
Abstract Multi‐ethnic party systems, which are mainly composed of multi‐ethnic parties, face a distinctive form of the “exclusion‐amid‐inclusion” problem. In such contexts, ethnic minorities cannot rely on their own ethnic party to represent them, and risk being represented in merely tokenistic ways by multi‐ethnic parties. This article examines how this risk can be mitigated by identifying the actors, practices, and affordances of multi‐ethnic party systems that made substantive minority representation possible against the odds in Mauritius. Despite a long history of tokenism, substantive representation of the Creole minority was achieved in the 2000s, notably through the establishment of a Truth and Justice Commission on the legacy of slavery and indentured labour. Building on archival research and interviews, we use controversy mapping to study substantive representation in practice. Our findings suggest that, while multi‐ethnic party systems can enable tokenism, they also offer minorities unique avenues for achieving substantive minority representation.
Abstract One of the primary goals of political campaigns is to shape voters' decisions. Despite elites spending money on advertising, its effectiveness in persuading voters remains a subject of debate. Based on theories of attitude change, I argue that increased exposure to advertising persuades voters to change their vote intention in the direction of the ads. Moreover, this study examines the moderating effect of sophistication on the relationship between ad exposure and vote choice. To test the effect of print and online advertisements on vote change, I link detailed campaign advertisement data to individual‐level rolling cross‐section panel data from the 2023 Climate Law referendum in Switzerland. The findings show that exposure to advertisements against the Climate Law significantly influences vote change, while exposure to ads in favor does not reach statistical significance. Evidence regarding sophistication's moderating role is limited.
This study examines Swiss citizens' preferences for alternative political decision-makers-independent experts, businesspeople, and ordinary citizens via referenda-relative to party politicians, and how these preferences, when combined with attitudes toward strong leadership, translate into voting orientations for the main Swiss parties. Using data from the 2023 Selects post-election survey, our findings show that, contrary to crisis-based interpretations, support for alternative decision-makers is not rooted in anti-system attitudes but reflects the pluralistic logic of Swiss institutions, characterized by direct democracy, collegial executive governance, and the militia principle. Moreover, expert-oriented citizens are more inclined toward progressive parties, whereas direct democrats show a higher propensity to support the SVP. Support for strong leadership further reinforces this pattern, increasing the likelihood of voting for the SVP. Diese Studie untersucht die Pr & auml;ferenzen von Schweizer B & uuml;rgern f & uuml;r alternative politische Entscheidungstr & auml;ger - unabh & auml;ngige Expertinnen und Experten, Unternehmerinnen und Unternehmer sowie gew & ouml;hnliche B & uuml;rgerinnen und B & uuml;rger in Volksabstimmungen - im Vergleich zu Parteipolitikerinnen und -politikern. Zudem analysiert sie, wie sich diese Pr & auml;ferenzen in Verbindung mit Einstellungen gegen & uuml;ber einer starken F & uuml;hrungspers & ouml;nlichkeit auf die Wahlabsichten zugunsten der wichtigsten Schweizer Parteien auswirken. Unsere Ergebnisse, die auf der Selects-Nachwahlbefragung 2023 basieren, zeigen dass die Unterst & uuml;tzung alternativer Entscheidungstr & auml;ger entgegen krisenorientierten Interpretationen nicht auf antidemokratischen oder systemfeindlichen Einstellungen beruht, sondern die pluralistische Logik der Schweizer Institutionen widerspiegelt, die durch die direkte Demokratie, eine kollegiale Regierungsf & uuml;hrung und das Milizprinzip gepr & auml;gt sind. Zudem neigen expertenorientierte B & uuml;rger eher dazu, progressive Parteien zu unterst & uuml;tzen, w & auml;hrend direktdemokratisch orientierte B & uuml;rger eine st & auml;rkere Neigung aufweisen, die SVP zu w & auml;hlen. Die Unterst & uuml;tzung einer starken F & uuml;hrungspers & ouml;nlichkeit verst & auml;rkt dieses Muster zus & auml;tzlich und erh & ouml;ht profil & uuml;bergreifend die Wahrscheinlichkeit einer SVP-Wahl. Cette & eacute;tude examine les pr & eacute;f & eacute;rences des citoyens suisses pour les d & eacute;cideurs politiques alternatifs - experts ind & eacute;pendants, chefs d'entreprise et citoyens ordinaires par r & eacute;f & eacute;rendum - par rapport aux & eacute;lus traditionnels, ainsi que la mani & egrave;re dont ces pr & eacute;f & eacute;rences, combin & eacute;es aux attitudes envers un leadership fort, se traduisent en orientations de vote pour les principaux partis. & Agrave; partir des donn & eacute;es de l'enqu & ecirc;te post & eacute;lectorale Selects 2023, nos r & eacute;sultats montrent que le soutien & agrave; des d & eacute;cideurs alternatifs n'est pas enracin & eacute; dans des attitudes antisyst & egrave;mes, mais refl & egrave;te la logique pluraliste des institutions suisses, fond & eacute;es sur la d & eacute;mocratie directe, la coll & eacute;gialit & eacute; de l'ex & eacute;cutif et le principe de milice. Les citoyens qui confieraient les d & eacute;cisions & agrave; des experts tendent davantage & agrave; soutenir les partis progressistes, tandis que ceux qui les confieraient aux citoyens ordinaires pr & eacute;sentent une plus forte propension & agrave; voter pour l'UDC. Le soutien & agrave; un leadership fort renforce cette tendance en augmentant la probabilit & eacute; de voter pour l'UDC. Questo studio esamina le preferenze dei cittadini svizzeri nei confronti di decisori politici alternativi - esperti indipendenti, imprenditori e cittadini ordinari tramite referendum - rispetto ai tradizionali politici di partito, e il modo in cui tali preferenze, combinate con gli atteggiamenti verso una leadership forte, si traducono in orientamenti di voto per i principali partiti svizzeri. Sulla base dell'indagine post-elettorale Selects 2023, i risultati mostrano che il sostegno a decisori alternativi non & egrave; radicato in atteggiamenti antisistema, bens & igrave; riflette la logica pluralistica delle istituzioni svizzere, fondate sulla democrazia diretta, sulla collegialit & agrave; dell'esecutivo e sul principio di milizia. Chi affiderebbe le decisioni politiche agli esperti tende a sostenere maggiormente i partiti progressisti, mentre chi le affiderebbe ai cittadini mostra una maggiore propensione a votare per l'UDC. Il sostegno a una leadership forte rafforza ulteriormente questa tendenza, aumentando la probabilit & agrave; di voto per l'UDC.
Powersharing systems rely on descriptive representation, where elected elites 'stand in' for their segment's voters, incentivising intransigence and penalising cross-segmental cooperation. Yet powersharing politics regularly witness cross-segmental appeals, voting patterns and party formation. Though irrational under institutions encouraging descriptive representation, they are the consequence of nested claims: representative strategies through which segmental elites incorporate non-segmental issues into their programmatic appeals, simultaneously entrenching their intrasegmental position and signalling institutional commitment. Thereby, intrasegmental competition drives the process: non-dominant elites adopt issues originating outside formal politics and test their electoral viability; dominant elites adopt those that prove successful, transmitting societal concerns into formal political agendas without requiring cross-segmental parties to succeed electorally. Departing from centripetalist and institutional accommodationist accounts, my argument generates three observable subgames traced through a structured focused comparison of Northern Ireland and Bosnia: dominant elites broaden appeals when secure, retrench around vital interests under electoral threat, while non-dominant elites will innovate continuously. Machtteilungssysteme st & uuml;tzen sich auf deskriptive Repr & auml;sentation. Dabei & bdquo;ersetzen "gew & auml;hlte Eliten die W & auml;hler:innen ihres eigenen Segments, was Unnachgiebigkeit beg & uuml;nstigt und segment & uuml;bergreifende Kooperation erschwert. Dennoch sind in der Machtteilungspolitik regelm & auml;ssig segment & uuml;bergreifende Appelle, Abstimmungsmuster und Parteibildungen zu beobachten. Obwohl diese unter Institutionen, die deskriptive Repr & auml;sentation f & ouml;rdern, irrational erscheinen, sind sie die Folge verschachtelter Anspr & uuml;che (nested claims): Repr & auml;sentationsstrategien, durch die segment & auml;re Eliten nicht-segment & auml;re Themen in ihre programmatischen Appelle integrieren. Damit festigen sie gleichzeitig ihre intrasegment & auml;re Position und signalisieren institutionelles Engagement. Der Prozess wird somit durch den intrasegment & auml;ren Wettbewerb angetrieben: Nicht-dominante Eliten greifen Themen auf, die ausserhalb der formalen Politik entstehen, und testen deren elektoralen Erfolg; dominante Eliten & uuml;bernehmen die erfolgreichen Themen und tragen gesellschaftliche Anliegen in formale politische Agenden ein, ohne dass segment & uuml;bergreifende Parteien f & uuml;r einen Wahlerfolg notwendig w & auml;ren. In Abgrenzung zu zentripetalistischen und institutionell-akkommodatorischen Ans & auml;tzen leitet mein Argument drei beobachtbare Teilspiele ab, die mittels eines strukturierten, fokussierten Vergleichs von Nordirland und Bosnien nachgezeichnet werden: Dominante Eliten weiten ihre Appelle aus, wenn sie abgesichert sind, und ziehen sich bei einer elektoralen Bedrohung auf vitale Interessen zur & uuml;ck, w & auml;hrend nicht-dominante Eliten kontinuierlich Innovationen hervorbringen. Les syst & egrave;mes de partage du pouvoir reposent sur la repr & eacute;sentation descriptive, o & ugrave; les & eacute;lites & eacute;lues & laquo; repr & eacute;sentent & raquo; les & eacute;lecteurs & centerdot;rices de leur propre segment, ce qui encourage l'intransigeance et p & eacute;nalise la coop & eacute;ration transsegmentaire. Pourtant, la vie politique du partage du pouvoir est r & eacute;guli & egrave;rement le th & eacute;& acirc;tre d'appels transsegmentaires, de mod & egrave;les de vote et de formations de partis. Bien qu'irrationnels dans le cadre d'institutions qui encouragent la repr & eacute;sentation descriptive, ils sont la cons & eacute;quence de revendications imbriqu & eacute;es (nested claims): des strat & eacute;gies de repr & eacute;sentation par lesquelles les & eacute;lites segmentaires int & egrave;grent des enjeux non segmentaires dans leurs appels programmatiques, renfor & ccedil;ant simultan & eacute;ment leur position intrasegmentaire et signalant leur engagement institutionnel. Ainsi, la comp & eacute;tition intrasegmentaire est le moteur de ce processus: les & eacute;lites non dominantes adoptent des enjeux n & eacute;s en dehors de la politique formelle et testent leur viabilit & eacute; & eacute;lectorale; les & eacute;lites dominantes adoptent ceux qui s'av & egrave;rent fructueux, transmettant les pr & eacute;occupations soci & eacute;tales dans les agendas politiques formels sans qu'il soit n & eacute;cessaire que des partis transsegmentaires l'emportent aux & eacute;lections. Se d & eacute;marquant des approches centrip & eacute;tistes et accommodationnistes institutionnelles, mon argument g & eacute;n & egrave;re trois sous-jeux observables, retrac & eacute;s & agrave; travers une comparaison structur & eacute;e et cibl & eacute;e de l'Irlande du Nord et de la Bosnie: les & eacute;lites dominantes & eacute;largissent leurs appels lorsqu'elles sont en s & eacute;curit & eacute;, se replient sur des int & eacute;r & ecirc;ts vitaux en cas de menace & eacute;lectorale, tandis que les & eacute;lites non dominantes innoveront continuellement. I sistemi di condivisione del potere (power-sharing) si basano sulla rappresentanza descrittiva, in cui le & eacute;lite elette & laquo;sostituiscono & raquo; l'elettorato del proprio segmento, incentivando l'intransigenza e penalizzando la cooperazione trans-segmentale. Eppure, le dinamiche politiche di condivisione del potere mostrano regolarmente appelli trans-segmentali, modelli di voto e la formazione di nuovi partiti. Sebbene irrazionali all'interno di istituzioni che incoraggiano la rappresentanza descrittiva, essi sono la conseguenza di rivendicazioni nidificate (nested claims): strategie di rappresentanza attraverso cui le & eacute;lite segmentali incorporano questioni non segmentali nei loro appelli programmatici, consolidando simultaneamente la propria posizione intrasegmentale e segnalando un impegno istituzionale. In questo modo, la competizione intrasegmentale guida il processo: le & eacute;lite non dominanti adottano questioni nate al di fuori della politica formelle e ne testano la fattibilit & agrave; elettorale; le & eacute;lite dominanti adottano quelle che si rivelano vincenti, trasmettendo le istanze sociali nelle agende politiche formali senza richiedere il successo elettorale di partiti trans-segmentali. Distanziandosi dagli approcci centripetalisti e dell'accomodamento istituzionale, il mio argomento genera tre sotto-giochi osservabili, tracciati attraverso una comparazione strutturata e mirata di Irlanda del Nord e Bosnia: le & eacute;lite dominanti ampliano i propri appelli quando si sentono sicure, si arroccano su interessi vitali sotto minaccia elettorale, mentre le & eacute;lite non dominanti innoveranno continuamente.
What can the United Nations do to strengthen the protection of civilians when it fails? When missions struggle to protect civilians, high-level naming and shaming of non-responsive units within the operation can occur to reorient the operation. Shaming helps rehabilitate the operation and achieve the protection of civilians. Using an interrupted time-series design, I test this claim in the context of the United Nations Mission in South Sudan (UNMISS), which provides a hard test for the proposition as it occurred during mass atrocities and is often seen as a failure. Isolating short-term versus long-term effects helps illustrate that even in the hardest of cases, shaming can improve civilian protection. Was k & ouml;nnen die Vereinten Nationen tun, um den Schutz von Zivilpersonen zu st & auml;rken, wenn er nicht gew & auml;hrleistet werden kann? Wenn Missionen beim Zivilpersonenschutz an ihre Grenzen stossen, kann ein hochrangiges Anprangern (naming and shaming) nicht reagierender Einheiten innerhalb der Operation eingesetzt werden, um die Mission neu auszurichten. Dieses Anprangern tr & auml;gt dazu bei, die Operation zu rehabilitieren und den Schutz der Zivilbev & ouml;lkerung zu gew & auml;hrleisten. Mithilfe eines unterbrochenen Zeitreihendesigns (interrupted time-series design) teste ich diese These im Kontext der Mission der Vereinten Nationen im S & uuml;dsudan (UNMISS). Dieser Fall stellt eine strenge Pr & uuml;fung f & uuml;r diese Hypothese dar, da er sich w & auml;hrend schwerer Massengr & auml;ueltaten ereignete und h & auml;ufig als Misserfolg bewertet wird. Die Isolierung von kurz- und langfristigen Effekten verdeutlicht, dass ein Anprangern selbst in den schwierigsten F & auml;llen den Schutz von Zivilpersonen verbessern kann. Que peuvent faire les Nations Unies pour renforcer la protection des civils lorsqu'elle & eacute;choue? Lorsque les missions peinent & agrave; prot & eacute;ger les populations civiles, une d & eacute;nonciation publique (naming and shaming) & agrave; haut niveau des unit & eacute;s d & eacute;faillantes au sein de l'op & eacute;ration peut & ecirc;tre mis en oe uvre afin de la r & eacute;orienter. Cette d & eacute;nonciation contribue & agrave; r & eacute;habiliter l'op & eacute;ration et & agrave; assurer la protection des civils. & Agrave; l'aide d'une m & eacute;thode & agrave; s & eacute;ries temporelles interrompues (interrupted time-series design), je teste cette hypoth & egrave;se dans le contexte de la Mission des Nations Unies au Soudan du Sud (MINUSS). Ce cas constitue un test exigeant pour cette proposition, parce qu'il s'inscrit dans un contexte d'atrocit & eacute;s de masse et est souvent consid & eacute;r & eacute; comme un & eacute;chec. L'isolement des effets & agrave; court et & agrave; long terme permet de d & eacute;montrer que, m & ecirc;me dans les cas les plus difficiles, la d & eacute;nonciation peut am & eacute;liorer la protection des civils. Che cosa possono fare le Nazioni Unite per rafforzare la protezione dei civili quando quest'ultima fallisce? Quando le missioni faticano a proteggere i civili, l'esposizione pubblica ad alto livello (naming and shaming) delle unit & agrave; non reattive all'interno dell'operazione pu & ograve; essere utilizzata per riorientare la missione stessa. Tale denuncia aiuta a riabilitare l'operazione e a conseguire la protezione dei civili. Utilizzando un disegno a serie temporali interrotte (interrupted time-series design), verifico questa tesi nel contesto della Missione delle Nazioni Unite nel Sudan del Sud (UNMISS). Questo caso rappresenta un test severo (hard test) per l'ipotesi formulata, poich & eacute; si & egrave; verificato durante atrocit & agrave; di massa ed & egrave; spesso considerato un fallimento. Isolare gli effetti a breve e a lungo termine evidenzia come, anche nei casi pi & ugrave; complessi, l'esposizione possa migliorare la protezione dei civili.