Nanobubbles (NBs; ~100-500 nm diameter) are preclinical ultrasound (US) contrast agents that expand applications of contrast enhanced US (CEUS). Due to their sub-micron size, high particle density, and deformable shell, NBs in pathological states of heightened vascular permeability (e.g. in tumors) extravasate, enabling applications not possible with microbubbles (~1000-10,000 nm diameter). A method that can separate intravascular versus extravascular NB signal is needed as an imaging biomarker for improved tumor detection. We present a demonstration of decorrelation time (DT) mapping for enhanced tumor NB-CEUS imaging. In vitro models validated the sensitivity of DT to agent motion. Prostate cancer mouse models validated in vivo imaging potential and sensitivity to cancerous tissue. Our findings show that DT is inversely related to NB motion, offering enhanced detail of NB dynamics in tumors, and highlighting the heterogeneity of the tumor environment. Average DT was high in tumor regions (~9 s) compared to surrounding normal tissue (~1 s) with higher sensitivity to tumor tissue compared to other mapping techniques. Molecular NB targeting to tumors further extended DT (11 s) over non-targeted NBs (6 s), demonstrating sensitivity to NB adherence. From DT mapping of in vivo NB dynamics we demonstrate the heterogeneity of tumor tissue while quantifying extravascular NB kinetics and delineating intra-tumoral vasculature. This new NB-CEUS-based biomarker can be powerful in molecular US imaging, with improved sensitivity and specificity to diseased tissue and potential for use as an estimator of vascular permeability and the enhanced permeability and retention (EPR) effect in tumors.
This study explores the challenges associated with nanoparticle-based drug delivery to the tumor parenchyma, focusing on the widely utilized enhanced permeability and retention effect (EPR). While EPR has been a key strategy, its inconsistent clinical success lacks clear mechanistic understanding and is hindered by limited tools for studying relevant phenomena. This work introduces an approach that employs multiparametric dynamic contrast-enhanced ultrasound (CEUS) with a nanoscale contrast agent for noninvasive, real-time examination of tumor microenvironment characteristics. We demonstrate that CEUS imaging can: (1) evaluate tumor microenvironment features, (2) be used to help predict the distribution of doxorubicin-loaded liposomes in the tumor parenchyma, and (3) be used to predict nanotherapeutic efficacy. CEUS using nanobubbles (NBs) was carried out in two tumor types of high (LS174T) and low (U87) vascular permeability. LS174T tumors consistently showed significantly different time intensity curve (TIC) parameters, including area under the rising curve (AUCR, 2.7x) and time to peak intensity (TTP, 1.9x) compared to U87 tumors. Crucially, a recently developed decorrelation time (DT) parameter specific to NB CEUS dynamics successfully predicted the distribution of doxorubicin-loaded liposomes within the tumor parenchyma (r = 0.86 +/- 0.13). AUCR, TTP, and DT were used to correlate imaging findings to nanotherapeutic response with 100% accuracy in SKOV-3 tumors. These findings suggest that NB-CEUS parameters can effectively discern tumor vascular permeability, serving as a biomarker for identifying tumor characteristics and predicting the responsiveness to nanoparticle-based therapies. The observed differences between LS174T and U87 tumors and the accurate prediction of nanotherapeutic efficacy in SKOV-3 tumors indicate the potential utility of this method in predicting treatment efficacy and evaluating EPR in diseases characterized by pathologically permeable vasculature. Ultimately, this research contributes valuable insights into refining drug delivery strategies and assessing the broader applicability of EPR-based approaches.
Nanomedicine in oncology has not had the success in clinical impact that was anticipated in the early stages of the field's development. Ideally, nanomedicines selectively accumulate in tumor tissue and reduce systemic side effects compared to traditional chemotherapeutics. However, this has been more successful in preclinical animal models than in humans. The causes of this failure to translate may be related to the intra- and inter-patient heterogeneity of the tumor microenvironment. Predicting whether a patient will respond positively to treatment prior to its initiation, through evaluation of characteristics like nanoparticle extravasation and retention potential in the tumor, may be a way to improve nanomedicine success rate. While there are many potential strategies to accomplish this, prediction and patient stratification via noninvasive medical imaging may be the most efficient and specific strategy. There have been some preclinical and clinical advances in this area using MRI, CT, PET, and other modalities. An alternative approach that has not been studied as extensively is biomedical ultrasound, including techniques such as multiparametric contrast-enhanced ultrasound (mpCEUS), doppler, elastography, and super-resolution processing. Ultrasound is safe, inexpensive, noninvasive, and capable of imaging the entire tumor with high temporal and spatial resolution. In this work, we summarize the in vivo imaging tools that have been used to predict nanoparticle distribution and treatment efficacy in oncology. We emphasize ultrasound imaging and the recent developments in the field concerning CEUS. The successful implementation of an imaging strategy for prediction of nanoparticle accumulation in tumors could lead to increased clinical translation of nanomedicines, and subsequently, improved patient outcomes.This article is categorized under: Diagnostic Tools In Vivo Nanodiagnostics and Imaging Therapeutic Approaches and Drug Discovery Nanomedicine for Oncologic Disease Therapeutic Approaches and Drug Discovery Emerging Technologies Medical imaging modalities, especially those with companion nanoparticle capabilities, can be used to analyze tumors and separate patients into potential positive and negative responders to nanotherapeutics. Ultrasound is an excellent modality for this purpose due to its versatility through its many functions including contrast-mode, B-mode, doppler, elastography, and more. image
Contrast-enhanced ultrasound is currently used worldwide with clinical indications in cardiology and radiology, and it continues to evolve and develop through innovative technological advancements. Clinically utilized contrast agents for ultrasound consist of hydrophobic gas microbubbles stabilized with a biocompatible shell. These agents are used commonly in echocardiography, with emerging applications in cancer diagnosis and therapy. Microbubbles are a blood pool agent with diameters between 1 and 10 μm, which precludes their use in other extravascular applications. To expand the potential use of contrast-enhanced ultrasound beyond intravascular applications, sub-micron agents, often called nanobubbles or ultra-fine bubbles, have recently emerged as a promising tool. Combining the principles of ultrasound imaging with the unique properties of nanobubbles (high concentration and small size), recent work has established their imaging potential. Contrast-enhanced ultrasound imaging using these agents continues to gain traction, with new studies establishing novel imaging applications. We highlight the recent achievements in nonlinear nanobubble contrast imaging, including a discussion on nanobubble formulations and their acoustic characteristics. Ultrasound imaging with nanobubbles is still in its early stages, but it has shown great potential in preclinical research and animal studies. We highlight unexplored areas of research where the capabilities of nanobubbles may offer new advantages. As technology advances, this technique may find applications in various areas of medicine, including cancer detection and treatment, cardiovascular imaging, and drug delivery.
Lipid shell-stabilized nanoparticles with a perfluorocarbon gas-core, or nanobubbles, have recently attracted attention as a new contrast agent for molecular ultrasound imaging and image-guided therapy. Due to their small size (∼275 nm diameter) and flexible shell, nanobubbles have been shown to extravasate through hyperpermeable vasculature (e.g., in tumors). However, little is known about the dynamics and depth of extravasation of intact, acoustically active nanobubbles. Accordingly, in this work, we developed a microfluidic chip with a lumen and extracellular matrix (ECM) and imaging method that allows real-time imaging and characterization of the extravasation process with high-frequency ultrasound. The microfluidic device has a lumen and is surrounded by an extracellular matrix with tunable porosity. The combination of ultrasound imaging and the microfluidic chip advantageously produces real-time images of the entire length and depth of the matrix. This captures the matrix heterogeneity, offering advantages over other imaging techniques with smaller fields of view. Results from this study show that nanobubbles diffuse through a 1.3 μm pore size (2 mg mL-1) collagen I matrix 25× faster with a penetration depth that was 0.19 mm deeper than a 3.7 μm (4 mg mL-1) matrix. In the 3.7 μm pore size matrix, nanobubbles diffused 92× faster than large nanobubbles (∼875 nm diameter). Decorrelation time analysis was successfully used to differentiate flowing and extra-luminally diffusing nanobubbles. In this work, we show for the first time that combination of an ultrasound-capable microfluidic chip and real-time imaging provided valuable insight into spatiotemporal nanoparticle movement through a heterogeneous extracellular matrix. This work could help accurately predict parameters (e.g., injection dosage) that improve translation of nanoparticles from in vitro to in vivo environments.
Nanoscale ultrasound contrast agents, or nanobubbles, are being explored in preclinical applications ranging from vascular and cardiac imaging to targeted drug delivery in cancer. These sub-micron particles are approximately 10x smaller than clinically available microbubbles. This allows them to effectively traverse compromised physiological barriers and circulate for extended periods of time. While various aspects of nanobubble behavior have been previously examined, their behavior in human whole blood has not yet been explored. Accordingly, herein we examined, for the first time, the short and long-term effects of blood components on nanobubble acoustic response. We observed differences in the kinetics of backscatter from nanobubble suspensions in whole blood compared to bubbles in phosphate buffered saline (PBS), plasma, or red blood cell solutions (RBCs). Specifically, after introducing nanobubbles to fresh human whole blood, signal enhancement, or the magnitude of nonlinear ultrasound signal, gradually increased by 22.8 ± 13.1% throughout our experiment, with peak intensity reached within 145 s. In contrast, nanobubbles in PBS had a stable signal with negligible change in intensity (-1.7 ± 3.2%) over 8 min. Under the same conditions, microbubbles made with the same lipid formulation showed a -56.8 ± 6.1% decrease in enhancement in whole blood. Subsequent confocal, fluorescent, and scanning electron microscopy analysis revealed attachment of the nanobubbles to the surface of RBCs, suggesting that direct interactions, or hitchhiking, of nanobubbles on RBCs in the presence of plasma may be a possible mechanism for the observed effects. This phenomenon could be key to extending nanobubble circulation time and has broad implications in drug delivery, where RBC interaction with nanoparticles could be exploited to improve delivery efficiency.
Lipid-shell C3F8 nanobubble (NB) ultrasound contrast agents have demonstrated an extended in vivo lifespan compared to traditional microbubble contrast agents. One potential explanation behind this extended lifespan is non-covalent interactions between NBs and red blood cells (RBCs). This has been observed in vitro where interactions increased contrast intensity and signal stability over time. However, the mechanism of this interaction and the factors influencing it have not been fully elucidated. In this study, we investigate the role of NB shell stiffness and solution temperature on signal stability in human whole blood and PBS in vitro. We used three NB shell stiffnesses and a fourth formulation with the addition of a targeting ligand and assessed extent of RBC interaction using autocorrelation analysis. Results demonstrate a clear dependence of RBC interaction on shell stiffness. The stiffest NB formulation had a decorrelation time ~2x faster than all other formulations and showed no effect on signal change over time. Less stiff NBs resulted in an increase in intensity over time and increased decorrelation time, consistent with prior studies. No such effects were observed in PBS. Furthermore, the presence of a targeting ligand did not appear to play a role in contrast enhancement over time or decorrelation time. Decorrelation time in whole blood decreased with increasing temperature. This work examined the effect of shell stiffness and solution temperature on NB signal stability and interactions with RBCs in human whole blood in vitro. Understanding why NBs interact with RBCs could improve NB formulation optimization for extended circulation time in vivo.
The tumor microenvironment is characterized by dysfunctional endothelial cells, resulting in heightened vascular permeability. Many nanoparticle-based drug delivery systems attempt to use this enhanced permeability combined with impaired lymphatic drainage (a concept known as the 'enhanced permeability and retention effect' or EPR effect) as the primary strategy for drug delivery, but this has not proven to be as clinically effective as anticipated. The specific mechanisms behind the inconsistent clinical outcomes of nanotherapeutics have not been clearly articulated, and the field has been hampered by a lack of accessible tools to study EPR-associated phenomena in clinically relevant scenarios. While medical imaging has tremendous potential to contribute to this area, it has not been broadly explored. This work examines, for the first time, the use of multiparametric dynamic contrast-enhanced ultrasound (CEUS) with a novel nanoscale contrast agent to examine tumor microenvironment characteristics noninvasively and in real-time. We demonstrate that CEUS imaging can: (1) evaluate tumor microenvironment features and (2) be used to help predict the distribution of doxorubicin-loaded liposomes in the tumor parenchyma. CEUS using nanobubbles (NBs) was carried out in two tumor types of high (LS174T) and low (U87) vascular permeability, and time-intensity curve (TIC) parameters were evaluated in both models prior to injection of doxorubicin liposomes. Consistently, LS174T tumors showed significantly different TIC parameters, including area under the rising curve (2.7x), time to peak intensity (1.9x) and decorrelation time (DT, 1.9x) compared to U87 tumors. Importantly, the DT parameter successfully predicted tumoral nanoparticle distribution (r = 0.86 ± 0.13). Ultimately, substantial differences in NB-CEUS generated parameters between LS174T and U87 tumors suggest that this method may be useful in determining tumor vascular permeability and could be used as a biomarker for identifying tumor characteristics and predicting sensitivity to nanoparticle-based therapies. These findings could ultimately be applied to predicting treatment efficacy and to evaluating EPR in other diseases with pathologically permeable vasculature.
Liver metastasis is a major obstacle in treating aggressive cancers, and current therapeutic options often prove insufficient. To overcome these challenges, there has been growing interest in ultrasound-mediated drug delivery using lipid-shelled microbubbles (MBs) and nanobubbles (NBs) as promising strategies for enhancing drug delivery to tumors. Our previous work demonstrated the potential of Doxorubicin-loaded C 3 F 8 NBs (hDox-NB, 280 ± 123 nm) in improving cancer treatment in vitro using low-frequency ultrasound. In this study, we investigated the pharmacokinetics and biodistribution of sonicated hDox-NBs in orthotopic rat liver tumors. We compared their delivery and therapeutic efficiency with size-isolated MBs (hDox-MB, 1104 ± 373 nm). Results showed a similar accumulation of hDox in tumors treated with hDox-MBs and unfocused therapeutic ultrasound (hDox-MB+TUS) and hDox-NB+TUS. However, significantly increased apoptotic cell death in the tumor and fewer off-target apoptotic cells in the normal liver were found upon the treatment with hDox-NB+TUS. The tumor-to-liver apoptotic ratio was elevated 9.4-fold following treatment with hDox-NB+TUS compared to hDox-MB+TUS, suggesting that the therapeutic efficacy and specificity are significantly increased when using hDox-NB+TUS. These findings highlight the potential of this approach as a viable treatment modality for liver tumors. By elucidating the behavior of drug-loaded bubbles in vivo , we aim to contribute to developing more effective liver cancer treatments that could ultimately improve patient outcomes and decrease off-target side effects.
Microvessel (MV) imaging using non-contrast US is challenging due to low blood echo SNR, the presence of spectrally overlapping tissue clutter, and noise. Spatiotemporal clutter removal, e.g., via singular value decomposition (SVD), requires parameter tuning and are computationally expensive. In this work, we proposed an end-to-end deep learning approach to remove tissue clutter and extract blood signals from US ensemble in a purely data-driven fashion. Our deep learning approach accelerates the decluttering process and provides a generalizable framework to adapt to realistic scenarios via diversly augmented data. In this preliminary study, we scanned a day 8 developing chicken embryo to collect US ensembles of different regions of the embryo. Training data was created using a fine-tuned SVD for tissue clutter removal and to train a 2D U-net. The proposed deep learning approach can reconstruct MV from US ensembles (structural similarity index of 0.83 ± 0.02 compared to processing via SVD) implying good reconstruction. Our end-to-end deep learning approach is also 2x faster than the traditional SVD approach. Deep learning based MV imaging using non-contrast US shows promise in reconstructing MV in presence of different tissue motions and can be extended to perform under various SNR, noise, and motion conditions.
Nanobubble ultrasound contrast agents (NBs) offer enhanced access to deep tumor tissue by extrapolation from vasculature. When combined with targeting moieties, shell-stabilized nanobubbles can outperform other agents used in molecular ultrasound imaging due to their small size. The visualization and decoupling of extravasated and intravascular NBs is critical to furthering nanobubble molecular imaging with ultrasound. Spatiotemporal processing of echo data, usually via singular value decomposition (SVD), enables enhanced decoupling of signals of stationary from moving scatterers and therefore provides a novel tool for analysis of NB extravasation into the parenchyma. Instead of trivial solutions, we have developed non-negative SVD (nnSVD) methods applicable to most commercial scanners without requiring the raw data. Additionally, our formulation allows addition of proper regularizers, such as sparsity, to further expand the decomposition dimensions. We validate these methods in phantom models and present how the suggested decompositions can distinctly decouple flowing from extravasated NBs in in vivo tumour models with enhanced permeability. Our results show the successful tracking of nanobubble accumulation in tumour tissue and can serve as a relative metric for molecular targeting of prostate cancer. Further exploration of these methods could be used to improve long-term imaging and drug delivery capabilities of NBs.
Understanding the pressure dependence of the nonlinear behavior of ultrasonically excited phospholipid-stabilized nanobubbles (NBs) is important for optimizing ultrasound exposure parameters for implementations of contrast enhanced ultrasound, critical to molecular imaging. The viscoelastic properties of the shell can be controlled by the introduction of membrane additives, such as propylene glycol as a membrane softener or glycerol as a membrane stiffener. We report on the production of high-yield NBs with narrow dispersity and different shell properties. Through precise control over size and shell structure, we show how these shell components interact with the phospholipid membrane, change their structure, affect their viscoelastic properties, and consequently change their acoustic response. A two-photon microscopy technique through a polarity-sensitive fluorescent dye, C-laurdan, was utilized to gain insights on the effect of membrane additives to the membrane structure. We report how the shell stiffness of NBs affects the pressure threshold (P-t) for the sudden amplification in the scattered acoustic signal from NBs. For narrow size NBs with 200 nm mean size, we find P-t to be between 123 and 245 kPa for the NBs with the most flexible membrane as assessed using C-Laurdan, 465-588 kPa for the NBs with intermediate stiffness, and 588-710 kPa for the NBs with stiff membranes. Numerical simulations of the NB dynamics are in good agreement with the experimental observations, confirming the dependence of acoustic response to shell properties, thereby substantiating further the development in engineering the shell of ultrasound contrast agents. The viscoelastic-dependent threshold behavior can be utilized for significantly and selectively enhancing the diagnostic and therapeutic ultrasound applications of potent narrow size NBs.
Understanding the pressure dependence of the nonlinear behavior of ultrasonically excited phospholipid (PL)-stabilized NBs is important for optimizing US exposure parameters for implementations of contrast enhanced ultrasound, critical to molecular imaging. The viscoelastic properties of the shell can be controlled by introduction of membrane additives, such as propylene glycol as a membrane softener or glycerol as a membrane stiffener. We report for the first time, the production of high yield NBs with narrow dispersity and different shell properties. Through precise control over size and shell structure, we show how these shell components interact with the phospholipid membrane, change its structure, affect their viscoelastic properties, and consequently change their acoustic response. A two-photon microscopy technique through a polarity-sensitive fluorescent dye, C-laurdan, was utilized to gain insights on the effect of membrane additives to the membrane structure. We report how the shell stiffness of NBs affects the pressure threshold (Pt) for the sudden amplification in the scattered acoustic signal from NBs. For narrow size NBs with 200 nm mean size, we find Pt to be between 123-245 kPa for the NBs with the most flexible membrane as assessed using C-Laurdan, 465-588 kPa for the NBs with intermediate stiffness and 588-710 kPa for the NBs with stiff membranes. Numerical simulations of the NB dynamics are in good agreement with the experimental observations confirming the dependence of acoustic response to shell properties, thereby substantiating further the development in engineering the shell of UCAs. The viscoelastic dependent threshold behavior can be utilized for significantly and selectively enhancing the diagnostic and therapeutic ultrasound applications of potent narrow size NBs.
Advancement of ultrasound molecular imaging applications requires not only a reduction in size of the ultrasound contrast agents (UCAs) but also a significant improvement in the in vivo stability of the shell-stabilized gas bubble. The transition from first generation to second generation UCAs was marked by an advancement in stability as air was replaced by a hydrophobic gas, such as perfluoropropane and sulfur hexafluoride. Further improvement can be realized by focusing on how well the UCAs shell can retain the encapsulated gas under extreme mechanical deformations. Here we report the next generation of UCAs for which we engineered the shell structure to impart much better stability under repeated prolonged oscillation due to ultrasound, and large changes in shear and turbulence as it circulates within the body. By adapting an architecture with two layers of contrasting elastic properties similar to bacterial cell envelopes, our ultrastable nanobubbles (NBs) withstand continuous in vitro exposure to ultrasound with minimal signal decay and have a significant delay on the onset of in vivo signal decay in kidney, liver, and tumor. Development of ultrastable NBs can potentially expand the role of ultrasound in molecular imaging, theranostics, and drug delivery.
Ultrasound is the second most utilized imaging modality in the world because it is widely accessible, robust, and safe. Aside from its extensive use in diagnostic imaging, ultrasound has also been frequently utilized in therapeutic applications. Particularly, when combined with appropriate delivery systems, ultrasound provides a flexible platform for simultaneous real-time imaging and triggered release, enabling precise, on-demand drug delivery to target sites. This chapter will discuss the basics of ultrasound including its mechanism of action and how it can be used to trigger the release of encapsulated drug either through thermal or cavitation effects. Fundamentals of ultrasound contrast agents, how they enhance ultrasound signals, and how they can be modified to function as carriers for triggered and targeted release of drugs will also be discussed.
Intravascular drug delivery technologies majorly utilize spherical nanoparticles as carrier vehicles. Their targets are often at the blood vessel wall or in the tissue beyond the wall, such that vehicle localization towards the wall (margination) becomes a pre-requisite for their function. To this end, some studies have indicated that under flow environment, micro-particles have a higher propensity than nano-particles to marginate to the wall. Also, non-spherical particles theoretically have a higher area of surface-adhesive interactions than spherical particles. However, detailed systematic studies that integrate various particle size and shape parameters across nano-to-micro scale to explore their wall-localization behavior in RBC-rich blood flow, have not been reported. We address this gap by carrying out computational and experimental studies utilizing particles of four distinct shapes (spherical, oblate, prolate, rod) spanning nano- to-micro scale sizes. Computational studies were performed using the Large-scale Atomic/Molecular Massively Parallel Simulator (LAMMPS) package, with Dissipative Particle Dynamics (DPD). For experimental studies, model particles were made from neutrally buoyant fluorescent polystyrene spheres, that were thermo-stretched into non-spherical shapes and all particles were surface-coated with biotin. Using microfluidic setup, the biotin-coated particles were flowed over avidin-coated surfaces in absence versus presence of RBCs, and particle adhesion and retention at the surface was assessed by inverted fluorescence microscopy. Our computational and experimental studies provide a simultaneous analysis of different particle sizes and shapes for their retention in blood flow and indicate that in presence of RBCs, micro-scale non-spherical particles undergo enhanced 'margination + adhesion' compared to nano-scale spherical particles, resulting in their higher binding. These results provide important insight regarding improved design of vascularly targeted drug delivery systems.