
Heating accounts for approximately half of global final energy consumption and remains largely dependent on fossil fuels. Many governments are introducing strategic heat planning, including heat network zoning in the UK, which designates areas for district heating networks. However, zoning alone does not guarantee delivery. Networks also need suitable low-carbon heat sources and planning decisions requiring new development to be network-ready. Geothermal energy is a low-carbon heat source beneath many cities, yet governance conditions linking zoning, spatial planning and subsurface resources have received little empirical attention. This paper examines these conditions in Leeds, UK, a pilot city for heat network zoning in England. We combined three-dimensional geological modelling, geospatial analysis of zone boundaries and planning approvals, stakeholder interviews and a participatory workshop. The modelled geothermal resource could in principle meet over 90% of annual heat demand across 255 km2 of central Leeds, but most of it lies outside the heat network zones designated by government. Within indicative zones, planning approvals continue to permit heating systems incompatible with future network connection, such as individual gas boilers and air source heat pumps, creating lock-in. We term this combined pattern dual exclusion, a concept which extends multi-level governance and policy coherence research. It arises because decisions are distributed across scales and sectors, with national zoning developed without subsurface resource data and zones yet to carry statutory weight in local spatial planning. We propose an integrated governance framework and three policy reforms linking heat network zoning, spatial planning and subsurface resource management.
Large-scale solar photovoltaic (LSS) systems have been the largest source of electricity generating capacity added annually the United States since 2009. As LSS development matures, strengthening the foundation of the supporting research is important for establishing a shared understanding of public responses to siting and a robust evidence base that can guide decision-making. This systematic review and critical analysis synthesizes social science research on public responses to LSS in the United States. We examine research trends, geographic coverage, key explanatory factors, and enduring issues within the literature, highlighting high-value research areas and key considerations for decision-makers, developers, and host communities. We also propose a conceptual framework for interpreting the research findings and offer recommendations to help the field converge around shared definitions, methodologies, and priorities. Across the literature reviewed, public responses to LSS are most consistently associated with place-based values and meanings, risk-benefit perceptions, and judgements about procedural and distributive fairness. Three broader implications emerge from this review related to information and trust; opportunities and constraints for LSS integration with agriculture; and place-based siting approaches that build on common principles. These insights provide practical guidance for LSS research and public engagement and offer transferrable lessons for socially acceptable siting and land use decision-making more broadly.
Digital Building Logbooks (DBLs) and Building Renovation Passports (BRPs) are intended to support building decarbonisation by improving access to building information and guiding renovation decisions. However, their effectiveness across governance systems remains insufficiently understood. This study examines how institutional arrangements, regulatory frameworks, and stakeholder practices shape implementation and support for building renovation. It compares two contrasting cases: Woningpas in Flanders, Belgium, which integrates DBL and BRP functions within a public-sector platform, and the Carnet d'Information du Logement (CIL) in France, a nationally regulated DBL with BRP functionalities emerging through private providers. Drawing on the Sabatier and Mazmanian policy implementation framework, the study combines qualitative policy analysis with nine semi-structured interviews involving public authorities, platform providers, and housing-sector actors. The findings reveal that both cases face fragmented data systems, interoperability problems, limited stakeholder engagement, and coordination challenges, but with different outcomes. Woningpas benefits from integrated public data infrastructure and institutional coordination, yet voluntary use, limited incentives, and weak integration into routine renovation decisions restrict its impact. In France, legal requirements coexist with weak enforcement, inconsistent data practices, and fragmented market-based delivery, limiting interoperability and engagement. The study demonstrates that neither centralised coordination nor legal obligations alone ensure effective implementation. Instead, outcomes depend on alignment between regulation, data infrastructure, institutional capacity, organisational practices, and stakeholder incentives. By comparing these contrasting approaches, the study advances understanding of how digital renovation instruments operate in practice and highlights the need to connect building information systems with accessible renovation advice, financial support, and practical decision-making processes.