• 学术搜索
  • 科研智能体
    • Research Labs
    • AI 阅读
    • AI 文库
    • 深度研究
    • 学者亮点
  • 学术资源
    • AI2000
    • 期刊/会议
    • 学者库
    • 学术API
      MCP&Skill
    • 溯源树
    • 数据集
  • 知识沉淀
    • 学术空间
订阅小程序
旧版功能
aminer vip
开通会员低至0.73元/天
一次搞定AI科研
立即登录
  • English
  • 联系方式
    Cumhuriyet Ilahiyat Dergisi-Cumhuriyet Theology Journal

    Cumhuriyet Ilahiyat Dergisi-Cumhuriyet Theology Journal

    JournalISSN 2528-9861eISSN 2528-987X中科院 哲学 4区

    年发文量

    研究主题

    论文(1726)

    排序
    1The Theory of Demonstration (burhān) in Ibn Al-Mutahhar Al-Hillī
    Ersan Turkmen, Adem Evmes

    This article examines the theory of demonstration (burh & amacr;n) developed by Ibn al-Mutahhar al-Hills, a multifaceted thinker who lived in the 13th century. Employing an analytical method, this article aims to provide a comprehensive understanding of Ibn al-Mutahhar's theory of demonstration, which has not yet been scientifically studied in Turkish. Primarily known as a Shi'i theologian and methodist, al-Hills authored numerous works in various disciplines. Some of these works dealt with religious problems, while others focused on rational issues. Living after figures like Fakhr al-Dsn al-R & amacr;zs and Nassr al-Dsn al-T & umacr;ss, who are considered representatives of the philosophical theology (al-kal & amacr;m alfalsafs), al-Hills is particularly recognized as a thinker closely associated with al-T & umacr;ss in terms of his ideas and doctrine. In his works dealing with rational sciences, al-Hills focused particularly on the ontological problems of philosophical theology, especially those referred to as um & umacr;r `& amacr;mma. However, he also centered his works on the issue of method and methodology, a fundamental problem of philosophical theology. Therefore, in many of his works, al-Hills discussed the problem of knowledge and attempted to systematically ground his thoughts on this subject. In this context, one of the most important topics he addressed in detail was the problems of logic. Al-Hills wrote two types of works on logic: The first are commentaries, examples of which include al-Jawhar al-Nadsd fs Sharh al-Tajrsd and al-Qaw & amacr;`id al-Jaliyyah fs Sharh al-Ris & amacr;lah al-Shamsiyyah. The second type are original works. His work, al-Asr & amacr;r al-Khafiyyah fs `Ul & umacr;m al-`Aqliyyah, serves as an example for this group. In these works, the thinker particularly focuses on Peripatetic logic and attempts to explain the foundation of his own thought system. Essentially, al-Hills considers logic within the context of the knowledge acquisition process. Initially existing without knowledge, humans begin to acquire information primarily through their sensory faculties. However, these faculties are insufficient for distinguishing truth from falsehood. Therefore, to perform the process of verification and falsification, they are forced to resort to another method or tool. According to al-Hills, the tool that performs this process is nothing other than logic. In some of his works, the thinker refers to logic as a tool, defining it as "a tool that protects the mind from error in thought/idea, as long as it is adhered to." It is possible to say that this definition, which he includes in his works, was known before him. Although he includes this definition in his works, he criticizes some concepts contained in the definition of logic. The most important concept he criticizes is the term "instrument". Al-Hills believes that logic is not an instrument but an independent science by stating that logic is an independent science, Al-Hills argues that the desired outcome of this science is proof (burh & amacr;n). Proof consists of premises whose truth must be accepted as necessary. Agreeing with most logicians, Al-Hills identifies six types of demonstrative premises: self-evident (awwaliyy & amacr;t), observation (mush & amacr;had & amacr;t), empirical (mujarrab & amacr;t), intuition (hadsiyy & amacr;t), widely transmitted (mutaw & amacr;tir & amacr;t), and natural syllogisms (fitrs qiy & amacr;s & amacr;t). However, he particularly criticized other Peripatetic logicians from various perspectives regarding self-evident and widel A similar critical stance can be seen in some issues of syllogism. In fact, al-Hills's critical approach in these matters forms a whole with his other philosophical tendencies. Indeed, he largely built his thought system on intellectual and religious matters upon the approach he demonstrated in matters of logic.

    2026
    引用
    AI阅读
    加入学术空间
    2Perception of Nawābit in Mu'tazilite Kalām: A Theological Analysis and Its Philosophical Implications
    Mikail Ipek

    This article examines the semantic content, historical deveoplent, and shifts in meaning of the concept of naw & amacr;bit within Mu`tazili kal & amacr;m, addressing its doctrinal (i`tiq & amacr;di), social (ijtim & amacr;`i), and political dimensions. The scope of the study is limited to identifying the various meanings attributed to the term by scholars who engaged with the concept of naw & amacr;bit in Mu`tazili thought, as well as analyzing the semantic transformations the term underwent over time. In this regard, particular attention is devoted to the views of prominent theologians such as al-J & amacr;hiz, al-Khayy & amacr;t, and al-Zamakhshari, who employed the concept in a pronounced manner. The study aims to demonstrate that the discourse of naw & amacr;bit was not merely utilized as a label of denigration and disparagement; rather, it also functioned as an instrument of exclusion and defense through which different intellectual schools delineated their epistemic boundaries, articulated their perceptions of social order, and constructed claims to legitimacy. In this respect, the article highlights the often-overlooked role of conceptual labels and polemical designations in shaping power relations and processes of knowledge production within the fields of kal & amacr;m and the secterian historiography. As a products of the systems they construct, sectarian formations seek both to establish epistemic authority through the production of knowledge in the field of kal & amacr;m and to generate sociopolitical spheres of power through their relations with political authority and society. Within this framework, the concept of naw & amacr;bit emerges as an expression of the need to define the correct by first identifying and excluding the incorrect. The first chapter of the study offers an etymological analysis of the term naw & amacr;bit, constructing its metaphorical semantic field through the distinction between n & amacr;bita and nab & amacr;t. This analysis suggests that the term naw & amacr;bit was employed to designate individuals or groups who neglect reason in matters of belief, interpret religious texts in a rigidly literalist manner, and are perceived as lacking epistemic competence. Al-J & amacr;hiz employs the term naw & amacr;bit to describe those who sought to legitimize the injustice, abuses, and erroneous practices of the Umayyad political authority; who adopted a determinist (jabri) understanding of predestination; and who advanced anthropomorphic (tajsim) and assimilationist (tashbih) views through literalist readings of scriptural texts. Later Mu`tazili theologians such as al-Khayy & amacr;t and al-Zamakhshari preserved the core meaning of the term while simultaneously expanding its semantic scope. In the course of this development, the concept underwent significant semantic shifts. Indeed, following al-J & amacr;hiz, the term came to signify not a specific sect, but rather epistemic degeneration within sectarian structures, scholarly inadequacy, polemical excess, and tendencies toward marginalization. Among Islamic philosophers, alF & amacr;r & amacr;bi employs the concept of naw & amacr;bit to characterize the vicious elements within the virtuous city, whereas Ibn B & amacr;jja uses the same term to refer to the virtuous individuals within a corrupt society. By contrast, certain scholars associated with Ahl al-Hadith, such as Ibn Qutayba and Ibn Abi Ya`l & amacr;, employed the term to describe Ahl al-Ra'y and other groups critical of their positions. Methodologically, the study adopts a textcentered reading alongside a historical-conceptual analytical approach.

    2026
    引用
    AI阅读
    加入学术空间
    3Shiblī Nu'mānī's Defense Strategy Against Orientalist Criticism
    Erkan Bulut

    This article examines the methodological approach and response strategy developed by Shibli Nu`m & acirc;n & icirc; (1857-1914), who was raised in India in the 19th century and is considered one of the pioneers of the New Ilm-i Kel & acirc;m, in response to Orientalists' claims about Islam. During that century, the Western world established clear superiority over the Islamic world in science, politics, technology, military affairs, industry, economics, culture, and thought. This superiority extended beyond technological progress and reforms in the Islamic world. The works and discourse of Orientalists on the Islamic religion and history have raised doubts and hesitations in the minds of Muslims. Their criticisms of Islam have often been shaped by a framework of biased, reductionist, and distorted discourse. Through this discourse, attempts have been made to consciously devalue Islam's historical, social, political, and cultural heritage. The Orientalists' approach has triggered an intellectual process that has led Muslim intellectuals not only to develop defensive reflexes but also to reconstruct Islamic thought methodologically and conceptually. During this period, Muslim scholars emerged who took on the responsibility of responding to Orientalist criticism using their own scientific methods. One of these scholars was the Indian Islamic scholar Shibli Nu`m & amacr;n & imacr;. He distinguished himself as one of the Islamic thinkers who systematically reflected on the new issue of ilm-i kal & amacr;m. Faced with Westerncentered intellectual challenges, like many Muslim scholars, he regarded the renewal of kal & amacr;m science in the Indian subcontinent as an intellectual and ideological responsibility; he waged a comprehensive scholarly struggle against criticism and attacks directed at Islam and the Prophet Muhammad. In this context, Shibli closely examined Orientalist literature and sought to respond to the claims advanced in these works with his own methods and arguments. The method developed by Shibli went beyond the classical defensive understanding of kalam, centered on elements such as the relationship between reason and tradition, historical context, and critical thinking. In this way, while aiming to write refutations using scientific methods on the one hand, he also clarified the historical reality and universal messages of Islamic civilization on the other. Thus, he developed a methodological defense based on the modern scientific methods used by Orientalists. The article examines the method adopted by Shibli Nu`m & acirc;n & icirc;, discusses his intellectual legacy and its impact on modern Islamic thought, and emphasizes the dynamism of Islamic thought in the face of modern challenges. The study uses systematic analysis and evaluation methods, along with a literature review. The Arabic and Turkish translations of Shibli Nu`m & acirc;n & icirc;'s works were used as primary sources, and Turkish and Arabic articles written about him were also used as much as possible.

    2026
    引用
    AI阅读
    加入学术空间
    4Methods of Criminal Proof in the Qur'anic Text an Analytical Study of Circumstantial Evidence (context/indications) in Surat Yusuf
    Medhet Korichi

    This study examines the Qur'anic methodology for establishing criminal liability and rebutting accusations through an analysis of the use of circumstantial evidence (qara'in) in Surat Yusuf. Such evidence does not prove the disputed event or alleged offense in a direct and explicit manner; rather, it enables the inference of the underlying reality through a set of external indicators, conditions, and contextual elements that are coherent and mutually reinforcing . The study aims to explore the rational, logical, and argumentative structure underpinning the Qur'anic discourse in processes of proving crimes or dismissing allegations. It does so by focusing on three principal incidents narrated in Surat Yusuf: the enforced disappearance to which Prophet Joseph (Yusuf) was subjected; the alleged incident of sexual misconduct in which both parties-Joseph (Yusuf) and the wife of al-'Az & imacr;z (commonly identified as Zulaykha)-were implicated; and the accusation of theft directed at Benjamin. Against this backdrop, the research is motivated by the need to understand how the Qur'an, particularly in Surat Yusuf, deploys circumstantial evidence and to what extent such evidence is regarded as a valid basis for rebutting accusations, dispelling doubts, or establishing culpability. Accordingly, the study seeks to address the following central question: To what extent does the Qur'anic discourse, as reflected in Surat Yusuf, recognize circumstantial evidence as a legitimate means of proving criminal liability or removing suspicion? The findings indicate that the Qur'an operates through an integrated network of interrelated evidentiary indicators-such as the presence of prior motive, patterns of subsequent conduct (for instance, the absence of denial), and material evidence (such as Joseph's shirt)-to construct a reasoned judgment that reaches a high degree of certainty. This process does not necessarily depend on the availability of direct, conclusive proof. Methodologically, the study adopts a descriptive-analytical approach. Relevant narrative passages in Surat Yusuf that involve elements of alleged wrongdoing are examined in detail; the relationship between circumstantial indicators and the narrated facts is analyzed; and the results are comparatively assessed in light of contemporary scholarship in Islamic legal theory and modern legal studies. The study concludes that the Qur'anic approach to circumstantial evidence is characterized by precision, depth, and objectivity. Judgment is not grounded in a single, isolated indicator-regardless of its apparent strength-but rather in a constellation of mutually corroborating and coherent evidentiary elements. In this respect, the Qur'anic model of reasoning constitutes a robust and reliable means of proof, one that, in its underlying principles, converges with key tenets of contemporary judicial systems.

    2026
    引用
    AI阅读
    加入学术空间
    5Dark Pattern Practices in E-Commerce: an Assessment from the Perspectives of Positive Turkish Law and Islamic Law
    Recep Bagbanci

    With the rapid expansion of digital technologies, commercial activities have increasingly shifted to online environments, giving rise to various subtle and often invisible manipulation techniques commonly referred to as dark patterns. Dark patterns are interface design strategies that intentionally steer, pressure, or mislead users into making decisions they would not otherwise choose under conditions of full information and genuine freedom of choice. These practices are particularly prevalent in e-commerce platforms, subscription-based services, and digital advertising, where consumers' decision-making processes are influenced through design rather than explicit persuasion. This study examines dark patterns from a comparative legal perspective, focusing on Turkish positive law and Islamic law. The main argument of the article is that although dark patterns are a contemporary and technologically mediated concept, their underlying logic-the manipulation of consent and distortion of informed choice-closely corresponds to legal and ethical concerns long addressed in both legal traditions. From the perspective of Turkish law, dark patterns are not regulated as a distinct legal concept. Nevertheless, they fall within the scope of consumer protection rules, particularly under the Law on the Protection of Consumers No. 6502 and the Regulation on Commercial Advertising and Unfair Commercial Practices. These instruments prohibit practices that significantly distort, or are likely to distort, the economic behaviour of consumers. Within this framework, dark patterns generally appear as misleading actions, misleading omissions, or aggressive commercial practices. Decisions of the Advertising Board further demonstrate that interface-based manipulations, such as hidden costs, artificial urgency, or misleading presentation of contractual conditions, may constitute unlawful commercial practices. From the perspective of Islamic law, the concept of dark pattern-a modern concept-overlaps in terms of content and purpose with many prohibited acts discussed in classical fiqh literature. In this study, the relationship between dark patterns and Islamic law is analysed through the concepts of taghrir (misleading inducement), tadlis (concealment of defects or deceptive presentation), ghabn (manifest imbalance in consideration), and najash (artificial manipulation of demand or price perception). These doctrines share a common normative foundation: the prohibition of conduct that distorts the will of the other party through deception, concealment, or manipulation. Islamic law places particular emphasis on transparency, honesty, and fairness in commercial transactions. Accordingly, practices that obscure essential information, exaggerate scarcity or popularity, or create false impressions regarding price or value are regarded as violations of both legal and ethical norms. The study concludes that Turkish law and Islamic law converge in their objective of protecting consumers, although they differ in their conceptual frameworks and methods. Turkish law adopts a regulatory and result-oriented approach focusing on the effects of practices on consumer behaviour, whereas Islamic law integrates legal rules with moral accountability by emphasising intention, honesty, and the preservation of trust in market relations. The study also demonstrates that deceptive commercial practices may be evaluated not only from the perspective of private law but also in terms of sanctions, and that such practices can be addressed under the concept of ta'z & imacr;r in Islamic law.

    2026
    引用
    AI阅读
    加入学术空间
    立即登录,查看全部 1726 篇论文

    高被引作者

    作者引用发文
    Bayram Ali Cetinkaya18512
    Enbiya Yildirim16113
    Ünal Kiliç11411
    Kadir Ozkose9420
    M. Kazim Arican9413
    Ali Akpinar935
    Ismail Caliskan9318
    Ali Aksu9311
    Cemal Ağirman936
    Alim Yildiz7112

    高产作者

    作者引用发文
    Abdullah Demir1427
    Kadir Ozkose9420
    Ismail Caliskan9318
    Saban Erdic5616
    M. Kazim Arican9413
    Enbiya Yildirim16113
    Alim Yildiz7112
    Bayram Ali Cetinkaya18512
    Ünal Kiliç11411
    Ali Aksu9311

    相关期刊

    Cumhuriyet Ilahiyat Dergisi
    Al-Tahrir
    Bilimname: Düşünce Platformu
    Mütefekkir
    Journal of Divinity, Faculty of Hitit University
    DinBILIMLERI AKADEMIK ARASTIRMA DERGISI-JOURNAL of ACADEMIC RESEARCH in RELIGIOUS SCIENCES
    ILAHIYAT TETKIKLERI DERGISI-JOURNAL of ILAHIYAT RESEARCHES
    SAKARYA UNIVERSITESI ILAHIYAT FAKULTESI DERGISI-JOURNAL of SAKARYA UNIVERSITY FACULTY of THEOLOGY
    Journal of Islamic Thought and Civilization
    Darulfunun Ilahiyat