The classical probabilistic models attempt to capture the ad hoc information retrieval problem within a rigorous probabilistic framework. It has long been recognized that the primary obstacle to the effective performance of the probabilistic models is the need to estimate a relevance model. The Dirichlet compound multinomial (DCM) distribution based on the Polya Urn scheme, which can also be considered as a hierarchical Bayesian model, is a more appropriate generative model than the traditional multinomial distribution for text documents. We explore a new probabilistic model based on the DCM distribution, which enables efficient retrieval and accurate ranking. Because the DCM distribution captures the dependency of repetitive word occurrences, the new probabilistic model based on this distribution is able to model the concavity of the score function more effectively. To avoid the empirical tuning of retrieval parameters, we design several parameter estimation algorithms to automatically set model parameters. Additionally, we propose a pseudo-relevance feedback algorithm based on the mixture modeling of the Dirichlet compound multinomial distribution to further improve retrieval accuracy. Finally, our experiments show that both the baseline probabilistic retrieval algorithm based on the DCM distribution and the corresponding pseudo-relevance feedback algorithm outperform the existing language modeling systems on several TREC retrieval tasks. The main objective of this research is to develop an effective probabilistic model based on the DCM distribution. A secondary objective is to provide a thorough understanding of the probabilistic retrieval model by a theoretical understanding of various text distribution assumptions.
Active learning algorithms actively select training examples to acquire labels from domain experts, which are very effective to reduce human labeling effort in the context of supervised learning. To reduce computational time in training, as well as provide more convenient user interaction environment, it is necessary to select batches of new training examples instead of a single example. Batch mode active learning algorithms incorporate a diversity measure to construct a batch of diversified candidate examples. Existing approaches use greedy algorithms to make it feasible to the scale of thousands of data. Greedy algorithms, however, are not efficient enough to scale to even larger real world classification applications, which contain millions of data. In this paper, we present an extremely efficient active learning algorithm. This new active learning algorithm achieves the same results as the traditional greedy algorithm, while the run time is reduced by a factor of several hundred times. We prove that the objective function of the algorithm is submodular, which guarantees to find the same solution as the greedy algorithm. We evaluate our approach on several largescale real-world text classification problems, and show that our new approach achieves substantial speedups, while obtaining the same classification accuracy.
We provide an automation perspective on modeling knowledge services. We consider a service center as the atomic unit for building networks of enterprises, suppliers, and customers. We provide an approach to integrate knowledge and resource management in service centers. We describe specific models and solutions for optimized information and knowledge retrieval, relevance feedback and active learning and associated performance results. We also outline an approach for incorporating topic detection, context, social networks and collaboration, and combined document and expert ranking/identification. We also sketch an approach for combining knowledge retrieval with system resource optimization of the service engineers and experts to provide optimized responsiveness.
An active relevance feedback system actively selects retrieved documents for user relevance evaluation, and modifies the search results based on the user evaluation. The most challenging problems in active relevance feedback include the following: the active selection of the most informative feedback document set, and the effective incorporation of user evaluation in the new search.In order to overcome the above challenges, we need to do the following: use a robust learning algorithm that can work reasonably well and avoid overfitting when the number of feedback documents is small; design a learning algorithm that can effectively learn from negative feedback documents when initial retrieved documents contain significant non-relevant documents; explore the retrieved documents to select the most informative feedback documents set. This dissertation uses the Bayesian modeling approach as a unified framework for active relevance feedback. We develop a set of solutions that enable us to build an active relevance feedback system with the desired characteristics in a principled way. We evaluate and justify these solutions on several large and diverse sets of standard ad hoc information retrieval test collections.In the dissertation, we first design an effective active learning algorithm that explicitly considers the relevance, diversity and density of a candidate feedback document belonging to a document set under consideration. We also give an intuitive explanation on how these key factors influence the active learning performance.Second, we designed an active relevance feedback algorithm based on the online Bayesian logistic regression model to reduce overfitting caused by limited feedback documents. The new model projects the original feature space to a more compact set which preserves the most important information concerning relevance. The new model also actively selects feedback documents based on a variance reduction scheme.Third, we solve the long-standing model estimation problem in probabilistic ranking models. We apply the Dirichlet compound multinomial (DCM) distribution as the generative sources, since the DCM distribution is able to account for the dependency between word repetitive occurrences. We also design several parameter estimation techniques to estimate the parameters of the DCM distribution. Additionally, we propose a pseudo-relevance feedback algorithm based on the latent mixture modeling of the DCM distribution to further improve retrieval accuracy.Fourth, we solve a difficult IR research problem: how do we learn from negative feedback documents effectively for difficult queries? We propose a new relevance feedback algorithm, based on a mixture model of the DCM distribution, to effectively utilize the information from both the positive and negative feedback documents by modeling the overlap between the positive and negative feedback documents. Consequently, the new algorithm improves the retrieval performance substantially for difficult queries. To further reduce human effort in relevance evaluation, we propose a new active learning algorithm in conjunction with the new relevance feedback model we have already developed, and thus enhance efficiency. The new active learning algorithm implicitly models the diversity, density and relevance of the unlabeled data in a transductive experimental design framework.
Relevance feedback has been demonstrated to be an effective strategy for improving retrieval accuracy. The existing relevance feedback algorithms based on language models and vector space models are not effective in learning from negative feedback documents, which are abundant if the initial query is difficult. The probabilistic retrieval model has the advantage of being able to naturally improve the estimation of both the relevant and non-relevant models. The Dirichlet compound multinomial (DCM) distribution, which relies on hierarchical Bayesian modeling techniques, is a more appropriate generative model for the probabilistic retrieval model than the traditional multinomial distribution. We propose a new relevance feedback algorithm, based on a mixture model of the DCM distribution, to effectively model the overlaps between the positive and negative feedback documents. Consequently, the new algorithm improves the retrieval performance substantially for difficult queries. To further reduce human relevance evaluation, we propose a new active learning algorithm in conjunction with the new relevance feedback model. The new active learning algorithm implicitly models the diversity, density and relevance of unlabeled data in a transductive experimental design framework. Experimental results on several TREC datasets show that both the relevance feedback and active learning algorithm significantly improve retrieval accuracy.
Relevance feedback, which traditionally uses the terms in the relevant documents to enrich the user's initial query, is an effective method for improving retrieval performance. The traditional relevance feedback algorithms lead to overfitting because of the limited amount of training data and large term space. This paper introduces an online Bayesian logistic regression algorithm to incorporate relevance feedback information. The new approach addresses the overfitting problem by projecting the original feature space onto a more compact set which retains the necessary information. The new set of features consist of the original retrieval score, the distance to the relevant documents and the distance to non-relevant documents. To reduce the human evaluation effort in ascertaining relevance, we introduce a new active learning algorithm based on variance reduction to actively select documents for user evaluation. The new active learning algorithm aims to select feedback documents to reduce the model variance. The variance reduction approach leads to capturing relevance, diversity and uncertainty of the unlabeled documents in a principled manner. These are the critical factors of active learning indicated in previous literature. Experiments with several TREC datasets demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed approach.
The classical probabilistic models attempt to capture the Ad hoc information retrieval problem within a rigorous probabilistic framework. It has long been recognized that the primary obstacle to effective performance of the probabilistic models is the need to estimate a relevance model. The Dirichlet compound multinomial (DCM) distribution, which relies on hierarchical Bayesian modeling techniques, or the Polya Urn scheme, is a more appropriate generative model than the traditional multinomial distribution for text documents. We explore a new probabilistic model based on the DCM distribution, which enables efficient retrieval and accurate ranking. Because the DCM distribution captures the dependency of repetitive word occurrences, the new probabilistic model is able to model the concavity of the score function more effectively. To avoid the empirical tuning of retrieval parameters, we design several parameter estimation algorithms to automatically set model parameters. Additionally, we propose a pseudo-relevance feedback algorithm based on the latent mixture modeling of the Dirichlet compound multinomial distribution to further improve retrieval accuracy. Finally, our experiments show that both the baseline probabilistic retrieval algorithm based on the DCM distribution and the corresponding pseudo-relevance feedback algorithm outperform the existing language modeling systems on several TREC retrieval tasks.
Relevance feedback, which uses the terms in relevant documents to enrich the user’s initial query, is an effective method for improving retrieval performance. An associated key research problem is the following: Which documents to present to the user so that the user’s feedback on the documents can significantly impact relevance feedback performance. This paper views this as an active learning problem and proposes a new algorithm which can efficiently maximize the learning benefits of relevance feedback. This algorithm chooses a set of feedback documents based on relevancy, document diversity and document density. Experimental results show a statistically significant and appreciable improvement in the performance of our new approach over the existing active feedback methods.
This paper describes the results of a significant research and development effort conducted at NASA Ames Research Center to develop new text mining algorithms to discover anomalies in free-text reports regarding system health and safety of two aerospace systems. We discuss two problems of significant import in the aviation industry. The first problem is that of automatic anomaly discovery concerning an aerospace system through the analysis of tens of thousands of free-text problem reports that are written about the system. The second problem that we address is that of automatic discovery of recurring anomalies, i.e., anomalies that may be described in different ways by different authors, at varying times and under varying conditions, but that are truly about the same part of the system. The intent of recurring anomaly identification is to determine project or system weakness or high-risk issues. The discovery of recurring anomalies is a key goal in building safe, reliable, and cost-effective aerospace systems. We address the anomaly discovery problem on thousands of free-text reports using two strategies: (1) as an unsupervised learning problem where an algorithm takes free-text reports as input and automatically groups them into different bins, where each bin corresponds to a different unknown anomaly category; and (2) as a supervised learning problem where the algorithm classifies the free-text reports into one of a number of known anomaly categories. We then discuss the application of these methods to the problem of discovering recurring anomalies. In fact, because recurring anomalies tend to have very small cluster sizes, we explore new methods and measures to enhance the original approach for anomaly detection. We present our results on the identification of recurring anomalies in problem reports concerning two aerospace systems as well as benchmark data sets that are widely used in the field of text mining. The first system is the Aviation Safety Reporting System (ASRS) database, which contains several hundred-thousand free text reports filed by commercial pilots concerning safety issues on commercial airlines. The second aerospace system we analyze is the NASA Space Shuttle problem reports as represented in the CARS data set, which consists of 7440 NASA Shuttle problem reports. We show significant classification accuracies on both of these systems as well as compare our results with reports classified into anomaly categories by field experts
This viewgraph document describes the data mining system developed at NASA Ames. Many NASA programs have large numbers (and types) of problem reports.These free text reports are written by a number of different people, thus the emphasis and wording vary considerably With so much data to sift through, analysts (subject experts) need help identifying any possible safety issues or concerns and help them confirm that they haven't missed important problems. Unsupervised clustering is the initial step to accomplish this; We think we can go much farther, specifically, identify possible recurring anomalies. Recurring anomalies may be indicators of larger systemic problems. The requirement to identify these anomalies has led to the development of Recurring Anomaly Discovery System (ReADS).