Precision radial velocity spectrographs that use adaptive optics (AO) show promise to advance telescope observing capabilities beyond those of seeing-limited designs. We are building a spectrograph for the Large Binocular Telescope (LBT) named iLocater that uses AO to inject starlight directly into single mode fibers. iLocater's first acquisition camera system (the SX camera), which receives light from one of the 8.4 m diameter primary mirrors of the LBT, was initially installed in summer 2019 and has since been used for several commissioning runs. We present results from first-light observations that include on-sky measurements as part of commissioning activities. Imaging measurements of the bright B3IV star 2 Cygni (V = 4.98) resulted in the direct detection of a candidate companion star at an angular separation of only theta = 70 mas. Follow-up AO measurements using Keck/NIRC2 recover the candidate companion in multiple filters. An R approximate to 1500 miniature spectrograph recently installed at the LBT named Lili provides spatially resolved spectra of each binary component, indicating similar spectral types and strengthening the case for companionship. Studying the multiplicity of young runaway star systems like 2 Cygni (36.6 +/- 0.5 Myr) can help to understand formation mechanisms for stars that exhibit anomalous velocities through the Galaxy. This on-sky demonstration illustrates the spatial resolution of the iLocater SX acquisition camera working in tandem with the LBT AO system; it further derisks a number of technical hurdles involved in combining AO with Doppler spectroscopy.
Diffraction-limited radial-velocity instruments offer a pathway towards improved precision and stability, and the exploration of new parameter spaces at high spatial and spectral resolution. However, achieving the necessary performance requires careful instrument design and considerable on-sky testing. We describe the design and construction of 'Little iLocater' (Lili), a compact spectrograph that has been used to validate the performance of the front-end fibre-injection system of the iLocater spectrograph. We present the design, assembly, and performance using on-sky data obtained at the Large Binocular Telescope (LBT), including extraction of spectra from standard stars, testing of the atmospheric dispersion corrector to elevations of 40 degrees, and spatially resolved spectra from close companion systems. These results show the front-end fibre-injection system is performing as expected and is indicative of iLocater's capabilities once installed at the LBT.
iLocater is a near-infrared, extremely precise radial velocity (EPRV) spectrograph under construction for the dual 8.4m diameter Large Binocular Telescope (LBT). The instrument will undertake precision radial velocity studies of Earth-like planets orbiting low-mass stars. Operating in the diffraction-limited regime, iLocater uses adaptive optics to efficiently inject starlight directly into single-mode fibers that illuminate a high spectral resolution (R=190,500 median), cryogenic, diffraction-limited spectrograph. To maximize performance, the spectrograph uses a new design strategy for EPRV instruments, combining intrinsically stable materials for its optomechanical fabrication with precision optical fabrication. This novel combination will enable unique EPRV capabilities for exoplanet and astrophysics studies of the solar neighborhood. We present the final optical and mechanical designs of the spectrograph system. Ensuring the as-built spectrograph achieves its designed spectral resolution and diffraction-limited performance has required careful control of the end-to-end system wavefront error (WFE) budget. We discuss the efforts undertaken to achieve this goal including minimizing residual WFE in the optical design, assessing diffraction grating WFE performance, optimizing material choices, and requiring precision optical design and fabrication. Our goal is to deliver diffraction-limited performance across the full spectral format, which, combined with intrinsic thermal stability requirements for EPRV science, has driven the selection of silicon optics and Invar optomechanics. The system performance is further optimized using precision (sub-mK) thermal control. This set of design features will allow iLocater to achieve sub-m/s radial velocity precision in the near-infrared, and to serve as the first optimized diffraction-limited spectrograph for EPRV science.
Spectrographs nominally contain a degree of quasi-static optical aberrations resulting from the quality of manufactured component surfaces, imperfect alignment, design residuals, thermal effects, and other other associated phenomena involved in the design and construction process. Aberrations that change over time can mimic the line centroid motion of a Doppler shift, introducing radial velocity (RV) uncertainty that increases time-series variability. Even when instrument drifts are tracked using a precise wavelength calibration source, barycentric motion of the Earth leads to a wavelength shift of stellar light causing a translation of the spectrum across the focal plane array by many pixels. The wavelength shift allows absorption lines to experience different optical propagation paths and aberrations over observing epochs. We use physical optics propagation simulations to study the impact of aberrations on precise Doppler measurements made by diffraction-limited, high-resolution spectrographs. We quantify the uncertainties that cross-correlation techniques introduce in the presence of aberrations and barycentric RV shifts. We find that aberrations which shift the PSF photo-center in the dispersion direction, in particular primary horizontal coma and trefoil, are the most concerning. To maintain aberration-induced RV errors less than 10 cm/s, phase errors for these particular aberrations must be held well below 0.05 waves at the instrument operating wavelength. Our simulations further show that wavelength calibration only partially compensates for instrumental drifts, owing to a behavioral difference between how cross-correlation techniques handle aberrations between starlight versus calibration light. Identifying subtle physical effects that influence RV errors will help ensure that diffraction-limited planet-finding spectrographs are able to reach their full scientific potential.
ABSTRACT Enabling efficient injection of light into single-mode fibres (SMFs) is a key requirement in realizing diffraction-limited astronomical spectroscopy on ground-based telescopes. SMF-fed spectrographs, facilitated by the use of adaptive optics (AO), offer distinct advantages over comparable seeing-limited designs, including higher spectral resolution within a compact and stable instrument volume, and a telescope independent spectrograph design. iLocater is an extremely precise radial velocity (EPRV) spectrograph being built for the Large Binocular Telescope (LBT). We have designed and built the front-end fibre injection system, or acquisition camera, for the SX (left) primary mirror of the LBT. The instrument was installed in 2019 and underwent on-sky commissioning and performance assessment. In this paper, we present the instrument requirements, acquisition camera design, as well as results from first-light measurements. Broad-band SMF coupling in excess of 35 per cent (absolute) in the near-infrared (0.97–1.31 ${\mu {\rm m}}$) was achieved across a range of target magnitudes, spectral types, and observing conditions. Successful demonstration of on-sky performance represents both a major milestone in the development of iLocater and in making efficient ground-based SMF-fed astronomical instruments a reality.
Optimizing on-sky single-mode fiber (SMF) injection is an essential part of developing precise Doppler spectrometers and new astrophotonics technologies. We installed and tested a prototype SMF-injection system at the Large Binocular Telescope in 2016 April. The fiber injection unit was built as part of the derisking process for a new instrument named iLocater that will use adaptive optics (AO) to feed a high resolution, near-infrared spectrograph. In this paper we report Y-band SMF coupling measurements for bright, M-type stars. We compare theoretical expectations for delivered Strehl ratio and SMF coupling to experimental results, and evaluate fundamental effects that limit injection efficiency. We find the pupil geometry of the telescope itself limits fiber coupling to a maximum efficiency of 0.78. Further analysis shows the individual impact of AO correction, tip-tilt residuals, and static (noncommon-path) aberrations contribute coupling coefficients of 0.33, 0.8 respectively. Combined, these effects resulted in an average Y-band SMF efficiency of 0.18 for all observations. Finally, we investigate the impact of fiber coupling on radial velocity precision as a function of stellar apparent magnitude.
New spectroscopic technologies and techniques are needed to detect and characterize terrestrial planets located in the habitable zones around nearby stars. Existing radial velocity (RV) instruments are limited to 1 m/s single measurement precision at visible wavelengths, and several meters-per-second in the infrared. In order to determine key physical quantities of rocky worlds (mass, density, orbital elements, spin-orbit alignment, etc.), a RV precision one order of magnitude better than the current state-of-the-art is necessary. Such advances would permit the study of planets potentially capable of supporting life. Doppler spectrographs that leverage telescope adaptive optics (AO) capabilities show promise to address many of the systematic effects that prevent current instruments from otherwise achieving more precise measurements. iLocater is a near-infrared (NIR) RV spectrograph being developed for the Large Binocular Telescope (LBT) in Arizona. Unlike seeing-limited designs, iLocater uses AO to inject starlight directly into single-mode fibers (SMF), enabling high spectral resolution while simultaneously mitigating a number of systematic effects. The primary objective of this thesis is to derisk the design of iLocater and facilitate the project’s transition from initial development stages to efficient on-sky operations. An end-to-end data reduction pipeline and analysis architecture has been developed to simulate instrument performance (Chapters 2-3). Investigations into detector noise find that persistent charge remaining from previous exposures could introduce unwanted RV uncertainty without careful calibration. Mitigation strategies for persistence and other detector effects are explored (Chapter 4). Earth’s Barycentric motion creates multi-pixel lateral Doppler shifts across the detector that cannot be tracked using conventional wavelength calibration; simulations of the spectrograph optical components are used to quantify this effect, along with the impact of spatially varying aberrations, on RV precision when operating near the diffraction-limit (Chapter 5). Simulations of expected on-sky performance were essential in supporting iLocater’s successful instrument design reviews at the LBT. It is predicted that the instrument can reach approximately 0.4 m/s single measurement precision on quiescent, bright guide stars provided that telluric absorption is properly calibrated in the YJ-bands. iLocater’s first fiber injection system was commissioned in July 2019. The spectrograph and wavelength calibration system are being constructed and assembled at Notre Dame. The thesis concludes with example scientific applications that involve AO and RV measurements, including: high-contrast imaging of stars that exhibit long-term RV trends; and the discovery that two transiting planets that reside in hierarchical triple star systems (Chapter 6).
The physical properties of faint stellar and substellar objects often rely on indirect, model-dependent estimates. For example, the masses of brown dwarfs are usually inferred using evolutionary models, which are age dependent and have yet to be properly calibrated. With the goal of identifying new benchmark objects to test low-mass stellar and substellar models, we have carried out a comprehensive adaptive optics survey as part of the TaRgetting bENchmark-objects with the Doppler Spectroscopy high-contrast imaging program. Using legacy radial velocity measurements from the High Resolution Echelle Spectrometer at Keck, we have identified several dozen stars that show long-term Doppler accelerations. We present follow-up high-contrast observations from the campaign and report the discovery of 31 comoving companions, as well as 11 strong candidate companions, to solar-type stars with well-determined parallax and metallicity values. Benchmark objects of this nature lend themselves to orbit determinations, dynamical mass estimates, and independent compositional assessment. This compendium of benchmark objects will serve as a convenient test group to substantiate theoretical evolutionary and atmospheric models near the hydrogen fusing limit.
The use of single-mode fibers (SMFs) to illuminate radial velocity (RV) spectrographs shows promise to achieve extremely precise Doppler measurements. Due to their small core diameter, SMFs only propagate a single spatial mode which allows for diffraction-limited optical performance while simultaneously eliminating fiber modal noise. The single spatial mode however consists of two orthogonal polarization modes. In circular core fiber with a non-isotropic refractive index profile or asymmetries in the cross-sectional geometry, the two polarization modes propagate with different relative speeds inducing birefringence. Conditions at a telescope observatory will subject the fiber to mechanical (bending and twisting) and thermal stresses, inducing birefringence that varies in time. The interaction of variable birefringence combined with with polarization sensitive optics, such as diffraction gratings, results in an intensity modulation that causes unwanted Doppler shifts via "polarization noise." In this paper, we characterize variable fiber birefringence both in the laboratory and at the Large Binocular Telescope using a Stokes parameters. We then combine the measured Stokes vector through a numerical model of a SMF spectrograph to understand the impact of variable polarization on RV precision. We find that polarization noise is a tens of cm s(-1)to several m s(-1)effect, which is exacerbated by the degree of polarization of the light source and the polarization response of the spectrograph optics. Finally we show experimentally mitigating the RV offset using polarization averaging methods and in-line fiber depolarizers and can reduce a several m s(-1)polarization noise to sigma <= 10 cm s(-1).
EarthFinder is a NASA Astrophysics Probe mission concept selected for study as input to the 2020 Astrophysics National Academies Decadal Survey. The EarthFinder concept is based on a dramatic shift in our understanding of how PRV measurements should be made. We propose a new paradigm which brings the high precision, high cadence domain of transit photometry as demonstrated by Kepler and TESS to the challenges of PRV measurements at the cm/s level. This new paradigm takes advantage of: 1) broad wavelength coverage from the UV to NIR which is only possible from space to minimize the effects of stellar activity; 2) extremely compact, highly stable, highly efficient spectrometers (R>150,000) which require the diffraction-limited imaging possible only from space over a broad wavelength range; 3) the revolution in laser-based wavelength standards to ensure cm/s precision over many years; 4) a high cadence observing program which minimizes sampling-induced period aliases; 5) exploiting the absolute flux stability from space for continuum normalization for unprecedented line-by-line analysis not possible from the ground; and 6) focusing on the bright stars which will be the targets of future imaging missions so that EarthFinder can use a ~1.5 m telescope.
Precise Doppler radial-velocity (RV) instruments will continue to play an essential role in advancing our holistic understanding of exoplanetary systems. The combination of orbital parameters from transit surveys and follow-up RV measurements is vital to unlock mass and density estimates of detected planets, giving us insight into their environment and structure. However, the exoplanet field is reaching a critical juncture: the measurement sensitivity of existing radial-velocity instruments is becoming the limiting factor in further increasing our knowledge. Without improvement in delivered RV measurement precision, we will not be able to provide dynamical mass and density estimates for some of the most exciting (and consequently most challenging) discoveries expected from new transit missions including the Transiting Exoplanet Survey Satellite (TESS) (Plavchan et al. 2015, Ricker et al. 2014). RV precisions at the 10cm/s level are required to fully confirm earth-like analogues, provide masses and measure density to the 1-5 this RV capability will also be important to allow for efficient target selection for facilities such as the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST). A promising way forward to achieve this goal is to use single-mode fibers to inject light to a spectrograph. This mitigates many of the error terms facing current generation seeing-limited RV instruments while simultaneously offering the capability of high resolution spectroscopy within a small optical footprint (Schwab et al. 2012, Crepp 2014, Jovanovic et al. 2016a). We discuss the benefits of this technique, its challenges, and the current status of development.
The use of single-mode fibers to feed astronomical instruments is becoming a reality through technological advancements and improvements in adaptive optics. A key application is in high-spatial and high-spectral resolution measurements which offer a pathway to improve radial velocity precision for exoplanet and other astronomical studies.
iLocater is a near-infrared (NIR) radial velocity (RV) spectrograph that is being developed for the Large Binocular Telescope in Arizona. Unlike seeing-limited designs, iLocater uses adaptive optics to inject starlight directly into a single-mode fiber. This feature offers high spectral resolution while simultaneously maintaining a compact optical design. Although this approach shows promise to generate extremely precise RV measurements, it differs from conventional Doppler spectrographs, and therefore carries additional risk. To aid with the design of the instrument, we have developed a comprehensive simulator and data reduction pipeline. In this paper, we describe the simulation code and quantify its performance in the context of understanding terms in a RV error budget. We find that the program has an intrinsic precision of σ < 5 cm s−1, thereby justifying its use in a number of instrument trade studies. The code is written in Matlab and available for download on GitHub.
At wavelengths longwards of the sensitivity of silicon, hybrid structured mercury-cadmium-telluride (HgCdTe) detectors show promise to enable extremely precise radial velocity (RV) measurements of late-type stars. The most advanced near infrared (NIR) detector commercially available is the HAWAII series (HxRG) of NIR detectors. While the quantum efficiency of such devices has been shown to be approx ninety percent, the noise characteristics of these devices, and how they relate to RV measurements, have yet to be quantified. We characterize the various noise sources generated by H4RG arrays using numerical simulations. We present recent results using our end-to-end spectrograph simulator in combination with the HxRG Noise Generator, which emulates the effects of read noise, parameterized by white noise, correlated and uncorrelated pink noise, alternating column noise, and picture frame noise. The effects of nonlinear pixel response, dark current, persistence, and interpixel capacitance (IPC) on RV precision are also considered. Our results have implications for RV error budgets and instrument noise floors that can be achieved with NIR Doppler spectrographs that utilize this kind of detector.
EarthFinder is a Probe Mission concept selected for study by NASA for input to the 2020 astronomy decadal survey. This study is currently active and a final white paper report is due to NASA at the end of calendar 2018. We are tasked with evaluating the scientific rationale for obtaining precise radial velocity (PRV) measurements in space, which is a two-part inquiry: What can be gained from going to space? What can't be done form the ground? These two questions flow down to these specific tasks for our study - Identify the velocity limit, if any, introduced from micro- and macro-telluric absorption in the Earth's atmosphere; Evaluate the unique advantages that a space-based platform provides to emable the identification and mitigation of stellar acitivity for multi-planet signal recovery.
The physical properties of brown dwarf companions found to orbit nearby, solar-type stars can be benchmarked against independent measures of their mass, age, chemical composition, and other parameters, offering insights into the evolution of substellar objects. The TRENDS high-contrast imaging survey has recently discovered a (mass/age/metallicity) benchmark brown dwarf orbiting the nearby ( d = 18.69 ± 0.19 pc), G8V/K0V star HD 4747. We have acquired follow-up spectroscopic measurements of HD 4747 B using the Gemini Planet Imager to study its spectral type, effective temperature, surface gravity, and cloud properties. Observations obtained in the H -band and K 1 -band recover the companion and reveal that it is near the L/T transition (T1 ± 2). Fitting atmospheric models to the companion spectrum, we find strong evidence for the presence of clouds. However, spectral models cannot satisfactorily fit the complete data set: while the shape of the spectrum can be well-matched in individual filters, a joint fit across the full passband results in discrepancies that are a consequence of the inherent color of the brown dwarf. We also find a 2 σ tension in the companion mass, age, and surface gravity when comparing to evolutionary models. These results highlight the importance of using benchmark objects to study “secondary effects” such as metallicity, non-equilibrium chemistry, cloud parameters, electron conduction, non-adiabatic cooling, and other subtleties affecting emergent spectra. As a new L/T transition benchmark, HD 4747 B warrants further investigation into the modeling of cloud physics using higher resolution spectroscopy across a broader range of wavelengths, polarimetric observations, and continued Doppler radial velocity and astrometric monitoring.
Single-mode fiber (SMF) spectrographs fed with adaptive optics (AO) offer a unique path for achieving extremely precise radial velocity (EPRV) measurements. We present a radial velocity (RV) error budget based on end-to-end numerical simulations of an instrument named iLocater that is being developed for the Large Binocular Telescope (LBT). Representing the first AO-fed, SMF spectrograph, iLocater's design is used to quantify and assess the relative advantages and drawbacks of precise Doppler time series measurements made at the diffraction limit. This framework can be applied for trade-study work to investigate the impact of instrument design decisions on systematic uncertainties encountered in the regime of sub-meter-per-second precision. We find that working at the diffraction-limit through the use of AO and SMF's allows for high spectral resolution and improved instrument stability at the expense of limiting magnitude and longer integration times. Large telescopes equipped with AO alleviates the primary challenges of SMF spectrographs.
The demonstration of efficient single-mode fiber (SMF) coupling is a key requirement for the development of a compact, ultra-precise radial velocity (RV) spectrograph. iLocater is a next generation instrument for the Large Binocular Telescope (LBT) that uses adaptive optics (AO) to inject starlight into a SMF. In preparation for commissioning iLocater, a prototype SMF injection system was installed and tested at the LBT in the Y-band (0.970-1.065 $\mu$m). This system was designed to verify the capability of the LBT AO system as well as characterize on-sky SMF coupling efficiencies. SMF coupling was measured on stars with variable airmasses, apparent magnitudes, and seeing conditions for six half-nights using the Large Binocular Telescope Interferometer. We present the overall optical and mechanical performance of the SMF injection system, including details of the installation and alignment procedure. A particular emphasis is placed on analyzing the instrument's performance as a function of telescope elevation to inform the final design of the fiber injection system for iLocater.