This study presents physics-based, 3D simulations using the EQSIM framework for several earthquakes in the Los Angeles region. The primary objective was to assess the ability of deterministic physics-based ground motion simulations to reproduce the observed motions from historical events. The selected events included the 5.4 2008 Chino Hills, the 4.4 2024 Highland Park, and the 4.3 2021 Carson events. The simulated motions were evaluated by comparing the recorded and simulated seismograms, as well as the Fourier amplitude spectra, across multiple seismic stations. The SCEC 3D velocity model, CVM-S4.26.M01, was used to represent the regional geology, and ground motion simulations were carried out with a resolution of up to 5 Hz. The results indicate that the simulated motions captured the recorded motions up to approximately 4 Hz. While careful iterations regarding source parameters and corner frequencies were required, and, for the case of the Highland Park event, some of the near-source stations had relatively low accuracy, the present study established a positive step toward the utilization of physics-based simulations in practical applications. The computational efficiencies exhibited by EQSIM, especially on GPU clusters, further supported this assertion, as wall-clock times of simulations involving more than 10 billion grid points were as low as minutes. This permits ensemble simulations for a considered scenario event so that modeling uncertainties (e.g., source and geology) can be bracketed.
With the recent increases in measured ground motion records for large earthquakes, most notably the 2023 M7.8 Pazarcik earthquake in T & uuml;rkiye, the potential for pervasive high velocity fault rupture propagation over an extensive fault length has been observed. This shallow strike-slip event, with unprecedented near-fault strong motion instrumentation throughout a large segment of the fault rupture zone, exhibited intense fault-normal directivity pulses and fault-parallel fling step for over two hundred kilometers along the fault. Observations of near-shear (fault rupture velocity approaching the shear wave velocity) and supershear (fault rupture velocity exceeding the shear wave velocity) ruptures in recent major earthquakes, and the associated potential for highly damaging ground motions, motivate the need for deeper understanding of the relationship between high velocity ruptures and seismic risk to infrastructure systems. In this article, recent developments in high performance, regional-scale fault-to-structure simulations are applied to provide additional insight into how high velocity ruptures can impact ground motions and the demands on building structures. First, the characteristic nonlinear response of buildings to observed intense near-fault motions from the T & uuml;rkiye event are assessed, and second, fault-to-structure simulations are performed for M7 strike-slip events on the Hayward fault in the San Francisco Bay region for varying fault rupture velocities. These simulations illustrate the pronounced influence of fault rupture velocity and quantify the significant increase in regional seismic demand on structures for near-shear and supershear scenarios.
The Wasatch Front Community Velocity Model (WFCVM) is the most complete and detailed Earth model for the Wasatch Front region in north-central Utah (USA). Until recently, it had not been well evaluated with strong ground motion observations due to a lack of local earthquakes with magnitude M5+. The 2020 March 18 M-w 5.7 Magna, Utah, earthquake generated excellent strong ground motion data at dozens of stations along the Wasatch Front, with peak ground accelerations up to 0.54 g. Here, we use the forward finite-difference code SW4 to simulate waveforms of the 2020 Magna mainshock in the WFCVM up to 3 Hz and compare its predictions to observations from 35 nearby stations at epicentral distances of 4-46 km. We use a finite fault source model with a semistochastic slip distribution and overlay stochastic velocity perturbations (S) and surface topography (T) on the WFCVM, which we refer to as the 3D+S+T model. Observed-predicted amplitude ratios and Goodness-of-Fit (GOF) scores for peak ground acceleration, velocity, displacement, Arias intensity and duration, cumulative energy and duration are calculated. Our 3D+S+T model performed fairly, matching the general character of the observations with an average GOF score of 5.20 (out of a maximum of 10), slightly better than the unaltered WFCVM score (GOF = 4.97). Stochastic velocity perturbations mostly affect peak ground motions at the closest sites (<20 km), while surface topography improves durations for basin sites and generates more realistic signals at higher frequencies. Neither addition resolves underprediction of basin amplification in the eastern Salt Lake Basin and overprediction of ground motion at basin-edge sites, which likely reflect inaccurate representations of basin structure in the WFCVM. Based on these results, we recommend including stochastic velocity perturbations and topography in future simulations but conclude that updating deterministic models of basin structure will lead to the biggest improvement in forecasting ground motion for future large (M6.75+) earthquakes in the Wasatch Front region.
Discriminating low-yield underground nuclear explosions from small earthquakes is a key task in monitoring nuclear test ban treaties. P/S amplitude ratios have been an effective discriminant for moderate-sized events recorded at regional distances, but it is unclear if they are as effective in discriminating small seismic events recorded at local distances (<150 km). The difference between local magnitude (ML) and coda duration magnitude (Mc) has been proposed as a new discriminant that may complement P/S amplitude ratios at local distances. Here, we calculate high-frequency (up to ∼4 Hz) synthetic seismograms at epicentral distances of 0–30 km in realistic models of the Salt Lake basin (Utah, United States) to better understand how variations in source type and depth affect ML−Mc values. The Earth models incorporate simplified 1D and deterministic 3D structures, small-wavelength stochastic velocity perturbations, and surface topography. Coda waves are enhanced for the more complicated models compared to the base 1D model, but still underpredict observed durations by about a factor of two, which results in overprediction of amplitude to duration ratios (i.e., ML−Mc values) for a near-surface explosion and a 7 km deep earthquake. For both source types, the predicted ML and Mc values decrease as source depth increases, and ML−Mc shows only minor variation with depth; however, ML−Mc is on average ∼0.5 units smaller for explosions than earthquakes. This finding may imply that ML−Mc has sensitivity to source type, in addition to being a depth discriminant, but more modeling is needed given the limitations of the current study. Future modeling should incorporate higher-frequency (≳5 Hz) simulations over a larger distance range (0–150 km), where ML and Mc are commonly measured, while honoring low shear velocities (<300 m/s) near the surface and sampling a wider range of earthquake and explosion source mechanisms.
The effects of the co-seismic static offset (known as fling step) and associated velocity pulses on civil structures have been difficult to study because the static offset is typically removed during the processing of earthquake ground motion records. Simulated ground motions contain fling features and require no processing; therefore, they create new opportunities for representing fling features in seismic hazard analysis and assessing their influence on the seismic demands on near-fault structures. We use physics-based fault rupture simulations to study the characteristics of ground motions with fling step and the sensitivity of the near-fault structural demands to strong fling features. We uncover that simulated ground motions with a large fling step tend to have higher spectral intensity than those without a fling step at the same rupture distance, especially at periods longer than 2 s. As a result, the structural demands on flexible buildings tend to be the most sensitive to the fling features. Statistical analysis suggests that the ground motion spectral shape (represented by spectral accelerations at multiple periods) is—in most cases—a sufficient predictor of the structural demands on near-fault low-rise and mid-rise buildings at locations that are susceptible to strong fling effects. Finally, ground motion record selection experiments reveal that representing the spectral shape features at periods that are most relevant to a given structure may be an effective strategy to reduce the bias in the estimated demands on near-fault long-period structures when the available database of records is considered deficient in fling features.
Earthquake strong-motion predictions using kinematic source modeling require knowledge of the slip-rate functions (SRFs) along the rupture and their distinct characteristics in asperities, background (off-asperity) areas and near the surface. Here, we analyzed SRFs from well-validated, self-consistent, and fully dynamic rupture models from earthquake cycles obeying a rate-and-state friction law, from our companion study (Galvez et al., 2021). The shapes of SRFs in asperities are well described by the regularized Yoffe function (RYF), which has only two parameters: rise time Tr and smoothing time Ts, which control the generation of long-and short-period ground motions, respectively. In background areas, we demonstrate that, in addition to the primary rupture, multiple secondary ruptures may also nucleate from rupture heterogeneities related to asperities, resulting in SRFs with multiple peaks. Because it is impossible to fit a multiple-peak SRF by the single-peak RYF, we describe SRFs in background areas in an effective way by fitting their amplitude spectra with the RYF spectra. Such spectrally effective RYFs capture salient aspects of seismic-wave generation and can be used in rupture generators for strong motion prediction. We found that small Ts values correlate with small characteristic weakening distances, large peak slip rates (PSRs), and large rupture velocities. Tr values are larger in background areas and smaller in asperities. Within the shallow aseismic zone, Ts values approximately quadruple whereas Tr values approximately double. Because of this dominant Ts increase, PSR values decrease in the near-surface zone. These features indicate that the generation of strong motions by the near-surface portions of the rupture is negligible in the studied scenarios.
In this study, we evaluated the performance of the United States Geological Survey velocity model developed for the San Francisco Bay Area (SFBA), version 21.1. The evaluation was performed through high-resolution three-dimensional physics-based ground motion simulations of seven small-magnitude earthquakes (ranging from magnitude 3.8 to 4.4) that occurred on the eastern side of the San Francisco Bay. The simulations were performed in the frequency range from 0 to 5 Hz with a minimum shear-wave velocity of 250 m/s, which allowed the capture of wave propagation effects of the near-surface soft materials that characterize local basins. Based on the direct comparison of Fourier amplitude spectra between recorded and simulated ground motions for more than 250 stations, we found that the velocity model generally performs well in the frequency range of 0.2-5 Hz. The median value of the Fourier amplitude residuals was found to be near zero for all seven earthquakes. The slight over-prediction of 0.2 log-natural units at frequencies above 3 Hz in our simulations was attributed to the potentially inaccurate representation of the source radiation pattern by a double-couple point source model, and simple representation of shallow small-scale underground structural complexity in the velocity model. Maps of spectral amplitude differences between the simulated and recorded data were used to identify areas responsible for systematic ground motion over-predictions or under-predictions. For example, while some sub-domains over soft sediments show over-prediction patterns, the block east of the Hayward fault is prone to exhibit patterns of under-prediction. These maps can be used to guide future refinements of the SFBA velocity model. Since our simulation methodology allows for the decoupling of the source and wave propagation effects, the ground motion data generated by our simulations can also be used to quantify the epistemic uncertainty due to the velocity model, in empirically based ground motion estimates for the SFBA.
ABSTRACT In this study, we simulate ground motions for three major earthquakes that occurred in Central Italy: the 2009 Mw 6.3 L’Aquila earthquake and the two largest events of the 2016 Amatrice–Visso–Norcia sequence, the Mw 6.2 Amatrice and Mw 6.5 Norcia earthquakes. These events caused widespread damage, intense ground shaking, and casualties, making them key cases for evaluating and improving ground-motion modeling techniques, especially given the high-quality recordings available from near-source stations. We use the frequency–wavenumber (f-k) method to generate broadband synthetic ground motions ≤7 Hz. This approach balances computational efficiency with physical accuracy, making it well suited for regional-scale applications. Green’s functions are computed from the Central Italian Apennines 1D layered velocity model (Herrmann et al., 2011), and kinematic rupture models are generated using the methodology of Graves and Pitarka (2016; hereafter, GP16), implemented into the f-k framework. Site response is incorporated using frequency-dependent nonlinear amplification factors (Borcherdt, 1994). We evaluate the simulations through a detailed comparison with observed ground motions using RotD50 spectral acceleration and a goodness-of-fit analysis. In addition to simulations at recorded stations, we compute ground motions over a dense grid of virtual sites to assess spatial variability and source-related effects such as rupture directivity and regional amplification. Results are benchmarked against predictions from the empirical ground-motion model ITA18 (Lanzano et al., 2019). Our findings demonstrate that the f-k method can reproduce key features of observed ground motion with good agreement, capturing both near-fault effects and broader regional trends. This study demonstrates that the f-k approach offers a computationally efficient and physically robust alternative for deterministic ground-motion simulation, bridging empirical models and 3D simulations for practical use in hazard scenarios and urgent computing workflows.
The California Community Earth Models for Seismic Hazard Assessments Workshop (https://www.scec.org/workshops/2024/california-community-models, accessed December 16, 2024) was held online on March 4-5, 2024, with more than 200 participants over two days. In this report, we provide a summary of the key points from the presentations and discussions. We highlight three use cases that drive the development of community Earth models, present an inventory of existing community Earth models in California, summarize a few techniques for integrating and merging models, discuss potential connections with the Cascadia Region Earthquake Science Center (CRESCENT), and discuss what "community" means in community Earth models. Appendix B contains the workshop agenda and Appendix C contains a list of participants.
We propose a deep learning model, WaveCastNet, to forecast high-dimensional wavefields. WaveCastNet integrates a convolutional long expressive memory architecture into a sequence-to-sequence forecasting framework, enabling it to model long-term dependencies and multiscale patterns in both space and time. By sharing weights across spatial and temporal dimensions, WaveCastNet requires significantly fewer parameters than more resource-intensive models such as transformers, resulting in faster inference times. Crucially, WaveCastNet also generalizes better than transformers to rare and critical seismic scenarios, such as high-magnitude earthquakes. Here, we show the ability of the model to predict the intensity and timing of destructive ground motions in real time, using simulated data from the San Francisco Bay Area. Furthermore, we demonstrate its zero-shot capabilities by evaluating WaveCastNet on real earthquake data. Our approach does not require estimating earthquake magnitudes and epicenters, steps that are prone to error in conventional methods, nor does it rely on empirical ground-motion models, which often fail to capture strongly heterogeneous wave propagation effects.
The Central Italy area close to the town of Amatrice was hit by a seismic sequence that started with a Mw 6.2 mainshock and lasted more than 1 year, with the highest event being the Mw 6.5 earthquake in Norcia. Reliable prediction of ground motion is difficult due to the limited data available particularly in the near-source; for this reason, we need realistic simulations of near-source broadband ground motion for seismic hazard assessment. Such simulations should be accurate and computationally efficient. In this work, we performed physics-based simulations to investigate ground motion variability for the Amatrice and Norcia earthquakes. Using the Frequency-Wavenumber (FK) technique we generated broadband ground motion time histories up to 10 Hz for both earthquakes. We exploited accurate source rupture models and various sets of Green’s functions generated with 1D velocity models obtained by slightly modifying the 1D velocity model of the Central Apennine Area proposed by Hermann et al. (2011). First, we employed the Graves and Pitarka (2016) technique to generate kinematic rupture models. Then, FK Green's functions are computed using the propagator matrix method proposed by Zhu and Rivera (2002). Using the RotD50 SA goodness of fit (GoF) between the recorded and simulated ground motion, we conducted 1D velocity model sensitivity analysis. Overall, the simulated time histories match well the recorded ground motion. We found that the 1D velocity model of the Central Apennine Area, modified for the inclusion of thin near-surface sedimentary layers, performed better than the other 1D velocity models considered in the GOF analysis. Our ground motion simulations suggest that the FK-based simulation approach can effectively reproduce the recorded ground motion in the frequency range of 0-10 Hz. Consequently, this approach holds promise for the seismic hazard assessment in Central Italy, enabling significant computer time savings compared to more complex methodologies that involve 3D wave propagation modeling.
This study presents a pilot investigation into a novel method for reconstructing real-time ground motion during small magnitude earthquakes (M < 4.5), removing the need for computationally expensive source characterization and simulation processes to assess ground shaking. Small magnitude earthquakes, which occur frequently and can be modeled as point sources, provide ideal conditions for evaluating real-time reconstruction methods. Utilizing sparse observation data, the method applies the Gappy Auto-Encoder (Gappy AE) algorithm for efficient field data reconstruction. This is the first study to apply the Gappy AE algorithm to earthquake ground motion reconstruction. Numerical experiments conducted with SW4 simulations demonstrate the method's accuracy and speed across varying seismic scenarios. The reconstruction performance is further validated using real seismic data from the Berkeley area in California, USA, demonstrating the potential for practical application of real-time earthquake data reconstruction using Gappy AE. As a pilot investigation, it lays the groundwork for future applications to larger and more complex seismic events.
Comprehensive understanding of earthquake ground motions, particularly in the near-fault region of large-magnitude events, is limited by gaps in strong-motion data. This challenge is prominent in areas with high seismic hazard but infrequent large earthquakes where data is sparse and difficult to interpret. These data limitations lead to uncertainties in the development of site-specific ground motions, which are crucial for engineering risk assessments. To address these challenges, physics-based regional-scale ground-motion simulations have been developed. With the emergence of exaflop-scale computing ecosystems, it is now possible to simulate regional earthquake processes at unprecedented fidelity and generate the large number of fault rupture realizations necessary to characterize both intra- and inter-event ground-motion variability. This article introduces a new database of simulated earthquake ground motions, created for applications in earthquake engineering, earthquake planning, and emergency response. The inaugural version of the database features simulated ground motions for a magnitude 7 Hayward Fault earthquake in the San Francisco Bay Region (SFBR), using the EarthQuake SIMulation (EQSIM) simulation framework and the Graves-Pitarka kinematic rupture model. The aim is to provide high-fidelity, spatially dense, three-component motions generated on the Department of Energy's (DOE) newest generation of graphics processing unit (GPU)-accelerated supercomputers. These motions are being made openly available to the engineering, scientific, and disaster planning communities. In addition, this work develops protocols for the efficient dissemination of these large data sets and emphasizes community engagement to build confidence in their application. This article discusses the methodology behind the data, underlying software verification and validation, scalable data management, and a user interface for data access. The goal is to facilitate widespread use and elicit expert feedback to maximize the utility and exploitation of simulated motions. While the initial focus is on the San Francisco Region, simulations for additional regions will be added as the DOE program progresses.
Recent advancements in high performance computing platforms and computational workflow for regional-scale simulations are enabling unprecedented modeling of fault-to-structure earthquake processes. Regional simulations resolving ground motions at frequencies relevant to engineered systems are becoming computationally viable and provide a new capability to improve understanding of the geographical distribution and intensity of risk to buildings and critical infrastructure. As computational capabilities advance, it is essential to move beyond illustrative single rupture realizations for scenario earthquake events towards the development of a full suite of rupture realizations that appropriately characterize the range of risk to building systems. The work described in this article investigates the application of a suite of fault rupture realizations with the objective of assessing near-fault, site-specific seismic demand variability for building structures. A representative high-performance regional-scale computational model is utilized to execute ground motion and building response simulations based on 18 kinematic rupture realizations of an M7 strike-slip scenario earthquake. The fault rupture models for the scenario earthquake are created by systematically perturbing the hypocenter location and stochastically generating rupture parameters (slip, rise time, rake angle) to represent a breadth of ground motion intensities resulting from the spatial and temporal variabilities of an earthquake rupture process. The resulting seismic demand variability for three-story (short period) and forty-story (long period) steel moment-resisting frame buildings is characterized in terms of the median and distribution of peak inter-story drift ratio for a range of near-fault sites. The full suite of 18 fault rupture realizations and approximately 280,000 nonlinear dynamic building simulations indicate that the three-story building undergoes higher median seismic demand and significantly greater variability of demand at a given site than the forty-story building, which has important implications for the level of certainty in predicting building performance during an earthquake. The simulations performed provide deeper insight into the relationship between fault rupture parameterization and building response, which is essential information for developing a representative suite of rupture realizations for specific earthquake scenarios.
Despite the evidence from past earthquakes and several numerical investigations demonstrating the detrimental impact of vertical ground motions (VGMs) on the integrity of bridge structures, incorporating their effects into seismic assessment and design procedures has traditionally been given limited consideration. Current codes utilize rather simplistic approaches to account for the concurrent effects of vertical and horizontal motions in structural performance evaluations, potentially leading to unconservative estimates of structural demands. This paper reviews the main features of VGMs and their effect on the seismic response of bridges. The methods and empirical models available to estimate vertical motions for design purposes are discussed, and research gaps and related research needs are identified. Finally, the emerging role of physics-based ground-motion simulations, as well as their limitations, in supporting future research and informing the development of simplified design procedures is examined. The main areas of interest for future research are identified in the need to carry out systematic sensitivity studies to gain insight into the main earthquake parameters that influence key VGMs features, understand the influence of soil nonlinearities on VGMs amplitude and frequency content, inform the development of empirical models that cover a range of site conditions and source-to-site distances where current models are poorly constrained, generate arrays of motions to update coherency models to properly inform the analysis of distributed infrastructure, investigate the impulsive character of VGMs, and assess the approximations made in estimating VGMs with 1D site response analyses. Specific focus is laid on large-magnitude earthquakes in the near-field.
This article presents the results of a research that is part of a larger collaborative effort between the Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory and the Pacific Earthquake Engineering Research Center, funded by the US Department of Energy Office of Cybersecurity, Energy Security and Emergency Response. The main objective of this study is to assess a suite of near and far-field simulated ground motions obtained from 20 realizations of an M7 Hayward Fault earthquake in the San Francisco Bay Area, California USA, and inform the selection of rupture simulation parameters leading to strong motions. To this aim, comparisons are conducted with NGA-W2 and directivity ground-motion models and a selected population of records. An archetypal steel moment-resisting frame is utilized to assess infrastructure response distributions. The analyses carried out for each simulated event and subdomain with consistent properties in terms of shallow shear-wave velocity proved to be instrumental for better interpreting the differences between simulated motions and empirical models. The main reasons identified for variances between simulations and empirical relationships included (1) directivity effects fully captured by the simulations across the full breadth of rupture models; (2) site vicinity to ruptures that incorporate large-slip patches, particularly if these are in the forward-directivity direction; and (3) presence of geologic structures that can “trap” seismic waves and produce ground motions with large amplitude and long signal duration. The analyses carried out in this work provide a path for interpreting ground-motion site and event specificity obtained from a suite of physics-based simulations, differing only in the rupture model characterization, to inform the selection of simulation scenarios for site-specific engineering analyses under strong excitations. Evidence from this work points to the possibility that current hazard models may underestimate ground-motion intensities in areas where the combined effect of directivity and site conditions results in large ground-motion amplitudes.
Earthquakes present world-wide risk to economic and human safety. The 2023 earthquakes in Turkey provided a reminder of the potential for catastrophic consequences with 50,700 deaths and 15.7 million people affected. The ability to predict ground motions and infrastructure damage for earthquakes continues to be a challenging problem for scientists and engineers. Until now, estimates of ground motions have been performed empirically by looking at sparse data from past earthquakes. This approach can provide statistical information on intensity amplitudes but cannot inform site-specific ground motions essential to developing the most effective resilience. Interest has grown in largescale computational models to simulate earthquakes at regional scale. The U.S. DOE EQSIM framework was developed for regional-scale earthquake simulations at unprecedented fidelity, taking advantage of emerging GPU-accelerated systems. This article describes the EQSIM workflow and demonstrates regional-scale simulations with the new computational capability available to scientists in their quest to mitigate future disasters.
ABSTRACT The devastating 24 August 2016 Mw 6.2 earthquake that struck Amatrice, Italy, marked the beginning of a prolonged seismic sequence dominated by three subsequent Mw ≥6.0 events in the central Apennines region. The earthquake destroyed Amatrice’s historic center, claiming the lives of 299 individuals and causing widespread damage in the neighboring villages. The severity of the ground shaking, with a recorded maximum acceleration of 850 cm/s2 on the east–west component at the Amatrice station, was far greater than the predicted acceleration based on the Italian ground-motion model (GMM). As pointed out by several investigations, the observed ground-motion amplitude and its spatial variability during the earthquake can be linked to specific rupture characteristics, including slip distribution and rupture directivity effects revealed by the observed data (Tinti et al., 2016; Pischiutta et al., 2021). In this study, we conducted physics-based 3D numerical simulations of ground motion for the Amatrice earthquake for frequencies up to 3 Hz. We employed a series of kinematic rupture models and a well-constrained local 3D velocity model incorporating surface topography. The kinematic rupture realizations were generated using multiscale hybrid and fully stochastic models, following the technique proposed by Graves and Pitarka (2016). We focused on assessing the sensitivity of near-fault ground-motion amplitudes to earthquake rupture characteristics, in particular, the spatial slip pattern. To evaluate the quality of our simulations, we employed goodness-of-fit measurements performed in comparisons of simulated and recorded ground motions. The simulated ground motions compare well with the recorded data and predictions from GMMs for Italy, ITA18 (Lanzano et al., 2019). However, we found that the simulated interevent ground-motion variability (randomness in the source process) of peak ground velocity, σ (PGV) is higher than the constant σ (PGV) predicted by conventional GMMs. Our simulations using several rupture scenarios demonstrate that the near-fault ground-motion amplification pattern is directly related to the slip distribution pattern.