The production and use of sustainable aviation fuel (SAF) could lower aviation's carbon footprint. Feedstock agricultural management can optimize-or potentially determine-SAF sustainability and profitability, but long-term SAF feedstock comparisons are limited. Life cycle assessments (LCA) are commonly used to estimate the carbon intensity of producing SAF from emerging feedstocks due to the limited availability of long-term, primary field data. We quantified the agricultural phase and well-to-wake (WTWa) carbon intensities of producing SAF from no-till, continuous corn (Zea mays L.) under 120 kg N ha(-1) year(-1) (120 N corn) and switchgrass (Panicum virgatum L.) under 60 or 120 kg N ha(-1) year(-1) (60 N and 120 N SWG, respectively) via LCAs based on measured data from a long-term (1998-present) field experiment on marginally productive cropland located in Eastern NE, USA. Measured data included crop productivity, long-term changes in soil organic carbon (SOC) stocks (0-150 cm), annual soil N2O emissions, and field management practices. Both 120 N corn (2078 L ha(-1)) and 120 N SWG (1752 L ha(-1)) produced more SAF than 60 N SWG (1229 L ha(-1)) (p < 0.0001). However, making SAF from corn had greater life cycle GHG emissions (i.e., WTWa carbon intensity) than making SAF from 120 N and 60 N SWG (61.5 > -14.5 and -27.5 g CO(2)e MJ(-1) SAF, respectively; p = 0.0007), primarily due to SOC accrual during crop production. Here, we demonstrate that agricultural management (e.g., crop type, fertilizer use) can determine the sustainably and productivity of producing SAF by using long-term, measured field data in LCAs.
ABSTRACT The capacity to produce switchgrass efficiently and cost‐effectively across diverse environments can be pivotal in achieving the short‐ and medium‐term Sustainable Aviation Fuel targets set by the U.S. Department of Energy. This study evaluated the economic performance of forage‐ and bioenergy‐type switchgrass cultivars and their response to N fertilization under diverse marginal environments across the US Midwest that included Illinois (IL), Iowa (IA), Nebraska (NE), and South Dakota (SD). Data Envelopment Analysis (DEA) was used to evaluate the efficiency of 23 Decision‐Making Units (DMUs)—cultivar types and N fertilization rate combinations—while a cost–benefit analysis calculated their profitability over 5 years. Results showed that two energy‐type cultivars—“Independence” and “Liberty”—were superior economically to the forage cultivars. Independence performed best with the highest profit margin when fertilized at 56 kg N ha−1, particularly in the US hardiness zone 6a (Urbana, IL). Liberty exhibited the highest profit margins in hardiness zone 5b (Madrid, IA, and Ithaca, NE) at 56 kg N ha−1 and showed exceptional profitability with 28 kg N ha−1 in hardiness zone 6b (Brighton, IL). Switchgrass cultivar “Carthage” showed better efficiency score and profitability results in hardiness zone 4b (South Shore, SD) at 56 kg N ha−1. The profit trends observed in current study sites may indicate broader patterns across similar US hardiness zones. This study provides valuable insights for decision‐makers to optimize input strategies for biomass production of bioenergy switchgrass to meet renewable energy demands.
Guayule (Parthenium argentatum A. Gray) is a valuable domestic source for rubber and resin. At its center of origin in the Northern Mexico and Southern Texas deserts, guayule, a perennial shrub, is hybridized with its relative species mariola (Parthenium incanum Kunth). As rubber and resin are the main products derived from guayule, there is interest in using guayule bagasse as a bioenergy feedstock to meet the growing bioenergy and biofuel demands. This study aimed to explore and characterize phenotypic diversity in cell wall constituents (lignin, cellulose, and hemicellulose) and their yields among 51 guayule and mariola genotypes under two irrigation regimes (well-watered and water-stressed). Significant genotypic and environmental effects were observed for lignin, cellulose and hemicellulose concentrations, and yields, indicating the wide genetic variability of the collection for bioenergy-related traits. Moderate to high entry-mean heritability values for lignin, cellulose, and hemicellulose suggest that selection is feasible to enhance genetic gain. Significant positive correlations were found among cellulose and hemicellulose concentrations and yields, indicating the possibility to select multiple traits together during breeding cycles. High positive correlations between rubber and resin and lignin, cellulose, and hemicellulose yields highlight the opportunity to develop guayule germplasm with enhanced multi-use traits for industrial applications. Wide variations in drought stress indices (stress tolerance index, yield index, and yield stability index) underscore the environmental impact on the lignocellulosic traits. Several genotypes were identified with high stress index scores and could be parental candidates for improving guayule for arid and semi-arid sustainable agricultural systems. The current study is the first to characterize the phenotypic diversities in guayule and mariola for lignocellulosic components and yield, providing the foundation for future breeding efforts aimed at enhancing guayule’s value for diverse production goals and environmental conditions.
Estimating soil organic carbon (SOC) stocks in agricultural fields is essential for environmental and agronomic research, management, and policy. Stratified sampling is a classic strategy for estimating mean soil properties, and has recently been codified in SOC monitoring protocols. However, for the specific task of estimating the SOC stock of an agricultural field, concrete guidance is needed for which covariates to stratify on and how much stratification can improve estimation efficiency. It is also unknown how stratified sampling of SOC stocks compares to modern alternatives, notably doubly balanced sampling. To address these gaps, we collected high-density (average of 7 samples ha−1) and deep (average of 75 cm) measurements of SOC stocks at eight commercial fields under maize-soybean production in two US Midwestern states. We combined these measurements with a Bayesian geostatistical model to evaluate stratified and balanced sampling strategies that use a set of readily-available geographic, topographic, spectroscopic, and soil survey data. We examined the number of samples needed to achieve a given level of SOC stock estimation accuracy. While stratified sampling using these variables enables an average sample size reduction of 17% (95% CI, 11% to 23%) compared to simple random sampling, doubly balanced sampling is consistently more efficient, reducing sample sizes by 32% (95% CI, 25% to 37%). The data most important to these efficiency gains are a remotely-sensed SOC index, SSURGO estimates of SOC stocks, and the topographic wetness index. We conclude that in order to meet the urgent challenge of climate change, SOC stocks in agricultural fields could be more efficiently estimated by taking advantage of this readily-available data, especially with doubly balanced sampling.
Soybean harvest leaves little residue, potentially subjecting the soil to negative environmental impacts. Additionally, integrated livestock producers with crops and cattle identified a need to fill early spring forage deficiencies. Planting winter-hardy cereal cover crops after soybean harvest provides ground cover until the next cash crop is planted and has potential for early spring grazing before perennial pastures are ready. A 3-year study was conducted near Mead, Nebraska to evaluate the grazing potential of winter wheat, winter triticale, and cereal rye when planted after soybean harvest. A 7.3-ha field was split into nine 0.81-h paddocks and paddocks were then randomly assigned to a small cereal species (n = 3 paddocks per treatment), then divided further into 2, 0.4 ha paddocks to allow for rotational grazing within the assigned paddock. Growing steers were stratified by body weight (BW) and randomly assigned to paddock with 6 steers per paddock in years 1 and 2, and 5 steers per paddock in year 3. Steers were limit-fed at 2% of BW to equalize gut fill and weighed before and at the conclusion of grazing. Grazing was initiated when a paddock reached 13 cm. The initial BW did not differ among treatments (P > 0.05) with steers weighing 303, 335, and 372 kg in years 1 through 3, respectively. The final BW did not differ among treatments (P > 0.05). There was a treatment by year interaction (P ≤ 0.01) for average daily gain (ADG). There were no differences (P > 0.05) in ADG among treatments in year 1 (1.9 kg/d) or year 3 (1.3 kg/d). However, in year 2, steers grazing rye gained more (P < 0.01) at 1.4 kg than wheat (0.83 kg) and triticale (0.67 kg), which did not differ (P > 0.05). There were no differences (P > 0.05) among treatments for animal unit months (AUM) per hectare. Year 1 provided the most (P < 0.01) grazing at 5.1 AUM/ha, year 2 provided the least (P < 0.01) at 2.4 AUM/ha, and year 3 was intermediate at 3.1 AUM/ha. For gain per hectare (GPH), there were no differences (P > 0.05) among treatments. Steers in year 1 had greater (P < 0.01) GPH (390 kg/ha) than subsequent years, with year 2 (93 kg/ha) being less (P < 0.01) than year 3 (151 kg/ha). For all 3 years, there were no differences among treatments in pre-graze (P > 0.05) or post-graze biomass (P > 0.05). These data suggest that during early spring there are no major differences in the grazing potential and growing cattle performance for wheat, rye, or triticale in eastern Nebraska.
Maintaining low levels of rust incidence (caused by Puccinia novopanici) in switchgrass (Panicum virgatum L.) breeding populations is a priority for the USDA-ARS program engaged in improving cultivars for high biomass yield and quality. Essential to this goal is the unbiased and accurate estimation of genetic parameters to predict the merits of parents and progeny. Spores of the fungus were inoculated in greenhouse-grown seedling progeny of 31 half-sib families in generation 2 (Gen 2) of a composite Summer × Kanlow population for evaluation of rust incidence on the leaves with a 0–9 rating scale. Two parents were later chosen to cross and develop a linkage mapping population as Gen 3. The Gen 2, 3, and Kanlow seedlings were transplanted into the field located near Mead, NE, in early June 2020 and laid out as a replicated row–column design with six blocks of single-row plots of five plants each. The field trial was rated in September 2021 and 2022 with a 0–4 scale. Lab and field data were subjected to univariate linear mixed models via the restricted maximum likelihood to extract the variance components needed to predict the breeding values. The additive genetic variation was substantial (p < 0.01), enough to result in high heritability estimates ranging from 0.42 ± 14 to 0.73 ± 0.09 at the individual and family mean levels. This result implies that rust resistance is under strong genetic control to use mass selection for obtaining satisfactory gains. A possible rust incidence x year interaction was detected with a Spearman correlation of breeding values of −0.38, caused by significant rank changes of the Gen 3 genotypes in 2022 (a high heat and drought year). Genetic gains were predicted to reduce rust incidence scores by at least two points on the rating scale when selecting backwards, and by one point when selecting individual candidates as parents of the next generation. Faster gains (31 and 59%) were realized relative to the second generation by respectively selecting the top 10% of the families in Gen 3 or the top 10% of genotypes within this group. Based on these results, strategies for controlling the incidence of rust will be developed to optimize gains in the other traits of economic importance.
Obtaining greater genetic gains, particularly for biomass yield, requires a good understanding of the gene action governing the inheritance of traits with economic importance in switchgrass (Panicum virgatum L.). Individual genotypes from three different accessions were crossed in single-pair matings with reciprocals to assess the relative importance of additive to nonadditive genetic variation and the potential of using inter-ecotypic crosses to improve dry matter yield (DMY), in vitro dry matter digestibility (IVDMD), lignin content (ADL and KL), and ethanol yield (ETOH). Crosses and four reference populations were planted in a randomized complete block design with eight replications of single family-rows plots, with five-plants each and 1 m spacings. A linear mixed model was applied as per the restricted maximum likelihood method, integrated with a pedigree tracing back to the original founders of these parental populations, and augmented with the designation of four genetic groups. Variation due to SCA (specific combining ability) was predominant for all traits, contributing from 20% to 57% of the total phenotypic variation and with Baker’s ratios (GCA/SCA) varying from 0.003 to 0.67. Heritability values calculated at the fullsib-family mean level were moderate to very high. Variation due to GCA (general combining ability) was detected with a lesser significance for DMY and ETOH. A reciprocal GCA effect was present in the form of maternal inheritance for DMY, suggesting the use of the highest biomass-yielding parent as female in inter-ecotypic breeding. Selecting and deploying fullsib families, deploying clonal hybrids, and adopting an introgression breeding approach are all possibilities available to switchgrass breeders to exploit the complementary genes from this germplasm and capitalize on the non-additive genetic variation present in these crosses.
Harnessing energy for cooking, heating, eating, and travel is a fundamental human requirement and, prior to fossil fuel adoption, much energy was derived from local landscapes. In the North American Great Plains, the nineteenth century was a period of rapid social-ecological change, and adaptive fuel procurement was at its core. Here, we review nineteenth-century accounts of energy acquisition and use in Great Plains landscapes, documenting the utilities, renewabilities and geographic distributions of important organic fuels, excluding coal. Native and Euro-Americans devised and adopted diverse strategies for accessing energy stored in herbaceous biomass and woody biomass, which, although variable in form, availability, specific energy and energy density, could generally be obtained locally and regenerate relatively quickly. Three forms of herbaceous biomass - forage (undigested), buffalo chips (partially digested) and pemmican (metabolized) - were associated with ubiquity of prairie vegetation and bison, whereas woody biomass was a rarer fuel largely restricted to lowlands and decreasing from east to west. Amidst transformational waves of colonisation in dynamic environments, seasonal strategies for securing energy locally were supplanted by strategies of fuel storage and importation. All fuel-based adaptations had social-ecological causes and consequences and, in nineteenth century plains landscapes, colonisation facilitated rapid, cross-cultural exchanges of fuel sources, technologies, strategies for increasing energy access and human environmental influences that collectively shaped regional environmental history.
Abstract Cool‐season grass species (18) and cultivars (85) were evaluated for use in seeded grasslands in the tallgrass prairie and shortgrass steppe ecoregions of the central United States at the test locations of Ithaca and Sidney, NE, respectively. Both native and introduced grasses were evaluated in sward trails. Significant differences existed among species and cultivars for all traits evaluated except for in vitro dry matter digestibility (IVDMD) among cultivars within species at Sidney. The grasses that had the best establishment, persistence, and forage yields in the Ithaca trial were introduced wheatgrass (Thinopyrum) and bromegrass (Bromus) species. At the Sidney location, the best species using the same criteria were wheatgrasses (Thinopyrum, Agropryon, Pascopyrum, and Elymus spp.) and wildryes (Psathyrostachys). The only native grasses that were marginally competitive with the introduced grasses were western wheatgrass [Pascopyrum smithii (Rydb.) A. Löve] and thickspike wheatgrass [Elymus macrourus (Turcz.) Tzvelev] at the Sidney location and western wheatgrass at Ithaca. The study was the largest cool‐season forage grass multispecies and cultivar sward evaluation to date in these two major land areas. The superior species and cultivars that were identified represent the best cool‐season grasses available for restoring marginal croplands to grazed grasslands in these two major land areas.
Obtaining good accuracy and reliability of estimated breeding values is essential to increase the efficiency of a plant breeding program. Genetic variation was assessed for categorical (Virc) and binary (Virb) mosaic (caused by Panicum mosaic virus), dry matter (DMY) and predicted ethanol (Etoh) yields, and lignin content (Klason or KL, and acid-detergent or ADL) in a Summer-Kanlow switchgrass (Panicum virgatum L.) population. Breeding values were predicted with the restricted maximum likelihood-best linear unbiased prediction (REML-BLUP) approaches using a multivariate phenotypic (PBLUP) and animal (ABLUP) models, integrating a three-generation pedigree (1,622 half-sibs) in ABLUP and not in PBLUP. Models were compared in their precision (accuracy and reliability) in assessing genetic parameters and estimating breeding values. The models were similar in most aspects, allocating the highest heritability (hi2) values to DMY (.38 +/- .035 vs. .41 +/- .035), Etoh (.46 +/- .031 vs. .42 +/- .033), and Virc (.43 +/- .046 vs. .37 +/- .047) and the lowest (.17 +/- .032 to .30 +/- .044) to KL, ADL, and Virb. Genetic correlations were always larger than residual and phenotypic correlations. Intermediate or strong additive genetic control suggest that selecting for high-biomass genotypes will slightly increase lignin content and simultaneously impart mosaic tolerance. Mitigating an increase in lignin content will require including Etoh in a selection index based on its much stronger negative correlation (r(G) = -.63) with lignin. In this population, accuracy values ranged from .06 to .94 (PBLUP) and from .26 to .92 (ABLUP) and corresponding reliability ranged from .004 to .89 and from .07 to .87. However, ABLUP improved average reliability of DMY and Etoh by 11% and of other traits by 4-5% over the PBLUP model. The ABLUP was a better model over PBLUP, which is a valid analysis in the absence of a pedigree.
Integrated crop–livestock systems (ICLSs) can help increase food production while benefiting soils and the environment. This review summarizes recent impacts of ICLSs on crop and livestock production and rural economics and discusses lessons learned in the northern Great Plains (NGP). Research on ICLS conducted in the NGP indicates that the crop residue grazing, swath grazing, and annual forage grazing can positively influence crop production; whereas, livestock performance varies with season, forage nutritive value, and grazing management. Furthermore, ICLSs can reduce the costs and risks of agricultural production. The success of ICLSs in NGP region depends on trade‐offs, planning, economic benefits, policies, regulations, community acceptance, and management skills. The ICLSs could play a strategic role in future agricultural production. The lessons learned from adopting ICLSs in the NGP include the lack of available land for fertilizer (manure) management, that to implement ICLS practices skills and knowledge must be maintained, and ICLS provides an entry point for young farmers and ranchers however capital is needed. These experiences and lessons could be valuable references for producers to adopt ICLSs in the NGP or other regions.Core Ideas Integrated crop–livestock systems positively affect crop production by improving soil health. Common integrated crop–livestock system management techniques can enhance the northern Great Plains crop production. Integrated crop–livestock system livestock performance is impacted by season, forage selection, and management. Integrated crop–livestock systems can increase economic benefits and reduce economic risks. Experiences and lessons in the northern Great Plains could be valuable for other regions to adopt integrated crop–livestock systems.
The native prairies of the Great Plains USA are dominated by perennial C4 grasses like switchgrass (Panicum virgatum) and big bluestem (Andropogon gerardii). Spring hard freeze injury to C4 perennial grasses is rare but information is lacking in the literature. Our objective was to document effects of spring hard freeze damage to C4 perennial grasses native to the Great Plains USA. On 2 May at 24:00 pm, air temperature near Mead, Nebraska was below freezing and remained below freezing until 8:00 am on 3 May, with a minimum air temperature of -2.8°C. Based on 50-year of weather data for this site, a minimum threshold temperature of 0°C on or after 3 May occurred 16 times, but a minimum threshold temperature of -2.8°C on or after 3 May occurred only twice. Grass tillers were visually evaluated to determine extent of freeze damage. The terminal 3- to 5-cm of the leaf lamina was blackened 4-d after freezing and had complete browning, rolling, and desiccation 14-d after freezing. Tiller survival was not negatively affected by the freezing temperatures in May 2004. As the growing season progressed, all agronomic and livestock responses were within normal ranges for these C4 grasses. This is the first field report of multiple C4 prairie grass species responses to a spring hard freeze following significant spring growth. Plant recovery to this late-spring hard freeze demonstrates the ecological resilience of these C4 prairie grasses. These rare spring hard freezes had short-term impacts on C4 grasses but did not negatively impact agronomic performance for forage or bioenergy later in the growing season.
Core Ideas Grazed corn residue is a cost‐efficient forage resource. Current value of grazed corn residue is $95 M returned to the crop sector in NE, SD, KS, and ND. Gross value for grazed corn residue is $191 M for the beef cattle sector in NE, SD, KS, and ND. Opportunities exist to increase use of corn residue grazing. Transportation costs and animal care arrangements are complicating factors. Integrated crop–livestock systems have included grazing perennial grasses during the spring and summer and corn (Zea mays L.) residues during the winter. Our objectives were to identify opportunities for expanded corn residue use through grazing and provide an economic assessment for value‐added grazing. We estimated the economic value to the crop sector through grazing leased corn residue at over $95 million for Nebraska, South Dakota, Kansas, and North Dakota under current management. Additionally, gross economic value to the livestock sector in these states was estimated at greater than $191 million. Advantages for increased grazing use of corn residue include managing residue quantity in high‐yielding environments, providing a source of supplemental revenue, and expanding integrated crop–livestock systems using a simple, but cost‐efficient practice.
The production of dedicated energy crops on marginally productive cropland is projected to play an important role in reaching the US Billion Ton goal. This study aimed to evaluate warm‐season grasses for biomass production potential under different harvest timings (summer [H1], after killing frost [H2], or alternating between two [H3]) and nitrogen (N) fertilizer rates (0, 56, and 112 kg N/ha) on a wet marginal land across multiple production years. Six feedstocks were evaluated including Miscanthus x giganteus , two switchgrass cultivars ( Panicum virgatum L .), prairie cordgrass ( Spartina pectinata Link), and two polycultures including a mixture of big bluestem ( Andropogon gerardii Vitman), indiangrass ( Sorghastrum nutans ), and sideoats grama ( Bouteloua curtipendula [Michx.] Torr.), and a mixture of big bluestem and prairie cordgrass. Across four production years, harvest timing and feedstock type played an important role in biomass production. Miscanthus x giganteus produced the greatest biomass (18.7 Mg/ha), followed by the switchgrass cultivar “Liberty” (14.7 Mg/ha). Harvest in H1 tended to increase yield irrespective of feedstock; the exception being M. x giganteus that had significantly lower biomass when harvested in H1 when compared to H2 and H3. The advantage H1 harvest had over H2 for all feedstocks declined over time, suggesting H2 or H3 would provide greater and more sustainable biomass production for the observed feedstocks. The N application rate played an important role mainly for M. x giganteus where 112 kg N/ha yielded more biomass than no N. Other feedstocks occasionally showed a slight, but statistically insignificant increase in biomass yield with increasing N rate. This study showed the potential of producing feedstocks for bioenergy on wet marginal land; however, more research on tissue and soil nutrient dynamics under different N rates and harvest regimes will be important in understanding stand longevity for feedstocks grown under these conditions.
BACKGROUND:Switchgrass breeders need to improve the rates of genetic gain in many bioenergy-related traits in order to create improved cultivars that are higher yielding and have optimal biomass composition. One way to achieve this is through genomic selection. However, the heritability of traits needs to be determined as well as the accuracy of prediction in order to determine if efficient selection is possible.RESULTS:Using five distinct switchgrass populations comprised of three lowland, one upland and one hybrid accession, the accuracy of genomic predictions under different cross-validation strategies and prediction methods was investigated. Individual genotypes were collected using GBS while kin-BLUP, partial least squares, sparse partial least squares, and BayesB methods were employed to predict yield, morphological, and NIRS-based compositional data collected in 2012-2013 from a replicated Nebraska field trial. Population structure was assessed by F statistics which ranged from 0.3952 between lowland and upland accessions to 0.0131 among the lowland accessions. Prediction accuracy ranged from 0.57-0.52 for cell wall soluble glucose and fructose respectively, to insignificant for traits with low repeatability. Ratios of heritability across to within-population ranged from 15 to 0.6.CONCLUSIONS:Accuracy was significantly affected by both cross-validation strategy and trait. Accounting for population structure with a cross-validation strategy constrained by accession resulted in accuracies that were 69% lower than apparent accuracies using unconstrained cross-validation. Less accurate genomic selection is anticipated when most of the phenotypic variation exists between populations such as with spring regreening and yield phenotypes.
Biomass yield and adaptability to a broad range of environments are important characteristics of dedicated energy crops for sustainable bioenergy feedstock production. In addition to yield potential, the role of species diversity on ecosystem services is also growing in importance as we seek to develop sustainable feedstock production systems. The objective of this study was to compare the biomass yield potential of the commercially available germplasm of native warm-season grasses in monocultures and in blends (mixture of different cultivars of the same species) or mixtures of different species across an environmental gradient (temperature and precipitation) in the Midwest, USA. Warm-season grasses including switchgrass ( Panicum virgatum L.), big bluestem ( Andropogon gerardii Vitman), indiangrass ( Sorghastrum nutans [L.] Nash), sideoats grama ( Bouteloua curtipendula [Michx.] Torr.) and Miscanthus × giganteus (Greef and Deu.) were planted in 2009. Biomass was annually harvested from 2010 through 2015 for Urbana, IL and Mead, NE but only in 2010 and 2011 for Ames, IA. The effect of species in monocultures and mixtures (or blends) on biomass yields was significant for all locations. In monocultures, the annual biomass yields averaged over a 6-year period were 11.12 Mg ha −1 and 10.98 Mg ha −1 at Urbana and Mead, respectively, while the annual biomass yield averaged over a 2-year period was 7.99 Mg ha −1 at Ames, IA. Also, the annual biomass yields averaged across the different mixtures and blends at each location were 10.25 Mg ha −1 , 9.88 Mg ha −1 , and 7.64 Mg ha −1 at Urbana, Mead, and Ames, respectively. At all locations, M. × giganteus and ‘Kanlow N1’ produced the highest biomass yield in monocultures while mixtures containing switchgrass and big bluestem had the greatest mixture yield. The results from this multi-environment study suggest mixtures of different species provided no yield advantage over monocultures for bioenergy feedstocks in Illinois and Nebraska and both systems consistently produced biomass as long as April–July precipitation was near or above the average precipitation (300 mm) of the regions.