases in extracellular free-water in populations of patients with early psychosis. However, prior work focused on the discrete stages of the illness with relatively small samples. In this study, we present the largest application of Free Water Imaging to patients with schizophrenia across the course of illness.
Axonal myelination and repair, critical processes for brain development, maturation, and aging, remain controlled by sexual hormones. Whether this influence is reflected in structural brain differences between sexes, and whether it can be quantified by neuroimaging, remains controversial. Diffusion-weighted magnetic resonance imaging (dMRI) is an in vivo method that can track myelination changes throughout the lifespan. We utilize a large, multisite sample of harmonized dMRI data (n = 551, age = 9-65 years, 46% females/54% males) to investigate the influence of sex on white matter (WM) structure. We model lifespan trajectories of WM using the most common dMRI measure fractional anisotropy (FA). Next, we examine the influence of both age and sex on FA variability. We estimate the overlap between male and female FA and test whether it is possible to label individual brains as male or female. Our results demonstrate regionally and spatially specific effects of sex. Sex differences are limited to limbic structures and young ages. Additionally, not only do sex differences diminish with age, but tracts within each subject become more similar to one another. Last, we show the high overlap in FA between sexes, which implies that determining sex based on WM remains open.
Several previous smaller studies have shown that individuals with schizophrenia demonstrate widespread cognitive deficits and that cognitive deficits are among the best predictors of real-world functioning. Here, we combine cognitive, imaging, and clinical data (n = 900) to investigate cognition across the schizophrenia trajectory and to test the associations with clinical variables and white matter.
White matter (WM) abnormalities are repeatedly demonstrated across the schizophrenia time-course. However, our understanding of how demographic and clinical variables interact, influence, or are dependent on WM pathologies is limited. The most well-known barriers to progress are heterogeneous findings due to small sample sizes and the confounding influence of age on WM. The present study leverages access to the harmonized diffusion magnetic-resonance-imaging data and standardized clinical data from 13 international sites (597 schizophrenia patients (SCZ)). Fractional anisotropy (FA) values for all major WM structures in patients were predicted based on FA models estimated from a healthy population (n = 492). We utilized the deviations between predicted and real FA values to answer three essential questions. (1) "Which clinical variables explain WM abnormalities?". (2) "Does the degree of WM abnormalities predict symptom severity?". (3) "Does sex influence any of those relationships?". Regression and mediator analyses revealed that a longer duration-of-illness is associated with more severe WM abnormalities in several tracts. In addition, they demonstrated that a higher antipsychotic medication dose is related to more severe corpus callosum abnormalities. A structural equation model revealed that patients with more WM abnormalities display higher symptom severity. Last, the results exhibited sex-specificity. Males showed a stronger association between duration-of-illness and WM abnormalities. Females presented a stronger association between WM abnormalities and symptom severity, with IQ impacting this relationship. Our findings provide clear evidence for the interaction of demographic, clinical, and behavioral variables with WM pathology in SCZ. Our results also point to the need for longitudinal studies, directly investigating the casualty and sex-specificity of these relationships, as well as the impact of cognitive resiliency on structure-function relationships.
Abstract Background The association of white matter (WM) abnormalities with clinical variables in schizophrenia (SCZ) is poorly understood. We investigated the clinical correlates of WM impairments using imaging data of 597 patients with SCZ and 490 healthy controls (HC). We focused on lifelong changes of WM (measured by Fractional Anisotropy [FA]) in SCZ and compared it to that of HC. We investigated how age, duration of illness, and medication influence WM trajectories, and examined how structural impairments are related to symptoms and cognition. Last, we tested for the role of sex in structure-function interactions. Methods Diffusion-weighted images and clinical measurements were collected as part of 13 independent studies, and data was harmonized across all sites. We registered images to the IIT Human Brain Atlas and averaged FA for forceps major, forceps minor, cingulum, inferior fronto-occipital fasciculus, inferior longitudinal fasciculus, superior longitudinal fasciculus (SLF) and uncinate fasciculus. First, we modeled the FA age trajectory of each tract in HC and used it to regress out the effect of age in patients. The residuals in the FA values were utilized for further analyses. We conducted mediator regression analyses with FA as the dependent variable, sex as a covariate, and age and duration of illness as the independent variables. Next, patients were grouped based on Chlorpromazine equivalent dosage (CPZ) and CPZ group was added to the regression model. To examine the association between structure and function, a structural equation model (SEM) was used, with cognition as a mediator. Last, all analyses were repeated for males and females separately. Results Regression analyses revealed a significant influence of duration of illness on the forceps major (T=3.24, p<.001), forceps minor (T=3.40, p<.001), and SLF (T=3.83, p<.0001). When adding both age and duration of illness, duration of illness mediated the influence of age on FA. Adding CPZ to the model displayed a significant effect of medication on forceps major (T=3.93, p<.0001). For SEM, FA of all tracts was used to represent structural impairment, and symptom scores were used to reflect functional impairment. All data paths were calculated with an asymptotically distribution-free model. The overall model fit was acceptable (RMSEA =.09) with a medium-strong effect of structural impairment on functional impairment (standardized estimate=.44). When separating sexes, males showed a significant association of duration of illness and FA. Females displayed a stronger influence of structural impairment on functional impairment (standardized estimate: males = .29, females =.52), and cognition had an impact on this relationship for females only. Discussion The effect of duration of illness on specific WM tracts suggests a progressive, neurodegenerative pathology, which might contribute to the devastating effects of chronicity. Medication seems to have only a small, localized effect on corpus callosum WM integrity. However, since our analysis used cross-sectional CPZ measures, future studies should include measurements of lifetime dosage. The observed impact of WM abnormalities on function further highlights the importance of WM for SCZ pathology. The association of structure and function seems sex-specific. Men show a stronger effect of chronicity. For females, cognition mediates the effect of structure on function, suggesting the role of cognitive reserve. Our approach provides the first step towards evidence-based medicine, by demonstrating the apparent relationship between structural pathology and functional outcome and suggesting possible mediators of this relationship, including duration of illness, cognition, medication, and sex.
The findings from diffusion-weighted magnetic resonance imaging (dMRI) studies often show inconsistent and sometimes contradictory results due to small sample sizes as well as differences in acquisition parameters and pre-/post-processing methods. To address these challenges, collaborative multi-site initiatives have provided an opportunity to collect larger and more diverse groups of subjects, including those with neuropsychiatric disorders, leading to increased power and findings that may be more representative at the group and individual level. With the availability of these datasets openly, the ability of joint analysis of multi-site dMRI data has become more important than ever. However, intrinsic- or acquisition-related variability in scanner models, acquisition protocols, and reconstruction settings hinder pooling multi-site dMRI directly. One powerful and fast statistical harmonization method called ComBat ( https://github.com/Jfortin1/ComBatHarmonization ) was developed to mitigate the “batch effect” in gene expression microarray data and was adapted for multi-site dMRI harmonization to reduce scanner/site effect. Our goal is to evaluate this commonly used harmonization approach using a large diffusion MRI dataset involving 542 individuals from 5 sites. We investigated two important aspects of using ComBat for harmonization of fractional anisotropy (FA) across sites: First, we assessed how well ComBat preserves the inter-subject biological variability (measured by the effect sizes of between-group FA differences) after harmonization. Second, we evaluated the effect of minor differences in pre-processing on ComBat’s performance. While the majority of effect sizes are mostly preserved in some sites after harmonization, they are not well-preserved at other sites where non-linear scanner contributions exist. Further, even minor differences in pre-processing can yield unwanted effects during ComBat harmonization. Thus, our findings suggest paying careful attention to the data being harmonized as well as using the same processing pipeline while using ComBat for data harmonization.
Background: The health of people with schizophrenia is poor, leading to shortened lifespans. Sedentary behavior has recently been identified as an independent health risk in the general population. Because people with schizophrenia lead even more sedentary lives, their health is at even greater risk, likely compounding their already unhealthy lifestyle. The prevalence and pattern of sedentary behavior in schizophrenia, however, has not been determined. This study used ecological momentary assessment (EMA) data for an innovative purpose, to estimate activity levels in people with schizophrenia. Methods: Behavior and activity of 100 patients with schizophrenia were compared to healthy controls (n=71) using ecological momentary assessment (EMA). EMA provides real-time, real-world monitoring of behavior through the use of electronic devices that prompt participants to provide information. For this study, behavior was sampled seven times daily for 7 days, with the frequent sampling allowing for quantification of productive vs. unproductive and active vs. inactive behaviors; and three different movement/postural patterns (standing/moving, recumbent, sitting). Results: Patients were at home and inactive most of the day most days. For 64% of the surveys, the patients reported being home for the entire last hour, with this rate higher for patients in assisted living. Healthy controls were much less likely to be at home (28%). When patients were at home, the most prominent activities during waking hours were combinations of watching TV resting and sitting (60% of samples). At home recreational activities, which are performed while seated, accounted for 15% of the samples. Activities at home that involved standing (20%) or moving (10%) were much less commonly performed. Out of home activities that involved, treatment, leisure, or vocational activities were reported in 20% of the out of home surveys. These activities themselves were generally not physically active. In contrast, the healthy controls were engaged in activities that involved standing or moving 60% of the time. Discussion: Patients are inactive 60% of their time during the day while at home and are not particularly active when away from home. None of the predominant activities appeared to confer health benefits alone or in combination. This pattern poses a significant health risk and allows for targeted interventions. Even in a unique sample of healthy controls for are available to participate in an EMA study, levels of physical activity were considerably greater.
Several prominent theories of schizophrenia suggest that structural white matter pathologies may follow a developmental, maturational, and/or degenerative process. However, a lack of lifespan studies has precluded verification of these theories. Here, we analyze the largest sample of carefully harmonized diffusion MRI data to comprehensively characterize age-related white matter trajectories, as measured by fractional anisotropy (FA), across the course of schizophrenia. Our analysis comprises diffusion scans of 600 schizophrenia patients and 492 healthy controls at different illness stages and ages (14–65 years), which were gathered from 13 sites. We determined the pattern of age-related FA changes by cross-sectionally assessing the timing of the structural neuropathology associated with schizophrenia. Quadratic curves were used to model between-group FA differences across whole-brain white matter and fiber tracts at each age; fiber tracts were then clustered according to both the effect-sizes and pattern of lifespan white matter FA differences. In whole-brain white matter, FA was significantly lower across the lifespan (up to 7%; p < 0.0033) and reached peak maturation younger in patients (27 years) compared to controls (33 years). Additionally, three distinct patterns of neuropathology emerged when investigating white matter fiber tracts in patients: (1) developmental abnormalities in limbic fibers, (2) accelerated aging and abnormal maturation in long-range association fibers, (3) severe developmental abnormalities and accelerated aging in callosal fibers. Our findings strongly suggest that white matter in schizophrenia is affected across entire stages of the disease. Perhaps most strikingly, we show that white matter changes in schizophrenia involve dynamic interactions between neuropathological processes in a tract-specific manner.
The term "cerebral torque" refers to opposing right-left asymmetries of frontal and parieto-occipital regions. These are assumed to derive from a lateralized gradient of embryological development of the human brain. To establish the timing of its evolution, we computed and compared the torque, in terms of three principal features, namely petalia, shift, and bending of the inter-hemispheric fissure as well as the inter-hemispheric asymmetry of brain length, height and width for in vivo Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) scans of 91 human and 78 chimpanzee brains. We found that the cerebral torque is specific to the human brain and that its magnitude is independent of brain size and that it comprises features that are inter-related. These findings are consistent with the concept that a "punctuational" genetic change of relatively large effect introduced lateralization in the hominid lineage. The existence of the cerebral torque remains an unsolved mystery and the present study provides further support for this most prominent structural brain asymmetry being specific to the human brain. Establishing the genetic origins of the torque may, therefore, have relevance for a better understanding on human evolution, the organisation of the human brain, and, perhaps, also aspects of the neural basis of language.
One prominent feature of human brain asymmetry is the cerebral torque. To investigate whether this characteristic is shared with chimpanzees who are our closest extant relative, we developed an automatic method to compute cerebral hemisphere width and perimeter length on consecutive 2D sections through 3D MR images obtained in vivo for 91 human and 78 chimpanzee brains. In brief, contiguous inter-hemispheric width and perimeter asymmetries were calculated on coronal sections, which in profile allow us to examine asymmetry in relation to speciation. The right frontal and left occipital asymmetry (greater posteriorly in females) distinguishes humans from chimpanzees. This result is consistent with a major saltational (discontinuity) event occurring at some point after the separation of humanity and the great apes in the last 6 million years.
Schizophrenia is genetic in origin and associated with a fecundity disadvantage. The deficits in schizophrenia have been attributed to variation related to the human capacity for language or brain laterality. How sex influences the relative connectivity of the 2 hemispheres is a route to understanding these 2 functions. Using resting-state functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) we searched for sex- and hemisphere-specific changes in whole-brain functional-connectivity in multi-site datasets (altogether 672 subjects including 286 patients, all right-handed) in the first-episode schizophrenia (illness duration ≤ 1 year, mostly drug naive) and in chronic stages of schizophrenia (illness duration > 1 year), respectively. We used meta-analyses to integrate data from different sources concerning individuals at the same illness stage. We found first-episode male patients are predominantly left-lateralized in aberrant connectivity with a focus on Broca's area. Female patients show a lesser degree of lateralization than males, but to the right particularly in orbital frontal cortex. In the chronic stage, the focus of aberrant connectivity shifted from anterior to posterior structures with prominent involvement of the thalamus and pre- and post-central gyri bilaterally and in both sexes. While the "deviant connectivity" is right-sided in both the first-episode and the chronic stages in females, in males there is a shift between stages from the left to the right hemisphere. We hypothesized that the pathophysiology of schizophrenia may lie in the interaction between sex and lateralization, ie, in genetic mechanisms located on the X and Y chromosomes, intrinsic to the evolution of language.
Evidence for age related brain white matter (WM) abnormalities in schizophrenia (SZ) has been observed using MRI, and interpreted by various studies as reflecting either developmental, maturational and/or degenerative pathology. Such conflicting findings, mostly due to lack of longitudinal data and statistical power, have hindered consensus on patterns and trajectories of brain dysfunction in SZ. ‘Big Data’ provides a new and powerful means to identify subtle abnormalities across the course of SZ. We have accumulated and processed, what we believe the biggest, to-date, sample of thoughtfully harmonized diffusion MRI (dMRI) cross sectional data, and performed the study aimed at comprehensively characterizing age-related WM changes (trajectories) through the course of SZ. Our dMRI data comprises a total of 1092 participants, aged between 14 and 65. This includes 600 individuals with SZ at different illness stages (383 males, 217 females, age: 31.3+/- 12) and 492 healthy controls-HC (275 males, 217 females, age: 29.8+/-13), from 13 different sites. Preprocessing and dMRI data harmonization based on the rotation invariant spherical harmonics were used to remove the nonlinear scanner and sequence differences across sites. All harmonized data was registered to a common template. Fractional Anisotropy (FA) for Whole Brain (WB) and 14 individual WM regions of interest (ROIs) were computed using a probabilistic tractography atlas. We modeled FA changes over age by quadratic curves (the best fitted model: highest adjusted r^2) and fitted separately to SZ and HC. Peak age and upper and lower bounds of the model were estimated after 5000 bootstraps. FA% differences were modeled at each age between SZ and HC for WB and each ROI, while sex was treated as a confound. The effect sizes (Cohen’s d) between SZ and HC were also computed at each age. Finally, WM pathologies (i.e. based on between-group differences) were clustered into three groups according to d occurring along trajectory using kmeans. In WB, FA was lower in SZ comparing to HC at each age, but the percentage differences as well as d varied significantly by age (range of %FA change = [1.5 7], d = [.5 1.8]). Also, WB peaks of FA differed between groups, observed at the age of 33 in HC, shifted to the age of 27 in SZ. Three groups emerged from examining the degree of WM pathology across the age trajectories in ROIs, characterized by: 1) .3