
There have been several moving obituaries following Michael Burawoy’s sad death in a hit-and-run accident early this year, many charting his contribution to sociological research and Marxist theorizing from the early 1970s onwards. This piece has a narrower focus. It concentrates on the ethnographic research Burawoy conducted for his Ph.D., and the resulting case-study monograph, Manufacturing Consent , which established his reputation as a radical sociologist of the workplace and as a Marxist theorist of both the consolidation and vulnerabilities of modern capitalism. The article examines the key features of Burawoy’s case-study analysis of the manufacture of consent and summarizes some of the strengths and weaknesses identified in both enthusiastic and critical responses to his influential work. It then discusses some of the leading themes that emerged from this debate, and especially from Burawoy’s auto-critique, which he pursued over the decades. His death has robbed us of a voice that would have continued to illuminate significant changes in the organization of work and the social relations of production across the globe. It falls to us to draw on the critical insights and analytical resources that Burawoy bequeathed to do justice to his intellectual legacy.
Neoliberalism has in some senses evolved into a sub-discipline of its own. A series of academic texts have emerged looking beyond the fetishizing of market relations and emergent political dominance to locate neoliberalism in a historical context. Some of the discussions locate pivotal moments of change such as the 1980s and the emergence of the New Right; others look back to trace the dominance of market relations, institutionally visible for some time beyond the writing of key figures such as Friedrich Hayek. This review essay focuses on two texts – Quinn Slobodian, Globalists: The End of Empire and the Birth of Neoliberalism (2018) and Nathalie Lévy et al ., The Anglo-American Model of Neoliberalism of the 1980s (2022) – both of which demonstrate the importance of historical analysis and sensitivity. Slobodian considers how neoliberal thought became central to state institutions and an international order long before the periods we normally scan historically as social and political observers. Lévy et al . focus on the construction and dissemination of neoliberalism in various national contexts nearly half a century ago and the attempts to ensure its dominance since then.
The first half of the nineteenth century witnessed exceptional social turbulence in Britain, not least rapid industrialization and squalid urbanization. Against this background emerged a genre of English literature – the ‘condition-of-England’ novel – whose authors drew the attention of the privileged classes to the living and working conditions of the urban poor, and suggested ways to improve them. These authors were sympathetic to the plight of the working classes but were at the same time invariably hostile towards the activity of trade unions, the very organizations that workers formed to help themselves. This article examines two questions. First, why were these authors so hostile to the collective action of the working classes, and why did that hostility begin to dissolve by the early 1850s? And second, what does analysis of these novels reveal about the evolving nature of the alternative solutions they proposed to resolve working-class poverty? By tracing an arc of development in authors’ attitudes over the period c.1830–1855 – from a focus on working-class education to reform of legislation on working time and conciliation between the classes – it tracks the gradual emergence of an innovative ‘sociological imagination’ in the later novels.
In introducing his new book, A Concise Introduction to Employment Relations (Elger: 2005), Richard Hyman notes that if anyone were inventing the subject today, they would not think of calling it industrial relations, which does tend to imply manufacturing industry, whereas the world of work today primarily involves very different forms of productive activity, including much external to the boundaries of the contract of employment and large organizations. Offering a critical discussion of Polanyi is one of the themes Hyman uses to analyse the landscape of contemporary work, the sustained assault on workers living standards and collective organizations, and the possibilities for a counter-mobilization by workers to confront the challenges of Covid-19 and its aftermath, international politics and European war, and climate politics and the green transition.