The Kentucky Department of Fish and Wildlife Resources, an agency of the Kentucky Tourism, Arts and Heritage Cabinet, is responsible for the conservation of wildlife resources and for boating projects in the state. A commissioner appointed by the Fish and Wildlife Commission heads the department. The commission, which is responsible for department policy, is a nine-member bipartisan body appointed by the governor from a list of candidates voted upon by sportsmen's organizations in each of nine districts. Financial support of the Department is derived through the sale of hunting and fishing licenses, federal grants and numerous other receipts. The department has a $50 million budget and employs 600 people. It does not receive money from the state General Fund.
Objective Reproduction and recruitment represent distinct demographic processes that may independently limit establishment and spread of an invasive species. We evaluated reproduction and recruitment success of Bighead Carp Hypophthalmichthys nobilis and Silver Carp H. molitrix in the Ohio River basin across multiple spatial and temporal scales to identify potential demographic bottlenecks.Methods We assessed detection/nondetection data on Bighead Carp and Silver Carp eggs/larvae and young of the year (age 0) to provide information on these species' reproduction and recruitment, respectively. Data were assessed at reach-level (i.e., pool) and site-level spatial scales and at annual and intra-annual temporal scales throughout the Ohio River basin, relating patterns of egg/larval and young-of-the-year occurrence to adult relative abundance, hydrologic conditions, and nursery habitat availability.Results Estimated occurrence of Bighead Carp eggs/larvae and young of the year was inconsistent throughout the study area, suggesting limited establishment success in the Ohio River. Silver Carp egg/larval persistence probability was primarily associated with adult densities rather than variation in flow or temperature, and eggs were estimated to occur across a large portion of the basin. However, Silver Carp young-of-the-year occurrence appeared to be spatially restricted. Annual pool and intra-annual site young-of-the-year persistence probability was correlated with the availability of nursery habitat at both scales. Young of the year were consistently detected at only one location, a floodplain lake (Hovey Lake) in the John T. Myers pool, indicating the presence of a potential localized source population in this location.Conclusions Silver Carp eggs/larvae were detected across much of the invaded portion of the Ohio River, suggesting that reproduction is widespread. However, young-of-the-year occurrence was most strongly associated with nursery habitat. In the Ohio River, the lack of widespread nursery habitat may be limiting the recruitment success of young-of-the-year Silver Carp into the population, potentially creating a demographic bottleneck that constrains their spread in this basin. Bighead Carp and Silver Carp are spreading in U.S. rivers, but in the Ohio River their expansion may be slowed due to lower availability of suitable nursery habitat. Identifying and managing these key habitats could help to limit future impacts.
The spread of aquatic invasive species (AIS) poses a major threat to freshwater biodiversity. Understanding the mechanisms regulating occurrence of invasive species in invaded systems requires a multi-scale approach, as regional dispersal can facilitate arrival while local processes ultimately determine their persistence across a landscape. We used a dynamic multi-scale occupancy model to test hypothesized factors limiting the occurrence of invasive bigheaded carps (bighead carp Hypophthalmichthys nobilis and silver carp H. molitrix) in the Ohio River, USA. Across the basin, invasion has slowed, with limited evidence of upstream advancement of their invaded range in this system. However, once present, silver carp and bighead carp populations tended to persist even in apparently low numbers. Bighead carp occurrence was not correlated with any environmental variables. On the local scale, silver carp exhibit clear habitat and flow preferences, where populations persisted in low velocity off-channel locations especially when flows are too high in the main channel. We found evidence for decreasing detection of both species in mid-reach and upstream pools, potentially because of lower abundance in these reaches. Our results indicated that while silver carp occurred throughout a large range of the Ohio River, fewer sites were occupied in upstream reaches. However, there was indirect evidence that site-level occurrence was increasing in the invasion front. Understanding these multi-scale dynamics can be helpful for developing effective strategies to contain invasive silver carp and bighead carp in the Ohio River and other systems.
Invasive carp, including Silver Carp (Hypophthalmichthys molitrix) and Grass Carp (Ctenopharyngodon idella), are increasing their range within the Mississippi River Basin, threatening native fishes and ecosystem function. We conducted a 3-year field test of a multi-modal deterrent that uses sound, bubbles, and light to test its ability to impede upstream passage by invasive carp. The test was performed at a lock and dam on the Cumberland River, Kentucky, USA, using acoustic telemetry to track the movements of Silver Carp, Grass Carp, and several native fish species. When the deterrent was operating, the estimated probability of upstream lock passage was 53% lower (95% CI: 41%-63%) for Silver Carp but 74% higher (95% CI: 3%-190%) for Grass Carp compared to times when the deterrent was not operating. Paddlefish (Polyodon spathula) passage was reduced by 43% (95% CI: 71% reduction to 9% increase), although this was not statistically significant. We detected no significant effects on Freshwater Drum (Aplodinotus grunniens) or Smallmouth Buffalo (Ictiobus bubalus). However, sample sizes were small for these native species, limiting our ability to identify effects. Water temperature, tailwater elevation, and vessel lockages affected passage rates, although this varied among species.
The United States Endangered Species Act (ESA) of 1973 set a precedent for biodiversity conservation across the globe.1 A key requirement of protections afforded by the ESA is the accurate delimitation of imperiled species. We present a comparative reference-based taxonomic approach to species delimitation that integrates genomic and morphological data for objectively assessing the distinctiveness of species targeted for protection by governmental agencies. We apply this protocol to the Snail Darter (Percina tanasi), a freshwater fish from the Tennessee River that was discovered in 1973 and declared an endangered species under the ESA in 1975.2 Concurrently, the Snail Darter’s habitat was slated to be destroyed through the construction of the Tellico Dam by the Tennessee Valley Authority (TVA),3,4 inspiring nationwide protests advocating for the suspension of the federal project. This David versus Goliath struggle between supporters of the 3-inch fish and the TVA culminated in the first major legal conflict over protections afforded by the ESA, the US Supreme Court case Hill v. TVA, 437 U.S. 153 (1978), with a 6 to 3 ruling in favor of protecting the Snail Darter and interrupting the completion of the Tellico Dam. Here, we integrate multiple lines of evidence in a comparative framework to demonstrate that despite its legacy, the Snail Darter is not a distinct species but is a population of the Stargazing Darter (Percina uranidea) described in 1887. These results illustrate how a reference-based framework for species delimitation dramatically aids the proper direction of efforts toward protecting biodiversity.