ABSTRACT Background World Health Organization Grade 2 meningiomas (G2Ms) exhibit an aggressive natural history characterized by recurrence and therapy resistance. G2Ms with histopathological necrosis have been associated with worse local control (LC) following radiation therapy, but drivers and biomarkers of radiation resistance in these G2Ms remain unknown. Methods We performed genetic sequencing and histopathological analysis of 113 G2Ms and investigated the role of intratumoral hypoxia as well as genes of interest through knockdown and clonogenic survival following ionizing radiation. Lastly, we performed transcriptional profiling of our in vitro model and 18 G2M tumors using RNA sequencing. Results NF2 loss-of-function (LOF) mutations were associated with necrosis in G2Ms (p=0.0127). Tumors with NF2 mutation and necrosis had worse post-radiation LC compared to NF2 wildtype tumors without necrosis (p=0.035). Under hypoxic conditions, NF2 knockdown increased radiation resistance in vitro (p<0.001). Bulk RNA sequencing of our in vitro model revealed NF2 - and hypoxia-specific changes and a 50-gene set signature specific to radiation resistant, NF2 knockdown and hypoxic cells, which could distinguish NF2 mutant and necrotic patient G2Ms by unsupervised clustering. Gene set enrichment analysis of patient tumor and in vitro data revealed downregulation of apoptosis and upregulation of proliferation in NF2 -deficient and hypoxic cells, which we validated with functional assays. Conclusions NF2 LOF in the setting of hypoxia confers radiation resistance through transcriptional programs that reduce apoptosis and promote proliferation. These pathways may identify tumors resistant to radiation and represent therapeutic targets that in the future could improve LC in patients with radiation resistant G2Ms. KEY POINTS 1. Spontaneous necrosis with NF2 mutations is associated with radio-resistance in WHO G2Ms. 2. NF2 knockdown in the setting of hypoxia confers radio-resistance to meningioma cells in vitro and is driven by increased cell proliferation and decreased apoptosis. IMPORTANCE OF THE STUDY World Health Organization Grade 2 meningiomas (G2M) are often treated with surgical resection followed by radiation, especially in the case of recurrence. However, the mechanisms underlying radiation resistance in G2Ms remain to be identified, and moreover, we lack biomarkers to distinguish G2Ms that will respond to radiotherapy from those that are refractory. In this study we perform histological and molecular analysis of a large cohort of G2Ms to identify predictors of radiation resistance. Using these data and an in vitro model of radiation therapy, we demonstrate that radiation resistance in G2Ms is likely driven by the combination of NF2 gene mutations and the hypoxia that accompanies tumor necrosis. Patients whose tumors bear these two features may therefore benefit from alternative treatments that target specific pathways implicated in radiation resistance.
Glioblastoma is a lethal brain cancer marked by functional plasticity driven by tumor cell-intrinsic mutations and their interplay with developmental programs. To investigate how canonical glioblastoma mutations promote functional plasticity, we have developed an isogenic human neural stem cell (NSC) model of glioblastoma by sequential addition of TERT promoter, TP53, and PDGFRA point mutations. TP53 loss-of-function increases TERT expression during serial mutagenesis, but only triple mutant NSCs reliably form lethal brain tumors in vivo that recapitulate glioblastoma. Tumor cell evolution triggers stress-related metabolic changes and transitions toward a neuronal progenitor network driven by transcription factor INSM1. INSM1 is highly expressed in human glioblastoma tumors and, during cortical development, in intermediate progenitor cells, which give rise to neurons. Remarkably, INSM1 knockdown in triple mutant NSCs and primary glioblastoma cells disrupts oncogenic gene expression and function and inhibits the in vivo tumorigenicity of triple mutant NSCs, highlighting the functional importance of an intermediate progenitor cell-like cell state in glioblastoma pathogenesis.
Background: World Health Organization Grade 2 meningiomas (G2Ms) often recur and resist therapies. Grade 2 meningiomas with histopathological necrosis have been associated with worse local control (LC) after radiation therapy, but the drivers and biomarkers of radiation resistance in G2Ms remain unknown. Methods: We performed genetic sequencing and histopathological analysis of 113 G2Ms and investigated the role of genetic and microenvironmental factors on clonogenic survival after ionizing radiation. We performed transcriptional profiling of our in vitro model and 18 human G2M tumors by bulk RNA sequencing as well as 8 G2Ms by single nuclei RNA sequencing. Results: NF2 loss-of-function (LOF) mutations were associated with necrosis in G2Ms (P = .0127). Tumors with NF2 mutation and necrosis had worse post-radiation LC compared to NF2 wildtype tumors without necrosis (P = .035). Under hypoxic conditions, NF2 knockdown increased radiation resistance in vitro (P < .001). Bulk RNA sequencing revealed NF2- and hypoxia-specific changes and a 50-gene set signature specific to radiation-resistant, NF2 knockdown, and hypoxic cells, which distinguished NF2 mutant/necrotic patient G2Ms by unsupervised clustering. Enrichment analysis revealed downregulation of apoptosis pathway genes and upregulation of proliferation-associated genes and genes normally downregulated after UV radiation exposure in NF2-mutant/necrotic tumor cells, which were validated with functional assays. Conclusions: NF2 LOF in the setting of hypoxia confers radiation resistance through transcriptional programs that reduce apoptosis and promote proliferation. These pathways may identify tumors resistant to radiation and represent therapeutic targets that in the future could improve LC in patients with radiation resistant G2Ms.
Precise control of protein ubiquitination is essential for brain development, and hence, disruption of ubiquitin signaling networks can lead to neurological disorders. Mutations of the deubiquitinase USP7 cause the Hao-Fountain syndrome (HAFOUS), characterized by developmental delay, intellectual disability, autism, and aggressive behavior. Here, we report that conditional deletion of USP7 in excitatory neurons in the mouse forebrain triggers diverse phenotypes including sensorimotor deficits, learning and memory impairment, and aggressive behavior, resembling clinical features of HAFOUS. USP7 deletion induces neuronal apoptosis in a manner dependent of the tumor suppressor p53. However, most behavioral abnormalities in USP7 conditional mice persist despite p53 loss. Strikingly, USP7 deletion in the brain perturbs the synaptic proteome and dendritic spine morphogenesis independently of p53. Integrated proteomics analysis reveals that the neuronal USP7 interactome is enriched for proteins implicated in neurodevelopmental disorders and specifically identifies the RNA splicing factor Ppil4 as a novel neuronal substrate of USP7. Knockdown of Ppil4 in cortical neurons impairs dendritic spine morphogenesis, phenocopying the effect of USP7 loss on dendritic spines. These findings reveal a novel USP7-Ppil4 ubiquitin signaling link that regulates neuronal connectivity in the developing brain, with implications for our understanding of the pathogenesis of HAFOUS and other neurodevelopmental disorders.
An important subset of meningiomas behaves aggressively and is characterized by multiple recurrences. We identify clinical, genetic, and epigenetic predictors of multiply recurrent meningiomas (MRMs) and evaluate the evolution of these meningiomas in patient-matched samples. On multivariable binomial logistic regression, MRMs were significantly associated with male sex ( P = 0.012), subtotal resection ( P = 0.001), higher number of meningiomas on presentation ( P = 0.017), and histopathological sheeting ( P = 0.002). Multiomic analysis of primary meningiomas revealed that MRMs have greater copy number losses ( P = 0.0313) and increased DNA methylation ( P = 0.0155). In meningioma cells with knockdown of EDNRB , a locus with greater promoter methylation and decreased gene expression in MRMs had increased proliferation ( P < 0.0001). MRM recurrences were found to be similar to primaries but have a greater burden of copy number gains ( P < 0.0001) and increased methylation ( P = 0.0045). This clinical and multiomic investigation of MRMs harbors implications for the future development of biomarkers and therapeutic agents for these challenging tumors.
Brain-derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF) is a major neurotrophin whose loss or interruption is well established to have numerous intersections with the pathogenesis of progressive neurological disorders. There is perhaps no greater example of disease pathogenesis resulting from the dysregulation of BDNF signaling than Huntington's disease (HD)-an inherited neurodegenerative disorder characterized by motor, psychiatric, and cognitive impairments associated with basal ganglia dysfunction and the ultimate death of striatal projection neurons. Investigation of the collection of mechanisms leading to BDNF loss in HD highlights this neurotrophin's importance to neuronal viability and calls attention to opportunities for therapeutic interventions. Using electronic database searches of existing and forthcoming research, we constructed a literature review with the overarching goal of exploring the diverse set of molecular events that trigger BDNF dysregulation within HD. We highlighted research that investigated these major mechanisms in preclinical models of HD and connected these studies to those evaluating similar endpoints in human HD subjects. We also included a special focus on the growing body of literature detailing key transcriptomic and epigenetic alterations that affect BDNF abundance in HD. Finally, we offer critical evaluation of proposed neurotrophin-directed therapies and assessed clinical trials seeking to correct BDNF expression in HD individuals.
Glioblastoma (GBM) is the most common and lethal primary brain malignancy and is characterized by a high degree of intra and intertumor cellular heterogeneity, a starkly immunosuppressive tumor microenvironment, and nearly universal recurrence. The application of various genomic approaches has allowed us to understand the core molecular signatures, transcriptional states, and DNA methylation patterns that define GBM. Histone posttranslational modifications (PTMs) have been shown to influence oncogenesis in a variety of malignancies, including other forms of glioma, yet comparatively less effort has been placed on understanding the transcriptional impact and regulation of histone PTMs in the context of GBM. In this review we discuss work that investigates the role of histone acetylating and methylating enzymes in GBM pathogenesis, as well as the effects of targeted inhibition of these enzymes. We then synthesize broader genomic and epigenomic approaches to understand the influence of histone PTMs on chromatin architecture and transcription within GBM and finally, explore the limitations of current research in this field before proposing future directions for this area of research.
Additional file 2: Table S1. Biological replicates and clonal lines used. (A) Biological replicate experiments performed, and clones used for each biological replicate experiment are shown. Results obtained for the wild type (WT) H1 hESC line were compared with at least two different clonal H1 derivatives with CRISPR-mediated introduction of the H3K27M mutation, across 3-6 biological replicate experiments, except for ChIP-seq, which involved H3K27M clone 1 versus WT comparisons. (B) ELDA assay: biological replicate experiments performed, and clones used for each biological replicate experiment as well as individual data values are shown. (C) Titer-Glo assay: biological replicate experiments performed, and clones used for each biological replicate experiment as well as individual data values are shown. (D-L) Protein assay: biological replicate experiments performed, and clones used for each biological replicate experiment as well as individual data values are shown. (M-O) Scorecard assay: biological replicate experiments performed, and clones used for each biological replicate experiment as well as individual data values are shown. (P) RT-qPCR assay: biological replicate experiments performed, and clones used for each biological replicate experiment as well as individual data values are shown. (Q) Positive and negative control primer pairs used for DNA methylation analysis.
The pluripotency transcription factor SOX2 is essential for the maintenance of glioblastoma stem cells (GSC), which are thought to underlie tumor growth, treatment resistance, and recurrence. To understand how SOX2 is regulated in GSCs, we utilized a proteomic approach and identified the E3 ubiquitin ligase TRIM26 as a direct SOX2-interacting protein. Unexpectedly, we found TRIM26 depletion decreased SOX2 protein levels and increased SOX2 polyubiquitination in patient-derived GSCs, suggesting TRIM26 promotes SOX2 protein stability. Accordingly, TRIM26 knockdown disrupted the SOX2 gene network and inhibited both self-renewal capacity as well as in vivo tumorigenicity in multiple GSC lines. Mechanistically, we found TRIM26, via its C-terminal PRYSPRY domain, but independent of its RING domain, stabilizes SOX2 protein by directly inhibiting the interaction of SOX2 with WWP2, which we identify as a bona fide SOX2 E3 ligase in GSCs. Our work identifies E3 ligase competition as a critical mechanism of SOX2 regulation, with functional consequences for GSC identity and maintenance.
Huntington's disease (HD) is a devastating and fatal monogenic neurodegenerative disorder characterized by progressive loss of selective neurons in the brain and is caused by an abnormal expansion of CAG trinucleotide repeats in a coding exon of the huntingtin (HTT) gene. Progressive gene expression changes that begin at premanifest stages are a prominent feature of HD and are thought to contribute to disease progression. Increasing evidence suggests the critical involvement of epigenetic mechanisms in abnormal transcription in HD. Genome-wide alterations of a number of epigenetic modifications, including DNA methylation and multiple histone modifications, are associated with HD, suggesting that mutant HTT causes complex epigenetic abnormalities and chromatin structural changes, which may represent an underlying pathogenic mechanism. The causal relationship of specific epigenetic changes to early transcriptional alterations and to disease pathogenesis require further investigation. In this article, we review recent studies on epigenetic regulation in HD with a focus on DNA and histone modifications. We also discuss the contribution of epigenetic modifications to HD pathogenesis as well as potential mechanisms linking mutant HTT and epigenetic alterations. Finally, we discuss the therapeutic potential of epigenetic-based treatments.
BACKGROUND:The blood-brain and blood-tumor barriers (BBB and BTB), which restrict the entry of most drugs into the brain and tumor, respectively, are a significant challenge in the treatment of glioblastoma. Laser interstitial thermal therapy (LITT) is a minimally invasive surgical technique increasingly used clinically for tumor cell ablation. Recent evidence suggests that LITT might locally disrupt BBB integrity, creating a potential therapeutic window of opportunity to deliver otherwise brain-impermeant agents.METHODS:We established a LITT mouse model to test if laser therapy can increase BBB/BTB permeability in vivo. Mice underwent orthotopic glioblastoma tumor implantation followed by LITT in combination with BBB tracers or the anticancer drug doxorubicin. BBB/BTB permeability was measured using fluorimetry, microscopy, and immunofluorescence. An in vitro endothelial cell model was also used to corroborate findings.RESULTS:LITT substantially disrupted the BBB and BTB locally, with increased permeability up to 30 days after the intervention. Remarkably, molecules as large as human immunoglobulin extravasated through blood vessels and permeated laser-treated brain tissue and tumors. Mechanistically, LITT decreased tight junction integrity and increased brain endothelial cell transcytosis. Treatment of mice bearing glioblastoma tumors with LITT and adjuvant doxorubicin, which is typically brain-impermeant, significantly increased animal survival.CONCLUSIONS:Together, these results suggest that LITT can locally disrupt the BBB and BTB, enabling the targeted delivery of systemic therapies, including, potentially, antibody-based agents.
Abstract INTRODUCTION A central challenge in glioblastoma treatment is the presence of the blood-brain barrier (BBB) and blood-tumor barrier (BTB), which prevent access of drugs to the brain and tumor respectively. Recent evidence in patients suggests laser interstitial thermal therapy (LITT), used clinically for tumor ablation, locally disrupts BBB integrity, potentially creating a therapeutic window to deliver otherwise brain-impermeant agents. METHODS A mouse model for LITT, established using a Nd-YAG laser coupled to a 600 mm fiber optic and thermocouple probe, was inserted via burrhole to target the somatosensory cortex. Syngeneic GL261 tumor cells were stereotactically implanted prior to LITT. BBB and BTB permeability were assessed through measurement of fluorescein and doxorubicin after IV injection. Permeability of IV dextran (10 and 70 kDa) and human IgG was monitored by immunohistochemistry (IHC) analysis. Mechanisms of BBB breakdown in vivo were explored utilizing electron microscopy and IHC. RESULTS By fluorescein assay, LITT-induced BBB and BTB permeability began one day post-treatment and was sustained for at least 2 weeks. Additionally, both normal brain and brain tumors demonstrated an increase in Dextran 10 kDa, Dextran 70 kDa, and human IgG extravasation after IV injection in vivo. Mechanistically, we provide evidence that LITT triggers both a decrease in tight junction integrity and an increase in brain endothelial cell transcytosis. As proof-of-concept that LITT can enhance tumor delivery of systemic drugs, LITT increased IV doxorubicin permeability in brain in vivo. Moreover, LITT plus doxorubicin significantly increased survival in brain tumor-bearing mice compared to doxorubicin or LITT alone. CONCLUSIONS Our data suggest that LITT increases BBB and BTB permeability over a defined time window to large molecular weight agents, including antibodies, through multiple cellular mechanisms. Our preclinical results with LITT plus doxorubicin, which mirror a current clinical trial, indicate LITT can enhance the efficacy of systemically delivered drugs.
Huntington's disease (HD) is a fatal neurodegenerative disorder caused by an abnormal expansion of polyglutamine repeats in the huntingtin protein (Htt). Transcriptional dysregulation is an early event in the course of HD progression and is thought to contribute to disease pathogenesis, but how mutant Htt causes transcriptional alterations and subsequent cell death in neurons is not well understood. RNA-Seq analysis revealed that expression of a mutant Htt fragment in primary cortical neurons leads to robust gene expression changes before neuronal death. Basic helix-loop-helix transcription factor Twist1, which is essential for embryogenesis and is normally expressed at low levels in mature neurons, was substantially up-regulated in mutant Htt–expressing neurons in culture and in the brains of HD mouse models. Knockdown of Twist1 by RNAi in mutant Htt–expressing primary cortical neurons reversed the altered expression of a subset of genes involved in neuronal function and, importantly, abrogated neurotoxicity. Using brain-derived neurotrophic factor (Bdnf), which is known to be involved in HD pathogenesis, as a model gene, we found that Twist1 knockdown could reverse mutant Htt–induced DNA hypermethylation at the Bdnf regulatory region and reactivate Bdnf expression. Together, these results suggest that Twist1 is an important upstream mediator of mutant Htt–induced neuronal death and may in part operate through epigenetic mechanisms.
Glioblastoma stem-like cells (GSCs) play a critical role in glioblastoma progression and recurrence. We discuss recent results on the role of the mitotic ubiquitin ligase cell division cycle 20-anaphase-promoting complex (CDC20-APC) in the governance of cardinal GSC functions through a mechanism involving the transcription factor sex-determining region Y-box 2 (SOX2). These findings expand the non-mitotic roles of CDC20-APC with implications for stem cell biology.
Although epigenetic abnormalities have been described in Huntington's disease (HD), the causal epigenetic mechanisms driving neurodegeneration in HD cortex and striatum remain undefined. Using an epigenetic pathway-targeted drug screen, we report that inhibitors of DNA methyltransferases (DNMTs), decitabine and FdCyd, block mutant huntingtin (Htt)-induced toxicity in primary cortical and striatal neurons. In addition, knockdown of DNMT3A or DNMT1 protected neurons against mutant Htt-induced toxicity, together demonstrating a requirement for DNMTs in mutant Htt-triggered neuronal death and suggesting a neurodegenerative mechanism based on DNA methylation-mediated transcriptional repression. Inhibition of DNMTs in HD model primary cortical or striatal neurons restored the expression of several key genes, including Bdnf, an important neurotrophic factor implicated in HD. Accordingly, the Bdnf promoter exhibited aberrant cytosine methylation in mutant Htt-expressing cortical neurons. In vivo, pharmacological inhibition of DNMTs in HD mouse brains restored the mRNA levels of key striatal genes known to be downregulated in HD. Thus, disturbances in DNA methylation play a critical role in mutant Htt-induced neuronal dysfunction and death, raising the possibility that epigenetic strategies targeting abnormal DNA methylation may have therapeutic utility in HD.
Accumulating evidence suggests cancer cells exhibit a dependency on metabolic pathways regulated by nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide (NAD+). Nevertheless, how the regulation of this metabolic cofactor interfaces with signal transduction networks remains poorly understood in glioblastoma. Here, we report nicotinamide phosphoribosyltransferase (NAMPT), the rate-limiting step in NAD+ synthesis, is highly expressed in glioblastoma tumors and patient-derived glioblastoma stem-like cells (GSCs). High NAMPT expression in tumors correlates with decreased patient survival. Pharmacological and genetic inhibition of NAMPT decreased NAD+ levels and GSC self-renewal capacity, and NAMPT knockdown inhibited the in vivo tumorigenicity of GSCs. Regulatory network analysis of RNA sequencing data using GSCs treated with NAMPT inhibitor identified transcription factor E2F2 as the center of a transcriptional hub in the NAD+-dependent network. Accordingly, we demonstrate E2F2 is required for GSC self-renewal. Downstream, E2F2 drives the transcription of members of the inhibitor of differentiation (ID) helix-loop-helix gene family. Finally, we find NAMPT mediates GSC radiation resistance. The identification of a NAMPT-E2F2-ID axis establishes a link between NAD+ metabolism and a self-renewal transcriptional program in glioblastoma, with therapeutic implications for this formidable cancer.
Emerging evidence shows that nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide (NAD+)-dependent signaling plays a critical role in a variety of biological contexts including cancer. The rate-limiting enzyme of the mammalian NAD+ synthesis pathway, nicotinamide phosphoribosyltransferase (NAMPT), governs NAD+-dependent processes by catalyzing production of nicotinamide mononucleotide (NMN), a key NAD+ precursor. However, the role and molecular mechanisms of NAMPT in the biology of human glioblastoma have remained poorly understood. Here, we demonstrate that NAMPT is highly expressed in glioblastoma tumor specimens and patient-derived glioblastoma stem-like cells (GSCs). High NAMPT expression in glioblastoma tumors correlates with poor prognosis in patients. NAMPT inhibition using FK866 as well as RNA interference (RNAi) depleted NAD+ levels in GSCs and substantially decreased GSC self-renewal. Importantly, NAMPT knockdown diminished the in vivo tumorigenicity of GSCs and prolonged the survival of animals in an orthotopic xenograft model. Bioinformatic analysis of RNA-sequencing data derived from FK866-treated GSCs revealed E2F family transcription factor E2F2 as a potential hub of the NAD+-dependent transcriptome. Accordingly, E2F2 knockdown decreased the self-renewal capacity of GSCs. Downstream, we find that E2F2 directly controls the transcription of helix-loop-helix protein inhibitor of differentiation 1 (ID1), a known regulator of self-renewal. Finally, we show that NAMPT promotes radiation resistance of GSCs in culture, highlighting the potential therapeutic relevance of this pathway. The identification of a NAMPT-E2F2-ID1 signaling pathway, which regulates GSC maintenance, has ramifications for the development of novel therapeutic strategies for glioblastoma patients.
Glioblastoma harbors a dynamic subpopulation of glioblastoma stem-like cells (GSCs) that can propagate tumors in vivo and is resistant to standard chemoradiation. Identification of the cell-intrinsic mechanisms governing this clinically important cell state may lead to the discovery of therapeutic strategies for this challenging malignancy. Here, we demonstrate that the mitotic E3 ubiquitin ligase CDC20-anaphase-promoting complex (CDC20-APC) drives invasiveness and self-renewal in patient tumor-derived GSCs. Moreover, CDC20 knockdown inhibited and CDC20 overexpression increased the ability of human GSCs to generate brain tumors in an orthotopic xenograft model in vivo. CDC20-APC control of GSC invasion and self-renewal operates through pluripotency-related transcription factor SOX2. Our results identify a CDC20-APC/SOX2 signaling axis that controls key biological properties of GSCs, with implications for CDC20-APC-targeted strategies in the treatment of glioblastoma.
Recent studies have shown that the major mitotic regulator CDC20-Anaphase Promoting Complex (APC) is required for the maintenance of human glioblastoma stem-like cells (GSCs), a clinically important subpopulation of glioblastoma cells that are believed to underlie tumor recurrence. We have previously shown that CDC20-APC operates through pluripotency transcription factor SOX2 to promote GSC self-renewal and invasion in vitro (Mao, Gujar et al. Cell Reports. 2015). Using patient-derived GSCs, we herein show that APC co-activator CDC20 is required for GSC tumorigenicity in an orthotopic xenograft model. We further demonstrate through in vivo epistasis experiments that CDC20 acts through SOX2 to control GSC tumorigenicity. To test if CDC20-APC activity might dictate GSC responsiveness to standard-of-care chemotherapy agent temozolomide (TMZ), we utilized pharmacological and genetic approaches to inhibit CDC20-APC activity. Intriguingly, both APC inhibitor ProTAME and lentiviral CDC20 RNA interference augmented TMZ cytotoxicity in human GSCs. Collectively, these data suggest that CDC20-APC controls the tumor-initiating potential of GSCs in vivo through SOX2 and that CDC20-APC inhibitory strategies may not only disrupt the GSC state but also enhance the efficacy of chemotherapy.