Most mammalian genes undergo alternative splicing. The splicing of some exons has been acquired or lost in specific mammalian lineages, but differences in splicing within the human population are poorly understood. Using GTEx tissue transcriptomes from 838 individuals, we identified 57,271 “naturally variable exons” (NVEs) – exons which are included in mRNAs in some individuals but entirely excluded from others (or vice versa). NVEs impact three quarters of protein-coding genes, occur at all population frequencies, and are often absent from reference annotations. NVEs are more abundant in genes depleted of genetic loss-of-function mutations and aid in the interpretation of causal genetic variants. Genetic variants modulate the splicing of many NVEs, and 5’ untranslated region and coding-region NVEs are often associated with increased and decreased gene expression, respectively. Together, our findings characterize abundant splicing variation in the human population, with implications for a range of human genetic analyses. Most human genes undergo alternative splicing, but population-level variation is poorly understood. Here, the authors map over 57,000 naturally variable exons across 838 individuals, revealing widespread splicing diversity and its impact on gene expression and genetic interpretation.
BACKGROUND:Both promoters and untranslated regions (UTRs) have critical regulatory roles, yet variants in these regions are largely excluded from clinical genetic testing due to difficulty in interpreting pathogenicity. The extent to which these regions may harbour diagnoses for individuals with rare disease is currently unknown. METHODS:We present a framework for the identification and annotation of potentially deleterious proximal promoter and UTR variants in known dominant disease genes. We use this framework to annotate de novo variants (DNVs) in 8040 undiagnosed individuals in the Genomics England 100,000 genomes project, which were subject to strict region-based filtering, clinical review, and validation studies where possible. In addition, we performed region and variant annotation-based burden testing in 7862 unrelated probands against matched unaffected controls. RESULTS:We prioritised eleven DNVs and identified an additional variant overlapping one of the eleven. Ten of these twelve variants (82%) are in genes that are a strong match to the individual's phenotype and six had not previously been identified. Through burden testing, we did not observe a significant enrichment of potentially deleterious promoter and/or UTR variants in individuals with rare disease collectively across any of our region or variant annotations. CONCLUSIONS:Whilst screening promoters and UTRs can uncover additional diagnoses for individuals with rare disease, including these regions in diagnostic pipelines is not likely to dramatically increase diagnostic yield. Nevertheless, we provide a framework to aid identification of these variants.
Variants in ion channel genes are common causes of pediatric epilepsy, often leading to intractable seizures, developmental delay and other comorbidities, which increases risk of death. Pathogenic variants in the SCN8A gene, which encodes a voltage-gated sodium channel critical for action potential generation in the brain, account for ∼1% of genetic epilepsies. The voltage sensor in SCN8A domain 1 is encoded by one of two developmentally-regulated mutually exclusive alternative exons, 5N and 5A. We observe that variants in these exons are more likely to cause infantile spasms, a severe seizure type, than variants elsewhere in SCN8A , and that some pathogenic variants affect exon 5 splicing, impacting patient phenotype. Molecular and evolutionary analyses implicate the exon sequences of these and other voltage-gated ion channel alternative exons in splicing regulation. We identified antisense oligonucleotides (ASOs) that shift splicing of SCN8A exon 5N to 5A or vice versa. These ASOs normalize neuronal activity in patient-derived iPSC neurons, and reduce seizures and motor impairment and extend lifespan in a new exon 5N mutant mouse model. Our results demonstrate that splice-switching ASOs can effectively reduce the expression of pathogenic isoforms and rescue both seizure and non-seizure phenotypes. Similar approaches should be applicable to pediatric genetic epilepsies caused by mutations in other ion channel alternative exons.
Mutation or deletion of the U1 snRNP-associated factor LUC7L2 is associated with myeloid neoplasms, and knockout of LUC7L2 alters cellular metabolism. Here, we show that members of the LUC7 protein family differentially regulate two major classes of 5' splice sites (5'SS) and broadly regulate mRNA splicing in both human cell lines and leukemias with LUC7L2 copy number variation. We describe distinctive 5'SS features of exons impacted by the three human LUC7 paralogs: LUC7L2 and LUC7L enhance splicing of "right-handed" 5'SS with stronger consensus matching on the intron side of the near invariant /GU, while LUC7L3 enhances splicing of "left-handed" 5'SS with stronger consensus matching upstream of the /GU. We validated our model of sequence-specific 5'SS regulation both by mutating splice sites and swapping domains between human LUC7 proteins. Evolutionary analysis indicates that the LUC7L2/LUC7L3 subfamilies evolved before the split between animals and plants. Analysis of Arabidopsis thaliana mutants confirmed that plant LUC7 orthologs possess similar specificity to their human counterparts, indicating that 5'SS regulation by LUC7 proteins is highly conserved.
Spliceosomal introns are a ubiquitous feature of eukaryotic genes, whose presence often boosts the expression of their host gene, a phenomenon known as intron-mediated enhancement (IME). IME has been noted across diverse genes and organisms but remains mysterious in many respects. For example, how does intron sequence affect the magnitude of IME? In this study, we performed a massively parallel reporter assay (MPRA) to assess the effect of varying intron sequence on gene expression in a high-throughput manner, in human cells, using tens of thousands of synthetic introns with natural splice sites and randomized internal sequence. We observe that most random introns splice efficiently and enhance gene expression as well as or better than fully natural introns. Nearly all introns stimulate gene expression ∼eight-fold above an intronless control, at both mRNA and protein levels, suggesting that the primary mechanism acts to increase mRNA levels. IME strength is positively associated with splicing efficiency and with the intronic content of poly-uridine stretches, which we confirm using reporter experiments. In sum, this work assesses the IME of a diverse library of introns and uncovers sequence-dependent aspects, but suggests that enhancement of gene expression is a general property of splicing, largely independent of intron sequence.
Typical RNA sequencing (RNA-seq) experiments uncover hundreds of splicing changes, reflecting underlying changes in splicing factor (SF) activity. Understanding how SF activity influences transcriptomic variation requires elucidating how each SF impacts splicing. Here, we present an interpretable regression model, KATMAP, which models splicing changes throughout the transcriptome by analyzing changes in SF binding and the resulting alterations in RNA processing. To learn a regulatory model, KATMAP requires SF perturbation RNA-seq data and the SF's binding motif as inputs, returning a description of the SF's position-specific regulatory activity and predicted targets. The KATMAP software includes models pretrained on ENCODE SF knockdown data. Learned KATMAP models can be applied to predict SF regulation and cis-elements at individual exons, which can guide the design of splice-switching antisense oligonucleotides. KATMAP can also interpret RNA-seq data by uncovering the factors responsible for transcriptomic changes, distinguishing direct SF targets from indirect effects and inferring relevant SFs from clinical RNA-seq data.
Pathogenic variants in SCN8A, which encodes the voltage-gated sodium (NaV) channel NaV1.6, associate with neurodevelopmental disorders, including developmental and epileptic encephalopathy. Previous approaches to determine SCN8A variant function may be confounded by use of a neonatally expressed, alternatively spliced isoform of NaV1.6 (NaV1.6N) and engineered mutations rendering the channel tetrodotoxin (TTX) resistant. We investigated the impact of SCN8A alternative splicing on variant function by comparing the functional attributes of 15 variants expressed in 2 developmentally regulated splice isoforms (NaV1.6N, NaV1.6A). We employed automated patch clamp recording to enhance throughput, and developed a neuronal cell line (ND7/LoNav) with low levels of endogenous NaV current to obviate the need for TTX-resistance mutations. Expression of NaV1.6N or NaV1.6A in ND7/LoNav cells generated NaV currents with small, but significant, differences in voltage dependence of activation and inactivation. TTX-resistant versions of both isoforms exhibited significant functional differences compared with the corresponding WT channels. We demonstrated that many of the 15 disease-associated variants studied exhibited isoform-dependent functional effects, and that many of the studied SCN8A variants exhibited functional properties that were not easily classified as either gain- or loss-of-function. Our work illustrates the value of considering molecular and cellular context when investigating SCN8A variants.
ABSTRACT While evolution is often considered from a DNA- and protein-centric view, RNA-based regulation can also impact gene expression and protein sequences. Here we examined interspecies differences in RNA-protein interactions using the conserved neuronal RNA binding protein, Unkempt (UNK) as model. We find that roughly half of mRNAs bound in human are also bound in mouse. Unexpectedly, even when transcript-level binding was conserved across species differential motif usage was prevalent. To understand the biochemical basis of UNK-RNA interactions, we reconstituted the human and mouse UNK-RNA interactomes using a high-throughput biochemical assay. We uncover detailed features driving binding, show that in vivo patterns are captured in vitro , find that highly conserved sites are the strongest bound, and associate binding strength with downstream regulation. Furthermore, subtle sequence differences surrounding motifs are key determinants of species-specific binding. We highlight the complex features driving protein-RNA interactions and how these evolve to confer species-specific regulation.
Spliceosomal introns are a ubiquitous feature of eukaryotic genes, whose presence often boosts the expression of their host gene, a phenomenon known as intron- mediated enhancement (IME). IME has been noted across diverse genes and organisms, but remains mysterious in many respects. For example, how does intron sequence affect the magnitude of IME? In this study, we performed a massively parallel reporter assay (MPRA) to assess the effect of varying intron sequence on gene expression in a high-throughput manner, in human cells, using tens of thousands of synthetic introns with natural splice sites and randomized internal sequence. We observe that most random introns splice efficiently and enhance gene expression as well as or better than fully natural introns. Nearly all introns stimulate gene expression ~eight-fold above an intronless control, at both mRNA and protein levels, suggesting that the primary mechanism acts to increase mRNA levels. IME strength is positively associated with splicing efficiency and with the intronic content of poly-uridine stretches, which we confirm using reporter experiments. Together, this work elucidates sequence determinants of IME from tens of thousands of random introns, and confirms that enhancement of gene expression is a general property of splicing. ### Competing Interest Statement The authors have declared no competing interest.
It is well-established that splicing factors (SFs) regulate splicing in a position-dependent manner. However, despite extensive experimental work focused on this regulation, quantifying SF regulatory activity in a form that can be readily applied to new analyses remains a challenge. Here we present an interpretable regression model, KATMAP, which explicitly models splicing changes upon SF knockdown in terms of changes in SF binding across the transcriptome and the resulting loss of regulation. This allows us to learn an SF’s positional activity and predict the factor’s regulatory impact on individual exons, yielding regulatory models consistent with prior literature and highly reproducible across knockdowns of the same SF in different cell types, even generalizing well to related species. We leverage this generalizability to distinguish direct targets from the indirect effects of knockdown, and identify the secondary SFs responsible for these widespread indirect effects. We further uncover evidence of cooperative regulation between RBFOX and QKI. The generality of our statistical framework means it could be extended to the study of RNA regulation and processing beyond splicing. ### Competing Interest Statement The authors have declared no competing interest.
Many non-coding variants associated with phenotypes occur in 3ʹ untranslated regions (3ʹ UTRs), and may affect interactions with RNA-binding proteins (RBPs) to regulate gene expression post-transcriptionally. However, identifying functional 3ʹ UTR variants has proven difficult. We use allele frequencies from the Genome Aggregation Database (gnomAD) to identify classes of 3ʹ UTR variants under strong negative selection in humans. We develop intergenic mutability-adjusted proportion singleton (iMAPS), a generalized measure related to MAPS, to quantify negative selection in non-coding regions. This approach, in conjunction with in vitro and in vivo binding data, identifies precise RBP binding sites, miRNA target sites, and polyadenylation signals (PASs) under strong selection. For each class of sites, we identify thousands of gnomAD variants under selection comparable to missense coding variants, and find that sites in core 3ʹ UTR regions upstream of the most-used PAS are under strongest selection. Together, this work improves our understanding of selection on human genes and validates approaches for interpreting genetic variants in human 3ʹ UTRs.
Sequence-specific RNA-binding proteins (RBPs) play central roles in splicing decisions. Here, we describe a modular splicing architecture that leverages in vitro-derived RNA affinity models for 79 human RBPs and the annotated human genome to produce improved models of RBP binding and activity. Binding and activity are modeled by separate Motif and Aggregator components that can be mixed and matched, enforcing sparsity to improve interpretability. Training a new Adjusted Motif (AM) architecture on the splicing task not only yields better splicing predictions but also improves prediction of RBP-binding sites in vivo and of splicing activity, assessed using independent data.
While evolution is often considered from a DNA- and protein-centric view, RNA-based regulation can also impact gene expression and protein sequences. Here we examine interspecies differences in RNA-protein interactions using the conserved neuronal RNA-binding protein, Unkempt (UNK) as model. We find that roughly half of mRNAs bound in human are also bound in mouse. Unexpectedly, even when transcript-level binding was conserved across species differential motif usage was prevalent. To understand the biochemical basis of UNK-RNA interactions, we reconstitute the human and mouse UNK-RNA interactomes using a high-throughput biochemical assay. We uncover detailed features driving binding, show that in vivo patterns are captured in vitro, find that highly conserved sites are the strongest bound, and associate binding strength with downstream regulation. Furthermore, subtle sequence differences surrounding motifs are key determinants of species-specific binding. We highlight the complex features driving protein-RNA interactions and how these evolve to confer species-specific regulation.
Our ability to determine the clinical impact of variants in 3' untranslated regions (UTRs) of genes remains poor. We provide a thorough analysis of 3' UTR variants from several datasets. Variants in putative regulatory elements, including RNA -binding protein motifs, eCLIP peaks, and microRNA sites, are up to 16 times more likely than variants not in these elements to have gene expression and phenotype associations. Variants in regulatory motifs result in allele -specific protein binding in cell lines and allele -specific gene expression differences in population studies. In addition, variants in shared regions of alternatively polyadenylated isoforms and those proximal to polyA sites are more likely to affect gene expression and phenotype. Finally, pathogenic 3' UTR variants in ClinVar are up to 20 times more likely than benign variants to fall in a regulatory site. We incorporated these findings into RegVar, a software tool that interprets regulatory elements and annotations for any 3' UTR variant and predicts whether the variant is likely to affect gene expression or phenotype. This tool will help prioritize variants for experimental studies and identify pathogenic variants in individuals.
Pre-mRNA splicing is a fundamental step in gene expression, conserved across eukaryotes, in which the spliceosome recognizes motifs at the 3 ' and 5 ' splice sites (SSs), excises introns, and ligates exons. SS recognition and pairing is often influenced by protein splicing factors (SFs) that bind to splicing regulatory elements (SREs). Here, we describe SMsplice, a fully interpretable model of pre-mRNA splicing that combines models of core SS motifs, SREs, and exonic and intronic length preferences. We learn models that predict SS locations with 83 to 86% accuracy in fish, insects, and plants and about 70% in mammals. Learned SRE motifs include both known SF binding motifs and unfamiliar motifs, and both motif classes are supported by genetic analyses. Our comparisons across species highlight similarities between non-mammals, increased reliance on intronic SREs in plant splicing, and a greater reliance on SREs in mammalian splicing.
ABSTRACT Pre-mRNA splicing is surveilled at different stages by quality control (QC) mechanisms. The leukemia-associated DExH-box family helicase h DHX15/ sc Prp43, is known to disassemble spliceosomes after splicing. Here, using rapid protein depletion and analysis of nascent and mature RNA to enrich for direct effects, we identified a widespread splicing QC function for DHX15 in human cells, consistent with recent in vitro studies. We found that suboptimal introns with weak splice sites, multiple branch points, and cryptic introns are repressed by DHX15, suggesting a general role in promoting splicing fidelity. We identified SUGP1 as a G-patch factor that activates DHX15’s splicing QC function. This interaction is dependent on both DHX15’s ATPase activity and on SUGP1’s ULM domain. Together, our results support a model in which DHX15 plays a major role in splicing QC when recruited and activated by SUGP1.
Abstract Background Both promoters and untranslated regions (UTRs) have critical regulatory roles, yet variants in these regions are largely excluded from clinical genetic testing due to difficulty in interpreting pathogenicity. The extent to which these regions may harbour diagnoses for individuals with rare disease is currently unknown. Methods We present a framework for the identification and annotation of potentially deleterious proximal promoter and UTR variants in known dominant disease genes. We use this framework to annotate de novo variants (DNVs) in 8,040 undiagnosed individuals in the Genomics England 100,000 genomes project, which were subject to strict region-based filtering, clinical review, and validation studies where possible. In addition, we performed region and variant annotation-based burden testing in 7,862 unrelated probands against matched unaffected controls. Results We prioritised eleven DNVs and identified an additional variant overlapping one of the eleven. Ten of these twelve variants (82%) are in genes that are a strong match to the individual's phenotype and six had not previously been identified. Through burden testing, we did not observe a significant enrichment of potentially deleterious promoter and/or UTR variants in individuals with rare disease collectively across any of our region or variant annotations. Conclusions Overall, we demonstrate the value of screening promoters and UTRs to uncover additional diagnoses for previously undiagnosed individuals with rare disease and provide a framework for doing so without dramatically increasing interpretation burden. Keywords Untranslated regions, promoters, splicing, rare disease, non-coding, regulatory regions
Figure S1 shows that pHLIP localization to the acidic tissues in vivo is pH-dependent and pHLIP- CA9 colocalization in lung mets and enrichment of pHLIP and CA9 at tumor stroma interface in mouse and human tumors
Figure S4 shows the effect of low pH on different types of splicing event and validation of candidate splicing events