Progesterone monitoring is an essential component of in vitro fertilization treatments and reproductive management of dairy cows. Gold-standard biosensors for progesterone monitoring rely on antibodies, which are expensive and difficult to procure. We have developed an alternative transcription factor-based sensor that is superior to conventional progesterone biosensors. Here, we incorporate this transcription factor-based progesterone sensor into an affordable, portable paperfluidic format to facilitate widespread implementation of progesterone monitoring at the point of care. Oligonucleotides labeled with a fluorescent dye are immobilized onto nitrocellulose via a biotin-streptavidin interaction. In the absence of progesterone, these oligonucleotides form a complex with a transcription factor that is fluorescently labeled with tdTomato. In the presence of progesterone, the fluorescent transcription factor unbinds from the immobilized DNA, resulting in a decrease in tdTomato fluorescence. The limit of detection of our system is 27 nm, which is a clinically relevant level of progesterone. We demonstrate that transcription factor-based sensors can be incorporated into paperfluidic devices, thereby making them accessible to a broader population due to the portability and affordability of paper-based devices.
In 2019, the first cases of SARS-CoV-2 were detected in Wuhan, China, and by early 2020 the first cases were identified in the United States. SARS-CoV-2 infections increased in the US causing many states to implement stay-at-home orders and additional safety precautions to mitigate potential outbreaks. As policies changed throughout the pandemic and restrictions lifted, there was an increase in demand for COVID-19 testing which was costly, difficult to obtain, or had long turn-around times. Some academic institutions, including Boston University (BU), created an on-campus COVID-19 screening protocol as part of a plan for the safe return of students, faculty, and staff to campus with the option for in-person classes. At BU, we put together an automated high-throughput clinical testing laboratory with the capacity to run 45,000 individual tests weekly by Fall of 2020, with a purpose-built clinical testing laboratory, a multiplexed reverse transcription PCR (RT-qPCR) test, robotic instrumentation, and trained staff. There were many challenges including supply chain issues for personal protective equipment and testing materials in addition to equipment that were in high demand. The BU Clinical Testing Laboratory (CTL) was operational at the start of Fall 2020 and performed over 1 million SARS-CoV-2 PCR tests during the 2020-2021 academic year.
We report a combined experimental and computational study to systematically compare the nature of the dye, i.e., organic fluorophore vs. inorganic nanoparticle, and the position of the FRET donor or acceptor on the biosensor performances.
Sexually transmitted infections, including the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) and the human papillomavirus (HPV), disproportionally impact those in low-resource settings. Early diagnosis is essential for managing HIV. Similarly, HPV causes nearly all cases of cervical cancer, the majority (90%) of which occur in low-resource settings. Importantly, infection with HPV is six times more likely to progress to cervical cancer in women who are HIV-positive. An inexpensive, adaptable point-of-care test for viral infections would make screening for these viruses more accessible to a broader set of the population. Here, we report a novel, cost-effective electrochemical platform using gold leaf electrodes to detect clinically relevant viral loads. We have combined this platform with loop-mediated isothermal amplification and a CRISPR-based recognition assay to detect HPV. Lower limits of detection were demonstrated down to 10(4) total copies of input nucleic acids, which is a clinically relevant viral load for HPV DNA. Further, proof-of-concept experiments with cervical swab samples, extracted using standard extraction protocols, demonstrated that the strategy is extendable to complex human samples. This adaptable technology could be applied to detect any viral infection rapidly and cost-effectively.
Nucleic acid amplification tests (NAATs), which amplify and detect pathogen nucleic acids, are vital methods to diagnose diseases, particularly in cases where patients exhibit low levels of infection. For many blood-borne pathogens such as HIV or Plasmodium falciparum, it is necessary to first extract pathogen RNA or DNA from patient blood prior to NAAT analysis. Traditional nucleic acid extraction methods are expensive, resource-intensive and are often difficult to deploy to resource-limited areas where many blood-borne infections are widespread. Here, we describe a portable, paper-and-plastic device, called SNAPflex, for instrument-free nucleic acid extraction from whole blood, which builds upon our previous work for RNA extraction using a pressure-driven extraction system. SNAPflex shows improved HIV RNA extraction from simulated patient samples compared to traditional extraction methods as well as long-term stability of extracted RNA without the need for cold storage. We further demonstrated successful extraction and recovery of P. falciparum DNA from cultured parasites in whole blood. SNAPflex was designed to be easily manufacturable and deployable to resource-limited settings.
Loop-mediated amplification (LAMP) is an isothermal amplification technique favored in diagnostics and point-of-care work due to its high sensitivity and ability to run in isothermal conditions. In addition, a visual readout by lateral flow strips (LFS) can be used in conjunction with LAMP, making the assay accessible at the point-of-care. However, the amplicons resulting from a LAMP reaction varied in length and shape, making them undiscernible on a double-stranded DNA intercalating dye stained gel. Standard characterization techniques also do not identify which amplicons specifically bind to the LFS, which generate the visual readout. We aimed to standardize our characterization of LAMP products during assay development by using fluorescein amidite (FAM) and biotin-tagged loop forward and backward primers during assay development. A pvuII restriction enzyme digest is applied to the LAMP products. FAM-tagged bands are directly correlated with the LFS visual readout. We applied this assay development workflow for an HPV 16 assay using both plasmid DNA and clinical samples to demonstrate proof of concept for generalized assay development work.
The glucose biosensor, built upon the redox enzyme glucose oxidase, is the most commercially successful and studied enzymatic biosensor. However, the lack of available and functionally validated enzymes is prohibiting the development of redox-based sensors for other important analytes. Herein, we present the development and assessment of an electrochemical nicotine biosensor, using genomic screening to identify the gene for a known nicotine catabolizing redox enzyme. The resulting nicotine biosensor demonstrated a specific, sensitive, and stable operational profile with a limit of detection of 27 μM over the range of 0-200 μM. This range is well within the physiological concentrations of nicotine present in smoker urine. Specificity and cross-reactivity were measured against structurally similar compounds to nicotine as well as to known physiological by-products. Our results highlight that this novel enzymatic electrochemical nicotine biosensor possesses operational capabilities for monitoring of nicotine in physiologically relevant conditions. The screening methodology can be generalized for the discovery of enzymes for novel sensor development.
Bacteria are an enormous and largely untapped reservoir of biosensing proteins. We describe an approach to identify and isolate bacterial allosteric transcription factors (aTFs) that recognize a target analyte and to develop these TFs into biosensor devices. Our approach utilizes a combination of genomic screens and functional assays to identify and isolate biosensing TFs, and a quantum-dot Förster Resonance Energy Transfer (FRET) strategy for transducing analyte recognition into real-time quantitative measurements. We use this approach to identify a progesterone-sensing bacterial aTF and to develop this TF into an optical sensor for progesterone. The sensor detects progesterone in artificial urine with sufficient sensitivity and specificity for clinical use, while being compatible with an inexpensive and portable electronic reader for point-of-care applications. Our results provide proof-of-concept for a paradigm of microbially-derived biosensors adaptable to inexpensive, real-time sensor devices.
An alternative molecular recognition approach was developed for sensing small molecule analytes using the differential binding of an allosteric transcription factor (TF, specifically TetR) to its cognate DNA as the molecular recognition element coupled with fluorescent resonance energy transfer (FRET) to yield an internally calibrated optical signal transduction mechanism. Sensors were evaluated comprising Cy5-modified DNA (FRET acceptor) with either a tdTomato-TetR fusion protein (FP-TF) or quantum dot-TetR conjugate (QD-TF) as the FRET donor by measuring the ratio of acceptor and donor fluorescence intensities (F-A/F-D) with titrations of a derivative of the antibiotic tetracycline, anhydrous tetracycline (aTc). A proof-of-concept FRET-based biosensor was successfully demonstrated through the modulation of F-A/F-D signal intensities based on varying analyte concentrations. Sensor design parameters affecting overall signal-to-noise ratio and sensitivity of the sensors are also identified.
Proper management of an HIV infection requires that a patient be at least 80-95% adherent to a prescribed drug regimen to avoid poor health outcomes and the development of drug-resistant HIV strains. Clinicians generally monitor adherence habits indirectly through patient self-reporting, pill counting, and electronic drug monitoring. While direct measurement of patient samples like urine for monitoring drug levels is possible, it requires specialized equipment and training that is not readily available in resource-limited settings where the need is greatest. In this work we report the development of an antibody that binds to tenofovir (TFV), a key small molecule drug for both the treatment and prevention of HIV, and a competitive lateral flow assay that uses that antibody to monitor urine samples for the presence of the drug. TFV was conjugated to an immunogenic protein and injected into rabbits to raise polyclonal antibodies sensitive to the drug. The antibodies were verified for TFV-sensitivity by immunoprecipitation and HPLC. A gold nanoparticle-based competitive assay was developed to detect the presence of TFV in urine samples with a sensitivity of 1 mu g mL(-1). This TFV assay could be deployed as a point-of-care device for adherence monitoring in resource-limited settings as a low-cost, accurate, and speedy alternative to current methods to better inform changes in treatment. (C) 2018 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
DNA extraction from clinical samples is commonly achieved with a silica solid phase extraction column in the presence of a chaotrope. Versions of these protocols have been adapted for point of care (POC) diagnostic devices in miniaturized platforms, but commercial kits require a high amount of input DNA. Thus, when the input clinical sample contains less than 1 μg of total DNA, the target-specific DNA recovery from most of these protocols is low without supplementing the sample with exogenous carrier DNA. In fact, many clinical samples used in the development of POC diagnostics often exhibit target DNA concentrations as low as 3 ng/mL. With the broader goal of improving the yield and efficiency of nucleic acid-based POC devices for dilute samples, we investigated both DNA adsorption and recovery from silica particles by using 1 pg– 1 μg of DNA with a set of adsorption and elution buffers ranging in pH and chaotropic presence. In terms of adsorption, we found that low pH and the presence of chaotropic guanidinium thiocyanate (GuSCN) enhanced DNA-silica adsorption. When eluting with a standard low-salt, high-pH buffer, > 70% of DNA was unrecoverable, except when DNA was initially adsorbed with 5 M GuSCN at pH 5.2. Unrecovered DNA was either not initially adsorbed or irreversibly bound on the silica surface. Recovery was improved when eluting with 95°C formamide and 1 M NaOH, which suggested that DNA-silica-chaotrope interactions are dominated by hydrophobic interactions and hydrogen bonding. While heated formamide and NaOH are non-ideal elution buffers for practical POC devices, the salient results are important for engineering a set of optimized reagents that could maximize nucleic acid recovery from a microfluidic DNA-silica-chaotrope system.
Wearable chemical sensor technologies enable the opportunity to continuously collect physiologically information on an individual’s health status. This is in contrast to traditional blood draws and subsequent analysis. Using glucose oxidase as a model enzyme we compare several fabrication methods and describe an optimized glucose monitoring sensor which works in open circuit potential with good selectivity and sensitivity over a glucose concentration range of 50 to 300 µM (Figure 1). The sensors maintain good sensitivity of more than 2000 nA/mM after two weeks. The current drifting is minimal and reproducible and device can be made. (Figure 1c). Key steps, procedural details, and findings will be discussed in this work. Figure 1. (a) The open circuit potential amperometric monitoring the liberated hydrogen peroxide after (a) 1 day of fabrication and (b) 15 days of fabrication; along with the calibration curves on inset. (c) Drifting and calibration curve obtained for sensors made from different batches. Figure 1
Monitoring the adherence of patients taking highly-active anti-retroviral therapy (HAART) and Pre-Exposure Prophylaxis (PrEP) is a key step in treating an HIV infection. Since current monitor methods are non-direct there is a need for assays that directly verify the presence of active drug in the patient. In this work we modified an existing assay for the detection of cytosine to sense the presence of lamivudine (3TC) in spiked urine and emtricitabine (FTC) in water. 3TC and FTC is reacted with bromine and barium hydroxide to generate a colored precipitate in less than an hour indicating the presence of active drug. The current detection limit of the 3TC assay is 870uM in water and 2mM in urine. This assay can be applied in clinics to monitor patient adherence without the need for expensive equipment such as HPLC.
Monitoring the adherence of patients taking highly active antiretroviral therapy (HAART) is a key step in treating an HIV infection, especially in resource-limited settings in the developing world. For most regimens, when patients are not at least 95% adherent to their drug schedule, there is a loss of effectiveness in treatment resulting in increases in health care costs, increases in the rate of transmission, and reduction of positive patient outcomes. Currently, subjective methods such as pill counting, electronic drug monitoring, and patient self-reporting are the only ways clinicians can track adherence and intervene in cases of noncompliance. We address this issue by developing a dipstick-based point-of-care azide-alkyne click chemistry assay with colorimetric read-out that directly tests for the presence of one common HAART drug in patient urine. An alkyne-modified dextran was synthesized and characterized by NMR and then used to colorimetrically report the presence of azidothymidine, an azide-containing HAART drug, in urine samples. The assay is specific to azide-containing molecules that are not naturally present in the urine and is sensitive to physiologically relevant urine concentrations as low as 750 uM. This point-of-care device is a strong alternative in resource-limited settings over current direct measurement techniques that are expensive and require trained users such as HPLC.
Correction for ‘Paper-based molecular diagnostic for Chlamydia trachomatis’ by Jacqueline C. Linnes et al., RSC Adv., 2014, 4, 42245–42251.
The 2009 Influenza A (H1N1) pandemic disproportionately affected the developing world and highlighted the key inadequacies of traditional diagnostic methods that make them unsuitable for use in resource-limited settings, from expensive equipment and infrastructure requirements to unacceptably long turnaround times. While rapid immunoassay diagnostic tests were much less costly and more context-appropriate, they suffered from drastically low sensitivities and high false negative rates. An accurate, sensitive, and specific molecular diagnostic that is also rapid, low-cost, and independent of laboratory infrastructure is needed for effective point-of-care detection and epidemiological control in these developing regions. We developed a paper-based assay that allows for the extraction and purification of RNA directly from human clinical nasopharyngeal specimens through a poly(ether sulfone) paper matrix, H1N1-specific in situ isothermal amplification directly within the same paper matrix, and immediate visual detection on lateral flow strips. The complete sample-to-answer assay can be performed at the point-of-care in just 45 min, without the need for expensive equipment or laboratory infrastructure, and it has a clinically relevant viral load detection limit of 10(6) copies/mL, offering a 10-fold improvement over current rapid immunoassays.
Abstract a) The current gold-standard of care in the management of patients with thyroid nodules is ultrasound-guided fine needle aspiration biopsy (FNAB) followed by microscopic examination of cell morphology by a trained cytopathologist. Due to the lack of distinguishing morphology, 10-25% of FNAs are termed “indeterminate” and required surgery. However, only 35% of them are found to have cancer. There is a need for a more accurate and minimally invasive cancer diagnostic technology. Our objective is to develop an inexpensive, point-of-care molecular diagnostic platform to isolate and detect thyroid specific proteins to enable real-world use of biomarkers to inform patient care. b) In this study, we engineer a miniature ion exchange column within a plastic (cyclic olefin polymer), disposable lab-on-a-chip platform for sample preparation and protein purification using microfluidic channels with a specialized porous polymer monolith (PPM)-based resin bed. We capitalized on the finding that cancer cells exhibit differential protein expressional patterns compared to normal thyroid cells by targeting thyroid transcription factor (TTF-1), a thyroid specific enhancer binding protein, as a biomarker for the diagnosis of thyroid cancer. The ability to capture and release TTF-1 from the papillary thyroid cancer (PTC) cell line was evaluated via western blot. We also tested various types of thyroid samples obtained from malignant and benign human thyroid nodules. c) We compared the efficiency of a small-scale protein prep using a commercial gravity column versus our lab-on-a-chip column. Our method showed TTF-1 protein was detectable from the lysate of 5x104 cultured BCPAP cancer cell line. In contrast, it was not detectable when purified by gravity ion-exchange column. We next showed that one can maximize the concentration of protein eluted from as fewer cells as possible. We found that by titrating the elution volume per fraction down to 10 µl, the final concentration of eluted protein can be increased, and hence increase the downstream LOD to 104 cells. Next, we evaluated our extraction and purification system by using 10 mg patient thyroid tissue samples. We tested 11 human thyroid specimens for TTF-1 protein capture. They were all found to be positive which correlated with the official histopathological findings. All tissue extracts had measurable levels of TTF-1 protein and the levels of the TTF-1 were variable in the tissue specimens. We also tested one negative thyroid specimen. No TTF-1 protein was found. d) Our microfluidic protein extraction and purification system is a platform technology that may allow for optimal use of low-volume sample preparation such as we see in thyroid biopsies. This manner, when combined with an on-chip ELISA assay, would be a simple, cost effective test that gives the doctor all the needed information quickly in a single test. When mature, the device can be applied to other type of cancer based on tailored assays for specific biomarkers. Citation Format: Shichu Huang, Siddhartha Sharma, Lena Liu, Andy Fan, Catherine Klapperich, Jennifer Rosen. Microfluidic platform for a protein-based thyroid cancer diagnostics. [abstract]. In: Proceedings of the 105th Annual Meeting of the American Association for Cancer Research; 2014 Apr 5-9; San Diego, CA. Philadelphia (PA): AACR; Cancer Res 2014;74(19 Suppl):Abstract nr 3494. doi:10.1158/1538-7445.AM2014-3494
In order to counter the common perception that molecular diagnostics are too complicated to work in low resource settings, we have performed a difficult sample preparation and DNA amplification protocol using instrumentation designed to be operated without wall or battery power. In this work we have combined a nearly electricity-free nucleic acid extraction process with an electricity-free isothermal amplification assay to detect the presence of Clostridium difficile (C. difficile) DNA in the stool of infected patients. We used helicase-dependent isothermal amplification (HDA) to amplify the DNA in a low-cost, thermoplastic reaction chip heated with a pair of commercially available toe warmers, while using a simple Styrofoam insulator. DNA was extracted from known positive and negative stool samples. The DNA extraction protocol utilized an air pressure driven solid phase extraction device run using a standard bicycle pump. The simple heater setup required no electricity or battery and was capable of maintaining the temperature at 65°C±2°C for 55 min, suitable for repeatable HDA amplification. Experiments were performed to explore the adaptability of the system for use in a range of ambient conditions. When compared to a traditional centrifuge extraction protocol and a laboratory thermocycler, this disposable, no power platform achieved approximately the same lower limit of detection (1.25×10(-2) pg of C. difficile DNA) while requiring much less raw material and a fraction of the lab infrastructure and cost. This proof of concept study could greatly impact the accessibility of molecular assays for applications in global health.