Spin states in semiconductors provide exceptionally stable and noise-resistant environments for qubits, positioning them as optimal candidates for reliable quantum computing technologies. The proposal to use nuclear and electronic spins of donor atoms in silicon, introduced by Kane in 1998, sparked a new research field focused on the precise positioning of individual impurity atoms for quantum devices, utilising scanning tunnelling microscopy and ion implantation. This roadmap article reviews the advancements in the 25 years since Kane’s proposal, the current challenges, and the future directions in atomic-scale semiconductor device fabrication and measurement. It covers the quest to create a silicon-based quantum computer and expands to include diverse material systems and fabrication techniques, highlighting the potential for a broad range of semiconductor quantum technological applications. Key developments include phosphorus in silicon devices such as single-atom transistors, arrayed few-donor devices, one- and two-qubit gates, three-dimensional architectures, and the development of a toolbox for future quantum integrated circuits. The roadmap also explores new impurity species like arsenic and antimony for enhanced scalability and higher-dimensional spin systems, new chemistry for dopant precursors and lithographic resists, and the potential for germanium-based devices. Emerging methods, such as photon-based lithography and electron beam manipulation, are discussed for their disruptive potential. This roadmap charts the path toward scalable quantum computing and advanced semiconductor quantum technologies, emphasising the critical intersections of experiment, technological development, and theory.
Matter at the atomic-scale is inherently governed by the laws of quantum mechanics. This makes charges and spins confined to individual atoms—and interactions among them—an invaluable resource for fundamental research and quantum technologies alike. However, harnessing the inherent ‘quantumness’ of atomic-scale objects requires that they can be precisely engineered and addressed at the individual atomic level. Since its invention in the 1980s, scanning tunnelling microscopy (STM) has repeatedly demonstrated the unrivalled ability to not only resolve but manipulate matter at atomic length scales. Over the past decades, this has enabled the design and investigation of bottom-up tailored nanostructures as reliable and reproducible platforms to study designer quantum physics and chemistry, band topology, and collective phenomena. The vast range of STM-based techniques and modes of operation, as well as their combination with electromagnetic fields from the infrared to microwave spectral range, has even allowed for the precise control of individual charge and spin degrees of freedom. This roadmap reviews the most recent developments in the field of atomically-engineered quantum platforms and explores their potential in future fundamental research and quantum technologies.
This perspective outlines a selection of research directions that members of the JPCM editorial board anticipate may shape the frontier of condensed matter physics over the next decade. Rather than a comprehensive review or formal roadmap, this perspective reflects a set of informed views drawn from diverse areas of expertise. Our intention is to spark curiosity, provoke discussion, and encourage readers to imagine-and pursue-the exciting possibilities that lie ahead.
Because it is easily switched from insulator to metal either via chemical doping or electrical gating, silicon is at the core of modern information technology and remains a candidate platform for quantum computing. The metal-to-insulator transition in this material has therefore been one of the most studied phenomena in condensed matter physics, and has been revisited with considerable profit each time a new fabrication technology has been introduced. Here we take advantage of recent advances in creating ultra-thin layers of Bohr-atom-like dopants to realize the two-dimensional disordered Hubbard model at half-filling and its metal-to-insulator transition (MIT) as a function of mean distance between atoms. We use gas-phase dosing of dopant precursor molecules on silicon to create arsenic and phosphorus δ-layers as thin as 0.4 nm and as dilute as 10^13 cm^-2. On approaching the insulating state, the conventional weak localization effects, prevalent at high dopant densities and due to orbital motion of the electrons in the plane, become dominated by electron-electron interaction contributions which obey a paramagnetic Zeeman scaling law. The latter make a negative contribution to the conductance, and thus cannot be interpreted in terms of an emergent Kondo regime near the MIT.
We present the first scanning tunneling microscopy (STM) image of hydrogenic acceptor wave functions in silicon. These acceptor states appear as square-ring-like features in STM images and originate from near-surface defects introduced by high-energy bismuth implantation into a silicon (001) wafer. Scanning tunneling spectroscopy confirms the formation of a p-type surface. Effective-mass and tight-binding calculations provide an excellent description of the observed square-ring-like features, confirming their acceptor character and attributing their symmetry to the light- and heavy-hole band degeneracy in silicon. A detailed understanding of the energetic and spatial properties of acceptor wave functions in silicon is essential for engineering large-scale acceptor-based quantum devices.
Artificial lattices constructed from individual dopant atoms within a semiconductor crystal hold promise to provide novel materials with tailored electronic, magnetic, and optical properties. These custom-engineered lattices are anticipated to enable new, fundamental discoveries in condensed matter physics and lead to the creation of new semiconductor technologies including analog quantum simulators and universal solid-state quantum computers. This work reports precise and repeatable, substitutional incorporation of single arsenic atoms into a silicon lattice. A combination of scanning tunneling microscopy hydrogen resist lithography and a detailed statistical exploration of the chemistry of arsine on the hydrogen-terminated silicon (001) surface are employed to show that single arsenic dopants can be deterministically placed within four silicon lattice sites and incorporated with 97 ± 2% yield. These findings bring closer to the ultimate frontier in semiconductor technology: the deterministic assembly of atomically precise dopant and qubit arrays at arbitrarily large scales.
Atomically precise hydrogen desorption lithography using scanning tunnelling microscopy (STM) has enabled the development of single-atom, quantum-electronic devices on a laboratory scale. Scaling up this technology to mass-produce these devices requires bridging the gap between the precision of STM and the processes used in next-generation semiconductor manufacturing. Here, we demonstrate the ability to remove hydrogen from a monohydride Si(001):H surface using extreme ultraviolet (EUV) light. We quantify the desorption characteristics using various techniques, including STM, X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS), and photoemission electron microscopy (XPEEM). Our results show that desorption is induced by secondary electrons from valence band excitations, consistent with an exactly solvable non-linear differential equation and compatible with the current 13.5 nm (~92 eV) EUV standard for photolithography; the data imply useful exposure times of order minutes for the 300 W sources characteristic of EUV infrastructure. This is an important step towards the EUV patterning of silicon surfaces without traditional resists, by offering the possibility for parallel processing in the fabrication of classical and quantum devices through deterministic doping.
Fabrication of semiconductor heterostructures is now so precise that metrology has become a key challenge for progress in science and applications. It is now relatively straightforward to characterize classic III-V and group IV heterostructures consisting of slabs of different semiconductor alloys with thicknesses of ∼5 nm and greater using sophisticated tools such as diffraction, high energy X-ray photoemission spectroscopy, and secondary ion mass spectrometry. However, profiling thin layers with nm or sub-nm thickness, e.g. atomically thin dopant layers (), of impurities required for modulation doping and spin-based quantum and classical information technologies is more challenging. Here, we present theory and experiment showing how resonant-contrast reflectometry meets this challenge. The technique takes advantage of the change in the scattering factor of atoms as their core level resonances are scanned by varying the energy. We demonstrate the capability of the resulting element-selective, non-destructive profilometry for single arsenic δ-layers within silicon, and show that the sub-nm electronic thickness of the corresponds to sub-nm chemical thickness. In combination with X-ray fluorescence imaging, this enables non-destructive three-dimensional characterization of nano-structured quantum devices. Due to the strong resonances at soft X-ray wavelengths, the technique is also ideally suited to characterize layered quantum materials, such as cuprates or the topical infinite-layer nickelates.
Dataset: SX-ARPES raw data, processed data and the codes used for analysing and data fitting our work at doi/10.1002/advs.202302101 are all available here. The theoretical mdelling is also avaiable. Abstract: Two-dimensional dopant layers (δ-layers) in semiconductors provide the high-mobility electron liquids (2DELs) needed for nanoscale quantum-electronic devices. Key parameters such as carrier densities, effective masses, and confinement thicknesses for 2DELs have traditionally been extracted from quantum magnetotransport. In principle, the parameters are immediately readable from the one-electron spectral function that can be measured by angle-resolved photoemission (ARPES). Here, we measure buried 2DEL δ-layers in silicon with soft X-ray (SX) ARPES to obtain detailed information about their filled conduction bands and extract device-relevant properties. We take advantage of the larger probing depth and photon energy range of SX-ARPES relative to vacuum ultraviolet (VUV) ARPES to accurately measure the δ-layer electronic confinement. Our measurements are made on ambient-exposed samples and yield extremely thin (< 1 nm) and dense (~1014 cm-2) 2DELs. Critically, we use this method to show that δ-layers of arsenic exhibit better electronic confinement than δ-layers of phosphorus fabricated under identical conditions.
We investigate the adsorption and thermal decomposition of triphenyl bismuth (TPB) on the silicon (001) surface using atomic-resolution scanning tunneling microscopy, synchrotron-based X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy, and density functional theory calculations. Our results show that the adsorption of TPB at room temperature creates both bismuth-silicon and phenyl-silicon bonds. Annealing above room temperature leads to increased chemical interactions between the phenyl groups and the silicon surface, followed by phenyl detachment and bismuth subsurface migration. The thermal decomposition of the carbon fragments leads to the formation of silicon carbide at the surface. This chemical understanding of the process allows for controlled bismuth introduction into the near surface of silicon and opens pathways for ultra-shallow doping approaches.
Dataset: STM, XPS and PEEM raw data, processed data and the codes used for data fitting our work at doi/xxx/xxx are all available here. Abstract: Atomically precise hydrogen desorption lithography using scanning tunnelling microscopy (STM) has enabled the development of single-atom, quantum-electronic devices on a laboratory scale. Scaling up this technology to mass-produce these devices requires bridging the gap between the precision of STM and the processes used in next-generation semiconductor manufacturing. Here, we demonstrate the ability to remove hydrogen from a monohydride Si(001):H surface using extreme ultraviolet (EUV) light. We quantify the desorption characteristics using various techniques, including STM, X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS), and photoemission electron microscopy (XPEEM). Our results show that desorption is induced by secondary electrons from valence band excitations, consistent with an exactly solvable non-linear differential equation and compatible with the current 13.5 nm (~92 eV) EUV standard for photolithography; the data imply useful exposure times of order minutes for the 300 W sources characteristic of EUV infrastructure. This is an important step towards the EUV patterning of silicon surfaces without traditional resists, by offering the possibility for parallel processing in the fabrication of classical and quantum devices through deterministic doping.
Abstract The progress of miniaturization in integrated electronics has led to atomic and nanometer‐sized dopant devices in silicon. Such structures can be fabricated routinely by hydrogen resist lithography, using various dopants such as P and As. However, the ability to non‐destructively obtain atomic‐species‐specific images of the final structure, which would be an indispensable tool for building more complex nano‐scale devices, such as quantum co‐processors, remains an unresolved challenge. Here, X‐ray fluorescence is exploited to create an element‐specific image of As dopants in Si, with dopant densities in absolute units and a resolution limited by the beam focal size (here ≈1 µm), without affecting the device's low temperature electronic properties. The As densities provided by the X‐ray data are compared to those derived from Hall effect measurements as well as the standard non‐repeatable, scanning tunneling microscopy and secondary ion mass spectroscopy, techniques. Before and after the X‐ray experiments, we also measured the magneto‐conductance, which is dominated by weak localization, a quantum interference effect extremely sensitive to sample dimensions and disorder. Notwithstanding the 1.5 × 1010 Sv (1.5 × 1016 Rad cm−2) exposure of the device to X‐rays, all transport data are unchanged to within experimental errors, corresponding to upper bounds of 0.2 Angstroms for the radiation‐induced motion of the typical As atom and 3% for the loss of activated, carrier‐contributing dopants. With next generation synchrotron radiation sources and more advanced optics, the authors foresee that it will be possible to obtain X‐ray images of single dopant atoms within resolved radii of 5 nm.
In this work, we show the feasibility of extreme ultraviolet (EUV) patterning on an HF-treated silicon (100) surface in the absence of a photoresist. EUV lithography is the leading lithography technique in semiconductor manufacturing due to its high resolution and throughput, but future progress in resolution can be hampered because of the inherent limitations of the resists. We show that EUV photons can induce surface reactions on a partially hydrogen-terminated silicon surface and assist the growth of an oxide layer, which serves as an etch mask. This mechanism is different from the hydrogen desorption in scanning tunneling microscopy-based lithography. We achieve silicon dioxide/silicon gratings with 75-nanometer half-pitch and 31-nanometer height, demonstrating the efficacy of the method and the feasibility of patterning with EUV lithography without the use of a photoresist. Further development of the resistless EUV lithography method can be a viable approach to nanometer-scale lithography by overcoming the inherent resolution and roughness limitations of photoresist materials.
Abstract Two‐dimensional dopant layers (δ‐layers) in semiconductors provide the high‐mobility electron liquids (2DELs) needed for nanoscale quantum‐electronic devices. Key parameters such as carrier densities, effective masses, and confinement thicknesses for 2DELs have traditionally been extracted from quantum magnetotransport. In principle, the parameters are immediately readable from the one‐electron spectral function that can be measured by angle‐resolved photoemission spectroscopy (ARPES). Here, buried 2DEL δ‐layers in silicon are measured with soft X‐ray (SX) ARPES to obtain detailed information about their filled conduction bands and extract device‐relevant properties. This study takes advantage of the larger probing depth and photon energy range of SX‐ARPES relative to vacuum ultraviolet (VUV) ARPES to accurately measure the δ‐layer electronic confinement. The measurements are made on ambient‐exposed samples and yield extremely thin (< 1 nm) and dense (≈1014 cm−2) 2DELs. Critically, this method is used to show that δ‐layers of arsenic exhibit better electronic confinement than δ‐layers of phosphorus fabricated under identical conditions.
Dopant impurity species can be incorporated into the silicon (001) surface via the adsorption and dissociation of simple precursor molecules. Examples include phosphine (PH3), arsine (AsH3), and diborane (B2H6) for the incorporation of phosphorus, arsenic, and boron, respectively. Through exploitation of precursor surface chemistry, the spatial locations of these incorporated dopants can be controlled at the atomic scale via the patterning of a hydrogen lithographic resist layer using scanning tunneling microscopy (STM). There is strong interest in the spatial control of bismuth atoms incorporated into silicon for quantum technological applications; however, there is currently no known precursor for the incorporation of bismuth that is compatible with this STM-based lithographic method. Here, we explore the precursor chemistry (adsorption, diffusion, and dissociation) of bismuth trichloride (BiCl3) on Si(001). We show atomic-resolution STM images of BiCl3 exposed Si(001) surfaces at low coverage and combine this with density functional theory calculations to produce a model of the surface processes and the observed features. Our results show that, at room temperature, BiCl3 completely dissociates to produce bismuth ad-atoms, ad-dimers, and surface-bound chlorine, and we explain how BiCl3 is a strong candidate for a bismuth precursor compound compatible with lithographic patterning at the sub-nanometer scale.
Germanium has emerged as an exceptionally promising material for spintronics and quantum information applications, with significant fundamental advantages over silicon. However, efforts to create atomic-scale devices using donor atoms as qubits have largely focused on phosphorus in silicon. Positioning phosphorus in silicon with atomic-scale precision requires a thermal incorporation anneal, but the low success rate for this step has been shown to be a fundamental limitation prohibiting the scale-up to large-scale devices. Here, we present a comprehensive study of arsine (AsH3) on the germanium (001) surface. We show that, unlike any previously studied dopant precursor on silicon or germanium, arsenic atoms fully incorporate into substitutional surface lattice sites at room temperature. Our results pave the way for the next generation of atomic-scale donor devices combining the superior electronic properties of germanium with the enhanced properties of arsine/germanium chemistry that promises scale-up to large numbers of deterministically placed qubits.
1 London Centre for Nanotechnology, University College London, WC1H 0AH, London, United Kingdom 2 Department of Physics and Astronomy, University College London, WC1E 6BT, London, United Kingdom 3 Department of Chemistry and Biochemistry, University of Delaware, Newark, Delaware 19716, United States of America 4 Department of Physics, University of Central Florida, Orlando, Florida 32816-2385, United States of America
Germanium has emerged as an exceptionally promising material for spintronics and quantum information applications, with significant fundamental advantages over silicon. However, efforts to create atomic-scale devices using donor atoms as qubits have largely focussed on phosphorus in silicon. Positioning phosphorus in silicon with atomic-scale precision requires a thermal incorporation anneal, but the low success rate for this step has been shown to be a fundamental limitation prohibiting the scale-up to large-scale devices. Here, we present a comprehensive study of arsine (AsH_3) on the germanium (001) surface. We show that, unlike any previously studied dopant precursor on silicon or germanium, arsenic atoms fully incorporate into substitutional surface lattice sites at room temperature. Our results pave the way for the next generation of atomic-scale donor devices combining the superior electronic properties of germanium with the enhanced properties of arsine/germanium chemistry that promises scale-up to large numbers of deterministically-placed qubits.
•An atomically flat GeSn wetting-layer can be grown on Ge(100).•Ge intermixing with the GeSn layer is minimal (<2%).•Room temperature Sn growth minimizes the thermal impact on integrated devices.•As Sn coverage increases to a full wetting layer the growth kinetics change.
We present the discovery of a charge density wave (CDW) ground state in heavily electron-doped molybdenum disulfide (MoS2). This is the first observation of a CDW in any d2 (column 6) transition metal dichalcogenide (TMD). The band structure of MoS2 is distinct from the d0 and d1 TMDs in which CDWs have been previously observed, facilitating new insight into CDW formation. We demonstrate a metal–insulator transition at 85 K, a 25 meV gap at the Fermi level, and two distinct CDW modulations, (2√3 × 2√3) R30° and 2 × 2, attributable to Fermi surface nesting (FSN) and electron–phonon coupling (EPC), respectively. This simultaneous exhibition of FSN and EPC CDW modulations is unique among observations of CDW ground states, and we discuss this in the context of band folding. Our observations provide a route toward the resolution of controversies surrounding the origin of CDW modulations in TMDs.