
Abstract Background Research has shown that school climates characterized by equality, inclusion, and multiculturalism are associated with more positive academic and psychological outcomes. However, prior work has focused mainly on school-level diversity approaches, with less attention to students’ collective diversity norms. Additionally, evidence has largely come from Western single-country samples. Aims This study examines associations between two forms of student-endorsed diversity norms—multicultural and equality/inclusion norms—and academic performance (math and reading) as well as psychological adjustment (school belonging, attitudes toward learning) across multiple national contexts. It also examines whether these associations are indirect through school belonging and whether cross-national patterns vary according to the OECD migration-context typology. Sample Data were drawn from the 2018 Programme for International Student Assessment, comprising 273,623 15-year-old students across 34 countries/regions. Methods Multilevel modeling accounted for the nested data structure and estimated associations between diversity norms and student outcomes, controlling for student-level covariates and school-level immigrant proportion and school-average socioeconomic status. Multilevel mediation analyses examined whether school belonging accounted for associations between norms and adjustment. Results Multicultural norms showed very small positive associations with school belonging and attitudes toward learning, and moderate positive associations with academic performance. Equality/inclusion norms showed small positive associations with school belonging and academic performance but not with attitudes toward learning. For multicultural norms, school belonging accounted for associations with attitudes toward learning, math performance, and reading performance; for equality/inclusion norms, this indirect association was observed only for attitudes toward learning. Cross-national analyses indicated that associations varied by norm type and outcome: multicultural norms showed greater cross-national generalizability for academic performance than for psychological adjustment, whereas equality/inclusion norms showed more context-dependent patterns across all outcomes. Overall, the strength of associations between student-endorsed diversity norms and adjustment differed systematically across migration contexts, institutional frameworks, and stages of diversity integration. Conclusions Students'' endorsed diversity norms are important school-level correlates of academic and psychological adjustment, highlighting their relevance as a dimension of school diversity climates and their potential importance for supporting students'' academic and psychosocial development in increasingly diverse school environments.
International large-scale assessments permit comparative examination of affective and behavioural correlates of achievement, but whether these associations are shared or system-dependent across selected East Asian education systems remains unclear. This study examined adjusted associations among two mathematics self-efficacy indices, math anxiety, mathematics-specific behavioural engagement, and mathematical literacy in six systems participating in PISA 2022. Three survey-weighted regression models were estimated using 33,824–33,854 students from Chinese Taipei, Hong Kong (China), Japan, Korea, Macao (China), and Singapore, with the two mathematics self-efficacy indices included as focal predictors. Equal-system pooled models, in which each system contributed equal total weight, incorporated the final student weight and 80 BRR–Fay replicate weights. All 10 mathematics plausible values were analysed for quantities involving mathematical literacy. Interaction models assessed coefficient heterogeneity across systems, gender, and socioeconomic status, and regression coefficients were combined to estimate model-implied indirect associations under the hypothesised ordering. Both self-efficacy indices were associated with lower math anxiety and greater behavioural engagement. Self-efficacy for formal and applied mathematics showed the largest focal adjusted association with mathematical literacy: a one-standard-deviation contrast corresponded to approximately 49 PISA points, and the association was positive in all six systems. By contrast, the mutually adjusted association between reasoning-related self-efficacy and literacy was specification-sensitive. Math anxiety was negatively associated with behavioural engagement and literacy; its quadratic association with literacy was statistically detectable but substantively small (incremental R2 ≈ 0.0012). Behavioural engagement had an approximately zero pooled association with literacy, although system-specific coefficients differed in direction. Several associations varied across systems, whereas evidence of gender- and socioeconomic-status-related heterogeneity was limited. Anxiety-related indirect associations were small, and engagement-related routes were not supported in the pooled analysis. The findings indicate a mixture of comparatively consistent and system-dependent adjusted associations across the six systems. Formal and applied mathematics self-efficacy was the most substantial focal correlate of mathematical literacy, whereas other associations were smaller, specification-sensitive, or more system-dependent. Because the data were cross-sectional, the results describe adjusted associations rather than temporal or causal processes.
Abstract This study applies a large-scale unsupervised learning pipeline to Saber Pro microdata from 452,020 Colombian higher education students (2021 to 2023), integrating academic performance across five modules with socioeconomic, financing, labor, digital-asset, and educational-background variables. K-means, Gaussian Mixture Models, DBSCAN, and HDBSCAN were evaluated on UMAP-reduced representations across 128 configurations, using a two-phase design: hyperparameter search on a validated 200,000-record stratified sample, followed by retraining on the full dataset. An ablation study confirmed UMAP’s necessity (4.5× higher Silhouette than the original 32-dimensional space). The selected K-means K = 8 configuration showed internal validity indices (Silhouette = 0.428, Davies-Bouldin = 0.74) indistinguishable from those obtained on permuted null data, and moderate stability under the most conservative replication protocol (mean ARI = 0.506, SD = 0.085, across 15 reruns varying both UMAP seed and fitting subsample); the profiles’ structural meaningfulness is instead supported by their convergence with independently documented regional inequality patterns (geographic external validation). Eight structurally differentiated profiles emerged, ranging from severe digital exclusion in frontier territories (mean score 136.30) to high-performing students (205.28), with intermediate profiles defined by financing dependence, parental education asymmetries, and working-hour constraints. The contrast between DBSCAN’s highest Silhouette (0.828, with 98.8% of observations classified as noise) and the selected solution illustrates the importance of distinguishing statistical optimization from institutional usability. Profile alignment with known regional inequalities, without geographic variables in clustering, provides external validity. Findings support three differentiated intervention tiers: structural equity interventions, preventive academic supports, and enrichment pathways.
Abstract Second-level digital divides, often studied as the association between socioeconomic status (SES) and digital competence, remain a central concern in digital educational research. Whereas many countries have invested substantially in school digitalization, little is known about which school-level factors can mitigate SES-related disparities in digital competence. We addressed this gap using large-scale and representative data from the International Computer and Information Literacy Study (ICILS) 2023. Employing a two-step meta-analytic approach, country-specific multilevel models were first estimated and subsequently synthesized to quantify average effects and cross-national variation. Results indicated a positive, moderate association between SES and digital competence (β = 17.73, SE = 0.93, 95% CI [15.84, 19.61]). Several digital classroom practices, including the use of general information and communication technology (ICT) applications, inquiry-based teaching, and teachers’ use of utility software were positively related to students’ digital competence. Crucially, the SES-digital competence association was not moderated by classroom practices or teacher- or school-level factors. Whereas digital media integration was linked to higher overall levels of digital competence, it did not systematically reduce socioeconomic disparities. These findings suggest that digital instructional practices function primarily as performance-enhancing rather than equity-enhancing mechanisms. For research in digital education, the results highlight the importance of distinguishing between average learning gains and distributional effects. If digital competence is to serve as a lever for educational equity, targeted and structural interventions may be required beyond general digitalization strategies.
Adolescents’ digital skill development is shaped not only by school environments but also by parental regulation of technology use. While Parental Mediation Theory distinguishes between restrictive and enabling strategies, empirical research has rarely differentiated between forms of restrictive mediation, particularly the distinction between strict (no exceptions) and flexible (homework-permitted) screen-time limits. Moreover, existing studies often rely on self-reports for gauging student achievement, lack comprehensive controls, or overlook how the flexibility of rules may matter. This study examines how different forms of parental screen-time limits are associated with Grade 8 students’ computer and information literacy (CIL) and computational thinking (CT), and whether these associations vary by socioeconomic status. We analyze data from the International Computer and Information Literacy Study (ICILS) 2023 using three-level linear models (students nested within schools within countries). The analytic samples include 96,455 students (CIL; 4,609 schools; 29 countries) and 60,223 students (CT; 2,722 schools; 19 countries). Outcomes are CIL and CT plausible values. Key predictors distinguish strict and flexible parental screen-time limits (reference: no limits). Models adjust for gender, socioeconomic status (SES), immigration status, computer experience, ICT self-efficacy, and internet access, with covariates group-mean centered. Cross-level interactions test whether SES moderates associations between parental rules and outcomes. Within schools, strict screen-time limits are negatively associated with both outcomes (CIL: B = -14.94, p < .001; CT: B = -17.31, p < .001), whereas flexible limits are positively associated with performance, particularly for CT (CIL: B = 2.17, p < .001; CT: B = 8.34, p < .001). Similarly, at the between-school level, strict screen-time limits are negatively associated with both outcomes (CIL: B = -48.12, p < .001; CT: B = -47.22, p < .001), whereas flexible limits are positively associated with performance, particularly for CT (CIL: B = 9.74, p < .05; CT: B = 33.67, p < .001). Interaction models indicate no statistically significant moderation by SES for CIL. For CT, however, the positive interaction between flexible parental limits and SES (B = 3.82, p < .01) suggests that the association between flexible regulation and CT is stronger among higher-SES students, consistent with cumulative advantage. Not all restrictive parental strategies operate equivalently. While strict limitations appear to constrain opportunities for digital skill development, flexible rules that permit educational use are associated with higher performance, particularly among socioeconomically advantaged students for computational thinking. These findings extend Parental Mediation Theory by demonstrating that the structure and flexibility of rules—rather than restriction per se—are central to understanding digital skill acquisition. The results highlight the importance of context-sensitive parental guidance and suggest that policies should support parents in adopting balanced, education-oriented approaches to screen-time regulation.