Enzymatic depolymerization has the potential to contribute to nylon waste recycling. However, the implementation of a viable industrial process still lags far behind progress in enzymatic polyester recycling. Here we review the current biocatalytic nylon recycling landscape, highlighting biochemical, structural, and materials science barriers that currently limit depolymerization extents. We detail efforts to identify, engineer, and characterize new nylon depolymerases, where currently even the best biocatalysts rarely exceed ~1 wt% conversion of solid polymer to products. Based on our analyses, we suggest that limited substrate accessibility due to substrate crystallinity and hydrogen bonding, rather than intrinsic enzyme inefficiency or instability, is the primary bottleneck to enhanced depolymerization. Guided by successes in polyester enzymatic recycling, we outline a research roadmap combining nylonase engineering with polymer pretreatment, chemo-enzymatic cascades, and process analyses to accelerate development of viable enzymatic nylon recycling processes.
Lignin is a sustainable alternative to petroleum as a feedstock for the chemical industry. Emergent strategies for lignin valorization involve tandem processes in which biomass is chemo-catalytically fractionated, followed by bioconversion of the depolymerized lignin by microbial cell factories. A rate-limiting step in this bioconversion is O -demethylation of the lignin-derived monomers. The reductive catalytic fractionation of hardwood biomass generates high yields of two classes of monomers: 4-alkylguaiacols and 4-alkylsyringols. The former are O- demethylated by AgcA, a cytochrome P450, and AgcB, the cognate reductase, but there are no known enzymes that convert the latter. To develop a biocatalyst that can efficiently transform these monomers, we studied and rationally engineered AgcAB. A 1.82 Å resolution crystal structure of AgcA EP4 from Rhodococcus rhodochrous EP4 in complex with 4-ethylguaiacol identified residues Leu78, Ala293, and Phe166 as potential specificity determinants. Substitution of Ala293 and Leu78 decreased the specificity of AgcA EP4 for alkylguaiacols. Substitution of Phe166 yielded a variant that bound 4-propylsyringol but did not transform it. In contrast, the corresponding variant in the Rhodococcus aromaticivorans RHA1 homologue, AgcA RHA1 Y166A, catalyzed the O -demethylation of both methoxy groups of 4-propylsyringol with a k cat /K m of 8500 M –1 s –1 for the first O -demethylation, nearly 7-fold higher than WT AgcA RHA1 . Engineering RHA1 to express the variant yielded a strain that transformed 4-propylsyringol and 4-propylguaiacol simultaneously. Moreover, the engineered strain converted some of the 4-propylsyringol to pentanoyl-CoA, consistent with catabolism via the meta -cleavage pathway that catabolizes 4-alkylguaiacols. Exometabolomics validated the conversion of 4-propylsyringol via this pathway and identified O -demethylation and extradiol ring cleavage as bottlenecks for its transformation. These studies improve our understanding of a critical lignin-degrading enzyme system and significantly advance the development of a biocatalyst to convert these monomers.
Lignin is a sustainable alternative to petroleum as a feedstock for the chemical industry. Emergent strategies for lignin valorization involve tandem processes in which biomass is chemo-catalytically fractionated, followed by bioconversion of the depolymerized lignin by microbial cell factories. A rate-limiting step in this bioconversion is O-demethylation of the lignin-derived monomers. The reductive catalytic fractionation of hardwood biomass generates high yields of two classes of monomers: 4-alkylguaiacols and 4-alkylsyringols. The former are O-demethylated by AgcA, a cytochrome P450, and AgcB, the cognate reductase, but there are no known enzymes that convert the latter. To develop a biocatalyst that can efficiently transform these monomers, we studied and rationally engineered AgcAB. A 1.82 & Aring; resolution crystal structure of AgcAEP4 from EP4 in complex with 4-ethylguaiacol identified residues Leu78, Ala293, and Phe166 as potential specificity determinants. Substitution of Ala293 and Leu78 decreased the specificity of AgcAEP4 for alkylguaiacols. Substitution of Phe166 yielded a variant that bound 4-propylsyringol but did not transform it. In contrast, the corresponding variant in the RHA1 homologue, AgcARHA1 Y166A, catalyzed the O-demethylation of both methoxy groups of 4-propylsyringol with a k cat /K m of 8500 M-1 s-1 for the first O-demethylation, nearly 7-fold higher than WT AgcARHA1. Engineering RHA1 to express the variant yielded a strain that transformed 4-propylsyringol and 4-propylguaiacol simultaneously. Moreover, the engineered strain converted some of the 4-propylsyringol to pentanoyl-CoA, consistent with catabolism via the meta-cleavage pathway that catabolizes 4-alkylguaiacols. Exometabolomics validated the conversion of 4-propylsyringol via this pathway and identified O-demethylation and extradiol ring cleavage as bottlenecks for its transformation. These studies improve our understanding of a critical lignin-degrading enzyme system and significantly advance the development of a biocatalyst to convert these monomers.
Enzymatic hydrolysis of poly-(ethylene terephthalate) (PET) releases mono-(2-hydroxyethyl) terephthalate (MHET) as a major product, the accumulation of which can prolong reactor residence times and complicate downstream monomer separations. The use of a MHETase enzyme can enable MHET hydrolysis to the monomers, terephthalic acid and ethylene glycol, but industrial PETases typically operate at thermophilic temperatures and the well-known MHETase from Ideonella sakaiensis is a mesophilic enzyme, thus warranting the development of thermophilic MHETases. Here, we characterize thermostable MHET-active enzymes from a natural diversity screen by applying a hidden Markov model based on the previously reported, archaeal ferulic acid esterase, PET46. We identified enzymes with higher thermostability than PET46 and quantified their MHETase activity in reactions at 70 °C. The crystal structure of MHT077, the homologue with the highest MHETase activity and an apparent melting temperature (T m,app) of 94.6 °C, informed site saturation mutagenesis in the active site and lid-domain interface. MHT077 exhibited a ∼100-fold slower unfolding rate at 65 °C than PET46, indicating substantially greater kinetic stability. In parallel, we applied evolution-informed design, a probabilistic model that leverages coevolutionary patterns in large multiple sequence alignments, to improve the activity and thermostability of five ferulic acid esterases. One design, EV-MHT043-5 was identified with a comparable thermostability (T m,app = 96.1 °C) and a 3-fold improvement in its MHETase activity relative to the wildtype enzyme, MHT043. Combination variants of beneficial mutations were screened and afforded a variant, MHT077LFK, which reduced MHET accumulation in bioreactor experiments with postconsumer PET waste. Overall, this study expands the known MHET-hydrolyzing protein scaffolds available for enzymatic PET recycling.
Enzymatic depolymerization of poly(ethylene terephthalate) (PET) has received considerable attention for closed-loop polyester recycling. However, current approaches for enzymatic PET recycling face challenges to achieve commercial viability with lower environmental impacts compared with virgin polyester manufacturing. Here we present multiple process innovations for enzymatic PET recycling that enable economic and environmental feasibility. We show that substrate amorphization through extrusion and quenching is energy-efficient and enables near-quantitative enzymatic conversion in 50 h. Using ammonium hydroxide for pH control and thermolysis of the isolated diammonium terephthalate salt reduces the acid and base consumption by >99 Enzymatic recycling is an emerging technology to circularize the ubiquitous polyester poly(ethylene terephthalate). Here the authors evaluate and implement multiple process changes to improve the scalability and viability of this recycling technology. Process modeling demonstrates that these changes could enable cost competitiveness and greatly reduce overall life cycle impacts.
The enzymatic depolymerization of poly-(ethylene terephthalate) (PET) is emerging as a leading chemical recycling technology for waste polyester. As part of this endeavor, new candidate enzymes identified from natural diversity can serve as useful starting points for enzyme evolution and engineering. In this study, we improved upon HMM searches by applying an iterative machine learning strategy to identify 400 putative PET-degrading enzymes (PET hydrolases) from naturally occurring homologs. Using high-throughput (HTP) experimental techniques, we successfully expressed and purified >200 enzyme candidates and assayed them for PET hydrolysis activity as a function of pH, temperature, and substrate crystallinity. From this library, we discovered 91 previously unknown PET hydrolases, 35 of which retain activity at pH 4.5 on crystalline material, which are conditions relevant to developing more efficient commercial processes. Notably, four enzymes showed equal to or higher activity than LCC-ICCG, a benchmark PET hydrolase, at this challenging condition in our screening assay, and 11 of which have pH optima <7. Using these data, we identified regions of PETases statistically correlated to activity at lower pH. We additionally investigated the effect of condition-specific activity data on trained machine learning predictors and found a precision (putative hit rate) improvement of up to 30% compared to a Hidden Markov Model alone. Our findings show that by pointing enzyme discovery toward conditions of interest with multiple rounds of experimental and machine learning, we can discover large sets of active enzymes and explore factors associated with activity at those conditions.
This paper discusses the scale-up feasibility and industrial adoption of polyhydroxyalkanoates (PHAs), emphasizing the need to link PHA development with recycling technologies and highlighting strategies for designing PHAs for closed-loop recycling.
Polyethylene terephthalate (PET), the most abundantly produced polyester plastic, can be depolymerized by the Ideonella sakaiensis PETase enzyme. Based on multiple PETase crystal structures, the reaction has been proposed to proceed via a two-step serine hydrolase mechanism mediated by a serine-histidine-aspartate catalytic triad. To elucidate the multi-step PETase catalytic mechanism, we use transition path sampling and likelihood maximization to identify optimal reaction coordinates for the PETase enzyme. We predict that deacylation is likely rate-limiting, and the reaction coordinates for both steps include elements describing nucleophilic attack, ester bond cleavage, and the “moving-histidine” mechanism. We find that the flexibility of Trp185 promotes the reaction, providing an explanation for decreased activity observed in mutations that restrict Trp185 motion. Overall, this study uses unbiased computational approaches to reveal the detailed reaction mechanism necessary for further engineering of an important class of enzymes for plastics bioconversion.
Cytochromes P450 (P450s) are a superfamily of hemecontaining enzymes possessing a broad range of monooxygenase activities. One such activity is O-demethylation, an essential and rate-determining step in emerging strategies to valorize lignin that employ carbon-carbon - carbon bond cleavage. We recently identified fi ed PbdA, a P450 from Rhodococcus jostii RHA1, and PbdB, its cognate reductase, which catalyze the O-demethylation of para-methoxylated benzoates (p p-MBAs) to initiate growth of RHA1 on these compounds. PbdA had the highest affinity fi nity (Kd K d = 3.8 +/- 0.6 m M) and apparent specificity fi city (kcat/KM k cat / K M = 20,000 +/- 3000 M-1 s-1)-1 ) for pMBA. The enzyme also O-demethylated two related lignin-derived aromatic compounds with remarkable efficiency: fi ciency: veratrate and isovanillate. PbdA also catalyzed the hydroxylation and dehydrogenation of pethylbenzoate even though RHA1 did not grow on this compound. Atomic-resolution structures of PbdA in complex with p-MBA, pethylbenzoate, and veratrate revealed a cluster of three residues that form hydrogen bonds with the substrates' ' carboxylate: Ser87, Ser237, and Arg84. Substitution of these residues resulted in lower affinity fi nity and O-demethylation activity on p-MBA as well as increased affinity fi nity for the acetyl analog, pmethoxyacetophenone. The S87A and S237A variants of PbdA also catalyzed the O-demethylation of an aldehyde analog of p-MBA, p-methoxy-benzaldehyde, while the R84M variant did not, despite binding this compound with high affi nity. These results suggest that Ser87, Ser237, and Arg84 are not only important determinants of specificity fi city but also help to orientate that substrate correctly in the active site. This study facilitates the design of biocatalysts for lignin valorization.
Deciphering the mechanisms of bacterial fatty acid biosynthesis is crucial for both the engineering of bacterial hosts to produce fatty acid-derived molecules and the development of new antibiotics. However, gaps in our understanding of the initiation of fatty acid biosynthesis remain. Here, we demonstrate that the industrially relevant microbe Pseudomonas putida KT2440 contains three distinct pathways to initiate fatty acid biosynthesis. The first two routes employ conventional β-ketoacyl-ACP synthase III enzymes, FabH1 and FabH2, that accept short- and medium-chain-length acyl-CoAs, respectively. The third route utilizes a malonyl-ACP decarboxylase enzyme, MadB. A combination of exhaustive in vivo alanine-scanning mutagenesis, in vitro biochemical characterization, X-ray crystallography, and computational modeling elucidate the presumptive mechanism of malonyl-ACP decarboxylation via MadB. Given that functional homologs of MadB are widespread throughout domain Bacteria, this ubiquitous alternative fatty acid initiation pathway provides new opportunities to target a range of biotechnology and biomedical applications.
Lignin valorization is being intensely pursued via tandem catalytic depolymerization and biological funneling to produce single products. In many lignin depolymerization processes, aromatic dimers and oligomers linked by carbon-carbon bonds remain intact, necessitating the development of enzymes capable of cleaving these compounds to monomers. Recently, the catabolism of erythro-1,2-diguaiacylpropane-1,3-diol (erythro-DGPD), a ring-opened lignin-derived β-1 dimer, was reported in Novosphingobium aromaticivorans. The first enzyme in this pathway, LdpA (formerly LsdE), is a member of the nuclear transport factor 2 (NTF-2)-like structural superfamily that converts erythro-DGPD to lignostilbene through a heretofore unknown mechanism. In this study, we performed biochemical, structural, and mechanistic characterization of the N. aromaticivorans LdpA and another homolog identified in Sphingobium sp. SYK-6, for which activity was confirmed in vivo. For both enzymes, we first demonstrated that formaldehyde is the C1 reaction product, and we further demonstrated that both enantiomers of erythro-DGPD were transformed simultaneously, suggesting that LdpA, while diastereomerically specific, lacks enantioselectivity. We also show that LdpA is subject to a severe competitive product inhibition by lignostilbene. Three-dimensional structures of LdpA were determined using X-ray crystallography, including substrate-bound complexes, revealing several residues that were shown to be catalytically essential. We used density functional theory to validate a proposed mechanism that proceeds via dehydroxylation and formation of a quinone methide intermediate that serves as an electron sink for the ensuing deformylation. Overall, this study expands the range of chemistry catalyzed by the NTF-2-like protein family to a prevalent lignin dimer through a cofactorless deformylation reaction.
Enzyme-based depolymerization is a viable approach for recycling of poly(ethylene terephthalate) (PET). PETase from Ideonella sakaiensis (IsPETase) is capable of PET hydrolysis under mild conditions but suffers from concentration-dependent inhibition. In this study, this inhibition is found to be dependent on incubation time, the solution conditions, and PET surface area. Furthermore, this inhibition is evident in other mesophilic PET-degrading enzymes to varying degrees, independent of the level of PET depolymerization activity. The inhibition has no clear structural basis, but moderately thermostable IsPETase variants exhibit reduced inhibition, and the property is completely absent in the highly thermostable HotPETase, previously engineered by directed evolution, which simulations suggest results from reduced flexibility around the active site. This work highlights a limitation in applying natural mesophilic hydrolases for PET hydrolysis and reveals an unexpected positive outcome of engineering these enzymes for enhanced thermostability.
The Cover Feature shows the effect of concentration dependent inhibition of natural enzymes that break down poly(ethylene terephthalate) (PET), a polymer widely used in consumer packaging and which contributes to plastic pollution. Mesophilic enzymes (depicted on the right), such as IsPETase from Ideonella sakaiensis, are inhibited as the enzyme concentration increases. In contrast, enzymes engineered to be thermostable (depicted on the left), are not susceptible to this inhibition and can degrade PET at high enzyme concentration. More information can be found in the Research Article by L. Avilan et al. Image credit: Scivetica/Rita Clare.
Southeast Asia is considered to have some of the highest levels of marine plastic pollution in the world. It is therefore vitally important to increase our understanding of the impacts and risks of plastic pollution to marine ecosystems and the essential services they provide to support the development of mitigation measures in the region. An interdisciplinary, international network of experts (Australia, Indonesia, Ireland, Malaysia, the Philippines, Singapore, Thailand, the United Kingdom, and Vietnam) set a research agenda for marine plastic pollution in the region, synthesizing current knowledge and highlighting areas for further research in Southeast Asia. Using an inductive method, 21 research questions emerged under five non-predefined key themes, grouping them according to which: (1) characterise marine plastic pollution in Southeast Asia; (2) explore its movement and fate across the region; (3) describe the biological and chemical modifications marine plastic pollution undergoes; (4) detail its environmental, social, and economic impacts; and, finally, (5) target regional policies and possible solutions. Questions relating to these research priority areas highlight the importance of better understanding the fate of marine plastic pollution, its degradation, and the impacts and risks it can generate across communities and different ecosystem services. Knowledge of these aspects will help support actions which currently suffer from transboundary problems, lack of responsibility, and inaction to tackle the issue from its point source in the region. Being profoundly affected by marine plastic pollution, Southeast Asian countries provide an opportunity to test the effectiveness of innovative and socially inclusive changes in marine plastic governance, as well as both high and low-tech solutions, which can offer insights and actionable models to the rest of the world.
Enzymatic deconstruction of poly(ethylene terephthalate) (PET) is under intense investigation, given the ability of hydrolase enzymes to depolymerize PET to its constituent monomers near the polymer glass transition temperature. To date, reported PET hydrolases have been sourced from a relatively narrow sequence space. Here, we identify additional PET-active biocatalysts from natural diversity by using bioinformatics and machine learning to mine 74 putative thermotolerant PET hydrolases. We successfully express, purify, and assay 51 enzymes from seven distinct phylogenetic groups; observing PET hydrolysis activity on amorphous PET film from 37 enzymes in reactions spanning pH from 4.5–9.0 and temperatures from 30–70 °C. We conduct PET hydrolysis time-course reactions with the best-performing enzymes, where we observe differences in substrate selectivity as function of PET morphology. We employed X-ray crystallography and AlphaFold to examine the enzyme architectures of all 74 candidates, revealing protein folds and accessory domains not previously associated with PET deconstruction. Overall, this study expands the number and diversity of thermotolerant scaffolds for enzymatic PET deconstruction.
The application of microbes to valorize aromatic compounds derived from the abundant plant biopolymer lignin is a rapidly developing area of research that may ultimately enable viable conversion of this recalcitrant and heterogeneous resource to valuable bio-based chemical products. Starting from the three canonical lignin building blocks, which differ in the extent of aromatic ring methoxylation, several common classes of enzymatic reaction occur in the upper pathways of aromatic catabolism to prepare aromatic compounds for assimilation into central carbon metabolism, including aromatic O -demethylation, hydroxylation and decarboxylation. These critical enzymatic steps can often be rate-limiting for efficient biological funnelling of aromatic compounds. Here we review the known enzymatic mechanisms for these reactions that are relevant for aerobic aromatic catabolism of lignin-related monomers, highlighting opportunities at the intersection of biochemistry, enzyme engineering and metabolic engineering for applications in the expanding field of microbial lignin valorization.
In nature, enzymes that deconstruct biological polymers, such as cellulose and chitin, often exhibit multi-domain architectures, comprising a catalytic domain and a non-catalytic binding module; the latter serves to increase the enzyme concentration at the substrate surface. This multi-domain architecture has been shown to improve the hydrolysis of poly(ethylene terephthalate) (PET) using engineered cutinase enzymes. Here, we examine the role of accessory binding modules at industrially relevant PET solids loadings necessary for cost-effective enzymatic recycling. Using a thermostable variant of leaf compost cutinase (LCC), we produced synthetic fusion constructs of LCC with five type A carbohydrate-binding modules (CBMs). At solids loadings below 10 wt %, the CBMs improve aromatic monomer yield from PET, but above this threshold, conversion extents up to 97% are reached with no added benefits from the presence of CBM fusions. This suggests that fusion constructs with the herein studied CBMs are not necessary for industrial enzymatic PET recycling.
Significance More than 400 million tons of plastic waste is produced each year, the overwhelming majority of which ends up in landfills. Bioconversion strategies aimed at plastics have emerged as important components of enabling a circular economy for synthetic plastics, especially those that exhibit chemically similar linkages to those found in nature, such as polyesters. The enzyme system described in this work is essential for mineralization of the xenobiotic components of poly(ethylene terephthalate) (PET) in the biosphere. Our description of its structure and substrate preferences lays the groundwork for in vivo or ex vivo engineering of this system for PET upcycling.
Esterase enzymes catalyze diverse hydrolysis reactions with important biological, commercial, and biotechnological applications. For the improvement of these biocatalysts, there is a need for widely accessible, inexpensive, and adaptable activity screening assays that identify enzymes with particular substrate specificities. Natural systems for biopolymer bioconversion, and likely those designed to mimic them, depend on cocktails of enzymes, each of which specifically targets the intact material as well as water-soluble subunits of varying size. In this work, we have adapted a UV/visible assay using pH-sensitive sulfonphthalein dyes for the real-time quantification of ester hydrolysis of bis-(2-hydroxyethyl) terephthalate (BHET), a subunit of polyethylene terephthalate (PET) plastic. We applied this method to a diverse set of known PET hydrolases and commercial esterases in a microplate format. The approach identified four PET hydrolases and one commercial esterase with high levels of specificity for BHET hydrolysis. Five additional PET hydrolases and three commercial esterases, including a thermophilic enzyme, effectively hydrolyzed both BHET and its monoester product MHET (mono-(2-hydroxyethyl) terephthalate). Specific activities were discernible within one hour and reactions reached an unequivocal endpoint well within 24 hours. The results from the UV/visible method correlated well with conventional HPLC analysis of the reaction products. We examined the suitability of the method toward variable pH, temperature, enzyme preparation method, mono- and multi-ester substrate type, and level of sensitivity versus stringency, finding the assay to be easily adaptable to diverse screening conditions and kinetic measurements. This method offers an accurate, easily accessible, and cost-effective route towards high-throughput library screening to support the discovery, directed evolution, and protein engineering of these critical biocatalysts.
Aryl-O-demethylation is a common rate-limiting step in the catabolism of lignin- related compounds, including guaiacol. Here we used randomly barcoded transposon insertion sequencing (RB-TnSeq) in the bacterium Novosphingobium aromaticivorans to identify a Rieske-type guaiacol O-demethylase, GdmA. Similarity searches identified GdmA homologs in other bacteria, along with candidate reductase partners, denoted GdmB. GdmAB combinations were biochemically characterized for activity with several lignin-related substrates. Structural and sequence comparisons of vanillate- and guaiacol-specific O- demethylase active sites revealed conserved hallmarks of substrate specificity. GdmAB combinations were also evaluated in Pseudomonas putida KT2440, which does not natively utilize guaiacol. GdmAB from Cupriavidus necator N-1 demonstrated the highest rate of guaiacol turnover in vitro and in engineered P. putida strains and notably higher catalytic efficiency than a cytochrome P450 system ( GcoAB) and the vanillate Riesketype O-demethylase from P. putida (VanAB). The GdmAB O-demethylases described here expand the suite of options for microbial conversion of a model lignin-derived substrate.