
Prior studies indicate that there are two main channels used by multinational enterprises (MNEs) to shift profits from high-tax countries to low-tax countries: transfer pricing and debt financing. This study investigates profit shifting through these channels in Indonesia using Indonesian tax return data. The performances of foreign-owned Indonesian companies (FOICs), which are Indonesian affiliates of foreign MNEs, and domestic-owned Indonesian companies (DOICs) are compared in terms of earnings before interest and taxes scaled by total sales, and long-term debt to related parties scaled by total assets, in order to capture profit shifting using the transfer pricing and debt financing channels respectively. Propensity score matching and coarsened exact matching are used to match FOICs as the treatment group and DOICs as the control group. The results show that FOICs use both transfer pricing and debt financing to shift profits out of Indonesia.
This paper provides a perspective on the phenomenon of tax exceptionalism in New Zealand administrative law. Tax exceptionalism is broadly defined as the perception that tax law is so different or special when compared to other areas of law that relevant developments in other areas of the law are not applied or applied inconsistently. However, there has not yet, to our knowledge, been any investigation into tax exceptionalism in New Zealand. This article aims to fill this gap. First, it argues that tax exceptionalism is evident in the New Zealand Supreme Court's judicial review judgment in Tannadyce v Commissioner of Inland Revenue (Tannadyce)4 and, in particular, the Supreme Court's approach to privative clauses. It then argues that New Zealand's particular brand of tax exceptionalism represents a concerning departure from its constitutional norms and this cannot be justified by public policy. In doing so, the article not only sheds light on something that has not received attention in New Zealand, but further contributes to the broader international understanding of the phenomenon while recognising that the precise manifestation of the phenomenon is a reflection of the particular environment in which it occurs.
The higher-level government's degree of control over the subnational government administration is frequently a topic for discussion among academics and policymakers. Generally, local taxes are designed poorly and in a presumptive way, and "administered with low coverage rates, arbitrary assessments, and large delinquent lists" (Bird, 2015, p. 18). Increases in incidences of tax evasion and compliance costs are important arguments against the local administration of taxes. Recent theoretical and empirical studies argue for the existence of self-governing local governments, which requires an efficient local tax system to be in place. Using panchayat-level and municipal-level data, this paper investigates the efficiency of the local tax administration in Kerala, a state in India, and tries to estimate the amount of revenue that would be generated if the system were to be rationalised. It also addresses the question of whether local tax administration needs to be re-examined.
Media representation of tax practices is important because of the impact of public opinion on tax policy. Traditionally viewed as a technical subject and the preserve of professionals, taxation has recently become the focus of widespread and more informed public attention, as a result of, inter alia, tax scandals and the financial crisis. These events, together with wider international tax reform initiatives, provide researchers with an opportunity to explore the impact of tax reform on discourse by the public, as well as by tax experts and professionals. To this end, we analyse the changing treatment of tax-related issues in the mainstream and professional media in Ireland and the United Kingdom (UK) in order to capture expert voices, as well as public discourse. We do so in the immediate and medium-term aftermath of the financial crisis. Our analysis of tax discourse in general, and of the public framing of the term "tax avoidance" in particular, in both Ireland and the UK, reveals that a marked change has occurred in the public discourse in Ireland, a country struggling in the aftermath of a severe financial crisis. In contrast, our research finds that there is greater consistency in the UK's mainstream and professional media. Our findings also indicate that expert voices may lag behind public opinion.
In this article, the author seeks to establish a functioning, non-context-specific definition of an "unequal treaty" that takes into account underlying principles of state equality, the concept of treaties, and non-coercion, whilst sitting outside of any single historical moment, by reference to international customary law, the United Nations (UNs)' resolutions of the General Assembly, and normative or moral concepts of coercion. Having established a definition, the author goes on to apply that definition to a number of developments and provisions that were put in place in the last decade, such as the Foreign Account Tax Compliance Act (FATCA), the Common Reporting Standard (CRS) and the outflows of the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD)'s Base Erosion and Profit Shifting (BEPS) project, setting these provisions within their political and procedural contexts so as to place them within the historical tradition of treaties between large and small powers. By applying this definition, the author concludes that some, but not all, of the recent tax-related provisions amount to "unequal treaties". In establishing a methodology with which to assess the inequality of treaties and applying that to the current tax relevant provisions, the author hopes to allow an informed discussion based not only on the objectives of large powers but also on an assessment of the characteristics of the methods by which the community of developed nations, as represented by the OECD, achieves its goals in the tax context.