Osteoarthritis (OA) is the most common joint disease worldwide. Despite significant efforts byresearchers, no disease-modifying osteoarthritis drugs (DMOADs) have been approved yet. This review compares preclinical and clinical studies of promising therapeutic approaches to gain insights into the potential reasons for their failure in clinical trials. For this purpose, prime examples of different therapeutic groups, including the antioxidant NAC, senotherapeutic UBX0101, anti-inflammatory drug Anakinra®, Wnt inhibitor Lorecevivint®, chondroanabolic growth factor Sprifermin™, and various protease inhibitors, are discussed in detail. The limitations of commonly used OA animal models are elaborated to understand this failure better. Moreover, this review addresses the challenges of patient stratification into different endotypes and phenotypes, the consideration of subgrouping in clinical trials, and the lack of suitable clinical outcome parameters. In summary, this review highlights potential reasons for the high failure rate of DMOADs in clinical trials and outlines key points for future improvement.

Previous studies indicate an implication of the terminal complement complex (TCC) in disc degeneration (DD). To investigate the functional role of TCC in trauma-induced DD in vivo, the model of endplate (EP) drilling was first applied in rabbits using a C6-deficient rabbit strain in which no TCC formation was possible. In parallel the model of needle puncture was investigated. Using a minimally invasive surgical intervention, lumbar rabbit intervertebral discs (IVDs) were treated with EP drilling or needle puncture. Degenerative effects of both surgical interventions were assessed by Pfirrmann grading and T2 quantification of the IVDs based on high-resolution MRI (11.7 T), as well as radiographic determination of disc height index. Pfirrmann grading indicated significant degenerative effects after EP drilling. Contrary to our assumption, no evidence was found that the absence of TCC formation in C6-deficient rabbits reduces the development of DD compared to C6-sufficient animals. EP drilling was proven to be suitable for application in rabbits. However, results of the present study do not provide clear evidence of a central functional role of TCC within DD and suggest that TCC deposition in DD patients may be primarily considered as a marker of complement activation during DD progression.

Posttraumatic osteoarthritis (PTOA) is a special form of OA, developing after joint injuries. Except for some minor differences between the clinical characteristics of patients suffering from idiopathic OA (IOA) and PTOA, no biologic marker has yet been identified to distinguish IOA from PTOA. In this study, we investigated the expression of the stress-responsive cytokine growth differentiation factor 15 (GDF-15) in clinical samples from the Ulm OA study cohort (PTOA: n =12; IOA: n=54) and in a human ex vivo cartilage trauma model. We found significantly higher GDF-15 levels in synovial fluid of end-stage PTOA patients as compared to IOA patients. Further, we confirmed that fibroblast-like synoviocytes secreted increased levels of GDF-15 after stimulation with medium of ex vivo -traumatized cartilage. GDF-15 and its receptor, GFRAL, were significantly elevated in highly degenerated OA cartilage. By means of a human cartilage trauma model, we discovered that chondrocytes produced GDF-15 upon tissue injury, while antioxidative treatment attenuated GDF-15 secretion. We confirmed that oxidative stress and subsequent activation of p53 resulted in GDF-15 expression. As a transcriptional target of p53, GDF-15 was associated with chondrosenescence. Although the cytokine might therefore represent a senescence-associated secretory phenotype (SASP) factor, stimulation with exogenous GDF-15 did not cause detrimental effects but induced a pro-regenerative response in chondrocytes, characterized by enhanced proliferation as well as chondro- and cell protection after cartilage trauma. Overall, this study first describes GDF-15 as a stress-responsive and potentially pro-regenerative cytokine in the context of human PTOA. ### Competing Interest Statement The authors have declared no competing interest.

Joint injuries and consequent oxidative stress is a high-risk factor for developing post-traumatic osteoarthritis (OA). While antioxidative therapy using N-acetylcysteine (NAC) has cell- and chondroprotective effects following cartilage injury, it strongly impairs matrix synthesis. Consequently, direct application of Glutathione (GSH) was tested as an alternative therapeutic approach using an ex vivo cartilage trauma model and isolated chondrocytes, with comparison to NAC. Porcine cartilage explants were traumatized using a drop tower with an impact energy of 0.47 J and afterwards treated with 0.5-2 mM GSH or 2 mM NAC for 4 days according to a standardized protocol. The effects of antioxidative treatment on the chondrogenic phenotype were tested in a 3D pellet culture for 28 days. Our results demonstrated that both antioxidants had cell protective effects after cartilage trauma. GSH was most effective at a concentration of 0.5 mM, as confirmed in experiments with isolated human chondrocytes exposed to H2O2. At this concentration, GSH did not impair cell proliferation or hyaline cartilage matrix synthesis, while NAC suppressed the chondrogenic phenotype in pellet culture. Both, NAC and GSH elevated the intracellular GSH concentration, indicating an efficient uptake of the antioxidants. Furthermore, both therapeutics inhibited the activity of the matrix degrading enzyme MMP-2. Our results demonstrated cell- and chondroprotective effects by NAC and GSH therapy after cartilage trauma, with GSH demonstrating advantages in preserving the chondrogenic phenotype.

Cellular senescence is associated with various age-related disorders and is assumed to play a major role in the pathogenesis of osteoarthritis (OA). Based on this, we tested a senolytic combination therapy using Dasatinib (D) and Quercetin (Q) on aged isolated human articular chondrocytes (hACs), as well as in OA-affected cartilage tissue (OARSI grade 1-2). Stimulation with D + Q selectively eliminated senescent cells in both, cartilage explants and isolated hAC. Furthermore, the therapy significantly promoted chondroanabolism, as demonstrated by increased gene expression levels of COL2A1, ACAN, and SOX9, as well as elevated collagen type II and glycosaminoglycan biosynthesis. Additionally, D + Q treatment significantly reduced the release of SASP factors (IL6, CXCL1). RNA sequencing analysis revealed an upregulation of the anabolic factors, inter alia, FGF18, IGF1, and TGFB2, as well as inhibitory effects on cytokines and the YAP-1 signaling pathway, explaining the underlying mechanism of the chondroanabolic promotion upon senolytic treatment. Accordingly, stimulation of untreated hAC with conditioned medium of D + Q-treated cells similarly induced the expression of chondrogenic markers. Detailed analyses demonstrated that chondroanabolic effects could be mainly attributed to Dasatinib, while monotherapeutical application of Quercetin or Navitoclax did not promote the chondroanabolism. Overall, D + Q therapy restored the chondrogenic phenotype in OA hAC most likely by creating a pro-chondroanabolic environment through the reduction of SASP factors and upregulation of growth factors. This senolytic approach could therefore be a promising candidate for further testing as a disease-modifying osteoarthritis drug.

The terminal complement complex (TCC) has been described as a potential driver in the pathogenesis of posttraumatic osteoarthritis (PTOA). However, sublytic TCC deposition might also play a crucial role in bone development and regeneration. Therefore, we elucidated the effects of TCC on joint-related tissues using a rabbit PTOA model. In brief, a C6-deficient rabbit breed was characterized on genetic, protein, and functional levels. Anterior cruciate ligament transection (ACLT) was performed in C6-deficient (C6−/−) and C6-sufficient (C6+/−) rabbits. After eight weeks, the progression of PTOA was determined histologically. Moreover, the structure of the subchondral bone was evaluated by µCT analysis. C6 deficiency could be attributed to a homozygous 3.6 kb deletion within the C6 gene and subsequent loss of the C5b binding site. Serum from C6−/− animals revealed no hemolytic activity. After ACLT surgery, joints of C6−/− rabbits exhibited significantly lower OA scores, including reduced cartilage damage, hypocellularity, cluster formation, and osteophyte number, as well as lower chondrocyte apoptosis rates and synovial prostaglandin E2 levels. Moreover, ACLT surgery significantly decreased the trabecular number in the subchondral bone of C6−/− rabbits. Overall, the absence of TCC protected from injury-induced OA progression but had minor effects on the micro-structure of the subchondral bone.

Accumulation of dysfunctional chondrocytes has detrimental consequences on the cartilagehomeostasis and is thus thought to play a crucial role during the pathogenesis of osteoarthritis(OA). However, the underlying mechanisms of phenotypical alteration in chondrocytes areincompletely understood. Here, we provide evidence that disruption of the intracellularvimentin network and consequent phenotypical alteration in human chondrocytes results in anexternalization of the intermediate filament. The presence of the so-called cell surfacevimentin (CSV) on chondrocytes was associated with the severity of tissue degeneration inclinical OA samples and was enhanced after mechanical injury of cartilage tissue. By meansof a doxorubicine-based in vitro model of stress-induced premature senescence (SIPS), wecould confirm the connection between cellular senescence and amount of CSV. AlthoughsiRNA-mediated silencing of CDKN2A clearly reduced the senescent phenotype as well asCSV levels of human chondrocytes, cellular senescence could not be completely reversed.Interestingly, knockdown of vimentin resulted in a SIPS-like phenotype and consequentlyincreased CSV. Therefore, we concluded that the integrity of the intracellular vimentinnetwork is crucial to maintain cellular function in chondrocytes. This assumption could beconfirmed by chemically- induced collapse of the vimentin network, which resulted in cellularstress and enhanced CSV expression. Regarding its biological function, CSV was found to beassociated with enhanced chondrocyte adhesion and plasticity. While osteogenic capacitiesseemed to be enhanced in chondrocytes expressing high levels of CSV, the chondrogenicpotential was clearly compromised. Overall, our study reinforces the importance of thevimentin network in maintenance of the chondrogenic phenotype and introduces CSV as anovel membrane-bound marker of dysfunctional chondrocytes.

Nasal septum defects can currently only be reconstructed using autologous cartilage grafts. In this study, we examine the reconstruction of septal cartilage defects in a rabbit model using porcine decellularized nasal septal cartilage (DNSC) functionalized with recombinant platelet-derived growth factor-BB (PDFG-BB). The supportive function of the transplanted DNSC was estimated by the degree of septum deviation and shrinkage using magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). The biocompatibility of the transplanted scaffolds was evaluated by histology according to international standards. A study group with an autologous septal transplant was used as a reference. In situ regeneration of cartilage defects was assessed by histological evaluation 4 and 16 weeks following DNSC transplantation. A study group with non-functionalized DNSC was introduced for estimation of the effects of PDFG-BB functionalization. DNSC scaffolds provided sufficient structural support to the nasal septum, with no significant shrinkage or septal deviations as evaluated by the MRI. Biocompatibility analysis after 4 weeks revealed an increased inflammatory reaction of the surrounding tissue in response to DNSC as compared to the autologous transplants. The inflammatory reaction was, however, significantly attenuated after 16 weeks in the PDGF-BB group whereas only a slight improvement of the biocompatibility score was observed in the untreated group. In situ regeneration of septal cartilage, as evidenced by the degradation of the DNSC matrix and production of neocartilage, was observed in both experimental groups after 16 weeks but was more pronounced in the PDFG-BB group. Overall, DNSC provided structural support to the nasal septum and stimulated in situ regeneration of the cartilage tissue. Furthermore, PDFG-BB augmented the regenerative potential of DNSC and enhanced the healing process, as demonstrated by reduced inflammation after 16 weeks.

Terminal complement complex (TCC) deposition was identified in human degenerated discs. To clarify the role of terminal complement activation in disc degeneration (DD), we investigated respective activating mechanisms and cellular effects in annulus fibrosus (AF) cells. Isolated cells from human AF, nucleus pulposus (NP), and endplate (EP) were stimulated with human serum alone or with zymosan and treated with either the C3 inhibitor Cp40 or the C5 antibody eculizumab. Complement activation was determined via anaphylatoxin generation and TCC deposition detection. Thereby, induced catabolic effects were evaluated in cultured AF cells. Moreover, C5 cleavage under degenerative conditions in the presence of AF cells was assessed. Zymosan-induced anaphylatoxin generation and TCC deposition was significantly suppressed by both complement inhibitors. Zymosan induced gene expression of ADAMTS4, MMP1, and COX2. Whereas the C3 blockade attenuated the expression of ADAMTS4, the C5 blockade reduced the expression of ADAMTS4, MMP1, and COX2. Direct C5 cleavage was significantly enhanced by EP conditioned medium from DD patients and CTSD. These results indicate that terminal complement activation might be functionally involved in the progression of DD. Moreover, we found evidence that soluble factors secreted by degenerated EP tissue can mediate direct C5 cleavage, thereby contributing to complement activation in degenerated discs.

Purpose: Cartilage calcification (CC) is involved in Osteoarthritis (OA) pathogenesis and associated with cartilage degeneration. So far, the initial mechanisms of CC are not clear. It has previously been described that the anaphylatoxin receptors C3aR and especially C5aR are involved in the osteogenic differentiation of human mesenchymal stem cells (MSC). Thus, we suggested that the anaphylatoxins C3a and C5a, released after cartilage trauma and subsequent complement activation, are involved in the initiation of cartilage mineralization.

20 years ago, we described a human cell strain derived from subcutaneous adipose tissue of an infant supposed to have Simpson-Golabi-Behmel Syndrome (SGBS), thus called “SGBS cells”. Since then, these cells have emerged as the most commonly used cell model for human adipogenesis and human adipocyte biology. Although these adipocyte derived stem cells have not been genetically manipulated for transformation or immortalization, SGBS cells retain their capacity to proliferate and to differentiate into adipocytes for more than 50 population doublings, providing an almost unlimited source of human adipocyte progenitor cells. Original data obtained with SGBS cells led to more than 200 peer reviewed publications comprising investigations on adipogenesis and browning, insulin sensitivity, inflammatory response, adipokine production, as well as co-culture models and cell-cell communication. In this article, we provide an update on the characterization of SGBS cells, present basic methods for their application and summarize results of a systematic literature search on original data obtained with this cell strain.

Purpose: Cellular senescence is considered as a crucial pathomechanism in osteoarthritic (OA) disease. Senescent chondrocytes (snC) display a dysfunctional behavior, characterized by the senescence-associated secretory phenotype (SASP), thus promoting proceeding cartilage degeneration. Previously, we identified a potential membrane-associated biomarker, cell surface vimentin (CSV), on snC. Here, we further clarified the mechanisms involved in CSV presentation and the link to chondrosenescence.

Joint injuries are known to induce pathomechanisms that might lead to posttraumatic osteoarthritis (PTOA). In this regard, statins with their pleiotropic effects could represent potential therapeutic agents in preventing the development of PTOA. Therefore, we investigated the effects of simvastatin and fluvastatin in a drop-tower-based human ex vivo cartilage trauma model. After 7 days, a mechanical impact (0.59 J) resulted in a decrease of the cell viability and increased expression of catabolic enzymes in cartilage explants. Simvastatin and fluvastatin treatment of impacted cartilage demonstrated cell protective effects in a concentration dependent manner. Moreover, statin therapy exhibited chondroprotective effects as demonstrated by attenuated expression of MMP-2 and MMP-13 as well as subsequent breakdown of collagen type II (after impact). Further analysis indicated antioxidative properties of the statins by upregulating the gene expression of SOD2 and suppression that of NOX2 and NOX4. Despite its protective effects, simvastatin impaired the biosynthesis of collagen type II, which was confirmed during chondrogenic redifferentiation of high passage chondrocytes. However, while long-term administration of statins for 4 weeks impaired chondrogenic redifferentiation, addition of simvastatin at low concentrations for 1 week exhibited a slightly promoting effect. In conclusion, our data imply that simvastatin and fluvastatin are suitable in terms of initial harm reduction after cartilage trauma.

The incidence of musculoskeletal diseases is steadily increasing with aging of the population. In the past years, extracellular vesicles (EVs) have gained attention in musculoskeletal research. EVs have been associated with various musculoskeletal pathologies as well as suggested as treatment option. EVs play a pivotal role in communication between cells and their environment. Thereby, the EV cargo is highly dependent on their cellular origin. In this review, we summarize putative mechanisms by which EVs can contribute to musculoskeletal tissue homeostasis, regeneration and disease, in particular matrix remodeling and mineralization, pro-angiogenic effects and immunomodulatory activities. Mesenchymal stromal cells (MSCs) present the most frequently used cell source for EV generation for musculoskeletal applications, and herein we discuss how the MSC phenotype can influence the cargo and thus the regenerative potential of EVs. Induced pluripotent stem cell-derived mesenchymal progenitor cells (iMPs) may overcome current limitations of MSCs, and iMP-derived EVs are discussed as an alternative strategy. In the last part of the article, we focus on therapeutic applications of EVs and discuss both practical considerations for EV production and the current state of EV-based therapies.

Purpose Formation of terminal complement complex (TCC), a downstream complement system activation product inducing inflammatory processes and cell lysis, has been identified in degenerated discs. However, it remains unclear which molecular factors regulate complement activation during disc degeneration (DD). This study investigated a possible involvement of the pro-inflammatory cytokine interleukin-1β (IL-1β) and the lysosomal protease cathepsin D (CTSD). Methods Disc biopsies were collected from patients suffering from DD ( n = 43) and adolescent idiopathic scoliosis (AIS, n = 13). Standardized tissue punches and isolated cells from nucleus pulposus (NP), annulus fibrosus (AF) and endplate (EP) were stimulated with 5% human serum (HS) alone or in combination with IL-1β, CTSD or zymosan. TCC formation and modulation by the complement regulatory proteins CD46, CD55 and CD59 were analysed. Results In DD tissue cultures, IL-1β stimulation decreased the percentage of TCC + cells in AF and EP ( P < 0.05), whereas CTSD stimulation significantly increased TCC deposition in NP ( P < 0.01) and zymosan in EP ( P < 0.05). Overall, the expression of CD46, CD55 and CD59 significantly increased in all isolated cells during culture ( P < 0.05). Moreover, cellular TCC deposition was HS concentration dependent but unaffected by IL-1β, CTSD or zymosan. Conclusion These results suggest a functional relevance of IL-1β and CTSD in modulating TCC formation in DD, with differences between tissue regions. Although strong TCC deposition may represent a degeneration-associated event, IL-1β may inhibit it. In contrast, TCC formation was shown to be triggered by CTSD, indicating a multifunctional involvement in disc pathophysiology.

Decellularized extracellular matrices (DECM) are among the most common types of materials used in tissue engineering due to their cell instructive properties, biodegradability, and accessibility. Particularly in cartilage, a natural collagen type II matrix can be a promising means to provide the necessary cues and support for chondrogenic stem and progenitor cells (CSPCs). However, efficient remodeling of the transplanted DECM is largely dependent on the host immune response, with macrophages playing the central role in orchestrating both inflammatory and regenerative processes. Here we assessed the reaction of human primary macrophages to the cartilage DECM. Our findings show that the xenogeneic collagen matrix can elicit a mixed response in human macrophages, whereby the inflammatory response (M1) and the activation of remodeling (M2) type of macrophages are both present. Additionally, we demonstrate the inhibitory effect of macrophage response on the migratory capacity of human CSPCs. We further show that the inflammatory reaction of macrophages to the cartilage DECM, as well as the resulting inhibitory effects on CSPC migration, can be attenuated by interleukin-4 (IL-4). Finally, we demonstrate that IL-4 can effectively bind the matrix, thereby modulating macrophage response by reducing the inflammatory reaction and inducing the M2 phenotype.