The effort of this article is to solve one of the main problems in the field of banking, which is closely related to the field of information technology. The combination of the management discussion of this topic with the field of information technology will be one of the important topics in the field of information technology management. The main goal of this article is the clustering of bank customers.At first, all customer characteristics were extracted from the bank's database, which was randomly extracted for 900,000 customers, which will be provided as input to the proposed method of this article. All the characteristics of these customers were extracted and 10 characteristics (except four characteristics of the LRFM method) were listed using the opinions of experts. The proposed method should be able to choose among these 10 features for clustering customers, which results in more resolution in clustering. Due to the high number of cases of this problem, it is not possible to do it manually, and the proposed method tries to provide a separate model for clustering for the customers of each bank by examining different cases. Also, the problem of choosing the right value for the number of clusters in the K-means method is solved by the method proposed in this article. The results show that it is better than the basic RFM and LRFM methods.Keywords: relationship management with bank customers, clustering, RFM model, LRFM model, particle swarm algorithm, K-means method.
.Today, digitization is considered as a requirement for all financial and monetary institutions and markets, and the banking industry is no exception. However, moving to digital banking is not an easy task for banks, and the digital revolution has become a major challenge for this industry. In order to keep their business stable, banks need to launch digital platforms and create robust ecosystems around them that have the ability to evolve and adapt to the challenges caused by the chaotic and unpredictable environment in which organizations operate and the increase in internal inefficiencies. Therefore, this research was conducted with the purpose of modeling the generative mechanisms of the evolution of Iran's digital banking ecosystem. For this purpose, the qualitative content analysis method has been used. A semi-structured interview has been used to collect information using the opinions of experts in the field of digital banking. The analysis of the conducted interviews led to the identification of 674 themes, 181 codes, 59 subcategories, and 20 categories. The results of the research show that there are external factors, including cyber-attacks, political and governance obstacles, the increasing progress of communication and information technology, changes in the competitive environment, and conflicting investment relationships in the financial and banking fields, and internal factors, including the absence of strong security infrastructure in the network and weak security, weakness in digital human capital, changing needs and demands of actors, weakness in the traditional business model, and the lack of a management perspective regarding the growth of digital banking and regulatory and legal requirements, are the stimuli for the co-evolution of the elements of the digital banking ecosystem, which occurs with the activation of reinforcing and transformative generative mechanisms. The consequences of the evolution of the digital banking ecosystem can be classified into three levels: users, owner, and society.IntroductionIn the digital revolution, with the change in customer behavior and expectations and the behavior of businesses, the structure of the competition and the strategic context of the business world has changed, and the banking industry is not an exception to this rule; therefore, digitalization is considered a requirement for the banking industry. However, moving to digital banking is not an easy task for banks, and the digital revolution has become a major challenge for this industry. The previous studies have revealed that, so far, some banks have not been successful in facing the fundamental changes of the digital age and have not been able to take fundamental actions to stabilize their businesses. To this end, the first step to realizing these changes in the banking industry is a complete reconsideration of customer relations and the method of providing value to meet customer needs, business models, platforms, and ecosystems. Yet it is not enough to set up a digital platform ecosystem and just rapidly multiply it, as keeping it stable is also highly important as well. In fact, digital platform ecosystems that can be sustained over the long term are very rare. Therefore, digital platform ecosystems must have the ability to evolve and adapt to the challenges caused by the chaotic and unpredictable environment that organizations operate in as well as the increase of internal inefficiencies. Thus, besides the need for a complete rethinking of the digital banking ecosystem, the manner in which its evolutionary process has been in Iran's banking industry is important. Thus far, neither of these issues has been investigated in Iran which signifies the necessity of applied and fundamental research. The current research tries to fill this gap in the country.Research Question(s)What are the elements of the digital banking platform ecosystem and which will evolve in the future?What are the generative mechanisms of digital banking platform ecosystem evolution?What are the stimulating factors and consequences of the evolution of the digital banking platform ecosystem?Literature ReviewNowadays, digitization has become a strategic priority for the banking industry, and the establishment of digital banking requires creating a strong ecosystem around the digital banking platform and developing it. However, so far, there has not been any systematic and comprehensive approach regarding the evolution of the digital platform ecosystem. Previous studies identify digital platform ecosystems as highly evolving socio-technical arrangements that require rapid development and adaptation to ensure their long-term sustainability. Due to the lack of a clear conceptualization of the evolution of digital platform ecosystems, Stykova (2019) integrated different perspectives and proposed a novel conceptualization of the evolution of digital platform ecosystems. According to his studies, the evolution of the digital platform ecosystem delineates continuous changes in the digital platform ecosystem in relation to its actors, architecture, and governance. Through these changes, the simultaneous development of platform structures, infrastructure, functionalities, and governance regime occurs. The endogenous and exogenous events and factors emerging during the evolution of the digital platform ecosystem challenge the configuration of the ecosystem and lead to changing it. Staykova defines two types of generative mechanisms for the evolution of the digital platform ecosystem: transformative and reinforcing.MethodologyIn this research, the qualitative content analysis method is used. A group of experts in the field of digital banking in Iran's banking industry who have deep insight and the necessary knowledge about the subject of the research participated as the statistical population of this research. The purposive sampling method was employed for sampling and continued until the theoretical saturation was reached. Therefore, in this research, 21 interviews were conducted, and due to the incompleteness of some of them, in the end, by analyzing 18 interviews, the research questions were answered, and theoretical saturation was achieved.ResultsThe analysis of the interviews led to the identification of 674 themes, 181 codes, 59 subcategories, and 20 categories. Based on the results of categorization in thematic analysis and review of the theoretical foundations and the related literature, the elements of the digital banking platform ecosystem, including ecosystem actors, platform architecture, and platform governance were identified. Moreover, External factors, such as cyber-attacks, political and governance obstacles, the increasing progress of communication and information technology, changes in the competitive environment, and conflicting investment relationships in the financial and banking fields, as well as internal factors, such as the absence of strong security infrastructure in the network and weak security, weakness in digital human capital, changing needs and demands of actors, weakness in the traditional business model, and lack of management perspective regarding the growth of digital banking and regulatory and legal requirements, are the co-evolutionary stimuli of digital banking platform ecosystem elements, which appear as a result of the activation of generative, reinforcing and transformative mechanisms. Finally, the implications of the evolution of the ecosystem of the digital banking platform can be classified into three levels. The benefits of the evolution of the ecosystem for users are increasing the speed of providing and receiving services, gaining usefulness, improved security, freedom in providing and receiving services, ease of access, and co-creation of value. The implications of evolution for the owner (organization) are the Orchestrator role of the owner, dynamic capability, market size, increased revenue, increased productivity, and business sustainability. Furthermore, the outcomes of the evolution of the ecosystem at the community level include social, environmental, and economic benefits, which are indicators of reaching the maturity stage in the life cycle of the digital banking platform ecosystem.
The purpose of this research is to identify the main components and dimensions of digital content marketing according to the conditions of Iran and to present a model using a qualitative method based on the Grounded Theory approach. Data were collected through semi-structured in-depth interviews with experts. These experts included university professors in the field of digital content marketing and managers and activists of advertising and digital marketing agencies. Using targeted sampling and after conducting 15 in-depth interviews, theoretical saturation was achieved after the implementation and analysis of interviews and open, axial, and selective coding. The results showed that digital content marketing is realized by these conditions. Causal conditions (Internet development, ease of use, popularity of cyberspace, ease of communication with customers, virtual network features, The appeal of Digital Content Marketing, changing customer behavior, changing current structures), contextual conditions (personal characteristics, social characteristics), intervening factors (technical limitations, increasing competitors, lack of access, unawareness, severity of the spread of Covid-19), central category (Digital Content Marketing), strategies (make it enjoyable, increasing participation, providing various services to users, using various methods to increasing audience, exchange of information, infrastructure improvement, audience-friendly style, customer orientation), and consequences (market expansion, increasing profitability, groundwork for brand creation). The results indicate that the research model is acceptable level. IntroductionThe emergence of digital networks and the wide spread of technology dramatically changed human life compared to the latest technological tools of the previous decades (Torkestani et al, 2020), so that nowadays customers have significantly changed their behavior in line with the technology and economic environment of the world (Rostami et al, 2022). Modern advertising is more cost-effective and inexpensive than traditional advertising (Abdulle, 2022). Therefore, to attract customers, trust must be gained first, and customers should feel satisfied with our brand before purchasing a product or service. These features can be found in digital content marketing (Mozaffari et al, 2023). Inflation and the prevailing economic recession have created difficult conditions for individuals and businesses (Naseri, 2017). To overcome these difficult conditions, a native model must be explained in the field of digital content marketing.Research Question (s)The main research question is as follows: What is the conceptual model for digital content marketing? What are the main components and dimensions of this model? Literature ReviewTorkestani et al. (2022) discussed the possibility of personalizing content for each audience, the emotions hidden in the content and the date of publication of the content, the way the author is a member and his identity in the online community. Tahmasebpour et al. (2022) considered digital marketing elements to include six components: technical features of digital tools, relative advantage, cost to customers, management of items and processes, promotion, service quality, and information quality. Rostami et al. (2022) also prioritized the factors affecting marketing in digital businesses in their research and did not provide a model that included all aspects of this issue. (Naseri, 2017) also only looked at content features in four categories, content inherent elements, form elements, content distribution media elements and effectiveness measurement elements. (Naseri, 2017) examined only the characteristics of the content in four categories; intrinsic content elements, form elements, content distribution media elements, and effectiveness measurement elements. (Lou & Xie, 2020) also emphasized in their research on shaping brand experience and customer loyalty of. Boban et al. (2020) only investigated the relationship between content entertainment and informational social influence and between self-expression and normative social influence and electronic word-of-mouth communication. Furr. (2019) considered digital content marketing as a branding tool for colleges and universities. Taiminen & Ranaweera, (2019) focused on support, engagement, and interaction in brand communication and perceptions. MethodologyIn terms of purpose, this research is fundamental and applied, and in terms of nature, it is in the category of qualitative research. In terms of approach, the Grounded Theory and paradigm model of Strauss and Corbin have been used as a research plan, which is based on the identification of causal conditions, contextual conditions, central category, intervening conditions, strategies and consequences, and describing the relationships between them. A semi-structured in-depth interview was conducted with 15 experts who were selected in a non-probable and purposeful manner. Sampling was performed until theoretical saturation using the snowball method. The research community includes digital experts (academic and non-academic). This group includes university professors in the field of digital content marketing, as well as activists and specialists in the field of digital content production (institutions and agencies of digital marketing and advertising). They have at least five years of scientific, research, and executive experience in DCM and at least a master's degree or doctorate in the fields of marketing management, information technology management, and other related fields. In the analysis of the data obtained from the interviews, after the full implementation of the text of the interviews, MaxQuda 2020 was used. Immediately after each interview, the interview text was extracted and typed, entered into the software, and open, axial, and selective coding procedures were performed. ResultsThe information obtained from the interviews resulted in the extraction of 135 concepts (open coding), which were placed in the form of 26 subcategories (axial coding) and 5 main categories (selective coding), as follows: Internet development, ease of use, popularity of cyberspace, ease of communication with customers, virtual network features, the appeal of Digital Content Marketing, changing customer behavior, changing current structures, technical limitations, increasing competitors, lack of access, unawareness, severity of the spread of Covid-19, personal characteristics, social characteristics, make it enjoyable, increasing participation, providing various services to users, using various methods for increasing the audience, exchange of information, infrastructure improvement, audience-friendly style, customer orientation, market expansion, increasing profitability, groundwork for brand creation.The paradigm model is presented in figure 1.Figure.1. Paradigm model of the research ConclusionThis article aims to design a digital content marketing model. Making it enjoyable in this research includes gamification in social networks, visualizing content according to people's tastes, using humorous content, and entertaining content. The obtained results showed that making it enjoyable is an effective strategy for digital content marketing. In this research, the following were discovered to increase participation in digital content: using celebrities, participating in online campaigns, holding contests, and building trust and commitment in customers. The results also show that increasing participation is an important strategy in digital content marketing. The services that can be paid in the production of digital content to attract the audience are as follows: offering discounts, bonuses to users, free training, and support. The obtained results also show that providing diverse services to users is an influential factor in digital content marketing strategies. Various methods of increasing the audience in this research include: providing outstanding and strange information, producing educational content, producing therapeutic content, producing sports content, using new ideas to produce content, producing fresh and new content, teaching new methods of producing content, increasing quality, extensive advertising, social network viral marketing, and content creation based on frequent words. The results show that the use of methods to increase the audience is the most effective strategy. Information exchange includes modeling external pages, modeling successful pages, participation in online campaigns, and content exchange. The obtained results show that information exchange has a significant impact on digital content marketing strategies. Improving the infrastructure in the field of digital content includes increasing the speed of the Internet, website design, and the production of powerful internal applications, which the results show is one of the most important strategies. Audience-friendly style also includes creating differentiation, special and unique style, being up-to-date; using one of the special effects is the mastery of body language. The results show that an audience-friendly style is one of the most effective strategies in digital content marketing. Customer orientation also includes content production based on society's problems, compliance with professional ethics, monitoring customer needs, finding customers' tastes, and honesty in content production. The obtained results show that customer orientation is an important strategy in digital content marketing.Keywords: Digital Content Marketing, Online Marketing, Brand Awareness, Grounded Theory. The purpose of this research is to identify the main components and dimensions of digital content marketing according to the conditions of Iran and to present a model using a qualitative method based on the Grounded Theory approach. Data were collected through semi-structured in-depth interviews with experts. These experts included university professors in the field of digital content marketing and managers and activists of advertising and digital marketing agencies. Using targeted sampling and after conducting 15 in-depth interviews, theoretical saturation was achieved after the implementation and analysis of interviews and open, axial, and selective coding. The results showed that digital content marketing is realized by these conditions. Causal conditions (Internet development, ease of use, popularity of cyberspace, ease of communication with customers, virtual network features, The appeal of Digital Content Marketing, changing customer behavior, changing current structures), contextual conditions (personal characteristics, social characteristics), intervening factors (technical limitations, increasing competitors, lack of access, unawareness, severity of the spread of Covid-19), central category (Digital Content Marketing), strategies (make it enjoyable, increasing participation, providing various services to users, using various methods to increasing audience, exchange of information, infrastructure improvement, audience-friendly style, customer orientation), and consequences (market expansion, increasing profitability, groundwork for brand creation). The results indicate that the research model is acceptable level. IntroductionThe emergence of digital networks and the wide spread of technology dramatically changed human life compared to the latest technological tools of the previous decades (Torkestani et al, 2020), so that nowadays customers have significantly changed their behavior in line with the technology and economic environment of the world (Rostami et al, 2022). Modern advertising is more cost-effective and inexpensive than traditional advertising (Abdulle, 2022). Therefore, to attract customers, trust must be gained first, and customers should feel satisfied with our brand before purchasing a product or service. These features can be found in digital content marketing (Mozaffari et al, 2023). Inflation and the prevailing economic recession have created difficult conditions for individuals and businesses (Naseri, 2017). To overcome these difficult conditions, a native model must be explained in the field of digital content marketing.Research Question (s)The main research question is as follows: What is the conceptual model for digital content marketing? What are the main components and dimensions of this model? Literature ReviewTorkestani et al. (2022) discussed the possibility of personalizing content for each audience, the emotions hidden in the content and the date of publication of the content, the way the author is a member and his identity in the online community. Tahmasebpour et al. (2022) considered digital marketing elements to include six components: technical features of digital tools, relative advantage, cost to customers, management of items and processes, promotion, service quality, and information quality. Rostami et al. (2022) also prioritized the factors affecting marketing in digital businesses in their research and did not provide a model that included all aspects of this issue. (Naseri, 2017) also only looked at content features in four categories, content inherent elements, form elements, content distribution media elements and effectiveness measurement elements. (Naseri, 2017) examined only the characteristics of the content in four categories; intrinsic content elements, form elements, content distribution media elements, and effectiveness measurement elements. (Lou & Xie, 2020) also emphasized in their research on shaping brand experience and customer loyalty of. Boban et al. (2020) only investigated the relationship between content entertainment and informational social influence and between self-expression and normative social influence and electronic word-of-mouth communication. Furr. (2019) considered digital content marketing as a branding tool for colleges and universities. Taiminen & Ranaweera, (2019) focused on support, engagement, and interaction in brand communication and perceptions. MethodologyIn terms of purpose, this research is fundamental and applied, and in terms of nature, it is in the category of qualitative research. In terms of approach, the Grounded Theory and paradigm model of Strauss and Corbin have been used as a research plan, which is based on the identification of causal conditions, contextual conditions, central category, intervening conditions, strategies and consequences, and describing the relationships between them. A semi-structured in-depth interview was conducted with 15 experts who were selected in a non-probable and purposeful manner. Sampling was performed until theoretical saturation using the snowball method. The research community includes digital experts (academic and non-academic). This group includes university professors in the field of digital content marketing, as well as activists and specialists in the field of digital content production (institutions and agencies of digital marketing and advertising). They have at least five years of scientific, research, and executive experience in DCM and at least a master's degree or doctorate in the fields of marketing management, information technology management, and other related fields. In the analysis of the data obtained from the interviews, after the full implementation of the text of the interviews, MaxQuda 2020 was used. Immediately after each interview, the interview text was extracted and typed, entered into the software, and open, axial, and selective coding procedures were performed. ResultsThe information obtained from the interviews resulted in the extraction of 135 concepts (open coding), which were placed in the form of 26 subcategories (axial coding) and 5 main categories (selective coding), as follows: Internet development, ease of use, popularity of cyberspace, ease of communication with customers, virtual network features, the appeal of Digital Content Marketing, changing customer behavior, changing current structures, technical limitations, increasing competitors, lack of access, unawareness, severity of the spread of Covid-19, personal characteristics, social characteristics, make it enjoyable, increasing participation, providing various services to users, using various methods for increasing the audience, exchange of information, infrastructure improvement, audience-friendly style, customer orientation, market expansion, increasing profitability, groundwork for brand creation.The paradigm model is presented in figure 1.Figure.1. Paradigm model of the research ConclusionThis article aims to design a digital content marketing model. Making it enjoyable in this research includes gamification in social networks, visualizing content according to people's tastes, using humorous content, and entertaining content. The obtained results showed that making it enjoyable is an effective strategy for digital content marketing. In this research, the following were discovered to increase participation in digital content: using celebrities, participating in online campaigns, holding contests, and building trust and commitment in customers. The results also show that increasing participation is an important strategy in digital content marketing. The services that can be paid in the production of digital content to attract the audience are as follows: offering discounts, bonuses to users, free training, and support. The obtained results also show that providing diverse services to users is an influential factor in digital content marketing strategies. Various methods of increasing the audience in this research include: providing outstanding and strange information, producing educational content, producing therapeutic content, producing sports content, using new ideas to produce content, producing fresh and new content, teaching new methods of producing content, increasing quality, extensive advertising, social network viral marketing, and content creation based on frequent words. The results show that the use of methods to increase the audience is the most effective strategy. Information exchange includes modeling external pages, modeling successful pages, participation in online campaigns, and content exchange. The obtained results show that information exchange has a significant impact on digital content marketing strategies. Improving the infrastructure in the field of digital content includes increasing the speed of the Internet, website design, and the production of powerful internal applications, which the results show is one of the most important strategies. Audience-friendly style also includes creating differentiation, special and unique style, being up-to-date; using one of the special effects is the mastery of body language. The results show that an audience-friendly style is one of the most effective strategies in digital content marketing. Customer orientation also includes content production based on society's problems, compliance with professional ethics, monitoring customer needs, finding customers' tastes, and honesty in content production. The obtained results show that customer orientation is an important strategy in digital content marketing.
This study aimed to investigate the effect of brand interaction through social media on brand loyalty through brand equity. The research is a descriptive research of the correlational type in terms of practical purpose and based on the method. The statistical population of this research includes the customers of three Iranian brands, My, Cinere and Callista. The size of the population is considered unlimited and the G-POWER tool was used to determine the sample size and the statistical sample size was calculated to be 199 people. A simple random sampling method was chosen for data collection and the data collection required in this research was done using a localized standard questionnaire. In order to confirm content validity, CVI and CVR and expert panel were used. In order to determine the reliability of the questionnaire, Cronbach's alpha coefficient, combined reliability and homogeneous reliability were used. Because the data do not follow normal modeling; Therefore, structural equation model and partial least squares method and PLS software were used for hypothesis testing and path analysis. The results of this study showed that customer interaction with the brand through social media can have a positive effect on brand loyalty. Also, brand equity was a positive mediating factor in the relationship between brand interaction and brand loyalty. Among the three cognitive, emotional and behavioral paths, the behavioral path with a path coefficient of 0.630 is the best path in influencing customer interaction with the brand on brand loyalty.
Fintech and its entrepreneurial opportunities have the ability to play an effective role in the development of the financial industry. Therefore, it is necessary to make a correct and effective policy in this area to identify its probable future. This study is exploratory in terms of purpose and practical in terms of orientation. Interviews and questionnaires were used to collect data. 28 drivers were extracted by reviewing the background and interviewing experts. In order to screen the propellants, expert questionnaire and fuzzy Delphi method were used. Then the propellants screened were ranked through the priority assessment questionnaire and the developed COPRAS technique. The two drivers of the development of smart contracts in the financial industry and the tendency of financial institutions towards open innovation had the highest priority and were used to write research scenarios. Based on these two drivers, 4 scenarios of the era of pristine opportunities, the era of conservative managers, the era of dilapidated infrastructure and the ice age were developed. Then, using the MABAC technique, the scenario of the age of dilapidated infrastructures was selected as the possible scenario of the research. Research proposals were proposed based on priority drivers and possible scenarios. Government support, providing sufficient funds in order to create the necessary infrastructure for the development of smart contracts by banks or establishing a cooperative relationship between banks and financial institutions, fair legislation, development of regtechs, creating compatibility between current systems with new technologies were the most important practical proposals of the study.
New technologies in the field of Industry 4.0 enable companies to enhance their business processes and customize products and services through the generation of new knowledge. The creation and sharing of this new knowledge depends on both the optimal use of Industry 4.0 technologies and interactions along the value chain. However, achieving business benefits is highly dependent on human resources and their digital skills and competencies. Therefore, companies approaching the Industry 4.0 paradigm should consider these new technologies as tools that facilitate the creation and sharing of new knowledge. They should pay attention to the digital skills and competencies required to manage this technological transformation and enhance internal competencies. The purpose of this research is to combine the results and findings obtained from qualitative studies, providing new insights from previous research. In this study, a meta-composite approach was used to investigate qualitative case studies, examining the relationship between knowledge management and Industry 4.0 capabilities in organizations. The results show that knowledge management capabilities in the field of Industry 4.0 are examined in two dimensions: business models and organizational innovation. This research also emphasizes that in order to address organizational challenges, knowledge management strategies and the maturity level of Industry 4.0 technologies within organizations must be understood.IntroductionIndustry 4.0, driven by digital technologies such as smart sensors, IoT, cloud computing, big data, and AI, holds significant importance in the realm of organizational knowledge management. It enables convenient access to vast repositories of data that can be meticulously scrutinized to drive improvements in processes. Moreover, Industry 4.0 seamlessly merges the physical and virtual domains, thereby enhancing both production processes and resulting products (Wilkesmann, 2018). This study endeavors to propose a model that seamlessly integrates knowledge management and Industry 4.0 to gain a competitive advantage. The researchers will utilize the Meta-synthesis method to identify capabilities and develop a new framework, thus contributing to a deeper understanding in this field.Literature ReviewThe theoretical foundations are categorized into two components: Industry 4.0 and knowledge management.2.1. Industry 4.0Industry 4.0 emerged in 2011 as the fourth industrial revolution, focusing on fully automated and intelligent production systems. It involves the integration of production systems through real-time information exchange and flexible production. The internet and related technologies play a crucial role in connecting physical objects, machines, and processes across organizations (Ghobakhloo, 2018). Industry 4.0 relies on data-driven decision-making and recognizes the value of real-time data utilization. It disrupts traditional competition and impacts various aspects of organizational strategy, business models, innovation, supply chains, production processes, and stakeholder relationships (Pozzi et al., 2023).2.2. Knowledge management strategies and approaches in Industry4.0Knowledge is essential for decision-making in implementing Industry 4.0 technologies. Industry 4.0 significantly influences knowledge management within organizations. These technologies facilitate knowledge management by enhancing existing knowledge and generating new knowledge. Knowledge sharing and storage are key components of knowledge management in the context of Industry 4.0 (Salvadorinho & Teixeira, 2021). The cost-effective and high-performance nature of Industry 4.0 technologies makes them suitable for storing and sharing knowledge. Industry 4.0 technologies enhance value creation through knowledge sharing within organizations and enable organizational innovation and competitive advantage maximization through knowledge management (Gupta et al., 2022).MethodologyThis research proposes Meta-synthesis as a suitable method for effectively combining the various factors involved in knowledge management capabilities and Industry 4.0 technologies within organizations. Meta-synthesis serves as a valuable instrument in formulating a comprehensive theory by systematically amalgamating these elements. The selection of the Hoon model (Hoon, 2013) for this research is based on its comprehensive and innovative nature in comparison to other Meta-synthesis models. It is characterized as an exploratory and inductive research design that integrates qualitative case studies to extend the findings of the original studies. Hoon's proposed Metasynthesis entails eight specific steps, which are briefly outlined below:Step 1 involves designing and framing the research question related to knowledge management capabilities in Industry 4.0. Step 2 includes searching for articles using specific keywords and selecting relevant research. Step 3 involves screening and selecting suitable texts based on inclusion criteria. Step 4 entails extracting and coding evidence from selected studies. Step 5 analyzes individual studies using a causal network technique. Step 6 synthesizes findings on an across-study level. Step 7 involves building theory from meta-synthesis.Results and DiscussionThe convergence of Industry 4.0 and knowledge management within organizational frameworks serves to amplify the influence of knowledge management on the performance of organizational innovation (Tortorella et al., 2022). This study furnishes valuable perspectives for formulating an adoption strategy and prioritizing tasks in the integration of Industry 4.0. It underscores the significance of knowledge dissemination in expediting the assimilation of Industry 4.0 and recommends a focus on cultivating affiliations with strategic counterparts. The development of internal capabilities and competencies stands as pivotal for meaningful engagement in knowledge dissemination for Industry 4.0. Effective knowledge exchange among organizations can offset the dearth of internal resources and knowledge during the adoption process. This study accentuates the cost-effectiveness of knowledge sharing as an alternative to external consultants. In sum, it furnishes invaluable insights for managers seeking to augment organizational innovation, fortify stakeholder associations, and attain a competitive edge in the landscape of Industry 4.0.ConclusionThe Meta-synthesis approach used in this study has limitations, including a smaller sample size of only 8 studies, which raises concerns about the generalizability of the findings. The reliance on a limited number of keywords for searching and identifying studies is another limitation. However, the study's analysis revealed similarities among the chosen articles, and the selection process followed the criteria set by Hoon (2013). The Meta-synthesis protocol allows for the development of causal networks, meta-causal network, and case comparison table, showing a wider context of knowledge management and Industry 4.0 capabilities in organizations. Future studies should encompass a wider scope, as organizations in the Industry 4.0 environment need to share and manage knowledge both internally and externally. The Meta causal network developed in this study can be used as a foundation for developing strategies that generate value and foster a competitive advantage in the realm of Industry 4.0.Keywords: Knowledge Management, Industry 4.0, Meta-Synthesis, Case Study.Figure 1. Meta-causal network of selected analyzed studies (research findings)
The digital world provides many opportunities for marketers to reach customers. However, in the fast-paced world, finding new and innovative ways to advertise and sell products and services is very important. Due to the advancement of artificial intelligence and its development in the field of advertising and sales, professionals now have the tools to completely redefine the current understanding of branding, marketing, advertising and sales. The growing popularity of the Internet and the increased use of mobile devices are generating massive amounts of consumer data that feed artificial intelligence-based systems. This research is a type of mixed research with a qualitative and quantitative approach, which is a survey descriptive study in terms of its purpose, application, and in terms of data collection. The statistical population of the research was managers and experts in the field of digital marketing and IT in the field of advertising and sales, who were selected using the snowball sampling method. In the qualitative part, the tools for collecting information were library and articles review, interviews, and in the quantitative part, questionnaires. In the qualitative part of the data analysis method, using the theme analysis that was compiled with MAXQDA software and using the coding method, and in the quantitative part, the analysis method was based on Kendall's correlation test. According to the results of the research, 7 main themes, 22 sub-themes and 44 codes were discovered, which included the consequences of using artificial intelligence and machine learning in advertising and sales
Crowdfunding is an effective way to achieve the non-profit goals of the charities which can be expanded using information and communication technology. In this regard, this study was conducted with the aim of providing an online donation intention model for collective financing of charitable institutions in Iran. The current research is an applied-developmental research in terms of its purpose, and it is considered a cross-sectional survey research from the data collection point of view. The statistical population in the qualitative section includes managers of charity institutions and university professors. Sampling was done using a purposeful method and theoretical saturation with 10 interviews. In the quantitative section, the views of 357 benefactors were used. The data collection tool is a semi-structured interview and a researcher-made questionnaire. To analyze the collected data, qualitative thematic analysis and partial least squares were used. The research findings showed that the technical infrastructure facilitating conditions, the quality and transparency of the website information, the security of the site and the application, and the preservation of privacy affect the perceived risk. Perceived risk affects the expectation of effort and the pleasure of helping others and leads to the expectation of performance and social influence. Finally, online donation intention is strengthened through trust.IntroductionToday, charity institutions in the country can expose to the various needs of the needy to the public using crowdfunding platforms, so that with the participation of people the necessary financial resources are provided and the problems of the needy and the deprived are solved. In this field, practical and scientific activities have also been carried out however one of the most important issues neglected from the researchers’ view point and activists in this field is the discussion of the desire or intention of online donation among benefactors. The best online donation platforms and the use of the latest technologies are not enough to attract public participation, and it is not easy to encourage and motivate people to donate online. This issue itself can be discussed from various aspects. On the one hand, the basic element of this method of financing is the maximum participation of people, and on the other hand, members of the society have little knowledge about the issue and do not have much desire to attend such calls.Therefore, in general, it can be said that the intention to donate online is a fundamental factor in the success of the efforts of the country's charities for crowdfunding. The basic question of this research is that: what is the online donation intention model for collective financing of charities in Iran?Literature ReviewCrowdfunding is an alternative way to finance a project with specific goals at a specific time through an online platform. The phenomenon of crowdfunding is emerging in the field of financing resources, goods and services in the modern digital field (Jiao and Yue, 2021). The current study focuses on the crowdfunding approach based on donations in Iranian charities. This method is mostly used in non-profit and philanthropic projects, and the participants do not expect any financial support, and are mostly used to finance charities, religious places, and civil institutions (Salido et al., 2021). In the crowdfunding method based on donation, the participants do not have any expectations for the provided financial support. The donor believes wholeheartedly in the correctness of his act and considers it to be socially beneficial. This model is usually used in financing civil institutions and charities (Van Thienbroek et al., 2023).MethodologyThis is an applied-developmental research. The population of participants in the qualitative section includes theoretical experts and experimental. Sampling was done with a purposeful method and theoretical saturation was achieved with 10 interviews. The sample size was estimated to be 357 people using Cochran's formula.The main tool for collecting research data is a semi-structured interview and a researcher-made questionnaire. And then, using ISM, the relationships between the main factors affecting the intention to donate online were determined by experts. The interview included 6 basic questions and was conducted in a semi-structured way. The research questionnaire includes 10 main constructs and 51 items with a five-point Likert scale. Thematic analysis was used to identify the categories of online donation intention for crowdfunding of charities in Iran. Data analysis was done in qualitative phase with MAXQDA software and in quantitative phase with Smart PLS software.ResultsThe results of the interviews were analyzed by the qualitative method of thematic analysis based on the six-step method of Etrid-Straling (2001). 830 open codes were identified in the first stage. After analysis and review, we reached 5 overarching themes, 10 organizing themes and 51 basic themes as below:Overarching themes: Social factors- Technical factors-Individual factors- Security factors- Consequence factors.Organizer themes: Performance expectation- Endeavour expectation- Social influence- Quality and transparency of website information- Technical infrastructure facilitating conditions- Trust- The joy of helping others- Perceived risk- Site and application security and privacy- Intention to donate online.DiscussionThe present study was conducted with the aim of presenting the online donation intention model for the collective financing of charitable organizations in Iran. Based on the results, it was determined that the facilitating conditions of the technical infrastructure, the quality and transparency of the website information, the security of the site and the application, and the protection of privacy affect the perceived risk. In the results of Zhang et al.'s (2023) and Shahidi and Kivani's (1401) studies, the technical infrastructure and website information components are also mentioned as important elements in the intention to donate online, and from this point of view, it is consistent with the results of the present study. It was also shown that the perceived risk affects the expectation of effort and the pleasure of helping others and leads to the expectation of performance and social influence. In the results of the studies of Hassanzadeh Sarostani et al. (2017) and Bass and Rushdi (2023), the importance of paying attention to the perceived risk is also mentioned, and from this point of view, it is consistent with the results of the present study. Finally, the results of the research showed that online donation intention is strengthened through trust. This importance has been confirmed in the results of Shahabi-Shojaei et al.'s study (1401).ConclusionThe present study was conducted with the aim of presenting the online donation intention model for the collective financing of charitable institutions in Iran. Based on the results, it was determined that the facilitating conditions of the technical infrastructure, the quality and transparency of the website information, the security of the site and the application, and the protection of privacy affect the perceived risk. It was also shown that the perceived risk affects the expectation of effort and the pleasure of helping others and leads to the expectation of performance and social influence. Finally, the results of the research showed that online donation intention is strengthened through trust.
Smart technologies have brought changes in the supply chain. This study was conducted with the aim of investigating the impact of the Internet of Things on the intelligent management of the supply chain, which evaluates the relationships between variables and their impact and effectiveness with the fuzzy cognitive mapping method. The statistical population is academic experts and active experts in the drug distribution company in Bushehr province. After identifying the components from the background of the research, an interview was conducted. Then the questionnaire was presented to 10 experts and experts and it was analyzed in several stages, and finally, the main factors of the use of Internet of Things in the supply chain were determined in 9 categories of criteria and 41 sub-criteria. The criteria include: intelligent management of inventory and warehousing, intelligent management of operations, intelligent management of information, intelligent management of products, intelligent management of costs, intelligent management of corporate productivity, intelligent management of customers and drug suppliers, intelligent management of sales and marketing, and intelligent management of the environment.The results showed that intelligent information management was obtained as the most important indicator; Because it affects all indicators. intelligent management of customers, intelligent management of sales and marketing, and intelligent management of operations are the second most influential. Therefore, managers of the drug distribution industry should use Internet of Things technology to intelligently manage information in their organization, improve relationships with customers, improve operations and focus on the sales process, and optimize supply chain processes and profitability.
The reduction of profit margins and the disappearance of past competitive advantages have pushed companies in Petrochemical industries toward innovation by utilizing digital capabilities. This necessitates the establishment of a strategic alignment between digital capabilities and innovation strategies and decisions. This research aims to examine the dimensions of alignment between digital capability variables and innovation strategies and create a framework for its assessment. Initially, by reviewing the background of studies, a framework for assessing each of the variables was developed. Subsequently, a questionnaire for confirmatory structural analysis of the identified concepts and dimensions was formulated. This questionnaire was completed by 99 experts in innovation management, digital technologies in the industry, and academia. As a result, it was determined that to assess the level of alignment between digital capabilities and innovation strategies, creating digital value and digital innovation processes for innovation strategies, digital innovation infrastructure and digital innovation capabilities for digital capabilities, and complementarity, balance, and coordination for alignment were considered as assessment dimensions of the variables.
In the digital age, blockchain technology is recognized as an operational innovation that is rapidly joining the field of supply chain and humanitarian logistics. Hence, blockchain technology has the potential to fundamentally change the field of humanitarian aid, but still relatively little research has been published aimed at improving understanding of the various barriers to blockchain adoption in humanitarian logistics. The aim of this research is to provide an integrated framework for evaluating the barriers to blockchain adoption in the field of humanitarian logistics. To assess the barriers, integrated approach has been applied in three phases. In the first phase of this approach, based on the literature, 10 barriers to the adoption of blockchain in humanitarian logistics are identified and evaluated using the FMEA method. In the second phase, using the opinions of experts, the weights of the three factors are calculated. Then, in the third phase and according to the outputs of the previous phases, obstacles are prioritized using the proposed Z-ARAS method. In addition to assigning different weights to the three factors considering uncertainty and reliability in barriers is also considered in this approach through the theory of Z numbers. The proposed approach of current study was implemented in the evaluation of blockchain adoption barriers in humanitarian logistics. According to the results, the most critical barriers concern with integrating issues, risk of cyber-attacks, and technology risks. The results shown the capability and superiority of the proposed approach compared to other traditional methods such as FMEA and Fuzzy ARAS.
Nowadays, the development of science and technology parks and improving their performance depends on cooperation with industry and university and communication with the environment and related centers. Hence, it is important to identify cooperation network and networking indicators in science and technology parks. The purpose of this research is to identify the indicators of networking in science and technology parks. The method of the current research is qualitative and in it three methods of Meta- synthesis, Fuzzy Delphi and DEMATEL were used. A search was conducted in Persian and English databases and 10 related studies were identified and analyzed. In order to verify the networking indicators extracted from the theoretical literature, 13 experts and managers of Pardis Technology Park were surveyed and the indicators were confirmed by the experts using the Fuzzy Delphi method. In order to draw the causal model of the relationships between the indicators, DEMATEL method was used. The data was analyzed using Excel software. The results showed that networking in science and technology parks has 15 indicators, such as improving the level of products, information, increasing market share, goals and creating value. According to experts, the market share increase index is the first priority and organizational learning is the last. Drawing the causal model of networking showed that indicators such as management, organizational learning, information and knowledge are effective indicators. Indicators such as new product development, market opportunity creation, relationships and opportunity exploitation are also effective indicators in the networking of science and technology parks.
The convergence of information technology, media and communication has changed consumer behavior in terms of searching, obtaining, processing and responding to company information or services. A company's ability to plan, implement and manage digital marketing to increase its competitiveness in the eyes of consumers is called digital marketing capability. The purpose of this research is to design a model for improving marketing capabilities by emphasizing the indicators of using digital marketing in industrial companies. This research is a type of mixed research with a qualitative and quantitative approach, which is a survey study in terms of its purpose, application, and in terms of data collection. The statistical population of the research was managers and experts in the field of digital marketing of industrial companies and university professors who were selected using the snowball sampling method. In the qualitative part, the data collection tool was an interview, and in the quantitative part, a questionnaire was used to identify the categories, and a semi-structured interview was used, and a questionnaire was used to validate the model. In the qualitative part of the data analysis method, the Grounded theory approach was based on the Strauss and Corbin method, which was compiled using MAXQDA software and using the coding method, and in the quantitative part, the analysis method was based on Kendall's correlation test
The purpose of this research is to investigate the effective factors in predicting the academic performance of undergraduate students in the classification of four classes. To achieve this goal, the study follows the CRISP data mining method. The data set was extracted from the NAD educational system for the bachelor's degree in Shahed University for the entry of the years 2011 to 2021. 1468 records were used in data mining. First, the effective features on students' academic performance were extracted. Modeling was done using Rapidminer9.9 tool. To improve classification performance and satisfactory prediction accuracy, we use a combination of principal component analysis combined with machine learning algorithms and feature selection techniques and optimization algorithms. The performance of the prediction models is verified using 10-fold cross-validation. The results showed that the decision tree algorithm is the best algorithm in predicting students' performance with an accuracy of 84.71%. This algorithm correctly predicted the graduation of 77.88% of excellent students, 85.26% of good students, 84.69% of medium students, and 85.96% of weak students based on the final GPA.
Artificial intelligence provides unique opportunities to improve the performance of various industries, including the automotive industry. The present study seeks to identify the applications and requirements of using artificial intelligence in new automotive products such as self-driving cars by obtaining opinions from managers and employees of domestic automotive companies through semi-structured interviews and thematic analysis. The interviewees included 11 managers and 17 employees, of which 15 had a bachelor's degree, 11 had a master's degree, and 2 had a doctorate degree. 21 codes were identified in the applications section and 26 codes were identified in the requirements section. After conducting 28 interviews, theoretical saturation was achieved. From the codes identified in the applications section, self-driving cars and voice assistants, shared transportation, and resource allocation, expert staff, and team formation can be mentioned in the requirements section. Considering the variety of artificial intelligence applications in new car products and according to the specified requirements according to the opinions of experts, the development of a suitable platform for hard and soft technologies in an integrated manner; And government support regarding the creation of legal infrastructure can improve the development path of the current technology. Of course, in order to create a context for the successful operation of artificial intelligence in the automotive industry, all the effects of its application from different cultural and social aspects should be considered with a systematic perspective.
Abstract Today, with the increasing growth of the Internet and the rapid expansion of virtual space and its impressive features, including the increase in the speed of information exchange, easy and free access to information, the variety of topics, etc., people spend most of their time in cyberspace, especially in social networks are dedicated, in this regard, the opinions registered by users in virtual networks have grown day by day and become very important; Based on this, the aim of the current research is to analyze and review the opinions of Twitter users about virtual reality technology by using machine learning methods and a dictionary-based approach, which is advanced by collecting about 1 million tweets in the field of virtual reality technology by a web crawler. Data processing including the removal of stop words and links, de-wording was discussed, then Latent Dirichlet Allocation topic modeling was implemented on the data and the degree of semantic similarity between words and the distinction between topics was obtained by the coherence score and the number of topics that The one with the highest score was selected and the data were categorized into 9 topics. The Perplexity was used to evaluate the model, and its value was -9.44, which shows the effectiveness of the model. Then the situations related to virtual reality technology were named.
Considering that the users are the main focus of immersive journalism, any study in this field without understanding and recognizing them is incomplete. The quality of the VR news experience depends on many parameters, the most important of which are related to the cognitive and behavioral science of the users, apart from the technological factors that are prerequisites for making VR. In this regard, through interviews with experts in journalism and cognitive sciences, this research identified the categories that influence the depth of user’s immersion based on the Grounded Theory methodology and finally presented a conceptual model. The phenomenon of the model is “user involvement”. This category is affected by contextual factors such as "user’s demographic characteristics" and "type of news", as well as the intervening factors of "trauma" and "preventing factors of using virtual reality". In addition, the three categories of "cognition", "narrative" and "crafting pieces" provided the causal conditions that are the basis for the immersion in the news narrative. Finally, "focusing on user’s cognitive factors" in creating VR pieces is the interaction strategy that brought two consequences of "increasing immersion" and "changing norms and behaviors".
طی دهههای اخیر سهم اقتصاد دیجیتال از کل کیک اقتصاد جهان با شیب تندی افزایش یافته و اقتصاد از منبع محوری به داده محوری در حال گذار است. کسبوکارهای مبتنی بر فناوری اطلاعات، مهمترین بازیگران این عصر جدید اقتصاد هستند. هدف از انجام پژوهش حاضر، بررسی عوامل موثر بر توسعه این کسبوکارها و اعتبارسنجی یکی از مدلهای مفهومی موجود در ادبیات است. تحقیق از نظر هدف کاربردی بوده و در زمره پژوهشهای توصیفی پیمایشی قرار میگیرد. در این پژوهش، یافتههای مدل منتخب به همراه چند شاخص دیگر که از مطالعات سایر پژوهشگران استخراج شده در قالب یک پرسشنامه پیادهسازی شده و به صورت الکترونیکی در جامعهای متشکل از سه گروه مختلف از فعالان این صنعت توزیع شده است. دادههای دریافت شده از 232 پرسشنامه تکمیل شده با استفاده از روش تحلیل عاملی تاییدی و مدلیابی معادلات ساختاری مورد تجزیه و تحلیل قرار گرفته، یافتهها در قالب یک مدل نهایی ارایه گردیده است. نتایج این پژوهش نشان میدهد که توسعه اقتصاد دیجیتال مستلزم توانمندسازی بنگاههای هوشمند و توجه همزمان به عوامل محیطی است. همچنین، عوامل سیاستی و نقش دولت در توسعه این کسبوکارها بسیار کلیدی بوده، سایر عوامل با اثرپذیری از سیاستهای دولت در توسعه این شرکتها ایجاد اثر میکنند. یافتههای این پژوهش میتواند در سیاستگذاری توسعه اقتصاد دیجیتال در کشور و جهتدهی به حمایتهای حاکمیت از کسبروکارهای این حوزه موثر باشد.
شبکههای اجتماعی، مشارکت مشتری آنلاین صنعت بازاریابی را تسهیل کردهاند. این پژوهش درصدد بررسی مشارکت مشتری در صفحات برندهای لوازمآرایشی ایرانی اینستاگرام است. این تحقیق با بهرهگیری از روش تحلیل محتوای کمی صورت گرفته است. جمعیت آماری پژوهش تمام برندهای آرایشی موجود بود که پنج برند مطرح (مای، کالیستا، اینلی، سینره و آموتیا) بهعنوان نمونه برگزیده شد و با روش نمونهگیری غیراحتمالی هدفمند از هر صفحه برند 60 پست مورد تحلیل قرار گرفت. نتایج حاکی از آن است که بین نوع محتوای پستها (انگیزشی، تبلیغاتی، اطلاعاتی و سرگرمی) و مشارکت مشتری (لایکها و نظرات) رابطه مثبت و معناداری وجود دارد. همچنین بین محتوا و تعامل و لحن منفی با مشارکت بیشتر رابطه معناداری وجود ندارد. همچنین بین وضوح پستها و لحن مثبت نیز فرضیه تا حدی تأیید شد و حاکی از تأثیرگذاری جزئی آن بر مشارکت مشتری است. تحلیل رگرسیون چندگانه برای تعداد لایک و نظرات در پستها نشان میدهد که واریانس کل مدل و ضریب تعیین، برای این دو به ترتیب 668/0% با مقدار 372/15 F= و 001/0 p< و 410/0% با مقدار 590/7F= 001/0 p< است و نشان از معنیدار بودن آن دارد. ضریب تعیین تعدیلشده نشان میدهد که 5/66 درصد تغییرات متغیر وابسته (لایکها) و 6/40 تغییرات نظرات حاصل تأثیر متغیرهای مستقل تحقیق است.
IntroductionAugmented reality has emerged as one of the main trends in the digital market in recent years (Whang et al, 2021). Augmented reality technologies, such as 3D spatialization mechanisms and sound adaptation mechanisms, eliminate distance barriers to information acquisition, add more enjoyable and entertaining components to the visit, and increase visitor immersion in exhibitions (Huang, 2021).As consumers' use of mobile augmented reality applications increases, it is necessary to strengthen theoretical and empirical insights to support this technology and understand its effects on consumer behaviors (McLean, & Wilson, 2019). Despite the rapid growth and increasing importance of augmented reality, recent research shows that managers lack insight into how augmented reality interacts with customers and need guidance to target customers who have adopted augmented reality (Jessen et al, 2020). A comprehensive review of cognitive, emotional, and behavioral responses in augmented reality shows that various studies have focused on benefits such as enjoyment and usefulness (Whang et al, 2021; Hilken et al, 2017). While things like the feeling of virtual presence, perceived value, attitude towards augmented reality, satisfaction, and experiential value have been paid less attention to (Kowalczuk et al, 2021; Nikhashemi et al, 2021). In order to answer the aforementioned research gap, the present research is trying to answer the following main question:How does a mobile-based augmented reality application affect the decision-making process in the real shopping experience?Literature ReviewMarketers are using mobile augmented reality apps to connect with their consumers in new and exciting ways. From a marketing research perspective, augmented reality is a strategic concept that integrates information or digital objects into the subject's perception of the physical world, often in combination with other media, to express or demonstrate consumer interests to achieve obvious organizational goals (Rauschnabel et al., 2019).Researches show that augmented reality enhances the consumer experience and drives their behavioral intentions Fan, et al, 2020; Kowalczuk et al., 2021; Nikhashemi et al., 2021). The research results of Whang et al. (2021) confirmed that the capabilities of mobile augmented reality technology evoke consumer behavioral and cognitive states, which in turn stimulate consumer purchase intention. However, their study did not consider the intention of continuous use of augmented reality, which is a major issue in this field. Because recent industry statistics show that about a quarter of augmented reality apps are never used after the initial download (Nikhashemi et al, 2021).In addition, purchase intention focuses on the extent to which consumers attempt to make a purchase after interacting with mobile augmented reality applications, while continued use intention emphasizes the extent to which consumers will use mobile augmented reality applications in the future (Lo et al, 2020). Tsai & Hung, 2019). Hence, it is critical to address the importance of augmented reality as a strategy to enhance consumer engagement and its responsive effects on purchase intention.MethodologyBased on the purpose, this research is applied, in terms of the type of data, it is quantitative, and in terms of data collection, it is descriptive and survey type. The statistical population was the customers of the Digikala online store, whose number was estimated to be more than 3000 people. With the available sampling method, 384 people were selected as a sample, and a researcher-made questionnaire (based on the Likert scale) was sent to them as an electronic link. 307 usable questionnaires were returned. Structural equation modeling with partial least squares approach was used for data analysis and hypothesis testing.ResultsThe data analysis showed that the factor loading value between the components of a variable and the latent variable is more than 0.4, which indicates that the components of this variable have been able to evaluate the latent variable well. Also, the significance of the factor load of each of the variables of the verification model is more than 1.96 and it is significant.Discussion and ConclusionThe current research was conducted with the aim of investigating the role of mobile augmented reality programs on continuous use and purchase intention by consumers among users of the Digikala store. The results of the research showed that virtual presence, experiential value, and purchase benefits have a positive effect on the attitude towards the mobile augmented reality program. In this regard, it can be said that the mobile augmented reality program produces and provides the content to the consumer that is more attractive to the user than ever before (Qin et al, 2021). The more customers engage with the content, the more likely they are to make the expected brand reaction (Park & Yoo, 2020). Also, perceived value and attitude towards the use of mobile augmented reality have a positive effect on consumer satisfaction. It can be claimed that mobile augmented reality allows users to see information related to customer service of various goods and products on any type of display around. Therefore, the more appropriate and up-to-date the quality of the designed system is, it leads to more people being interested and also more people using this technology and encouraging them to buy, and it leads to an increase in their satisfaction (Mclean et al, 2018; Oni et al. al, 2016; Chopdar & Balakrishnan, 2020). Based on the results of the research, satisfaction and perceived value have a positive effect on the intention to continue using and the intention to purchase. As the mobile augmented reality app enhances the shopping experience with the light and sound effects of a 3D movie, it allows stores and malls to transport their customers into a world of their own creation, combining elements of traditional online shopping with 3D experiences for Combine increased satisfaction and more accurate customer purchases (Chang et al, 2018; Chopdar & Balakrishnan, 2020).
